Cooperative and directional folding of the preQ1 riboswitch aptamer domain

Supercomputing in the biological sciences: Toward Zettascale and Yottascale simulations

Molecular simulations of biological systems tend to be significantly more compute-intensive than those in materials science and astrophysics, due to important contributions of long-range electrostatic forces and large numbers of time steps (>1E9) required. Simulations of biomolecular complexes of microseconds to milliseconds are considered state-of-the-art today. However, these time scales are miniscule in comparison to physiological time scales relevant to molecular machine activity, drug action, and elongation cycles for protein synthesis, RNA synthesis, and DNA synthesis (seconds to days). While an exascale supercomputer has simulated an entire virus for nanoseconds, this supercomputer would need to be 10 billion times faster to simulate that virus for 3 hours of physiological time, demonstrating the insatiable need for computing power. With growing interest in computational drug design from the pharmaceutical sector, the biological sciences are positioned to be an industry driver in computing.

Tertiary Base Triple Formation in the SRV-1 Frameshifting Pseudoknot Stabilizes Secondary Structure Components

Minor-groove base triples formed between stem 1 and loop 2 of the simian retrovirus type 1 (SRV-1) mRNA frameshifting pseudoknot are essential in stimulating -1 ribosomal frameshifting. How tertiary base triple formation affects the local stabilities of secondary structures (stem 1 and stem 2) and thus ribosomal frameshifting efficiency is not well understood. We made a short peptide nucleic acid (PNA) that is expected to invade stem 1 of the SRV-1 pseudoknot by PNA-RNA duplex formation to mimic the stem 1 unwinding process by a translating ribosome. In addition, we used a PNA for invading stem 2 in the SRV-1 pseudoknot. Our nondenaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis data for the binding of PNA to the SRV-1 pseudoknot and mutants reveal that mutations in loop 2 disrupting base triple formation between loop 2 and stem 1 in the SRV-1 pseudoknot result in enhanced invasion by both PNAs. Our data suggest that tertiary stem 1-loop 2 base triple interactions in the SRV-1 pseudoknot can stabilize both of the secondary structural components, stem 1 and stem 2. Stem 2 stability is thus coupled to the structural stability of stem 1-loop 2 base triples, mediated through a long-range effect. The apparent dissociation constants of both PNAs are positively correlated with the pseudoknot mechanical stabilities and frameshifting efficiencies. The relatively simple PNA local invasion experiment may be used to characterize the energetic contribution of tertiary interactions and ligand binding in many other RNA and DNA structures.

Perspective on the Future Role of Aptamers in Analytical Chemistry

It has been almost 30 years since the invention of Systematic Evolution of Ligands by Exponential Enrichment (SELEX) methodology and the description of the first aptamers. In retrospect over the past 30 years, advances in aptamer development and application have demonstrated that aptamers are potentially useful reagents that can be employed in diverse areas within analytical chemistry, biotechnology, biomedicine, and molecular biology. While often touted as artificial antibodies with an ability to be selected for any target, aptamer development, unfortunately, lags behind development of analytical methodologies that employ aptamers, hindering deeper integration into the application of analytical tool development. This perspective covers recent advances in SELEX methodology for improving efficiency of the SELEX procedure and enhancing affinity and specificity of the selected aptamers, what we view as a critical barrier in the future role of aptamers in analytical chemistry. We discuss postselection modifications that can be used for enhancing performance of the selected aptamers in an analytical device by including understanding intermolecular interaction forces in the binding domain. While highlighting promising properties of aptamers that enable several analytical advances, we provide discussion on the challenges of penetration of aptamers in the analytical field.

Ligand Modulates Cross-Coupling between Riboswitch Folding and Transcriptional Pausing

Numerous classes of riboswitches have been found to regulate bacterial gene expression in response to physiological cues, offering new paths to antibacterial drugs. As common studies of isolated riboswitches lack the functional context of the transcription machinery, we here combine single-molecule, biochemical, and simulation approaches to investigate the coupling between co-transcriptional folding of the pseudoknot-structured preQ₁ riboswitch and RNA polymerase (RNAP) pausing. We show that pausing at a site immediately downstream of the riboswitch requires a ligand-free pseudoknot in the nascent RNA, a precisely spaced sequence resembling the pause consensus, and electrostatic and steric interactions with the RNAP exit channel. While interactions with RNAP stabilize the native fold of the riboswitch, binding of the ligand signals RNAP release from the pause. Our results demonstrate that the nascent riboswitch and its ligand actively modulate the function of RNAP and vice versa, a paradigm likely to apply to other cellular RNA transcripts.

Structure-Based Model of RNA Pseudoknot Captures Magnesium-Dependent Folding Thermodynamics

We develop a simple, coarse-grained approach for simulating the folding of the Beet Western Yellow Virus (BWYV) pseudoknot toward the goal of creating a transferable model that can be used to study other small RNA molecules. This approach combines a structure-based model (SBM) of RNA with an electrostatic scheme that has previously been shown to correctly reproduce ionic condensation in the native basin. Mg²⁺ ions are represented explicitly, directly incorporating ion-ion correlations into the system, and K⁺ is represented implicitly, through the mean-field generalized Manning counterion condensation theory. Combining the electrostatic scheme with a SBM enables the electrostatic scheme to be tested beyond the native basin. We calibrate the SBM to reproduce experimental BWYV unfolding data by eliminating overstabilizing backbone interactions from the molecular contact map and by strengthening base pairing and stacking contacts relative to other native contacts, consistent with the experimental observation that relative helical stabilities are central determinants of the RNA unfolding sequence. We find that this approach quantitatively captures the Mg²⁺ dependence of the folding temperature and generates intermediate states that better approximate those revealed by experiment. Finally, we examine how our model captures Mg²⁺ condensation about the BWYV pseudoknot and a U-tail variant, for which the nine 3' end nucleotides are replaced with uracils, and find our results to be consistent with experimental condensation measurements. This approach can be easily transferred to other RNA molecules by eliminating and strengthening the same classes of contacts in the SBM and including generalized Manning counterion condensation.

