Metal Ion Control of Photoinduced Electron Spin Polarization in Electronic Ground States

Spin-related excited-state phenomena in photochemistry

The spin of electrons plays a vital role in chemical reactions and processes, and the excited state generated by the absorption of photons shows abundant spin-related phenomena. However, the importance of electron spin in photochemistry studies has been rarely mentioned or summarized. In this review, we briefly introduce the concept of spin photochemistry based on the spin multiplicity of the excited state, which leads to the observation of various spin-related photophysical properties and photochemical reactivities. Then, we focus on the recent advances in terms of light-induced magnetic properties, excited-state magneto-optical effects and spin-dependent photochemical reactions. The review aims to provide a comprehensive overview to utilize the spin multiplicity of the excited state in manipulating the above photophysical and photochemical processes. Finally, we discuss the existing challenges in the emerging field of spin photochemistry and future opportunities such as smart magnetic materials, optical information technology and spin-enhanced photocatalysis.

Radical enhanced intersystem crossing mechanism, electron spin dynamics of high spin states and their applications in the design of heavy atom-free triplet photosensitizers

Heavy atom-free triplet photosensitizers (PSs) can overcome the high cost and biological toxicity of traditional molecular systems containing heavy atoms (such as Pt(II), Ir(III), Ru(II), Pd(II), Lu(III), I, or Br atoms) and, therefore, are developing rapidly. Connecting a stable free radical to the chromophore can promote the intersystem crossing (ISC) process through electron spin exchange interaction to produce the triplet state of the chromophore or the doublet (D) and quartet (Q) states when taking the whole spin system into account. These molecular systems based on the radical enhanced ISC (REISC) mechanism are important in the field of heavy atom-free triplet PSs. The REISC system has a simple molecular structure and good biocompatibility, and it is especially helpful for building high-spin quantum states (D and Q states) that have the potential to be developed as qubits in quantum information science. This review introduces the molecular structure design for the purpose of high-spin states. Time-resolved electron paramagnetic resonance (TREPR) is the most important characterization method to reveal the properties of these molecular systems, generation mechanism and electron spin polarization (ESP) of the high spin states. The spin polarization manipulation of high spin states and potential application in the field of quantum information engineering are also summarized. Moreover, molecular design principles of the REISC system to obtain long absorption wavelength, high triplet state quantum yield and long triplet state lifetime are introduced, as well as applications of the compounds in triplet-triplet annihilation upconversion, photodynamic therapy and bioimaging. This review is useful for the design of heavy atom-free triplet PSs based on the radical-chromophore molecular structure motif and the study of the photophysics of the compounds, as well as the electron spin dynamics of the multi electron system upon photoexcitation.

Guest-responsive coherence time of radical qubits in a metal-organic framework

Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) integrated with molecular qubits are promising for quantum sensing. In this study, a new UiO-type MOF with a 5,12-diazatetracene (DAT)-containing ligand is synthesized, and the radicals generated in the MOF exhibit high stability and a relatively long coherence time (T2) responsive to the introduction of various guest molecules.

Photoinduced Magnetic Exchange-Jump Promotes Ground State Biradical Electron Spin Polarization

