Ultrafast Fluctuations of High Amplitude Electric Fields in Lipid Membranes

Lipid Landscapes: Vibrational Spectroscopy for Decoding Membrane Complexity

Cell membranes are incredibly complex environments containing hundreds of components. Despite substantial advances in the past decade, fundamental questions related to lipid-lipid interactions and heterogeneity persist. This review explores the complexity of lipid membranes, showcasing recent advances in vibrational spectroscopy to characterize the structure, dynamics, and interactions at the membrane interface. We include an overview of modern techniques such as surface-enhanced infrared spectroscopy as a steady-state technique with single-bilayer sensitivity, two-dimensional sum-frequency generation spectroscopy, and two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy to measure time-evolving structures and dynamics with femtosecond time resolution. Furthermore, we discuss the potential of multiscale molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, focusing on recently developed simulation algorithms, which have emerged as a powerful approach to interpret complex spectra. We highlight the ongoing challenges in studying heterogeneous environments in multicomponent membranes via current vibrational spectroscopic techniques and MD simulations. Overall, this review provides an up-to-date comprehensive overview of the powerful combination of vibrational spectroscopy and simulations, which has great potential to illuminate lipid-lipid, lipid-protein, and lipid-water interactions in the intricate conformational landscape of cell membranes.

Cholesterol Changes Interfacial Water Alignment in Model Cell Membranes

The nanoscopic layer of water that directly hydrates biological membranes plays a critical role in maintaining the cell structure, regulating biochemical processes, and managing intermolecular interactions at the membrane interface. Therefore, comprehending the membrane structure, including its hydration, is essential for understanding the chemistry of life. While cholesterol is a fundamental lipid molecule in mammalian cells, influencing both the structure and dynamics of cell membranes, its impact on the structure of interfacial water has remained unknown. We used surface-specific vibrational sum-frequency generation spectroscopy to study the effect of cholesterol on the structure and hydration of monolayers of the lipids 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPPC), 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC), and egg sphingomyelin (SM). We found that for the unsaturated lipid DOPC, cholesterol intercalates in the membrane without significantly changing the orientation of the lipid tails and the orientation of the water molecules hydrating the headgroups of DOPC. In contrast, for the saturated lipids DPPC and SM, the addition of cholesterol leads to clearly enhanced packing and ordering of the hydrophobic tails. It is also observed that the orientation of the water hydrating the lipid headgroups is enhanced upon the addition of cholesterol. These results are important because the orientation of interfacial water molecules influences the cell membranes' dipole potential and the strength and specificity of interactions between cell membranes and peripheral proteins and other biomolecules. The lipid nature-dependent role of cholesterol in altering the arrangement of interfacial water molecules offers a fresh perspective on domain-selective cellular processes, such as protein binding.

Perturbation of Fermi Resonance on Hydrogen-Bonded > C═O: 2D IR Studies of Small Ester Probes

We utilized linear and 2D infrared spectroscopy to analyze the carbonyl stretching modes of small esters in different solvents. Particularly noteworthy were the distinct carbonyl spectral line shapes in aqueous solutions, prompting our investigation of the underlying factors responsible for these differences. Through our experimental and theoretical calculations, we identified the presence of the hydrogen-bond-induced Fermi resonance as the primary contributor to the varied line shapes of small esters in aqueous solutions. Furthermore, our findings revealed that the skeletal deformation mode plays a crucial role in the Fermi resonance for all small esters. Specifically, the first overtone band of the skeletal deformation mode intensifies when hydrogen bonds form with the carbonyl group of esters, whereas such coupling is rare in aprotic organic solvents. These spectral insights carry significant implications for the utilization of esters as infrared probes in both biological and chemical systems.

