Oligomerization of the amide sensor protein AmiC by x-ray and neutron scattering and molecular modeling

X-ray and neutron scattering data and their constrained molecular modeling

X-ray and neutron solution scattering methods provide multiparameter structural and compositional information on proteins that complements high-resolution protein crystallography and NMR studies. We describe the procedures required to (1) obtain validated X-ray and neutron scattering data, (2) perform Guinier analyses of the scattering data to extract the radius of gyration R(G) and intensity parameters, and (3) calculate the distance distribution function P(r). Constrained modeling is important because this confirms the experimental data analysis and produces families of best-fit molecular models for comparison with crystallography and NMR structures. The modeling procedures are described in terms of (4) generating appropriate starting models, (5) randomizing these for trial-and-error scattering fits, (6) identifying the final best-fit models, and (7) applying analytical ultracentrifugation (AUC) data to validate the scattering modeling. These procedures and pitfalls in them will be illustrated using work performed in the authors' laboratory on antibodies and the complement proteins of the human immune defense system. Four different types of modeling procedures are distinguished, depending on the number and type of domains in the protein. Examples when comparisons with crystallography and NMR structures are important are described. For multidomain proteins, it is often found that scattering provides essential evidence to validate or disprove a crystal structure. If a large protein cannot be crystallized, scattering provides the only means to obtain a structure.

Three-dimensional model of the extracellular domain of the type 4a metabotropic glutamate receptor: new insights into the activation process

Metabotropic glutamate receptors (mGluRs) belong to the family 3 of G-protein-coupled receptors. On these proteins, agonist binding on the extracellular domain leads to conformational changes in the 7-transmembrane domains required for G-protein activation. To elucidate the structural features that might be responsible for such an activation mechanism, we have generated models of the amino terminal domain (ATD) of type 4 mGluR (mGlu4R). The fold recognition search allowed the identification of three hits with a low sequence identity, but with high secondary structure conservation: leucine isoleucine valine-binding protein (LIVBP) and leucine-binding protein (LBP) as already known, and acetamide-binding protein (AmiC). These proteins are characterized by a bilobate structure in an open state for LIVBP/LBP and a closed state for AmiC, with ligand binding in the cleft. Models for both open and closed forms of mGlu4R ATD have been generated. ACPT-I (1-aminocyclopentane 1,3,4-tricarboxylic acid), a selective agonist, has been docked in the two models. In the open form, ACPT-I is only bound to lobe I through interactions with Lys74, Arg78, Ser159, and Thr182. In the closed form, ACPT-I is trapped between both lobes with additional binding to Tyr230, Asp312, Ser313, and Lys317 from lobe II. These results support the hypothesis that mGluR agonists bind a closed form of the ATDs, suggesting that such a conformation of the binding domain corresponds to the active conformation.

Probing the ligand-binding domain of the mGluR4 subtype of metabotropic glutamate receptor

Metabotropic glutamate receptors (mGluRs) are G-protein-coupled glutamate receptors that subserve a number of diverse functions in the central nervous system. The large extracellular amino-terminal domains (ATDs) of mGluRs are homologous to the periplasmic binding proteins in bacteria. In this study, a region in the ATD of the mGluR4 subtype of mGluR postulated to contain the ligand-binding pocket was explored by site-directed mutagenesis using a molecular model of the tertiary structure of the ATD as a guiding tool. Although the conversion of Arg(78), Ser(159), or Thr(182) to Ala did not affect the level of protein expression or cell-surface expression, all three mutations severely impaired the ability of the receptor to bind the agonist L-[(3)H]amino-4-phosphonobutyric acid. Mutation of other residues within or in close proximity to the proposed binding pocket produced either no effect (Ser(157) and Ser(160)) or a relatively modest effect (Ser(181)) on ligand affinity compared with the Arg(78), Ser(159), and Thr(182) mutations. Based on these experimental findings, together with information obtained from the model in which the glutamate analog L-serine O-phosphate (L-SOP) was "docked" into the binding pocket, we suggest that the hydroxyl groups on the side chains of Ser(159) and Thr(182) of mGluR4 form hydrogen bonds with the alpha-carboxyl and alpha-amino groups on L-SOP, respectively, whereas Arg(78) forms an electrostatic interaction with the acidic side chains of L-SOP or glutamate. The conservation of Arg(78), Ser(159), and Thr(182) in all members of the mGluR family indicates that these amino acids may be fundamental recognition motifs for the binding of agonists to this class of receptors.

