The role of hydrogen bonding in the formation of bile salt micelles. Reply to comments

Self-association of sodium isoursodeoxycholate and sodium isohenodeoxycholate in water

Bile salts (BS) form hydrophobic Small's primary micelles at concentrations above the critical micelle concentration (CMC), while at concentrations above 3CMC they form secondary micelles (by the association of primary micelles via H-bonds). In this paper the self-associations of the anions of isohenodeoxycholic acid (3-epimer of henodeoxycholic acid, ICD) and the anions of isoursodeoxycholic acid (3-epimer of ursodeoxycholic acid, IUD) are examined, since the thermodynamic parameters of their self-association have not yet been published. Forming of IUD aggregates with two or three building units is slightly more favorable via α sides of steroid skeletons, regarding hydrophobicity, while regarding steric repulsive interactions it is more favorable to associate via β sides. Due to this, IUD in the vicinity of the CMC can form primary micelles by association of IUD particles both from the convex side and from the concave side of the steroid ring system. Therefore, IUD is significantly more prone to initial micellization than bile salt derivatives whose steroidal skeletons contain equatorially oriented OH groups.

Kinetics of formation of bile salt micelles from coarse-grained Langevin dynamics simulations

We examine the mechanism of formation of micelles of dihydroxy bile salts using a coarse-grained, implicit solvent model and Langevin dynamics simulations. We find that bile salt micelles primarily form via addition and removal of monomers, similarly to surfactants with typical head-tail molecular structures, and not via a two-stage mechanism - involving formation of oligomers and their subsequent aggregation to form larger micelles - originally proposed for bile salts. The free energy barrier to removal of single bile monomers from micelles is ≈2kBT, much less than what has been observed for head-tail surfactants. Such a low barrier may be biologically relevant: it allows for rapid release of bile monomers into the intestine, possibly enabling the coverage of fat droplets by bile salt monomers and subsequent release of micelles containing fats and bile salts - a mechanism that is not possible for ionic head-tail surfactants of similar critical micellar concentrations.

Solubilization and Interaction Studies of Bile Salts with Surfactants and Drugs: a Review

In this review, bile salt, bile salt-surfactant, and bile salt-drug interactions and their solubilization studies are mainly focused. Usefulness of bile salts in digestion, absorption, and excretion of various compounds and their rare properties in ordering the shape and size of the micelles owing to the presence of hydrophobic and hydrophilic faces are taken into consideration while compiling this review. Bile salts as potential bio-surfactants to solubilize drugs of interest are also highlighted. This review will give an insight into the selection of drugs in different applications as their properties get modified by interaction with bile salts, thus influencing their solution behavior which, in turn, modifies the phase-forming behavior, microemulsion, and clouding phenomenon, besides solubilization. Finally, their future perspectives are taken into consideration to assess their possible uses as bio-surfactants without side effects to human beings.

Effect of sodium salts of 3α,12α-dihydroxy-7-oxo-5β-cholanoic and 3,7,12-trioxo-5β-cholanoic acids on verapamil hydrochloride in biophysical-chemical model experiments

It is known that certain bile acids have a promotive effect on the action of some drugs. Special attention is paid to bile acids having oxo groups instead of OH groups in the steroid skeleton of their molecule, since these derivatives have a lower hemolytic potential (membrane toxicity). This study examined the effects of sodium salts of 3?,12?-dihydroxy-7-oxo-5?-cholanoic acid (7-oC) and 3,7,12-trioxo-5?- cholanoic acid (3,7,12-toC) on the adsorption of verapamil hydrochloride on activated carbon (model of the cell membrane). The interaction was followed by measuring the effect of verapamil on the functional dependence between the spin-lattice relaxation time T1 (protons of the C18 angular group of the bile acid molecule) and the bile acid concentration in deuterated chloroform (model of the cell membrane lipid phase). Whether a depot effect of verapamil exists when 7-oC and 3,7,12-toC (in the form of methyl esters) are present in chloroform was also investigated. It was found that 7-oC exhibited a significant effect in the experiments with verapamil, whereas 3,7,12-toC showed no difference of the measured parameters with respect to the control. This indicates that bile acid molecules should have OH groups bound to the steroid nucleus, in order to exhibit an effect on the monitored physico-chemical parameters of verapamil.

