THE NATURE OF THE INTERMEDIATE IN CARBONIUM ION-TYPE INTERCONVERSION REACTIONS OF CYCLOBUTYL, CYCLOPROPYLCARBINYL AND ALLYLCARBINYL DERIVATIVES1

Taming nonclassical carbocations to control small ring reactivity

Prediction of the outcome of ring opening of small organic rings under cationic conditions can be challenging due to the intermediacy of nonclassical carbocations. For example, the solvolysis of cyclobutyl or cyclopropylmethyl derivatives generates up to four products on nucleophilic capture or elimination via cyclopropylcarbinyl and bicyclobutonium ions. Here, we show that such reaction outcomes can be controlled by subtle changes to the structure of nonclassical carbocation. Using bicyclo[1.1.0]butanes as cation precursors, the regio- and stereochemistry of ring opening is shown to depend on the degree and nature of the substituents on the cationic intermediates. Reaction outcomes are rationalized using computational models, resulting in a flowchart to predict product formation from a given cation precursor.

Molecular Dynamics of the Norbornyl Cation in Solution and Its Generation in Winstein-Trifan Solvolysis: The Timing of Sigma Bridging

Molecular dynamics simulations were performed on the solvolyses of exo- and endo-norbornyl brosylate and for the "nonclassical" σ-bridged norbornyl cation in an acetic acid solution. This computational modeling of the original Winstein-Trifan experiment confirms that exo-solvolysis is accompanied by σ-bridging in the transition state, while endo-solvolysis is not; σ-bridging eventually occurs in a dynamically stepwise fashion. Simulations of the norbornyl cation in solution show typical vibrations due to zero-point and thermal vibrations but no tendency to sample localized "classical cation" geometries.

History of the Woodward-Hoffmann Rules. The No-Mechanism Puzzle

This is Paper 2 in the 27-paper series on the history of the development of the Woodward-Hoffmann rules. Paper 2 takes the reader back to the 1950s and early 1960s, before the publication of the first Woodward-Hoffmann paper in January 1965. The scope of the pericyclic no-mechanism problem is described along with many of the key "hints" or "clues" to orbital symmetry control that were available in the literature prior to 1965. A chronology of reactions with alternating stereospecificities is provided. A second chronology of alternating theoretical hints is provided, e. g., 4n+2 versus 4n. Another chronology is provided, that of the development of frontier molecular orbital theory, with and without phases and nodes. A tabulation is provided of 36 instances in which the MOs of 1,3-butadiene were reported in the literature. A knowledge of the MOs of 1,3-butadiene, plus a knowledge of some of the alternating stereospecific reactions, could have led many chemists to the solution of the pericyclic no-mechanism problem before Woodward and Hoffmann.

3-t-Butyl-1-methylcyclobutyl Cation. Experimental vs Computational Insights into Tertiary Bicyclobutonium Cations

The stereochemistry of the substitution product formed when (1s,3s)-3-(tert-butyl)-1-methylcyclobutyl methanesulfonate, 7, reacts in trifluoroethanol is one of retention of configuration. This is consistent with the intermediacy of a nonclassical bicyclobutonium cation 8N. As the solvent becomes less highly ionizing, the product contains increasing amounts of the isomeric inverted product. This is indicative of the competitive involvement of a classical cation 8C that captures solvent from both sides. Solvolytic rate studies show no large rate enhancements due to the t-butyl group in 7. However, computational studies suggest that the combined stabilization of the bicyclobutonium cation 8N by C-C σ-interactions and the t-butyl group amounts to 10.8 kcal/mol in the gas phase. Computationally, the t-butyl group contributes to stabilization of 8N, but this stabilization is not revealed by kinetic studies. This discrepancy suggests caution when relating computational studies on carbocations to solvolytic studies in common solvents.

The cyclopropylcarbinyl route to γ-silyl carbocations

The mesylate derivative of cis-1-hydroxymethyl-2-trimethylsilylcyclopropane has been prepared, along with a number of related mesylates and triflates with substituents on the 1-position. These substrates all solvolyze in CD₃CO₂D to give products derived from cyclopropylcarbinyl cations that undergo further rearrangement to give 3-trimethylsilylcyclobutyl cations. These 3-trimethylsilylcyclobutyl cations are stabilized by a long-range rear lobe interaction with the γ-trimethylsilyl group. When the substituent is electron-withdrawing (CF₃, CN, or CO₂CH₃), significant amounts of bicyclobutane products are formed. The bicyclobutanes are a result of γ-trimethylsilyl elimination from the cationic intermediate that has an unusually long calculated Si–C bond. The solvolysis chemistry of mesylate and triflate derivatives of trans-1-hydroxymethyl-2-trimethylsilylcyclopropane and 1-substituted analogs can be quite different since these substrates do not generally lead to 3-trimethylsilylcyclobutyl cations.