Kinetics coming into focus: single-molecule microscopy of riboswitch dynamics

Riboswitches are dynamic RNA motifs that are mostly embedded in the 5'-untranslated regions of bacterial mRNAs, where they regulate gene expression transcriptionally or translationally by undergoing conformational changes upon binding of a small metabolite or ion. Due to the small size of typical ligands, relatively little free energy is available from ligand binding to overcome the often high energetic barrier of reshaping RNA structure. Instead, most riboswitches appear to take advantage of the directional and hierarchical folding of RNA by employing the ligand as a structural 'linchpin' to adjust the kinetic partitioning between alternate folds. In this model, even small, local structural and kinetic effects of ligand binding can cascade into global RNA conformational changes affecting gene expression. Single-molecule (SM) microscopy tools are uniquely suited to study such kinetically controlled RNA folding since they avoid the ensemble averaging of bulk techniques that loses sight of unsynchronized, transient, and/or multi-state kinetic behavior. This review summarizes how SM methods have begun to unravel riboswitch-mediated gene regulation.

RNA Structural Dynamics As Captured by Molecular Simulations: A Comprehensive Overview

With both catalytic and genetic functions, ribonucleic acid (RNA) is perhaps the most pluripotent chemical species in molecular biology, and its functions are intimately linked to its structure and dynamics. Computer simulations, and in particular atomistic molecular dynamics (MD), allow structural dynamics of biomolecular systems to be investigated with unprecedented temporal and spatial resolution. We here provide a comprehensive overview of the fast-developing field of MD simulations of RNA molecules. We begin with an in-depth, evaluatory coverage of the most fundamental methodological challenges that set the basis for the future development of the field, in particular, the current developments and inherent physical limitations of the atomistic force fields and the recent advances in a broad spectrum of enhanced sampling methods. We also survey the closely related field of coarse-grained modeling of RNA systems. After dealing with the methodological aspects, we provide an exhaustive overview of the available RNA simulation literature, ranging from studies of the smallest RNA oligonucleotides to investigations of the entire ribosome. Our review encompasses tetranucleotides, tetraloops, a number of small RNA motifs, A-helix RNA, kissing-loop complexes, the TAR RNA element, the decoding center and other important regions of the ribosome, as well as assorted others systems. Extended sections are devoted to RNA-ion interactions, ribozymes, riboswitches, and protein/RNA complexes. Our overview is written for as broad of an audience as possible, aiming to provide a much-needed interdisciplinary bridge between computation and experiment, together with a perspective on the future of the field.

Genetic regulation mechanism of the yjdF riboswitch

The yjdF riboswitch resides in potential 5' UTRs of homologues of protein-coding gene yjdF in Firmicutes. Unlike other 30 riboswitch classes previously validated, this riboswitch class, can sense and bind to a broad collection of azaaromatic ligands. Among these compounds, some do activate production of yjdF protein driven by the riboswitch, while others are out of riboswitch-mediated modulation possibly because of the toxicity at high ligand concentrations. By incorporating the structures with pseudoknots and ligand binding kinetics into the co-transcriptional folding theory, we theoretically studied the co-transcriptional folding behaviors of the yjdF riboswitch from Bacillus subtilis at different transcription conditions. Like most riboswitches, the yjdF riboswitch can quickly fold into the aptamer structure without any trapped states during the transcription process. After the aptamer structure is formed, the riboswitch shows two main co-transcriptional folding pathways: aptamer→ON state→OFF state and aptamer → the ligand bound aptamer → the ligand bound ON state. Our results suggested that this translational riboswitch is coupled with the transcription process to exert its biological function and it is kinetically controlled. The threshold concentration for the ligand to activate the riboswitch depends on the transcription rate and the association rate of the ligand binding.

Optimal allosteric stabilization sites using contact stabilization analysis

Proteins can be destabilized by a number of environmental factors such as temperature, pH, and mutation. The ability to subsequently restore function under these conditions by adding small molecule stabilizers, or by introducing disulfide bonds, would be a very powerful tool, but the physical principles that drive this stabilization are not well understood. The first problem lies is in choosing an appropriate binding site or disulfide bond location to best confer stability to the active site and restore function. Here, we present a general framework for predicting which allosteric binding sites correlate with stability in the active site. Using the Karanicolas-Brooks Gō-like model, we examine the dynamics of the enzyme β-glucuronidase using an Umbrella Sampling method to thoroughly sample the conformational landscape. Each intramolecular contact is assigned a score termed a "stabilization factor" that measures its correlation with structural changes in the active site. We have carried out this analysis for three different scaling strengths for the intramolecular contacts, and we examine how the calculated stabilization factors depend on the ensemble of destabilized conformations. We further examine a locally destabilized mutant of β-glucuronidase that has been characterized experimentally, and show that this brings about local changes in the stabilization factors. We find that the proximity to the active site is not sufficient to determine which contacts can confer active site stability. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Conformational Rearrangements of Individual Nucleotides during RNA-Ligand Binding Are Rate-Differentiated

A pronounced rate differentiation has been found for conformational rearrangements of individual nucleobases that occur during ligand recognition of the preQ1 class-I riboswitch aptamer from Thermoanaerobacter tengcongensis. Rate measurements rely on the 2ApFold approach by analyzing the fluorescence response of riboswitch variants, each with a single, strategically positioned 2-aminopurine nucleobase substitution. Observed rate discrimination between the fastest and the slowest conformational adaption is 22-fold, with the largest rate observed for the rearrangement of a nucleoside directly at the binding site and the smallest rate observed for the 3'-unpaired nucleoside that stacks onto the pseudo-knot-closing Watson-Crick base pair. Our findings provide novel insights into how compact, prefolded RNAs that follow the induced-fit recognition mechanism adapt local structural elements in response to ligand binding on a rather broad time scale and how this process culminates in a structural signal that is responsible for efficient downregulation of ribosomal translation.

How do metal ions direct ribozyme folding?

