Formation of (HCOO–)(H2SO4) Anion Clusters: Violation of Gas-Phase Acidity Predictions

Understanding the Formation and Growth of New Atmospheric Particles at the Molecular Level through Laboratory Molecular Beam Experiments

Atmospheric new particle formation (NPF), which exerts comprehensive implications for climate, air quality and human health, has received extensive attention. From molecule to cluster is the initial and most important stage of the nucleation process of atmospheric new particles. However, due to the complexity of the nucleation process and limitations of experimental characterization techniques, there is still a great uncertainty in understanding the nucleation mechanism at the molecular level. Laboratory-based molecular beam methods can experimentally implement the generation and growth of typical atmospheric gas-phase nucleation precursors to nanoscale clusters, characterize the key physical and chemical properties of clusters such as structure and composition, and obtain a series of their physicochemical parameters, including association rate coefficients, electron binding energy, pickup cross section and pickup probability and so on. These parameters can quantitatively illustrate the physicochemical properties of the cluster, and evaluate the effect of different gas phase nucleation precursors on the formation and growth of atmospheric new particles. We review the present literatures on atmospheric cluster formation and reaction employing the experimental method of laboratory molecular beam. The experimental apparatuses were classified and summarized from three aspects of cluster generation, growth and detection processes. Focus of this review is on the properties of nucleation clusters involving different precursor molecules of water, sulfuric acid, nitric acid and NxOy, respectively. We hope this review will provide a deep insight for effects of cluster physicochemical properties on nucleation, and reveal the formation and growth mechanism of atmospheric new particle at the molecular level.

Investigation of the Proton-Bound Dimer of Dihydrogen Phosphate and Formate Using Infrared Spectroscopy in Helium Droplets

Understanding the structural and dynamic properties of proton-bound complexes is crucial for elucidating fundamental aspects of chemical reactivity and molecular interactions. In this work, the proton-bound complex between dihydrogen phosphate and formate, and its deuterated counterparts, is investigated using IR action spectroscopy in helium droplets. Contrary to the initial expectation that the stronger phosphoric acid would donate a proton to formate, both experiment and theory show that all exchangeable protons are located in the phosphate moiety. The experimental spectra show good agreement with both scaled harmonic and VPT2 anharmonic calculations, indicating that anharmonic effects are small. Some H-bending modes of the nondeuterated complex are found to be sensitive to the helium environment. In the case of the partially deuterated complexes, the experiments indicate that internal dynamics leads to isomeric interconversion upon IR excitation.

Location of the Shared Proton in Proton-Bound Dimer Compound of Hydrogen Sulfate and Formate: Path Integral Molecular Dynamics Study

The structure of the proton-bound dimer compound of hydrogen sulfate and formate has been studied by considering nuclear quantum effects (NQEs) using the path integral molecular dynamics method. This study unveiled the location of the shared proton and answered the following question: "Is the shared proton localized on either an anion or located around the center of two anions?" We have elucidated that the shared proton is distributed in the region beyond the transition state due to the NQEs, even though the shared proton did not completely overcome the transition state for the proton shuttle.

Hydrogen bond networks in gas-phase complex anions

Hydrogen bond networks (HBNs) have piqued the interest of the scientific community due to their crucial roles in nature. However, HBNs that are isolated from complicated backgrounds for unraveling their characteristics are still scarce. Herein, we propose that HBNs exist in complex anions formed between α-cyclodextrin (α-CD) and four benzoic acids (RBAs) in the gas phase. The complex anions are facilely extracted from solutions via the electrospray ionization technique, and subsequently activated through collision for the investigation of their transition dynamics. It is revealed that the generation of deprotonated α-CD and neutral RBAs is the unexpected dominant dissociation pathway for all the four complex anions, and the complex anions formed from more acidic RBAs exhibit higher stabilities. These dissociation results are successfully explained by the cooperative stretching dynamics of the proposed HBNs that are formed involving the intramolecular HBN of α-CD and the intermolecular hydrogen bonds (HBs) between α-CD and RBAs. Furthermore, the rarely observed low barrier HBs (LBHBs) are suggested to be present in the HBNs. It is believed that the present complex anions can serve as a facilely accessible and informative model for studying HBNs in the future.

Hydrogen bond networks and low barrier hydrogen bonds are demonstrated in the complex anions formed between α-cyclodextrin and benzoic acids.

