Continuum simulations of acetylcholine consumption by acetylcholinesterase: a Poisson-Nernst-Planck approach

Electrostatic Reaction Inhibition in Nanoparticle Catalysis

Electrostatic reaction inhibition in heterogeneous catalysis emerges if charged reactants and products with similar charges are adsorbed on the catalyst and thus repel the approaching reactants. In this work, we study the effects of electrostatic inhibition on the reaction rate of unimolecular reactions catalyzed on the surface of a spherical model nanoparticle using particle-based reaction-diffusion simulations. Moreover, we derive closed rate equations based on an approximate Debye-Smoluchowski rate theory, valid for diffusion-controlled reactions, and a modified Langmuir adsorption isotherm, relevant for reaction-controlled reactions, to account for electrostatic inhibition in the Debye-Hückel limit. We study the kinetics of reactions ranging from low to high adsorptions on the nanoparticle surface and from the surface- to diffusion-controlled limits for charge valencies 1 and 2. In the diffusion-controlled limit, electrostatic inhibition drastically slows down the reactions for strong adsorption and low ionic concentration, which is well described by our theory. In particular, the rate decreases with adsorption affinity because, in this case, the inhibiting products are generated at a high rate. In the (slow) reaction-controlled limit, the effect of electrostatic inhibition is much weaker, as semiquantitatively reproduced by our electrostatic-modified Langmuir theory. We finally propose and verify a simple interpolation formula that describes electrostatic inhibition for all reaction speeds ("diffusion-influenced" reactions) in general.

Electrodiffusion Phenomena in Neuroscience and the Nernst–Planck–Poisson Equations

This work is aimed to give an electrochemical insight into the ionic transport phenomena in the cellular environment of organized brain tissue. The Nernst–Planck–Poisson (NPP) model is presented, and its applications in the description of electrodiffusion phenomena relevant in nanoscale neurophysiology are reviewed. These phenomena include: the signal propagation in neurons, the liquid junction potential in extracellular space, electrochemical transport in ion channels, the electrical potential distortions invisible to patch-clamp technique, and calcium transport through mitochondrial membrane. The limitations, as well as the extensions of the NPP model that allow us to overcome these limitations, are also discussed.

Enriched gradient recovery for interface solutions of the Poisson-Boltzmann equation

Accurate calculation of electrostatic potential and gradient on the molecular surface is highly desirable for the continuum and hybrid modeling of large scale deformation of biomolecules in solvent. In this article a new numerical method is proposed to calculate these quantities on the dielectric interface from the numerical solutions of the Poisson-Boltzmann equation. Our method reconstructs a potential field locally in the least square sense on the polynomial basis enriched with Green's functions, the latter characterize the Coulomb potential induced by charges near the position of reconstruction. This enrichment resembles the decomposition of electrostatic potential into singular Coulomb component and the regular reaction field in the Generalized Born methods. Numerical experiments demonstrate that the enrichment recovery produces drastically more accurate and stable potential gradients on molecular surfaces compared to classical recovery techniques.

Product interactions and feedback in diffusion-controlled reactions

Steric or attractive interactions among reactants or between reactants and inert crowders can substantially influence the total rate of a diffusion-influenced reaction in the liquid phase. However, the role of the product species, which has typically different physical properties than the reactant species, has been disregarded so far. Here we study the effects of reactant-product and product-product interactions as well as asymmetric diffusion properties on the rate of diffusion-controlled reactions in the classical Smoluchowski-setup for chemical transformations at a perfect catalytic sphere. For this, we solve the diffusion equation with appropriate boundary conditions coupled by a mean-field approach on the second virial level to account for the particle interactions. We find that all particle spatial distributions and the total rate can change significantly, depending on the diffusion and interaction properties of the accumulated products. Complex competing and self-regulating (homeostatic) or self-amplifying effects are observed for the system, leading to both decrease and increase in the rates, as the presence of interacting products feeds back to the reactant flux and thus the rate with which the products are generated.