Ribozymes, which carry out phosphoryl-transfer reactions, often require Mg(2+) ions for catalytic activity. The correct folding of the active site and ribozyme tertiary structure is also regulated by metal ions in a manner that is not fully understood. Here we employ coarse-grained molecular simulations to show that individual structural elements of the group I ribozyme from the bacterium Azoarcus form spontaneously in the unfolded ribozyme even at very low Mg(2+) concentrations, and are transiently stabilized by the coordination of Mg(2+) ions to specific nucleotides. However, competition for scarce Mg(2+) and topological constraints that arise from chain connectivity prevent the complete folding of the ribozyme. A much higher Mg(2+) concentration is required for complete folding of the ribozyme and stabilization of the active site. When Mg(2+) is replaced by Ca(2+) the ribozyme folds, but the active site remains unstable. Our results suggest that group I ribozymes utilize the same interactions with specific metal ligands for both structural stability and chemical activity.

Structural, functional, and taxonomic diversity of three preQ1 riboswitch classes

Previously, two riboswitch classes have been identified that sense and respond to the hypermodified nucleobase called prequeuosine1 (preQ1). The enormous expansion of available genomic DNA sequence data creates new opportunities to identify additional representatives of the known riboswitch classes and to discover novel classes. We conducted bioinformatics searches on microbial genomic DNA data sets to discover numerous additional examples belonging to the two previously known riboswitch classes for preQ1 (classes preQ1-I and preQ1-II), including some structural variants that further restrict ligand specificity. Additionally, we discovered a third preQ1-binding riboswitch class (preQ1-III) that is structurally distinct from previously known classes. These findings demonstrate that numerous organisms monitor the concentrations of this modified nucleobase by exploiting one or more riboswitch classes for this widespread compound.

Coarse-Grained HiRE-RNA Model for ab Initio RNA Folding beyond Simple Molecules, Including Noncanonical and Multiple Base Pairings

HiRE-RNA is a coarse-grained model for RNA structure prediction and the dynamical study of RNA folding. Using a reduced set of particles and detailed interactions accounting for base-pairing and stacking, we show that noncanonical and multiple base interactions are necessary to capture the full physical behavior of complex RNAs. In this paper, we give a full account of the model and present results on the folding, stability, and free energy surfaces of 16 systems with 12 to 76 nucleotides of increasingly complex architectures, ranging from monomers to dimers, using a total of 850 μs of simulation time.

Collisional unfolding of multiprotein complexes reveals cooperative stabilization upon ligand binding

Cooperative binding mechanisms are a common feature in biology, enabling a diverse range of protein-based molecular machines to regulate activities ranging from oxygen uptake to cellular membrane transport. Much, however, is not known about such cooperative binding mechanisms, including how such events typically add to the overall stability of such protein systems. Measurements of such cooperative stabilization events are challenging, as they require the separation and resolution of individual protein complex bound states within a mixture of potential stoichiometries to individually assess protein stabilities. Here, we report ion mobility-mass spectrometry results for the concanavalin A tetramer bound to a range of polysaccharide ligands. We use collision induced unfolding, a relatively new methodology that functions as a gas-phase analog of calorimetry experiments in solution, to individually assess the stabilities of concanavalin A bound states. By comparing the differences in activation voltage required to unfold different concanavalin A-ligand stoichiometries, we find evidence suggesting a cooperative stabilization of concanavalin A occurs upon binding most carbohydrate ligands. We critically evaluate this observation by assessing a broad range of ligands, evaluating the unfolding properties of multiple protein charge states, and by comparing our gas-phase results with those obtained from calorimetry experiments carried out in solution.

Integrating molecular dynamics simulations with chemical probing experiments using SHAPE-FIT

Integration and calibration of molecular dynamics simulations with experimental data remain a challenging endeavor. We have developed a novel method to integrate chemical probing experiments with molecular simulations of RNA molecules by using a native structure-based model. Selective 2'-hydroxyl acylation by primer extension (SHAPE) characterizes the mobility of each residue in the RNA. Our method, SHAPE-FIT, automatically optimizes the potential parameters of the force field according to measured reactivities from SHAPE. The optimized parameter set allows simulations of dynamics highly consistent with SHAPE probing experiments. Such atomistic simulations, thoroughly grounded in experiment, can open a new window on RNA structure-function relations.

Using simulations and kinetic network models to reveal the dynamics and functions of riboswitches

Riboswitches, RNA elements found in the untranslated region, regulate gene expression by binding to target metaboloites with exquisite specificity. Binding of metabolites to the conserved aptamer domain allosterically alters the conformation in the downstream expression platform. The fate of gene expression is determined by the changes in the downstream RNA sequence. As the metabolite-dependent cotranscriptional folding and unfolding dynamics of riboswitches are the key determinant of gene expression, it is important to investigate both the thermodynamics and kinetics of riboswitches both in the presence and absence of metabolite. Single molecule force experiments that decipher the free energy landscape of riboswitches from their mechanical responses, theoretical and computational studies have recently shed light on the distinct mechanism of folding dynamics in different classes of riboswitches. Here, we first discuss the dynamics of water around riboswitch, highlighting that water dynamics can enhance the fluctuation of nucleic acid structure. To go beyond native state fluctuations, we used the Self-Organized Polymer model to predict the dynamics of add adenine riboswitch under mechanical forces. In addition to quantitatively predicting the folding landscape of add-riboswitch, our simulations also explain the difference in the dynamics between pbuE adenine- and add adenine-riboswitches. In order to probe the function in vivo, we use the folding landscape to propose a system level kinetic network model to quantitatively predict how gene expression is regulated for riboswitches that are under kinetic control.

Molecular dynamic simulations of protein/RNA complexes: CRISPR/Csy4 endoribonuclease

BACKGROUND

Many prokaryotic genomes comprise Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats (CRISPRs) offering defense against foreign nucleic acids. These immune systems are conditioned by the production of small CRISPR-derived RNAs matured from long RNA precursors. This often requires a Csy4 endoribonuclease cleaving the RNA 3'-end.

METHODS

We report extended explicit solvent molecular dynamic (MD) simulations of Csy4/RNA complex in precursor and product states, based on X-ray structures of product and inactivated precursor (55 simulations; ~3.7μs in total).

