Relative Quantitation of Unsaturated Phosphatidylcholines Using 193 nm Ultraviolet Photodissociation Parallel Reaction Monitoring Mass Spectrometry

Detailed lipid investigation of edible seaweeds by photochemical derivatization and untargeted lipidomics

Seaweeds are macrophytic algae that have been gaining interest as alternative healthy foods, renewable drug sources, and climate change mitigation agents. In terms of their nutritional value, seaweeds are renowned for their high content of biologically active polyunsaturated fatty acids. However, little is known about the regiochemistry-the geometry and position of carbon-carbon double bonds-of free and conjugated fatty acids in seaweeds. In the present work, a detailed characterization of the seaweed lipidome was achieved based on untargeted HRMS-based analysis and lipid derivatization with a photochemical aza-Paternò-Büchi reaction. A triple-data processing strategy was carried out to achieve high structural detail on the seaweed lipidome, i.e., (i) a first data processing workflow with all samples for aligning peak and statistical analysis that led to the definition of lipid sum compositions (e.g., phosphatidylglycerol (PG) 34:1), (ii) a second data processing workflow in which the samples of each seaweed were processed separately to annotate molecular lipids with known fatty acyl isomerism (e.g., PG 16:0_18:1), and (iii) the annotation of lipid regioisomers following MS/MS annotation of the lipid derivatives obtained following the aza-Paternò-Büchi reaction (e.g., PG 16:0_18:1 ω-9). Once the platform was set up, the lipid extracts from 8 seaweed species from different seaweed families were characterized, describing over 900 different lipid species, and information on the regiochemistry of carbon-carbon double bonds uncovered unknown peculiarities of seaweeds belonging to different families. The overall analytical approach helped to fill a gap in the knowledge of the nutritional composition of seaweeds.

FAIMS Shotgun Lipidomics for Enhanced Class- and Charge-State Separation Complemented by Automated Ganglioside Annotation

The analysis of gangliosides is extremely challenging, given their structural complexity, lack of reference standards, databases, and software solutions. Here, we introduce a fast 6 min high field asymmetric ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) shotgun lipidomics workflow, along with a dedicated software solution for ganglioside detection. By ramping FAIMS compensation voltages, ideal ranges for different ganglioside classes were obtained. FAIMS revealed both class- and charge-state separation behavior based on the glycan headgroup moiety. The number of sialic acids attached to the glycan moiety correlates positively with their preferred charge states, i.e., trisialylated gangliosides were mainly present as [M - 3H]3- ions, whereas [M - 4H]4- and [M - 5H]5- ions were observed for GQ1 and GP1. For data evaluation, we developed a shotgun/FAIMS extension for the open-source Lipid Data Analyzer (LDA), enabling automated annotation of gangliosides up to the molecular lipid species level. This extension utilized combined orthogonal fragmentation spectra from CID, HCD, and 213 nm UVPD ion activation methods and covers 29 ganglioside classes, including acetylated and fucosylated modifications. With our new workflow and software extension 117 unique gangliosides species were identified in porcine brain extracts. While conventional shotgun lipidomics favored the observation of singly charged ganglioside species, the utilization of FAIMS made multiply charged lipid species accessible, resulting in an increased number of detected species, primarily due to an improved signal-to-noise ratio arising from FAIMS charge state filtering. Therefore, this FAIMS-driven workflow, complemented by new software capabilities, offers a promising strategy for complex ganglioside and glycosphingolipid characterization in shotgun lipidomics.

First Proof of Concept of a Click Inverse Electron Demand Diels-Alder Reaction for Assigning the Regiochemistry of Carbon-Carbon Double Bonds in Untargeted Lipidomics

