Interplay of structure, hydration and thermal stability in formacetal modified oligonucleotides: RNA may tolerate nonionic modifications better than DNA

Properties and synergistic effects of a nonionic backbone and aminoalkyl modified nucleosides in RNAs

In this study, we report the synthesis of two formacetal (FA)-linked dimer building blocks, namely 2'-O-methyluridyl-2'-O-methyluridine and 2'-O-methyluridyl-2'-O-aminoethyluridine. We utilize the former dimer in combination with (S)-5'-C-aminopropyl-2'-O-methylnucleosides (5'-APs) as a neutral trimer unit, and the latter dimer as a cationic unit. Double-stranded RNA containing the neutral trimer unit exhibits greater stability compared to the cationic unit and maintains nuclease stability in a serum-containing buffer. Furthermore, this unit appears to establish additional hydrogen bonds with complementary bases, as supported by modeling simulations and mismatch melting temperature assays. Importantly, siRNAs modified with this unit enhance RNA interference activity in cultured cells. These findings suggest that the trimer unit holds promise for therapeutic siRNAs.

Synthesis and Properties of RNA Modified with Cationic Amine Internucleoside Linkage

Chemical modifications of RNA are important tools for the development of RNA therapeutics. The present study reports a novel RNA backbone modification that replaces the negatively charged phosphate with a positively charged amine linkage. Despite being thermally destabilizing in RNA duplexes, the amine linkage caused a relatively modest decrease of activity of a modified short interfering RNA (siRNA). At position 2 of the guide strand, the amine modification strongly enhanced the specificity of siRNA while causing an ∼5-fold drop of on-target activity. These results support the future development of amines as cationic RNA modifications and novel tools to modulate protein-RNA interactions.

Conformational Morphing by a DNA Analogue Featuring 7-Deazapurines and 5-Halogenpyrimidines and the Origins of Adenine-Tract Geometry

Several efforts are currently directed at the creation and cellular implementation of alternative genetic systems composed of pairing components that are orthogonal to the natural dA/dT and dG/dC base pairs. In an alternative approach, Watson-Crick-type pairing is conserved, but one or all of the four letters of the A, C, G, and T alphabet are substituted by modified components. Thus, all four nucleobases were altered to create halogenated deazanucleic acid (DZA): dA was replaced by 7-deaza-2'-deoxyadenosine (dzA), dG by 7-deaza-2'-deoxyguanosine (dzG), dC by 5-fluoro-2'-deoxycytidine (FdC), and dT by 5-chloro-2'-deoxyuridine (CldU). This base-pairing system was previously shown to retain function in Escherichia coli. Here, we analyze the stability, hydration, structure, and dynamics of a DZA Dickerson-Drew Dodecamer (DDD) of sequence 5'-FdC-dzG-FdC-dzG-dzA-dzA-CldU-CldU-FdC-dzG-FdC-dzG-3'. Contrary to similar stabilities of DDD and DZA-DDD, osmotic stressing revealed a dramatic loss of hydration for the DZA-DDD relative to that for the DDD. The parent DDD 5'-d(CGCGAATTCGCG)-3' features an A-tract, a run of adenosines uninterrupted by a TpA step, and exhibits a hallmark narrow minor groove. Crystal structures─in the presence of RNase H─and MD simulations show increased conformational plasticity ("morphing") of DZA-DDD relative to that of the DDD. The narrow dzA-tract minor groove in one structure widens to resemble that in canonical B-DNA in a second structure. These changes reflect an indirect consequence of altered DZA major groove electrostatics (less negatively polarized compared to that in DNA) and hydration (reduced compared to that in DNA). Therefore, chemical modifications outside the minor groove that lead to collapse of major groove electrostatics and hydration can modulate A-tract geometry.

Replacement of the phosphodiester backbone between canonical nucleosides with a dirhenium carbonyl "click" linker-a new class of luminescent organometallic dinucleoside phosphate mimics

The first-in-class luminescent dinucleoside phosphate analogs with a [Re₂(μ-Cl)₂(CO)₆(μ-pyridazine)] "click" linker as a replacement for the natural phosphate group are reported together with the synthesis of luminescent adenosine and thymidine derivatives having the [Re₂(μ-Cl)₂(CO)₆(μ-pyridazine)] entity attached to positions 5' and 3', respectively. These compounds were synthesized by applying inverse-electron-demand Diels-Alder and copper(I)-catalyzed azide-alkyne 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition reactions in three or four steps. The obtained compounds exhibited orange emission (λ_PL ≈ 600 nm, Φ_PL ≈ 0.10, and τ = 0.33-0.61 μs) and no toxicity (except for one nucleoside) to human HeLa cervical epithelioid and Ishikawa endometrial adenocarcinoma cancer cells in vitro. Furthermore, the compounds' ability to inhibit the growth of Gram-positive Staphylococcus aureus and Gram-negative Escherichia coli bacterial strains was moderate and only observed at a high concentration of 100 μM. Confocal microscopy imaging revealed that the "dirhenium carbonyl" dinucleosides and nucleosides localized mainly in the membranous structures of HeLa cells and uniformly inside S. aureus and E. coli bacterial cells. An interesting finding was that some of the tested compounds were also found in the nuclei of HeLa cells.

