Redox Properties of Wild-Type and Heme-Binding Loop Mutants of Bacterial Cytochromes c Measured by Direct Electrochemistry

Mutating the environment of heme b595 of E. coli cytochrome bd-I oxidase shifts its redox potential by 200 mV without inactivating the enzyme

Cytochrome bd-I catalyzes the reduction of oxygen to water with the aid of hemes b₅₅₈, b₅₉₅ and d. Here, effects of a mutation of E445, a ligand of heme b₅₉₅ and of R448, hydrogen bonded to E445 are studied electrochemically in the E. coli enzyme. The equilibrium potential of the three hemes are shifted by up to 200 mV in these mutants. Strikingly the E445D and the R448N mutants show a turnover of 41 ± 2 % and 20 ± 4 %, respectively. Electrocatalytic studies confirm that the mutants react with oxygen and bind and release NO. These results point towards the ability of cytochrome bd to react even if the electron transfer is less favorable.

Elucidating Electron Storage and Distribution within the Pentaheme Scaffold of Cytochrome c Nitrite Reductase (NrfA)

Cytochrome c nitrite reductases (CcNIR or NrfA) play important roles in the global nitrogen cycle by conserving the usable nitrogen in the soil. Here, the electron storage and distribution properties within the pentaheme scaffold of Geobacter lovleyi NrfA were investigated via electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy coupled with chemical titration experiments. Initially, a chemical reduction method was established to sequentially add electrons to the fully oxidized protein, 1 equiv at a time. The step-by-step reduction of the hemes was then followed using ultraviolet-visible absorption and EPR spectroscopy. EPR spectral simulations were used to elucidate the sequence of heme reduction within the pentaheme scaffold of NrfA and identify the signals of all five hemes in the EPR spectra. Electrochemical experiments ascertain the reduction potentials for each heme, observed in a narrow range from +10 mV (heme 5) to -226 mV (heme 3) (vs the standard hydrogen electrode). On the basis of quantitative analysis and simulation of the EPR data, we demonstrate that hemes 4 and 5 are reduced first (before the active site heme 1) and serve the purpose of an electron storage unit within the protein. To probe the role of the central heme 3, an H108M NrfA variant was generated where the reduction potential of heme 3 is shifted positively (from -226 to +48 mV). The H108M mutation significantly impacts the distribution of electrons within the pentaheme scaffold and the reduction potentials of the hemes, reducing the catalytic activity of the enzyme to 1% compared to that of the wild type. We propose that this is due to heme 3's important role as an electron gateway in the wild-type enzyme.

Influence of heme c attachment on heme conformation and potential

Heme c is characterized by its covalent attachment to a polypeptide. The attachment is typically to a CXXCH motif in which the two Cys form thioether bonds with the heme, "X" can be any amino acid other than Cys, and the His serves as a heme axial ligand. Some cytochromes c, however, contain heme attachment motifs with three or four intervening residues in a CX₃CH or CX₄CH motif. Here, the impacts of these variations in the heme attachment motif on heme ruffling and electronic structure are investigated by spectroscopically characterizing CX₃CH and CX₄CH variants of Hydrogenobacter thermophilus cytochrome c₅₅₂. In addition, a novel CXCH variant is studied. ¹H and ¹³C NMR, EPR, and resonance Raman spectra of the protein variants are analyzed to deduce the extent of ruffling using previously reported relationships between these spectral data and heme ruffling. In addition, the reduction potentials of these protein variants are measured using protein film voltammetry. The CXCH and CX₄CH variants are found to have enhanced heme ruffling and lower reduction potentials. Implications of these results for the use of these noncanonical motifs in nature, and for the engineering of novel heme peptide structures, are discussed.

Determining Redox Potentials of the Iron-Sulfur Clusters of the AdoMet Radical Enzyme Superfamily

While protein film electrochemistry (PFE) has proven to be an effective tool in the interrogation of redox cofactors and assessing the electrocatalytic activity of many different enzymes, recently it has been proven to be useful for the study of the redox potentials of the cofactors of AdoMet radical enzymes (AREs). In this chapter, we review the challenges and opportunities of examining the redox cofactors of AREs in a high level of detail, particularly for the deconvolution of redox potentials of multiple cofactors. We comment on how to best assess the electroactive nature of any given ARE, and we see that when applied well, PFE allows for not only determining redox potentials, but also determining proton-coupling and ligand-binding phenomena in the ARE superfamily.

