O6-alkylguanine postlesion DNA synthesis is correct with the right complement of hydrogen bonding

Conformation and Pairing Properties of an O6-Methyl-2'-deoxyguanosine-Directed Benzimidazole Nucleoside Analog in Duplex DNA

O6-Methyl-2'-deoxyguanosine (O6-MeG) is one of the most common DNA lesions and arises as a consequence of both xenobiotic carcinogens and endogenous methylation by S-adenosylmethionine. O6-MeG frequently causes G-to-A mutations during DNA replication due to the misincorporation of dTTP and continued DNA synthesis. Efforts to detect DNA adducts such as O6-MeG, and to understand their impacts on DNA structure and function, have motivated the creation of nucleoside analogs with altered base moieties to afford a more favorable interaction with the adduct as compared to the unmodified nucleotide. Such analogs directed at O6-MeG include benzimidazolinone and benzimidazole nucleotides, as well as their extended π surface analogs naphthimidazolinone and napthimidazole derivatives. These analogs form a more stable pair with O6-MeG than with G, most likely due to a combination of H-bonding and stacking. While extending the π surface of the analogs enhances their performance as adduct-directed probes, the precise origins of the increased affinity between the synthetic analogs and O6-MeG remain unclear. To better understand relevant conformational and pairing properties, we used X-ray crystallography and analyzed the structures of the DNA duplexes with naphthimidazolinone inserted opposite G or O6-MeG. The structures reveal a complex interaction of the analog found either in an anti orientation and stacked inside the duplex, either above or below G or O6-MeG, or in a syn orientation and paired opposite G with formation of a single H-bond. The experimental structural data are consistent with the stabilizing effect of the synthetic analog observed in UV melting experiments and calculations and moreover reveal that the origin of these observations appears to be superior stacking between O6-MeG and the extended π system of the synthetic probe.

Enzymatic Synthesis of Cu(II)-Responsive Deoxyribozymes through Polymerase Incorporation of Artificial Ligand-Type Nucleotides

Metal-mediated artificial base pairs, consisting of ligand-type nucleotides and a bridging metal ion, have shown promise as functional units to develop stimuli-responsive DNA materials. Although a variety of metal-mediated base pairs have been constructed with artificial ligand-type nucleotides and various metal ions, the application of such metal-mediated base pairs has been relatively poorly explored mainly due to the cumbersome chemical synthesis of artificial DNA strands. Herein we report a facile enzymatic method to synthesize DNA strands containing a ligand-type hydroxypyridone (H) nucleotide, which forms a Cu^II-mediated base pair (H-Cu^II-H). A two-step primer extension reaction using two commercially available polymerases enabled the incorporation of a H nucleotide at an internal position of oligonucleotides. The polymerase synthesis was subsequently applied to the development of metal-responsive deoxyribozymes (DNAzymes), whose catalytic activity was regulated by the formation of a single H-Cu^II-H base pair in its stem region. The DNAzyme activity was reversibly switched by the alternate addition and the removal of Cu^II ions. Furthermore, metal-dependent orthogonal activation of a Cu^II-responsive H-DNAzyme and a Hg^II-responsive T-DNAzyme was experimentally demonstrated by utilizing both H-Cu^II-H as well as widely explored T-Hg^II-T base pairs. These results suggest that the incorporation of H-Cu^II-H base pairs would facilitate the rational design of metal-responsive functional DNAs. Accordingly, the facile enzymatic synthesis of artificial ligand-bearing DNAs developed in this study would significantly expand the toolbox of DNA-based supramolecular chemistry and DNA nanotechnology.

