Photochemical generation and reactivity of the 5,6-dihydrouridin-6-yl radical

Cleavage of carbon–carbon bonds by radical reactions

This review provides insights into the in situ generated radicals triggered carbon–carbon bond cleavage reactions.

Theoretical Insights on the Inefficiency of RNA Oxidative Damage under Aerobic Conditions

Oxidative damage to RNA has been linked to change or loss of RNA function and development of many human age-related diseases. However, knowledge on the nature of RNA oxidative damage is relatively limited. In this study, oxidative damage to RNA is investigated under anaerobic and aerobic conditions by exploring the properties and reactions of 5-hydroxyl-2'-uridin-6-yl and its peroxyl diastereoisomers in the RNA strand, respectively. Selective addition of OH to the nucleic base from the 5'-end is studied at the molecular level for the first time, explaining the large number of the 5S-isomer available for further reactions. Our results provide clear evidence that the efficiency of C2'-H2' bond activation in the peroxyl isomers is lower than in the carbon radical species. An exception is observed for the isomer cis-(5S,6R)-A1, whose internucleotidyl H2'-abstraction barrier is far smaller than that in the corresponding C6-yl radical. However, analysis of the equilibrium species distribution reveals that the amount of cis-(5S,6R)-A1 is very small among the peroxyl diastereoisomers, and hence the resulting products from direct strand scission should be a less important component in RNA oxidative damage. The species with maximum distribution is the cis-(5S,6R)-B1 isomer, which is derived from cis-(5S,6R)-A1 and has a moderate intranucleotidyl H2'-abstraction barrier. More importantly, the reaction is mildly exothermic. These results show that the main fraction of the intranucleotidyl H2'-abstraction intermediates can be formed from the cis-(5S,6R)-B1 isomer. The absolute reduction potentials, the hydrogen atom binding energies, and the key structural parameters of the C6-peroxyl species are used to understand the diverse reactivity of the cis-(5S,6R) diastereoisomers toward the C2'-H2' bonds activation. The present study shows that in addition to the selectivity of the OH radical addition, there is a strong correlation between the conformation of the modified uracil base and its reactivity in RNA oxidative damage.

Mechanistic Studies on RNA Strand Scission from a C2'-Radical

The C2'-carbon-hydrogen bond in ribonucleotides is significantly weaker than other carbohydrate carbon-hydrogen bonds in RNA or DNA. Independent generation of the C2'-uridine radical (1) in RNA oligonucleotides via Norrish type I photocleavage of a ketone-substituted nucleotide yields direct strand breaks via cleavage of the β-phosphate. The reactivity of 1 in different sequences and under a variety of conditions suggests that the rate constant for strand scission is significantly greater than 10⁶ s^-1 at pH 7.2. The initially formed C2'-radical (1) is not trapped under a variety of conditions, consistent with computational studies ( Chem.-Eur. J. 2009 , 15 , 2394 ) that suggest that the barrier to strand scission is very low and that synchronous proton transfer from the 2'-hydroxyl to the departing phosphate group facilitates cleavage. The C2'-radical could be a significant contributor to RNA strand scission by the hydroxyl radical, particularly under anaerobic conditions where 1 can be produced from nucleobase radicals.

Pyrimidine Nucleobase Radical Reactivity in DNA and RNA

Nucleobase radicals are major products of the reactions between nucleic acids and hydroxyl radical, which is produced via the indirect effect of ionizing radiation. The nucleobase radicals also result from hydration of cation radicals that are produced via the direct effect of ionizing radiation. The role that nucleobase radicals play in strand scission has been investigated indirectly using ionizing radiation to generate them. More recently, the reactivity of nucleobase radicals resulting from formal hydrogen atom or hydroxyl radical addition to pyrimidines has been studied by independently generating the reactive intermediates via UV-photolysis of synthetic precursors. This approach has provided control over where the reactive intermediates are produced within biopolymers and facilitated studying their reactivity. The contributions to our understanding of pyrimidine nucleobase radical reactivity by this approach are summarized.

Reactivity of Nucleic Acid Radicals

Nucleic acid oxidation plays a vital role in the etiology and treatment of diseases, as well as aging. Reagents that oxidize nucleic acids are also useful probes of the biopolymers' structure and folding. Radiation scientists have contributed greatly to our understanding of nucleic acid oxidation using a variety of techniques. During the past two decades organic chemists have applied the tools of synthetic and mechanistic chemistry to independently generate and study the reactive intermediates produced by ionizing radiation and other nucleic acid damaging agents. This approach has facilitated resolving mechanistic controversies and lead to the discovery of new reactive processes.

