Reversible Formation of Alkyl Radicals at [Fe4S4] Clusters and Its Implications for Selectivity in Radical SAM Enzymes

Coordination-induced reductive elimination from a titanium(IV) complex

Diamidopyridine-supported titanium dibenzyl complexes undergo coordination-induced C-C reductive elimination upon addition of alkynes and quantitative formation of titanacyclopentadienes. The distinct radical mechanism of this reductive mechanism gives new insights into C-C bond formation with titanium.

Dinitrogen activation at chromium by photochemically induced CrII-C bond homolysis

The synthesis of the organochromium(II) complexes [POCOPtBu]Cr(R) (R = p-Tol, Bn) is reported. Exposure of [POCOPtBu]Cr(Bn) to visible light promoted homolytic Cr-CBn bond cleavage and formed {[POCOPtBu]Cr}2(η1:η1μ-N2) via a putative [POCOPtBu]Cr(I) species.

Highly Activated Terminal Carbon Monoxide Ligand in an Iron-Sulfur Cluster Model of FeMco with Intermediate Local Spin State at Fe

Nitrogenases, the enzymes that convert N2 to NH3, also catalyze the reductive coupling of CO to yield hydrocarbons. CO-coordinated species of nitrogenase clusters have been isolated and used to infer mechanistic information. However, synthetic FeS clusters displaying CO ligands remain rare, which limits benchmarking. Starting from a synthetic cluster that models a cubane portion of the FeMo cofactor (FeMoco), including a bridging carbyne ligand, we report a heterometallic tungsten-iron-sulfur cluster with a single terminal CO coordination in two oxidation states with a high level of CO activation (νCO = 1851 and 1751 cm-1). The local Fe coordination environment (2S, 1C, 1CO) is identical to that in the protein making this system a suitable benchmark. Computational studies find an unusual intermediate spin electronic configuration at the Fe sites promoted by the presence the carbyne ligand. This electronic feature is partly responsible for the high degree of CO activation in the reduced cluster.

Coordination-Induced Radical Generation: Selective Hydrogen Atom Abstraction via Controlled Ti-C σ-Bond Homolysis

A method for the generation of transient alkyl radicals via homolytic Ti-C bond cleavage was developed by employing a tailor-made organotitanium half-cage complex. In contrast to established metal-mediated radical initiation protocols via thermal or photochemical M-C σ-bond homolysis, radical formation is triggered solely by coordination of a solvent molecule (thf) to a titanium(IV) center. During the reaction, the nonstabilized alkyl radical is formed along with a persistent titanium(III) metalloradical, thus taming the former transient radical (persistent radical effect). Radical coupling and hydrogen atom abstraction (HAT) reactions have been explored not only experimentally but also computationally and by means of kinetic analysis. Exploiting these findings led to the development of selective HAT transformations, for example, with 9,10-dihydroanthracene. Deuterium labeling studies using selectively deuterated alkyls and 9,10-dihydroanthracene-d4 confirmed a radical pathway, which was underpinned by developing a radical-radical cross-coupling reaction for transferring the alkyl radical to a stable Sn-centered radical. To set the stage for an application in organic synthesis, a 5-endo-trig radical cyclization based on our methodology was established, and a dihydroxylated sesquiterpene was thus prepared in high diastereomeric excess.

Unraveling Hydrogen Atom Transfer Mechanisms with Voltammetry: Oxidative Formation and Reactivity of Cobalt Hydride

The utility of transition metal hydride catalyzed hydrogen atom transfer (MHAT) has been widely demonstrated in organic transformations such as alkene isomerization and hydrofunctionalization reactions. However, the highly reactive nature of the hydride and radical intermediates has hindered mechanistic insight into this pivotal reaction. Recent advances in electrochemical MHAT have opened up the possibility for new analytical approaches for mechanistic diagnosis. Here, we report a voltammetric interrogation of Co-based MHAT reactivity, describing in detail the oxidative formation and reactivity of the key Co-H intermediate and its reaction with aryl alkenes. Insights from cyclic voltammetry and finite element simulations help elucidate the rate-limiting step as metal hydride formation, which we show to be widely tunable based on ligand design. Voltammetry is also suggestive of the formation of Co-alkyl intermediates and a dynamic equilibrium with the reactive neutral radical. These mechanistic studies provide information for the design of future hydrofunctionalization reactions, such as catalyst and silane choice, the relative stability of metal-alkyl species, and how hydrofunctionalization reactions utilize Co-alkyl intermediates. In summary, these studies establish an important template for studying MHAT reactions from the perspective of electrochemical kinetic frameworks.