Determining Steady-State Kinetics of DNA Polymerase Nucleotide Incorporation

Polymerase enzymes catalyze the replication of DNA by incorporating deoxynucleoside monophosphates (dNMPs) into a primer strand in a 5' to 3' direction. Monitoring kinetic aspects of this catalytic process provides mechanistic information regarding polymerase-mediated DNA synthesis and the influences of nucleobase structure. For example, a range of polymerases have different capacities to synthesize DNA depending on the structure of the inserted dNMP (natural or synthetic) and also depending on the templating DNA base (modified vs. unmodified). Under steady-state conditions, relative rates depend on the deoxynucleoside triphosphate (dNTP) residence times in the ternary (polymerase-DNA-dNTP) complex. This chapter describes a method to measure steady-state incorporation efficiencies by which polymerase enzymes insert dNMPs into primer-template (P/T) oligonucleotides. The method described involves the use of a primer oligonucleotide 5' radiolabeled with [γ-³²P]ATP. Significant established applications of this experiment include studies regarding mechanisms of nucleotide misincorporation as a basis of chemically induced DNA mutation. Further, it can provide information important in various contexts ranging from biophysical to medical-based studies.

DNA Adduct-Directed Synthetic Nucleosides

Chemical damage to DNA is a key initiator of adverse biological consequences due to disruption of the faithful reading of the genetic code. For example, O⁶-alkylguanine ( O⁶-alkylG) DNA adducts are strongly miscoding during DNA replication when the damaged nucleobase is a template for polymerase-mediated translesion DNA synthesis. Thus, mutations derived from O⁶-alkylG adducts can have severe adverse effects on protein translation and function and are an early event in the initiation of carcinogenesis. However, the low abundance of these adducts places significant limitations on our ability to relate their presence and biological influences with resultant mutations or disease risk. As a consequence, there is a critical need for novel tools to detect and study the biological role of alkylation adducts. Incorporating DNA bases with altered structures that are derived synthetically is a strategy that has been used widely to interrogate biological processes involving DNA. Such synthetic nucleosides have contributed to our understanding of DNA structure, DNA polymerase (Pol) and repair enzyme function, and to the expansion of the genetic alphabet. This Account describes our efforts toward creating and applying synthetic nucleosides directed at DNA adducts. We synthesized a variety of nucleosides with altered base structures that complement the altered hydrogen bonding capacity and hydrophilicity of O⁶-alkylG adducts. The heterocyclic perimidinone-derived nucleoside Per was the first of such adduct-directed synthetic nucleosides; it specifically stabilized O⁶-benzylguanine ( O⁶-BnG) in a DNA duplex. Structural variants of Per were used to determine hydrogen bonding and base-stacking contributions to DNA duplex stability in templates containing O⁶-BnG as well as O⁶-methylguanine ( O⁶-MeG) adducts. We created synthetic probes able to stabilize damaged over undamaged templates and established how altered hydrogen bonding or base-stacking properties impact DNA duplex stability as a function of adduct structures. This knowledge was then applied to devise a hybridization-based detection strategy involving gold nanoparticles that distinguish damaged from undamaged DNA by colorimetric changes. Furthermore, synthetic nucleosides were used as mechanistic tools to understand chemical determinants such as hydrogen bonding, π-stacking, and size and shape deviations that impact the efficiency and fidelity of DNA adduct bypass by DNA Pols. Finally, we reported the first example of amplifying alkylated DNA, accomplished by combining an engineered polymerase and synthetic triphosphate for which incorporation is templated by a DNA adduct. The presence of the synthetic nucleoside in amplicons could serve as a marker for the presence and location of DNA damage at low levels in DNA strands. Adduct-directed synthetic nucleosides have opened new concepts to interrogate the levels, locations, and biological influences of DNA alkylation.

A gene-targeted polymerase-mediated strategy to identify O6-methylguanine damage

Detecting DNA adducts in cancer genes is important for understanding cancer etiology. This study reports a strategy to identify the mutagenic DNA adduct O⁶-methylguanine in K-Ras. The strategy involves selective replication past a synthetic primer when placed opposite O⁶-methylguanine. Future work can apply this approach to other cancer-relevant genes.