Amide-Modified RNA: Using Protein Backbone to Modulate Function of Short Interfering RNAs

RNA-based technologies to control gene expression, such as RNA interference (RNAi) and CRISPR-Cas9, have become powerful tools in molecular biology and genomics. The exciting potential that RNAi and CRISPR-Cas9 may also become new therapeutic approaches has reinvigorated interest in chemically modifying RNA to improve its properties for in vivo applications. Chemical modifications can improve enzymatic stability, in vivo delivery, cellular uptake, and sequence specificity as well as minimize off-target activity of short interfering RNAs (siRNAs) and CRISPR associated RNAs. While numerous good solutions for improving stability toward enzymatic degradation have emerged, optimization of the latter functional properties remains challenging. In this Account, we discuss synthesis, structure, and biological activity of novel nonionic analogues of RNA that have the phosphodiester backbone replaced by amide linkages (AM1). Our long-term goal is to use the amide backbone to improve the stability and specificity of siRNAs and other functional RNAs. Our work in this area was motivated by early discoveries that nonionic backbone modifications, including AM1, did not disturb the overall structure or thermal stability of RNA duplexes. We hypothesized that the reduced negative charge and hydrophobic nature of the AM1 backbone modification might be useful in optimizing functional applications through enhanced cellular uptake, and might suppress unwanted off-target effects of siRNAs. NMR and X-ray crystallography studies showed that AM1 was an excellent mimic of phosphodiester linkages in RNA. The local conformational changes caused by the amide linkages were easily accommodated by small adjustments in RNA's conformation. Further, the amide carbonyl group assumed an orientation that is similar to one of the nonbridging P-O bonds, which may enable amide/phosphate mimicry by conserving hydrogen bonding interactions. The crystal structure of a short amide-modified DNA-RNA hybrid in complex with RNase H indicated that the amide N-H could also act as an H-bond donor to stabilize RNA-protein interactions, which is an interaction mode not available to phosphate groups. Functional assays established that amides were well tolerated at internal positions in both strands of siRNAs. Surprisingly, amide modifications in the middle of the guide strand and at the 5'-end of the passenger strand increased RNAi activity compared to unmodified siRNA. Most importantly, an amide linkage between the first and second nucleosides of the passenger strand completely abolished its undesired off-target activity while enhancing the desired RNAi activity. These results suggest that RNAi may tolerate more substantial modifications of siRNAs than the chemistries tried so far. The findings are also important and timely because they demonstrate that amide modifications may reduce off-target activity of siRNAs, which remains an important roadblock for clinical use of RNAi. Taken together, our work suggests that amide linkages have underappreciated potential to optimize the biological and pharmacological properties of RNA. Expanded use of amide linkages in RNA to enhance CRISPR and other technologies requiring chemically stable, functional mimics of noncoding RNAs is expected.

Structural Basis of Duplex Thermodynamic Stability and Enhanced Nuclease Resistance of 5'-C-Methyl Pyrimidine-Modified Oligonucleotides

Although judicious use of chemical modifications has contributed to the success of nucleic acid therapeutics, poor systemic stability remains a major hurdle. The introduction of functional groups around the phosphate backbone can enhance the nuclease resistance of oligonucleotides (ONs). Here, we report the synthesis of enantiomerically pure (R)- and (S)-5'-C-methyl (C5'-Me) substituted nucleosides and their incorporation into ONs. These modifications generally resulted in a decrease in thermal stability of oligonucleotide (ON) duplexes in a manner dependent on the stereoconfiguration at C5' with greater destabilization characteristic of (R)-epimers. Enhanced stability against snake venom phosphodiesterase resulted from modification of the 3'-end of an ON with either (R)- or (S)-C5'-Me nucleotides. The (S)-isomers with different 2'-substituents provided greater resistance against 3'-exonucleases than the corresponding (R)-isomers. Crystal structure analyses of RNA octamers with (R)- or (S)-5'-C-methyl-2'-deoxy-2'-fluorouridine [(R)- or (S)-C5'-Me-2'-FU, respectively] revealed that the stereochemical orientation of the C5'-Me and the steric effects that emanate from the alkyl substitution are the dominant determinants of thermal stability and are likely molecular origins of resistance against nucleases. X-ray and NMR structural analyses showed that the (S)-C5'-Me epimers are spatially and structurally more similar to their natural 5' nonmethylated counterparts than the corresponding (R)-epimers.

