Modulating Rhodopsin Receptor Activation by Altering the pKa of the Retinal Schiff Base

Early Proton Transfer Reaction in a Primate Blue-Sensitive Visual Pigment

The proton transfer reaction belongs to one of the key triggers for the functional expression of membrane proteins. Rod and cone opsins are light-sensitive G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) that undergo the cis-trans isomerization of the retinal chromophore in response to light. The isomerization event initiates a conformational change in the opsin protein moiety, which propagates the downstream effector signaling. The final step of receptor activation is the deprotonation of the retinal Schiff base, a proton transfer reaction which has been believed to be identical among the cone opsins. Here, we report an unexpected proton transfer reaction occurring in the early photoreaction process of primate blue-sensitive pigment (MB). By using low-temperature UV-visible spectroscopy, we found that the Lumi intermediate of MB formed in transition from the BL intermediate shows an absorption maximum in the UV region, indicating the deprotonation of the retinal Schiff base. Comparison of the light-induced difference FTIR spectra of Batho, BL, and Lumi showed significant α-helical backbone C=O stretching and protonated carboxylate C=O stretching vibrations only in the Lumi intermediate. The transition from BL to Lumi thus involves dramatic changes in protein environment with a proton transfer reaction between the Schiff base and the counterion resulting in an absorption maximum in the UV region.

Ligand Binding-Induced Structural Changes in the M2 Muscarinic Acetylcholine Receptor Revealed by Vibrational Spectroscopy

M₂ muscarinic acetylcholine receptor (M₂R) is a prototypical G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) that responds to acetylcholine and mediates various cellular responses in the nervous system. Here, we used attenuated total reflection-Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy analyses on M₂R reconstituted in a lipid membrane to understand the molecular mechanism behind the ligand binding-induced conformational changes. Upon agonist binding, M₂R shows large spectral change of the amide-I band corresponding to backbone C═O stretch, which likely connects with the receptor activation in the lipid environment. These results pave the way to probe effects of different ligand binding on GPCRs using vibrational spectroscopy.

Protein Sequence and Membrane Lipid Roles in the Activation Kinetics of Bovine and Human Rhodopsins

Rhodopsin is a G protein-coupled receptor found in the rod outer segments in the retina, which triggers a visual response under dim light conditions. Recently, a study of the late, microsecond-to-millisecond kinetics of photointermediates of the human and bovine rhodopsins in their native membranes revealed a complex, double-square mechanism of rhodopsin activation. In this kinetic scheme, the human rhodopsin exhibited more Schiff base deprotonation than bovine rhodopsin, which could arise from the ∼7% sequence difference between the two proteins, or from the difference between their membrane lipid environments. To differentiate between the effects of membrane and protein structure on the kinetics, the human and bovine rhodopsins were inserted into 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine lipid nanodiscs and the kinetics of activation at 15°C and pH 8.7 was investigated by time-resolved absorption spectroscopy and global kinetic analysis. For both proteins, the kinetics in nanodiscs shows the characteristics observed in the native membranes, and is described by a multisquare model with Schiff base deprotonation at the lumirhodopsin I intermediate stage. The results indicate that the protein sequence controls the extent of Schiff base deprotonation and accumulation of intermediates, and thus plays the main role in the different activation kinetics observed between human and bovine rhodopsins. The membrane lipid does have a minor role by modulating the timing of the kinetics, with the nanodisc environment leading to an earlier Schiff base deprotonation.

Retinal Conformation Changes Rhodopsin's Dynamic Ensemble

G protein-coupled receptors are vital membrane proteins that allosterically transduce biomolecular signals across the cell membrane. However, the process by which ligand binding induces protein conformation changes is not well understood biophysically. Rhodopsin, the mammalian dim-light receptor, is a unique test case for understanding these processes because of its switch-like activity; the ligand, retinal, is bound throughout the activation cycle, switching from inverse agonist to agonist after absorbing a photon. By contrast, the ligand-free opsin is outside the activation cycle and may behave differently. We find that retinal influences rhodopsin dynamics using an ensemble of all-atom molecular dynamics simulations that in aggregate contain 100 μs of sampling. Active retinal destabilizes the inactive state of the receptor, whereas the active ensemble was more structurally homogenous. By contrast, simulations of an active-like receptor without retinal present were much more heterogeneous than those containing retinal. These results suggest allosteric processes are more complicated than a ligand inducing protein conformational changes or simply capturing a shifted ensemble as outlined in classic models of allostery.