High Sensitivity of Human Translesion DNA Synthesis Polymerase κ to Variation in O6-Carboxymethylguanine Structures

Carboxymethylation of DNA, including the formation of the DNA adduct O⁶-carboxymethylguanine ( O⁶-CMG), is associated with lifestyle factors, such as diet. It can impede replicative polymerases (Pols) and lead to replication fork stalling, or an alternative means for replication to proceed by translesion DNA synthesis (TLS). TLS requires specialized DNA Pols characterized by open and preformed active sites capable of preferential bypass of alkylated DNA adducts but that have high error rates, leading to mutations. Human TLS Pols can bypass O⁶-CMG with varying degrees of accuracy, but it is not known how the chemical structure of the O⁶-CMG adduct influences polymerase proficiency or fidelity. To better understand how adduct structure determines dNTP selection at lesion sites, we prepared DNA templates with a series of O⁶-CMG structural analogs and compared the primer extension patterns of Y- and X-family Pols in response to these modifications. The results indicate that the structure of the DNA adduct had a striking effect on dNTP selection by Pol κ and that an increased steric size influences the fidelity of Pol η, whereas Pol ι and β function were only marginally affected. To test the hypothesis that specific hydrogen bonding interactions between the templating base and the incoming dNTP are a basis of this selection, we modeled the structural analogs with incoming dNTP in the Pol κ active site. These data indicate that the base pairing geometry and stabilization by a dense hydrogen bonding network are important molecular features for dNTP incorporation, providing a basis for understanding error-free bypass of O⁶-CMG by Pol κ.

Computational insights into the mutagenicity of two tobacco-derived carcinogenic DNA lesions

4-(methylnitrosamino)-1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone is a potent carcinogen found in all tobacco products that leads to a variety of DNA lesions in cells, including O6-[4-oxo-4-(3-pyridyl)butyl]guanine (POB-G) and O6-[4-hydroxy-4-(3-pyridyl)butyl]guanine (PHB-G), which differ by only a single substituent in the bulky moiety. This work uses a multiscale computational approach to shed light on the intrinsic conformational and base-pairing preferences of POB-G and PHB-G, and the corresponding properties in DNA and the polymerase η active site. Our calculations reveal that both lesions form stable pairs with C and T, with the T pairs being the least distorted relative to canonical DNA. This rationalizes the experimentally reported mutational profile for POB-G and validates our computational model. The same approach predicts that PHB-G is more mutagenic than POB-G due to a difference in the bulky moiety hydrogen-bonding pattern, which increases the stability of the PHB-G:T pair. The mutagenicity of PHB-G is likely further increased by stabilization of an intercalated DNA conformation that is associated with deletion mutations. This work thereby uncovers structural explanations for the reported mutagenicity of POB-G, provides the first clues regarding the mutagenicity of PHB-G and complements a growing body of literature highlighting that subtle chemical changes can affect the biological outcomes of DNA adducts.

Hydrogen-Bonding Interactions at the DNA Terminus Promote Extension from Methylguanine Lesions by Human Extender DNA Polymerase ζ

Chemically induced DNA lesions can become DNA replication substrates that are bypassed by low-fidelity DNA polymerases. Following nucleotide misinsertion opposite a DNA lesion, the extension step can contribute to preserving such errors and lead to genomic instability and cancer. DNA polymerase ζ, a B-family polymerase, is proficient as an extender polymerase that catalyzes elongation; however, the chemical factors that impact its DNA replication are not understood. This study addresses the question of how DNA polymerase ζ achieves extension by examining the ability of recombinant human DNA polymerase ζ to extend from a series of methylated guanine lesions. The influence of H-bonding was examined by placing structurally altered nucleoside analogues and canonical bases opposite G, O⁶-MeG, N¹-MeG, and N²-MeG. We determined that terminal base pairs with the highest proclivity for H-bonding were most efficiently extended in both primer extension assays and steady-state kinetic analysis. In contrast, when no H-bonding was possible at the DNA terminus, the least efficient steady-state kinetics were observed. To evaluate H-bonding protein minor groove interactions that may underlie this phenomenon, we performed computational modeling with Escherichia coli DNA polymerase II, a homologue for DNA polymerase ζ. The modeling data together with the primer extension assays demonstrate the importance of having a carbonyl group on the primer strand that can interact with a lysine residue found to be conserved in many B-family polymerases, including human Pol ζ. These data provide a model whereby interbase H-bonding interactions at the DNA terminus promote lesion bypass and extension by human DNA polymerase ζ.