Molecular structures from low angle X-ray and neutron scattering studies

Molecular structures can be extracted from solution scattering analyses of multidomain or oligomeric proteins by a new method of constrained automated scattering curve fits. Scattering curves are calculated using a procedure tested by comparisons of crystal structures with experimental X-ray and neutron data. The domains or subunits in the protein of interest are all represented by atomic coordinates in order to provide initial constraints. From this starting model, hundreds or thousands of different possible structures are computed, from each of which a scattering curve is computed. Each model is assessed for steric overlap, radii of gyration and R-factors in order to leave a small family of good fit models that corresponds to the molecular structure of interest. This method avoids the tedium of curve fitting by hand and error limits on the ensuing models can be described. For single multidomain proteins, the key constraint is the correct stereochemical connections between the domains in all the models. Successful applications to determine structures are summarised for the Fab and Fc fragments in immunoglobulin G, the three domain pairs in the Fc subunit of immunoglobulin E and the seven, domains in carcinoembryonic antigen. For oligomeric proteins, the key constraint is provided by symmetry and successful analyses were performed for the association of the monomers of the bacterial amide sensor protein AmiC to form trimers and pentameric serum amyloid P component to form decameric structures. The successful analysis of the heterodimeric complex of tissue factor and factor VIIa required the use of constraints provided from biochemical data. The outcome of these analyses is critically appraised, in particular the biological significance of structures determined by these solution scattering curve fits.

Pentameric and decameric structures in solution of serum amyloid P component by X-ray and neutron scattering and molecular modelling analyses

Human serum amyloid P component (SAP) is a normal plasma glycoprotein and the precursor of amyloid P component which is a universal constituent of the abnormal tissue deposits in amyloidosis. X-ray and neutron scattering data showed that pentameric or decameric ring structures for SAP in solution are readily distinguished. Further neutron data collection showed that SAP pentamers were reproducibly obtained in the presence of Ca2+ at pH 5.5 or in the presence of methyl 4,6-O-(1-carboxyethylidene)-beta-d-galactopyranoside (MObetaDG) and Ca2+ at pH 6.0 to 8.0, while SAP decamers were obtained in the presence of EDTA between pH 5.5 and 8.0. SAP pentamers have a mean X-ray RG of 3.99(+/-0.11) nm and a mean neutron RG of 3.69(+/-0.12) nm in 100% 2H2O. SAP decamers have a mean X-ray RG of 4.23(+/-0.12) nm and a mean neutron RG of 4.09(+/-0.14) nm in 100% 2H2O. The absorption coefficients of SAP pentamers and decamers differ by 10%. If we infer that the two alpha-helical A-faces are in contact with each other in the SAP decamer, the lack of structural change of the decamer with pH may be explained by the absence of His residues from the A-face of the SAP pentamer, and the change in absorption coefficients is compatible with the presence of Trp residues at this A-face. The rigid ring structure of pentameric SAP provided a test of scattering curves calculated from crystal structures. The only structural unknown is the orientation of the five chemically homogeneous oligosaccharide chains relative to the protein, but extended oligosaccharide structures were found to account for its scattering curve. X-ray scattering curves were best calculated using a hydrated structure, while neutron scattering curves were best calculated using an unhydrated structure. The outcome of these analyses was used to model the structure of decameric SAP. The evaluation of 640 structures for two SAP pentamers brought face-to-face to form SAP decamers gave better curve fits for structures in which the two A-faces were in contact with each other, in which it is likely that the two pentamers were out of alignment by a rotation of 36 degrees and the oligosaccharide chains were extended.