Lipidomics by high-resolution mass spectrometry (HRMS) has become a prominent tool in clinical chemistry due to the proven connections between lipid dysregulation and the insurgence of pathologies. However, it is difficult to achieve structural characterization beyond the fatty acid level by HRMS, especially when it comes to the regiochemistry of carbon-carbon double bonds, which play a major role in determining the properties of cell membranes. Several approaches have been proposed for elucidating the regiochemistry of double bonds, such as derivatization before MS analysis by photochemical reactions, which have shown great potential for their versatility but have the unavoidable drawback of splitting the MS signal. Among other possible approaches for derivatizing electron-rich double bonds, the emerging inverse-electron-demand Diels-Alder (IEDDA) reaction with tetrazines stands out for its unmatchable kinetics and has found several applications in basic biology and protein imaging. In this study, a catalyst-free click IEDDA reaction was employed for the first time to pinpoint carbon-carbon double bonds in free and conjugated fatty acids. Fatty acid and glycerophospholipid regioisomers were analyzed alone and in combination, demonstrating that the IEDDA reaction had click character and allowed the obtention of diagnostic product ions following MS/MS fragmentation as well as the possibility of performing relative quantitation of lipid regioisomers. The IEDDA protocol was later employed in an untargeted lipidomics study on plasma samples of patients suffering from prostate cancer and benign prostatic conditions, confirming the applicability of the proposed reaction to complex matrices of clinical interest.

One-phase extraction coupled with photochemical reaction allows the in-depth lipid characterization of hempseeds by untargeted lipidomics

Due to their valuable nutritional content, several hemp-derived products from hempseeds have recently been placed in the market as food and food ingredients. In particular, the lipid composition of hempseeds has raised interest for their rich content in biologically active polyunsaturated fatty acids with an optimum ratio of omega-3 and omega-6 compounds. At present, however, the overall polar lipidome composition of hempseeds remains largely unknown. In the present work, an analytical platform was developed for the extraction, untargeted HRMS-based analysis, and detailed annotation of the lipid species. First, five one- and two-phase solid-liquid extraction protocols were tested and compared on a hempseed pool sample to select the method that allowed the overall highest efficiency as well as easy coupling with lipid derivatization by photochemical [2 + 2] cycloaddition with 6-azauracil. Underivatized lipids were annotated employing a data processing workflow on Compound Discoverer software that was specifically designed for polar lipidomics, whereas inspection of the MS/MS spectra of the derivatized lipids following the aza-Paternò-Büchi reaction allowed pinpointing the regiochemistry of carbon-carbon double bonds. A total of 184 lipids were annotated, i.e., 26 fatty acids and 158 phospholipids, including minor subclasses such as N-acylphosphatidylethanolamines. Once the platform was set up, the lipid extracts from nine hempseed samples from different hemp strains were characterized, with information on the regiochemistry of free and conjugated fatty acids. The overall analytical approach helped to fill a gap in the knowledge of the nutritional composition of hempseeds.

Shotgun Lipidomic Profiling of Sebum Lipids via Photocatalyzed Paternò-Büchi Reaction and Ion Mobility-Mass Spectrometry

Sebum lipids are composed of nonpolar lipids, and they pose challenges for mass spectrometry-based analysis due to low ionization efficiency and the existence of numerous isomers and isobars. To address these challenges, we have developed ethyl 2-oxo-2-(pyridine-3-yacetate as a charge-tagging Paternò-Büchi reagent and Michler's ketone as a highly efficient photocatalyst, achieving ∼90% conversion for C═C derivatization under 440 nm LED irradiation. This derivatization, when coupled with electrospray ionization-tandem mass spectrometry, boosts the detection of sebum lipids and pinpoints C═C location in a chain-specific fashion. Identification and quantitation of isomers are readily achieved for wax esters, a class of underexplored sebum lipids, which have C═C bonds distributed in fatty alcohol and fatty acyl chains. A shotgun analysis workflow has been developed by pairing the offline PB derivatization with cyclic ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry. Besides the dominant n-10 C═C location in unsaturated wax esters, profiling of low abundance isomers, including the rarely reported n-7 and n-13 locations, is greatly enhanced due to separations of C═C diagnostic ions by ion mobility. Over 900 distinct lipid structures from human sebum lipid extract have been profiled at the chain-specific C═C level, including wax esters (500), glycerolipids (393), and cholesterol esters (22), far more exceeding previous reports. Overall, we have developed a fast and comprehensive lipidomic profiling tool for sebum samples, a type of noninvasive biofluids holding potential for the discovery of disease markers in distal organs.