Photoinduced electron spin polarization (ESP) is reported in the electronic ground states of three Pt(II) complexes comprised of two S = 1/2 nitronyl nitroxide (NN) radicals attached through different length para-phenylethynyl bridges to the 3,6 positions of a catecholate (CAT, donor) and 4,4'-di-tert-butyl-2,2'-bipyridine (bpy, acceptor). Complexes 1-3 have from 17 to 41 bonds separating NN radicals and display cw-EPR spectra consistent with |JNN-NN| ≫ |aN|, |JNN-NN| ≥ |aN|, and |JNN-NN| < |aN|, respectively, where JNN-NN is the magnetic exchange coupling between NN radicals in the electronic ground state, and aN is the isotropic 14N hyperfine coupling constant. Light-induced transient EPR spectra characterized as enhanced ground-state absorption were observed for all three complexes using 532 nm pulsed laser excitation into the ligand-to-ligand charge transfer (LL'CT) band of the (CAT)Pt(bpy) chromophore. The magnitude of the observed ESP increases in the order 1 < 2 < 3 and is inversely correlated with the magnitude of ground-state JNN-NN. In addition to the experimental observation of net absorptive polarization in 1-3, light excitation also produces multiplet polarization in 2. Since the weak dipolar coupling leads to a strong spectral overlap of the absorptive and emissive components, the multiplet polarization is not observed in 1 and 3 and is very weak in 2. The ability to spin-polarize multiple radical spins with a single photon is anticipated to advance new photoinduced multi qubit/qudit ESP protocols for quantum information science applications.

Theoretical investigation of multi-spin excited states of anthracene radical-linked π-conjugated spin systems by computational chemistry

Multi-spin excited states of chromophore radical-linked π-conjugated spin systems are investigated by molecular orbital calculations based on density functional theory (DFT). The investigated systems consist of an anthracene photosensitive unit leading to a triplet-excited-state (S = 1), π-conjugated linker to propagate spin exchange-coupling, and stable organic radical with a doublet-ground-state (S = 1/2). The intramolecular exchange coupling (JDQ), g value, and fine-structure interaction of their excited states depended on the π-conjugation network (π-topology), type of radical, and molecular structure of the π-linker (length and dihedral angle). The exchange interaction was dependent on the π-topology and the type of radical species. A decrease in the dihedral angle between the anthracene moiety and phenyl linker in the photo-excited state led to larger exchange coupling. With an increase in the π-linker length (r), the magnitude of the exchange coupling gradually decreased in the photoexcited states according to JDQ = JEx0 exp(-βr), similar to the ground-state exchange. The g values of the quartet (Q) state depended only on the radical type (independent of the linker). Conversely, the fine-structure interaction of the Q state was independent of the radical type and depended on both the linker length and the dihedral angle.

Estimation of Heisenberg exchange interaction in rigid photoexcited chromophore-radical compound by transient EPR

The magnetic field dependence of the spin polarization in a photoexcited rigid chromophore-radical conjugate is theoretically investigated. The excitation of the chromophore-radical conjugate often populates the metastable doublet and quartet states formed by the interactions of the unpaired electrons of the triplet chromophore and the radical. The intensities of the +1/2 ↔ - 1/2 transitions of the doublet and quartet manifolds are sensitive to the ratio jω = 3J/ω0 between the triplet-doublet exchange interaction J and the Zeeman energy ω0. It is shown that the analytical expressions of these intensities previously found for the triplet mechanism of the initial spin polarization can be expanded and applied to a broader class of compounds that may have other intersystem crossing pathways of the depopulation of the excited singlet state of the chromophore. It is also shown that the exchange interaction can be evaluated not only by comparing the electron paramagnetic resonance spectra obtained in different microwave frequency bands but also by comparing the data obtained in the same microwave band but with a shift of the frequency of the resonator. The results obtained broaden the potential applications of the previously proposed approach for analyzing the correlation between the exchange coupling and the distance separating the radical and the chromophore spins, as well as the structure of the bridge connecting their fragments.

Variation from closed-shell to open shell electronic structures in oligothiophene bis(dioxolene) complexes