Functionally Distinct Bacterial Cytochrome c Peroxidases Proceed through a Common (Electro)catalytic Intermediate

The diheme cytochrome c peroxidase from Shewanella oneidensis (So CcP) requires a single electron reduction to convert the oxidized, as-isolated enzyme to an active conformation. We employ protein film voltammetry to investigate the mechanism of hydrogen peroxide turnover by So CcP. When the enzyme is poised in the active state by incubation with sodium l-ascorbate, the graphite electrode specifically captures a highly active state that turns over peroxide in a high potential regime. This is the first example of an on-pathway catalytic intermediate observed for a bacterial diheme cytochrome c peroxidase that requires reductive activation, consistent with the observed voltammetric response from the diheme cytochrome c peroxidase from Nitrosomonas europaea (Ne), which is constitutively active and does not require the same one electron activation. Mutational analysis at the active site of So CcP confirms that the rate-limiting step involves a proton-coupled single electron reduction of a high valent iron species centered on the low-potential heme, consistent with the same mutation in Ne CcP. The pH dependence of catalysis for wild-type So CcP suggests that reduction shifts the pK(a)'s of at least two amino acids. Mutation of His81 in "loop 1", a surface exposed loop thought to shift conformation during the reductive activation process, eliminated one of the pH dependent features, confirming that the loop 1 shifts, changing the environment of His81 during the rate-limiting step. The observed catalytic intermediate has the same electron stoichiometry and similar pH dependence to that previously reported for Ne CcP, which is constitutively active and therefore hypothesized to follow a different catalytic mechanism. The prominent similarities between the rate-limiting steps of differing mechanistic classes of bCcPs suggest unexpected similarities in the intermediates formed.

Methionine ligand lability of homologous monoheme cytochromes c

Direct electrochemical analysis of adsorbed bacterial monoheme cytochromes c has revealed a phenomenological loss of the axial methionine when examined using pyrolytic "edge-plane" graphite (EPG) electrodes. While prior findings have reported that the Met-loss state may be quantitatively understood using the cytochrome c from Hydrogenobacter thermophilus as a model system, here we demonstrate that the formation of the Met-loss state upon EPG electrodes can be observed for a range of cytochrome orthologs. Through an electrochemical comparison of the wild-type proteins from organisms of varying growth temperature optima, we establish that Met-ligand losses at graphite surfaces have similar energetics to the "foldons" for known protein folding pathways. Furthermore, a downward shift in reduction potential to approximately -100 mV vs standard hydrogen electrode was observed, similar to that of the alkaline transition found in mitochondrial cytochromes c. Pourbaix diagrams for the Met-loss forms of each cytochrome, considered here in comparison to mutants where the Met-ligand has been substituted to His or Ala, suggest that the nature of the Met-loss state is distinct from either a His-/aquo- or a bis-His-ligated heme center, yet more closely matches the pKa values found for bis-His-ligated hemes., We find the propensity for adoption of the Met-loss state in bacterial monoheme cytochromes c scales with their overall thermal stability, though not with the specific stability of the Fe-Met bond.

Structural characterization of nitrosomonas europaea cytochrome c-552 variants with marked differences in electronic structure

Nitrosomonas europaea cytochrome c-552 (Ne c-552) variants with the same His/Met axial ligand set but with different EPR spectra have been characterized structurally, to aid understanding of how molecular structure determines heme electronic structure. Visible light absorption, Raman, and resonance Raman spectroscopy of the protein crystals was performed along with structure determination. The structures solved are those of Ne c-552, which displays a "HALS" (or highly anisotropic low-spin) EPR spectrum, and of the deletion mutant Ne N64Δ, which has a rhombic EPR spectrum. Two X-ray crystal structures of wild-type Ne c-552 are reported; one is of the protein isolated from N. europaea cells (Ne c-552n, 2.35 Å resolution), and the other is of recombinant protein expressed in Escherichia coli (Ne c-552r, 1.63 Å resolution). Ne N64Δ crystallized in two different space groups, and two structures are reported [monoclinic (2.1 Å resolution) and hexagonal (2.3 Å resolution)]. Comparison of the structures of the wild-type and mutant proteins reveals that heme ruffling is increased in the mutant; increased ruffling is predicted to yield a more rhombic EPR spectrum. The 2.35 Å Ne c-552n structure shows 18 molecules in the asymmetric unit; analysis of the structure is consistent with population of more than one axial Met configuration, as seen previously by NMR. Finally, the mutation was shown to yield a more hydrophobic heme pocket and to expel water molecules from near the axial Met. These structures reveal that heme pocket residue 64 plays multiple roles in regulating the axial ligand orientation and the interaction of water with the heme. These results support the hypothesis that more ruffled hemes lead to more rhombic EPR signals in cytochromes c with His/Met axial ligation.

