Valinophos Reveals a New Route in Microbial Phosphonate Biosynthesis That Is Broadly Conserved in Nature

Biosynthesis of Bacillus Phosphonoalamides Reveals Highly Specific Amino Acid Ligation

Phosphonate natural products have a history of commercial success across numerous industries due to their potent inhibition of metabolic processes. Over the past decade, genome mining approaches have successfully led to the discovery of numerous bioactive phosphonates. However, continued success is dependent upon a greater understanding of phosphonate metabolism, which will enable the prioritization and prediction of biosynthetic gene clusters for targeted isolation. Here, we report the complete biosynthetic pathway for phosphonoalamides E and F, antimicrobial phosphonopeptides with a conserved C-terminal l-phosphonoalanine (PnAla) residue. These peptides, produced by Bacillus, are the direct result of PnAla biosynthesis and serial ligation by two ATP-grasp ligases. A critical step of this pathway was the reversible transamination of phosphonopyruvate to PnAla by a dedicated transaminase with preference for the forward reaction. The dipeptide ligase PnfA was shown to ligate alanine to PnAla to afford phosphonoalamide E, which was subsequently ligated to alanine by PnfB to form phosphonoalamide F. Specificity profiling of both ligases found each to be highly specific, although the limited acceptance of noncanonical substrates by PnfA allowed for in vitro formation of products incorporating alternative pharmacophores. Our findings further establish the transaminative branch of phosphonate metabolism, unveil insights into the specificity of ATP-grasp ligation, and highlight the biocatalytic potential of biosynthetic enzymes.

Phosphonoalamides Reveal the Biosynthetic Origin of Phosphonoalanine Natural Products and a Convergent Pathway for Their Diversification

Phosphonate natural products, with their potent inhibitory activity, have found widespread use across multiple industries. Their success has inspired development of genome mining approaches that continue to reveal previously unknown bioactive scaffolds and biosynthetic insights. However, a greater understanding of phosphonate metabolism is required to enable prediction of compounds and their bioactivities from sequence information alone. Here, we expand our knowledge of this natural product class by reporting the complete biosynthesis of the phosphonoalamides, antimicrobial tripeptides with a conserved N-terminal l-phosphonoalanine (PnAla) residue produced by Streptomyces. The phosphonoalamides result from the convergence of PnAla biosynthesis and peptide ligation pathways. We elucidate the biochemistry underlying the transamination of phosphonopyruvate to PnAla, a new early branchpoint in phosphonate biosynthesis catalyzed by an aminotransferase with evolved specificity for phosphonate metabolism. Peptide formation is catalyzed by two ATP-grasp ligases, the first of which produces dipeptides, and a second which ligates dipeptides to PnAla to produce phosphonoalamides. Substrate specificity profiling revealed a dramatic expansion of dipeptide and tripeptide products, while finding PnaC to be the most promiscuous dipeptide ligase reported thus far. Our findings highlight previously unknown transformations in natural product biosynthesis, promising enzyme biocatalysts, and unveil insights into the diversity of phosphonopeptide natural products.

Discovery of Antimicrobial Phosphonopeptide Natural Products from Bacillus velezensis by Genome Mining

Phosphonate natural products are renowned for inhibitory activities which underly their development as antibiotics and pesticides. Although most phosphonate natural products have been isolated from Streptomyces, bioinformatic surveys suggest that many other bacterial genera are replete with similar biosynthetic potential. While mining actinobacterial genomes, we encountered a contaminated Mycobacteroides data set which included a biosynthetic gene cluster predicted to produce novel phosphonate compounds. Sequence deconvolution revealed that the contig containing this cluster, as well as many others, belonged to a contaminating Bacillus and is broadly conserved among multiple species, including the epiphyte Bacillus velezensis. Isolation and structure elucidation revealed a new di- and tripeptide composed of l-alanine and a C-terminal l-phosphonoalanine which we name phosphonoalamides E and F. These compounds exhibit broad-spectrum antibacterial activity, including strong inhibition against the agricultural pests responsible for vegetable soft rot (Erwinia rhapontici), onion rot (Pantoea ananatis), and American foulbrood (Paenibacillus larvae). This work expands our knowledge of phosphonate metabolism and underscores the importance of including underexplored microbial taxa in natural product discovery. IMPORTANCE Phosphonate natural products produced by bacteria have been a rich source of clinical antibiotics and commercial pesticides. Here, we describe the discovery of two new phosphonopeptides produced by B. velezensis with antibacterial activity against human and plant pathogens, including those responsible for widespread soft rot in crops and American foulbrood. Our results provide new insight on the natural chemical diversity of phosphonates and suggest that these compounds could be developed as effective antibiotics for use in medicine or agriculture.

