Identifying RNA minor groove tertiary contacts by nucleotide analogue interference mapping with N2-methylguanosine

Analysis of catalytic RNA structure and function by nucleotide analog interference mapping

Nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) is a quick and efficient method to define concurrently, yet singly, the importance of specific functional groups at particular nucleotide residues to the structure and function of an RNA. NAIM can be utilized on virtually any RNA with an assayable function. The method hinges on the ability to successfully incorporate, within an RNA transcript, various 5'-O-(1-thio)nucleoside analogs randomly via in vitro transcription. This could be achieved by using wild-type or Y639F mutant T7 RNA polymerase, thereby creating a pool of analog doped RNAs. The pool when subjected to a selection step to separate the active transcripts from the inactive ones leads to the identification of functional groups that are crucial for RNA activity. The technique can be used to study ribozyme structure and function via monitoring of cleavage or ligation reactions, define functional groups critical for RNA folding, RNA-RNA interactions, and RNA interactions with proteins, metals, or other small molecules. All major classes of catalytic RNAs have been probed by NAIM. This is a generalized approach that should provide the scientific community with the tools to better understand RNA structure-activity relationships.

Identification of a tertiary interaction important for cooperative ligand binding by the glycine riboswitch

The glycine riboswitch has a tandem dual aptamer configuration, where each aptamer is a separate ligand-binding domain, but the aptamers function together to bind glycine cooperatively. We sought to understand the molecular basis of glycine riboswitch cooperativity by comparing sites of tertiary contacts in a series of cooperative and noncooperative glycine riboswitch mutants using hydroxyl radical footprinting, in-line probing, and native gel-shift studies. The results illustrate the importance of a direct or indirect interaction between the P3b hairpin of aptamer 2 and the P1 helix of aptamer 1 in cooperative glycine binding. Furthermore, our data support a model in which glycine binding is sequential; where the binding of glycine to the second aptamer allows tertiary interactions to be made that facilitate binding of a second glycine molecule to the first aptamer. These results provide insight into cooperative ligand binding in RNA macromolecules.

Nucleotide analog interference mapping

Nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) is a powerful chemogenetic technique that rapidly identifies chemical groups essential for RNA function. Using a series of phosphorothioate-tagged nucleotide analogs, each carrying different modifications of nucleobase or backbone functionalities, it is possible to simultaneously, yet individually, assess the contribution of particular functional groups to an RNA's activity at every position within the molecule. In contrast to traditional mutagenesis, which modifies RNA on the nucleobase level, the smallest mutable unit in a NAIM analysis is a single atom, providing a detailed description of interactions at critical nucleotides. Because the method introduces modified nucleotides by in vitro transcription, NAIM offers a straightforward and efficient approach to study any RNA that has a selectable function, and it can be applied to RNAs of nearly any length.

Dissecting RNA folding by nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM)

Nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) is a powerful chemogenetic approach that allows RNA structure and function to be characterized at the atomic level. Random modifications of base or backbone moieties are incorporated into the RNA transcript as nucleotide analog phosphorothioates. The resulting RNA pool is then subjected to a stringent selection step, in which the RNA has to accomplish a specific task, for example, folding. RNA functional groups important for this process can be identified by physical isolation of the functional and the nonfunctional RNA molecules and subsequent mapping of the modified nucleotide positions in both RNA populations by iodine cleavage of the susceptible phosphorothioate linkage. This approach has been used to analyze a variety of aspects of RNA biochemistry, including RNA structure, catalysis and ligand interaction. Here, I describe how to set up a NAIM assay for studying RNA folding. This protocol can be readily adapted to study any RNAs and their properties. The time required to complete the experiment is dependent on the length of the RNA and the number of atomic modifications tested. In general, a single NAIM experiment can be completed in 1-2 weeks, but expect a time frame of several weeks to obtain reliable and statistically meaningful results.

Chemical basis of glycine riboswitch cooperativity

The glycine binding riboswitch forms a unique tandem aptamer structure that binds glycine cooperatively. We employed nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) and mutagenesis to explore the chemical basis of glycine riboswitch cooperativity. Based on the interference pattern, at least two sites appear to facilitate cooperative tertiary interactions, namely, the minor groove of the P1 helix from aptamer 1 and the major groove of the P3a helix from both aptamers. Mutation of these residues altered both the cooperativity and binding affinity of the riboswitch. The data support a model in which the P1 helix of the first aptamer participates in a tertiary interaction important for cooperativity, while nucleotides in the P1 helix of the second aptamer interface with the expression platform. These data have direct analogy to well-characterized mutations in hemoglobin, which provides a framework for considering cooperativity in this RNA-based system.

