Dynamic Time-Warping Correction for Shifts in Ultrahigh Resolving Power Ion Mobility Spectrometry and Structures for Lossless Ion Manipulations

Computational tools and algorithms for ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry

Ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (IMS-MS or IM-MS) is a powerful analytical technique that combines the gas-phase separation capabilities of IM with the identification and quantification capabilities of MS. IM-MS can differentiate molecules with indistinguishable masses but different structures (e.g., isomers, isobars, molecular classes, and contaminant ions). The importance of this analytical technique is reflected by a staged increase in the number of applications for molecular characterization across a variety of fields, from different MS-based omics (proteomics, metabolomics, lipidomics, etc.) to the structural characterization of glycans, organic matter, proteins, and macromolecular complexes. With the increasing application of IM-MS there is a pressing need for effective and accessible computational tools. This article presents an overview of the most recent free and open-source software tools specifically tailored for the analysis and interpretation of data derived from IM-MS instrumentation. This review enumerates these tools and outlines their main algorithmic approaches, while highlighting representative applications across different fields. Finally, a discussion of current limitations and expectable improvements is presented.

Overlapping peak separation algorithm for ion mobility spectra based on multistrategy JAYA

RATIONALE

In the field of separation science, ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) plays an important role as an analytical tool. However, the lack of sufficient structural resolution is a common problem in qualitative and quantitative analysis using IMS. A method is needed to solve the problem of overlapping peaks caused by insufficient resolution.

METHODS

The method uses multiple strategies to more effectively use population information to balance exploration and exploitation capabilities, prevent local optimization, accurately resolve overlapping peaks, quickly obtain optimal spectral peak model coefficients, and accurately identify compounds.

RESULTS

Multistrategy JAYA algorithm's (MSJAYA) performance is compared with improved particle swarm optimization (IPSO), dynamic inertia weight particle swarm optimization (DIWPSO), and multiobjective dynamic teaching-learning-based optimization (MDTLBO). The analysis shows that MSJAYA's maximum separation error is within 0.6%, a level of accuracy not guaranteed by the other algorithms. In addition, the separation error fluctuates within a much smaller range, demonstrating MSJAYA's superior robustness.

CONCLUSIONS

Compared with other overlapping peak separation algorithms, MSJAYA is more applicable because no special parameters are used. The method allows fast deconvolution analysis of strong overlapping peaks with multiple components, which greatly improves the resolution of IMS.

Coupling Isotopic Shifts with Collision Cross-Section Measurements for Carbohydrate Characterization in High-Resolution Ion Mobility Separations

Herein, we introduce a two-dimensional strategy to better characterize carbohydrate isomers. In a single experiment, we can derive cyclic ion mobility-mass spectrometry (cIMS-MS)-based collision cross-section (CCS) values in conjunction with measuring isotopic shifts through the relative arrival times of light and heavy isotopologues. These isotopic shifts were introduced by permethylating carbohydrates with either light, CH3, or heavy, CD3, labels at every available hydroxyl group to generate a light/heavy pair of isotopologues for every individual species analyzed. We observed that our calculated CCS values, which were exclusively measured for the light isotopologues, were orthogonal to our measured isotopic shifts (i.e., relative arrival time values between heavy and light permethylated isotopologues). Our permethylation-induced isotopic shifts scaled well with increasing molecular weight, up to ∼m/z 1300, expanding the analysis of isotopic shifts to molecules 3-4 times as large as those previously studied. Our presented use of coupling CCS values with the measurement of isotopic shifts in a single cIMS-MS experiment is a proof-of-concept demonstration that our two-dimensional approach can improve the characterization of challenging isomeric carbohydrates. We envision that our presented 2D approach will have broad utility for varying molecular classes as well as being amenable to many forms of derivatization.

SLIM Tricks: Tools, Concepts, and Strategies for the Development of Planar Ion Guides

