Single R-Group Polymorphisms (SRPs) and R-Cliffs: An Intuitive Framework for Analyzing and Visualizing Activity Cliffs in a Single Analog Series

Automatic Identification of Analogue Series from Large Compound Data Sets: Methods and Applications

Analogue series play a key role in drug discovery. They arise naturally in lead optimization efforts where analogues are explored based on one or a few core structures. However, it is much harder to accurately identify and extract pairs or series of analogue molecules in large compound databases with no predefined core structures. This methodological review outlines the most common and recent methodological developments to automatically identify analogue series in large libraries. Initial approaches focused on using predefined rules to extract scaffold structures, such as the popular Bemis-Murcko scaffold. Later on, the matched molecular pair concept led to efficient algorithms to identify similar compounds sharing a common core structure by exploring many putative scaffolds for each compound. Further developments of these ideas yielded, on the one hand, approaches for hierarchical scaffold decomposition and, on the other hand, algorithms for the extraction of analogue series based on single-site modifications (so-called matched molecular series) by exploring potential scaffold structures based on systematic molecule fragmentation. Eventually, further development of these approaches resulted in methods for extracting analogue series defined by a single core structure with several substitution sites that allow convenient representations, such as R-group tables. These methods enable the efficient analysis of large data sets with hundreds of thousands or even millions of compounds and have spawned many related methodological developments.

Fast Modeling of Binding Affinities by Means of Superposing Significant Interaction Rules (SSIR) Method

The Superposing Significant Interaction Rules (SSIR) method is described. It is a general combinatorial and symbolic procedure able to rank compounds belonging to combinatorial analogue series. The procedure generates structure-activity relationship (SAR) models and also serves as an inverse SAR tool. The method is fast and can deal with large databases. SSIR operates from statistical significances calculated from the available library of compounds and according to the previously attached molecular labels of interest or non-interest. The required symbolic codification allows dealing with almost any combinatorial data set, even in a confidential manner, if desired. The application example categorizes molecules as binding or non-binding, and consensus ranking SAR models are generated from training and two distinct cross-validation methods: leave-one-out and balanced leave-two-out (BL2O), the latter being suited for the treatment of binary properties.

AnalogExplorer2 - Stereochemistry sensitive graphical analysis of large analog series

AnalogExplorer is a computational methodology for the extraction and organization of series of structural analogs from compound data sets and their graphical analysis. The method is suitable for the analysis of large analog series originating from lead optimization programs. Herein we report AnalogExplorer2 designed to explicitly take stereochemical information during graphical analysis into account and describe a freely available deposition of the original AnalogExplorer program, AnalogExplorer2, and exemplary compound sets to illustrate their use.

An Overview of the Challenges in Designing, Integrating, and Delivering BARD: A Public Chemical-Biology Resource and Query Portal for Multiple Organizations, Locations, and Disciplines

Recent industry-academic partnerships involve collaboration among disciplines, locations, and organizations using publicly funded "open-access" and proprietary commercial data sources. These require the effective integration of chemical and biological information from diverse data sources, which presents key informatics, personnel, and organizational challenges. The BioAssay Research Database (BARD) was conceived to address these challenges and serve as a community-wide resource and intuitive web portal for public-sector chemical-biology data. Its initial focus is to enable scientists to more effectively use the National Institutes of Health Roadmap Molecular Libraries Program (MLP) data generated from the 3-year pilot and 6-year production phases of the Molecular Libraries Probe Production Centers Network (MLPCN), which is currently in its final year. BARD evolves the current data standards through structured assay and result annotations that leverage BioAssay Ontology and other industry-standard ontologies, and a core hierarchy of assay definition terms and data standards defined specifically for small-molecule assay data. We initially focused on migrating the highest-value MLP data into BARD and bringing it up to this new standard. We review the technical and organizational challenges overcome by the interdisciplinary BARD team, veterans of public- and private-sector data-integration projects, who are collaborating to describe (functional specifications), design (technical specifications), and implement this next-generation software solution.

Recent progress in understanding activity cliffs and their utility in medicinal chemistry

The activity cliff concept is of high relevance for medicinal chemistry. Recent studies are discussed that have further refined our understanding of activity cliffs and suggested different ways of exploiting activity cliff information. These include alternative approaches to define and classify activity cliffs in two and three dimensions, data mining investigations to systematically detect all possible activity cliffs, the introduction of computational methods to predict activity cliffs, and studies designed to explore activity cliff progression in medicinal chemistry. The discussion of these studies is complemented with new findings revealing the frequency of activity cliff formation when different molecular representations are used and the distribution of activity cliffs across different targets. Taken together, the results have a number of implications for the practice of medicinal chemistry.

