Evidence that the (6-4) photolyase mechanism can proceed through an oxetane intermediate

Regiochemical memory in the adiabatic photolysis of thymine-derived oxetanes. A combined ultrafast spectroscopic and CASSCF/CASPT2 computational study

The photoinduced cycloreversion of oxetanes has been thoroughly investigated in connection with the photorepair of the well-known DNA (6-4) photoproducts. In the present work, the direct photolysis of the two regioisomers arising from the irradiation of benzophenone (BP) and 1,3-dimethylthymine (DMT), namely the head-to-head (HH-1) and head-to-tail (HT-1) oxetane adducts, has been investigated by combining ultrafast spectroscopy and theoretical multiconfigurational quantum chemistry analysis. Both the experimental and computational results agree with the involvement of an excited triplet exciplex 3[BPDMT]* for the photoinduced oxetane cleavage to generate 3BP* and DMT through an adiabatic photochemical reaction. The experimental signature of 3[BPDMT]* is the appearance of an absorption band at ca. 400 nm, detected by femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopy. Its formation is markedly regioselective, as it is more efficient and proceeds faster for HH-1 (∼2.8 ps) than for HT-1 (∼6.3 ps). This is in line with the theoretical analysis, which predicts an energy barrier to reach the triplet exciplex for HT-1, in contrast with a less hindered profile for HH-1. Finally, the more favorable adiabatic cycloreversion of HH-1 compared to that of HT-1 is explained by its lower probability to reach the intersystem crossing with the ground state, which would induce a radiationless deactivation process leading either to a starting adduct or to a dissociated BP and DMT.

Insights into Light-driven DNA Repair by Photolyases: Challenges and Opportunities for Electronic Structure Theory

Ultraviolet radiation causes two of the most abundant mutagenic and cytotoxic DNA lesions: cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers and 6-4 photoproducts. (6-4) Photolyases are light-activated enzymes that selectively bind to DNA and trigger repair of mutagenic 6-4 photoproducts via photoinduced electron transfer from flavin adenine dinucleotide anion (FADH^- ) to the lesion triggering repair. This review provides an overview of the sequential steps of the repair process, that is light absorption and resonance energy transfer, photoinduced electron transfer and electron-induced splitting mechanisms, with an emphasis on the role of theory and computation. In addition, theoretical calculations and physical properties that can be used to classify specific mechanism are discussed in an effort to trace the fundamental aspects of each individual step and assist the interpretation of experimental data. The current challenges and suggested future directions are outlined for each step, concluding with a view on the future.

Characterization of the Intermediate in and Identification of the Repair Mechanism of (6-4) Photolesions by Photolyases

Quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics calculations are employed to assign previously recorded experimental spectroscopic signatures of the intermediates occurring during the photo-induced repair of (6-4) photolesions by photolyases to specific molecular structures. Based on this close comparison of experiment and theory it is demonstrated that the acting repair mechanism involves proton transfer from the protonated His365 to the N3' nitrogen of the lesion, which proceeds simultaneously with intramolecular OH transfer along an oxetane-like transition state.

A quantum chemical perspective on (6-4) photolesion repair by photolyases

(6-4)-Photolyases are fascinating enzymes which repair (6-4)-DNA photolesions utilizing light themselves. It is well known that upon initial photo-excitation of an antenna pigment an electron is transferred from an adjacent FADH(-) cofactor to the photolesion initiating repair, i.e. restoration of the original undamaged DNA bases. Concerning the molecular details of this amazing repair mechanism, the early steps of energy transfer and catalytic electron generation are well understood, the terminal repair mechanism, however, is still a matter of ongoing debate. In this perspective article, recent results of quantum chemical investigations are presented, and their meaning for the repair mechanism under natural conditions is outlined. Consequences of natural light conditions, temperature and thermal equilibration are highlighted when issues like the initial protonation state of the relevant histidines and the lesion, or the direction of electron transfer are discussed.