The Base Pairing Partner Modulates Alkylguanine Alkyltransferase

O⁶-Alkylguanine DNA adducts are repaired by the suicide enzyme alkylguanine alkyltransferase (AGT). AGT facilitates repair by binding DNA in the minor groove, flipping out the damaged base, and transferring the O⁶-alkyl group to a cysteine residue in the enzyme's active site. Despite there being significant knowledge concerning the mechanism of AGT repair, there is limited insight regarding how altered interactions of the adduct with its complementary base in the DNA duplex influence its recognition and repair. In this study, the relationship of base pairing interactions and repair by human AGT (hAGT) was tested in the frequently mutated codon 12 of the KRAS gene with complementary sequences containing each canonical DNA base. The rate of O⁶-MeG repair decreased 2-fold when O⁶-MeG was paired with G, whereas all other canonical bases had no impact on the repair rate. We used a combination of biochemical studies, molecular modeling, and artificial nucleobases to elucidate the mechanism accounting for the 2-fold decrease. Our results suggest that the reduced rate of repair is due to O⁶-MeG adopting a syn conformation about the glycosidic bond precluding the formation of a repair-active complex. These data provide a novel chemical basis for how direct reversion repair may be impeded through modification of the base pair partner and support the use of artificial nucleobases as tools to probe the biochemistry of damage repair processes.

Molecular Insights into the Translesion Synthesis of Benzyl-Guanine from Molecular Dynamics Simulations: Structural Evidence of Mutagenic and Nonmutagenic Replication

DNA can be damaged by many compounds in our environment, and the resulting damaged DNA is commonly replicated by translesion synthesis (TLS) polymerases. Because the mechanism and efficiency of TLS are affected by the type of DNA damage, obtaining information for a variety of DNA adducts is critical. However, there is no structural information for the insertion of a dNTP opposite an O6-dG adduct, which is a particularly harmful class of DNA lesions. We used molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to investigate structural and energetic parameters that dictate preferred dNTP insertion opposite O6-benzyl-guanine (Bz-dG) by DNA polymerase IV, a prototypical TLS polymerase. Specifically, MD simulations were completed on all possible ternary insertion complexes and ternary -1 base deletion complexes with different Bz-dG conformations. Our data suggests that the purines are unlikely to be inserted opposite anti- or syn-Bz-dG, and dTTP is unlikely to be inserted opposite syn-Bz-dG, because of changes in the active site conformation, including critical hydrogen-bonding interactions and/or reaction-ready parameters compared to natural dG replication. In contrast, a preserved active site conformation suggests that dCTP can be inserted opposite either anti- or syn-Bz-dG and dTTP can be inserted opposite anti-Bz-dG. This is the first structural explanation for the experimentally observed preferential insertion of dCTP and misincorporation of dTTP opposite Bz-dG. Furthermore, we provide atomic level insight into why Bz-dG replication does not lead to deletion mutations, which is in contrast with the replication outcomes of other adducts. These findings provide a basis for understanding the replication of related O6-dG adducts.

