Assessment of Stereoelectronic Factors That Influence the CO2 Fixation Ability of N-Heterocyclic Carbenes: A DFT Study

Nitronium salts as mild and inexpensive oxidizing reagents toward designing efficient strategies in organic syntheses; A mechanistic investigation based on the DFT insights

Today, introducing and evaluating the performance of novel reagents are an undeniable part of designing a successful synthetic strategy. Herein, we study the efficiency and mechanism of recently synthesized nitronium salts (e.g., NO₂FSO₃, NO₂CF₃SO₃, NO₂HS₂O₇, NO₂BF₄, NO₂PF₆, and NO₂HSO₄) in the oxidation reaction of ethanol to acetic acid, as a model of the primary alcohol transformations to linear carboxylic acid. An aldehyde molecule is the first produced species in this reaction which is converted to the acetic acid molecule in the presence of in situ-produced nitric acid. Concerning the proposed mechanism, among the studied nitronium salts, two different behaviors can be observed in the transition state of the step in which the aldehyde molecule is formed. The calculated barrier energies of this step have been scrutinized by powerful descriptors such as Quantum Theory of Atoms in Molecules (QTAIM), Natural Bond Orbital (NBO), Electrostatic Potential (ESP) surfaces, and Activation Strain Model (ASM). The outcomes of the studied descriptors illustrate that nitronium salts have different performances in progressing the formation of the aldehyde molecule. Indeed, the likeness of the transition state of this step to the products for NO₂FSO₃, NO₂CF₃SO₃, and NO₂HS₂O₇ species is more significant than the others. Accordingly, these reagents have more potential to apply as oxidizing agents in the primary alcohol transformations to linear carboxylic acid.

Competitive Reactivity of SO2 and NO2 with N-Heterocyclic Carbene: A Mechanistic Study

Recent DFT based molecular engineering to obtain stable oxathiirane S-oxide derivatives evokes the recommencement of the use of carbenes for the sequestering of SO₂, which has been kept separate so far. Carbene is one of the key chemicals for the sequestering of various premier greenhouse gases like CO₂, CO, N₂O, etc. In this respect, a comparative study of the reactivity of carbenes with variant greenhouse gases is highly demanding. The present investigation is engrossed in the comparative reactivity of SO₂ and NO₂ with carbenes. All three selected carbenes are highly susceptible to SO₂ and NO₂. Through an immaculate mechanistic study, we are able to corroborate that the end product of the carbene-SO₂ reaction is an adduct which has a preferable structure having a six-membered ring with hydrogen bonding instead of ketone and SO with higher thermodynamic stability than the corresponding oxathiirane S-oxide derivative. Carbene reacts with NO₂ to form a stable carbene N, N-dioxide derivative which forms vibrationally excited oxaziridine N-oxide which rapidly dissociates to form a ketone derivative. The formation of carbene S, S-dioxide and carbene N, N-dioxide is a barrierless process. The dissociation of oxaziridene N-oxide is also a barrierless process.

Solvation Induction of Free Energy Barriers of Decarboxylation Reactions in Aqueous Solution from Dual-Level QM/MM Simulations

Carbon dioxide capture, corresponding to the recombination process of decarboxylation reactions of organic acids, is typically barrierless in the gas phase and has a relatively low barrier in aprotic solvents. However, these processes often encounter significant solvent-reorganization-induced barriers in aqueous solution if the decarboxylation product is not immediately protonated. Both the intrinsic stereoelectronic effects and solute-solvent interactions play critical roles in determining the overall decarboxylation equilibrium and free energy barrier. An understanding of the interplay of these factors is important for designing novel materials applied to greenhouse gas capture and storage as well as for unraveling the catalytic mechanisms of a range of carboxy lyases in biological CO₂ production. A range of decarboxylation reactions of organic acids with rates spanning nearly 30 orders of magnitude have been examined through dual-level combined quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical simulations to help elucidate the origin of solvation-induced free energy barriers for decarboxylation and the reverse carboxylation reactions in water.

The Brönsted Basicities of N-Heterocyclic Olefins in DMSO: An Effective Way to Evaluate the Stability of NHO-CO2 Adducts

A Brönsted basicity scale (∼24 pK units) for 85 commonly seen imidazole-, imidazoline-, triazole-, and thiazole-based N-heterocyclic olefins (NHOs) in DMSO was established using a well-examined computational model. The influence of substituents on the Brönsted basicities of these NHOs was investigated through basicity comparisons and rationalized by geometric analyses. The Gibbs energy (ΔG_r) of the reaction between NHO and CO₂ was also calculated, which linearly correlates with the basicity of the corresponding NHO, suggesting that the stability of NHO-CO₂ adducts can be evaluated by the basicity of NHOs and a stronger basicity leads to a more stable NHO-CO₂ adduct.