Ultrafast Spectroscopy Reveals Slow Water Dynamics in Biocondensates

Cells achieve high spatiotemporal control over biochemical processes through compartmentalization to membrane-bound as well as membraneless organelles that assemble by liquid-liquid phase separation. Characterizing the balance of forces within these environments is essential to understanding their stability and function, and water is an integral part of the condensate, playing an important role in mediating electrostatic and hydrogen-bonding interactions. Here, we investigate the ultrafast, picosecond hydrogen-bond dynamics of a model biocondensate consisting of a peptide poly-l-arginine (Poly-R) and the nucleic acid adenosine monophosphate (AMP) using coherent two-dimensional infrared (2D IR) spectroscopy. We investigated three vibrational modes: the arginine side-chain C═N stretches, an AMP ring mode, and the amide backbone carbonyl stretching modes. Dynamics slow considerably between the dilute phase and the condensate phase for each vibrational probe. For example, the arginine side-chain C═N modes slow from 0.38 to 2.26 ps due to strong electrostatic interactions. All-atom molecular dynamics simulations provide an atomistic interpretation of the H-bond network disruption resulting from electrostatic contributions as well as collapse within the condensate. Simulations predict that a fraction of water molecules are highly constrained within the condensate, explaining the observed slowdown in the H-bond dynamics.

Probing the Hydrophobic Region of a Lipid Bilayer at Specific Depths Using Vibrational Spectroscopy

A novel spectroscopic approach for studying the flexibility and mobility in the hydrophobic interior of lipid bilayers at specific depths is proposed. A set of test compounds featuring an azido moiety and a cyano or carboxylic acid moiety, connected by an alkyl chain of different lengths, was synthesized. FTIR data and molecular dynamics calculations indicated that the test compounds in a bilayer are oriented so that the cyano or carboxylic acid moiety is located in the lipid head-group region, while the azido group stays inside the bilayer at the depth determined by its alkyl chain length. We found that the asymmetric stretching mode of the azido group (νN3) can serve as a reporter of the membrane interior dynamics. FTIR and two-dimensional infrared (2DIR) studies were performed at different temperatures, ranging from 22 to 45 °C, covering the Lβ-Lα phase transition temperature of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (∼41 °C). The width of the νN3 peak was found to be very sensitive to the phase transition and to the temperature in general. We introduced an order parameter, SN3, which characterizes restrictions to motion inside the bilayer. 2DIR spectra of νN3 showed different extents of inhomogeneity at different depths in the bilayer, with the smallest inhomogeneity in the middle of the leaflet. The spectral diffusion dynamics of the N3 peak was found to be dependent on the depth of the N3 group location in the bilayer. The obtained results enhance our understanding of the bilayer dynamics and can be extended to investigate membranes with more complex compositions.

Sponge-phase Lipid Droplets as Synthetic Organelles: An Ultrafast Study of Hydrogen Bonding and Interfacial Environments

Bottom-up design of biomimetic organelles has gained recent attention as a route towards understanding the transition between non-living matter and life. Despite various artificial lipid membranes being developed, the specific relations between lipid structure, composition, interfacial properties, and morphology are not currently understood. Sponge-phase droplets contain dense, nonlamellar lipid bilayer networks that capture the complexities of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), making them ideal artificial models of such organelles. Here, we combine ultrafast two-dimensional infrared (2D IR) spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations to investigate the interfacial H-bond networks in sponge-phase droplets composed of glycolipid and nonionic detergents. In the sponge phase, the interfacial environments are more hydrated and water molecules confined to the nanometer-scale aqueous channels in the sponge phase exhibit dynamics that are significantly slower compared to bulk water. Surfactant configurations and microscopic phase separation play a dominant role in determining membrane curvature and slow dynamics observed in the sponge phase. The studies suggest that H-bond networks within the nanometer-scale channels are disrupted not only by confinement but also by the interactions of surfactants, which extend 1-2 nm from the bilayer surface. The results provide a molecular-level description for controlling phase and morphology in the design of synthetic lipid organelles.

Electric-driven membrane poration: A rationale for water role in the kinetics of pore formation

Electroporation is a well-established technique used to stimulate cells, enhancing membrane permeability by inducing reversible membrane pores. In the absence of experimental observation of the dynamics of pore creation, molecular dynamics studies provide the molecular-level evidence that the electric field promotes pore formation. Although single steps in the pore formation process are well assessed, a kinetic model representing the mathematical description of the electroporation process, is lacking. In the present work we studied the basis of the pore formation process, providing a rationale for the definition of a first-order kinetic scheme. Here, authors propose a three-state kinetic model for the process based on the assessed mechanism of water defects intruding at the water/lipid interface, when applying electric field intensities at the edge of the linear regime. The methodology proposed is based on the use of two robust biophysical quantities analyzed for the water molecules intruding at the water/lipid interface: (i) number of hydrogen bonds; (ii) number of contacts. The final model, sustained by a robust statistical sampling, provides kinetic constants for the transitions from the intact bilayer state to the hydrophobic pore state.