RESULTS

The simulations identify double-protonated His29 and deprotonated terminal phosphate as the likely dominant protonation states consistent with the product structure. We revealed potential substates consistent with Ser148 and His29 acting as the general base and acid, respectively. The Ser148 could be straightforwardly deprotonated through solvent and could without further structural rearrangements deprotonate the nucleophile, contrasting similar studies investigating the general base role of nucleobases in ribozymes. We could not locate geometries consistent with His29 acting as general base. However, we caution that the X-ray structures do not always capture the catalytically active geometries and then the reactive structures may be unreachable by the simulation technique.

CONCLUSIONS

We identified potential catalytic arrangement of the Csy4/RNA complex but we also report limitations of the simulation technique. Even for the dominant protonation state we could not achieve full agreement between the simulations and the structural data.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

Potential catalytic arrangement of the Csy4/RNA complex is found. Further, we provide unique insights into limitations of simulations of protein/RNA complexes, namely, the influence of the starting experimental structures and force field limitations. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Recent developments of molecular dynamics.

Dynamics of riboswitches: Molecular simulations

Riboswitch RNAs play key roles in bacterial metabolism and represent a promising new class of antibiotic targets for treatment of infectious disease. While many studies of riboswitches have been performed, the exact mechanism of riboswitch operation is still not fully understood at the atomistic level of detail. Molecular dynamics simulations are useful for interpreting existing experimental data and producing predictions for new experiments. Here, a wide range of computational studies on riboswitches is reviewed. By elucidating the key principles of riboswitch operation, computation may aid in the effort to design more specific antibiotics with affinities greater than those of the native ligand. Such a detailed understanding may be required to improve efficacy and reduce side effects. These studies are laying the groundwork for understanding the action mechanism of new compounds that inhibit riboswitch activity. Future directions such as magnesium effects, large-scale conformational changes, expression platforms and co-transcriptional folding are also discussed. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Riboswitches.

Structural dynamics of a single-stranded RNA-helix junction using NMR

Many regulatory RNAs contain long single strands (ssRNA) that adjoin secondary structural elements. Here, we use NMR spectroscopy to study the dynamic properties of a 12-nucleotide (nt) ssRNA tail derived from the prequeuosine riboswitch linked to the 3' end of a 48-nt hairpin. Analysis of chemical shifts, NOE connectivity, (13)C spin relaxation, and residual dipolar coupling data suggests that the first two residues (A25 and U26) in the ssRNA tail stack onto the adjacent helix and assume an ordered conformation. The following U26-A27 step marks the beginning of an A6-tract and forms an acute pivot point for substantial motions within the tail, which increase toward the terminal end. Despite substantial internal motions, the ssRNA tail adopts, on average, an A-form helical conformation that is coaxial with the helix. Our results reveal a surprising degree of structural and dynamic complexity at the ssRNA-helix junction, which involves a fine balance between order and disorder that may facilitate efficient pseudoknot formation on ligand recognition.

Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Nucleic Acids. From Tetranucleotides to the Ribosome

We present a brief overview of explicit solvent molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of nucleic acids. We explain physical chemistry limitations of the simulations, namely, the molecular mechanics (MM) force field (FF) approximation and limited time scale. Further, we discuss relations and differences between simulations and experiments, compare standard and enhanced sampling simulations, discuss the role of starting structures, comment on different versions of nucleic acid FFs, and relate MM computations with contemporary quantum chemistry. Despite its limitations, we show that MD is a powerful technique for studying the structural dynamics of nucleic acids with a fast growing potential that substantially complements experimental results and aids their interpretation.

Structure and function of preQ1 riboswitches

PreQ₁ riboswitches help regulate the biosynthesis and transport of preQ₁ (7-aminomethyl-7-deazaguanine), a precursor of the hypermodified guanine nucleotide queuosine (Q), in a number of Firmicutes, Proteobacteria, and Fusobacteria. Queuosine is almost universally found at the wobble position of the anticodon in asparaginyl, tyrosyl, histidyl and aspartyl tRNAs, where it contributes to translational fidelity. Two classes of preQ₁ riboswitches have been identified (preQ₁-I and preQ₁-II), and structures of examples from both classes have been determined. Both classes form H-type pseudoknots upon preQ₁ binding, each of which has distinct unusual features and modes of preQ₁ recognition. These features include an unusually long loop 2 in preQ₁-I pseudoknots and an embedded hairpin in loop 3 in preQ₁-II pseudoknots. PreQ₁-I riboswitches are also notable for their unusually small aptamer domain, which has been extensively investigated by NMR, X-ray crystallography, FRET, and other biophysical methods. Here we review the discovery, structural biology, ligand specificity, cation interactions, folding, dynamics, and applications to biotechnology of preQ₁ riboswitches. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Riboswitches.

Themes and variations in riboswitch structure and function

The complexity of gene expression control by non-coding RNA has been highlighted by the recent progress in the field of riboswitches. Discovered a decade ago, riboswitches represent a diverse group of non-coding mRNA regions that possess a unique ability to directly sense cellular metabolites and modulate gene expression through formation of alternative metabolite-free and metabolite-bound conformations. Such protein-free metabolite sensing domains utilize sophisticated three-dimensional folding of RNA molecules to discriminate between a cognate ligand from related compounds so that only the right ligand would trigger a genetic response. Given the variety of riboswitch ligands ranging from small cations to large coenzymes, riboswitches adopt a great diversity of structures. Although many riboswitches share structural principles to build metabolite-competent folds, form precise ligand-binding pockets, and communicate a ligand-binding event to downstream regulatory regions, virtually all riboswitch classes possess unique features for ligand recognition, even those tuned to recognize the same metabolites. Here we present an overview of the biochemical and structural research on riboswitches with a major focus on common principles and individual characteristics adopted by these regulatory RNA elements during evolution to specifically target small molecules and exert genetic responses. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Riboswitches.