Combinatory data-independent acquisition and parallel reaction monitoring method for revealing the lipid metabolism biomarkers of coronary heart disease and its comorbidities

Disorders of lipid metabolism are a common cause of coronary heart disease (CHD) and its comorbidities. In this study, ultra-performance liquid chromatography-high-resolution mass spectrometry in data-independent acquisition (DIA) mode was applied to collect abundant tandem mass spectrometry data, which provided valuable information for lipid annotation. For the lipid isomers that could not be completely separated by chromatography, parallel reaction monitoring (PRM) mode was used for quantification. A total of 223 plasma lipid metabolites were annotated, and 116 of them were identified for their fatty acyl chain composition and location. In addition, 152 plasma lipids in patients with CHD and its comorbidities were quantitatively analyzed. Multivariate statistical analysis and metabolic pathway analysis demonstrated that glycerophospholipid and sphingolipid metabolism deserved more attention for CHD. This study proposed a method combining DIA and PRM for high-throughput characterization of plasma lipids. The results also improved our understanding of metabolic disorders of CHD and its comorbidities, which can provide valuable suggestions for medical intervention.

Novel Structure-Driven Predict-to-Hit Strategy for PC Double Bond Positional Isomer Identification Based on Negative LC-MRM Analysis

As the predominant phospholipids in mammalian cells, phosphatidylcholines (PCs) have been demonstrated to play a crucial role in a multitude of vital biological processes. Research has highlighted the significance of the diversity in PC isomers as instigators of both physiological and pathological responses, particularly those with variations in the position of double bonds within their fatty chains. Profiling these PC isomers is paramount to advancing our understanding of their biological functions. Despite the availability of analytical methods utilizing high-resolution secondary mass spectrometry (MS2) fragmentation, a novel approach was imperative to facilitate large-scale profiling of PC isomers while ensuring accessibility, facility, and reliability. In this study, an innovative strategy centered around structure-driven predict-to-hit profiling of the double bond positional isomers for PCs was meticulously developed, employing negative reversed-phase liquid chromatography-multiple reaction monitoring (RPLC-MRM). This novel methodology heightened the sensitivity. The analysis of rat lung tissue samples resulted in the identification of 130 distinct PC isomers. This approach transcended the confines of available PC isomer standards, thereby broadening the horizons of PC-related biofunction investigations. By optimizing the quantitation reliability, the scale of sample analysis was judiciously managed. This work pioneers a novel paradigm for the exploration of PC isomers, distinct from the conventional methods reliant on high-resolution mass spectrometry (HRMS). It equips researchers with potent tools to further explore the biofunctional aspects of lipids.

Mass filtering combined with photochemical derivatization enables high throughput mass spectrometric analysis of unsaturated phosphatidylcholine isomers

Phosphatidylcholines (PCs) are closely related to coronary heart disease, such as myocardial infarction. The analysis of the deep structure of PCs is of great significance for exploring the effects of exercise rehabilitation and lipid metabolism. Here, we present a mass filtering combined with photochemical derivatization method for rapid screening and accurate identification of the CC position and sn-location isomer of PCs. This method is simple to execute and easily implementable for routine analysis. The accurate qualitative and quantitative analysis of PCs and isomers facilitates the discovery of biomarkers for exercise rehabilitation of patients with myocardial infarction.

Ozone-enabled fatty acid discovery reveals unexpected diversity in the human lipidome

Fatty acid isomers are responsible for an under-reported lipidome diversity across all kingdoms of life. Isomers of unsaturated fatty acids are often masked in contemporary analysis by incomplete separation and the absence of sufficiently diagnostic methods for structure elucidation. Here, we introduce a comprehensive workflow, to discover unsaturated fatty acids through coupling liquid chromatography and mass spectrometry with gas-phase ozonolysis of double bonds. The workflow encompasses semi-automated data analysis and enables de novo identification in complex media including human plasma, cancer cell lines and vernix caseosa. The targeted analysis including ozonolysis enables structural assignment over a dynamic range of five orders of magnitude, even in instances of incomplete chromatographic separation. Thereby we expand the number of identified plasma fatty acids two-fold, including non-methylene-interrupted fatty acids. Detection, without prior knowledge, allows discovery of non-canonical double bond positions. Changes in relative isomer abundances reflect underlying perturbations in lipid metabolism.

