Development of a novel method to study the rate-determining step during protein regeneration: application to the oxidative folding of RNase A at low temperature reveals BPTI-like kinetic traps

Securing Native Disulfide Bonds in Disulfide-Coupled Protein Folding Reactions: The Role of Intrinsic and Extrinsic Elements vis-à-vis Protein Aggregation and Neurodegeneration

Disulfide bonds play an important role in physiology and are the mainstay of proteins that reside in the plasma membrane and of those that are secreted outside the cell. Disulfide-bond-containing proteins comprise ∼30% of all eukaryotic proteins. Using bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) as an exemplar, we review the regeneration (oxidative folding) of disulfide-bond-containing proteins from their fully reduced state to the biologically active form. We discuss the key aspects of the oxidative folding landscape w.r.t. the acquisition and retention of native disulfide bonds which is an essential requirement for the polypeptide to be biologically functional. By re-examining the regeneration trajectory in light of the symbiotic relationship between native disulfide bonds and a protective structure, we describe the elements that compete with the processes that secure native disulfide bonds in disulfide-coupled protein folding. The impact of native-disulfide-bond formation on protein stability, trafficking, protein misfolding, and neurodegenerative onset is elaborated upon.

The Formation of Native Disulfide Bonds: Treading a Fine Line in Protein Folding

The folding of proteins that contain disulfide bonds is termed oxidative protein folding. It involves a chemical reaction resulting in the formation of disulfide bonds and a physical conformational folding reaction that promotes the formation of the native structure. While the presence of disulfide bonds significantly increases the complexity of the folding landscape, it is generally recognized that native disulfide bonds help funnel the trajectory towards the final folded form. Here, we review the role of disulfide bonds in oxidative protein folding and argue that even structure-inducing native disulfide bond formation treads a fine line in the regeneration of disulfide-bond-containing proteins. The translation of this observation to protein misfolding related disorders is discussed.

Revisiting the Formation of a Native Disulfide Bond: Consequences for Protein Regeneration and Beyond

Oxidative protein folding involves the formation of disulfide bonds and the regeneration of native structure (N) from the fully reduced and unfolded protein (R). Oxidative protein folding studies have provided a wealth of information on underlying physico-chemical reactions by which disulfide-bond-containing proteins acquire their catalytically active form. Initially, we review key events underlying oxidative protein folding using bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A), bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor (BPTI) and hen-egg white lysozyme (HEWL) as model disulfide bond-containing folders and discuss consequential outcomes with regard to their folding trajectories. We re-examine the findings from the same studies to underscore the importance of forming native disulfide bonds and generating a “native-like” structure early on in the oxidative folding pathway. The impact of both these features on the regeneration landscape are highlighted by comparing ideal, albeit hypothetical, regeneration scenarios with those wherein a native-like structure is formed relatively “late” in the R→N trajectory. A special case where the desired characteristics of oxidative folding trajectories can, nevertheless, stall folding is also discussed. The importance of these data from oxidative protein folding studies is projected onto outcomes, including their impact on the regeneration rate, yield, misfolding, misfolded-flux trafficking from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) to the cytoplasm, and the onset of neurodegenerative disorders.

The Structure-Forming Juncture in Oxidative Protein Folding: What Happens in the ER?

The folding of disulfide bond containing proteins proceeds in a biphasic manner. Initially, cysteines are oxidized to form disulfide bonds. Structure is largely absent during this phase. Next, when a minimally correct number of native linkages of disulfide bonds have been acquired, the biopolymer conformationally folds into the native, or a native-like, state. Thus, at the end of this "oxidative folding" process, a stable and biologically active protein is formed. This review focuses on dissecting the "structure-forming step" in oxidative protein folding. The ability to follow this pivotal step in protein maturation in somewhat detail is uniquely facilitated in "oxidative" folding scenarios. We review this step using bovine pancreatic Ribonuclease A as a model while recognizing the impact that this step has in subcellular trafficking and protein aggregation.

