Using sequence-specific oligonucleotides to inhibit bacterial rRNA

Vitamin B12-peptide nucleic acids use the BtuB receptor to pass through the Escherichia coli outer membrane

Short modified oligonucleotides that bind in a sequence-specific way to messenger RNA essential for bacterial growth could be useful to fight bacterial infections. One such promising oligonucleotide is peptide nucleic acid (PNA), a synthetic DNA analog with a peptide-like backbone. However, the limitation precluding the use of oligonucleotides, including PNA, is that bacteria do not import them from the environment. We have shown that vitamin B₁₂, which most bacteria need to take up for growth, delivers PNAs to Escherichia coli cells when covalently linked with PNAs. Vitamin B₁₂ enters E. coli via a TonB-dependent transport system and is recognized by the outer-membrane vitamin B₁₂-specific BtuB receptor. We engineered the E. coli ΔbtuB mutant and found that transport of the vitamin B₁₂-PNA conjugate requires BtuB. Thus, the conjugate follows the same route through the outer membrane as taken by free vitamin B₁₂. From enhanced sampling all-atom molecular dynamics simulations, we determined the mechanism of conjugate permeation through BtuB. BtuB is a β-barrel occluded by its luminal domain. The potential of mean force shows that conjugate passage is unidirectional and its movement into the BtuB β-barrel is energetically favorable upon luminal domain unfolding. Inside BtuB, PNA extends making its permeation mechanically feasible. BtuB extracellular loops are actively involved in transport through an induced-fit mechanism. We prove that the vitamin B₁₂ transport system can be hijacked to enable PNA delivery to E. coli cells.

Antisense antibacterial compounds

Extensive antibiotic use combined with poor historical drug stewardship practices have created a medical crisis in which once treatable bacterial infections are now increasingly unmanageable. To combat this, new antibiotics will need to be developed and safeguarded. An emerging class of antibiotics based upon nuclease-stable antisense technologies has proven valuable in preclinical testing against a variety of bacterial pathogens. This review describes the current state of development of antisense-based antibiotics, the mechanisms thus far employed by these compounds, and possible future avenues of research.

Antibacterial Peptide Nucleic Acids-Facts and Perspectives

Antibiotic resistance is an escalating, worldwide problem. Due to excessive use of antibiotics, multidrug-resistant bacteria have become a serious threat and a major global healthcare problem of the 21st century. This fact creates an urgent need for new and effective antimicrobials. The common strategies for antibiotic discovery are based on either modifying existing antibiotics or screening compound libraries, but these strategies have not been successful in recent decades. An alternative approach could be to use gene-specific oligonucleotides, such as peptide nucleic acid (PNA) oligomers, that can specifically target any single pathogen. This approach broadens the range of potential targets to any gene with a known sequence in any bacterium, and could significantly reduce the time required to discover new antimicrobials or their redesign, if resistance arises. We review the potential of PNA as an antibacterial molecule. First, we describe the physicochemical properties of PNA and modifications of the PNA backbone and nucleobases. Second, we review the carriers used to transport PNA to bacterial cells. Furthermore, we discuss the PNA targets in antibacterial studies focusing on antisense PNA targeting bacterial mRNA and rRNA.

Thermal Stability of Peptide Nucleic Acid Complexes

Peptide nucleic acid (PNA) is a neutral nucleic acid analogue that base pairs with itself and natural nucleic acids. PNA-nucleic acid complexes are more thermally stable than the corresponding complexes of natural nucleic acids. In addition, PNA is biostable and thus used in many antisense and antigene applications to block functional RNA or DNA via sequence-specific interactions. We have recently developed force field parameters for molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of PNA and PNA-involving duplexes with natural nucleic acids. In this work, we provide the first application of this force field to biologically relevant PNA sequences and their complexes with RNA. We investigated thermal stabilities of short PNA-PNA, PNA-RNA, and RNA-RNA duplexes using UV-monitored thermal denaturation experiments and MD simulations at ambient and elevated temperatures. The simulations show a two-state melting transition and reproduce the thermal stability from melting experiments, with PNA-PNA being the most and RNA-RNA the least stable. The PNA-PNA duplex also displays the highest activation energy for melting. The atomistic details of unfolding of PNA duplexes suggest that all PNA-PNA bases melt concomitantly, whereas the RNA-RNA and PNA-RNA are destabilized from the termini toward the central part of the duplexes.

