A calcium-metalloribozyme with autodecapping and pyrophosphatase activities

Promiscuous Ribozymes and Their Proposed Role in Prebiotic Evolution

The ability of enzymes, including ribozymes, to catalyze side reactions is believed to be essential to the evolution of novel biochemical activities. It has been speculated that the earliest ribozymes, whose emergence marked the origin of life, were low in activity but high in promiscuity, and that these early ribozymes gave rise to specialized descendants with higher activity and specificity. Here, we review the concepts related to promiscuity and examine several cases of highly promiscuous ribozymes. We consider the evidence bearing on the question of whether de novo ribozymes would be quantitatively more promiscuous than later evolved ribozymes or protein enzymes. We suggest that while de novo ribozymes appear to be promiscuous in general, they are not obviously more promiscuous than more highly evolved or active sequences. Promiscuity is a trait whose value would depend on selective pressures, even during prebiotic evolution.

Evolutionary origins and directed evolution of RNA

In vitro selection experiments show first and foremost that it is possible that functional nucleic acids can arise from random sequence libraries. Indeed, even simple sequence and structural motifs can prove to be robust binding species and catalysts, indicating that it may have been possible to transition from even the earliest self-replicators to a nascent, RNA-catalyzed metabolism. Because of the diversity of aptamers and ribozymes that can be selected, it is possible to construct a 'fossil record' of the evolution of the RNA world, with in vitro selected catalysts filling in as doppelgangers for molecules long gone. In this way a plausible pathway from simple oligonucleotide replicators to genomic polymerases can be imagined, as can a pathway from basal ribozyme activities to the ribosome. Most importantly, though, in vitro selection experiments can give a true and quantitative idea of the likelihood that these scenarios could have played out in the RNA world. Simple binding species and catalysts could have evolved into other structures and functions. As replicating sequences grew longer, new, more complex functions or faster catalytic activities could have been accessed. Some activities may have been isolated in sequence space, but others could have been approached along large, interconnected neutral networks. As the number, type, and length of ribozymes increased, RNA genomes would have evolved and eventually there would have been no area in a fitness landscape that would have been inaccessible. Self-replication would have inexorably led to life.

Two independently selected capping ribozymes share similar substrate requirements

We report the isolation and characterization of a second capping ribozyme, called 6.17. This ribozyme has substrate requirements that are very similar to a previously isolated capping ribozyme called Iso6. Both ribozymes promote capping and cap exchange reactions with a broad range of nucleotide substrates. The ribozymes mediate a reaction where the terminal phosphate of the nucleotide substrate attacks the alpha-phosphate found at the ribozyme's 5' terminus. This reaction involves the release of pyrophosphate during capping or a nucleotide during cap exchange. The second-order rate constants for 6.17 and Iso6 depend strongly on the length of the phosphate group found on the nucleotide substrate. Nucleoside diphosphates or triphosphates are efficiently utilized, while monophosphates are used approximately 20-fold less efficiently by both ribozymes. These ribozymes also have rates that increase as pH is decreased. Despite these similarities, the ribozymes are not identical and 6.17 performs optimally when incubated with divalent magnesium ions, while Iso6 displays a preference for calcium ions. Further, the ribozymes have globally different secondary structures; 6.17 has a complicated pseudoknot structure consisting of five helical elements, while Iso6 likely consists of four helical elements. We hypothesize that capping proceeds via an invariant phosphate dependent mechanism that imposes a nearly identical "catalytic fingerprint" on these two distinct ribozymes.

In vitro selection of kinase and ligase deoxyribozymes

Exploration of the limits of biocatalysis has led to the discovery that DNA has significant potential for enzymatic function. This makes possible the construction of DNA enzymes or "deoxyribozymes" for catalyzing various chemical reactions that could be used to address fundamental questions in biocatalysis or that could find unique applications in biotechnology. Of significant interest are self-modification reactions, given the fundamental role that DNA serves in modern living systems. Recently, in vitro selection strategies have been used to isolate prototypical ATP-dependent deoxyribozymes from random-sequence populations of DNA that catalyze DNA phosphorylation and others that catalyze DNA adenylation. In nature, protein enzymes such as T4 DNA kinase and T4 DNA ligase catalyze identical chemical reactions. These findings suggest that DNA constructs could be engineered to efficiently catalyze other self-modifying reactions, including ATP-dependent DNA ligation. This article provides a detailed overview of the methods used to isolate deoxyribozymes that promote ATP-dependent DNA ligation.

Kinetics at a multifunctional RNA active site

Kinetics of a self-capping RNA, Iso6, have been investigated to constrain the catalytic mechanism. The role of phosphates has been examined by varying the number of phosphates on the nucleophilic attacking group or on the RNA. While the number of phosphates in the nucleophile affects capping kinetics, only KM but not kcat is altered. The KM values for GMP, GDP, GTP and ppppG are 200, 11, 13 and 31 microM, respectively. A reaction product, pyrophosphate, is also found to strongly inhibit RNA activities through a competitive exchange mechanism with an apparent Ki of 200 nM. Uniquely strong binding of pyrophosphate supports the idea that capping originated by utilization of the initial pyrophosphate leaving group site for capping nucleophiles. In contrast to the nucleophile phosphate, change of 5' RNA terminus from triphosphate to tetraphosphate enhances the overall rate and kcat by 40%, with little effect on KM. Thus, only the leaving group appears to affect the rate of the chemical transformation. We propose two possible mechanisms that explain this apparent rate-limiting chemical step, either dissociation of pyrophosphate to form a metaphosphate monoester intermediate or formation of a circular phosphoramidate intermediate, using an internal RNA nitrogenous group. A single essential Ca ion is required for all activities.

RNA enzymes with two small-molecule substrates

BACKGROUND

The 'RNA world' hypothesis posits ancient organisms employing versatile catalysis by RNAs. In particular, such a metabolism would have required RNA catalysts that join small molecules. Such anabolic reactions now occur very widely, for example in phospholipid, terpene, amino acid and nucleotide synthetic pathways in modern organisms. Present RNA systems, however, do not perform such reactions using substrates that do not base pair. Here we ask whether this lack is a methodological artifact due to the practice of selection-amplification, or a fundamental property of active sites reconstructed within RNA structures.

RESULTS

Three rationally modified RNA enzymes, Iso6-G, Iso6-2G and Iso63G, catalyze the formation of (5'-->5') polyphosphate-linked oligonucleotides in trans. One of these, Iso6-G RNA, has a specific substrate site for a guanosine triphosphate, GTP, dGTP or ddGTP, and one nonspecific substrate site for a terminal-phosphate-containing small molecule. This ribozyme catalyzes multiple turnovers, proceeding at a constant rate. Guanosine specificity is probably not attributable to Watson-Crick base pairing.

CONCLUSIONS

Ribozymes can readily bind multiple small-molecule substrates simultaneously and catalyze reactions that build up larger products, apparently independent of substrate-RNA Watson-Crick base pairing. RNA enzymes therefore parallel proteins, which often overcome the entropic difficulties of positioning multiple small substrates for catalysis of anabolic reactions. These results support the idea of a complex ancestral metabolism based on RNA catalysis.