Independent generation and reactivity of uridin-2'-yl radical

The uridin-2'-yl radical (1) has been proposed as an intermediate during RNA oxidation. However, its reactivity has not been thoroughly studied due to the complex conditions under which it is typically generated. The uridin-2'-yl radical was independently generated from a benzyl ketone (2a) via Norrish type I photocleavage upon irradiation at λmax = 350 nm. Dioxygen and β-mercaptoethanol are unable to compete with loss of uracil from 1 in phosphate buffer. Thiol trapping competes with uracil fragmentation in less polar solvent conditions. This is ascribed mostly to a reduction in the rate constant for uracil elimination in the less polar solvent. Hydrogen atom transfer to 1 from β-mercaptoethanol occurs exclusively from the α-face to produce arabinouridine. Mass balances range from 72 to 95%. Furthermore, the synthesis of 2a is amenable to formation of the requisite phosphoramidite for solid-phase oligonucleotide synthesis. This and the fidelity with which the urdin-2'-yl radical is generated from 2a suggest that this precursor should be useful for studying the radical's reactivity in synthetic oligonucleotides.

5,6-Dihydropyrimidine peroxyl radical reactivity in DNA

Nucleobase radicals are a major family of reactive species produced in DNA as a result of oxidative stress. Two such radicals, 5-hydroxy-5,6-dihydrothymidin-6-yl radical (1) and 5,6-dihydrouridin-6-yl radical (5), were independently generated within chemically synthesized oligonucleotides from photochemical precursors. Neither nucleobase radical produces direct strand breaks or alkali-labile lesions in single or double stranded DNA. The respective peroxyl radicals, resulting from O₂ trapping, add to 5′-adjacent nucleobases, with a preference for dG. Distal dG’s are also oxidatively damaged by the peroxyl radicals. Experiments using a variety of sequences indicate that distal damage occurs via covalent modification of the 5′-adjacent dG, but there is no evidence for electron transfer by the nucleobase peroxyl radicals.

Photochemical control of DNA structure through radical disproportionation

Photolysis of an aryl sulfide-containing 5,6-dihydropyrimidine (1) at 350 nm produces high yields of thymidine and products resulting from trapping of a 5,6-dihydrothymidin-5-yl radical by O₂ or thiols. Thymidine is believed to result from disproportionation of the radical pair originally generated from C--S bond homolysis of 1 on the microsecond timescale, which is significantly shorter than other photochemical transformations of modified nucleotides into their native forms. Duplex DNA containing 1 is destabilized, presumably due to disruption of π-stacking. Incorporation of 1 within the binding site of the restriction endonuclease EcoRV provides a photochemical switch for turning on the enzyme's activity. In contrast, 1 is a substrate for endonuclease VIII and serves as a photochemical off switch for this base excision repair enzyme. Modification 1 also modulates the activity of the 10-23 DNAzyme, despite its incorporation into a nonduplex region. Overall, dihydropyrimidine 1 shows promise as a tool to provide spatiotemporal control over DNA structure on the miscrosecond timescale.

Photochemical control of RNA structure by disrupting π-stacking

Photolabile nucleotides that disrupt nucleic acid structure are useful mechanistic probes and can be used as tools for regulating biochemical processes. Previous probes can be limited by the need to incorporate multiple modified nucleotides into oligonucleotides and in kinetic studies by the rate-limiting step in the conversion to the native nucleotide. Photolysis of aryl sulfide 1 produces high yields of 5-methyluridine, and product formation is complete in less than a microsecond. Aryl sulfide 1 prevents RNA hairpin formation and complete folding of the preQ(1) class I riboswitch. Proper folding is achieved in each instance upon photolysis at 350 nm. Aryl sulfide 1 is a novel tool for modulating RNA structure, and formation of 5-methyluridine within a radical cage suggests that it will be useful in kinetic studies.

Photochemical generation and reactivity of the major hydroxyl radical adduct of thymidine

5,6-Dihydro-5-hydroxythymidin-6-yl radical (1), the major reactive intermediate resulting from hydroxyl radical addition to C5 of the pyrimidine, is produced via 350 nm photolysis of a 2,5-dimethoxyphenylsulfide precursor (2). Competition between O(2) and thiol for 1 suggests that the radical reacts relatively slowly with β-mercaptoethanol compared to other alkyl radicals. Overall, aryl sulfide 2 should be an effective precursor for the major hydroxyl radical adduct of thymidine in DNA.