A series of oligothiophene bis(dioxolene) complexes, SQ-Thn-SQ (SQ = S = ½TpCum,MeZnII(3-tert-butyl-orthosemiquinonate); TpCum,Me = tris(5-cumenyl-3-methylpyrazolyl)borate anion) have been synthesized, structurally characterized, and studied as a function of the number of thiophene bridging units, n (n = 0-3) using a combination of variable-temperature (VT) electronic absorption and EPR spectroscopies, and VT magnetic susceptibility measurements. The thiophene bridge bond lengths determined by X-ray crystallography display dramatic differences across the SQ-Thn-SQ series. Bridge bond deviation values (Σ|Δi|) display a progressive change in the nature of the bridge fragment bonding as the number of thiophene groups increases, with quinoidal bridge character for n = 1 (SQ-Th-SQ) and biradical character with "aromatic" bridge bond lengths for n = 3 (SQ-Th3-SQ). Remarkably, for n = 2 (SQ-Th2-SQ) the nature of the bridge fragment is intermediate between quinoid and biradical aromatic, which we describe as having open-shell character as opposed to biradicaloid since the open-shell biradical configuration does not have the correct symmetry to mix with the quinoidal ground-state configuration. This bridge bonding character is reflected in the energies of the lowest lying open-shell states for these three molecules. The SQ-Th-SQ molecule is diamagnetic at all temperatures studied, and we provide evidence for SQ-SQ antiferromagnetic exchange coupling and population of triplet states in SQ-Th2-SQ and SQ-Th3-SQ, with JSQ-SQ(ave) = -279 cm-1 (VT EPR/electronic absorption/magnetic susceptibility) and JSQ-SQ = -117 cm-1 (VT EPR/electronic absorption/magnetic susceptibility), respectively. The results have been interpreted in the context of state configurational mixing within a simplified 4-electron, 3-orbital model that explicitly contains contributions of a bridge fragment. Variable-temperature spectroscopic- and magnetic susceptibility data are consistent with two low-lying open-shell states for SQ-Th3-SQ, but three low-lying states (one closed-shell and two open-shell) for SQ-Th2-SQ. This model provides a simple symmetry-based framework to understand the continuum of electronic and geometric structures of this class of molecules as a function of the number of thiophene units in the bridge.

Competitive reversed quartet mechanisms for photogenerated ground state electron spin polarization

Photoinduced electron spin polarization (ESP) of a spin-½ organic radical (nitronyl nitroxide, NN) in a series of Pt(ii) complexes comprised of 4,4'-di-tert-butyl-2,2'-bipyridine (bpy) and 3-tert-butylcatecholate (CAT) ligands, where the CAT ligand is substituted with (CH3)n-meta-phenyl-NN (bridge-NN) groups, is presented and discussed. We show the importance of attenuating the energy gap between localized NN radical and chromophoric excited states to control both the magnitude and sign of the optically-generated ESP, and to provide deeper insight into the details of the ESP mechanism. Understanding electronic structure contributions to optically generated ESP will enhance our ability to control the nature of prepared states for a variety of quantum information science applications, where strong ESP facilitates enhanced sensitivity and readout capabilities at low applied magnetic fields and higher temperatures.

Dinuclear ligand-to-ligand charge transfer complexes

The synthesis and characterization of dinuclear ligand-to-ligand charge transfer complexes are described. Each complex is comprised of square-planar platinum(II) coordinated to a 3-tert-butyl-orthocatecholate donor and a 4,4'-di-tert-butyl-2,2'-bipyridine acceptor. Both complexes exhibit donor → acceptor ligand-to-ligand charge transfer (LL'CT) bands in the visible spectrum. The platinum complexes are covalently attached at the catecholate 5-position to either a meta- or para-phenylene bridge fragment. Both cyclic voltammetry and electronic absorption spectroscopy exhibit features characteristic of intramolecular interaction between the platinum centres. The LL'CT excited state lifetimes are ∼twofold longer than the mononuclear parent complex. The properties of these complexes are discussed and compared to similar complexes in the literature.