Charged Substrate and Product Together Contribute Like a Nonreactive Species to the Overall Electrostatic Steering in Diffusion-Reaction Processes

The Debye-Hückel limiting law is used to study the binding kinetics of substrate-enzyme system as well as to estimate the reaction rate of a electrostatically steered diffusion-controlled reaction process. It is based on a linearized Poisson-Boltzmann model and known for its accurate predictions in dilute solutions. However, the substrate and product particles are in nonequilibrium states and are possibly charged, and their contributions to the total electrostatic field cannot be explicitly studied in the Poisson-Boltzmann model. Hence the influences of substrate and product on reaction rate coefficient were not known. In this work, we consider all the charged species, including the charged substrate, product, and mobile salt ions in a Poisson-Nernst-Planck model, and then compare the results with previous work. The results indicate that both the charged substrate and product can significantly influence the reaction rate coefficient with different behaviors under different setups of computational conditions. It is interesting to find that when substrate and product are both considered, under an overall neutral boundary condition for all the bulk charged species, the computed reaction rate kinetics recovers a similar Debye-Hückel limiting law again. This phenomenon implies that the charged product counteracts the influence of charged substrate on reaction rate coefficient. Our analysis discloses the fact that the total charge concentration of substrate and product, though in a nonequilibrium state individually, obeys an equilibrium Boltzmann distribution, and therefore contributes as a normal charged ion species to ionic strength. This explains why the Debye-Hückel limiting law still works in a considerable range of conditions even though the effects of charged substrate and product particles are not specifically and explicitly considered in the theory.

Hybrid finite element and Brownian dynamics method for charged particles

Diffusion is often the rate-determining step in many biological processes. Currently, the two main computational methods for studying diffusion are stochastic methods, such as Brownian dynamics, and continuum methods, such as the finite element method. A previous study introduced a new hybrid diffusion method that couples the strengths of each of these two methods, but was limited by the lack of interactions among the particles; the force on each particle had to be from an external field. This study further develops the method to allow charged particles. The method is derived for a general multidimensional system and is presented using a basic test case for a one-dimensional linear system with one charged species and a radially symmetric system with three charged species.

Self-consistent treatment of the local dielectric permittivity and electrostatic potential in solution for polarizable macromolecular force fields

A self-consistent method is presented for the calculation of the local dielectric permittivity and electrostatic potential generated by a solute of arbitrary shape and charge distribution in a polar and polarizable liquid. The structure and dynamics behavior of the liquid at the solute/liquid interface determine the spatial variations of the density and the dielectric response. Emphasis here is on the treatment of the interface. The method is an extension of conventional methods used in continuum protein electrostatics, and can be used to estimate changes in the static dielectric response of the liquid as it adapts to charge redistribution within the solute. This is most relevant in the context of polarizable force fields, during electron structure optimization in quantum chemical calculations, or upon charge transfer. The method is computationally efficient and well suited for code parallelization, and can be used for on-the-fly calculations of the local permittivity in dynamics simulations of systems with large and heterogeneous charge distributions, such as proteins, nucleic acids, and polyelectrolytes. Numerical calculation of the system free energy is discussed for the general case of a liquid with field-dependent dielectric response.

Hybrid finite element and Brownian dynamics method for diffusion-controlled reactions

Diffusion is often the rate determining step in many biological processes. Currently, the two main computational methods for studying diffusion are stochastic methods, such as Brownian dynamics, and continuum methods, such as the finite element method. This paper proposes a new hybrid diffusion method that couples the strengths of each of these two methods. The method is derived for a general multidimensional system, and is presented using a basic test case for 1D linear and radially symmetric diffusion systems.

Variational multiscale models for charge transport

This work presents a few variational multiscale models for charge transport in complex physical, chemical and biological systems and engineering devices, such as fuel cells, solar cells, battery cells, nanofluidics, transistors and ion channels. An essential ingredient of the present models, introduced in an earlier paper (Bulletin of Mathematical Biology, 72, 1562-1622, 2010), is the use of differential geometry theory of surfaces as a natural means to geometrically separate the macroscopic domain from the microscopic domain, meanwhile, dynamically couple discrete and continuum descriptions. Our main strategy is to construct the total energy functional of a charge transport system to encompass the polar and nonpolar free energies of solvation, and chemical potential related energy. By using the Euler-Lagrange variation, coupled Laplace-Beltrami and Poisson-Nernst-Planck (LB-PNP) equations are derived. The solution of the LB-PNP equations leads to the minimization of the total free energy, and explicit profiles of electrostatic potential and densities of charge species. To further reduce the computational complexity, the Boltzmann distribution obtained from the Poisson-Boltzmann (PB) equation is utilized to represent the densities of certain charge species so as to avoid the computationally expensive solution of some Nernst-Planck (NP) equations. Consequently, the coupled Laplace-Beltrami and Poisson-Boltzmann-Nernst-Planck (LB-PBNP) equations are proposed for charge transport in heterogeneous systems. A major emphasis of the present formulation is the consistency between equilibrium LB-PB theory and non-equilibrium LB-PNP theory at equilibrium. Another major emphasis is the capability of the reduced LB-PBNP model to fully recover the prediction of the LB-PNP model at non-equilibrium settings. To account for the fluid impact on the charge transport, we derive coupled Laplace-Beltrami, Poisson-Nernst-Planck and Navier-Stokes equations from the variational principle for chemo-electro-fluid systems. A number of computational algorithms is developed to implement the proposed new variational multiscale models in an efficient manner. A set of ten protein molecules and a realistic ion channel, Gramicidin A, are employed to confirm the consistency and verify the capability. Extensive numerical experiment is designed to validate the proposed variational multiscale models. A good quantitative agreement between our model prediction and the experimental measurement of current-voltage curves is observed for the Gramicidin A channel transport. This paper also provides a brief review of the field.