Riboswitch structure and dynamics by smFRET microscopy

Riboswitches are structured noncoding RNA elements that control the expression of their embedding messenger RNAs by sensing the intracellular concentration of diverse metabolites. As the name suggests, riboswitches are dynamic in nature so that studying their inherent conformational dynamics and ligand-mediated folding is important for understanding their mechanism of action. Single-molecule fluorescence energy transfer (smFRET) microscopy is a powerful and versatile technique for studying the folding pathways and intra- and intermolecular dynamics of biological macromolecules, especially RNA. The ability of smFRET to monitor intramolecular distances and their temporal evolution make it a particularly insightful tool for probing the structure and dynamics of riboswitches. Here, we detail the general steps for using prism-based total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy for smFRET studies of the structure, dynamics, and ligand-binding mechanisms of riboswitches.

Balancing bond, nonbond, and gō-like terms in coarse grain simulations of conformational dynamics

Characterization of the protein conformational landscape remains a challenging problem, whether it concerns elucidating folding mechanisms, predicting native structures or modeling functional transitions. Coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulation methods enable exhaustive sampling of the energetic landscape at resolutions of biological interest. The general utility of structure-based models is reviewed along with their differing levels of approximation. Simple Gō models incorporate attractive native interactions and repulsive nonnative contacts, resulting in an ideal smooth landscape. Non-Gō coarse-grained models reduce the parameter set as needed but do not include bias to any desired native structure. While non-Gō models have achieved limited success in protein coarse-graining, they can be combined with native structured-based potentials to create a balanced and powerful force field. Recent applications of such Gō-like models have yielded insight into complex folding mechanisms and conformational transitions in large macromolecules. The accuracy and usefulness of reduced representations are also revealed to be a function of the mathematical treatment of the intrinsic bonded topology.

Sequence-dependent folding landscapes of adenine riboswitch aptamers

Expression of a large fraction of genes in bacteria is controlled by riboswitches, which are found in the untranslated region of mRNA. Structurally riboswitches have a conserved aptamer domain to which a metabolite binds, resulting in a conformational change in the downstream expression platform. Prediction of the functions of riboswitches requires a quantitative description of the folding landscape so that the barriers and time scales for the conformational change in the switching region in the aptamer can be estimated. Using a combination of all atom molecular dynamics (MD) and coarse-grained model simulations we studied the response of adenine (A) binding add and pbuE A-riboswitches to mechanical force. The two riboswitches contain a structurally similar three-way junction formed by three paired helices, P1, P2, and P3, but carry out different functions. Using pulling simulations, with structures generated in MD simulations, we show that after P1 rips the dominant unfolding pathway in the add A-riboswitch is the rupture of P2 followed by unraveling of P3. In the pbuE A-riboswitch, after P1 unfolds P3 ruptures ahead of P2. The order of unfolding of the helices, which is in accord with single molecule pulling experiments, is determined by the relative stabilities of the individual helices. Our results show that the stability of isolated helices determines the order of assembly and response to force in these non-coding regions. We use the simulated free energy profile for the pbuE A-riboswitch to estimate the time scale for allosteric switching, which shows that this riboswitch is under kinetic control lending additional support to the conclusion based on single molecule pulling experiments. A consequence of the stability hypothesis is that a single point mutation (U28C) in the P2 helix of the add A-riboswitch, which increases the stability of P2, would make the folding landscapes of the two riboswitches similar. This prediction can be tested in single molecule pulling experiments.

Differences between cotranscriptional and free riboswitch folding

Riboswitches are part of noncoding regions of messenger RNA (mRNA) that act as RNA sensors regulating gene expression of the downstream gene. Typically, one out of two distinct conformations is formed depending on ligand binding when the transcript leaves RNA polymerase (RNAP). Elongation of the RNA chain by RNAP, folding and binding all occurs simultaneously and interdependently on the seconds' timescale. To investigate the effect of transcript elongation velocity on folding for the S-adenosylmethionine (SAM)-I and adenine riboswitches we employ two complementary coarse-grained in silico techniques. Native structure-based molecular dynamics simulations provide a 3D, atomically resolved model of folding with homogenous energetics. Energetically more detailed kinetic Monte Carlo simulations give access to longer timescale by describing folding on the secondary structure level and feature the incorporation of competing aptamer conformations and a ligand-binding model. Depending on the extrusion scenarios, we observe and quantify different pathways in structure formation with robust agreements between the two techniques. In these scenarios, free-folding riboswitches exhibit different folding characteristics compared with transcription-rate limited folding. The critical transcription rate distinguishing these cases is higher than physiologically relevant rates. This result suggests that in vivo folding of the analyzed SAM-I and adenine riboswitches is transcription-rate limited.

Kinetics of allosteric transitions in S-adenosylmethionine riboswitch are accurately predicted from the folding landscape

Riboswitches are RNA elements that allosterically regulate gene expression by binding cellular metabolites. The SAM-III riboswitch, one of several classes that binds S-adenosylmethionine (SAM), represses translation upon binding SAM (OFF state) by encrypting the ribosome binding sequence. We have carried out simulations of the RNA by applying mechanical force (f) to the ends of SAM-III, with and without SAM, to get quantitative insights into the f-dependent structural changes. Force-extension (z) curves (FECs) for the apo (ON) state, obtained in simulations in which f is increased at a constant loading rate, show three intermediates, with the first one being the rupture of SAM binding region, which is greatly stabilized in the OFF state. Force-dependent free energy profiles, G(z,f), as a function of z, obtained in equilibrium constant force simulations, reveal the intermediates observed in FECs. The predicted stability difference between the ON and OFF states using G(z,f) is in excellent agreement with experiments. Remarkably, using G(z,f)s and estimate of an effective diffusion constant at a single value of f allows us to predict the f-dependent transition rates using theory of first passage times for both the apo and holo states. To resolve the kinetics of assembly of SAM-III riboswitch in structural terms, we use force stretch-quench pulse sequences in which the force on RNA is maintained at a low (fq) value starting from a high value for a time period tq. Variation of tq over a wide range results in resolution of elusive states involved in the SAM binding pocket and leads to accurate determination of folding times down to fq = 0. Quantitative measure of the folding kinetics, obtained from the folding landscape, allows us to propose that, in contrast to riboswitches regulating transcription, SAM-III functions under thermodynamic control provided the basal concentration of SAM exceeds a small critical value. All of the predictions are amenable to tests in single molecule pulling experiments.