Pump Slice Amplitudes: A Simple and Robust Method for Connecting Two-Dimensional Infrared and Fourier Transform Infrared Spectra

Ultrafast two-dimensional infrared (2D IR) spectroscopy and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy are often performed in tandem, with FTIR typically used to interpret and provide hypotheses for 2D IR experiments. Comparisons between 2D IR and FTIR spectra can also be used to examine the structure and orientation in systems of coupled vibrational chromophores. The most common method for comparing 2D IR and FTIR lineshapes, the diagonal slice method, contains significant artifacts when applied to oscillators with low anharmonicities. Here, we introduce a new technique, the pump slice amplitude (PSA) method, for relating 2D IR lineshapes to FTIR lineshapes and compare PSAs against diagonal slices using theoretical and experimental spectra. We find that PSAs are significantly more similar to FTIR lineshapes than diagonal slices in systems with low anharmonicity.

Ultrafast Dynamics at Lipid-Water Interfaces

Lipid membranes are more than just barriers between cell compartments; they provide molecular environments with a finely tuned balance between hydrophilic and hydrophobic interactions that enable proteins to dynamically fold and self-assemble to regulate biological function. Characterizing dynamics at the lipid-water interface is essential to understanding molecular complexities from the thermodynamics of liquid-liquid phase separation down to picosecond-scale reorganization of interfacial hydrogen-bond networks.Ultrafast vibrational spectroscopy, including two-dimensional infrared (2D IR) and vibrational sum-frequency generation (VSFG) spectroscopies, is a powerful tool to examine picosecond interfacial dynamics. Two-dimensional IR spectroscopy provides a bond-centered view of dynamics with subpicosecond time resolutions, as vibrational frequencies are highly sensitive to the local environment. Recently, 2D IR spectroscopy has been applied to carbonyl and phosphate vibrations intrinsically located at the lipid-water interface. Interface-specific VSFG spectroscopy probes the water vibrational modes directly, accessing H-bond strength and water organization at lipid headgroup positions. Signals in VSFG arise from the interfacial dipole contributions, directly probing headgroup ordering and water orientation to provide a structural view of the interface.In this Account we discuss novel applications of ultrafast spectroscopy to lipid membranes, a field that has experienced significant growth over the past decade. In particular, ultrafast experiments now offer a molecular perspective on increasingly complex membranes. The powerful combination of ultrafast, interface-selective spectroscopy and simulations opens up new routes to understanding multicomponent membranes and their function. This Account highlights key prevailing views that have emerged from recent experiments: (1) Water dynamics at the lipid-water interface are slow compared to those of bulk water as a result of disrupted H-bond networks near the headgroups. (2) Peptides, ions, osmolytes, and cosolvents perturb interfacial dynamics, indicating that dynamics at the interface are affected by bulk solvent dynamics and vice versa. (3) The interfacial environment is generally dictated by the headgroup structure and orientation, but hydrophobic interactions within the acyl chains also modulate interfacial dynamics. Ultrafast spectroscopy has been essential to characterizing the biophysical chemistry of the lipid-water interface; however, challenges remain in interpreting congested spectra as well as designing appropriate model systems to capture the complexity of a membrane environment.

Ultrafast Dynamics at the Lipid-Water Interface: DMSO Modulates H-Bond Lifetimes

Dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) is a common cosolvent and cryopreservation agent used to freeze cells and tissues. DMSO alters the H-bond structure of water, but its interactions with biomolecules and, specifically, with biological interfaces remain poorly understood. Here we investigate the effects of DMSO on the H-bond dynamics at the lipid-water interface using a combination of ultrafast two-dimensional infrared (2D IR) spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations. Ester carbonyl absorption spectra show that DMSO dehydrates the interface, and simulations show that the area per lipid is decreased. Ultrafast 2D IR spectra measure the time scales of frequency fluctuations at the ester carbonyl positions located precisely between the hydrophobic and hydrophilic regions of the membrane. 2D IR measurements show that low DMSO concentrations (<10 mol %) induce ∼40% faster H-bond dynamics compared with pure water, whereas increased concentrations (>10-20 mol %) once again slow down the dynamics. This slow-fast-slow trend is described in terms of two different solvation regimes. Below 10 mol %, DMSO weakens the interfacial H bond, leading to faster "bulk-like" dynamics, whereas above 10 mol %, water molecules become "relatively immobilized" as the H-bond networks becoming disrupted by the H-bond donor/acceptor imbalance at the interface. These studies are an important step toward characterizing the environments around lipid membranes, which are essential to numerous biological processes.