GTP-dependent formation of a ribonucleoprotein subcomplex required for ribosome biogenesis

Ribosome biogenesis in eukaryotic organisms involves the coordinated assembly of 78 ribosomal proteins onto the four ribosomal RNAs, mediated by a host of trans-acting factors whose specific functions remain largely unknown. The essential GTPase Bms1, the putative endonuclease Rcl1 and the essential U3 small nucleolar RNA form a stable subcomplex thought to control an early step in the assembly of the 40S ribosomal subunit. Here, we provide a complete thermodynamic analysis of GTP-dependent subcomplex formation, revealing strong thermodynamic coupling of Rcl1, U3 small nucleolar RNA and GTP binding to Bms1 that is eliminated in the presence of GDP. The results suggest that Rcl1 activates Bms1 by promoting GDP/GTP exchange, analogous to ribosome-promoted nucleotide exchange within translation elongation factor EF-G. These and other data unveil thermodynamic similarities between Bms1 and the subgroup of GTPases involved in translation, providing evidence that parts of the ribosome assembly machinery may have evolved from the translation apparatus. This quantitative description of an early and essential step in pre-ribosome assembly provides a framework for elucidating the network of interactions between the Bms1 subcomplex and additional factors involved in ribosome biogenesis.

The functional anatomy of an intrinsic transcription terminator

To induce dissociation of the transcription elongation complex, a typical intrinsic terminator forms a G.C-rich hairpin structure upstream from a U-rich run of approximately eight nucleotides that define the transcript 3' end. Here, we have adapted the nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) approach to identify the critical RNA atoms and functional groups of an intrinsic terminator during transcription with T7 RNA polymerase. The results show that discrete components within the lower half of the hairpin stem form transient termination-specific contacts with the RNA polymerase. Moreover, disruption of interactions with backbone components of the transcript region hybridized to the DNA template favors termination. Importantly, comparative NAIM of termination events occurring at consecutive positions revealed overlapping but distinct sets of functionally important residues. Altogether, the data identify a collection of RNA terminator components, interactions and spacing constraints that govern efficient transcript release. The results also suggest specific architectural rearrangements of the transcription complex that may participate in allosteric control of intrinsic transcription termination.

The contribution of 2'-hydroxyls to the cleavage activity of the Neurospora VS ribozyme

We have used nucleotide analog interference mapping and site-specific substitution to determine the effect of 2'-deoxynucleotide substitution of each nucleotide in the VS ribozyme on the self-cleavage reaction. A large number of 2'-hydroxyls (2'-OHs) that contribute to cleavage activity of the VS ribozyme were found distributed throughout the core of the ribozyme. The locations of these 2'-OHs in the context of a recently developed helical orientation model of the VS ribozyme suggest roles in multi-stem junction structure, helix packing, internal loop structure and catalysis. The functional importance of three separate 2'-OHs supports the proposal that three uridine turns contribute to local and long-range tertiary structure formation. A cluster of important 2'-OHs near the loop that is the candidate region for the active site and one very important 2'-OH in the loop that contains the cleavage site confirm the functional importance of these two loops. A cluster of important 2'-OHs lining the minor groove of stem-loop I and helix II suggests that these regions of the backbone may play an important role in positioning helices in the active structure of the ribozyme.

A chemical phylogeny of group I introns based upon interference mapping of a bacterial ribozyme

Despite its small size, the 205 nt group I intron from Azoarcus tRNA(Ile) is an exceptionally stable self-splicing RNA. This IC3 class intron retains the conserved secondary structural elements common to group I ribozymes, but lacks several peripheral helices. These features make it an ideal system to establish the conserved chemical basis of group I intron activity. We collected nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) data of the Azoarcus intron using 14 analogs that modified the phosphate backbone, the ribose sugar, or the purine base functional groups. In conjunction with a complete interference set collected on the Tetrahymena group I intron (IC1 class), these data define a "chemical phylogeny" of functional groups that are important for the activity of both introns and that may be common chemical features of group I intron catalysts. The data identify the functional moieties most likely to play a conserved role as ligands for catalytic metal ions, the substrate helix, and the guanosine cofactor. These include backbone functional groups whose nucleotide identity is not conserved, and hence are difficult to identify by standard phylogenetic sequence comparisons. The data suggest that both introns utilize an equivalent set of long range tertiary interactions for 5'-splice site selection between the P1 substrate helix and its receptor in the J4/5 asymmetric bulge, as well as an equivalent set of 2'-OH groups for P1 helix docking into most of the single stranded segment J8/7. However, the Azoarcus intron appears to make an alternative set of interactions at the base of the P1 helix and at the 5'-end of the J8/7. Extensive differences were observed within the intron peripheral domains, particularly in P2 and P8 where the Azoarcus data strongly support the proposed formation of a tetraloop-tetraloop receptor interaction. This chemical phylogeny for group I intron catalysis helps to refine structural models of the RNA active site and identifies functional groups that should be carefully investigated for their role in transition state stabilization.