Single transcriptional and translational preQ1 riboswitches adopt similar pre-folded ensembles that follow distinct folding pathways into the same ligand-bound structure

Riboswitches are structural elements in the 5′ untranslated regions of many bacterial messenger RNAs that regulate gene expression in response to changing metabolite concentrations by inhibition of either transcription or translation initiation. The preQ₁ (7-aminomethyl-7-deazaguanine) riboswitch family comprises some of the smallest metabolite sensing RNAs found in nature. Once ligand-bound, the transcriptional Bacillus subtilis and translational Thermoanaerobacter tengcongensis preQ₁ riboswitch aptamers are structurally similar RNA pseudoknots; yet, prior structural studies have characterized their ligand-free conformations as largely unfolded and folded, respectively. In contrast, through single molecule observation, we now show that, at near-physiological Mg²⁺ concentration and pH, both ligand-free aptamers adopt similar pre-folded state ensembles that differ in their ligand-mediated folding. Structure-based Gō-model simulations of the two aptamers suggest that the ligand binds late (Bacillus subtilis) and early (Thermoanaerobacter tengcongensis) relative to pseudoknot folding, leading to the proposal that the principal distinction between the two riboswitches lies in their relative tendencies to fold via mechanisms of conformational selection and induced fit, respectively. These mechanistic insights are put to the test by rationally designing a single nucleotide swap distal from the ligand binding pocket that we find to predictably control the aptamers′ pre-folded states and their ligand binding affinities.

Tuning a riboswitch response through structural extension of a pseudoknot

Structural and dynamic features of RNA folding landscapes represent critical aspects of RNA function in the cell and are particularly central to riboswitch-mediated control of gene expression. Here, using single-molecule fluorescence energy transfer imaging, we explore the folding dynamics of the preQ1 class II riboswitch, an upstream mRNA element that regulates downstream encoded modification enzymes of queuosine biosynthesis. For reasons that are not presently understood, the classical pseudoknot fold of this system harbors an extra stem-loop structure within its 3'-terminal region immediately upstream of the Shine-Dalgarno sequence that contributes to formation of the ligand-bound state. By imaging ligand-dependent preQ1 riboswitch folding from multiple structural perspectives, we reveal that the extra stem-loop strongly influences pseudoknot dynamics in a manner that decreases its propensity to spontaneously fold and increases its responsiveness to ligand binding. We conclude that the extra stem-loop sensitizes this RNA to broaden the dynamic range of the ON/OFF regulatory switch.

The impact of a ligand binding on strand migration in the SAM-I riboswitch

Riboswitches sense cellular concentrations of small molecules and use this information to adjust synthesis rates of related metabolites. Riboswitches include an aptamer domain to detect the ligand and an expression platform to control gene expression. Previous structural studies of riboswitches largely focused on aptamers, truncating the expression domain to suppress conformational switching. To link ligand/aptamer binding to conformational switching, we constructed models of an S-adenosyl methionine (SAM)-I riboswitch RNA segment incorporating elements of the expression platform, allowing formation of an antiterminator (AT) helix. Using Anton, a computer specially developed for long timescale Molecular Dynamics (MD), we simulated an extended (three microseconds) MD trajectory with SAM bound to a modeled riboswitch RNA segment. Remarkably, we observed a strand migration, converting three base pairs from an antiterminator (AT) helix, characteristic of the transcription ON state, to a P1 helix, characteristic of the OFF state. This conformational switching towards the OFF state is observed only in the presence of SAM. Among seven extended trajectories with three starting structures, the presence of SAM enhances the trend towards the OFF state for two out of three starting structures tested. Our simulation provides a visual demonstration of how a small molecule (<500 MW) binding to a limited surface can trigger a large scale conformational rearrangement in a 40 kDa RNA by perturbing the Free Energy Landscape. Such a mechanism can explain minimal requirements for SAM binding and transcription termination for SAM-I riboswitches previously reported experimentally.

Entropic stabilization of the folded states of RNA due to macromolecular crowding

We review the effects of macromolecular crowding on the folding of RNA by considering the simplest scenario when excluded volume interactions between crowding particles and RNA dominate. Using human telomerase enzyme as an example, we discuss how crowding can alter the equilibrium between pseudoknot and hairpin states of the same RNA molecule-a key aspect of crowder-RNA interactions. We summarize data showing that the crowding effect is significant only if the size of the spherical crowding particle is smaller than the radius of gyration of the RNA in the absence of crowding particles. The implication for function of the wild type and mutants of human telomerase is outlined by using a relationship between enzyme activity and its conformational equilibrium. In addition, we discuss the interplay between macromolecular crowding and ionic strength of the RNA buffer. Finally, we briefly review recent experiments which illustrate the connection between excluded volume due to macromolecular crowding and the thermodynamics of RNA folding.

Coarse-grained model for predicting RNA folding thermodynamics

We present a thermodynamically robust coarse-grained model to simulate folding of RNA in monovalent salt solutions. The model includes stacking, hydrogen bond, and electrostatic interactions as fundamental components in describing the stability of RNA structures. The stacking interactions are parametrized using a set of nucleotide-specific parameters, which were calibrated against the thermodynamic measurements for single-base stacks and base-pair stacks. All hydrogen bonds are assumed to have the same strength, regardless of their context in the RNA structure. The ionic buffer is modeled implicitly, using the concept of counterion condensation and the Debye-Hückel theory. The three adjustable parameters in the model were determined by fitting the experimental data for two RNA hairpins and a pseudoknot. A single set of parameters provides good agreement with thermodynamic data for the three RNA molecules over a wide range of temperatures and salt concentrations. In the process of calibrating the model, we establish the extent of counterion condensation onto the single-stranded RNA backbone. The reduced backbone charge is independent of the ionic strength and is 60% of the RNA bare charge at 37 °C. Our model can be used to predict the folding thermodynamics for any RNA molecule in the presence of monovalent ions.

