On the hydrated electron as a structure-breaking ion

Simulating the Competitive Ion Pairing of Hydrated Electrons with Chaotropic Cations

Experiments show that the absorption spectrum of the hydrated electron (ehyd-) blue-shifts in electrolyte solutions compared with what is seen in pure water. This shift has been assigned to the ehyd-'s competitive ion-pairing interactions with the salt cation relative to the salt anion based on the ions' positions on the Hofmeister series. Remarkably, little work has been done investigating the ehyd-'s behavior when the salts have chaotropic cations, which should greatly change the ion-pairing interactions given that the ehyd- is a champion chaotrope. In this work, we remedy this by using mixed quantum/classical simulations to analyze the behavior of two different models of the ehyd- in aqueous RbF and RbI electrolyte solutions as a function of salt concentration. We find that the magnitude of the salt-induced spectral blue-shift is determined by a combination of the number of chaotropic Rb+ cations near the ehyd- and the number of salt anions near those cations so that the spectrum of the ehyd- directly reflects its local environment. We also find that the use of a soft-cavity ehyd- model predicts stronger competitive interactions with Rb+ relative to I- than a more traditional hard cavity model, leading to different predicted spectral shifts that should provide a way to distinguish between the two models experimentally. Our simulations predict that at the same concentration, salts with chaotropic cations should produce larger spectral blue-shifts than salts with kosmotropic cations. We also found that at high salt concentrations with chaotropic cations, the predicted blue-shift is greater when the salt anion is kosmotropic instead of chaotropic. Our goal is for this work to inspire experimentalists to make such measurements, which will help provide a spectroscopic means to distinguish between simulations models that predict different hydration structures for the ehyd-.

Ab Initio Studies of Hydrated Electron/Cation Contact Pairs: Hydrated Electrons Simulated with Density Functional Theory Are Too Kosmotropic

We have performed the first DFT-based ab initio MD simulations of a hydrated electron (e_aq^-) in the presence of Na⁺, a system chosen because ion-pairing behavior in water depends sensitively on the local hydration structure. Experiments show that e_aq^-'s interact weakly with Na⁺; the e_aq^-'s spectrum blue shifts by only a few tens of meV upon ion pairing without changing shape. We find that the spectrum of the DFT-simulated e_aq^- red shifts and changes shape upon interaction with Na⁺, in contrast with experiment. We show that this is because the hydration structure of the DFT-simulated e_aq^- is too ordered or kosmotropic. Conversely, simulations that produce e_aq^-'s with a less ordered or chaotropic hydration structure form weaker ion pairs with Na⁺, yielding predicted spectral blue shifts in better agreement with experiment. Thus, ab initio simulations based on hybrid GGA DFT functionals fail to produce the correct solvation structure for the hydrated electron.

A Simple ab Initio Model for the Hydrated Electron That Matches Experiment

Since its discovery over 50 years ago, the "structure" and properties of the hydrated electron have been a subject for wonderment and also fierce debate. In the present work we seriously explore a minimal model for the aqueous electron, consisting of a small water anion cluster embedded in a polarized continuum, using several levels of ab initio calculation and basis set. The minimum energy "zero Kelvin" structure found for any 4-water (or larger) anion cluster, at any post-Hartree–Fock theory level, is very similar to a recently reported embedded-DFT-in-classical-water-MD simulation (Uhlig, Marsalek, and Jungwirth, J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2012, 3, 3071−3075), with four OH bonds oriented toward the maximum charge density in a small central "void". The minimum calculation with just four water molecules does a remarkably good job of reproducing the resonance Raman properties, the radius of gyration derived from the optical spectrum, the vertical detachment energy, and the hydration free energy. For the first time we also successfully calculate the EPR g-factor and (low temperature ice) hyperfine couplings. The simple tetrahedral anion cluster model conforms very well to experiment, suggesting it does in fact represent the dominant structural motif of the hydrated electron.

