On the Origin of the Different Performance of Iron and Manganese Monocations in Catalyzing the Nitrous Oxide Reduction by Carbon Oxide

Probing gas phase catalysis by atomic metal cations with flow tube mass spectrometry

The evolution and applications of flow tube mass spectrometry in the study of catalysis promoted by atomic metal ions are tracked from the pioneering days in Boulder, Colorado, to the construction and application of the ICP/SIFT/QqQ and ESI/qQ/SIFT/QqQ instruments at York University and the VISTA-SIFT instrument at the Air Force Research Laboratory. The physical separation of various sources of atomic metal ions from the flow tube in the latter instruments facilitates the spatial resolution of redox reactions and allows the separate measurement of the kinetics of both legs of a two-step catalytic cycle, while also allowing a view of the catalytic cycle in progress downstream in the reaction region of the flow tube. We focus on measurements on O-atom transfer and bond activation catalysis as first identified in Boulder and emphasize fundamental aspects such as the thermodynamic window of opportunity for catalysis, catalytic efficiency, and computed energy landscapes for atomic metal cation catalysis. Gas-phase applications include: the catalytic oxidation of CO to CO2 , of H2 to H2 O, and of C2 H4 to CH3 CHO all with N2 O as the source of oxygen; the catalytic oxidation of CH4 to CH3 OH with O3 ; the catalytic oxidation of C6 H6 with O2 . We also address the environmentally important catalytic reduction of NO2 and NO to N2 with CO and H2 by catalytic coupling of two-step catalytic cycles in a multistep cycle. Overall, the power of atomic metal cations in catalysis, and the use of flow tube mass spectrometry in revealing this power, is clearly demonstrated.

Computational Evaluation of Potential Molecular Catalysts for Nitrous Oxide Decomposition

Nitrous oxide (N₂O) is a potent greenhouse gas (GHG) with limited use as a mild anesthetic and underdeveloped reactivity. Nitrous oxide splitting (decomposition) is critical to its mitigation as a GHG. Although heterogeneous catalysts for N₂O decomposition have been developed, highly efficient, long-lived solid catalysts are still needed, and the details of the catalytic pathways are not well understood. Reported herein is a computational evaluation of three potential molecular (homogeneous) catalysts for N₂O splitting, which could aid in the development of more active and robust catalysts and provide deeper mechanistic insights: one Cu(I)-based, [(CF₃O)₄Al]Cu (A-1), and two Ru(III)-based, Cl(POR)Ru (B-1) and (NTA)Ru (C-1) (POR = porphyrin, NTA = nitrilotriacetate). The structures and energetic viability of potential intermediates and key transition states are evaluated according to a two-stage reaction pathway: (A) deoxygenation (DO), during which a metal-N₂O complex undergoes N-O bond cleavage to produce N₂ and a metal-oxo species and (B) (di)oxygen evolution (OER), in which the metal-oxo species dimerizes to a dimetal-peroxo complex, followed by conversion to a metal-dioxygen species from which dioxygen dissociates. For the (F-L)Cu(I) activator (A-1), deoxygenation of N₂O is facilitated by an O-bound (F-L)Cu-O-N₂ or better by a bimetallic N,O-bonded, (F-L)Cu-NNO-Cu(F-L) complex; the resulting copper-oxyl (F-L)Cu-O is converted exergonically to (F-L)Cu-(η²,η²-O₂)-Cu(F-L), which leads to dioxygen species (F-L)Cu(η²-O₂), that favorably dissociates O₂. Key features of the DO/OER process for (POR)ClRu (B-1) include endergonic N₂O coordination, facile N₂ evolution from LR'u-N₂O-RuL to Cl(POR)RuO, moderate barrier coupling of Cl(POR)RuO to peroxo Cl(POR)Ru(O₂)Ru(POR)Cl, and eventual O₂ dissociation from Cl(POR)Ru(η¹-O₂), which is nearly thermoneutral. N₂O decomposition promoted by (NTA)Ru(III) (C-1) can proceed with exergonic N₂O coordination, facile N₂ dissociation from (NTA)Ru-ON₂ or (NTA)Ru-N₂O-Ru(NTA) to form (NTA)Ru-O; dimerization of the (NTA)Ru-oxo species is facile to produce (NTA)Ru-O-O-Ru(NTA), and subsequent OE from the peroxo species is moderately endergonic. Considering the overall energetics, (F-L)Cu and Cl(POR)Ru derivatives are deemed the best candidates for promoting facile N₂O decomposition.