Substituent Effect Parameters: Extending the Applications to Organometallic Chemistry

Typically, metal complexes are constituted of an acceptor metal ion and one or more Iigands containing the donor atoms. Accordingly, the properties of a metal complex are equally dependent on the nature of the metal ion and the ligands. Minute structural variations in the ligand will may result in linear changes in the respective energetic parameters and such linear relationships have paramount importance in organometallic chemistry. The variation in ligands is virtually limitless and substantial because of the extent of organic chemistry available for the modelling of desirable ligands, apart from the variation in metal ions. Anyhow, there is still a need for new parameters for the design and quantification of new ligands which in turn leads to the synthesis of metal complexes with possibly predictable chemical properties. Previous studies have demonstrated that quantum chemically derived molecular electrostatic potential (MESP) parameters can be listed as one of the superior quantifiers in this regard, which can act as an effective ligand electronic parameter. The interaction between the ligand part and metal-containing part will be crucial in assessing the reactivity of organometallic complexes. Here we are applying MESP based substituent constants derived from substituted benzenes to forecast the interaction energies in (pyr^* )W(CO)₅ , (NHC^* )Mo(CO)₅ and (η⁶ -arene^* )Cr(CO)₃ complexes. Ligands and metal ions are varied in each case for better understanding and transparency.

Comprehensive Basicity Scales for N-Heterocyclic Carbenes in DMSO: Implications on the Stabilities of N-Heterocyclic Carbene and CO2 Adducts

A very broad acidity scale (≈40 pK units) for about 400 N-heterocyclic carbene precursors (NHCPs) with various backbones and electronic features, including imidazolylidenes, 1,2,4-triazolylidenes, cyclic diaminocarbenes (CDACs), diamidocarbenes (DACs), thiazolylidenes, cyclic (alkyl)(amino)carbenes (CAACs) and mesoionic carbenes (MICs), was established in DMSO by a well examined computational method. Varying the backbone structure or flanking N-substituents can have different extent of acidifying effects, depending on both the nature and number of substituent(s). The Gibbs energies (ΔG_r s) for the reactions between the corresponding NHCs and CO₂ were also calculated. There is a good linear correlation between the pK_a s of most NHCPs and ΔG_r s, suggesting that a greater basicity of NHC leads to a more stable NHC-CO₂ adduct. Interestingly, the nearby asymmetric environment has virtually no differential effect on the acidities of the chiral NHCP enantiomers, but has a pronounced effect on the ΔG_r values.

Evaluation and understanding the performances of various derivatives of carbonyl-stabilized phosphonium ylides in CO2 transformation to cyclic carbonates

The kinetic and mechanism evaluations of the formation of cyclic carbonates by carbonyl-stabilized phosphonium ylides as an efficient and new class of organocatalysts are the main purposes of this research.

Computational Ligand Descriptors for Catalyst Design

Ligands, especially phosphines and carbenes, can play a key role in modifying and controlling homogeneous organometallic catalysts, and they often provide a convenient approach to fine-tuning the performance of known catalysts. The measurable outcomes of such catalyst modifications (yields, rates, selectivity) can be set into context by establishing their relationship to steric and electronic descriptors of ligand properties, and such models can guide the discovery, optimization, and design of catalysts. In this review we present a survey of calculated ligand descriptors, with a particular focus on homogeneous organometallic catalysis. A range of different approaches to calculating steric and electronic parameters are set out and compared, and we have collected descriptors for a range of representative ligand sets, including 30 monodentate phosphorus(III) donor ligands, 23 bidentate P,P-donor ligands, and 30 carbenes, with a view to providing a useful resource for analysis to practitioners. In addition, several case studies of applications of such descriptors, covering both maps and models, have been reviewed, illustrating how descriptor-led studies of catalysis can inform experiments and highlighting good practice for model comparison and evaluation.

