Small-Molecule Dimerization Inhibitors of Wild-Type and Mutant HIV Protease: A Focused Library Approach

Mechanism of darunavir binding to monomeric HIV-1 protease: a step forward in the rational design of dimerization inhibitors

HIV protease (HIVPR) is a key target in AIDS therapeutics. All ten FDA-approved drugs that compete with substrates in binding to this dimeric enzyme's active site have become ineffective due to the emergence of drug resistant mutants. Blocking the dimerization interface of HIVPR is thus being explored as an alternate strategy. The latest drug, darunavir (DRV), which exhibited a high genetic barrier to viral resistance, is said to have a dual mode of action - (i) binding to the dimeric active site, and (ii) preventing the dimerization by binding to the HIVPR monomer. Despite several reports on DRV complexation with dimeric HIVPR, the mode and mechanism of the binding of DRV to the HIVPR monomer are poorly understood. In this study, we utilized all-atomic MD simulations and umbrella sampling techniques to identify the best possible binding mode of DRV to the monomeric HIVPR and its mechanism of association. The results suggest that DRV binds between the active site and the flap of the monomer, and the flap plays a crucial role in directing the drug to bind and driving the other protein domains to undergo induced fit changes for stronger complexation. The obtained binding mode of DRV was validated by comparing with various mutational data from clinical isolates to reported in vitro mutations. The identified binding pose was also able to successfully reproduce the experimental K_i value in the picomolar range. The residue-level information extracted from this study could accelerate the structure-based drug designing approaches targeting HIVPR dimerization.

Disrupting the Constitutive, Homodimeric Protein-Protein Interface in CK2β Using a Biophysical Fragment-Based Approach

Identifying small molecules that induce the disruption of constitutive protein–protein interfaces is a challenging objective. Here, a targeted biophysical screening cascade was employed to specifically identify small molecules that could disrupt the constitutive, homodimeric protein–protein interface within CK2β. This approach could potentially be applied to achieve subunit disassembly of other homo-oligomeric proteins as a means of modulating protein function.

Retroviral proteases and their roles in virion maturation

Proteolytic processing of viral polyproteins is essential for retrovirus infectivity. Retroviral proteases (PR) become activated during or after assembly of the immature, non-infectious virion. They cleave viral polyproteins at specific sites, inducing major structural rearrangements termed maturation. Maturation converts retroviral enzymes into their functional form, transforms the immature shell into a metastable state primed for early replication events, and enhances viral entry competence. Not only cleavage at all PR recognition sites, but also an ordered sequence of cleavages is crucial. Proteolysis is tightly regulated, but the triggering mechanisms and kinetics and pathway of morphological transitions remain enigmatic. Here, we outline PR structures and substrate specificities focusing on HIV PR as a therapeutic target. We discuss design and clinical success of HIV PR inhibitors, as well as resistance development towards these drugs. Finally, we summarize data elucidating the role of proteolysis in maturation and highlight unsolved questions regarding retroviral maturation.

A multi-drug resistant HIV-1 protease is resistant to the dimerization inhibitory activity of TLF-PafF

Human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) protease, a homodimeric aspartyl protease, is a critical drug target in designing anti-retroviral drugs to treat HIV/AIDS. Multidrug-resistant (MDR) clinical isolate-769 HIV-1 protease (PDB ID: 3PJ6) has been shown to exhibit expanded active site cavity with wide-open conformation of flaps (Gly48-Gly52) due to the accumulation of multiple mutations. In this study, an HIV-1 protease dimerization inhibitor (PDI)-TLF-PafF, was evaluated against MDR769 HIV-1 protease using X-ray crystallography. It was hypothesized that co-crystallization of MDR769 HIV-1 protease in complex with TLF-PafF would yield either a monomeric or a disrupted dimeric structure. However, crystal structure of MDR769 I10V HIV-1 protease co-crystallized with TLF-PafF revealed an undisrupted dimeric protease structure (PDB ID: 4NKK) that is comparable to the crystal structure of its corresponding apo-protease (PDB ID: 3PJ6). In order to understand the binding profile of TLF-PafF as a PDI, docking analysis was performed using monomeric protease (prepared from the dimeric crystal structure, PDB ID: 4NKK) as docking receptor. Docking analysis revealed that TLF-PafF binds at the N and C termini (dimerization domain) in a clamp shape for the monomeric wild type receptor but not the MDR769 monomeric receptor. TLF-PafF preferentially showed higher binding affinity to the expanded active site cavity of MDR769 HIV-1 protease than to the termini. Irrespective of binding location, the binding affinity of TLF-PafF against wild type receptor (-6.7kcal/mol) was found to be higher compared to its corresponding binding affinity against MDR receptor (-4.6kcal/mol) suggesting that the MDR769 HIV-1 protease could be resistant to the PDI-activity of TLF-PafF, thus supporting the dimeric crystal structure (PDB ID: 4NKK).