A Novel Pathway for Biosynthesis of the Herbicidal Phosphonate Natural Product Phosphonothrixin Is Widespread in Actinobacteria

Phosphonothrixin is an herbicidal phosphonate natural product with an unusual, branched carbon skeleton. Bioinformatic analyses of the ftx gene cluster, which is responsible for synthesis of the compound, suggest that early steps of the biosynthetic pathway, up to production of the intermediate 2,3-dihydroxypropylphosphonic acid (DHPPA) are identical to those of the unrelated phosphonate natural product valinophos. This conclusion was strongly supported by the observation of biosynthetic intermediates from the shared pathway in spent media from two phosphonothrixin producing strains. Biochemical characterization of ftx-encoded proteins confirmed these early steps, as well as subsequent steps involving the oxidation of DHPPA to 3-hydroxy-2-oxopropylphosphonate and its conversion to phosphonothrixin by the combined action of an unusual heterodimeric, thiamine-pyrophosphate (TPP)-dependent ketotransferase and a TPP-dependent acetolactate synthase. The frequent observation of ftx-like gene clusters within actinobacteria suggests that production of compounds related to phosphonothrixin is common within these bacteria. IMPORTANCE Phosphonic acid natural products, such as phosphonothrixin, have great potential for biomedical and agricultural applications; however, discovery and development of these compounds requires detailed knowledge of the metabolism involved in their biosynthesis. The studies reported here reveal the biochemical pathway phosphonothrixin production, which enhances our ability to design strains that overproduce this potentially useful herbicide. This knowledge also improves our ability to predict the products of related biosynthetic gene clusters and the functions of homologous enzymes.

The functional importance of bacterial oxidative phosphonate pathways

Organophosphonates (Pns) are a unique class of natural products characterized by a highly stable C-P bond. Pns exhibit a wide array of interesting structures as well as useful bioactivities ranging from antibacterial to herbicidal. More structurally simple Pns are scavenged and catabolized by bacteria as a source of phosphorus. Despite their environmental and industrial importance, the pathways involved in the metabolism of Pns are far from being fully elucidated. Pathways that have been characterized often reveal unusual chemical transformations and new enzyme mechanisms. Among these, oxidative enzymes play an outstanding role during the biosynthesis and degradation of Pns. They are to a high extent responsible for the structural diversity of Pn secondary metabolites and for the break-down of both man-made and biogenic Pns. Here, we review our current understanding of the importance of oxidative enzymes for microbial Pn metabolism, discuss the underlying mechanistic principles, similarities, and differences between pathways. This review illustrates Pn biochemistry to involve a mix of classical redox biochemistry and unique oxidative reactions, including ring formations, rearrangements, and desaturations. Many of these reactions are mediated by specialized iron-dependent oxygenases and oxidases. Such enzymes are the key to both early pathway diversification and late-stage functionalization of complex Pns.