Quantification and classification of substituent effects in organic chemistry: a theoretical molecular electrostatic potential study

Substituent effects in organic chemistry are generally described in terms of experimentally derived Hammett parameters whereas a convenient theoretical tool to study these effects in π-conjugated molecular systems is molecular electrostatic potential (MESP) analysis. The present study shows that the difference between MESP at the nucleus of the para carbon of substituted benzene and a carbon atom in benzene, designated as ΔVC, is very useful to quantify and classify substituent effects. On the basis of positive and negative ΔVC values, a broad classification of around 381 substituents into electron withdrawing and donating categories is made. Each category is again sorted based on the magnitude of ΔVC into subcategories such as very strong, strong, medium, and weak electron donating/withdrawing. Furthermore, the data are used to show the transferability and additivity of substituent effects in π-conjugated organic molecules such as condensed aromatic, olefinic, acetylenic, and heterocyclic systems. The transferability properties hold good for ΔVC in all these molecular systems. The additive properties of substituent effects are strongly reflected on ΔVC and the predictive power of the data to assign the total substituent effects of multi-substituted systems is verified. The ΔVC data and the present classification of substituents are very useful to design π-conjugated organic molecular systems with desired electron rich/poor character.

Binding indirect greenhouse gases OCS and CS2by nitrogen heterocyclic carbenes (NHCs)

Carbon disulfide (CS₂) and carbonyl sulfide (OCS) are indirect greenhouse gases that can be effectively trapped by classical, abnormal and remote nitrogen heterocyclic carbenes (NHCs), according to high levelab initiocalculations.

Electrostatics for probing lone pairs and their interactions

The value of the molecular electrostatic potential minimum (V_min ) and its topographical features (position, as well as the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the corresponding Hessian matrix) are recently proposed as the criteria for characterizing a lone pair (Kumar A. et al., J. Phys. Chem. 2014, A118, 526). This electrostatic characterization of lone pairs is examined for a large number of small molecules employing MP4/6-311++G(d,p)//MP2/6-311++G(d,p) theory. The eigenvector of the Hessian matrix corresponding to its largest eigenvalue (λ_max ), is found to be directed toward the lone pair-bearing-atom, with λ_max showing a strong linear correlation with V_min . Large magnitudes of V_min and λ_max indicate a charge-dense lone pair. The topographical features of V_min are seen to provide insights into the interactive behavior of the molecules with model electrophiles, viz. HF, CO₂ , and Li⁺ . In all the complexes of HF and majority of the other complexes, the interaction energy (E_int ) correlates well with the respective V_min, value, but for some deviations occurring due to other competing secondary interactions. The electrostatic interactions are found to be highly directional in nature as the orientation of interacting atom correlates strongly to the position of lone pair. In summary, the present study on a large number of test molecules shows that electrostatics is able to probe lone pairs in molecules and offers a simple interpretation of chemical reactivity. © 2017 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Interpreting Oxidative Addition of Ph-X (X = CH3, F, Cl, and Br) to Monoligated Pd(0) Catalysts Using Molecular Electrostatic Potential

A B3LYP density functional theory study on the oxidative addition of halogenobenzenes and toluene to monoligated zerovalent palladium catalysts (Pd-L) has been carried out using the "L" ligands such as phosphines, N-heterocyclic carbenes, alkynes, and alkenes. The electron deficiency of the undercoordinated Pd in Pd-L is quantified in terms of the molecular electrostatic potential at the metal center (V _Pd), which showed significant variation with respect to the nature of the L ligand. Further, a strong linear correlation between ΔV _Pd and the activation barrier (E _act) of the reaction is established. The correlation plots between ΔV _Pd and E _act suggest that a priori prediction on the ability of the palladium complex to undergo oxidative addition is possible from V _Pd analysis. In general, as the electron-donating nature of ligand increases, the suitability of Pd(0) catalyst to undergo oxidative addition increases. V _Pd measures the electron-rich/-deficient nature of the metal center and provides a quantitative measure of the reactivity of the catalyst. By tuning the V _Pd value, efficient catalysts can be designed.

Electrophilicity and Nucleophilicity of Boryl Radicals

We carried out a survey of the relative reactivity of a collection of 91 neutral boryl radicals using density functional calculations. Their reactivities were characterized by four indices, i.e., the global electrophilicity, global nucleophilicity, local electrophilicity, and local nucleophilicity. Particularly, the global electrophilicity and nucleophilicity indices span over a moderately wider range than those of carbon radicals, indicating their potentially broader reactivity. Thus, boryl radicals may be utilized in electrophilic radical reactions, while traditionally they are only considered for nucleophilic radical reactions. In contrast, the local electrophilicity and nucleophilicity indices at the boron center show a different reactivity picture than their global counterparts. The inconsistency is rooted in the low and varying spin density on boron (for most radicals, less than 50%) in different boryl radicals, which is a combinative result of radical stabilization via electron delocalization and the low electronegativity of boron (compared to carbon). In short, the boron character in boryl radicals may be weak and their reactivity is not reflected by the local indices based on boron but by the global ones.