Hetero-cycloreversions mediated by photoinduced electron transfer

Discovered more than eight decades ago, the Diels-Alder (DA) cycloaddition (CA) remains one of the most versatile tools in synthetic organic chemistry. Hetero-DA processes are powerful methods for the synthesis of densely functionalized six-membered heterocycles, ubiquitous substructures found in natural products and bioactive compounds. These reactions frequently employ azadienes and oxadienes, but only a few groups have reported DA processes with thiadienes. The electron transfer (ET) version of the DA reaction, though less investigated, has emerged as a subject of increasing interest. In the last two decades, researchers have paid closer attention to radical ionic hetero-cycloreversions, mainly in connection with their possible involvement in the repair of pyrimidine(6-4)pyrimidone photolesions in DNA by photolyases. In biological systems, these reactions likely occur through a reductive photosensitization mechanism. In addition, photooxidation can lead to cycloreversion (CR) reactions, and researchers can exploit this strategy for DNA repair therapies. In this Account, we discuss electron-transfer (ET) mediated hetero-CR reactions. We focus on the oxidative and reductive ET splitting of oxetanes, azetidines, and thietanes. Photoinduced electron transfer facilitates the splitting of a variety of four-membered heterocycles. In this context, researchers have commonly examined oxetanes, both experimentally and theoretically. Although a few studies have reported the cycloreversion of azetidines and thietanes carried out under electron transfer conditions, the number of examples remains limited. In general, the cleavage of the ionized four-membered rings appears to occur via a nonconcerted two-step mechanism. The trapping of the intermediate 1,4-radical ions and transient absorption spectroscopy data support this hypothesis, and it explains the observed loss of stereochemistry in the products. In the initial step, either C-C or C-X bond breaking may occur, and the preferred route depends on the substitution pattern of the ring, the type of heteroatom, and various experimental conditions. To better accommodate spin and charge, C-X cleavage happens more frequently, especially in the radical anionic version of the reaction. The addition or withdrawal of a single electron provides a new complementary synthetic strategy to activate hetero-cycloreversions. Despite its potential, this strategy remains largely unexplored. However, it offers a useful method to achieve C═X/olefin metathesis or, upon ring expansion, to construct six-membered heterocyclic rings.

Combined QM/MM investigation on the light-driven electron-induced repair of the (6-4) thymine dimer catalyzed by DNA photolyase

The (6-4) photolyases are blue-light-activated enzymes that selectively bind to DNA and initiate splitting of mutagenic thymine (6-4) thymine photoproducts (T(6-4)T-PP) via photoinduced electron transfer from flavin adenine dinucleotide anion (FADH(-)) to the lesion triggering repair. In the present work, the repair mechanism after the initial electron transfer and the effect of the protein/DNA environment are investigated theoretically by means of hybrid quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) simulations using X-ray structure of the enzyme-DNA complex. By comparison of three previously proposed repair mechanisms, we found that the lowest activation free energy is required for the pathway in which the key step governing the repair photocycle is electron transfer coupled with the proton transfer from the protonated histidine, His365, to the N3' nitrogen of the pyrimidone thymine. The transfer simultaneously occurs with concerted intramolecular OH transfer without formation of an oxetane or isolated water molecule intermediate. In contrast to previously suggested mechanisms, this newly identified pathway requires neither a subsequent two-photon process nor electronic excitation of the photolesion.

DNA photolyases and SP lyase: structure and mechanism of light-dependent and independent DNA lyases

Light is essential for many critical biological processes including vision, circadian rhythms, photosynthesis and DNA repair. DNA photolyases use light energy and a fully reduced flavin cofactor to repair the major UV-induced DNA damages, the cis-syn cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPDs) and the pyrimidine-pyrimidone (6-4) photoproducts. Catalysis involves two photoreactions, the photoactivation which leads to the conversion of the flavin cofactor to its catalytic active form and the photorepair whose efficiency depends on a light-harvesting antenna chromophore. Very interestingly, an alternative and light-independent direct reversal mechanism to repair a distinct photolesion is found in bacterial spores, catalyzed by spore photoproduct lyase. This radical SAM enzyme uses an iron-sulfur cluster and S-adenosyl-l-methionine (SAM) to split a specific photoproduct, the so-called spore photoproduct (SP), back to two thymidine residues. The recently solved crystal structure of SP lyase provides new insights into this unique DNA repair mechanism and allows a detailed comparison with DNA photolyases. Similarities as well as divergences between DNA photolyases and SP lyase are highlighted in this review.