Multi-heme proteins: nature's electronic multi-purpose tool

While iron is often a limiting nutrient to Biology, when the element is found in the form of heme cofactors (iron protoporphyrin IX), living systems have excelled at modifying and tailoring the chemistry of the metal. In the context of proteins and enzymes, heme cofactors are increasingly found in stoichiometries greater than one, where a single protein macromolecule contains more than one heme unit. When paired or coupled together, these protein associated heme groups perform a wide variety of tasks, such as redox communication, long range electron transfer and storage of reducing/oxidizing equivalents. Here, we review recent advances in the field of multi-heme proteins, focusing on emergent properties of these complex redox proteins, and strategies found in Nature where such proteins appear to be modular and essential components of larger biochemical pathways. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Metals in Bioenergetics and Biomimetics Systems.

Methionine ligand lability in bacterial monoheme cytochromes c: an electrochemical study

The direct electrochemical analysis of adsorbed redox active proteins has proven to be a powerful technique in biophysical chemistry, frequently making use of the electrode material pyrolytic "edge-plane" graphite. However, many heme-bearing proteins such as cytochromes c have been also examined systematically at alkanethiol-modified gold surfaces, and previously we reported the characterization of the redox properties of a series of bacterial cytochromes c in a side-by-side comparison of carbon and gold electrode materials. In our prior findings, we reported an unanticipated, low potential (E(m) ∼ -100 mV vs SHE) redox couple that could be analogously observed when a variety of monoheme cytochromes c are adsorbed onto carbon-based electrodes. Here we demonstrate that our prior phenomological data can be understood quantitatively in the loss of the methionine ligand of the heme iron, using the cytochrome c from Hydrogenbacter thermophilum as a model system. Through the comparison of wild-type protein with M61H and M61A mutants, in direct electrochemical analyses conducted as a function of temperature and exogenous ligand concentration, we are able to show that Met-ligated cytochromes c have a propensity to lose their Met ligand at graphite surfaces, and that energetics of this process (6.3 ± 0.2 kJ/mol) is similar to the energies associated with "foldons" of known protein folding pathways.

Review: studies of ferric heme proteins with highly anisotropic/highly axial low spin (S = 1/2) electron paramagnetic resonance signals with bis-histidine and histidine-methionine axial iron coordination

Six-coordinated heme groups are involved in a large variety of electron transfer reactions because of their ability to exist in both the ferrous (Fe(2+)) and ferric (Fe(3+)) state without any large differences in structure. Our studies on hemes coordinated by two histidines (bis-His) and hemes coordinated by histidine and methionine (His-Met) will be reviewed. In both of these coordination environments, the heme core can exhibit ferric low spin (electron paramagnetic resonance EPR) signals with large g(max) values (also called Type I, highly anisotropic low spin, or highly axial low spin, HALS species) as well as rhombic EPR (Type II) signals. In bis-His coordinated hemes rhombic and HALS envelopes are related to the orientation of the His groups with respect to each other such that (i) parallel His planes results in a rhombic signal and (ii) perpendicular His planes results in a HALS signal. Correlation between the structure of the heme and its ligands for heme with His-Met axial ligation and ligand-field parameters, as derived from a large series of cytochrome c variants, show, however, that for such a combination of axial ligands there is no clear-cut difference between the large g(max) and the "small g-anisotropy" cases as a result of the relative Met-His arrangements. Nonetheless, a new linear correlation links the average shift delta of the heme methyl groups with the g(max) values.