Counterion binding in the aqueous solutions of bile acid salts, as studied by computer simulation methods

We investigate the structural and dynamical properties of counterion binding in sodium cholate and sodium deoxycholate micelles at three different concentration, namely, 30, 90, and 300 mM, by means of molecular dynamics simulations at the atomistic level. The obtained results can resolve a long-standing, apparent contradiction between different experiments that reported discordant values for the degree of counterion binding. Namely, our results suggest that certain experimental techniques, such as freezing point depression, are only sensitive to the contact counterions, and hence, the degree of contact binding of the counterions is measured. On the other hand, in experiments employing, e.g., electrode potential or nuclear magnetic resonance measurements, the solvent-separated counterions also contribute to the signal detected, and hence, the counterions that are measured as bound ones do include the solvent-separated counterions as well.

Morphology of bile salt micelles as studied by computer simulation methods

The relative arrangement of the neighboring bile ions and the shape of the hydrophobic and hydrogen-bonded primary micelles as well of the large secondary micelles formed by these ions are analyzed in detail on the basis of molecular dynamics computer simulations of 30 and 300 mM sodium cholate and sodium deoxycholate solutions. In the lower concentration considered, the systems only contain primary micelles, whereas in both of the 300 mM systems secondary micelles are also present. The simulations performed were long enough that the systems reached thermodynamic equilibrium. It is found that the neighboring cholate ions prefer alignments in which their quasi-planar tetracyclic ring systems are parallel with each other, whereas for deoxycholate an opening of the angle between these planes is observed. The shape of the micelles is characterized by the ratio of their three principal moments of inertia. The primary deoxycholate micelles are found to be rather spherical, whereas in the case of cholate somewhat flattened, disklike or oblate shaped ellipsoidal primary micelles are found, irrespective of whether these micelles are kept together by hydrogen bonds or are of hydrophobic origin. Finally, the secondary micelles are found to exhibit a large variety of shapes, ranging from flattened oblates to rodlike objects through various different irregular shapes, characterized by markedly different values of the three principal moments of inertia. The observed preferences of the relative arrangement of the neighboring ions and of the aggregate shapes as well as the differences observed in the behavior of the two bile ions studied in these respects are traced back to the molecular structure of these ions.

Supra-molecular association and polymorphic behaviour in systems containing bile acid salts

A wide number of supra-molecular association modes are observed in mixtures containing water and bile salts, BS, (with, eventually, other components). Molecular or micellar solutions transform into hydrated solids, fibres, lyotropic liquid crystals and/or gels by raising the concentration, the temperature, adding electrolytes, surfactants, lipids and proteins. Amorphous or ordered phases may be formed accordingly. The forces responsible for this very rich polymorphism presumably arise from the unusual combination of electrostatic, hydrophobic and hydrogen-bond contributions to the system stability, with subsequent control of the supra-molecular organisation modes. The stabilising effect due to hydrogen bonds does not occur in almost all surfactants or lipids and is peculiar to bile acids and salts. Some supra-molecular organisation modes, supposed to be related to malfunctions and dis-metabolic diseases in vivo, are briefly reported and discussed.

