Vibrational Collective Dynamics of Dry Proteins in the Terahertz Region

Intra-protein interacting collective modes in the terahertz frequency region

Understanding how proteins work requires a thorough understanding of their internal dynamics. Proteins support a wide range of motions, from the femtoseconds to seconds time scale, relevant to crucial biological functions. In this context, the term "protein collective dynamics" refers to the complex patterns of coordinated motions of numerous atoms throughout the protein in the sub-picosecond time scale (terahertz frequency region). It is hypothesized that these dynamics have a substantial impact on the regulation of functional dynamical mechanisms, including ligand binding and allosteric signalling, charge transport direction, and the regulation of thermodynamic and thermal transport properties. Using the theoretical framework of hydrodynamics, the collective dynamics of proteins had previously been described in a manner akin to that of simple liquids, i.e. in terms of a single acoustic-like excitation, related to intra-protein vibrational motions. Here, we employ an interacting-mode model to analyse the results from molecular dynamics simulations and we unveil that the vibrational landscape of proteins is populated by multiple acoustic-like and low-frequency optic-like modes, with mixed symmetry and interfering with each other. We propose an interpretation at the molecular level of the observed scenario that we relate to the side-chains and the hydrogen-bonded networks dynamics. The present insights provide a perspective for understanding the molecular mechanisms underlying the energy redistribution processes in the interior of proteins.

Correlated Evolution of Low-Frequency Vibrations and Function in Enzymes

Previous studies of the flexibility of ancestral proteins suggest that proteins evolve their function by altering their native state ensemble. Here, we propose a more direct method to analyze such changes during protein evolution by comparing thermally activated vibrations at frequencies below 6 THz, which report on the dynamics of collective protein modes. We analyzed the backbone vibrational density of states of ancestral and extant β-lactamases and thioredoxins and observed marked changes in the vibrational spectrum in response to evolution. Coupled with previously observed changes in protein flexibility, the observed shifts of vibrational mode densities suggest that protein dynamics and dynamical allostery are critical factors for the evolution of enzymes with specialized catalytic and biophysical properties.

Terahertz polarization sensing for protein concentration and a crystallization process on a reflective metasurface

Terahertz (THz) waves have attracted much attention in the field of biosensing due to advantages including non-destructiveness, being label-free, and high-sensitivity detection. Here we have experimentally demonstrated a THz polarization sensing method based on reflective metasurface sensors for detecting concentrations of protein solutions and their crystallization process. The protein with varying concentrations has been detected by five different polarization parameters, which show different spectral responses and sensing sensitivities. The sensing accuracy can reach the order of ng/mm². Furthermore, the crystallization process of the protein sample from the dissolved state to the crystalline has been dynamically measured by polarization sensing, of which the highest sensitivity can reach 0.67 °/%. Therefore, this new sensing platform can have broad development prospects in the trace matter detection of the biological sample.

Terahertz Spectroscopic Analysis in Protein Dynamics: Current Status

Proteins play a key role in living organisms. The study of proteins and their dynamics provides information about their functionality, catalysis and potential alterations towards pathological diseases. Several techniques are used for studying protein dynamics, e.g., magnetic resonance, fluorescence imaging techniques, mid-infrared spectroscopy and biochemical assays. Spectroscopic analysis, based on the use of terahertz (THz) radiation with frequencies between 0.1 and 15 THz (3–500 cm−1), was underestimated by the biochemical community. In recent years, however, the potential of THz spectroscopy in the analysis of both simple structures, such as polypeptide molecules, and complex structures, such as protein complexes, has been demonstrated. The THz absorption spectrum provides some information on proteins: for small molecules the THz spectrum is dominated by individual modes related to the presence of hydrogen bonds. For peptides, the spectral information concerns their secondary structure, while for complex proteins such as globular proteins and viral glycoproteins, spectra also provide information on collective modes. In this short review, we discuss the results obtained by THz spectroscopy in the protein dynamics investigations. In particular, we will illustrate advantages and applications of THz spectroscopy, pointing out the complementary information it may provide.