Spin Hyperpolarization in Modern Magnetic Resonance

Magnetic resonance techniques are successfully utilized in a broad range of scientific disciplines and in various practical applications, with medical magnetic resonance imaging being the most widely known example. Currently, both fundamental and applied magnetic resonance are enjoying a major boost owing to the rapidly developing field of spin hyperpolarization. Hyperpolarization techniques are able to enhance signal intensities in magnetic resonance by several orders of magnitude, and thus to largely overcome its major disadvantage of relatively low sensitivity. This provides new impetus for existing applications of magnetic resonance and opens the gates to exciting new possibilities. In this review, we provide a unified picture of the many methods and techniques that fall under the umbrella term "hyperpolarization" but are currently seldom perceived as integral parts of the same field. Specifically, before delving into the individual techniques, we provide a detailed analysis of the underlying principles of spin hyperpolarization. We attempt to uncover and classify the origins of hyperpolarization, to establish its sources and the specific mechanisms that enable the flow of polarization from a source to the target spins. We then give a more detailed analysis of individual hyperpolarization techniques: the mechanisms by which they work, fundamental and technical requirements, characteristic applications, unresolved issues, and possible future directions. We are seeing a continuous growth of activity in the field of spin hyperpolarization, and we expect the field to flourish as new and improved hyperpolarization techniques are implemented. Some key areas for development are in prolonging polarization lifetimes, making hyperpolarization techniques more generally applicable to chemical/biological systems, reducing the technical and equipment requirements, and creating more efficient excitation and detection schemes. We hope this review will facilitate the sharing of knowledge between subfields within the broad topic of hyperpolarization, to help overcome existing challenges in magnetic resonance and enable novel applications.

Origin of Ferromagnetic Exchange Coupling in Donor-Acceptor Biradical Analogues of Charge-Separated Excited States

A new donor-acceptor biradical complex, Tp^Cum,MeZn(SQ-VD) (Tp^Cum,MeZn⁺ = zinc(II) hydro-tris(3-cumenyl-5-methylpyrazolyl)borate complex cation; SQ = orthosemiquinone; VD = oxoverdazyl), which is a ground-state analogue of a charge-separated excited state, has been synthesized and structurally characterized. The magnetic exchange interaction between the S = 1/2 SQ and the S = 1/2 VD within the SQ-VD biradical ligand is observed to be ferromagnetic, with J_SQ-VD = +77 cm^-1 (H = -2J_SQ-VDŜ_SQ·Ŝ_VD) determined from an analysis of the variable-temperature magnetic susceptibility data. The pairwise biradical exchange interaction in Tp^Cum,MeZn(SQ-VD) can be compared with that of the related donor-acceptor biradical complex Tp^Cum,MeZn(SQ-NN) (NN = nitronyl nitroxide, S = 1/2), where J_SQ-NN ≅ +550 cm^-1. This represents a dramatic reduction in the biradical exchange by a factor of ∼7, despite the isolobal nature of the VD and NN acceptor radical SOMOs. Computations assessing the magnitude of the exchange were performed using a broken-symmetry density functional theory (DFT) approach. These computations are in good agreement with those computed at the CASSCF NEVPT2 level, which also reveals an S = 1 triplet ground state as observed in the magnetic susceptibility measurements. A combination of electronic absorption spectroscopy and CASSCF computations has been used to elucidate the electronic origin of the large difference in the magnitude of the biradical exchange coupling between Tp^Cum,MeZn(SQ-VD) and Tp^Cum,MeZn(SQ-NN). A Valence Bond Configuration Interaction (VBCI) model was previously employed to highlight the importance of mixing an SQ_SOMO → NN_LUMO charge transfer configuration into the electronic ground state to facilitate the stabilization of the high-spin triplet (S = 1) ground state in Tp^Cum,MeZn(SQ-NN). Here, CASSCF computations confirm the importance of mixing the pendant radical (e.g., VD, NN) LUMO (VD_LUMO and NN_LUMO) with the SOMO of the SQ radical (SQ_SOMO) for stabilizing the triplet, in addition to spin polarization and charge transfer contributions to the exchange. An important electronic structure difference between Tp^Cum,MeZn(SQ-VD) and Tp^Cum,MeZn(SQ-NN), which leads to their different exchange couplings, is the reduced admixture of excited states that promote ferromagnetic exchange into the Tp^Cum,MeZn(SQ-VD) ground state, and the intrinsically weaker mixing between the VD_LUMO and the SQ_SOMO compared to that observed for Tp^Cum,MeZn(SQ-NN), where this orbital mixing is significant. The results of this comparative study contribute to a greater understanding of biradical exchange interactions, which are important to our understanding of excited-state singlet-triplet energy gaps, electron delocalization, and the generation of electron spin polarization in both the ground and excited states of (bpy)Pt(CAT-radical) complexes.