Antimicrobial synergy between mRNA targeted peptide nucleic acid and antibiotics in E. coli

A combination of antibacterial agents should make the emergence of resistance in bacteria less probable. Thus we have analyzed the synergistic effects between antibacterial antisense peptide nucleic acids (PNA) and conventional antibiotics against Escherichia coli AS19 (lipopolysaccharide defective) strain and a derivative of a pathogenic strain E. coli O157:H7. PNAs were designed to target mRNA transcripts encoding the essential acyl carrier protein (gene acpP) and conjugated to the cell-penetrating peptide (KFF)₃K for cellular uptake. Antibiotics included aminoglycosides, aminopenicillins, polymyxins, rifamycins, sulfonamides and trimethoprim. Synergies were evaluated using the checkerboard technique. Fractional Inhibitory Concentration indices (FICi) were calculated for all combinations based on the minimal inhibitory concentration of each individual agent. The results demonstrate two novel synergistic combinations of antimicrobial agents, namely, (KFF)₃K-PNA anti-acpP with polymyxin B and (KFF)₃K-PNA anti-acpP with trimethoprim (both with FICi = 0.38). Polymyxin B's synergy postulates cell wall targeted antibiotics as attractive agents to improve the uptake of PNA while trimethoprim's interaction with PNA my reveal a new inhibitory mechanism.

Transfer RNA-derived fragments target and regulate ribosome-associated aminoacyl-transfer RNA synthetases

Ribosome-associated noncoding (ranc) RNAs are a novel class of short regulatory RNAs with functions and origins that have not been well studied. In this present study, we functionally characterized the molecular activity of Saccharomyces cerevisiae transfer RNA (tRNA)-derived fragments (tRFs) during protein biosynthesis. Our results indicate ribosome-associated tRFs derived from both 5' (ranc-5'-tRFs) and 3'-part of tRNAs (ranc-3'-tRFs) have regulatory roles during translation. We demonstrated five 3'-tRFs and one 5'-tRF associate with a small ribosomal subunit and aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aa-RSs) in yeast. Furthermore, we discovered that four yeast aa-RSs interact directly with yeast ribosomes. tRFs interactions with ribosome-associated aa-RSs correlate with impaired efficiency of tRNA aminoacylation.

Improved Force Fields for Peptide Nucleic Acids with Optimized Backbone Torsion Parameters

Peptide nucleic acids are promising nucleic acid analogs for antisense therapies as they can form stable duplex and triplex structures with DNA and RNA. Computational studies of PNA-containing duplexes and triplexes are an important component for guiding their design, yet existing force fields have not been well validated and parametrized with modern computational capabilities. We present updated CHARMM and Amber force fields for PNA that greatly improve the stability of simulated PNA-containing duplexes and triplexes in comparison with experimental structures and allow such systems to be studied on microsecond time scales. The force field modifications focus on reparametrized PNA backbone torsion angles to match high-level quantum mechanics reference energies for a model compound. The microsecond simulations of PNA-PNA, PNA-DNA, PNA-RNA, and PNA-DNA-PNA complexes also allowed a comprehensive analysis of hydration and ion interactions with such systems.

Interactions of 2'-O-methyl oligoribonucleotides with the RNA models of the 30S subunit A-site

Synthetic oligonucleotides targeting functional regions of the prokaryotic rRNA could be promising antimicrobial agents. Indeed, such oligonucleotides were proven to inhibit bacterial growth. 2’-O-methylated (2’-O-Me) oligoribonucleotides with a sequence complementary to the decoding site in 16S rRNA were reported as inhibitors of bacterial translation. However, the binding mode and structures of the formed complexes, as well as the level of selectivity of the oligonucleotides between the prokaryotic and eukaryotic target, were not determined. We have analyzed three 2’-O-Me oligoribonucleotides designed to hybridize with the models of the prokaryotic rRNA containing two neighboring aminoglycoside binding pockets. One pocket is the paromomycin/kanamycin binding site corresponding to the decoding site in the small ribosomal subunit and the other one is the close-by hygromycin B binding site whose dynamics has not been previously reported. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, as well as isothermal titration calorimetry, gel electrophoresis and spectroscopic studies have shown that the eukaryotic rRNA model is less conformationally stable (in terms of hydrogen bonds and stacking interactions) than the corresponding prokaryotic one. In MD simulations of the eukaryotic construct, the nucleotide U1498, which plays an important role in correct positioning of mRNA during translation, is flexible and spontaneously flips out into the solvent. In solution studies, the 2’-O-Me oligoribonucleotides did not interact with the double stranded rRNA models but all formed stable complexes with the single-stranded prokaryotic target. 2’-O-Me oligoribonucleotides with one and two mismatches bound less tightly to the eukaryotic target. This shows that at least three mismatches between the 2’-O-Me oligoribonucleotide and eukaryotic rRNA are required to ensure target selectivity. The results also suggest that, in the ribosome environment, the strand invasion is the preferred binding mode of 2’-O-Me oligoribonucleotides targeting the aminoglycoside binding sites in 16S rRNA.