A general method for metallocluster site-differentiation

The deployment of metalloclusters in applications such as catalysis and materials synthesis requires robust methods for site-differentiation: the conversion of clusters with symmetric ligand spheres to those with unsymmetrical ligand spheres. However, imparting precise patterns of site-differentiation is challenging because, compared with mononuclear complexes, the ligands bound to clusters exert limited spatial and electronic influence on one another. Here, we report a method that employs sterically encumbering ligands to bind to only a subset of a cluster's coordination sites. Specifically, we show that homoleptic, phosphine-ligated Fe-S clusters undergo ligand substitution with N-heterocyclic carbenes (NHCs) to give heteroleptic clusters in which the resultant clusters' site-differentiation patterns are encoded by the steric profile of the incoming NHC. This method affords access to every site-differentiation pattern for cuboidal [Fe4S4] clusters and can be extended to other cluster types, particularly in the stereoselective synthesis of site-differentiated Chevrel-type [Fe6S8] clusters.

A Guide to Tris(4-Substituted)-triphenylmethyl Radicals

Triphenylmethyl (trityl, Ph3C•) radicals have been considered the prototypical carbon-centered radical since their discovery in 1900. Tris(4-substituted)-trityls [(4-R-Ph)3C•] have since been used in many ways due to their stability, persistence, and spectroscopic activity. Despite their widespread use, existing synthetic routes toward tris(4-substituted)-trityl radicals are not reproducible and often lead to impure materials. We report here robust syntheses of six electronically varied (4-RPh)3C•, where R = NMe2, OCH3, tBu, Ph, Cl, and CF3. The characterization reported for the radicals and related compounds includes five X-ray crystal structures, electrochemical potentials, and optical spectra. Each radical is best accessed using a stepwise approach from the trityl halide, (RPh)3CCl or (RPh)3CBr, by controllably removing the halide with subsequent 1e- reduction of the trityl cation, (RPh)3C+. These syntheses afford consistently crystalline trityl radicals of high purity for further studies.

Exploiting Molecular Symmetry to Quantitatively Map the Excited-State Landscape of Iron-Sulfur Clusters

Cuboidal [Fe4S4] clusters are ubiquitous cofactors in biological redox chemistry. In the [Fe4S4]1+ state, pairwise spin coupling gives rise to six arrangements of the Fe valences ("valence isomers") among the four Fe centers. Because of the magnetic complexity of these systems, it has been challenging to understand how a protein's active site dictates both the arrangement of the valences in the ground state as well as the population of excited-state valence isomers. Here, we show that the ground-state valence isomer landscape can be simplified from a six-level system in an asymmetric protein environment to a two-level system by studying the problem in synthetic [Fe4S4]1+ clusters with solution C3v symmetry. This simplification allows for the energy differences between valence isomers to be quantified (in some cases with a resolution of <0.1 kcal/mol) by simultaneously fitting the VT NMR and solution magnetic moment data. Using this fitting protocol, we map the excited-state landscape for a range of clusters of the form [(SIMes)3Fe4S4-X/L]n, (SIMes = 1,3-dimesityl-imidazol-4,5-dihydro-2-ylidene; n = 0 for anionic, X-type ligands and n = +1 for neutral, L-type ligands) and find that a single ligand substitution can alter the relative ground-state energies of valence isomers by at least 103 cm-1. On this basis, we suggest that one result of "non-canonical" amino acid ligation in Fe-S proteins is the redistribution of the valence electrons in the manifold of thermally populated excited states.