A Novel Biosynthetic Gene Cluster Across the Pantoea Species Complex Is Important for Pathogenicity in Onion

Onion center rot is caused by at least four species of genus Pantoea (P. ananatis, P. agglomerans, P. allii, and P. stewartii subsp. indologenes). Critical onion pathogenicity determinants for P. ananatis were recently described, but whether those determinants are common among other onion-pathogenic Pantoea species remains unknown. In this work, we report onion pathogenicity determinants in P. stewartii subsp. indologenes and P. allii. We identified two distinct secondary metabolite biosynthetic gene clusters present separately in different strains of onion-pathogenic P. stewartii subsp. indologenes. One cluster is similar to the previously described HiVir phosphonate biosynthetic cluster identified in P. ananatis and another is a novel putative phosphonate biosynthetic gene cluster, which we named Halophos. The Halophos gene cluster was also identified in P. allii strains. Both clusters are predicted to be phosphonate biosynthetic clusters based on the presence of a characteristic phosphoenolpyruvate phosphomutase (pepM) gene. The deletion of the pepM gene from either HiVir or Halophos clusters in P. stewartii subsp. indologenes caused loss of necrosis on onion leaves and red onion scales and resulted in significantly lower bacterial populations compared with the corresponding wild-type and complemented strains. Seven (halB to halH) of 11 genes (halA to halK) in the Halophos gene cluster are required for onion necrosis phenotypes. The onion nonpathogenic strain PNA15-2 (P. stewartii subsp. indologenes) gained the capacity to cause foliar necrosis on onion via exogenous expression of a minimal seven-gene Halophos cluster (genes halB to halH). Furthermore, cell-free culture filtrates of PNA14-12 expressing the intact Halophos gene cluster caused necrosis on onion leaves consistent with the presence of a secreted toxin. Based on the similarity of proteins to those with experimentally determined functions, we are able to predict most of the steps in Halophos biosynthesis. Together, these observations indicate that production of the toxin phosphonate seems sufficient to account for virulence of a variety of different Pantoea strains, although strains differ in possessing a single but distinct phosphonate biosynthetic cluster. Overall, this is the first report of onion pathogenicity determinants in P. stewartii subsp. indologenes and P. allii. [Formula: see text] Copyright © 2023 The Author(s). This is an open access article distributed under the CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 International license.

Convergent and divergent biosynthetic strategies towards phosphonic acid natural products

The phosphonate class of natural products have received significant interests in the post-genomic era due to the relative ease with which their biosynthetic genes may be identified and the resultant final products be characterized. Recent large-scale studies of the elucidation and distributions of phosphonate pathways have provided a robust landscape for deciphering the underlying biosynthetic logic. A recurrent theme in phosphonate biosynthetic pathways is the interweaving of enzymatic reactions across different routes, which enables diversification to elaborate chemically novel scaffolds. Here, we provide a few vignettes of how Nature has utilized both convergent and divergent biosynthetic strategies to compile pathways for production of novel phosphonates. These examples illustrate how common intermediates may either be generated or intercepted to diversify chemical scaffolds and provides a starting point for both biotechnological and synthetic biological applications towards new phosphonates by similar combinatorial approaches.

Complete Biosynthetic Pathway of the Phosphonate Phosphonothrixin: Two Distinct Thiamine Diphosphate-Dependent Enzymes Divide the Work to Form a C-C Bond

Phosphonates often exhibit biological activities by mimicking the phosphates and carboxylates of biological molecules. The phosphonate phosphonothrixin (PTX), produced by the soil-dwelling bacterium Saccharothrix sp. ST-888, exhibits herbicidal activity. In this study, we propose a complete biosynthetic pathway for PTX by reconstituting its biosynthesis in vitro. Our intensive analysis demonstrated that two dehydrogenases together reduce phosphonopyruvate (PnPy) to 2-hydroxy-3-phosphonopropanoic acid (HPPA) to accelerate the thermodynamically unfavorable rearrangement of phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) to PnPy. The next four enzymes convert HPPA to (3-hydroxy-2-oxopropyl)phosphonic acid (HOPA). In the final stage of PTX biosynthesis, the "split-gene" transketolase homologue, PtxB5/6, catalyzes the transfer of a two-carbon unit attached to the thiamine diphosphate (TPP) cofactor (provided by the acetohydroxyacid synthase homologue, PtxB7) to HOPA to produce PTX. This study reveals a unique C-C bond formation in which two distinct TPP-dependent enzymes, PtxB5/6 and PtxB7, divide the work to transfer an acetyl group, highlighting an unprecedented biosynthetic strategy for natural products.