Nucleotides adjacent to the ligand-binding pocket are linked to activity tuning in the purine riboswitch

Direct sensing of intracellular metabolite concentrations by riboswitch RNAs provides an economical and rapid means to maintain metabolic homeostasis. Since many organisms employ the same class of riboswitch to control different genes or transcription units, it is likely that functional variation exists in riboswitches such that activity is tuned to meet cellular needs. Using a bioinformatic approach, we have identified a region of the purine riboswitch aptamer domain that displays conservation patterns linked to riboswitch activity. Aptamer domain compositions within this region can be divided into nine classes that display a spectrum of activities. Naturally occurring compositions in this region favor rapid association rate constants and slow dissociation rate constants for ligand binding. Using X-ray crystallography and chemical probing, we demonstrate that both the free and bound states are influenced by the composition of this region and that modest sequence alterations have a dramatic impact on activity. The introduction of non-natural compositions result in the inability to regulate gene expression in vivo, suggesting that aptamer domain activity is highly plastic and thus readily tunable to meet cellular needs.

Molecular mechanism of preQ1 riboswitch action: a molecular dynamics study

Riboswitches often occur in the 5'-untranslated regions of bacterial mRNA where they regulate gene expression. The preQ(1) riboswitch controls the biosynthesis of a hypermodified nucleoside queuosine in response to binding the queuosine metabolic intermediate. Structures of the ligand-bound and ligand-free states of the preQ(1) riboswitch from Thermoanaerobacter tengcongensis were determined recently by X-ray crystallography. We used multiple, microsecond-long molecular dynamics simulations (29 μs in total) to characterize the structural dynamics of preQ(1) riboswitches in both states. We observed different stabilities of the stem in the bound and free states, resulting in different accessibilities of the ribosome-binding site. These differences are related to different stacking interactions between nucleotides of the stem and the associated loop, which itself adopts different conformations in the bound and free states. We suggest that the loop not only serves to bind preQ(1) but also transmits information about ligand binding from the ligand-binding pocket to the stem, which has implications for mRNA accessibility to the ribosome. We explain functional results obscured by a high salt crystallization medium and help to refine regions of disordered electron density, which demonstrates the predictive power of our approach. Besides investigating the functional dynamics of the riboswitch, we have also utilized this unique small folded RNA system for analysis of performance of the RNA force field on the μs time scale. The latest AMBER parmbsc0χ(OL3) RNA force field is capable of providing stable trajectories of the folded molecule on the μs time scale. On the other hand, force fields that are not properly balanced lead to significant structural perturbations on the sub-μs time scale, which could easily lead to inappropriate interpretation of the simulation data.

Computational study of unfolding and regulation mechanism of preQ1 riboswitches

Riboswitches are novel RNA regulatory elements. Each riboswitch molecule consists of two domains: aptamer and express platform. The three-dimensional (3D) structure of the aptamer domain, depending on ligand binding or not, controls that of the express platform, which then switches on or off transcriptional or translational process. Here we study the two types of preQ(1) riboswitch aptamers from T. Tengcongensis (denoted as Tte preQ(1) riboswitch for short below) and Bacillus subtilis (denoted as Bsu preQ(1) riboswitch for short below), respectively. The free-state 3D structure of the Tte preQ(1) riboswitch is the same as its bound state but the Bsu preQ(1) riboswitch is not. Therefore, it is very interesting to investigate how these riboswitches realize their different regulation functions. We simulated the unfolding of these two aptamers through all-atom molecular dynamic simulation and found that they have similar unfolding or folding pathways and ligand-binding processes. The main difference between them is the folding intermediate states. The similarity and difference of their unfolding or folding dynamics may suggest their similar regulation mechanisms and account for their different functions, respectively. These results are also useful to understand the regulation mechanism of other riboswitches with free-state 3D structures similar to their bound states.

Pseudoknot preorganization of the preQ1 class I riboswitch

To explore folding and ligand recognition of metabolite-responsive RNAs is of major importance to comprehend gene regulation by riboswitches. Here, we demonstrate, using NMR spectroscopy, that the free aptamer of a preQ(1) class I riboswitch preorganizes into a pseudoknot fold in a temperature- and Mg(2+)-dependent manner. The preformed pseudoknot represents a structure that is close to the ligand-bound state and that likely represents the conformation selected by the ligand. Importantly, a defined base pair mutation within the pseudoknot interaction stipulates whether, in the absence of ligand, dimer formation of the aptamer competes with intramolecular pseudoknot formation. This study pinpoints how RNA preorganization is a crucial determinant for the adaptive recognition process of RNA and ligand.

Biomolecular dynamics: order-disorder transitions and energy landscapes

While the energy landscape theory of protein folding is now a widely accepted view for understanding how relatively weak molecular interactions lead to rapid and cooperative protein folding, such a framework must be extended to describe the large-scale functional motions observed in molecular machines. In this review, we discuss (1) the development of the energy landscape theory of biomolecular folding, (2) recent advances toward establishing a consistent understanding of folding and function and (3) emerging themes in the functional motions of enzymes, biomolecular motors and other biomolecular machines. Recent theoretical, computational and experimental lines of investigation have provided a very dynamic picture of biomolecular motion. In contrast to earlier ideas, where molecular machines were thought to function similarly to macroscopic machines, with rigid components that move along a few degrees of freedom in a deterministic fashion, biomolecular complexes are only marginally stable. Since the stabilizing contribution of each atomic interaction is on the order of the thermal fluctuations in solution, the rigid body description of molecular function must be revisited. An emerging theme is that functional motions encompass order-disorder transitions and structural flexibility provides significant contributions to the free energy. In this review, we describe the biological importance of order-disorder transitions and discuss the statistical-mechanical foundation of theoretical approaches that can characterize such transitions.

Molecular recognition and function of riboswitches

Regulatory mRNAs elements termed riboswitches respond to elevated concentrations of cellular metabolites by modulating expression of associated genes. Riboswitches attain their high metabolite selectivity by capitalizing on the intrinsic tertiary structures of their sensor domains. Over the years, riboswitch structure and folding have been amongst the most researched topics in the RNA field. Most recently, novel structures of single-ligand and cooperative double-ligand sensors have broadened our knowledge of architectural and molecular recognition principles exploited by riboswitches. The structural information has been complemented by extensive folding studies, which have provided several important clues on the formation of ligand-competent conformations and mechanisms of ligand discrimination. These studies have greatly improved our understanding of molecular events in riboswitch-mediated gene expression control and provided the molecular basis for intervention into riboswitch-controlled genetic circuits.