Retinal ligand mobility explains internal hydration and reconciles active rhodopsin structures

Rhodopsin, the mammalian dim-light receptor, is one of the best-characterized G-protein-coupled receptors, a pharmaceutically important class of membrane proteins that has garnered a great deal of attention because of the recent availability of structural information. Yet the mechanism of rhodopsin activation is not fully understood. Here, we use microsecond-scale all-atom molecular dynamics simulations, validated by solid-state (2)H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, to understand the transition between the dark and metarhodopsin I (Meta I) states. Our analysis of these simulations reveals striking differences in ligand flexibility between the two states. Retinal is much more dynamic in Meta I, adopting an elongated conformation similar to that seen in the recent activelike crystal structures. Surprisingly, this elongation corresponds to both a dramatic influx of bulk water into the hydrophobic core of the protein and a concerted transition in the highly conserved Trp265(6.48) residue. In addition, enhanced ligand flexibility upon light activation provides an explanation for the different retinal orientations observed in X-ray crystal structures of active rhodopsin.

Molecular mechanisms of disease for mutations at Gly-90 in rhodopsin

Two different mutations at Gly-90 in the second transmembrane helix of the photoreceptor protein rhodopsin have been proposed to lead to different phenotypes. G90D has been classically associated with congenital night blindness, whereas the newly reported G90V substitution was linked to a retinitis pigmentosa phenotype. Here, we used Val/Asp replacements of the native Gly at position 90 to unravel the structure/function divergences caused by these mutations and the potential molecular mechanisms of inherited retinal disease. The G90V and G90D mutants have a similar conformation around the Schiff base linkage region in the dark state and same regeneration kinetics with 11-cis-retinal, but G90V has dramatically reduced thermal stability when compared with the G90D mutant rhodopsin. The G90V mutant also shows, like G90D, an altered photobleaching pattern and capacity to activate Gt in the opsin state. Furthermore, the regeneration of the G90V mutant with 9-cis-retinal was improved, achieving the same A(280)/A(500) as wild type isorhodopsin. Hydroxylamine resistance was also recovered, indicating a compact structure around the Schiff base linkage, and the thermal stability was substantially improved when compared with the 11-cis-regenerated mutant. These results support the role of thermal instability and/or abnormal photoproduct formation in eliciting a retinitis pigmentosa phenotype. The improved stability and more compact structure of the G90V mutant when it was regenerated with 9-cis-retinal brings about the possibility that this isomer or other modified retinoid analogues might be used in potential treatment strategies for mutants showing the same structural features.

Cyclopropyl and isopropyl derivatives of 11-cis and 9-cis retinals at C-9 and C-13: subtle steric differences with major effects on ligand efficacy in rhodopsin

Retinal is the natural ligand (chromophore) of the vertebrate rod visual pigment. It occurs in either the 11-cis (rhodopsin) or the 9-cis (isorhodopsin) configuration. In its evolution to a G protein coupled photoreceptor, rhodopsin has acquired exceptional photochemical properties. Illumination isomerizes the chromophore to the all-trans isomer, which acts as a full agonist. This process is extremely efficient, and there is abundant evidence that the C-9 and C-13 methyl groups of retinal play a pivotal role in this process. To examine the steric limits of the C-9 and C-13 methyl binding pocket of the binding site, we have prepared C-9 and C-13 cyclopropyl and isopropyl derivatives of its native ligands and of α-retinal at C-9. Most isopropyl analogues show very poor binding, except for 9-cis-13-isopropylretinal. Most cyclopropyl derivatives exhibit intermediate binding activity, except for 9-cis-13-cyclopropylretinal, which presents good binding activity. In general, the binding site shows preference for the 9-cis analogues over the 11-cis analogues. In fact, 13-isopropyl-9-cis-retinal acts as a superagonist after illumination. Another surprising finding was that 9-cyclopropylisorhodopsin is more like native rhodopsin with respect to spectral and photochemical properties, whereas 9-cyclopropylrhodopsin behaves more like native isorhodopsin in these aspects.

Rhodopsin activation switches in a native membrane environment

The elucidation of structure-function relationships of membrane proteins still poses a considerable challenge due to the sometimes profound influence of the lipid bilayer on the functional properties of the protein. The visual pigment rhodopsin is a prototype of the family of G protein-coupled transmembrane receptors and a considerable part of our knowledge on its activation mechanisms has been derived from studies on detergent-solubilized proteins. This includes in particular the events associated with the conformational transitions of the receptor from the still inactive Meta I to the Meta II photoproduct states, which are involved in signaling. These events involve disruption of an internal salt bridge of the retinal protonated Schiff base, movement of helices and proton uptake from the solvent by the conserved cytoplasmic E(D)RY network around Glu134. As the equilibria associated with these events are considerably altered by the detergent environment, we set out to investigate these equilibria in the native membrane environment and to develop a coherent thermodynamic model of these activating steps using UV-visible and Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy as complementary techniques. Particular emphasis is put on the role of protonation of Glu134 from the solvent, which is a thermodynamic prerequisite for full receptor activation in membranes, but not in detergent. In view of the conservation of this carboxylate group in family A G protein-coupled receptors, it may also play a similar role in the activation of other family members.