Non-innocent PNN ligand is important for CO oxidation by N2O catalyzed by a (PNN)Ru-H pincer complex: insights from DFT calculations

Milstein et al. developed an efficient and mild method for CO oxidation by N₂O to give CO₂ and N₂ catalyzed by a (PNN)Ru-H pincer complex. To gain mechanistic information on this catalytic transformation, the reaction mechanism has been studied using density functional theory (DFT) calculations. It was found that the catalytic cycle for CO oxidation by N₂O proceeds in three stages: N₂O activation to form a (PNN)Ru-OH intermediate, CO insertion into the Ru-OH bond to form a (PNN)Ru-COOH intermediate and CO₂ release from (PNN)Ru-COOH. In the CO₂ release stage, CO₂ is not released via a β-H elimination mechanism as proposed in experiments, instead it is released via a deprotonation mechanism. The calculations demonstrated that the Ru-H bond of the catalyst plays an important role in facilitating the activation of N₂O, which is the rate-determining step for the whole catalytic cycle, and the non-innocent PNN ligand is very important for CO oxidation by N₂O. Our theoretical results are consistent with the experimental observations and could help design highly efficient catalysts for N₂O activation.

On the Pt(+) and Rh(+) Catalytic Activity in the Nitrous Oxide Reduction by Carbon Monoxide

Nitrous oxide activation by CO in the presence of platinum and rhodium monocations was elucidated by density functional methods for ground and first excited states. Platinum and rhodium cations fulfill the thermodynamic request for the oxygen-atom transport that allows the catalytic cycle to be completed, but actually, just the first one meaningfully improves the kinetics of the process. For both catalysts, the reaction pathways show the only activation barrier in correspondence of nitrogen release and monoxide cation formation. The kinetic analysis of the potential energy profile, in agreement with ICP/SIFT MS experimental data, indicates that platinum performs more in the reduction, while the whole process is not sufficiently fast in the case of rhodium ionic catalyst.

Theoretical Investigation of the Methanol Decomposition by Fe+)and Fe(C2H4)+: A π-Type Ligand Effect

Density functional theory has been used to probe the mechanism of gas-phase methanol decomposition by bare Fe(+) and ligated Fe(C(2)H(4))(+) in both quartet and sextet states. For the Fe(+)/methanol system, Fe(+) could directly attach to the O and methyl-H atoms of methanol, respectively, forming two encounter isomers. The methanol reaction with Fe(+) prefers initial C-O bond activation to yield methyl with slight endothermicity, whereas CH(4) elimination is hindered by the strong endothermicity and high-energy barrier of hydroxyl-H shift. For the Fe(C(2)H(4))(+)/methanol system, the major product of H(2)O is formed through six elementary steps: encounter complexation, C-O bond activation, C-C coupling, β-H shift, hydride H shift, and nonreactive dissociation. Both ligand exchange and initial C-O bond activation mechanisms could account for ethylene elimination with the ion products Fe(CH(3)OH)(+) and (CH(3))Fe(OH)(+), respectively. With the assistance of a π-type C(2)H(4) ligand, the metal center in the Fe(C(2)H(4))(+)/CH(3)OH system avoids formation of unfavorable multi-σ-type bonding and thus greatly enhances the reactivity compared to that of bare Fe(+).

Binding and activation of N2O at transition-metal centers: recent mechanistic insights

No laughing matter, nitrous oxide's role in stratospheric ozone depletion and as a greenhouse gas has stimulated great interest in developing and understanding its decomposition, particularly through the use of transition-metal promoters. Recent advances in our understanding of the reaction pathways for N(2)O reduction by metal ions in the gas phase and in heterogeneous, homogeneous, and biological catalytic systems have provided provocative ideas about the structure and properties of metal N(2)O adducts and derived intermediates. These ideas are likely to inform efforts to design more effective catalysts for N(2)O remediation.

Theoretical investigation of the gas-phase Mn(+)- and Co(+)-catalyzed oxidation of benzene by N(2)O

The gas-phase Mn(+)- and Co(+)-mediated oxidation of benzene by N(2)O has been theoretically investigated using density functional theory. The geometries and energies of all the stationary points involved are located. Two different oxidation mechanisms, i.e., mediated by M(+)(benzene) and MO(+), are taken into account. In the former catalytic cycle, benzene initially coordinates to the metal ion affording the M(+)(C(6)H(6)) adduct (M = Mn or Co), then N(2)O coordinates to the nascent benzene complex and gets activated by the metal to yield (C(6)H(6))M(+)O(N(2)). After releasing a molecular nitrogen, through the non-radical and/or O-insertion pathways, the system would be oxidized to phenol and regenerates the active catalyst M(+). This catalytic mechanism is energetically favourable, explaining the efficient Mn(+)- and Co(+)-catalyzed benzene hydroxylation observed in ion cyclotron resonance (ICR) experiments [J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1994, 116, 9565-9570]. For the alternative MO(+)-mediated oxidation mechanism, spin inversion as well as high energy barrier in the course of the N-O activation imply low reaction efficiency of the ground-state reactants, according with the ICR experiment finding that MO(+) was formed from exited M(+)*, thus both Mn(+) and Co(+) are unable to work as a catalyst in this case.