A tertiary interaction that links active-site domains to the 5' splice site of a group II intron

Group II introns are self-splicing RNAs that are commonly found in the genes of plants, fungi, yeast and bacteria. Little is known about the tertiary structure of group II introns, which are among the largest natural ribozymes. The most conserved region of the intron is domain 5 (D5), which, together with domain 1 (D1), is required for all reactions catalysed by the intron. Despite the importance of D5, its spatial relationship and tertiary contacts to other active-site constituents have remained obscure. Furthermore, D5 has never been placed directly at a site of catalysis by the intron. Here we show that a set of tertiary interactions (lambda-lambda') links catalytically essential regions of D5 and D1, creating the framework for an active-site and anchoring it at the 5' splice site. Highly conserved elements similar to components of the lambda-lambda' interaction are found in the eukaryotic spliceosome.

Ribozyme chemogenetics

In this review I will outline several chemogenetic approaches used to determine the chemical basis of large ribozyme function and structure. The term chemogenetics was first used to describe site-specific functional group modification experiments in the analysis of DNA-protein interactions. Within the past few years equivalent experiments have been performed on large catalytic RNAs using both single-site substitution and interference mapping techniques with nucleotide analogues. While functional group mutagenesis is an important aspect of a chemogenetic approach, chemical correlates to genetic revertants and suppressors must also be realized for the genetic analogy to be intellectually valid and experimentally useful. Several examples of functional group revertants and suppressors have now been obtained within the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme. These experiments define an ensemble of tertiary hydrogen bonds that have made it possible to construct a detailed model of the ribozyme catalytic core. The model includes a functionally important monovalent metal ion binding site, a wobble-wobble receptor motif for helix-helix packing interactions, and a minor groove triple helix.

Interstrand disulfide cross-linking of internal sugar residues in duplex RNA

Disulfide cross-linking is being used increasingly more to study the structure and dynamics of nucleic acids. We have previously developed a procedure for the formation of disulfide cross-links through the sugar-phosphate backbone of nucleic acids. Here we report the preparation and characterization of an RNA duplex containing a disulfide interstrand cross-link. A self-complementary oligoribonucleotide duplex containing an interstrand cross-link was prepared from the corresponding 2'-amino modified oligomer. Selective modification of the 2'-amino group with an aliphatic isocyanate, containing a protected disulfide, gave the corresponding 2'-urea derivative in excellent yield. An RNA duplex containing an intrahelical, interstrand disulfide cross-link was subsequently prepared by a thiol disulfide exchange reaction in nearly quantitative yield as judged by denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (DPAGE). The cross-linked RNA was further characterized by enzymatic digestion and the Structure of the cross-link lesion was verified by comparison to an authentic sample, prepared by chemical synthesis. The effect of the chemical modifications on duplex stability was determined by UV thermal denaturation experiments. The intrahelical cross-link stabilized the duplex considerably: the disulfide cross-linked oligomer had a melting temperature that was ca. 40 degrees C higher than that of the noncross-linked oligomer.

Nucleotide analog interference mapping of the hairpin ribozyme: implications for secondary and tertiary structure formation

The hairpin ribozyme is a small, naturally occurring RNA capable of folding into a distinct three-dimensional structure and catalyzing a specific phosphodiester transfer reaction. We have adapted a high throughput screening procedure entitled nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) to identify functional groups important for proper folding and catalysis of this ribozyme. A total of 18 phosphorothioate-tagged nucleotide analogs were used to determine the contribution made by individual ribose 2'-OH and purine functional groups to the hairpin ribozyme ligation reaction. Substitution with 2'-deoxy-nucleotide analogs disrupted activity at six sites within the ribozyme, and a unique interference pattern was observed at each of the 11 conserved purine nucleotides. In most cases where such information is available, the NAIM data agree with the previously reported single-site substitution results. The interference patterns are interpreted in comparison to the isolated loop A and loop B NMR structures and a model of the intact ribozyme. These data provide biochemical evidence in support of many, but not all, of the non-canonical base-pairs observed by NMR in each loop, and identify the functional groups most likely to participate in the tertiary interface between loop A and loop B. These groups include the 2'-OH groups of A10, G11, U12, C25, and A38, the exocyclic amine of G11, and the minor groove edge of A9 and A24. The data also predict non-A form sugar pucker geometry at U39 and U41. Based upon these results, a revised model for the loop A tertiary interaction with loop B is proposed. This work defines the chemical basis of purine nucleotide conservation in the hairpin ribozyme, and provides a basis for the design and interpretation of interference suppression experiments.