A simple polarizable continuum solvation model for electrolyte solutions

We propose a Debye-Hückel-like screening model (DESMO) that generalizes the familiar conductor-like screening model (COSMO) to solvents with non-zero ionic strength and furthermore provides a numerical generalization of the Debye-Hückel model that is applicable to non-spherical solute cavities. The numerical implementation of DESMO is based upon the switching/Gaussian (SWIG) method for smooth cavity discretization, which we have recently introduced in the context of polarizable continuum models (PCMs). This approach guarantees that the potential energy is a smooth function of the solute geometry and analytic gradients for DESMO are reported here. The SWIG formalism also facilitates analytic implementation of two other PCMs that are based on a screened Coulomb potential: the "integral equation formalism" (IEF-PCM) and the "surface and simulation of volume polarization for electrostatics" [SS(V)PE] method. Fully analytic implementations of these screened PCMs are reported here for the first time. Numerical results, for model systems where an exact solution of the linearized Poisson-Boltzmann equation is available, demonstrate that these screened PCMs are highly accurate. In realistic test cases, they are as accurate as the best available three-dimensional finite-difference methods. In polar solvents, DESMO is nearly as accurate as more sophisticated screened PCMs, but is significantly simpler and more efficient.

Poisson-Nernst-Planck Equations for Simulating Biomolecular Diffusion-Reaction Processes I: Finite Element Solutions

In this paper we developed accurate finite element methods for solving 3-D Poisson-Nernst-Planck (PNP) equations with singular permanent charges for electrodiffusion in solvated biomolecular systems. The electrostatic Poisson equation was defined in the biomolecules and in the solvent, while the Nernst-Planck equation was defined only in the solvent. We applied a stable regularization scheme to remove the singular component of the electrostatic potential induced by the permanent charges inside biomolecules, and formulated regular, well-posed PNP equations. An inexact-Newton method was used to solve the coupled nonlinear elliptic equations for the steady problems; while an Adams-Bashforth-Crank-Nicolson method was devised for time integration for the unsteady electrodiffusion. We numerically investigated the conditioning of the stiffness matrices for the finite element approximations of the two formulations of the Nernst-Planck equation, and theoretically proved that the transformed formulation is always associated with an ill-conditioned stiffness matrix. We also studied the electroneutrality of the solution and its relation with the boundary conditions on the molecular surface, and concluded that a large net charge concentration is always present near the molecular surface due to the presence of multiple species of charged particles in the solution. The numerical methods are shown to be accurate and stable by various test problems, and are applicable to real large-scale biophysical electrodiffusion problems.