The Protonation States of the Active-Site Histidines in (6-4) Photolyase

The active sites of the (6-4) photolyases contain two conserved histidine residues, which, in the Drosophila melanogaster enzyme, correspond to His365 and His369. While there are nine combinations in which the three possible protonation states of the two histidines (with protons on Nδ (HID), Nε (HIE), or both Nδ and Nε (HIP)) can be paired, there is presently no consensus as to which of these states is present, let alone mechanistically relevant. EPR hyperfine couplings for selected protons of the FADH(•) radical have previously been used to address this issue. Our QM/MM calculations show, however, that the experimental couplings are equally well reproduced by each of the nine combinations. Since the EPR results seemingly cannot be used to unequivocally assign the protonation states, the pKa values of the two histidines were calculated using the popular PROPKA, H++, and APBS approaches, in various environments and for several lesions. These techniques consistently indicate that, at pH = 7, both His365 and His369 should be neutral, although His369 is found to be more prone to becoming protonated. In a comparative approach, a series of molecular dynamics simulations was performed with all nine combinations, employing various reference crystal structures and different oxidation states of the FAD cofactor. The overall result of this approach is in agreement with our pKa results. Consequently, although the introduction of the reduced cofactor results in an increased stability for selected protonated states, particularly the His365═HID and His369═HIP combination, the neutral combination His365═HID and His365═HIE stands out as the most relevant state for the activity of the enzyme.

Repair of DNA Dewar photoproduct to (6-4) photoproduct in (6-4) photolyase

Dewar photoproduct (Dewar PP) is the valence isomer of (6-4) photoproduct ((6-4)PP) in photodamaged DNA. Compared to the extensive studied CPD photoproducts, the underlying repair mechanisms for the (6-4)PP, and especially for the Dewar PP, are not well-established to date. In this paper, the repair mechanism of DNA Dewar photoproduct T(dew)C in (6-4) photolyase was elucidated using hybrid density functional theory. Our results showed that, during the repair process, the T(dew)C has to isomerize to T(6-4)C photolesion first via direct C6'-N3' bond cleavage facilitated by electron injection. This isomerization mechanism is energetically much more efficient than other possible rearrangement pathways. The calculations provide a theoretical interpretation to recent experimental observations.

Photosensitized splitting of thymine dimer or oxetane unit by a covalently N-linked carbazole via electron transfer in different marcus regions

Although many similarities exist between the two classes of enzymes, cyclobutane photolyases and (6-4) photolyases have certain important differences. The most significant difference is in their repair quantum yields, cyclobutane photolyases with a uniformly high efficiency (0.7-0.98) and very low repair efficiency for (6-4) photolyases (0.05-0.1). To understand the significant difference, we prepared two classes of model compounds, covalently N-linked dimer- (1) or oxetane-carbazole (2) compounds with a dimethylene or trimethylene group as a linker. Under light irradiation, the dimer or oxetane unit of model compounds can be sensitized to split by the excited carbazole via an intramolecular electron transfer. The splitting reaction of dimer or oxetane unit in model compounds is strongly solvent dependent. In nonpolar solvents, such as cyclohexane or THF, no fluorescence quenching of the carbazole moiety of model compounds relative to a free carbazole, N-methylcarbazole, was observed and thus no splitting occurred. In polar solvents, two classes of model compounds reveal two reverse solvent effects on the splitting quantum yield. One is an inverse relation between the quantum yield and the polarity of the solvent for dimer-model systems, and another is a normal relation for oxetane-model systems. This phenomenon was also observed with another two classes of model compounds, covalently linked dimer- or oxetane-indole. Based on Marcus theory and thermodynamic data, it has been rationalized that the two reverse solvent effects derive from back electron transfer in the splitting process lying in the different Marcus regions. Back electron transfer lies in the Marcus inverted region for dimer-model systems and the normal region for oxetane-model systems. From repair solvent behavior of the two classes of model compounds, we gained some insights into the major difference in the repair efficiency for the two classes of photolyases.