Vitamin B12 as a carrier of peptide nucleic acid (PNA) into bacterial cells

Short modified oligonucleotides targeted at bacterial DNA or RNA could serve as antibacterial agents provided that they are efficiently taken up by bacterial cells. However, the uptake of such oligonucleotides is hindered by the bacterial cell wall. To overcome this problem, oligomers have been attached to cell-penetrating peptides, but the efficiency of delivery remains poor. Thus, we have investigated the ability of vitamin B12 to transport peptide nucleic acid (PNA) oligomers into cells of Escherichia coli and Salmonella Typhimurium. Vitamin B12 was covalently linked to a PNA oligomer targeted at the mRNA of a reporter gene expressing Red Fluorescent Protein. Cu-catalyzed 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition was employed for the synthesis of PNA-vitamin B12 conjugates; namely the vitamin B12 azide was reacted with PNA possessing the terminal alkyne group. Different types of linkers and spacers between vitamin B12 and PNA were tested, including a disulfide bond. We found that vitamin B12 transports antisense PNA into E. coli cells more efficiently than the most widely used cell-penetrating peptide (KFF)3K. We also determined that the structure of the linker impacts the antisense effect. The results of this study provide the foundation for developing vitamin B12 as a carrier of PNA oligonucleotides into bacterial cells.

Interactions of aminoglycoside antibiotics with rRNA

Aminoglycoside antibiotics are protein synthesis inhibitors applied to treat infections caused mainly by aerobic Gram-negative bacteria. Due to their adverse side effects they are last resort antibiotics typically used to combat pathogens resistant to other drugs. Aminoglycosides target ribosomes. We describe the interactions of aminoglycoside antibiotics containing a 2-deoxystreptamine (2-DOS) ring with 16S rRNA. We review the computational studies, with a focus on molecular dynamics (MD) simulations performed on RNA models mimicking the 2-DOS aminoglycoside binding site in the small ribosomal subunit. We also briefly discuss thermodynamics of interactions of these aminoglycosides with their 16S RNA target.

Helix 69 of Escherichia coli 23S ribosomal RNA as a peptide nucleic acid target

A fragment of 23S ribosomal RNA (nucleotides 1906-1924 in E. coli), termed Helix 69, forms a hairpin that is essential for ribosome function. Helix 69 forms a conformationally flexible inter-subunit connection with helix 44 of 16S ribosomal RNA, and the nucleotide A1913 of Helix 69 influences decoding accuracy. Nucleotides U1911 and U1917 are post-transcriptionally modified with pseudouridines (Ψ) and U1915 with 3-methyl-Ψ. We investigated Helix 69 as a target for a complementary synthetic oligonucleotide - peptide nucleic acid (PNA). We determined thermodynamic properties of Helix 69 and its complexes with PNA and tested the performance of PNA targeted at Helix 69 in inhibiting translation in cell-free extracts and growth of E. coli cells. First, we examined the interactions of a PNA oligomer complementary to the G1907-A1919 fragment of Helix 69 with the sequences corresponding to human and bacterial species (with or without pseudouridine modifications). PNA invades the Helix 69 hairpin creating stable complexes and PNA binding to the pseudouridylated bacterial sequence is stronger than to Helix 69 without any modifications. Second, we confirmed the binding of PNA to 23S rRNA and 70S ribosomes. Third, we verified the efficiency of translation inhibition of these PNA oligomers in the cell-free translation/transcription E. coli system, which were in a similar range as tetracycline. Next, we confirmed that PNA conjugated to the (KFF)₃K transporter peptide inhibited E. coli growth in micromolar concentrations. Overall, targeting Helix 69 with PNA or other sequence-specific oligomers could be a promising way to inhibit bacterial translation.