Stereospecific Ring Contraction of Bromocycloheptenes through Dyotropic Rearrangements via Nonclassical Carbocation-Anion Pairs

Experimental and theoretical evidence is reported for a rare type I dyotropic rearrangement involving a [1,2]-alkene shift, leading to the regio- and stereospecific ring contraction of bromocycloheptenes. This reaction occurs under mild conditions, with or without a Lewis acid catalyst. DFT calculations show that the reaction proceeds through a nonclassical carbocation–anion pair, which is crucial for the low activation barrier and enantiospecificity. The chiral cyclopropylcarbinyl cation may be a transition state or an intermediate, depending on the reaction conditions.

Ab initio/GIAO-CCSD(T) study of structures, energies, and 13C NMR chemical shifts of C4H7(+) and C5H9(+) ions: relative stability and dynamic aspects of the cyclopropylcarbinyl vs bicyclobutonium ions

The structures and energies of the carbocations C 4H 7 (+) and C 5H 9 (+) were calculated using the ab initio method. The (13)C NMR chemical shifts of the carbocations were calculated using the GIAO-CCSD(T) method. The pisigma-delocalized bisected cyclopropylcarbinyl cation, 1 and nonclassical bicyclobutonium ion, 2 were found to be the minima for C 4H 7 (+) at the MP2/cc-pVTZ level. At the MP4(SDTQ)/cc-pVTZ//MP2/cc-pVTZ + ZPE level the structure 2 is 0.4 kcal/mol more stable than the structure 1. The (13)C NMR chemical shifts of 1 and 2 were calculated by the GIAO-CCSD(T) method. Based on relative energies and (13)C NMR chemical shift calculations, an equilibrium involving the 1 and 2 in superacid solutions is most likely responsible for the experimentally observed (13)C NMR chemical shifts, with the latter as the predominant equilibrating species. The alpha-methylcyclopropylcarbinyl cation, 4, and nonclassical bicyclobutonium ion, 5, were found to be the minima for C 5H 9 (+) at the MP2/cc-pVTZ level. At the MP4(SDTQ)/cc-pVTZ//MP2/cc-pVTZ + ZPE level ion 5 is 5.9 kcal/mol more stable than the structure 4. The calculated (13)C NMR chemical shifts of 5 agree rather well with the experimental values of C 5H 9 (+).

Electrophilic Intermediates and Their Reactions in Superacids

Acid-catalyzed reactions have played a major role in hydrocarbon chemistry involving electron-deficient intermediates such as carbocations, carbodications, onium ions, etc. The pioneering discovery of the use of superacids by George A. Olah, in the early 1960s, to characterize such intermediates under so-called long-lived stable ion conditions led to the understanding of their structures and reactivity patterns much more clearly. Continuing studies in this area in the past 30 years have resulted in a paradigm shift in comprehending the stability and reactivity of electrophilic intermediates in superacid media.

Quantum-mechanical calculations of the stabilities of fluxional isomers of C4H(7)(+) in solution

Although numerous quantum calculations have been made over the years of the stabilities of the fluxional isomers of C(4)H(7)(+), none have been reported for other than the gas phase (which is unrealistic for these ionic species) that exhibit exceptional fluxional properties in solution. To be sure, quantum-mechanical calculations for solutions are subject to substantial uncertainties, but nonetheless it is important to see whether the trends seen for the gas-phase C(4)H(7)(+) species are also found in calculations for polar solutions. Of the C(4)H(7)(+) species, commonly designated bisected-cyclopropylcarbinyl 1, unsym-bicyclobutonium 2, sym-bicyclobutonium 3, allylcarbinyl 4, and pyramidal structure 6, the most advanced gas-phase calculations available thus far suggest that the order of stability is 1 > or = 2 > or = 3 4 6 with barriers of only approximately 1 kcalmol for interconversions among 1, 2, and 3. We report here that, when account is taken of solvation, 2 turns out to be slightly more stable than 1 or 3 in polar solvents. The pattern of the overall results is unexpected, in that despite substantial differences in structures and charge distributions between the primary players in the C(4)H(7)(+) equilibria and the large differences in solvation energies calculated for the solvents considered, the differential solvent effects from species to species are rather small.

REARRANGEMENT IN THE REACTION BETWEEN 2-PHENYLETHYLAMINE-1-C14 AND NITROUS ACID

On treatment with sodium nitrite, 2-phenylethylamine-1-C14 in aqueous hydrochloric, perchloric, acetic, or glacial acetic acid gives rise to products in which the C14 atoms have been rearranged from the C-1 to the C-2 position to an extent of 20.5 to 22.5%. The results are discussed on the basis of carbonium ions as possible reaction intermediates.