Dimerization of HIV-1 protease occurs through two steps relating to the mechanism of protease dimerization inhibition by darunavir

Dimerization of HIV-1 protease (PR) subunits is an essential process for PR's acquisition of proteolytic activity, which plays a critical role in the maturation of HIV-1. Recombinant wild-type PR (PR(WT)) proved to dimerize, as examined with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry; however, two active site interface PR mutants (PR(T26A) and PR(R87K)) remained monomeric. On the other hand, two termini interface PR mutants (PR(1-C95A) and PR(97/99)) took both monomeric and dimeric forms. Differential scanning fluorimetry indicated that PR(1-C95A) and PR(97/99) dimers were substantially less stable than PR(WT) dimers. These data indicate that intermolecular interactions of two monomers occur first at the active site interface, generating unstable or transient dimers, and interactions at the termini interface subsequently occur, generating stable dimers. Darunavir (DRV), an HIV-1 protease inhibitor, inhibits not only proteolytic activity but also PR dimerization. DRV bound to protease monomers in a one-to-one molar ratio, inhibiting the first step of PR dimerization, whereas conventional protease inhibitors (such as saquinavir) that inhibit enzymatic activity but not dimerization failed to bind to monomers. DRV also bound to mutant PRs containing the transframe region-added PR (TFR-PR(D25N) and TFR-PR(D25N-7AA)), whereas saquinavir did not bind to TFR-PR(D25N) or TFR-PR(D25N-7AA). Notably, DRV failed to bind to mutant PR containing four amino acid substitutions (V32I, L33F, I54M, and I84V) that confer resistance to DRV on HIV-1. To our knowledge, the present report represents the first demonstration of the two-step PR dimerization dynamics and the mechanism of dimerization inhibition by DRV, which should help design further, more potent novel PIs.

Disruption of oligomerization and dehydroalanine formation as mechanisms for ClpP protease inhibition

Over 100 protease inhibitors are currently used in the clinics, and most of them use blockage of the active site for their mode of inhibition. Among the protease drug targets are several enzymes for which the correct multimeric assembly is crucial to their activity, such as the proteasome and the HIV protease. Here, we present a novel mechanism of protease inhibition that relies on active-site-directed small molecules that disassemble the protease complex. We show the applicability of this mechanism within the ClpP protease family, whose members are tetradecameric serine proteases and serve as regulators of several cellular processes, including homeostasis and virulence. Compound binding to ClpP in a substoichiometric fashion triggers the formation of completely inactive heptamers. Moreover, we report the selective β-sultam-induced dehydroalanine formation of the active site serine. This reaction proceeds through sulfonylation and subsequent elimination, thereby obliterating the catalytic charge relay system. The identity of the dehydroalanine was confirmed by mass spectrometry and crystallography. Activity-based protein profiling experiments suggest the formation of a dehydroalanine moiety in living S. aureus cells upon β-sultam treatment. Collectively, these findings extend our view on multicomponent protease inhibition that until now has mainly relied on blockage of the active site or occupation of a regulatory allosteric site.

Design, synthesis and evaluation of a potent substrate analog inhibitor identified by scanning Ala/Phe mutagenesis, mimicking substrate co-evolution, against multidrug-resistant HIV-1 protease

Multidrug-resistant (MDR) clinical isolate-769, human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) protease (PDB ID: 1TW7), was shown to exhibit wide-open flaps and an expanded active site cavity, causing loss of contacts with protease inhibitors. In the current study, the expanded active site cavity of MDR769 HIV-1 protease was screened with a series of peptide-inhibitors that were designed to mimic the natural substrate cleavage site, capsid/p2. Scanning Ala/Phe chemical mutagenesis approach was incorporated into the design of the peptide series to mimic the substrate co-evolution. Among the peptides synthesized and evaluated, a lead peptide (6a) with potent activity (IC50: 4.4nM) was identified against the MDR769 HIV-1 protease. Isothermal titration calorimetry data showed favorable binding profile for 6a against both wild type and MDR769 HIV-1 protease variants. Nuclear magnetic resonance spectrum of (15)N-labeled MDR769 HIV-1 protease in complex with 6a showed some major perturbations in chemical shift, supporting the peptide induced conformational changes in protease. Modeling analysis revealed multiple contacts between 6a and MDR769 HIV-1 protease. The lead peptide-inhibitor, 6a, with high potency and good binding profile can be used as the basis for developing potent small molecule inhibitors against MDR variants of HIV.