Electrochemical evidence for multiple peroxidatic heme states of the diheme cytochrome c peroxidase of Pseudomonas aeruginosa

The enzyme cytochrome c peroxidase from Pseudomonas aeruginosa and its catalytic mechanism were investigated using protein film voltammetry. Monolayers of the diheme bacterial enzyme were immobilized on both pyrolytic graphite edge and alkanethiol-modified Au electrodes. The redox couple associated with the low potential heme could be detected on both electrode surfaces at a reduction potential of -234 mV vs SHE. The midpoint potential displays a distinct pH dependence at acidic pH values, indicative of proton-coupled electron transfer. The nonturnover signal of the LP heme can be transformed into sigmoidal waves upon the addition of substrate. The midpoint potentials of the turnover signals were used to calculate Michaelis-Menten kinetics with a K(m) = 25 microM. Catalysis was inhibited with addition of cyanide (K(i) = 50 microM). These kinetic parameters are in good agreement with previously reported solution-based studies, indicating that the activity of the enzyme is unaffected by the immobilization on the electrode surface. The reduction potential of the catalytic wave clearly shows that the rate-limiting species during electrocatalysis differs from those previously reported for peroxidases, indicating that PFV may be used in the future to distinguish the requirement for reductive activation in bacterial cytochrome c peroxidases.

Cytochrome c6A: discovery, structure and properties responsible for its low haem redox potential

Cytochrome c6A is a unique dithio-cytochrome of green algae and plants. It has a very similar core structure to that of bacterial and algal cytochromes c6, but is unable to fulfil the same function of transferring electrons from cytochrome f to Photosystem I. A key feature of cytochrome c6A is that its haem midpoint potential is more than 200 mV below that of cytochrome c6 (Em≈+340 mV) despite both cytochromes having histidine and methionine residues as axial haem-iron ligands. One salient difference between the haem pockets is that a valine residue in cytochrome c6A replaces a highly conserved glutamine residue in cytochrome c6. This difference has been probed using site-directed mutagenesis, X-ray crystallography and protein film voltammetry studies. It has been found that the stereochemistry of the glutamine residue within the haem pocket has a destabilizing effect and is responsible for tuning the haem's midpoint potential by over 100 mV. This large effect may have contributed to the evolution of a new biological function for cytochrome c6A.

Modulation of the ligand-field anisotropy in a series of ferric low-spin cytochrome c mutants derived from Pseudomonas aeruginosa cytochrome c-551 and Nitrosomonas europaea cytochrome c-552: a nuclear magnetic resonance and electron paramagnetic resonance study

Cytochromes of the c type with histidine-methionine (His-Met) heme axial ligation play important roles in electron-transfer reactions and in enzymes. In this work, two series of cytochrome c mutants derived from Pseudomonas aeruginosa (Pa c-551) and from the ammonia-oxidizing bacterium Nitrosomonas europaea (Ne c-552) were engineered and overexpressed. In these proteins, point mutations were induced in a key residue (Asn64) near the Met axial ligand; these mutations have a considerable impact both on heme ligand-field strength and on the Met orientation and dynamics (fluxionality), as judged by low-temperature electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra. Ne c-552 has a ferric low-spin (S = 1/2) EPR signal characterized by large g anisotropy with g(max) resonance at 3.34; a similar large g(max) value EPR signal is found in the mitochondrial complex III cytochrome c1. In Ne c-552, deletion of Asn64 (NeN64Delta) changes the heme ligand field from more axial to rhombic (small g anisotropy and g(max) at 3.13) and furthermore hinders the Met fluxionality present in the wild-type protein. In Pa c-551 (g(max) at 3.20), replacement of Asn64 with valine (PaN64V) induces a decrease in the axial strain (g(max) at 3.05) and changes the Met configuration. Another set of mutants prepared by insertion (ins) and/or deletion (Delta) of a valine residue adjacent to Asn64, resulting in modifications in the length of the axial Met-donating loop (NeV65Delta, NeG50N/V65Delta, PaN50G/V65ins), did not result in appreciable alterations of the originally weak (Ne c-552) or very weak (Pa c-551) axial field but had an impact on Met orientation, fluxionality, and relaxation dynamics. Comparison of the electronic fingerprints in the overexpressed proteins and their mutants reveals a linear relationship between axial strain and average paramagnetic heme methyl shifts, irrespective of Met orientation or dynamics. Thus, for these His-Met axially coordinated Fe(III), the large g(max) value EPR signal does not represent a special case as is observed for bis-His axially coordinated Fe(III) with the two His planes perpendicular to each other.