Dynamic energy landscapes of riboswitches help interpret conformational rearrangements and function

Riboswitches are RNAs that modulate gene expression by ligand-induced conformational changes. However, the way in which sequence dictates alternative folding pathways of gene regulation remains unclear. In this study, we compute energy landscapes, which describe the accessible secondary structures for a range of sequence lengths, to analyze the transcriptional process as a given sequence elongates to full length. In line with experimental evidence, we find that most riboswitch landscapes can be characterized by three broad classes as a function of sequence length in terms of the distribution and barrier type of the conformational clusters: low-barrier landscape with an ensemble of different conformations in equilibrium before encountering a substrate; barrier-free landscape in which a direct, dominant “downhill” pathway to the minimum free energy structure is apparent; and a barrier-dominated landscape with two isolated conformational states, each associated with a different biological function. Sharing concepts with the “new view” of protein folding energy landscapes, we term the three sequence ranges above as the sensing, downhill folding, and functional windows, respectively. We find that these energy landscape patterns are conserved in various riboswitch classes, though the order of the windows may vary. In fact, the order of the three windows suggests either kinetic or thermodynamic control of ligand binding. These findings help understand riboswitch structure/function relationships and open new avenues to riboswitch design.

Riboswitches are RNAs that modulate gene expression by ligand-induced conformational changes. However, the way that sequence dictates alternative folding pathways of gene regulation remains unclear. In this study, we mimic transcription by computing energy landscapes which describe accessible secondary structures for a range of sequence lengths. Consistent with experimental evidence, we find that most riboswitch landscapes can be characterized by three broad classes as a function of sequence length in terms of the distribution and barrier type of the conformational clusters: Low-barrier landscape with an ensemble of conformations in equilibrium before encountering a substrate; barrier-free landscape with a dominant “downhill” pathway to the minimum free energy structure; and barrier-dominated landscape with two isolated conformational states with different functions. Sharing concepts with the “new view” of protein folding energy landscapes, we term the three sequence ranges above as the sensing, downhill folding, and functional windows, respectively. We find that these energy landscape patterns are conserved between riboswitch classes, though the order of the windows may vary. In fact, the order of the three windows suggests either kinetic or thermodynamic control of ligand binding. These findings help understand riboswitch structure/function relationships and open new avenues to riboswitch design.

Unraveling the structural complexity in a single-stranded RNA tail: implications for efficient ligand binding in the prequeuosine riboswitch

Single-stranded RNAs (ssRNAs) are ubiquitous RNA elements that serve diverse functional roles. Much of our understanding of ssRNA conformational behavior is limited to structures in which ssRNA directly engages in tertiary interactions or is recognized by proteins. Little is known about the structural and dynamic behavior of free ssRNAs at atomic resolution. Here, we report the collaborative application of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and replica exchange molecular dynamics (REMD) simulations to characterize the 12 nt ssRNA tail derived from the prequeuosine riboswitch. NMR carbon spin relaxation data and residual dipolar coupling measurements reveal a flexible yet stacked core adopting an A-form-like conformation, with the level of order decreasing toward the terminal ends. An A-to-C mutation within the polyadenine tract alters the observed dynamics consistent with the introduction of a dynamic kink. Pre-ordering of the tail may increase the efficacy of ligand binding above that achieved by a random-coil ssRNA. The REMD simulations recapitulate important trends in the NMR data, but suggest more internal motions than inferred from the NMR analysis. Our study unmasks a previously unappreciated level of complexity in ssRNA, which we believe will also serve as an excellent model system for testing and developing computational force fields.

Atomic-scale characterization of conformational changes in the preQ₁ riboswitch aptamer upon ligand binding

Riboswitches are mRNA structural elements that act as intracellular sensors of small-molecule metabolites. By undergoing conformational changes capable of modulating translation or terminating transcription, riboswitches are able to play a role in regulating the concentration of essential metabolites in the cell. Computer-guided fluorescence experiments were carried out to interrogate molecular dynamics and conformational changes in the minimal riboswitch aptamer that binds 7-aminomethyl-7-deazaguanine (preQ₁). Our combined experimental results and computational analysis suggest that the preQ₁ riboswitch apo form is structured but shows no evidence of a ligand-binding pocket. Simulations of the apo and bound forms indicate a large conformational change is triggered by the breaking of the Watson-Crick base pairing of nucleotides G11 and C31 upon preQ₁ removal, followed by collapse of the pocket due to interfering π-stacking. Computational predictions of local aptamer dynamics were validated by fluorescence experiments employing 2-aminopurine substitutions. In-line probing reactions confirmed that fluorophore-labeled riboswitches retain similar higher-order structural features as the unlabeled aptamer upon ligand binding, although their affinity for the ligand is reduced by the introduction of the fluorescent reporter.

Topological constraints: using RNA secondary structure to model 3D conformation, folding pathways, and dynamic adaptation

Accompanying recent advances in determining RNA secondary structure is the growing appreciation for the importance of relatively simple topological constraints, encoded at the secondary structure level, in defining the overall architecture, folding pathways, and dynamic adaptability of RNA. A new view is emerging in which tertiary interactions do not define RNA 3D structure, but rather, help select specific conformers from an already narrow, topologically pre-defined conformational distribution. Studies are providing fundamental insights into the nature of these topological constraints, how they are encoded by the RNA secondary structure, and how they interplay with other interactions, breathing new meaning to RNA secondary structure. New approaches have been developed that take advantage of topological constraints in determining RNA backbone conformation based on secondary structure, and a limited set of other, easily accessible constraints. Topological constraints are also providing a much-needed framework for rationalizing and describing RNA dynamics and structural adaptation. Finally, studies suggest that topological constraints may play important roles in steering RNA folding pathways. Here, we review recent advances in our understanding of topological constraints encoded by the RNA secondary structure.