Traveling wave ion mobility experiments using planar electrode structures (e.g., structures for lossless ion manipulation, TW-SLIM) leverage the mature manufacturing capabilities of printed circuit boards (PCBs). With routine levels of mechanical precision below 150 μm, the conceptual flexibility afforded by PCBs for use as planar ion guides is expansive. To date, the design and construction of TW-SLIM platforms require considerable legacy expertise, especially with respect to simulation and circuit layout strategies. To lower the barrier of TW-SLIM implementation, we introduce Python-based interactive tools that assist in graphical layout of the core electrode footprints for planar ion guides with minimal user inputs. These scripts also export the exact component locations and assignments for direct integration into KiCad and SIMION for PCB finalization and ion flight simulations. The design concepts embodied in the set of scripts comprising SLIM Pickins (PCB CAD generation) and pigsim (SIMION workspace generation) build upon the lessons learned in the independent development of the research-grade TW-SLIM platforms in operation at WSU. Due to the inherent flexibility of the PCB manufacturing process and the time devoted to board layouts prior to manufacturing, both scripts serve to enable rapid, iterative design considerations. Because only a few predefined parameters are necessary (i.e., the TW-SLIM monomer width, x position following a TW Turn, and y position following a TW Turn) it is possible to design the exact component layouts and accompanying simulation space in a manner of minutes. There is no known limitation to the board layout capacities of the scripts, and the size of a designed layout is ultimately constrained by the abilities of the final PCB design and simulation tools, KiCad and SIMION, to accommodate the thousands of electrodes comprising the final design (i.e., RAM and software overhead). Toward removing the barriers to exploring new SLIM tracks and the likelihood of layout errors that require considerable revision and engineering time, the SLIM Pickins and pigsim tools (included as Supporting Information) allow the user to quickly design a length of planar ion guide, simulate its abilities to confine and transmit ions, compare hypothetical board outlines to given vacuum chamber dimensions, and generate a near-production ready PCB CAD file. In addition to these tools, this report outlines a series of cost-saving strategies with respect to vacuum feedthroughs and vacuum chamber design for TW ion mobility experiments using planar ion guides.

Hydrogen-Deuterium-Exchange-Based Mass Distribution Shifts in High-Resolution Cyclic Ion Mobility Separations

The mass distribution of ions influences separations in ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (IMS-MS). Herein, we introduce a method to induce mass distribution shifts for various analytes using hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDX) immediately prior to ionization using a dual syringe approach. By replacing labile hydrogens on analytes with deuteriums, we were able to differentiate isomers using separations of isotopologues. For each analyte studied, every possible level of deuteration (from undeuterated to fully deuterated) was generated and then separated using cyclic ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (cIMS-MS). The information gained from such separations (relative arrival times; t_Rel. values) was found to be orthogonal to conventional IMS-MS separations. Additionally, the observed shifts were linearly additive with increasing deuteration, suggesting that this methodology could be extended to analytes with a larger number of labile hydrogens. For one isomer pair, as few as two deuteriums were able to produce a large enough mass distribution shift to differentiate isomers. In another experiment, we found that the mass distribution shift was large enough to overcome the reduced mass contribution, resulting in a "flipped" arrival time where the heavier deuterated isotopologue arrived before the lighter one. In this work, we present a proof-of-concept demonstration that mass-distribution-based shifts, t_Rel. values, could potentially act as an added dimension to characterize molecules in IMS-MS. We anticipate, along with future work in this area, that mass-distribution-based shifts could enable the identification of unknown molecules through a database-driven approach in an analogous fashion to collision cross section (CCS) measurements.

Isomer and Conformer-Specific Mass Distribution-Based Isotopic Shifts in High-Resolution Cyclic Ion Mobility Separations

Herein, we present the use of mass distribution-based isotopic shifts in high-resolution cyclic ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (cIMS-MS)-based separations to characterize various isomeric species as well as conformers. Specifically, by using the observed relative arrival time values for the isotopologues found in the isotopic envelope after long pathlength cIMS-MS separations, we were able to distinguish dibromoaniline, dichloroaniline, and quaternary ammonium salt isomers, as well as a pair of 25-hydroxyvitamin D3 conformers based on their respective mass distribution-based shifts. Our observed shifts were highly reproducible and broadly applied to the isotopologues of various atoms (i.e., Cl, Br, and C). Additionally, through a control experiment, we determined that such shifts are indeed pathlength-independent, thus demonstrating that our presented methodology could be readily extended to other high-resolution IMS-MS platforms. These results are the first characterization of conformers using mass distribution-based IMS-MS shifts, as well as the first use of a commercial cIMS-MS platform to characterize isomers via their mass distribution-based shifts. We anticipate that our methodology will have broad applicability for biological analytes and that mass distribution-based shifts could potentially act as an added dimension of analysis in existing IMS-MS workflows in omics-based research. Specifically, we envision that the development of a database of these mass distribution-based shifts could, for example, enable the identification of unknown metabolites in complex matrices.