Experimental mapping of short-wavelength phonons in proteins

Phonons are quasi-particles, observed as lattice vibrations in periodic materials, that often dampen in the presence of structural perturbations. Nevertheless, phonon-like collective excitations exist in highly complex systems, such as proteins, although the origin of such collective motions has remained elusive. Here we present a picture of temperature and hydration dependence of collective excitations in green fluorescent protein (GFP) obtained by inelastic neutron scattering. Our results provide evidence that such excitations can be used as a measure of flexibility/softness and are possibly associated with the protein’s activity. Moreover, we show that the hydration water in GFP interferes with the phonon propagation pathway, enhancing the structural rigidity and stability of GFP.

•

Quantum phenomena in biology have long fascinated people around the world

•

This work presents a direct experimental observation of phonons, the quantum vibrations in a protein

•

The collective excitations or phonons in proteins were detected by utilizing inelastic neutron scattering technique at Oak Ridge National Laboratory

•

Our results illustrate the flexibility-activity relationship in proteins by mapping the temperature and hydration dependence of these collective excitations

Terahertz circular polarization sensing for protein denaturation based on a twisted dual-layer metasurface

Protein denaturation has very important research value in nutrition, biomedicine, and the food industry, which is caused by the changes in the molecular structure of the protein. Since the collective vibrational and torsional modes of protein molecules are within the terahertz (THz) frequency range, THz spectroscopy can characterize the protein denaturation with several advantages of non-contact, label-free, real-time, and non-destructive. Therefore, we proposed a reflective THz time-domain polarization spectroscopy sensing method, and use a flexible twisted dual-layer metasurface film as a sensor to realize the thermal denaturation sensing, concentration sensing, and types identification of protein aqueous solutions. The experiment tested three proteins (bovine serum albumin, whey protein, and ovalbumin), and the results show that: for the thermal denaturation sensing, its detection sensitivity can reach 6.30 dB/% and the detection accuracy is 0.77%; for the concentration sensing, the detection sensitivity and detection accuracy reach 52.9 dB·mL/g and 3.6·10^-5 g/mL, respectively; in addition, different protein types can be distinguished by the difference of the circular polarization spectra.

Multiple Interacting Collective Modes and Phonon Gap in Phospholipid Membranes

We combine Brillouin neutron scattering measurements with recent inelastic X-ray scattering [ Zhernenkov et al. Nat. Commun. 2016 , 7 , 11575 ] to propose a model for the collective dynamics of phospholipid bilayers. Neutron and X-ray spectra were fitted by the model response function associated with the Hamiltonian of an interacting-phonon system. This approach allows for a comprehensive and unprecedented picture of the vibrational collective features of phospholipids. At low wavevectors Q, the dispersion relations can be interpreted in terms of two acoustic-like modes, one longitudinal and one transverse, plus a dispersionless optic-like mode. The transverse mode of the liquid phase shows a phonon gap that can be linked to a passive transport mechanism through membranes, an interpretation that was proposed in Zhernenkov et al. At higher Q values, the interaction of the longitudinal acoustic excitation with the dispersionless mode gives rise to a pattern that is consistent with avoided-crossing behavior. Evidence is found for a slow- to fast-sound transition, similar to bulk water and other biomolecules.

Moving in the Right Direction: Protein Vibrations Steering Function

Nearly all protein functions require structural change, such as enzymes clamping onto substrates, and ion channels opening and closing. These motions are a target for possible new therapies; however, the control mechanisms are under debate. Calculations have indicated protein vibrations enable structural change. However, previous measurements found these vibrations only weakly depend on the functional state. By using the novel technique of anisotropic terahertz microscopy, we find that there is a dramatic change to the vibrational directionality with inhibitor binding to lysozyme, whereas the vibrational energy distribution, as measured by neutron inelastic scattering, is only slightly altered. The anisotropic terahertz measurements provide unique access to the directionality of the intramolecular vibrations, and immediately resolve the inconsistency between calculations and previous measurements, which were only sensitive to the energy distribution. The biological importance of the vibrational directions versus the energy distribution is revealed by our calculations comparing wild-type lysozyme with a higher catalytic rate double deletion mutant. The vibrational energy distribution is identical, but the more efficient mutant shows an obvious reorientation of motions. These results show that it is essential to characterize the directionality of motion to understand and control protein dynamics to optimize or inhibit function.