Ultrafast Spectroscopy of Lipid-Water Interfaces: Transmembrane Crowding Drives H-Bond Dynamics

Biology takes place in crowded, heterogeneous environments, and it is therefore essential to account for crowding effects in our understanding of biophysical processes at the molecular level. Comparable to the cytosol, proteins occupy approximately 30% of the plasma membrane surface; thus, crowding should have an effect on the local structure and dynamics at the lipid-water interface. Using a combination of ultrafast two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations, we quantify the effects of membrane peptide concentration on the picosecond interfacial H-bond dynamics. The measurements reveal a nonmonotonic dependence of water orientation and dynamics as a function of transmembrane peptide:lipid ratio. We observe three dynamical regimes: a "pure lipid-like" regime at low peptide concentrations, a bulk-like region at intermediate peptide concentrations where dynamics are faster by ∼20% compared to those of the pure lipid bilayer, and a crowded regime where high peptide concentrations slow dynamics by ∼50%.

Calcium-Lipid Interactions Observed with Isotope-Edited Infrared Spectroscopy

Calcium ions bind to lipid membranes containing anionic lipids; however, characterizing the specific ion-lipid interactions in multicomponent membranes has remained challenging because it requires nonperturbative lipid-specific probes. Here, using a combination of isotope-edited infrared spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations, we characterize the effects of a physiologically relevant (2 mM) Ca²⁺ concentration on zwitterionic phosphatidylcholine and anionic phosphatidylserine lipids in mixed lipid membranes. We show that Ca²⁺ alters hydrogen bonding between water and lipid headgroups by forming a coordination complex involving the lipid headgroups and water. These interactions distort interfacial water orientations and prevent hydrogen bonding with lipid ester carbonyls. We demonstrate, experimentally, that these effects are more pronounced for the anionic phosphatidylserine lipids than for zwitterionic phosphatidylcholine lipids in the same membrane.

Infrared Difference Spectroscopy of Proteins: From Bands to Bonds

Infrared difference spectroscopy probes vibrational changes of proteins upon their perturbation. Compared with other spectroscopic methods, it stands out by its sensitivity to the protonation state, H-bonding, and the conformation of different groups in proteins, including the peptide backbone, amino acid side chains, internal water molecules, or cofactors. In particular, the detection of protonation and H-bonding changes in a time-resolved manner, not easily obtained by other techniques, is one of the most successful applications of IR difference spectroscopy. The present review deals with the use of perturbations designed to specifically change the protein between two (or more) functionally relevant states, a strategy often referred to as reaction-induced IR difference spectroscopy. In the first half of this contribution, I review the technique of reaction-induced IR difference spectroscopy of proteins, with special emphasis given to the preparation of suitable samples and their characterization, strategies for the perturbation of proteins, and methodologies for time-resolved measurements (from nanoseconds to minutes). The second half of this contribution focuses on the spectral interpretation. It starts by reviewing how changes in H-bonding, medium polarity, and vibrational coupling affect vibrational frequencies, intensities, and bandwidths. It is followed by band assignments, a crucial aspect mostly performed with the help of isotopic labeling and site-directed mutagenesis, and complemented by integration and interpretation of the results in the context of the studied protein, an aspect increasingly supported by spectral calculations. Selected examples from the literature, predominately but not exclusively from retinal proteins, are used to illustrate the topics covered in this review.