Valence Localization in Alkyne and Alkene Adducts of Synthetic [Fe4S4]+ Clusters

Reported herein are alkyne and alkene adducts of synthetic [Fe₄S₄]⁺ clusters that model intermediates and inhibitor-bound states in enzymes involved in isoprenoid biosynthesis. Treatment of the N-heterocyclic carbene-ligated cluster [(IMes)₃Fe₄S₄(OEt₂)][BAr^F₄] (IMes = 1,3-dimesitylimidazol-2-ylidene; [BAr^F₄]^- = tetrakis(3,5-bis(trifluoromethyl)phenyl)borate) with phenylacetylene (PhCCH) or cis-cyclooctene (COE) results in displacement of the Et₂O ligand to yield the corresponding π complexes, [(IMes)₃Fe₄S₄(PhCCH)][BAr^F₄] and [(IMes)₃Fe₄S₄(COE)][BAr^F₄]. EPR spectroscopic analysis demonstrates that both clusters are doublets with g_iso > 2 and thus are spectroscopically faithful models of the analogous species characterized in the isoprenoid biosynthetic enzymes IspG and IspH. Structural and Mössbauer spectroscopic analysis reveals that both complexes are best described as [Fe₄S₄]⁺ clusters in which the unique Fe site engages in modest back-bonding to the π-acidic ligand. Paramagnetic NMR studies show that, even at room temperature, the alkyne/alkene-bound Fe centers harbor minority spin and therefore adopt an Fe²⁺ valence. We propose that such valence localization could likewise occur in Fe-S enzymes that interact with π-acidic molecules.

Synthesis of a Fe3-Carbyne Motif by Oxidation of an Alkyl Ligated Iron-Sulfur (WFe3S3) Cluster

The presence of a carbide ligand in the active site of nitrogenases remains an unusual example of organometallic chemistry employed by a protein. Carbide incorporation into the MFe7S9C cluster involves complex biosynthesis, but analogous synthetic methodologies are limited. Herein, we present a new synthetic strategy for incorporating carbon based bridging ligands into iron-sulfur clusters. Starting from a halide precursor, a WFe3S3 cluster displaying three terminal alkyl ligands and an open Fe3 face was prepared. Oxidation results in loss of alkane and formation of a μ3-carbyne. Characterization of these clusters and mechanistic studies are presented.

The Elusive Mononitrosylated [Fe4 S4 ] Cluster in Three Redox States

Iron-sulfur clusters are well-established targets in biological nitric oxide (NO) chemistry, but the key intermediate in these processes-a mononitrosylated [Fe4 S4 ] cluster-has not been fully characterized in a protein or a synthetic model thereof. Here, we report the synthesis of a three-member redox series of isostructural mononitrosylated [Fe4 S4 ] clusters. Mononitrosylation was achieved by binding NO to a 3 : 1 site-differentiated [Fe4 S4 ]+ cluster; subsequent oxidation and reduction afforded the other members of the series. All three clusters feature a local high-spin Fe3+ center antiferromagnetically coupled to 3 [NO]- . The observation of an anionic NO ligand suggests that NO binding is accompanied by formal electron transfer from the cluster to NO. Preliminary reactivity studies with the monocationic cluster demonstrate that exposure to excess NO degrades the cluster, supporting the intermediacy of mononitrosylated intermediates in NO sensing/signaling.

Reversible Alkyl-Group Migration between Iron and Sulfur in [Fe4S4] Clusters

Synthetic [Fe₄S₄] clusters with Fe-R groups (R = alkyl/benzyl) are shown to release organic radicals on an [Fe₄S₄]³⁺-R/[Fe₄S₄]²⁺ redox couple, the same that has been proposed for a radical-generating intermediate in the superfamily of radical S-adenosyl-l-methionine (SAM) enzymes. In attempts to trap the immediate precursor to radical generation, a species in which the alkyl group has migrated from Fe to S is instead isolated. This S-alkylated cluster is a structurally faithful model of intermediates proposed in a variety of functionally diverse S transferase enzymes and features an "[Fe₄S₄]⁺-like" core that exists as a physical mixture of S = 1/2 and 7/2 states. The latter corresponds to an unusual, valence-localized electronic structure as indicated by distortions in its geometric structure and supported by computational analysis. Fe-to-S alkyl group migration is (electro)chemically reversible, and the preference for Fe vs S alkylation is dictated by the redox state of the cluster. These findings link the organoiron and organosulfur chemistry of Fe-S clusters and are discussed in the context of metalloenzymes that are proposed to make and break Fe-S and/or C-S bonds during catalysis.