Differential geometry based multiscale models

Large chemical and biological systems such as fuel cells, ion channels, molecular motors, and viruses are of great importance to the scientific community and public health. Typically, these complex systems in conjunction with their aquatic environment pose a fabulous challenge to theoretical description, simulation, and prediction. In this work, we propose a differential geometry based multiscale paradigm to model complex macromolecular systems, and to put macroscopic and microscopic descriptions on an equal footing. In our approach, the differential geometry theory of surfaces and geometric measure theory are employed as a natural means to couple the macroscopic continuum mechanical description of the aquatic environment with the microscopic discrete atomistic description of the macromolecule. Multiscale free energy functionals, or multiscale action functionals are constructed as a unified framework to derive the governing equations for the dynamics of different scales and different descriptions. Two types of aqueous macromolecular complexes, ones that are near equilibrium and others that are far from equilibrium, are considered in our formulations. We show that generalized Navier-Stokes equations for the fluid dynamics, generalized Poisson equations or generalized Poisson-Boltzmann equations for electrostatic interactions, and Newton's equation for the molecular dynamics can be derived by the least action principle. These equations are coupled through the continuum-discrete interface whose dynamics is governed by potential driven geometric flows. Comparison is given to classical descriptions of the fluid and electrostatic interactions without geometric flow based micro-macro interfaces. The detailed balance of forces is emphasized in the present work. We further extend the proposed multiscale paradigm to micro-macro analysis of electrohydrodynamics, electrophoresis, fuel cells, and ion channels. We derive generalized Poisson-Nernst-Planck equations that are coupled to generalized Navier-Stokes equations for fluid dynamics, Newton's equation for molecular dynamics, and potential and surface driving geometric flows for the micro-macro interface. For excessively large aqueous macromolecular complexes in chemistry and biology, we further develop differential geometry based multiscale fluid-electro-elastic models to replace the expensive molecular dynamics description with an alternative elasticity formulation.

Kinetics of diffusion-controlled enzymatic reactions with charged substrates

The Debye-Hückel limiting law (DHL) has often been used to estimate rate constants of diffusion-controlled reactions under different ionic strengths. Two main approximations are adopted in DHL: one is that the solution of the linearized Poisson-Boltzmann equation for a spherical cavity is used to estimate the excess electrostatic free energy of a solution; the other is that details of electrostatic interactions of the solutes are neglected. This makes DHL applicable only at low ionic strengths and dilute solutions (very low substrate/solute concentrations). We show in this work that through numerical solution of the Poisson-Nernst-Planck equations, diffusion-reaction processes can be studied at a variety of conditions including realistically concentrated solutions, high ionic strength, and certainly with non-equilibrium charge distributions. Reaction rate coefficients for the acetylcholine-acetylcholinesterase system are predicted to strongly depend on both ionic strength and substrate concentration. In particular, they increase considerably with increase of substrate concentrations at a fixed ionic strength, which is open to experimental testing. This phenomenon is also verified on a simple model, and is expected to be general for electrostatically attracting enzyme-substrate systems.PACS Codes: 82.45.Tv, 87.15.VvMSC Codes: 92C30.

Enzymatic activity versus structural dynamics: the case of acetylcholinesterase tetramer

The function of many proteins, such as enzymes, is modulated by structural fluctuations. This is especially the case in gated diffusion-controlled reactions (where the rates of the initial diffusional encounter and of structural fluctuations determine the overall rate of the reaction) and in oligomeric proteins (where function often requires a coordinated movement of individual subunits). A classic example of a diffusion-controlled biological reaction catalyzed by an oligomeric enzyme is the hydrolysis of synaptic acetylcholine (ACh) by tetrameric acetylcholinesterase (AChEt). Despite decades of efforts, the extent to which enzymatic efficiency of AChEt (or any other enzyme) is modulated by flexibility is not fully determined. This article attempts to determine the correlation between the dynamics of AChEt and the rate of reaction between AChEt and ACh. We employed equilibrium and nonequilibrium electro-diffusion models to compute rate coefficients for an ensemble of structures generated by molecular dynamics simulation. We found that, for the static initial model, the average reaction rate per active site is approximately 22-30% slower in the tetramer than in the monomer. However, this effect of tetramerization is modulated by the intersubunit motions in the tetramer such that a complex interplay of steric and electrostatic effects either guides or blocks the substrate into or from each of the four active sites. As a result, the rate per active site calculated for some of the tetramer structures is only approximately 15% smaller than the rate in the monomer. We conclude that structural dynamics minimizes the adverse effect of tetramerization, allowing the enzyme to maintain similar enzymatic efficiency in different oligomerization states.

Molecular surface-free continuum model for electrodiffusion processes

Incorporation of van der Waals interactions enables the continuum model of electrodiffusion in biomolecular system to avoid the artifacts of introducing a molecular surface and the painful task of the surface mesh generation. Calculation examples show that the electrostatics, diffusion-reaction kinetics, and molecular surface defined as an isosurface of a certain density distribution can be extracted from the solution of the Poisson-Nernst-Planck equations using this model. The molecular surface-free model enables a wider usage of some modern numerical methodologies such as finite element methods for biomolecular modeling, and sheds light on a new paradigm of continuum modeling for biomolecular systems.