Charge Transfer Chromophores Derived from 3d-Row Transition Metal Complexes

A series of new charge transfer (CT) chromophores of "α-diimine-M^II-catecholate" type (where M is 3d-row transition metals-Cu, Ni, Co) were derived from 4,4'-di-tert-butyl-2,2'-bipyridyl and 3,6-di-tert-butyl-o-benzoquinone (3,6-DTBQ) in accordance with three modified synthetic approaches, which provide high yields of products. A square-planar molecular structure is inherent for monomeric [Cu^II(3,6-Cat)(bipy^tBu)]∙THF (1) and Ni^II(3,6-Cat)(bipy^tBu) (2) chromophores, while dimeric complex [Co^II(3,6-Cat)(bipy^tBu)]₂∙toluene (3) units two substantially distorted heteroleptic D-M^II-A (where D, M, A are donor, metal and acceptor, respectively) parts through a donation of oxygen atoms from catecholate dianions. Chromophores 1-3 undergo an effective photoinduced intramolecular charge transfer (λ = 500-715 nm, extinction coefficient up to 10⁴ M^-1·cm^-1) with a concomitant generation of a less polar excited species, the energy of which is a finely sensitive towards solvent polarity, ensuring a pronounced negative solvatochromic effect. Special attention was paid to energetic characteristics for CT and interacting HOMO/LUMO orbitals that were explored by a synergy of UV-vis-NIR spectroscopy, cyclic voltammetry, and DFT study. The current work sheds light on the dependence of CT peculiarities on the nature of metal centers from various groups of the periodic law. Moreover, the "α-diimine-M^II-catecholate" CT chromophores on the base of "late" transition elements with differences in d-level's electronic structure were compared for the first time.

Excited State Magneto-Structural Correlations Related to Photoinduced Electron Spin Polarization

Photoinduced electron spin polarization (ESP) is reported in the ground state of a series of complexes consisting of an organic radical (nitronylnitroxide, NN) covalently attached to a donor-acceptor chromophore either directly or via para-phenylene bridges substituted with 0-4 methyl groups. These molecules represent a class of chromophores that undergo visible light excitation to produce an initial exchange-coupled, three-spin [bpy^•-, CAT^•+ (= semiquinone, SQ) and NN^•], charge-separated doublet ²S₁ (S = chromophore spin singlet configuration) excited state that rapidly decays by magnetic exchange-enhanced internal conversion to a ²T₁ (T = chromophore excited spin triplet configuration) state. The ²T₁ state equilibrates with chromophoric and NN radical-derived excited states, resulting in absorptive ESP of the recovered ground state, which persists for greater than a millisecond and can be measured by low-temperature time-resolved electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy. The magnitude of the ground state ESP is found to correlate with the excited state magnetic exchange interaction between the CAT^+• and NN^• radicals, which in turn is controlled by the structure of the bridge fragment.