Molecular Aggregates in Aqueous Solutions of Bile Acid Salts. Molecular Dynamics Simulation Study

The aggregation behavior of two bile acid salts (i.e., sodium cholate and sodium deoxycholate) has been studied in their aqueous solutions of three different concentrations (i.e., 30, 90,and 300 mM) by means of molecular dynamics computer simulations. To let the systems reach thermodynamic equilibrium, rather long simulations have been performed: the equilibration period, lasting for 20-50 ns, has been followed by a 20 ns long production phase, during which the average size of the bile aggregates (regarded to be the slowest varying observable) has already fluctuated around a constant value. The production phase of the runs has been about an order of magnitude longer than the average lifetime of both the monomeric bile ions and the bonds that link two neighboring bile ions together to be part of the same aggregate. This has allowed the bile ions belonging to various aggregates to be in a dynamic equilibrium with the isolated monomers. The observed aggregation behavior of the studied bile ions has been found to be in good qualitative agreement with experimental findings. The analysis of the results has revealed that, due to their molecular structure, which is markedly different from that of the ordinary aliphatic surfactants, the bile ions form rather different aggregates than the usual spherical micelles. In the lowest concentration solution studied, the bile ions only form small oligomers. In the case of deoxycholate, these oligomers, such as the ordinary micelles, are kept together by hydrophobic interactions, whereas in the sodium cholate system, small hydrogen-bonded aggregates (mostly dimers) are also present. In the highest concentration systems, the bile ions form large secondary micelles, which are kept together both by hydrophobic interactions and by hydrogen bonds. Namely, in these secondary micelles, small hydrophobic primary micelles are linked together via the formation of hydrogen bonds between their hydrophilic outer surfaces.

Probing the binding dynamics to sodium cholate aggregates using naphthalene derivatives as guests

The binding dynamics with bile salt aggregates for a series of naphthalene derivatives of different polarities was studied using fluorescence and laser flash photolysis. Fluorescence was employed to determine the nature of the binding site for each guest and the accessibility of the bound guest to quenchers. Laser flash photolysis was employed to study the mobility of the triplet states of the naphthalenes between the sodium cholate aggregates and the aqueous phase. Primary aggregates, which provide an environment protected from quenchers in the aqueous phase, bind 1- and 2-ethylnaphthalene as guests. The complexation dynamics with this type of aggregate is slow. 1- and 2-Naphthyl-1-ethanol, and 1- and 2-acetonaphthone bind to the secondary aggregates, which provide moderate protection from quenching and faster binding dynamics. The addition of salts lowered the cholate concentration at which primary aggregates were formed, but did not influence the formation of secondary aggregates.

Characterization of mixed micellar pseudostationary phases in electrokinetic chromatography using linear solvation energy relationships

The influence of mixed micellar systems on retention and selectivity in micellar electrokinetic chromatography is examined using linear solvation energy relationships (LSER). Systems that were investigated include mixed bile salts [sodium deoxycholate (SDC) and sodium cholate (SC)] and mixed sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)-bile salt systems (e.g., SDS-SC and SDS-SDC). The retention behavior in individual and mixed micellar systems is primarily determined by size and hydrogen bond acceptor strengths of solutes. Through a comparative study of the LSER coefficients in the individual and mixed micellar systems, it was concluded that hydrogen bonding interactions have a significant effect on selectivity of these pseudostationary phases in electrokinetic chromatography. The interactive properties of the mixed micelles are different from the constituent individual micelles, however, the overall characteristics are closer to one of the bile salt micelles in the mixture even at the equimolar compositions.

Association of deoxycholic acid in organic solvents

The distribution of deoxycholic acid (I) between aqueous buffer and an organic phase consisting of isooctane-1-octanol (70:30, v/v) (System A) or isooctane-chloroform (80:20, v/v) (System B) was studied. The distribution isotherms suggested that I associates strongly in the organic Systems A and B unlike in pure 1-octanol. Therefore, a previous model, describing distribution of bile salts between 1-octanol and aqueous buffer, was modified to include association of I in the organic phases to describe distribution behavior. The treatment suggested that I exists as monomer and dimer in System A with a dimerization constant of 820 M-1. A model consisting of monomer-tetramer-hexamer in the organic phase best describes the data for System B. The data support the view that association in the organic phase is due to hydrogen bonding between bile acid molecules.