The oxidoreductase behavior of protein disulfide isomerase impedes fold maturation of endoplasmic reticulum-processed proteins in the pivotal structure-coupled step of oxidative folding: implications for subcellular protein trafficking

Protein disulfide isomerase (PDI), the chief endoplasmic reticulum (ER) resident oxidoreductase chaperone, is known to catalyze the maturation of disulfide bond-containing proteins primarily through oxidation and isomerization functions. The rate-determining step in the oxidative regeneration path of disulfide bond-containing proteins generally couples chemical thiol-disulfide-exchange reactions to a physical conformational folding reaction. We have determined the impact of PDI and its subdomains on the rate-determining step in ribonuclease A folding and on the physical structure-forming step of select ER-processed proteins including RNase A. This was facilitated through application of a novel chemical tool to exclusively populate native disulfide-containing intermediates in unstructured forms. The described biochemical inroad permits a deconvoluted study of the physical half-process in the rate-determining step from its chemical counterpart. Analysis of folding kinetics of RNase A and other proteins reveals that the highly evolved oxidoreductase activity of PDI masks its chaperone-like activity, impedes conformational folding of ER-processed proteins, and limits its potential to accelerate the rate-determining step in oxidative regeneration. Implications of the heretofore unknown and anomalous self-limiting behavior of PDI are discussed in the context of oxidative maturation and misfolding in vivo.

pH dependence of the isomerase activity of protein disulfide isomerase: insights into its functional relevance

The isomerase efficacy of the oxidoreductase, protein disulfide isomerase (PDI), has been examined by a simple method. Using this technique, the pH-dependence of relative efficiency of isomerization reactions by PDI has been evaluated and its impact on a key structure-forming step in the oxidative folding pathway of a model protein determined. Results reveal that PDI has a greater relative impact on thiol-disulfide reshuffling (isomerization) reactions and consequently the structure-forming step in oxidative folding at pH 7, as opposed to pH's 8 and 9. These results suggest that PDI, which possesses an anomalously low thiol pKa, is fine-tuned to catalyze oxidative folding in the lumen of the endoplasmic reticulum where the ambient pH of approximately 7 would otherwise retard thioldisulfide exchange reactions and hinder acquisition of the native fold. The pH-dependent impact on isomerization catalysis has important implications for the development of synthetic chaperones for in vivo and in vitro applications.

Acceleration of oxidative protein folding by curcumin through novel non-redox chemistry

Curcumin, the major constituent of turmeric is a known antioxidant. We have examined the oxidative folding of the model four-disulfide-bond-containing protein bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) in its presence; results indicate that RNase A regeneration rate increases in a curcumin-dependent manner. Examination of the native tendency of the fully-reduced polypeptide and the stability of key folding intermediates suggests that the increased oxidative folding rate can be attributed to native-like elements induced within the fully-reduced polypeptide and the stabilization of native-like species by this non-redox-active natural product. Our results provide a template for the design of curcuminoid-based synthetic small-molecule fold catalysts that accelerate the folding of ER-processed proteins; this assumes significance given that nitrosative stress and dysfunction of the ER-resident oxidoreductase protein disulfide isomerise due to S-nitrosylation are factors associated with the pathogenesis of Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases.

The Oxidative Folding Rate of Bovine Pancreatic Ribonuclease Is Enhanced by a Covalently Attached Oligosaccharide

Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease B (RNase B) differs from RNase A by the presence of an oligosaccharide moiety covalently attached to Asn 34. Oxidative folding studies of RNase B were carried out at different temperatures using DTT(ox) as the oxidizing agent, and the results were compared with those for RNase A. The oxidative folding rates of RNase B are between 1.7 and 1.3 times faster than those of RNase A at the temperatures that were investigated. The folding pathways of RNase B were determined to be similar to those of RNase A in that two structured intermediates, each lacking one native disulfide bond, were found to populate the regeneration pathways at 25 degrees C and pH 8.3. The thermodynamic stabilities of these two glycosylated intermediates, and their rates of formation from their unstructured precursors in the rate-determining step, were found to be higher than those of their unglycosylated counterparts from RNase A. Thus, the underlying cause for the faster rate of oxidative regeneration of native RNase B appears to be both thermodynamic and kinetic due to the higher stability, and faster rate of formation, of the intermediates of RNase B compared to those of RNase A.