Exchange Spin Coupling in Optically Excited States

In optically excited states in molecules and materials, coupling between local electron spins plays an important role for their photoemission properties and is interesting for potential applications in quantum information processing. Recently, it was experimentally demonstrated that the photogenerated local spins in donor-acceptor metal complexes can interact with the spin of an attached radical, resulting in a spin-coupling-dependent mixing of excited doublet states, which controls the local spin density distributions on donor, acceptor, and radical subunits in optically excited states. In this work, we propose an energy-difference scheme to evaluate spin coupling in optically excited states, using unrestricted and spin-flip simplified time-dependent density functional theory. We apply it to three platinum complexes which have been studied experimentally to validate our methodology. We find that all computed coupling constants are in excellent agreement with the experimental data. In addition, we show that the spin coupling between donor and acceptor in the optically excited state can be fine-tuned by replacing platinum with palladium and zinc in the structure. Besides the two previously discussed excited doublet states (one bright and one dark), our calculations reveal a third, bright excited doublet state which was not considered previously. This third state possesses the inverse spin polarization on donor and acceptor with respect to the previously studied bright doublet state and is by an order of magnitude brighter, which might be interesting for optically controlling local spin polarizations with potential applications in spin-only information transfer and manipulation of connected qubits.

Excited State Exchange Control of Photoinduced Electron Spin Polarization in Electronic Ground States

Ground-state electron spin polarization (ESP) is generated in radical elaborated (bpy)Pt(CAT-NN) and (bpy)Pt(CAT-p-Me₂PhMe₂-NN) (bpy = 5,5'-di-tert-butyl-2,2'-bipyridine, CAT = 3-tert-butylcatecholate, p-Ph = para-phenylene, NN = nitronylnitroxide). Photoexcitation produces an exchange-coupled, three-spin, charge-separated doublet ²S₁ (S = chromophore excited spin singlet configuration) excited state that rapidly decays to a ²T₁ (T = chromophore excited spin triplet configuration) excited state. The SQ-bridge-NN bond torsions affect the magnitude of the excited state exchange interaction (J_SQ-NN), which determines the ²T₁-⁴T₁ energy gap. Ground state ESP is dependent on the magnitude of J_SQ-NN, and we postulate that this results from differences in ²T₁ and ⁴T₁ state mixing. Mechanisms that lead to the rapid transfer of the excited state ESP to the ground state are discussed. Although subnanosecond ²T₁ state lifetimes are measured optically in solution, the ground state ESP decays very slowly at 20 K and is observable for more than a millisecond.

Chromophore-radical excited state antiferromagnetic exchange controls the sign of photoinduced ground state spin polarization

A change in the sign of the ground-state electron spin polarization (ESP) is reported in complexes where an organic radical (nitronylnitroxide, NN) is covalently attached to a donor-acceptor chromophore via two different meta-phenylene bridges in (bpy)Pt(CAT-m-Ph-NN) (mPh-Pt) and (bpy)Pt(CAT-6-Me-m-Ph-NN) (6-Me-mPh-Pt) (bpy = 5,5'-di-tert-butyl-2,2'-bipyridine, CAT = 3-tert-butylcatecholate, m-Ph = meta-phenylene). These molecules represent a new class of chromophores that can be photoexcited with visible light to produce an initial exchange-coupled, 3-spin (bpy˙-, CAT+˙ = semiquinone (SQ), and NN), charge-separated doublet 2S1 (S = chromophore excited spin singlet configuration) excited state. Following excitation, the 2S1 state rapidly decays to the ground state by magnetic exchange-mediated enhanced internal conversion via the 2T1 (T = chromophore excited spin triplet configuration) state. This process generates emissive ground state ESP in 6-Me-mPh-Pt while for mPh-Pt the ESP is absorptive. It is proposed that the emissive polarization in 6-Me-mPh-Pt results from zero-field splitting induced transitions between the chromophoric 2T1 and 4T1 states, whereas predominant spin-orbit induced transitions between 2T1 and low-energy NN-based states give rise to the absorptive polarization observed for mPh-Pt. The difference in the sign of the ESP for these molecules is consistent with a smaller excited state 2T1 - 4T1 gap for 6-Me-mPh-Pt that derives from steric interactions with the 6-methyl group. These steric interactions reduce the excited state pairwise SQ-NN exchange coupling compared to that in mPh-Pt.