A chemogenetic approach to RNA function/structure analysis

Almost two dozen nucleotide analogs have been synthesized with alpha-phosphorothioate-tagged triphosphates and utilized in an interference modification approach termed Nucleotide Analog Interference Mapping. This method has made it possible to determine the chemical basis of RNA function and structure, including the identification of new rules for RNA helix packing, the functional analysis of a binding site for monovalent metal ions within RNA and the characterization of the catalytic mechanism of RNA enzymes.

Nucleotide analog interference mapping

Single-atom substitution experiments provide atomic resolution biochemical information concerning RNA structure and function. Traditionally, these experiments are performed using chimeric RNAs generated by reassembly of full-length RNA from a synthetic substituted oligonucleotide and a truncated RNA transcript. Unfortunately, this technique is limited by the technical difficulty of assembling and measuring the effect of each singly substituted molecule in a given RNA. Here we review an alternate method for rapidly screening the effect of chemical group substitutions on RNA function. Nucleotide analog interference mapping is a chemogenetic approach that utilizes a series 5'-O-(1-thio)-nucleoside analog triphosphates to simultaneously, yet individually, probe the contribution of a functional group at every nucleotide position in an RNA molecule. A population of randomly substituted RNAs is prepared by including phosphorothioate-tagged nucleotide analogs in an in vitro transcription reaction. The active molecules in the RNA population are selected by an activity assay, and the location of the analog substitution detrimental to activity is identified by cleavage at the phosphorothioate tag with iodine and resolution of the cleavage fragments by gel electrophoresis. This method, which is as easy as RNA sequencing, is applicable to any RNA that can be transcribed in vitro and has an assayable function. Here we describe protocols for the synthesis of phosphorothioate-tagged analogs and their incorporation into RNA transcripts. The incorporation properties and unique biochemical signatures of each individual analog are discussed.

A hydrogen-bonding triad stabilizes the chemical transition state of a group I ribozyme

BACKGROUND

The group I intron is an RNA enzyme capable of efficiently catalyzing phosphoryl-transfer reactions. Functional groups that stabilize the chemical transition state of the cleavage reaction have been identified, but they are all located within either the 5'-exon (P1) helix or the guanosine cofactor, which are the substrates of the reaction. Functional groups within the ribozyme active site are also expected to assist in transition-state stabilization, and their role must be explored to understand the chemical basis of group I intron catalysis.

RESULTS

Using nucleotide analog interference mapping and site-specific functional group substitution experiments, we demonstrate that the 2'-OH at A207, a highly conserved nucleotide in the ribozyme active site, specifically stabilizes the chemical transition state by approximately 2 kcal mol-1. The A207 2'-OH only makes its contribution when the U(-1) 2'-OH immediately adjacent to the scissile phosphate is present, suggesting that the 2'-OHs of A207 and U(-1) interact during the chemical step.

CONCLUSIONS

These data support a model in which the 3'-oxyanion leaving group of the transesterification reaction is stabilized by a hydrogen-bonding triad consisting of the 2'-OH groups of U(-1) and A207 and the exocyclic amine of G22. Because all three nucleotides occur within highly conserved non-canonical base pairings, this stabilization mechanism is likely to occur throughout group I introns. Although this mechanism utilizes functional groups distinctive of RNA enzymes, it is analogous to the transition states of some protein enzymes that perform similar phosphoryl-transfer reactions.

A minor groove RNA triple helix within the catalytic core of a group I intron

Close packing of several double helical and single stranded RNA elements is required for the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme to achieve catalysis. The chemical basis of these packing interactions is largely unknown. Using nucleotide analog interference suppression (NAIS), we demonstrate that the P1 substrate helix and J8/7 single stranded segment form an extended minor groove triple helix within the catalytic core of the ribozyme. Because each triple in the complex is mediated by at least one 2'-OH group, this substrate recognition triplex is unique to RNA and is fundamentally different from major groove homopurine-homopyrimidine triplexes. We have incorporated these biochemical data into a structural model of the ribozyme core that explains how the J8/7 strand organizes several helices within this complex RNA tertiary structure.