Effects of HIV-1 protease on cellular functions and their potential applications in antiretroviral therapy

Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 (HIV-1) protease inhibitors (PIs) are the most potent class of drugs in antiretroviral therapies. However, viral drug resistance to PIs could emerge rapidly thus reducing the effectiveness of those drugs. Of note, all current FDA-approved PIs are competitive inhibitors, i.e., inhibitors that compete with substrates for the active enzymatic site. This common inhibitory approach increases the likelihood of developing drug resistant HIV-1 strains that are resistant to many or all current PIs. Hence, new PIs that move away from the current target of the active enzymatic site are needed. Specifically, allosteric inhibitors, inhibitors that prohibit PR enzymatic activities through non-competitive binding to PR, should be sought. Another common feature of current PIs is they were all developed based on the structure-based design. Drugs derived from a structure-based strategy may generate target specific and potent inhibitors. However, this type of drug design can only target one site at a time and drugs discovered by this method are often associated with strong side effects such as cellular toxicity, limiting its number of target choices, efficacy, and applicability. In contrast, a cell-based system may provide a useful alternative strategy that can overcome many of the inherited shortcomings associated with structure-based drug designs. For example, allosteric PIs can be sought using a cell-based system without considering the site or mechanism of inhibition. In addition, a cell-based system can eliminate those PIs that have strong cytotoxic effect. Most importantly, a simple, economical, and easy-to-maintained eukaryotic cellular system such as yeast will allow us to search for potential PIs in a large-scaled high throughput screening (HTS) system, thus increasing the chances of success. Based on our many years of experience in using fission yeast as a model system to study HIV-1 Vpr, we propose the use of fission yeast as a possible surrogate system to study the effects of HIV-1 protease on cellular functions and to explore its utility as a HTS system to search for new PIs to battle HIV-1 resistant strains.

Using peptides to study protein-protein interactions

Protein-protein interactions (PPIs) govern all aspects of cell function and, as such, are a major target for research and therapeutic intervention. A major rate-limiting step in PPI research is the expression and purification of full-length proteins. The use of peptides to study PPIs significantly facilitates the structural and biophysical characterization of PPIs as well as the effort to develop drugs to control PPIs. Here we describe examples for the use of peptides to study PPI and some of the important experimental methods that are used in the field. Peptides have proved to be excellent tools to study PPIs and have been contributing both for understanding mechanisms of PPIs as well as for drug design for PPI modulation.

Regulation of enzyme activity through interactions with nanoparticles

The structure and function of an enzyme can be altered by nanoparticles (NPs). The interaction between enzyme and NPs is governed by the key properties of NPs, such as structure, size, surface chemistry, charge and surface shape. Recent representative studies on the NP-enzyme interactions and the regulation of enzyme activity by NPs with different size, composition and surface modification are reviewed.

Analysis and characterization of dimerization inhibition of a multi-drug-resistant human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease using a novel size-exclusion chromatographic approach

Active-site inhibitors of HIV-1 PR (protease) block viral replication by preventing viral maturation. However, HIV-1 often develops resistance to active-site inhibitors through multiple mutations in PR and therefore recent efforts have focused on inhibiting PR dimerization as an alternative approach. Dimerization inhibitors have been identified using kinetic analysis, but additional characterization of the effect of these inhibitors on PR by physical methods has been difficult. In the present study, we identified a PR(MDR) (multi-drug-resistant HIV-1 PR) that was highly resistant to autoproteolysis. Using this PR and a novel size-exclusion chromatographic approach that incorporated fluorescence and MS detection, we were able to demonstrate inhibition of dimerization using P27 (peptide 27), a peptide dimerization inhibitor of PR previously identified on the basis of kinetic analysis. Incubation of PR(MDR) with P27, or other dimerization inhibitors, led to a dose- and time-dependent formation of PR monomers based on the change in elution time by size exclusion and its similar elution time to engineered forms of monomeric PR, namely PR(T26A) and glutathionylated PR. In contrast, incubation of PR(MDR) with a potent active-site inhibitor did not change the elution time for the PR(MDR) dimer. The monomeric PR induced by P27 had fluorescent characteristics which were consistent with unfolded PR. Structure-activity studies identified the active regions of P27 and experiments were performed to examine the effect of other dimerization inhibitors on PR. The present study is the first characterization of dimerization inhibition of PR(MDR), a prime target for these inhibitors, using a novel size-exclusion chromatographic approach.