Structural insights into auxiliary cofactor usage by radical S-adenosylmethionine enzymes

Radical S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) enzymes use a common catalytic core for diverse transformations. While all radical SAM enzymes bind a Fe₄S₄ cluster via a characteristic tri-cysteine motif, many bind additional metal cofactors. Recently reported structures of radical SAM enzymes that use methylcobalamin or additional iron-sulfur clusters as cosubstrates show that these auxiliary units are anchored by N- and C-terminal domains that vary significantly in size and topology. Despite this architectural diversity, all use a common surface for auxiliary cofactor docking. In the sulfur insertion and metallocofactor assembly systems evaluated here, interaction with iron-sulfur cluster assembly proteins or downstream scaffold proteins is an important component of catalysis. Structures of these complexes represent important new frontiers in structural analysis of radical SAM enzymes.

The Atypical Cobalamin-Dependent S-Adenosyl-l-Methionine Nonradical Methylase TsrM and Its Radical Counterparts

Cobalamin (Cbl)-dependent S-adenosyl-l-methionine (AdoMet) radical methylases are known for their use of a dual cofactor system to perform challenging radical methylation reactions at unactivated carbon and phosphorus centers. These enzymes are part of a larger subgroup of Cbl-dependent AdoMet radical enzymes that also perform difficult ring contractions and radical rearrangements. This subgroup is a largely untapped reservoir of diverse chemistry that requires steady efforts in biochemical and structural characterization to reveal its complexity. In this Perspective, we highlight the significant efforts over many years to elucidate the function, mechanism, and structure of TsrM, an unexpected nonradical methylase in this subgroup. We also discuss recent achievements in characterizing radical methylase subgroup members that exemplify how key tools in mechanistic enzymology are valuable time and again. Finally, we identify recent enzyme activity studies that have made use of bioinformatic analyses to expand our definition of the subgroup. Additional breakthroughs in radical (and nonradical) enzymatic chemistry and challenging transformations from the unexplored space of this subgroup are undoubtedly on the horizon.

l-methionine Adenosylation: Radical Intermediates and the Catalytic Competence of the 5'-Deoxyadenosyl Radical

Radical S-adenosyl-l-methionine (SAM) enzymes employ a [4Fe-4S] cluster and SAM to initiate diverse radical reactions via either H-atom abstraction or substrate adenosylation. Here we use freeze-quench techniques together with electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy to provide snapshots of the reaction pathway in an adenosylation reaction catalyzed by the radical SAM enzyme pyruvate formate-lyase activating enzyme on a peptide substrate containing a dehydroalanine residue in place of the target glycine. The reaction proceeds via the initial formation of the organometallic intermediate Ω, as evidenced by the characteristic EPR signal with g_∥ = 2.035 and g_⊥ = 2.004 observed when the reaction is freeze-quenched at 500 ms. Thermal annealing of frozen Ω converts it into a second paramagnetic species centered at g_iso = 2.004; this second species was generated directly using freeze-quench at intermediate times (∼8 s) and unequivocally identified via isotopic labeling and EPR spectroscopy as the tertiary peptide radical resulting from adenosylation of the peptide substrate. An additional paramagnetic species observed in samples quenched at intermediate times was revealed through thermal annealing while frozen and spectral subtraction as the SAM-derived 5'-deoxyadenosyl radical (5'-dAdo•). The time course of the 5'-dAdo• and tertiary peptide radical EPR signals reveals that the former generates the latter. These results thus support a mechanism in which Ω liberates 5'-dAdo• by Fe-C5' bond homolysis, and the 5'-dAdo• attacks the dehydroalanine residue of the peptide substrate to form the adenosylated peptide radical species. The results thus provide a picture of a catalytically competent 5'-dAdo• intermediate trapped just prior to reaction with the substrate.