Assessing the magnitude of folding forces along the oxidative folding pathway of multi-disulfide-containing proteins

Oxidative folding involves the acquisition of the native set of disulfide bonds and native structure of a protein from its reduced, unfolded form. Two major factors that influence the distribution of disulfide bonds (over their entropically favored probability of formation) during the regeneration, eventually favoring and sustaining the native set of disulfide bonds, are enthalpic interactions that lead to conformational ordering among intermediates and conformational folding, resulting in native (or nativelike) structure which protects the native disulfide bonds from reduction and intramolecular thiol-disulfide exchange reactions. Here, we report a novel technique to provide a quantitative description of the enthalpic and conformational folding forces present at any stage of the oxidative folding process of multi-disulfide-containing proteins which is made feasible by assessing their ability to form "structures" that are able to protect disulfide bonds from reduction.

Shifting the competition between the intramolecular Reshuffling reaction and the direct oxidation reaction during the oxidative folding of kinetically trapped disulfide-insecure intermediates

The oxidative folding pathway(s) of single-domain proteins can be characterized by the existence, stability, and structural nature of the intermediates that populate the regeneration pathway. Structured intermediates can be disulfide-secure in that they are able to protect their existing (native) disulfide bonds from SH/SS reshuffling and reduction reactions, and thereby form the native protein directly, i.e., by oxidation of their exposed (or locally exposable) thiols. Alternatively, they can be disulfide-insecure, usually requiring global unfolding to expose their free thiols. However, such an unfolding event also exposes the existing native disulfide bonds. Thus, the subsequent oxidation reaction to form the native protein in a disulfide-insecure intermediate competes with the intramolecular attack by the thiols of the macromolecule on its own native disulfide bonds, resulting in a large population of intermediates that are reshuffled instead of being oxidized. Under stabilizing conditions, disulfide-insecure species become long-lived kinetically trapped intermediates that slowly and only indirectly convert to the native protein through reshuffling reactions. In this study, trans-[Pt(en)(2)Cl(2)](2+), a strong oxidizing agent which has not traditionally been used in oxidative folding, was applied to shift the competition between reshuffling and oxidation reactions in des [58-110] and des [26-84], two long-lived disulfide-insecure intermediates of RNase A, and oxidize them directly under stable conditions to form the native protein. Such a successful direct conversion of kinetically trapped intermediates to the native molecule by trans-[Pt(en)(2)Cl(2)](2+) may be helpful in facilitating the oxidative folding processes of multi-disulfide-containing proteins in general.

Development of a novel method to populate native disulfide-bonded intermediates for structural characterization of proteins: implications for the mechanism of oxidative folding of RNase A

RNase A, a model protein for oxidative folding studies, has four native disulfide bonds. The roles of des [40-95] and des [65-72], the two native-like structured three-disulfide-bonded intermediates populated between 8 and 25 degrees C during the oxidative folding of RNase A, are well characterized. Recent work focuses on both the formation of these structured disulfide intermediates from their unstructured precursors and on the subsequent oxidation of the structured species to form the native protein. The major obstacles in this work are the very low concentration of the precursor species and the difficulty of isolating some of the structured intermediates. Here, we demonstrate a novel method that enables the native disulfide-bonded intermediates to be populated and studied regardless of whether they have stable structure and/or are present at low concentrations during the oxidative folding or reductive unfolding process. The application of this method enabled us to populate and, in turn, study the key intermediates with two native disulfide bonds on the oxidative folding pathway of RNase A; it also facilitated the isolation of des [58-110] and des [26-84], the other two native-like structured des species whose isolation had thus far not been possible.