Direct strand scission in double stranded RNA via a C5-pyrimidine radical

Nucleobase radicals are the major family of reactive intermediates produced when nucleic acids are exposed to γ-radiolysis. The 5,6-dihydrouridin-5-yl radical (1), the formal product of hydrogen atom addition and a model for hydroxyl radical addition, was independently generated from a ketone precursor via Norrish Type I photocleavage in single and double stranded RNA. Radical 1 produces direct strand breaks at the 5'-adjacent nucleotide and only minor amounts of strand scission are observed at the initial site of radical generation. Strand scission occurs preferentially in double stranded RNA and in the absence of O(2). The dependence of strand scission efficiency from the 5,6-dihydrouridin-5-yl radical (1) on secondary structure under anaerobic conditions suggests that this reactivity may be useful for extracting additional RNA structural information from hydroxyl radical reactions. Varying the identity of the 5'-adjacent nucleotide has little effect on strand scission. Internucleotidyl strand scission occurs via β-elimination of the 3'-phosphate following C2'-hydrogen atom abstraction by 1. The subsequently formed olefin cation radical yields RNA fragments containing 3'-phosphate or 3'-deoxy-2'-ketonucleotide termini from competing deprotonation pathways. The ketonucleotide end group is favored in the presence of low concentrations of thiol, presumably by reducing the cation radical to the enol. Competition studies with thiol show that strand scission from the 5,6-dihydrouridin-5-yl radical (1) is significantly faster than from the 5,6-dihydrouridin-6-yl radical (2) and is consistent with computational studies using the G3B3 approach that predict the latter to be more stable than 1 by 2.8 kcal/mol.

RNA self-cleavage activated by ultraviolet light-induced oxidation

A novel UV-C-light-induced ribozyme activity was discovered within the highly structured 5'-genomic regions of both Hepatitis C Virus (HCV) and the related Classic Swine Fever Virus (CSFV). Cleavage is mediated by exposure to UV-C light but not by exogenous oxygen radicals. It is also very selective, occurring at base positions HCV C(79) and CSFV A(45) in some molecules and at the immediately adjacent 5'-positions HCV U(78) and CSFV U(44) in others. Among other reaction products, the majority of biochemically active products detected contained 3'-phosphate and 5'-phosphate-end groups at the newly generated termini, along with a much lower amount of 3'-hydroxyl end group. While preservation of an E-loop RNA structure in the vicinity of the cleavage site was a requisite for HCV RNA self-cleavage, this was not the case for CSFV RNA. The short size of the reactive domains (~33 nt), which are compatible with primitive RNA motifs, and the lack of sequence homology, indicate that as-yet unidentified UV-activated ribozymes are likely to be found throughout structured RNAs, thereby providing clues to whether early RNA self-cleavage events were mediated by photosensitive RNA structures.

Product and mechanistic analysis of the reactivity of a C6-pyrimidine radical in RNA

Nucleobase radicals are the major reactive intermediates produced when hydroxyl radical reacts with nucleic acids. 5,6-Dihydrouridin-6-yl radical (1) was independently generated from a ketone precursor via Norrish Type I photocleavage in a dinucleotide, single-stranded, and double-stranded RNA. This radical is a model of the major hydroxyl radical adduct of uridine. Tandem lesions resulting from addition of the peroxyl radical derived from 1 to the 5'-adjacent nucleotide are observed by ESI-MS. Radical 1 produces direct strand breaks at the 5'-adjacent nucleotide and at the initial site of generation. The preference for cleavage at these two positions depends upon the secondary structure of the RNA and whether O(2) is present or not. Varying the identity of the 5'-adjacent nucleotide has little effect on strand scission. In general, strand scission is significantly more efficient under anaerobic conditions than when O(2) is present. Strand scission is more than twice as efficient in double-stranded RNA than in a single-stranded oligonucleotide under anaerobic conditions. Internucleotidyl strand scission occurs via β-fragmentation following C2'-hydrogen atom abstraction by 1. The subsequently formed olefin cation radical ultimately yields products containing 3'-phosphate or 3'-deoxy-2'-ketouridine termini. These end groups are proposed to result from competing deprotonation pathways. The dependence of strand scission efficiency from 1 on secondary structure under anaerobic conditions suggests that this reactivity may be useful for extracting additional RNA structural information from hydroxyl radical reactions.

Direct strand scission from a nucleobase radical in RNA

RNA oxidation is important in the etiology of disease and as a tool for studying the structure and folding kinetics of this biopolymer. Nucleobase radicals are the major family of reactive intermediates produced in RNA exposed to diffusible species such as hydroxyl radical. The nucleobase radicals are believed to produce direct strand breaks by abstracting hydrogen atoms from their own and neighboring ribose rings. By independently generating the formal C5 hydrogen atom addition product of uridine in RNA, we provide the first chemical characterization of the pathway for direct strand scission from an RNA nucleobase radical. The process is more efficient under anaerobic conditions. The preference for strand scission in double-stranded RNA over single-stranded RNA suggests that this chemistry may be useful for analyzing the secondary structure of RNA in hydroxyl radical cleavage experiments if they are carried out under anaerobic conditions.