Broken-Symmetry Density Functional Theory Analysis of the Ω Intermediate in Radical S-Adenosyl-l-methionine Enzymes: Evidence for a Near-Attack Conformer over an Organometallic Species

Radical S-adenosyl-l-methionine (SAM) enzymes are found in all domains of life and catalyze a wide range of biochemical reactions. Recently, an organometallic intermediate, Ω, has been experimentally implicated in the 5'-deoxyadenosyl radical generation mechanism of the radical SAM superfamily. In this work, we employ broken-symmetry density functional theory to evaluate several structural models of Ω. The results show that the calculated hyperfine coupling constants (HFCCs) for the proposed organometallic structure of Ω are inconsistent with the experiment. In contrast, a near-attack conformer of SAM bound to the catalytic [4Fe-4S] cluster, in which the distance between the unique iron and SAM sulfur is ∼3 Å, yields HFCCs that are all within 1 MHz of the experimental values. These results clarify the structure of the ubiquitous Ω intermediate and suggest a paradigm shift reversal regarding the mechanism of SAM cleavage by members of the radical SAM superfamily.

Spin-Regulated Electron Transfer and Exchange-Enhanced Reactivity in Fe4 S4 -Mediated Redox Reaction of the Dph2 Enzyme During the Biosynthesis of Diphthamide

The [4Fe-4S]-dependent radical S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) proteins is one of large families of redox enzymes that are able to carry a panoply of challenging transformations. Despite the extensive studies of structure-function relationships of radical SAM (RS) enzymes, the electronic state-dependent reactivity of the [4Fe-4S] cluster in these enzymes remains elusive. Using combined MD simulations and QM/MM calculations, we deciphered the electronic state-dependent reactivity of the [4Fe-4S] cluster in Dph2, a key enzyme involved in the biosynthesis of diphthamide. Our calculations show that the reductive cleavage of the S-C_(γ) bond is highly dependent on the electronic structure of [4Fe-4S]. Interestingly, the six electronic states can be classified into a low-energy and a high-energy groups, which are correlated with the net spin of Fe4 atom ligated to SAM. Due to the driving force of Fe4-C_(γ) bonding, the net spin on the Fe4 moiety dictate the shift of the opposite spin electron from the Fe1-Fe2-Fe3 block to SAM. Such spin-regulated electron transfer results in the exchange-enhanced reactivity in the lower-energy group compared with those in the higher-energy group. This reactivity principle provides fundamental mechanistic insights into reactivities of [4Fe-4S] cluster in RS enzymes.

Structure, reactivity, and spectroscopy of nitrogenase-related synthetic and biological clusters

The reduction of dinitrogen (N2) is essential for its incorporation into nucleic acids and amino acids, which are vital to life on earth. Nitrogenases convert atmospheric dinitrogen to two ammonia molecules (NH3) under ambient conditions. The catalytic active sites of these enzymes (known as FeM-cofactor clusters, where M = Mo, V, Fe) are the sites of N2 binding and activation and have been a source of great interest for chemists for decades. In this review, recent studies on nitrogenase-related synthetic molecular complexes and biological clusters are discussed, with a focus on their reactivity and spectroscopic characterization. The molecular models that are discussed span from simple mononuclear iron complexes to multinuclear iron complexes and heterometallic iron complexes. In addition, recent work on the extracted biological cofactors is discussed. An emphasis is placed on how these studies have contributed towards our understanding of the electronic structure and mechanism of nitrogenases.

A Terminal Imido Complex of an Iron-Sulfur Cluster

We report the synthesis and characterization of the first terminal imido complex of an Fe-S cluster, (IMes)₃ Fe₄ S₄ =NDipp (2; IMes=1,3-dimesitylimidazol-2-ylidene, Dipp=2,6-diisopropylphenyl), which is generated by oxidative group transfer from DippN₃ to the all-ferrous cluster (IMes)₃ Fe₄ S₄ (PPh₃ ). This two-electron process is achieved by formal one-electron oxidation of the imido-bound Fe site and one-electron oxidation of two IMes-bound Fe sites. Structural, spectroscopic, and computational studies establish that the Fe-imido site is best described as a high-spin Fe³⁺ center, which is manifested in its long Fe-N(imido) distance of 1.763(2) Å. Cluster 2 abstracts hydrogen atoms from 1,4-cyclohexadiene to yield the corresponding anilido complex, demonstrating competency for C-H activation.