Targeting protein–protein interactions for therapeutic intervention: a challenge for the future

Background: Over the last two decades, an increasing research effort in academia and industry has focused on the modulation (both inhibition and stabilization) of protein–protein interactions (PPIs) in order to develop novel therapeutic approaches and target-selective agents in drug discovery. Discussion: The diversity and complexity of highly dynamic systems such as PPIs present many challenges for the identification of drug-like molecules with the ability to modulate the PPI with the necessary selectivity and potency. In this review, a number of these strategies will be presented along with a critical overview of the challenges and potential solutions relating to the exploitation of PPIs as molecular targets. Conclusions: Both traditional drug discovery approaches and some more recently developed innovative strategies have already provided valuable tools for the discovery of PPI modulators, and a number of successful examples have highlighted the potential of targeting PPIs for therapeutic intervention, especially in the oncology area.

Sidechain-linked inhibitors of HIV-1 protease dimerization

There is a great need for alternative modes of inhibition for the design of anti-HIV therapies, due to the increased resistance of HIV to currently approved drugs. A novel strategy for generating potent dimerization inhibitors of HIV-1 protease is described based on sidechain-linked interfacial peptides. In a number of cases the activity of these agents against HIV-1 protease was found to be among the most potent reported, with inhibitory constants in the low nM range.

Modulation of the catalytic behavior of alpha-chymotrypsin at monolayer-protected nanoparticle surfaces

Amino-acid-functionalized gold clusters modulate the catalytic behavior of alpha-chymotrypsin (ChT) toward cationic, neutral, and anionic substrates. Kinetic studies reveal that the substrate specificity (k(cat)/K(M)) of ChT-nanoparticle complexes increases by approximately 3-fold for the cationic substrate but decreases by 95% for the anionic substrate as compared with that of free ChT, providing enhanced substrate selectivity. Concurrently, the catalytic constants (k(cat)) of ChT show slight augmentation for the cationic substrate and significant attenuation for the anionic substrate in the presence of amino-acid-functionalized nanoparticles. The amino acid monolayer on the nanoparticle is proposed to control both the capture of substrate by the active site and release of product through electrostatic interactions, leading to the observed substrate specificities and catalytic constants.

An alternative strategy for inhibiting multidrug-resistant mutants of the dimeric HIV-1 protease by targeting the subunit interface

Mutations that occur in response to the HIV-1 protease inhibitors are responsible for the development of multidrug cross-resistance to these antiproteases in AIDS treatment. One alternative to inhibiting the active site of HIV-1 protease is to target the dimer interface of the homodimeric enzyme at the antiparallel beta-sheet formed by the interdigitation of the C- and N-ends of each monomer. This region is highly conserved and is responsible for approx. 75% of the dimer-stabilization energy. The strategies that have been used to design small molecules to target the interface antiparallel beta-sheet have produced lipopeptides, guanidinium derivatives and peptides (or peptidomimetics) cross-linked with spacers. The mechanism of inhibition was determined using a combination of kinetic and biophysical methods. These dimerization inhibitors proved equally active in vitro against both wild-type and mutated proteases. They are therefore promising alternatives to active-site-directed inhibitors in AIDS therapy. Disruption of protein-protein interactions by small molecules is a new way to obtain potentially therapeutic molecules.

Targeting structural flexibility in HIV-1 protease inhibitor binding

HIV-1 protease remains an important anti-AIDS drug target. Although it has been known that ligand binding induces large conformational changes in the protease, the dynamic aspects of binding have been largely ignored. Several computational models describing protease dynamics have been reported recently. These have reproduced experimental observations, and have also explained how ligands gain access to the binding site through dynamic behavior of the protease. Specifically, the transitions between three different conformations of the protein have been modeled in atomic detail. Two of these forms were determined by crystallography, and the third was implied by NMR experiments. Based on these computational models, it has been suggested that binding of inhibitors in allosteric sites might affect protease flexibility and disrupt its function.