Microsolvated Ion-Molecule SN2 Reactions with Dual Nucleophiles Induced by Solvent Molecules

Singly-hydrated HOO - anion was found to induce alternative nucleophile HO - via proton transfer from water molecule as react with CH 3 Cl recently. To investigate the generality of this effect, the competition between the solvent-induced HO - -S N 2 pathway and the normal HOO - -S N 2 pathway is studied for the microsolvated HOO - (H 2 O) n=1,2,3 + CH 3 X (X = F, Cl, Br, I) reaction by quantum chemistry calculation. Incremental hydration increases the barrier heights of both pathways and enlarges the barrier difference between them, which favors the HOO - -S N 2 pathway. Interestingly, the barrier difference is insensitive to the leaving group. Calculation shows the water induced HO - -S N 2 pathway is highly suppressed as the degree of hydration increases beyond two. The differential barrier under incremental hydration can be explained by solvent molecules stabilizing the HOMO level of HO - (HOOH)(H 2 O) n-1 nucleophile more than that of HOO - (H 2 O) n nucleophile. Comparison between these HO - -nucleophiles and HOO - -nucleophiles suggests that α-effect exists. Activation strain analysis attributes the barrier differences to the stronger distortion of the TS of HO - -S N 2 pathway than the counterparts of HOO - -S N 2 pathway. This work adds our understanding of the role of individual solvent molecules to induce new nucleophiles of the fundamental organic reaction.

Stabilizing the Exotic Carbonic Acid by Bisulfate Ion

Carbonic acid is an important species in a variety of fields and has long been regarded to be non-existing in isolated state, as it is thermodynamically favorable to decompose into water and carbon dioxide. In this work, we systematically studied a novel ionic complex [H₂CO₃·HSO₄]^- using density functional theory calculations, molecular dynamics simulations, and topological analysis to investigate if the exotic H₂CO₃ molecule could be stabilized by bisulfate ion, which is a ubiquitous ion in various environments. We found that bisulfate ion could efficiently stabilize all the three conformers of H₂CO₃ and reduce the energy differences of isomers with H₂CO₃ in three different conformations compared to the isolated H₂CO₃ molecule. Calculated isomerization pathways and ab initio molecular dynamics simulations suggest that all the optimized isomers of the complex have good thermal stability and could exist at finite temperatures. We also explored the hydrogen bonding properties in this interesting complex and simulated their harmonic infrared spectra to aid future infrared spectroscopic experiments. This work could be potentially important to understand the fate of carbonic acid in certain complex environments, such as in environments where both sulfuric acid (or rather bisulfate ion) and carbonic acid (or rather carbonic dioxide and water) exist.

Helium Nanodroplet Infrared Action Spectroscopy of the Proton-Bound Dimer of Hydrogen Sulfate and Formate: Examining Nuclear Quantum Effects

The proton-bound dimer of hydrogen sulfate and formate is an archetypal structure for ionic hydrogen-bonding complexes that contribute to biogenic aerosol nucleation. Of central importance for the structure and properties of this complex is the location of the bridging proton connecting the two conjugate base moieties. The potential energy surface for bridging proton translocation features two local minima, with the proton localized at either the formate or hydrogen sulfate moiety. However, electronic structure methods reveal a shallow potential energy surface governing proton translocation, with a barrier on the order of the zero-point energy. This shallow potential complicates structural assignment and necessitates a consideration of nuclear quantum effects. In this work, we probe the structure of this complex and its isotopologues, utilizing infrared (IR) action spectroscopy of ions captured in helium nanodroplets. The IR spectra indicate a structure in which a proton is shared between the hydrogen sulfate and formate moieties, HSO₄^-···H⁺···^-OOCH. However, because of the nuclear quantum effects and vibrational anharmonicities associated with the shallow potential for proton translocation, the extent of proton displacement from the formate moiety remains unclear, requiring further experiments or more advanced theoretical treatments for additional insight.

Hydration motifs of ammonium bisulfate clusters show complex temperature dependence

The role of water in the formation of particles from atmospheric trace gases is not well understood, in large part due to difficulties in detecting its presence under atmospheric conditions and the variety of possible structures that must be screened computationally. Here, we use infrared spectroscopy and variable-temperature ion trap mass spectrometry to investigate the structural motifs adopted by water bound to ammonium bisulfate clusters and their temperature dependence. For clusters featuring only acid-base linkages, water adopts a bridging arrangement spanning an adjacent ammonium and bisulfate. For larger clusters, water can also insert into a bisulfate-bisulfate hydrogen bond, yielding hydration isomers with very similar binding energies. The population of these isomers shows a complex temperature evolution, as an apparent third isomer appears with a temperature dependence that is difficult to explain using simple thermodynamic arguments. These observations suggest that the thermodynamics of water binding to atmospheric clusters such as these may not be straightforward.