Methionine ligand lability of type I cytochromes c: detection of ligand loss using protein film voltammetry

Protein film voltammetry (PFV) is used to interrogate the behavior of a variety of bacterial and mitochondrial His/Met-ligated cytochromes c. While analogous studies upon alkanethiol-modified gold electrodes reveal the anticipated Fe(II/III) couple only, PFV using pyrolytic graphite edge (PGE) electrodes demonstrates the presence of a lower-potential form of each of the cyts c studied, with a potential of approximately -100 mV (vs hydrogen). The generation of the novel, lower-potential state is shown to arise specifically from the interaction with the PGE electrode. Simultaneously, the typical Fe(II/III) couple can be observed. PFV of a series of wild-type cytochromes and mutants in the Met-donating loop show that the lower-potential state is highly similar between proteins from Pseudomonas aeruginosa (PA), Hydrogenobacter thermophilus (HT), and horse heart. The generation of the lower-potential form correlates inversely with the stability of the Met-Fe interaction for each of the cytochromes. Comparison with chemically unfolded cyts c indicates that the lower-potential forms detected here are unique, and this distinct state is ascribed to the loss of the Met ligand. Thus, PGE is demonstrated to be a non-innocent electrode surface in PFV studies of His/Met-ligated cytochromes c.

Heme attachment motif mobility tunes cytochrome c redox potential

Hydrogen exchange (HX) rates and midpoint potentials (Em) of variants of cytochrome c from Pseudomonas aeruginosa (Pa cyt c551) and Hydrogenobacter thermophilus (Ht cyt c552) have been characterized in an effort to develop an understanding of the impact of properties of the Cys-X-X-Cys-His pentapeptide c-heme attachment (CXXCH) motif on heme redox potential. Despite structural conservation of the CXXCH motif, Ht cyt c552 exhibits a low level of protection from HX for amide protons within this motif relative to Pa cyt c551. Site-directed mutants have been prepared to determine the structural basis for and functional implications of these variations on HX behavior. The double mutant Ht-M13V/K22M displays suppressed HX within the CXXCH motif as well as a decreased Em (by 81 mV), whereas the corresponding double mutant of Pa cyt c551 (V13M/M22K) exhibits enhanced HX within the CXXCH pentapeptide and a modest increase in Em (by 30 mV). The changes in Em correlate with changes in axial His chemical shifts in the ferric proteins reflecting the extent of histidinate character. Thus, the mobility of the CXXCH pentapeptide is found to impact the His-Fe(III) interaction and therefore the heme redox potential.

Modulation of heme redox potential in the cytochrome c6 family

Cytochrome c6A is a unique dithio-cytochrome of green algae and plants. It has a very similar core structure to that of bacterial and algal cytochromes c6 but is unable to fulfill the same function of transferring electrons from cytochrome f to photosystem I. A key feature is that its heme midpoint potential is more than 200 mV below that of cytochrome c6 despite having His and Met as axial heme-iron ligands. To identify the molecular origins of the difference in potential, the structure of cytochrome c6 from the cyanobacterium Phormidium laminosum has been determined by X-ray crystallography and compared with the known structure of cytochrome c6A. One salient difference of the heme pockets is that a highly conserved Gln (Q51) in cytochrome c6 is replaced by Val (V52) in c6A. Using protein film voltammetry, we found that swapping these residues raised the c6A potential by +109 mV and decreased that of c6 by almost the same extent, -100 mV. X-ray crystallography of the V52Q protein showed that the Gln residue adopts the same configuration relative to the heme as in cytochrome c6 and we propose that this stereochemistry destabilizes the oxidized form of the heme. Consequently, replacement of Gln by Val was probably a key step in the evolution of cytochrome c6A from cytochrome c6, inhibiting reduction by the cytochrome b6f complex and facilitating establishment of a new function.