Current developments in HIV chemotherapy

HIV infection is the leading cause of death worldwide and despite major advances in treatment, more new cases were diagnosed in 2004 than any previous year. Current treatment regimens are based on the use of two or more drugs from two or more classes of inhibitors termed highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART). Although HAART is capable of suppressing viral loads to undetectable levels, problems of toxicity, patient adherence, and particularly the emergence of drug-resistant viruses continues to spur the development of new chemotherapeutics to combat HIV. Clinical candidates from the four existing classes of inhibitors are presented in this review along with lead compounds against new viral targets, with special emphasis on HIV integrase.

Targeting protein-protein interactions by rational design: mimicry of protein surfaces

Protein-protein interactions play key roles in a range of biological processes, and are therefore important targets for the design of novel therapeutics. Unlike in the design of enzyme active site inhibitors, the disruption of protein-protein interactions is far more challenging, due to such factors as the large interfacial areas involved and the relatively flat and featureless topologies of these surfaces. Nevertheless, in spite of such challenges, there has been considerable progress in recent years. In this review, we discuss this progress in the context of mimicry of protein surfaces: targeting protein-protein interactions by rational design.

Rapid Synthesis and In Situ Screening of Potent HIV-1 Protease Dimerization Inhibitors

A library of dimerization inhibitors of HIV-1 protease is described based on crosslinked interfacial peptides. The 54 component library was designed to contain two modifications to the starting structure, one each in the Northern and Southern fragments. A rapid synthesis and in situ screening method in microtiter plates was developed to facilitate the generation and evaluation of the library members. More than 90% of the doubly modified agents were more potent than their respective singly mutated parent compounds, and five of the most potent dimerization inhibitors of HIV-1 protease described to date were identified. The free energy of binding for the combined two modifications was generally found to be additive, demonstrating the predictive value of earlier libraries.

Regulation of α-chymotrypsin activity on the surface of substrate-functionalized gold nanoparticles

A gold nanoparticle functionalized with substrates for alpha-chymotrypsin was fabricated to afford an enzyme modulator that exhibited enzyme-specific activation coupled with general inhibition of other proteases.

Protein surface recognition and proteomimetics: mimics of protein surface structure and function

Due to their key roles in a number of biological processes, protein-protein interactions are attractive and important targets, typically involving areas greater than 6 nm2. The disruption of such interactions remains a challenging feat but, in recent years, there has been considerable progress in the design of proteomimetics: molecules that mimic the structure and function of extended regions of protein surfaces. In particular, porphyrins, calixarenes, alpha-helical mimetics and small molecules have successfully modulated significant protein-protein interactions, including those involved in cancer and HIV.

Tunable Inhibition and Denaturation of α-Chymotrypsin with Amino Acid-Functionalized Gold Nanoparticles

Water-soluble gold nanoparticles bearing diverse l-amino acid terminals have been fabricated to probe the effect of receptor surface on protein surface binding. The interaction of these nanoparticles with alpha-chymotrypsin (ChT) was investigated by activity assay, gel electrophoresis, zeta-potential, circular dichroism, and fluorescence spectroscopy. The results show that both electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions between the hydrophobic patches of receptors and the protein contribute to the stability of the complex. The microscopic binding constants for these receptor-protein systems are 10(6)-10(7) M(-1), with the capacity of the nanoparticle receptors to bind proteins determined by both their surface area and their surface charge density. Furthermore, it is found that the hydrophilic side chains destabilize the ChT structure through either competitive hydrogen bonding or breakage of salt bridges, whereas denaturation was much slower with hydrophobic amino acid side chains. Significantly, correlation between the hydrophobicity index of amino acid side chains and the binding affinity and denaturation rates was observed.

Switching between allosteric and dimerization inhibition of HIV-1 protease

Refining the functional groups on a phenethylamine moiety within an inhibitor of HIV-1 protease led to a switch in the mechanism of inhibition from competitive and allosteric to dimerization inhibition. Phenylether extensions to the phenethylamine group led to agents that target the dimerization interface of HIV-1 protease with high potency.

Development of Low Molecular Weight HIV-1 Protease Dimerization Inhibitors

The role of HIV protease in viral replication has made it a significant target for inhibition. The focus of our studies is to target the dimerization interface of HIV-1 protease because disruption of the dimer will inhibit enzymatic activity. The initial strategy began with cross-linked peptides derived from the interface of HIV protease. Herein we describe the design of a focused library of agents based on a minimal pharmacophore for HIV-1 protease dimerization inhibition.