Hydration changes upon DNA folding studied by osmotic stress experiments

The thermal stability of nucleic acid structures is perturbed under the conditions that mimic the intracellular environment, typically rich in inert components and under osmotic stress. We now describe the thermodynamic stability of DNA oligonucleotide structures in the presence of high background concentrations of neutral cosolutes. Small cosolutes destabilize the basepair structures, and the DNA structures consisting of the same nearest-neighbor composition show similar thermodynamic parameters in the presence of various types of cosolutes. The osmotic stress experiments reveal that water binding to flexible loops, unstable mismatches, and an abasic site upon DNA folding are almost negligible, whereas the binding to stable mismatch pairs is significant. The studies using the basepair-mimic nucleosides and the peptide nucleic acid suggest that the sugar-phosphate backbone and the integrity of the basepair conformation make important contributions to the binding of water molecules to the DNA bases and helical grooves. The study of the DNA hydration provides the basis for understanding and predicting nucleic acid structures in nonaqueous solvent systems.

Antisense drug discovery and development

Numerous chemically modified oligonucleotides have been developed so far and show their own unique chemical properties and pharmacodynamic/pharmacokinetic characteristics. Among all non-natural nucleotides, to the best of our knowledge, only five chemistries are currently being tested in clinical trials: phosphorothioate, 2´-O-methyl RNA, 2´-O-methoxyethyl RNA, 2´,4´-bridged nucleic acid/locked nucleic acid and the phosphorodiamidate morpholino oligomer. Since phosphorothioate modification can improve the pharmacokinetics of oligonucleotides, this modification is currently used in combination with all other modifications except phosphorodiamidate morpholino oligomer. For the treatment of metabolic, cardiovascular, cancer and other systemic diseases, the phosphorothioate class of drugs is obviously helpful, while superior efficacies can be observed in phosphorodiamidate morpholino oligomer compared to other classes of oligonucleotides for the treatment of Duchenne muscular dystrophy. Which properties of antisense molecules are actually essential for clinical applications? In this article, we provide an overview of the medicinal chemistry of existing non-natural antisense molecules, as well as their clinical applications, to discuss which properties of antisense oligonuculeotides affect therapeutic potency.

Synthesis and properties of triazole-linked RNA

RNA oligonucleotides having triazole linkages between uridine and adenosine nucleosides have been prepared and studied using spectroscopic techniques. UV melting and CD showed that triazole strongly destabilized RNA duplex (7-14°C per modification). NMR data suggested that, despite relative flexibility around the modified linkage, all base pairs were formed.

Unexpected origins of the enhanced pairing affinity of 2'-fluoro-modified RNA

Various chemical modifications are currently being evaluated for improving the efficacy of short interfering RNA (siRNA) duplexes as antisense agents for gene silencing in vivo. Among the 2'-ribose modifications assessed to date, 2'deoxy-2'-fluoro-RNA (2'-F-RNA) has unique properties for RNA interference (RNAi) applications. Thus, 2'-F-modified nucleotides are well tolerated in the guide (antisense) and passenger (sense) siRNA strands and the corresponding duplexes lack immunostimulatory effects, enhance nuclease resistance and display improved efficacy in vitro and in vivo compared with unmodified siRNAs. To identify potential origins of the distinct behaviors of RNA and 2'-F-RNA we carried out thermodynamic and X-ray crystallographic analyses of fully and partially 2'-F-modified RNAs. Surprisingly, we found that the increased pairing affinity of 2'-F-RNA relative to RNA is not, as commonly assumed, the result of a favorable entropic contribution ('conformational preorganization'), but instead primarily based on enthalpy. Crystal structures at high resolution and osmotic stress demonstrate that the 2'-F-RNA duplex is less hydrated than the RNA duplex. The enthalpy-driven, higher stability of the former hints at the possibility that the 2'-substituent, in addition to its important function in sculpting RNA conformation, plays an underappreciated role in modulating Watson-Crick base pairing strength and potentially π-π stacking interactions.