Molecular Specificity and Proton Transfer Mechanisms in Aerosol Prenucleation Clusters Relevant to New Particle Formation

Atmospheric aerosol particles influence the Earth's radiative energy balance and cloud properties, thus impacting the air quality, human health, and Earth's climate change. Because of the important scientific and overarching practical implications of aerosols, the past two decades have seen extensive research efforts, with emphasis on the chemical compositions and underlying mechanisms of aerosol formation. It has been recognized that new particle formation (NPF) contributes up to 50% of atmospheric aerosols. Nowadays, the general consensus is that NPF proceeds via two distinct stages: the nucleation from gaseous precursors to form critical nuclei of sub-1-2 nm size, and the subsequent growth into large particles. However, a fundamental understanding of both the NPF process and molecular-level characterization of the critical size aerosol clusters is still largely missing, hampering the efforts in developing reliable and predictive aerosol nucleation and climate models.Both field measurements and laboratory experiments have gathered convincing evidence about the importance of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in enhancing the nucleation and growth of aerosol particles. Numerous and abundant small clusters composed of sulfuric acid or bisulfate ion and organic molecules have been shown to exist in ∼2 nm sized aerosol particles. In particular, kinetic studies indicated the formation of clusters with one H₂SO₄ and one or two organics being the rate-limiting step.This Account discusses our effort in developing an integrated approach, which involves the laboratory cluster synthesis via electrospray ionization, size and composition analysis via mass spectrometry, photoelectron spectroscopic characterization, and quantum mechanics based theoretical modeling, to investigate the structures, energetics, and thermodynamics of the aerosol prenucleation clusters relevant to NPF. We have been focusing on the clusters formed between H₂SO₄ or HSO₄^- and the organics from oxidation of both biogenic and anthropogenic emissions. We illustrated the significant thermodynamic advantage by involving organic acids in the formation and growth of aerosol clusters. We revealed that the functional groups in the organics play critical roles in promoting NPF process. The enhanced roles were quantified explicitly for specific functional groups, establishing a Molecular Scale that ranks highly hierarchic intermolecular interactions critical to aerosol formation. The different cluster formation pathways, probably mimicking the various polluted industrial environments, that involve cis-pinonic and cis-pinic acids were unveiled as well. Furthermore, one intriguing fundamental phenomenon on the unusual protonation pattern, which violates the gas-phase acidity (proton affinity) prediction, was discovered to be common in sulfuric acid-organic clusters. The mechanism underlying the phenomenon has been rationalized by employing the temperature-dependent experiments of sulfuric acid-formate/halide model clusters, which could explain the high stability of the sulfuric acid containing aerosol clusters. Our work provides critical molecular-level information to shed light on the initial steps of nucleation of common atmospheric precursors and benchmarks critical data for large-scale theoretical modeling to further address problems of environmental interest.

Proton affinities of pertechnetate (TcO4-) and perrhenate (ReO4-)

The anions pertechnetate, TcO4-, and perrhenate, ReO4-, exhibit very similar chemical and physical properties. Revealing and understanding disparities between them enhances fundamental understanding of both. Electrospray ionization generated the gas-phase proton bound dimer (TcO4-)(H+)(ReO4-). Collision induced dissociation of the dimer yielded predominantly HTcO4 and ReO4-, which according to Cooks' kinetic method indicates that the proton affinity (PA) of TcO4- is greater than that of ReO4-. Density functional theory computations agree with the experimental observation, providing PA[TcO4-] = 300.1 kcal mol-1 and PA[ReO4-] = 297.2 kcal mol-1. Attempts to rationalize these relative PAs based on elementary molecular parameters such as atomic charges indicate that the entirety of bond formation and concomitant bond disruption needs to be considered to understand the energies associated with such protonation processes. Although in both the gas and solution phases, TcO4- is a stronger base than ReO4-, it is noted that the significance of even such qualitative accordance is tempered by the very different natures of the underlying phenomena.

An accurate single descriptor for ion-π interactions

Non-covalent interactions between ions and π systems play an important role in molecular recognition, catalysis and biology. To guide the screen and design for artificial hosts, catalysts and drug delivery, understanding the physical nature of ion-π complexes via descriptors is indispensable. However, even with multiple descriptors that contain the leading term of electrostatic and polarized interactions, the quantitative description for the binding energies (BEs) of ion-π complexes is still lacking because of the intrinsic shortcomings of the commonly used descriptors. Here, we have shown that the impartment of orbital details into the electrostatic energy (coined as OEE) makes an excellent single descriptor for BEs of not only spherical, but also multiply-shaped, ion-π systems, highlighting the importance of an accurate description of the electrostatic interactions. Our results have further demonstrated that OEEs from a low-level method could be calibrated to BEs from a high-level method, offering a powerful practical strategy for an accurate prediction of a set of ion-π interactions.

Determinants for proton location and electron coupled proton transfer in hydrogen bonded pentafluorophenol–anion clusters

This work reveals the determinant factors for proton locations and electron coupled proton transfer (ECPT) in biologically relevant hydrogen bonded systems.