Two protonation switches control rhodopsin activation in membranes

Activation of the G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) rhodopsin is initiated by light-induced isomerization of the retinal ligand, which triggers 2 protonation switches in the conformational transition to the active receptor state Meta II. The first switch involves disruption of an interhelical salt bridge by internal proton transfer from the retinal protonated Schiff base (PSB) to its counterion, Glu-113, in the transmembrane domain. The second switch consists of uptake of a proton from the solvent by Glu-134 of the conserved E(D)RY motif at the cytoplasmic terminus of helix 3, leading to pH-dependent receptor activation. By using a combination of UV-visible and FTIR spectroscopy, we study the activation mechanism of rhodopsin in different membrane environments and show that these 2 protonation switches become partially uncoupled at physiological temperature. This partial uncoupling leads to approximately 50% population of an entropy-stabilized Meta II state in which the interhelical PSB salt bridge is broken and activating helix movements have taken place but in which Glu-134 remains unprotonated. This partial activation is converted to full activation only by coupling to the pH-dependent protonation of Glu-134 from the solvent, which stabilizes the active receptor conformation by lowering its enthalpy. In a membrane environment, protonation of Glu-134 is therefore a thermodynamic rather than a structural prerequisite for activating helix movements. In light of the conservation of the E(D)RY motif in rhodopsin-like GPCRs, protonation of this carboxylate also may serve a similar function in signal transduction of other members of this receptor family.

Functional role of the "ionic lock"--an interhelical hydrogen-bond network in family A heptahelical receptors

Activation of family A G-protein-coupled receptors involves a rearrangement of a conserved interhelical cytoplasmic hydrogen bond network between the E(D)RY motif on transmembrane helix 3 (H3) and residues on H6, which is commonly termed the cytoplasmic "ionic lock." Glu134(3.49) of the E(D)RY motif also forms an intrahelical salt bridge with neighboring Arg135(3.50) in the dark-state crystal structure of rhodopsin. We examined the roles of Glu134(3.49) and Arg135(3.50) on H3 and Glu247(6.30) and Glu249(6.32) on H6 on the activation of rhodopsin using Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy of wild-type and mutant pigments reconstituted into lipid membranes. Activation of rhodopsin is pH-dependent with proton uptake during the transition from the inactive Meta I to the active Meta II state. Glu134(3.49) of the ERY motif is identified as the proton-accepting group, using the Fourier transform infrared protonation signature and the absence of a pH dependence of activation in the E134Q mutant. Neutralization of Arg135(3.50) similarly leads to pH-independent receptor activation, but with structural alterations in the Meta II state. Neutralization of Glu247(6.30) and Glu249(6.32) on H6, which are involved in interhelical interactions with H3 and H7, respectively, led to a shift toward Meta II in the E247Q and E249Q mutants while retaining the pH sensitivity of the equilibrium. Disruption of the interhelical interaction of Glu247(6.30) and Glu249(6.32) on H6 with H3 and H7 plays its role during receptor activation, but neutralization of the intrahelical salt bridge between Glu134(3.49) and Arg135(3.50) is considerably more critical for shifting the photoproduct equilibrium to the active conformation. These conclusions are discussed in the context of recent structural data of the beta(2)-adrenergic receptor.

Coupling of Protonation Switches During Rhodopsin Activation†

Recent studies of the activation mechanism of rhodopsin involving Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy and a combination of chromophore modifications and site-directed mutagenesis reveal an allosteric coupling between two protonation switches. In particular, the ring and the 9-methyl group of the all-trans retinal chromophore serve to couple two proton-dependent activation steps: proton uptake by a cytoplasmic network between transmembrane (TM) helices 3 and 6 around the conserved ERY (Glu-Arg-Tyr) motif and disruption of a salt bridge between the retinal protonated Schiff base (PSB) and a protein counterion in the TM core of the receptor. Retinal analogs lacking the ring or 9-methyl group are only partial agonists--the conformational equilibrium between inactive Meta I and active Meta II photoproduct states is shifted to Meta I. An artificial pigment was engineered, in which the ring of retinal was removed and the PSB salt bridge was weakened by fluorination of C14 of the retinal polyene. These modifications abolished allosteric coupling of the proton switches and resulted in a stabilized Meta I state with a deprotonated Schiff base (Meta I(SB)). This state had a partial Meta II-like conformation due to disruption of the PSB salt bridge, but still lacked the cytoplasmic proton uptake reaction characteristic of the final transition to Meta II. As activation of native rhodopsin is known to involve deprotonation of the retinal Schiff base prior to formation of Meta II, this Meta I(SB) state may serve as a model for the structural characterization of a key transient species in the activation pathway of a prototypical G protein-coupled receptor.