Strategic Utilization of Multifunctional Carbene for Direct Synthesis of Carboxylic-Phosphinic Mixed Anhydride from CO2

Direct synthesis of carboxylic-phosphinic mixed anhydrides has been achieved by treating carbon dioxide with N-phosphine oxide-substituted imidazolylidenes (PoxIms) that contain both nucleophilic carbene and electrophilic phosphorus moieties. This novel mixed anhydride was efficiently derivatized into an ester, an amide, and an unsymmetrical ketone via transformation into its corresponding imidazolium salt followed by a dual substitution reaction. The presented work used well-designed multifunctional carbene reagents to establish a novel utility for carbon dioxide in organic synthesis.

DFT study of N-Heterocyclic Olefins-catalyzed carboxylative cyclization of CO2 with alkynol: A CO2-promoted hydrogen abstraction mechanism

DFT calculations have been carried out to study the detailed mechanisms of the carboxylative cyclization reaction between propargylic alcohols and CO2 catalyzed by N-Heterocyclic Olefins (NHO), as well as the molecular orbital theory. Results indicated that this type of reaction prefers a three steps mechanism controlled by free NHO rather than to be catalyzed by the NHO–CO2 adducts. For the first step, CO2 promotes the hydrogen transfer from alkynol to NHO to form the carboxylate, in which propargylic alcohols was deprotonated by the free NHO acted as the catalyst precursor to form the alkynol anion; meanwhile, alkynol anion captures carbon dioxide to form the carboxylate. We found this CO2 promoting Hydrogen abstraction mechanism would decrease the reaction energy barrier and increase releasing heat of this reaction. Secondly, a five-membered-ring intermediate is easily formed to generate carboxylate via an intramolecular ring-closing reaction. Finally, the production generated through a protonating process.

Pincer Ligand Modifications To Tune the Activation Barrier for H2 Elimination in Water Splitting Milstein Catalyst

Modifications on the ligand environment of Milstein ruthenium(II) pincer hydride catalysts have been proposed to fine-tune the activation free energy, ΔG(⧧) for the key step of H2 elimination in the water splitting reaction. This study conducted at the B3LYP level of density functional theory including the solvation effect reveals that changing the bulky t-butyl group at the P-arm of the pincer ligand by methyl or ethyl group can reduce the ΔG(⧧) by a substantial margin, ∼ 10 kcal/mol. The reduction in the steric effect of the pincer ligand causes exothermic association of the water molecule to the metal center and leads to significant stabilization of all the subsequent reaction intermediates and the transition state compared to those of the original Milstein catalyst that promotes endothermic association of the water molecule. Though electron donating groups on the pyridyl unit of the pincer ligand are advantageous for reducing the activation barrier in the gas phase, the effect is only 1-1.4 kcal/mol compared to that of an electron withdrawing group. The absolute minimum of the electrostatic potential at the hydride ligand and carbonyl stretching frequency of the catalyst are useful parameters to gauge the effect of ligand environment on the H2 elimination step of the water splitting reaction.

Systematic strategy for designing immidazolium containing precursors to produce N-heterocyclic carbenes: a DFT study

A series of cationic N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) precursors that can be utilized as fluorescent chemosensors for carbon dioxide capture were investigated by density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Activation energy barriers for the reactions of the cationic NHC precursors and hydrogen carbonate (HCO3(-)) based on intrinsic reaction coordinate (IRC) profiles as well as proton affinity of the precursors were compared. The calculated proton affinity of 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazol-2-yliene was in good agreement with experimental one within the margin of error. We clarified main factors to lower the activation energy barrier based on the correlation among the number of N-heterocyclic functional group, aromatic ring size, and structural characteristics for the candidate compounds. On the basis of the results, it was verified that some of our model systems spontaneously generate NHCs without any specific catalyst.

Structurally simple complexes of CO2

A wide range of structurally characterized adducts of CO₂are discussed in this review, from the strongly bound, charge assisted carbamate complexes through the weaker halide and pseudo-halide complexes to the weakest possible inclusion complexes.

A theoretical investigation of substituent effects on the stability and reactivity of N-heterocyclic olefin carboxylates

Introduction of four phenyl groups at C-position and N-position not only favors decarboxylation but also ensures NHO as a strong nucleophile.

Cation-assisted interactions between N-heterocycles and CO2

Interactions between CO₂ and N-heterocycles are greatly enhanced by divalent cations.

Liberation of N-heterocyclic carbenes (NHCs) from thermally labile progenitors: protected NHCs as versatile tools in organo- and polymerization catalysis

The thermally triggered release of catalytically active, free NHCs from various heat-sensitive progenitors is discussed.