Characterization of glycerophospholipids at multiple isomer levels via Mn(II)-catalyzed epoxidation

Characterization of glycerophospholipid isomers is of significant importance as they play different roles in physiological and pathological processes. In this work, we present a novel and bifunctional derivatization method utilizing Mn(II)-catalyzed epoxidation to simultaneously identify carbon-carbon double bond (CC bond)- and stereonumbering (sn)-positional isomers of phosphatidylcholine. Mn(II) coordinates with picolinic acid and catalyzes epoxidation of unsaturated lipids by peracetic acid. Collision-induced dissociation (CID) of the epoxides generates diagnostic ions that can be used to locate CC bond positions. Meanwhile, CID of Mn(II) ion-lipid complexes produces characteristic ions for determination of sn positions. This bifunctional derivatization takes place in seconds, and the diagnostic ions produced in CID are clear and easy to interpret. Moreover, relative quantification of CC bond-and sn-positional isomers was achieved. The capability of this method in identifying lipids at multiple isomer levels was shown using lipid standards and lipid extracts from complex biological samples.

Voltage-Controlled Divergent Cascade of Electrochemical Reactions for Characterization of Lipids at Multiple Isomer Levels Using Mass Spectrometry

Cascading divergent reactions in a single system is highly desirable for their intrinsic efficiency and potential to achieve multilevel structural characterization of complex biomolecules. In this work, two electrochemical reactions, interfacial electro-epoxidation and cobalt anodic corrosion, are divergently cascaded in nanoelectrospray (nESI) and can be switched at different voltages. We applied these reactions to lipid identification at multiple isomer levels using mass spectrometry (MS), which remains a great challenge in structural lipidomics. The divergent cascade reactions in situ derivatize lipids to produce epoxidized lipids and cobalt-adducted lipids at different voltages. These lipids are then fragmented upon low-energy collision-induced dissociation (CID), generating diagnostic fragments to indicate C═C locations and sn-positions that cannot be achieved by the low-energy CID of native lipids. We have demonstrated that lipid structural isomers show significantly different profiles in the analysis of healthy and cancerous mouse prostate samples using this strategy. The application of divergent cascade reactions in lipid identification allows the four-in-one analysis of lipid headgroups, fatty acyl chains, C═C locations, and sn-positions simply by tuning the nESI voltages within a single experiment. This feature as well as its low sample consumption, no need for an extra apparatus, and quantitative analysis capability show its great potential in lipidomics.

Simultaneous Differentiation of C═C Position Isomerism in Fatty Acids through Ion Mobility and Theoretical Calculations

Fatty acids play a pivotal role in biological processes and have many isomers, particularly at the C═C position, that influence their biological function. Distinguishing between isomers is crucial to investigating their role in health and disease. However, separating the isomers poses a significant analytical challenge. In this study, we developed a simple and rapid strategy combining ion mobility spectrometry and theoretical chemical calculations to differentiate and quantify the C═C positional isomers in 2-/3-butenoic acid (BA), 2-/3-/4-pentenoic acid (PA), and 2-/3-/5-hexenoic acid (HA). C═C positional isomerism was mobility-differentiated by simple complexation with crown ethers (12C4, 15C5, and 18C6) and divalent metal ions (Mg²⁺, Ca²⁺, Mn²⁺, Fe²⁺, Co²⁺, Ni²⁺, Zn²⁺, Sr²⁺, and Ba²⁺), that is, converting C═C positional isomers with small structural differences into complexes with large structural differences through the interaction with metal ions and crown ethers. Metallized isomers were formed but could not be differentiated due to their complex and overlapping extracted ion mobiliograms (EIMs). Binary crown ether-isomer complexes were not observed, indicating that C═C positional isomers could not be separated by simple mixing with crown ethers. However, significant EIM differences were obtained for the formed ternary complexes, allowing baseline separation for the isomers. Notably, all crown ethers and metal ions have a separation effect with the isomers, with a calculated separation resolution (R_p-p) of 0.07-2.44. Theoretical chemical calculations were performed to provide in-depth structural information for the complexes and explain the separation principle. Theoretical conformational space showed that the divalent metal ions act as a bridge connecting the crown ether and the isomer. Additionally, the ternary complex becomes more compact as the distance between C═C and -COOH increases. Theoretical results can reflect the features of mobility experiments, with relative errors between the experiment collision cross-section (CCS) and theoretical CCS of no more than ±8.06%. This method was also evaluated in terms of quantification, accuracy, and precision repeatability. Overall, this study establishes that the crown ether-metal ion pair can function as a robust unit for differentiating C═C positional isomerism.