Conformational Dynamics of Cyanocobalamin and Its Conjugates with Peptide Nucleic Acids

Vitamin B₁₂ also called cobalamin (Cbl) is an important enzymatic cofactor taken up by mammalian and also by many bacterial cells. Peptide nucleic acid (PNA) is a synthetic DNA analogue that has the ability to bind in a complementary manner to natural nucleic acids. Provided that PNA is efficiently delivered to cells, it could act as a steric blocker of functional DNA or RNA and regulate gene expression at the level of transcription or translation. Recently, Cbl has been examined as a transporter of various molecules to cells. Also, PNA, if covalently linked with Cbl, can be delivered to bacterial cells, but it is crucial to verify that Cbl does not change the desired PNA biological properties. We have analyzed the structure and conformational dynamics of conjugates of Cbl with a PNA monomer and oligomer. We synthesized a cyanocobalamin derivative with a PNA monomer C connected via the triazole linker and determined its NMR spectra. Using microsecond-long molecular dynamics simulations, we examined the internal dynamics of cyanocobalamin-C, its conjugate with a 14-mer PNA, and free PNA. The results suggest that all compounds acquire rather compact structures but the PNA oligomer conformations vary. For the Cbl-C conjugate the cross-peaks from the ROESY spectrum corroborated with the clusters from molecular dynamics trajectories. Within PNA the dominant interaction is stacking but the stacking bases are not necessarily neighboring in the PNA sequence. More bases stack in free PNA than in PNA of the conjugate, but stacking is less stable in free PNA. PNA in the conjugate is slightly more exposed to solvent. Overall, cyanocobalamin attached to a PNA oligomer increases the flexibility of PNA in a way that could be beneficial for its hybridization with natural nucleic acid oligomers.

Analysis of ribosomal inter-subunit sites as targets for complementary oligonucleotides

The bacterial ribosome has many functional ribosomal RNA (rRNA) sites. We have computationally analyzed the rRNA regions involved in the interactions between the 30S and 50S subunits. Various properties of rRNA such as solvent accessibility, opening energy, hydrogen bonding pattern, van der Waals energy, thermodynamic stability were determined. Based on these properties we selected rRNA targets for hybridization with complementary 2'-O-methyl oligoribonucleotides (2'-OMe RNAs). Further, the inhibition efficiencies of the designed ribosome-interfering 2'-OMe RNAs were tested using a β-galactosidase assay in a translation system based on the E. coli extract. Several of the oligonucleotides displayed IC₅₀ values below 1 μM, which were in a similar range as those determined for known ribosome inhibitors, tetracycline and pactamycin. The calculated opening and van der Waals stacking energies of the rRNA targets correlated best with the inhibitory efficiencies of 2'-OMe RNAs. Moreover, the binding affinities of several oligonucleotides to both 70S ribosomes and isolated 30S and 50S subunits were measured using a double-filter retention assay. Further, we applied heat-shock chemical transformation to introduce 2'-OMe RNAs to E. coli cells and verify inhibition of bacterial growth. We observed high correlation between IC₅₀ in the cell-free extract and bacterial growth inhibition. Overall, the results suggest that the computational analysis of potential rRNA targets within the conformationally dynamic regions of inter-subunit bridges can help design efficient antisense oligomers to probe the ribosome function.

Scanning of 16S Ribosomal RNA for Peptide Nucleic Acid Targets

We have designed a protocol and server to aid in the search for putative binding sites in 16S rRNA that could be targeted by peptide nucleic acid oligomers. Various features of 16S rRNA were considered to score its regions as potential targets for sequence-specific binding that could result in inhibition of ribosome function. Specifically, apart from the functional importance of a particular rRNA region, we calculated its accessibility, flexibility, energetics of strand invasion by an oligomer, as well as similarity to human rRNA. To determine 16S rRNA flexibility in the ribosome context, we performed all-atom molecular dynamics simulations of the 30S subunit in explicit solvent. We proposed a few 16S RNA target sites, and one of them was tested experimentally to verify inhibition of bacterial growth by a peptide nucleic acid oligomer.