Rapid scanning structure-activity relationships in combinatorial data sets: identification of activity switches

We present a general approach to describe the structure-activity relationships (SAR) of combinatorial data sets with activity for two biological endpoints with emphasis on the rapid identification of substitutions that have a large impact on activity and selectivity. The approach uses dual-activity difference (DAD) maps that represent a visual and quantitative analysis of all pairwise comparisons of one, two, or more substitutions around a molecular template. Scanning the SAR of data sets using DAD maps allows the visual and quantitative identification of activity switches defined as specific substitutions that have an opposite effect on the activity of the compounds against two targets. The approach also rapidly identifies single- and double-target R-cliffs, i.e., compounds where a single or double substitution around the central scaffold dramatically modifies the activity for one or two targets, respectively. The approach introduced in this report can be applied to any analogue series with two biological activity endpoints. To illustrate the approach, we discuss the SAR of 106 pyrrolidine bis-diketopiperazines tested against two formylpeptide receptors obtained from positional scanning deconvolution methods of mixture-based libraries.

On exploring structure-activity relationships

Understanding structure-activity relationships (SARs) for a given set of molecules allows one to rationally explore chemical space and develop a chemical series optimizing multiple physicochemical and biological properties simultaneously, for instance, improving potency, reducing toxicity, and ensuring sufficient bioavailability. In silico methods allow rapid and efficient characterization of SARs and facilitate building a variety of models to capture and encode one or more SARs, which can then be used to predict activities for new molecules. By coupling these methods with in silico modifications of structures, one can easily prioritize large screening decks or even generate new compounds de novo and ascertain whether they belong to the SAR being studied. Computational methods can provide a guide for the experienced user by integrating and summarizing large amounts of preexisting data to suggest useful structural modifications. This chapter highlights the different types of SAR modeling methods and how they support the task of exploring chemical space to elucidate and optimize SARs in a drug discovery setting. In addition to considering modeling algorithms, I briefly discuss how to use databases as a source of SAR data to inform and enhance the exploration of SAR trends. I also review common modeling techniques that are used to encode SARs, recent work in the area of structure-activity landscapes, the role of SAR databases, and alternative approaches to exploring SAR data that do not involve explicit model development.

Scanning structure-activity relationships with structure-activity similarity and related maps: from consensus activity cliffs to selectivity switches

Systematic description of structure-activity relationships (SARs) of data sets and structure-property relationships (SPRs) is of paramount importance in medicinal chemistry and other research fields. To this end, structure-activity similarity (SAS) maps are one of the first tools proposed to describe SARs using the concept of activity landscape modeling. One of the major goals of the SAS maps is to identify activity cliffs defined as chemical compounds with high similar structure but unexpectedly very different biological activity. Since the first publication of the SAS maps more than ten years ago, these tools have evolved and adapted over the years to analyze various types of compound collections, including structural diverse and combinatorial sets with activity for one or multiple biological end points. The development of SAS maps has led to general concepts that are applicable to other activity landscape methods such as "consensus activity cliffs" (activity cliffs common to a series of representations or descriptors) and "selectivity switches" (structural changes that completely invert the selectivity pattern of similar compounds against two biological end points). Herein, we review the development, practical applications, limitations, and perspectives of the SAS and related maps which are intuitive and powerful informatics tools to computationally analyze SPRs.

Exploring Structure-Activity Data Using the Landscape Paradigm

In this article we present an overview of the origin and applications of the activity landscape view of structure-actvitiy relationship data as conceived by Maggiora. Within this landscape, different regions exemplify different aspects of SAR trends - ranging from smoothly varying trends to discontinuous trends (also termed activity cliffs). We discuss the various definitions of landscapes and cliffs that have been proposed as well as different approaches to the numerical quantification of a landscape. We then highlight some of the landscape visualization approaches that have been developed, followed by a review of the various applications of activity landscapes and cliffs to topics in medicinal chemistry and SAR analysis.

Directed R-group combination graph: a methodology to uncover structure-activity relationship patterns in a series of analogues

A graphical method is introduced to study details of structure-activity relationships (SARs) in analogue series that further extends conventional analysis of analogues using R-group tables or related approaches and that provides additional and more differentiated SAR information. The newly designed graph structure represents entire series of analogues in a consistent manner, regardless of their size and complexity of substitution patterns. The approach is specifically tailored toward a systematic exploration and intuitive interpretation of SAR features involving different R-groups and their combinations. Analogues and their potency information are systematically organized on the basis of R-group combinations that are present in a series. This organization scheme results in graph components that represent well-defined SAR patterns. Analysis of these patterns provides an immediate access to critical substitution sites and R-group combinations, favorable and unfavorable R-groups, or nonadditive potency effects of multisite substitutions. Furthermore, the data structure makes it possible to design new analogues by combining favorable R-group combinations derived from different compounds.