Primitive genetic polymers

Since the structure of DNA was elucidated more than 50 years ago, Watson-Crick base pairing has been widely speculated to be the likely mode of both information storage and transfer in the earliest genetic polymers. The discovery of catalytic RNA molecules subsequently provided support for the hypothesis that RNA was perhaps even the first polymer of life. However, the de novo synthesis of RNA using only plausible prebiotic chemistry has proven difficult, to say the least. Experimental investigations, made possible by the application of synthetic and physical organic chemistry, have now provided evidence that the nucleobases (A, G, C, and T/U), the trifunctional moiety ([deoxy]ribose), and the linkage chemistry (phosphate esters) of contemporary nucleic acids may be optimally suited for their present roles-a situation that suggests refinement by evolution. Here, we consider studies of variations in these three distinct components of nucleic acids with regard to the question: Is RNA, as is generally acknowledged of DNA, the product of evolution? If so, what chemical and structural features might have been more likely and advantageous for a proto-RNA?

Determination of nucleic acid hydration using osmotic stress

Water plays an important role in structure and molecular recognition of biopolymers. Understanding hydration of biopolymers is a significant problem in structural chemistry and biology. However, hydration is a dynamic process that is difficult to study. While X-ray crystallography, NMR, and molecular modeling have provided structural detail on nucleic acid hydration and valuable insights into water dynamics, the thermodynamic contribution of water molecules to conformational equilibria and recognition of nucleic acids remains poorly understood. This unit describes a thermodynamic analysis of nucleic acid hydration using osmotic stress. Osmotic stress monitors the depression of melting temperature upon decreasing water activity, and calculates the number of thermodynamically unique water molecules associated with the double helix and released from single strands upon melting. Comparison of the number of water molecules released upon melting of nucleic acids with different sequences and chemical modifications provides insights that complement and enhance information obtained by other methods.

Monomers for preparation of amide linked RNA: Synthesis of C3'-homologated nucleoside amino acids from d-xylose

Amides as neutral and hydrophobic internucleoside linkages in RNA are highly interesting modifications for RNA interference. However, testing amides in siRNAs is hampered by the shortage of efficient methods to synthesize the monomeric building blocks, the nucleoside amino acid equivalents. This paper reports an efficient synthesis of protected ribonucleoside 5'-amino 3'-carboxylic acids from d-xylose in 14 steps 7% overall yield. The key features that ensure efficiency and ease of operations are chemoselective reduction of the ester and minimization of protecting group manipulation.

The many twists and turns of DNA: template, telomere, tool, and target

If any proof were needed of DNA's versatile roles and use, it is certainly provided by the numerous depositions of new three-dimensional (3D) structures to the coordinate databanks (PDB, NDB) over the last two years. Quadruplex motifs involving G-repeats, adducted sequences and oligo-2'-deoxynucleotides (ODNs) with bound ligands are particularly well represented. In addition, structures of chemically modified DNAs (CNAs) and artificial analogs are yielding insight into stability, pairing properties, and dynamics, including those of the native nucleic acids. Besides being of significance for establishing diagnostic tools and in the analysis of protein-DNA interactions, chemical modification in conjunction with investigations of the structural consequences may yield novel nucleic acid-based therapeutics. DNA's predictable and highly specific pairing behavior makes it the material of choice for constructing 3D-nanostructures of defined architecture. Recently the first examples of DNA nanoparticle and self-assembled 3D-crystals were reported. Although the structures discussed in this review are all based either on X-ray crystallography or solution NMR, small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), and cryoEM are proving to be useful approaches for the characterization of nanoscale DNA architecture.

Differential stability of 2'F-ANA*RNA and ANA*RNA hybrid duplexes: roles of structure, pseudohydrogen bonding, hydration, ion uptake and flexibility

Hybrids of RNA with arabinonucleic acids 2′F-ANA and ANA have very similar structures but strikingly different thermal stabilities. We now present a thorough study combining NMR and other biophysical methods together with state-of-the-art theoretical calculations on a fully modified 10-mer hybrid duplex. Comparison between the solution structure of 2′F-ANA•RNA and ANA•RNA hybrids indicates that the increased binding affinity of 2′F-ANA is related to several subtle differences, most importantly a favorable pseudohydrogen bond (2′F–purine H8) which contrasts with unfavorable 2′-OH–nucleobase steric interactions in the case of ANA. While both 2′F-ANA and ANA strands maintained conformations in the southern/eastern sugar pucker range, the 2′F-ANA strand’s structure was more compatible with the A-like structure of a hybrid duplex. No dramatic differences are found in terms of relative hydration for the two hybrids, but the ANA•RNA duplex showed lower uptake of counterions than its 2′F-ANA•RNA counterpart. Finally, while the two hybrid duplexes are of similar rigidities, 2′F-ANA single strands may be more suitably preorganized for duplex formation. Thus the dramatically increased stability of 2′F-ANA•RNA and ANA•RNA duplexes is caused by differences in at least four areas, of which structure and pseudohydrogen bonding are the most important.