Application of a transparent window vibrational probe (azido probe) to the structural dynamics of model dipeptides and amyloid β-peptide

The azido asymmetric stretching motion is widely used for the elucidation of the intrinsic conformational preference and folding mechanism of protein since it has strong vibrational absorbance in the spectral transparent windows. However, the possible secondary structural disturbance induced by the insertion of azido group in the side chain of polypeptides should be carefully evaluated. Here, DFT calculation and enhanced sampling method were employed for model dipeptides with or without azido substitution, and the outcome results show that the lower potential energy basins of isolated model dipeptides are consistent with the preferred structural distributions of model dipeptides in aqueous solution. The azido asymmetric stretching frequency shows its sensitivity to the backbone configurations just like amide-I vibration does, and the azido vibration exhibits great potential as a structural reporter in the transparent window. For the evaluation of the application of azido group in biologically related system, the structural dynamics of Aβ_37-42 and N₃-Aβ_37-42 fragments and the self-assemble process of their protofiliments in aqueous solution were demonstrated. The outcome results show that the structural fluctuations of Aβ_37-42 and its protofilament in aqueous solution are quite similar with or without azido substitution, and the dewetting transitions of Aβ_37-42 and N₃-Aβ_37-42 β-sheet layers are both complete within 30 ns and assemble into stable protofilaments. Therefore, the azido asymmetric vibrational motion is a minimally invasive structural probe and would not introduce much disturbance to the structural dynamics of polypeptides.

Dynamic structure factor of a lipid bilayer in the presence of a high electric field

The influence of a high average electric field (∼1 V/nm) in the hydrophobic interior of a bilayer lipid membrane on short-wavelength in-plane phononic motions of lipid chains is considered. The average electric field is assumed to be nearly constant on a picosecond time scale and a nanometer length scale. This field may be induced, for instance, by externally applied subnanosecond electric pulses or the membrane dipole potential. Using a generalized hydrodynamic approach, we derive a corresponding electrohydrodynamic model generalized to high wave numbers. In the considered approximation, all electric field effects are reduced only to a constant contribution to the generalized isothermal compressibility modulus. The corresponding dynamic structure factor for a lipid bilayer is derived. We show that due to polarization effects, the high field can critically impact the dynamics of longitudinal acousticlike modes at wave numbers near the major peak of the static structure factor. We estimate quantitatively that for typical lipid bilayers, transverse high electric fields can cause strong phonon energy softening, enhancement of phonon population, and formation of a gap in the dispersion of excitation frequency. The results obtained agree with simulations of the initiation of lipid bilayer electropores, suggesting that the proposed model reproduces the essential features of the field's impact on atomic density fluctuations. The proposed mechanism may have significant implications for the understanding of electroporation, passive molecular transport, and spontaneous pore formation in lipid bilayers.

Mapping the amide-I vibrations of model dipeptides with secondary structure sensitivity and amino acid residue specificity, and its application to amyloid β-peptide in aqueous solution

Vibrational spectroscopy has been known as particularly well-suited for deciphering the polypeptide's structure. To decode structural information encoded in IR spectra, we developed amide-I frequency maps on the basis of model dipeptides to correlate the amide-I frequency of interest to the combination of the calculated secondary structure dependent amide-I frequency by using DFT method and the electrostatic potentials that projected onto the amide unit from the micro-environment within molecular mechanics force field. The constructed maps were applied to model dipeptides and amyloid β-peptide fragment (Aβ_25-35). The dipeptide specified map (DS map) and the hybrid map (HYB map) predicted amide-I bands of Aβ_25-35 in solution satisfactorily reproduce experimental observation, and indicate the preference of forming β-sheet and random coil structure for Aβ_25-35 in D₂O just as the results of cluster analysis suggested. These maps with secondary structural sensitivity and amino acid residue specificity open up a way for the interpretation of amide-I vibrations and show their potentials in the understanding of molecular structure of polypeptides in solution.