Theoretical study on the repair mechanism of the (6-4) photolesion by the (6-4) photolyase

UV irradiation of DNA can lead to the formation of mutagenic (6-4) pyrimidine-pyrimidone photolesions. The (6-4) photolyases are the enzymes responsible for the photoinduced repair of such lesions. On the basis of the recently published crystal structure of the (6-4) photolyase bound to DNA [Maul et al. 2008] and employing quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics techniques, a repair mechanism is proposed, which involves two photoexcitations. The flavin chromophore, initially being in its reduced anionic form, is photoexcited and donates an electron to the (6-4) form of the photolesion. The photolesion is then protonated by the neighboring histidine residue and forms a radical intermediate. The latter undergoes a series of energy stabilizing hydrogen-bonding rearrangements before the electron back transfer to the flavin semiquinone. The resulting structure corresponds to the oxetane intermediate, long thought to be formed upon DNA-enzyme binding. A second photoexcitation of the flavin promotes another electron transfer to the oxetane. Proton donation from the same histidine residue allows for the splitting of the four-membered ring, hence opening an efficient pathway to the final repaired form. The repair of the lesion by a single photoexcitation was shown not to be feasible.

Reaction mechanisms of DNA photolyase

DNA photolyase uses visible light and a fully reduced flavin cofactor FADH(-) to repair major UV-induced lesions in DNA, the cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPDs). Electron transfer from photoexcited FADH(-) to CPD, splitting of the two intradimer bonds, and back electron transfer to the transiently formed flavin radical FADH° occur in overall 1ns. Whereas the kinetics of FADH° was resolved, the DNA-based intermediates escaped unambiguous detection yet. Another light reaction, named photoactivation, reduces catalytically inactive FADH° to FADH(-) without implication of DNA. It involves electron hopping along a chain of three tryptophan residues in 30ps, as elucidated in detail by transient absorption spectroscopy. The same triple tryptophan chain is found in cryptochrome blue-light photoreceptors and may be involved in their primary photoreaction.

Electronic structure of (6-4) DNA photoproduct repair involving a non-oxetane pathway

Mutagenic pyrimidine-pyrimidone (6-4) photoproducts are one of the main DNA lesions induced by solar UV radiation. These lesions can be photoreversed by (6-4) photolyases. The originally published repair mechanism involves rearrangement of the lesion into an oxetane intermediate upon binding to the (6-4) photolyase, followed by light-induced electron transfer from the reduced flavin cofactor. In a recent crystallographic study on a (6-4) photoproduct complexed with (6-4) photolyase from Drosophila melanogaster no oxetane was observed, raising the possibility of a non-oxetane repair mechanism. Using quantum-chemical calculations we find that in addition to repair via an oxetane, a direct transfer of the hydroxyl group results in reversal of the radical anion (6-4) photoproduct. In both mechanisms, the transition states have high energies and correspond to avoided crossings of the ground and excited electronic states. To study whether the repair can proceed via these state crossings, the excited-state potential energy curves were computed. The radical excitation energies and accessibility of the nonadiabatic repair path were found to depend on hydrogen bonds and the protonation state of the lesion. On the basis of the energy calculations, a nonadiabatic repair of the excited (6-4) lesion radical anion via hydroxyl transfer is probable. This repair mechanism is in line with the recent structural data on the (6-4) photolyase from D. melanogaster .

Role of the carbonyl group of the (6-4) photoproduct in the (6-4) photolyase reaction

The (6-4) photoproduct, which is one of the major UV-induced DNA lesions, causes carcinogenesis with high frequency. The (6-4) photolyase is a flavoprotein that can restore this lesion to the original bases, but its repair mechanism has not been elucidated. In this study, we focused on the interaction between the enzyme and the 3' pyrimidone component of the (6-4) photoproduct and prepared a substrate analogue in which the carbonyl group, a hydrogen-bond acceptor, was replaced with an imine, a hydrogen-bond donor, to investigate the involvement of this carbonyl group in the (6-4) photolyase reaction. UV irradiation of oligodeoxyribonucleotides containing a single thymine-5-methylisocytosine site yielded products with absorption bands at wavelengths longer than 300 nm, similar to those obtained from the conversion of the TT site to the (6-4) photoproduct. Nuclease digestion, MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry, and the instability of the products indicated the formation of the 2-iminopyrimidine-type photoproduct. Analyses of the reaction and the binding of the (6-4) photolyase using these oligonucleotides revealed that this imine analogue of the (6-4) photoproduct was not repaired by the (6-4) photolyase, although the enzyme bound to the oligonucleotide with considerable affinity. These results indicate that the carbonyl group of the 3' pyrimidone ring plays an important role in the (6-4) photolyase reaction. On the basis of these results, we discuss the repair mechanism.