The Fast Detection of Abnormal ETC Data Based on an Improved DTW Algorithm

As one of the largest Internet of Things systems in the world, China’s expressway electronic toll collection (ETC) generates nearly one billion pieces of transaction data every day, recording the traffic trajectories of almost all vehicles on the expressway, which has great potential application value. However, there are inevitable missed transactions and false transactions in the expressway ETC system, which leads to certain false and missing rates in ETC data. In this work, a dynamic search step SegrDTW algorithm based on an improved DTW algorithm is proposed according to the characteristics of expressway ETC data with origin–destination (OD) data constraints and coupling between the gantry path and the vehicle trajectory. Through constructing the spatial window of segment retrieval, the spatial complexity of the DTW algorithm is effectively reduced, and the efficiency of the abnormal ETC data detection is greatly improved. In real traffic data experiments, the SegrDTW algorithm only needs 3.36 s to measure the abnormal events of a single set of OD path data for 10 days. Compared with the mainstream algorithms, the SegrDTW performs best. Therefore, the proposal provides a feasible method for the abnormal event detection of expressway ETC data in a province and even the whole country.

Measurement and Theory of Gas-Phase Ion Mobility Shifts Resulting from Isotopomer Mass Distribution Changes

The unanticipated discovery of recent ultra-high-resolution ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) measurements revealing that isotopomers─compounds that differ only in the isotopic substitution sites─can be separated has raised questions as to the physical basis for their separation. A study comparing IMS separations for two isotopomer sets in conjunction with theory and simulations accounting for ion rotational effects provides the first-ever prediction of rotation-mediated shifts. The simulations produce observable mobility shifts due to differences in gas-ion collision frequency and translational-to-rotational energy transfer. These differences can be attributed to distinct changes in the moment of inertia and center of mass between isotopomers. The simulations are in broad agreement with the observed experiments and consistent with relative mobility differences between isotopomers. These results provide a basis for refining IMS theory and a new foundation to obtain additional structural insights through IMS.

Improving Signal to Noise Ratios in Ion Mobility Spectrometry and Structures for Lossless Ion Manipulations (SLIM) using a High Dynamic Range Analog-to-Digital Converter

Signal digitization is a commonly overlooked part of ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IMS-MS) workflows, yet it greatly affects signal-to-noise ratio and MS resolution measurements. Here, we report on the integration of a 2 GS/s, 14-bit ADC with structures for lossless ion manipulations (SLIM-IMS-MS) and compare the performance to a commonly used 8-bit ADC. The 14-bit ADC provided a reduction in the digitized noise by a factor of ∼6, owing largely to the use of smaller bit sizes. The low baseline allowed threshold voltage levels to be set very close to the MCP baseline voltage, allowing for as much signal to be acquired as possible without overloading or excessive digitization of MCP baseline noise. Analyses of Agilent tuning mixture ions and a mixture of heavy labeled phosphopeptides showed that the 14-bit ADC provided a ∼1.5-2× signal-to-noise (S/N) increase for high intensity ions, such as the Agilent tuning mixture ions and the 2+ and 3+ charge states of many phosphopeptide constituents. However, signal enhancements were as much as 10-fold for low intensity ions, and the 14-bit ADC enabled discernible signal intensities otherwise lost using an 8-bit digitizer. Additionally, the 14-bit ADC required ∼14-fold fewer mass spectra to be averaged to produce a mass spectrum with a similar S/N as the 8-bit ADC, demonstrating ∼10× higher measurement throughput. The high resolution, low baseline, and fast speed of the new 14-bit ADC enables high performance digitization of MS, IMS-MS, and SLIM-IMS-MS spectra and provides a much better picture of analyte profiles in complex mixtures.

Approaches to Heterogeneity in Native Mass Spectrometry

Native mass spectrometry (MS) is aimed at preserving and determining the native structure, composition, and stoichiometry of biomolecules and their complexes from solution after they are transferred into the gas phase. Major improvements in native MS instrumentation and experimental methods over the past few decades have led to a concomitant increase in the complexity and heterogeneity of samples that can be analyzed, including protein-ligand complexes, protein complexes with multiple coexisting stoichiometries, and membrane protein-lipid assemblies. Heterogeneous features of these biomolecular samples can be important for understanding structure and function. However, sample heterogeneity can make assignment of ion mass, charge, composition, and structure very challenging due to the overlap of tens or even hundreds of peaks in the mass spectrum. In this review, we cover data analysis, experimental, and instrumental advances and strategies aimed at solving this problem, with an in-depth discussion of theoretical and practical aspects of the use of available deconvolution algorithms and tools. We also reflect upon current challenges and provide a view of the future of this exciting field.