Bypass of Mutagenic O(6)-Carboxymethylguanine DNA Adducts by Human Y- and B-Family Polymerases

The generation of chemical alkylating agents from nitrosation of glycine and bile acid conjugates in the gastrointestinal tract is hypothesized to initiate carcinogenesis. O(6)-carboxymethylguanine (O(6)-CMG) is a product of DNA alkylation derived from nitrosated glycine. Although the tendency of the structurally related adduct O(6)-methylguanine to code for the misincoporation of TTP during DNA replication is well-established, the impact of the presence of the O(6)-CMG adduct in a DNA template on the efficiency and fidelity of translesion DNA synthesis (TLS) by human DNA polymerases (Pols) has hitherto not been described. Herein, we characterize the ability of the four human TLS Pols η, ι, κ, and ζ and the replicative Pol δ to bypass O(6)-CMG in a prevalent mutational hot-spot for colon cancer. The results indicate that Pol η replicates past O(6)-CMG, incorporating dCMP or dAMP, whereas Pol κ incorporates dCMP only, and Pol ι incorporates primarily dTMP. Additionally, the subsequent extension step was carried out with high efficiency by TLS Pols η, κ, and ζ, while Pol ι was unable to extend from a terminal mismatch. These results provide a first basis of O(6)-CMG-promoted base misincorporation by Y- and B-family polymerases potentially leading to mutational signatures associated with colon cancer.

The use of an artificial nucleotide for polymerase-based recognition of carcinogenic O6-alkylguanine DNA adducts

Enzymatic approaches for locating alkylation adducts at single-base resolution in DNA could enable new technologies for understanding carcinogenesis and supporting personalized chemotherapy. Artificial nucleotides that specifically pair with alkylated bases offer a possible strategy for recognition and amplification of adducted DNA, and adduct-templated incorporation of an artificial nucleotide has been demonstrated for a model DNA adduct O(6)-benzylguanine by a DNA polymerase. In this study, DNA adducts of biological relevance, O(6)-methylguanine (O(6)-MeG) and O(6)-carboxymethylguanine (O(6)-CMG), were characterized to be effective templates for the incorporation of benzimidazole-derived 2'-deoxynucleoside-5'-O-triphosphates ( BENZI: TP and BIM: TP) by an engineered KlenTaq DNA polymerase. The enzyme catalyzed specific incorporation of the artificial nucleotide BENZI: opposite adducts, with up to 150-fold higher catalytic efficiency for O(6)-MeG over guanine in the template. Furthermore, addition of artificial nucleotide BENZI: was required for full-length DNA synthesis during bypass of O(6)-CMG. Selective incorporation of the artificial nucleotide opposite an O(6)-alkylguanine DNA adduct was verified using a novel 2',3'-dideoxy derivative of BENZI: TP. The strategy was used to recognize adducts in the presence of excess unmodified DNA. The specific processing of BENZI: TP opposite biologically relevant O(6)-alkylguanine adducts is characterized herein as a basis for potential future DNA adduct sequencing technologies.

Computational Evaluation of Nucleotide Insertion Opposite Expanded and Widened DNA by the Translesion Synthesis Polymerase Dpo4

Expanded (x) and widened (y) deoxyribose nucleic acids (DNA) have an extra benzene ring incorporated either horizontally (xDNA) or vertically (yDNA) between a natural pyrimidine base and the deoxyribose, or between the 5- and 6-membered rings of a natural purine. Far-reaching applications for (x,y)DNA include nucleic acid probes and extending the natural genetic code. Since modified nucleobases must encode information that can be passed to the next generation in order to be a useful extension of the genetic code, the ability of translesion (bypass) polymerases to replicate modified bases is an active area of research. The common model bypass polymerase DNA polymerase IV (Dpo4) has been previously shown to successfully replicate and extend past a single modified nucleobase on a template DNA strand. In the current study, molecular dynamics (MD) simulations are used to evaluate the accommodation of expanded/widened nucleobases in the Dpo4 active site, providing the first structural information on the replication of (x,y)DNA. Our results indicate that the Dpo4 catalytic (palm) domain is not significantly impacted by the (x,y)DNA bases. Instead, the template strand is displaced to accommodate the increased C1’–C1’ base-pair distance. The structural insights unveiled in the present work not only increase our fundamental understanding of Dpo4 replication, but also reveal the process by which Dpo4 replicates (x,y)DNA, and thereby will contribute to the optimization of high fidelity and efficient polymerases for the replication of modified nucleobases.