Photoelectron spectra of hydrated electron clusters: Fitting line shapes and grouping isomers

The photoelectron spectra of (H2O)(n = 2-69) - and (D2O)(n = 2-23) - are presented, and their spectral line shapes are analyzed in detail. This analysis revealed the presence of three different groupings of species, each of which are seen over the range, n = 11-16. These three groups are designated as dipole boundlike states, seen from n = 2-16, intermediate states, found from n = 6-16, and bulk embryonts, starting at n = 11 and continuing up through the largest sizes studied. Almost two decades ago [J. V. Coe et al., J. Chem. Phys. 92, 3980 (1990)], before the present comprehensive analysis, we concluded that the latter category of species were embryonic hydrated electrons with internalizing excess electrons (thus the term embryonts). Recent experiments with colder expansion (high stagnation chamber pressures) conditions by Neumark and coworkers [J. R. R. Verlet et al., Science 307, 93 (2005)] have also found three groups of isomers including the long-sought-after surface states of large water cluster anions. This work confirms that the species here designated as embryonts are in the process of internalizing the excess electron states as the cluster size increases (for n > or = 11).

Pulse Radiolysis of Supercritical Water. 3. Spectrum and Thermodynamics of the Hydrated Electron

Spectra of the hydrated electron in pressurized light and heavy water at temperatures up to and beyond the critical temperature are reported, for wavelengths between 0.4 and 1.7 microm. In agreement with previous work, spectra can be approximately represented by a Gaussian function on the low-energy side, and a Lorentzian function on the high-energy side in subcritical water, but deviations from this form are very clear above 200 degrees C. The spectrum shifts strongly to the red as temperature rises. At supercritical temperatures, the spectrum shifts slightly to the red as density decreases, and the Gaussian-Lorentzian form is a very poor description. Application of spectral moment theory allows one to make an estimate of the average size of the electron wave function and of its kinetic energy. It appears that for water densities below about 0.6 g/cc, and down to below 0.1 g/cc, the average radius of gyration for the electron remains constant at around 3.4 angstroms, and its absorption maximum is near 0.9 eV. For higher densities, the electron is squeezed into a smaller cavity and the spectrum is shifted to the blue. The enthalpy and free energy of electron hydration are derived as a function of temperature on the basis of existing equilibrium data and absolute proton hydration energies derived from the cluster-based common point method. In a discussion, we compare the effective "size" of the hydrated electron derived from both methods.

Observation of Large Water-Cluster Anions with Surface-Bound Excess Electrons

Anionic water clusters have long been studied to infer properties of the bulk hydrated electron. We used photoelectron imaging to characterize a class of (H2O)n- and (D2O)n- cluster anions (n </= 200 molecules) with vertical binding energies that are significantly lower than those previously recorded. The data are consistent with a structure in which the excess electron is bound to the surface of the cluster. This result implies that the excess electron in previously observed water-cluster anions, with higher vertical binding energies, was internally solvated. Thus, the properties of those clusters could be extrapolated to those of the bulk hydrated electron.

Structure of the aqueous solvated electron from resonance Raman spectroscopy: lessons from isotopic mixtures

The structure and thermodynamics of the hydrated electron are probed with resonance Raman spectroscopy of isotopic mixtures of H(2)O and D(2)O. The strongly enhanced intramolecular bends of e(-)(H(2)O) and e(-)(D(2)O) produce single downshifted bands, whereas the e(-)(HOD) bend consists of two components: one slightly upshifted from the 1,446 cm(-1) bulk frequency to 1,457 cm(-1) and the other strongly downshifted to approximately 1,396 cm(-1). This 60 cm(-1) split and the 200 (120) cm(-1) downshifts of the OH (OD) stretch frequencies relative to bulk water reveal that the water molecules that are Franck-Condon coupled to the electron are in an asymmetric environment, with one proton forming a strong hydrogen bond to the electron. The downshifted bend and librational frequencies also indicate significantly weakened torsional restoring forces on the water molecules of e(-)(aq), which suggests that the outlying proton is a poor hydrogen bond donor to the surrounding solvent. A 1.6-fold thermodynamic preference of the electron for H(2)O is observed based on the relative intensities of the e(-)(H(2)O) and e(-)(D(2)O) bands in a 50:50 isotopic mixture. This equilibrium isotope effect is consistent with the downshifted vibrational frequencies and a relative reduction of the zero-point energy of H(2)O bound to the electron. Our results enhance the cavity model of the solvated electron and support only those models that contain water monomers as opposed to other molecular species.