Spectroscopic evidence for intact carbonic acid stabilized by halide anions in the gas phase

The whole series of halide anions can stabilize elusive carbonic acid in the gas phase through dual hydrogen bonds.

Spectroscopic Signature of Proton Location in Proton Bound HSO4-·H+·X- (X = F, Cl, Br, and I) Clusters

Proton transfer plays a vital role in a variety of chemical and biological processes. The proton location in proton bound clusters, specifically, in the anions of HSO₄^-·H⁺·X^- (X = F, Cl, Br, and I), has been studied by negative ion photoelectron spectroscopy and ab initio theoretical calculations. The measured photoelectron spectra of HSO₄^-·H⁺·X^- (X = Cl, Br, and I) closely resemble those of X^- by simply shifting to higher electron binding energies, suggesting that X^- is the chromophore of the electron photodetachment, a fact clearly violating gas-phase acidity predictions. However, in the X = F case, the spectrum of HSO₄^-·H⁺·F^- is more similar to that of HSO₄^-, indicating that H⁺ stays with F^- and that the HSO₄^- moiety carries the extra electron. Accompanying theoretical analyses are in excellent agreement with the experimental measurements and observations. This work provides direct spectroscopic evidence of the proton locations, clearly showing cases in which proton affinities of the constituent bases cannot correctly predict the right chemistry involving proton transfer processes.

Hydration motifs of ammonium bisulfate clusters of relevance to atmospheric new particle formation

We have analyzed the binding motifs of water bound to a prototypical cluster containing three ammonium cations and two bisulfate anions using mass-selective vibrational spectroscopy and quantum chemical calculations.

Negative influence of pKa on activation energy barrier: A case study for double proton transfer reaction in inorganic acid dimers

Strength of acid can be determined by means of pK_a value. Attempts have been made to find a relationship between pK_a and activation energy barrier for a double proton transfer (DPT) reaction in inorganic acid dimers. Negative influence of pK_a is observed on activation energy (E_a ) which is contrary to the general convention of pK_a . Four different levels of theories with two different basis sets have been used to calculate the activation energy barrier of the DPT reaction in inorganic acid dimers. A model based on first and second order polynomial has been created to find the relationship between activation energy for DPT reaction. © 2018 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

The Interplay Between Hydrogen Bonding and Coulombic Forces in Determining the Structure of Sulfuric Acid-Amine Clusters

Acid-base cluster chemistry drives atmospheric new particle formation (NPF), but the details of the growth mechanisms are difficult to experimentally probe. Clusters of ammonia, alkylamines, and sulfuric acid, species fundamental to NPF, are probed by infrared spectroscopy. These spectra show that substitution of amines for ammonia, which is linked to accelerated growth, induces profound structural rearrangement in clusters with initial compositions (NH₄⁺) _n+1(HSO₄^-) _n (1 ≤ n ≤ 3). This rearrangement is driven by the loss of N-H hydrogen bond donors, yielding direct bisulfate-bisulfate hydrogen bonds, and its onset with respect to cluster composition indicates that more substituted amines induce rearrangement at smaller sizes. A simple model counting hydrogen bond donors and acceptors explains these observations. The presence of direct hydrogen bonds between formal anions shows that hydrogen bonding can compete with Coulombic forces in determining cluster structure. These results suggest that NPF mechanisms may be highly dependent on amine identity.

Nanoparticles grown from methanesulfonic acid and methylamine: microscopic structures and formation mechanism

Mechanisms of particle formation and growth in the atmosphere are of great interest due to their impacts on climate, health and visibility. However, the microscopic structures and related properties of the smallest nanoparticles are not known. In this paper we pursue computationally a microscopic description for the formation and growth of methanesulfonic acid (MSA) and methylamine (MA) particles under dry conditions. Energetic and dynamics simulations were used to assess the stabilities of proposed model structures for these particles. Density functional theory (DFT) and semi-empirical (PM3) calculations suggest that (MSA-MA)₄ is a major intermediate in the growth process, with the dissociation energies, enthalpies and free energies indicating considerable stability for this cluster. Dynamics simulations show that this species is stable for at least 100 ps at temperatures up to 500 K, well above atmospheric temperatures. In order to reach experimentally detectable sizes (>1.4 nm), continuing growth is suggested to occur via clustering of (MSA-MA)₄. The dimer (MSA-MA)₄(MSA-MA)₄ may be one of the smaller experimentally measured particles. Step by step addition of MSA to (MSA-MA)₄, is also a likely potential growth mechanism when MSA is excess. In addition, an MSA-MA crystal is predicted to exist. These studies demonstrate that computations of particle structure and dynamics in the nano-size range can be useful for molecular level understanding of processes that grow clusters into detectable particles.