Enhancing the Signal-to-Noise of Diagnostic Fragment Ions of Unsaturated Glycerophospholipids via Precursor Exclusion Ultraviolet Photodissociation Mass Spectrometry (PEx-UVPD-MS)

Understanding and elucidating the diverse structures and functions of lipids has motivated the development of many innovative tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) strategies. Higher-energy activation methods, such as ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD), generate unique fragment ions from glycerophospholipids that can be used to perform in-depth structural analysis and facilitate the deconvolution of isomeric lipid structures in complex samples. Although detailed characterization is central to the correlation of lipid structure to biological function, it is often impeded by the lack of sufficient instrument sensitivity for highly bioactive but low-abundance phospholipids. Here, we present precursor exclusion (PEx) UVPD, a simple yet powerful technique to enhance the signal-to-noise (S/N) of informative low-abundance fragment ions produced from UVPD of glycerophospholipids. Through the exclusion of the large population of undissociated precursor ions with an MS3 strategy, the S/N of diagnostic fragment ions from PC 18:0/18:2(9Z, 12Z) increased up to an average of 13x for PEx-UVPD compared to UVPD alone. These enhancements were extended to complex mixtures of lipids from bovine liver extract to confidently identify 35 unique structures using liquid chromatography PEx-UVPD. This methodology has the potential to advance lipidomics research by offering deeper structure elucidation and confident identification of biologically active lipids.

Deep-lipidotyping by mass spectrometry: recent technical advances and applications

In-depth structural characterization of lipids is an essential component of lipidomics. There has been a rapid expansion of mass spectrometry methods that are capable of resolving lipid isomers at various structural levels over the past decade. These developments finally make deep-lipidotyping possible, which provides new means to study lipid metabolism and discover new lipid biomarkers. In this review, we discuss recent advancements in tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) methods for identification of complex lipids beyond the species (known headgroup information) and molecular species (known chain composition) levels. These include identification at the levels of carbon-carbon double bond (C=C) location and sn-position as well as characterization of acyl chain modifications. We also discuss the integration of isomer-resolving MS/MS methods with different lipid analysis workflows and their applications in lipidomics. The results showcase the distinct capabilities of deep-lipidotyping in untangling the metabolism of individual isomers and sensitive phenotyping by using relative fractional quantitation of the isomers.

Enhanced Characterization of Cardiolipins via Hybrid 193 nm Ultraviolet Photodissociation Mass Spectrometry

Cardiolipins (CLs) constitute a structurally complex class of glycerophospholipids with a unique tetraacylated structure accompanied by distinctive functional roles. Aberrations in the composition of this lipid class have been associated with disease states, spurring interest in the development of new approaches to differentiate the structures of diverse CLs in complex mixtures. The structural characterization of these complex lipids using conventional methods, however, suffers from limited resolution and frequently proves unable to discern subtle yet biologically significant features such as unsaturation sites or acyl chain position assignments. Here, we describe the synergistic use of chemical derivatization and hybrid dissociation techniques to characterize CL from complex biological mixtures with both double bond and sn positional isomer resolution in a shotgun mass spectrometry strategy. Utilizing (trimethylsilyl)diazomethane (TMSD), CL phosphate groups were methylated to promote positive-mode ionization by the production of metal-cationized lipids, enabling structural interrogation via hybrid higher-energy collisional activation/ultraviolet photodissociation (HCD/UVPD). This combination of TMSD derivatization and HCD/UVPD fragmentation results in diagnostic product ions that permit distinction and relative quantitation of sn-stereoisomers and the localization of double bonds. Applying this strategy to a total lipid extract from a thyroid carcinoma revealed a previously unreported 18:2/18:1 motif, elucidating a structural feature unique to the lipid class.