Intensified C≡C Stretching Vibrator and Its Potential Role in Monitoring Ultrafast Energy Transfer in 2D Carbon Material by Nonlinear Vibrational Spectroscopy

In this work, an intensity-enhanced C≡C stretching infrared (IR) absorption is observed in hexakis[(trimethylsilyl)ethynyl]benzene (HTEB), whose IR transition dipole magnitude becomes comparable to that of a typical C═O stretch, and the enhancement is believed to be due to a joint effect of π-π conjugation and hyperconjugation associated with a terminal trimethylsilyl group. Using dynamical time-dependent two-dimensional infrared (2D IR) spectroscopy, a picosecond intramolecular energy redistribution process is observed between two nondegenerate C≡C stretching modes, whose symmetry breaking is attributed to a noncovalent halogen-bonding interaction between HTEB and solvent CH₂Cl₂. The rigid structure of HTEB and limited structural dynamics are also inferred from the insignificant initial spectral diffusion value extracted from the 2D IR spectra. This work provides the first nonlinear infrared investigation of the conventionally weak C≡C stretch. The methods outlined are particularly important for detailed understanding of the structure-related processes such as vibrational energy transfer in novel C≡C species containing materials such as graphdiyne.

Quantifying conformations of ester vibrational probes with hydrogen-bond-induced Fermi resonances

Solvatochromic shifts of local vibrational probes report on the strength of the surrounding electric fields and the probe's hydrogen bonding status. Stretching vibrational mode of the ester carbonyl group is a popular solvatochromic reporter used in the studies of peptides and proteins. Small molecules, used to calibrate the response of the vibrational probes, sometimes involve Fermi resonances (FRs) induced by inter-molecular interactions. In the present work, we focus on the scenario where FR does not appear in the infrared spectrum of the ester carbonyl stretching mode in aprotic solvents; however, it is intensified when a hydrogen bond with the reporter is established. When two molecules form hydrogen bonds to the same carbonyl oxygen atom, FR leads to strong hybridization of the involved modes and splitting of the absorption peak. Spectral overlap between the Fermi doublets associated with singly and doubly hydrogen-bonded carbonyl groups significantly complicates quantifying different hydrogen-bonded conformations. We employed a combination of linear and third-order (2DIR) infrared spectroscopy with chemometrics analysis to reveal the individual line shapes and to estimate the occupations of the hydrogen-bonded conformations in methyl acetate, a model small molecule. We identified a hydrogen-bond-induced FR in complexes of methyl acetate with alcohols and water and found that FR is lifted in larger molecules used for control experiments-cholesteryl stearate and methyl cyanoacetate. Applying this methodology to analyze acetonitrile-water solutions revealed that when dissolved in neat water, methyl acetate occupies a single hydrogen-bonding conformation, which is in contrast to the conclusions of previous studies. Our approach can be generally used when FRs prevent direct quantification of the hydrogen bonding status of the vibrational probe.

Physiological Calcium Concentrations Slow Dynamics at the Lipid-Water Interface

Phospholipids can interact strongly with ions at physiological concentrations, and these interactions can alter membrane properties. Here, we describe the effects of calcium ions on the dynamics in phospholipid membranes. We used a combination of time-resolved ultrafast two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations. We found that millimolar Ca2+ concentrations lead to slower fluctuations in the local environment at the lipid-water interface of membranes with phosphatidylserine. The effect was only observed in bilayers containing anionic phosphatidylserine; membranes composed of only zwitterionic phosphatidylcholine did not experience a slowdown. Local water dynamics were measured using the ester groups as label-free probes and were found to be up to 50% slower with 2.5 mM Ca2+. Molecular dynamics simulations show that Ca2+ primarily binds to the carboxylate group of phosphatidylserines. These findings have implications for apoptotic and diseased cells in which phosphatidylserine is exposed to extracellular calcium and for the biophysical effects of divalent cations on lipid bilayers.

Time-resolved measurements of an ion channel conformational change driven by a membrane phase transition

Using temperature-jump infrared spectroscopy, we are able to trigger a gel-to-fluid phase transition in lipid vesicles and monitor in real time how a membrane protein responds to structural changes in the membrane. The melting of lipid domains in 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine vesicles is observed to occur in as fast as 50 ns, with a temperature dependence characteristic of critical slowing. Gramicidin D (gD) added to the membrane responds primarily to the change in thickness of the membrane on a timescale coincident with the membrane melting. Using structure-based spectral modeling, we assign the conformational changes to compression and rotation of a partially dissociated gD dimer. Free energy calculations indicate that the high rate is a result of near-barrierless diffusion on a protein energy landscape that is radically reshaped by membrane thinning. The structural changes associated with the phase transition are similar to the fluctuation modes of fluid phase membranes, highlighting the importance of understanding the dynamic nature of the membrane environment around proteins.