Sequencing of DNA Lesions Facilitated by Site-Specific Excision via Base Excision Repair DNA Glycosylases Yielding Ligatable Gaps

Modifications to nucleotides in the genome can lead to mutations or are involved in regulation of gene expression, and therefore, finding the site of modification is a worthy goal. Robust methods for sequencing modification sites on commercial sequencers have not been developed beyond the epigenetic marks on cytosine. Herein, a method to sequence DNA modification sites was developed that utilizes DNA glycosylases found in the base excision repair pathway to excise the modification. This approach yields a gap at the modification site that is sealed by T4-DNA ligase, yielding a product strand missing the modification. Upon sequencing, the modified nucleotide is reported as a deletion mutation, identifying its location. This approach was used to detect a uracil (U) or 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine (OG) in codon 12 of the KRAS gene in synthetic oligodeoxynucleotides. Additionally, an OG modification site was placed in the VEGF promoter in a plasmid and sequenced. This method requires only commercially available materials and can be put into practice on any sequencing platform, allowing this method to have broad potential for finding modifications in DNA.

Identification of DNA lesions using a third base pair for amplification and nanopore sequencing

Damage to the genome is implicated in the progression of cancer and stress-induced diseases. DNA lesions exist in low levels, and cannot be amplified by standard PCR because they are frequently strong blocks to polymerases. Here, we describe a method for PCR amplification of lesion-containing DNA in which the site and identity could be marked, copied and sequenced. Critical for this method is installation of either the dNaM or d5SICS nucleotides at the lesion site after processing via the base excision repair process. These marker nucleotides constitute an unnatural base pair, allowing large quantities of marked DNA to be made by PCR amplification. Sanger sequencing confirms the potential for this method to locate lesions by marking, amplifying and sequencing a lesion in the KRAS gene. Detection using the α-hemolysin nanopore is also developed to analyse the markers in individual DNA strands with the potential to identify multiple lesions per strand.

Genomic DNA lesions exist in low levels and cannot be amplified by standard PCR. Here, Riedl et al. report a method to amplify damaged DNA sites by replacing them via DNA repair with unnatural base pairs, which are subsequently identified by Sanger sequencing or α-hemolysin nanopore sequencing.

Specific incorporation of an artificial nucleotide opposite a mutagenic DNA adduct by a DNA polymerase

The ability to detect DNA modification sites at single base resolution could significantly advance studies regarding DNA adduct levels, which are extremely difficult to determine. Artificial nucleotides that are specifically incorporated opposite a modified DNA site offer a potential strategy for detection of such sites by DNA polymerase-based systems. Here we investigate the action of newly synthesized base-modified benzimidazole-derived 2'-deoxynucleoside-5'-O-triphosphates on DNA polymerases when performing translesion DNA synthesis past the pro-mutagenic DNA adduct O(6)-benzylguanine (O(6)-BnG). We found that a mutated form of KlenTaq DNA polymerase, i.e., KTqM747K, catalyzed O(6)-BnG adduct-specific processing of the artificial BenziTP in favor of the natural dNTPs. Steady-state kinetic parameters revealed that KTqM747K catalysis of BenziTP is 25-fold more efficient for template O(6)-BnG than G, and 5-fold more efficient than natural dTMP misincorporation in adduct bypass. Furthermore, the nucleotide analogue BenziTP is required for full-length product formation in O(6)-BnG bypass, as without BenziTP the polymerase stalls at the adduct site. By combining the KTqM747K polymerase and BenziTP, a first round of DNA synthesis enabled subsequent amplification of Benzi-containing DNA. These results advance the development of technologies for detecting DNA adducts.