Synthesis and Reactivity of Iron Complexes with a Biomimetic SCS Pincer Ligand

Recent experimental evidence suggests that the FeMoco of nitrogenase undergoes structural rearrangement during N₂ reduction, which may result in the generation of coordinatively unsaturated iron sites with two sulfur donors and a carbon donor. In an effort to synthesize and study small-molecule model complexes with a one-carbon/two-sulfur coordination environment, we have designed two new SCS pincer ligands containing a central NHC donor accompanied by thioether- or thiolate-functionalized aryl groups. Metalation of the thioether ligand with Fe(OTf)₂ gives 6-coordinate complexes in which the SCS ligand binds meridionally. In contrast, metalation of the thiolate ligand with Fe(HMDS)₂ gives a four-coordinate pseudotetrahedral amide complex in which the ligand binds facially, illustrating the potential structural flexibility of these ligands. Reaction of the amide complex with a bulky monothiol gives a four-coordinate complex with a one-carbon/three-sulfur coordination environment that resembles the resting state of nitrogenase. Reaction of the amide complex with phenylhydrazine gives a product with a rare κ¹-bound phenylhydrazido group which undergoes N-N cleavage to give a phenylamido complex.

Construction of Synthetic Models for Nitrogenase-Relevant NifB Biogenesis Intermediates and Iron-Carbide-Sulfide Clusters

The family of nitrogenase enzymes catalyzes the reduction of atmospheric dinitrogen (N2) to ammonia under remarkably benign conditions of temperature, pressure, and pH. Therefore, the development of synthetic complexes or materials that can similarly perform this reaction is of critical interest. The primary obstacle for obtaining realistic synthetic models of the active site iron-sulfur-carbide cluster (e.g., FeMoco) is the incorporation of a truly inorganic carbide. This review summarizes the present state of knowledge regarding biological and chemical (synthetic) incorporation of carbide into iron-sulfur clusters. This includes the Nif cluster of proteins and associated biochemistry involved in the endogenous biogenesis of FeMoco. We focus on the chemical (synthetic) incorporation portion of our own efforts to incorporate and modify C1 units in iron/sulfur clusters. We also highlight recent contributions from other research groups in the area toward C1 and/or inorganic carbide insertion.

Radical SAM Enzyme Spore Photoproduct Lyase: Properties of the Ω Organometallic Intermediate and Identification of Stable Protein Radicals Formed during Substrate-Free Turnover

Spore photoproduct lyase is a radical S-adenosyl-l-methionine (SAM) enzyme with the unusual property that addition of SAM to the [4Fe-4S]¹⁺ enzyme absent substrate results in rapid electron transfer to SAM with accompanying homolytic S-C5' bond cleavage. Herein, we demonstrate that this unusual reaction forms the organometallic intermediate Ω in which the unique Fe atom of the [4Fe-4S] cluster is bound to C5' of the 5'-deoxyadenosyl radical (5'-dAdo^•). During catalysis, homolytic cleavage of the Fe-C5' bond liberates 5'-dAdo^• for reaction with substrate, but here, we use Ω formation without substrate to determine the thermal stability of Ω. The reaction of Geobacillus thermodenitrificans SPL (GtSPL) with SAM forms Ω within ∼15 ms after mixing. By monitoring the decay of Ω through rapid freeze-quench trapping at progressively longer times we find an ambient temperature decay time of the Ω Fe-C5' bond of τ ≈ 5-6 s, likely shortened by enzymatic activation as is the case with the Co-C5' bond of B₁₂. We have further used hand quenching at times up to 10 min, and thus with multiple SAM turnovers, to probe the fate of the 5'-dAdo^• radical liberated by Ω. In the absence of substrate, Ω undergoes low-probability conversion to a stable protein radical. The WT enzyme with valine at residue 172 accumulates a Val^•; mutation of Val172 to isoleucine or cysteine results in accumulation of an Ile^• or Cys^• radical, respectively. The structures of the radical in WT, V172I, and V172C variants have been established by detailed EPR/DFT analyses.