A high-flux upgrade for the BRISP spectrometer at ILL

To date, the BRISP spectrometer represents the state-of-the-art for every instrument aiming to perform Brillouin neutron scattering. Exploiting accurate ray-tracing McStas simulations, we investigate an improved configuration of the BRISP primary spectrometer to provide a higher flux at the sample position, while preserving all the present capabilities of the instrument. This configuration is based on a neutron guide system and is designed to fit the instrument platform with no modifications of the secondary spectrometer. These evaluations show that this setup can achieve a flux gain factor ranging from 3 to 6, depending on the wavelength. This can expand the experimental possibilities of BRISP towards smaller samples, possibly using also complex sample environments.

New Method to Study the Vibrational Modes of Biomolecules in the Terahertz Range Based on a Single-Stage Raman Spectrometer

The low-frequency vibrational (LFV) modes of biomolecules reflect specific intramolecular and intermolecular thermally induced fluctuations that are driven by external perturbations, such as ligand binding, protein interaction, electron transfer, and enzymatic activity. Large efforts have been invested over the years to develop methods to access the LFV modes due to their importance in the studies of the mechanisms and biological functions of biomolecules. Here, we present a method to measure the LFV modes of biomolecules based on Raman spectroscopy that combines volume holographic filters with a single-stage spectrometer, to obtain high signal-to-noise-ratio spectra in short acquisition times. We show that this method enables LFV mode characterization of biomolecules even in a hydrated environment. The measured spectra exhibit distinct features originating from intra- and/or intermolecular collective motion and lattice modes. The observed modes are highly sensitive to the overall structure, size, long-range order, and configuration of the molecules, as well as to their environment. Thus, the LFV Raman spectrum acts as a fingerprint of the molecular structure and conformational state of a biomolecule. The comprehensive method we present here is widely applicable, thus enabling high-throughput study of LFV modes of biomolecules.

Probing Intermolecular Interactions in Phospholipid Bilayers by Far-Infrared Spectroscopy

Fast thermal fluctuations and low frequency phonon modes are thought to play a part in the dynamic mechanisms of many important biological functions in cell membranes. Here we report a detailed far-infrared study of the molecular subpicosecond motions of phospholipid bilayers at various hydrations. We show that these systems sustain several low frequency collective modes and deduce that they arise from vibrations of different lipids interacting through intermolecular van der Waals forces. Furthermore, we observe that the low frequency vibrations of lipid membrane have strong similarities with the subpicosecond motions of liquid water and suggest that resonance mechanisms are an important element to the dynamics coupling between membranes and their hydration water.

Fingerprints of Conformational States of Human Hsp70 at Sub-THz Frequencies

Large multidomain proteins occur in different conformational states to function. Detection and monitoring of these different structural states are of crucial interest for understanding the mechanics of proteins. Using computational methods, we show that different protein conformational states of the two-domain 70 kDa human Heat-shock protein (hHsp70), with similar vibrational density of states, lead to remarkably different far-IR spectra at acoustical frequencies (ν < 300 GHz). We found that the slow damped motions of the positively charged residues of hHsp70 contribute the most to collective IR active modes at low frequencies (ν < 300 GHz). We predicted that different structural states and functional modes of large proteins, such as hHsp70, might be detected in the sub-THz frequency range by single-molecule spectroscopy similar to the recent extraordinary acoustic Raman spectroscopy (Wheaton S.; Nat. Photonics2015, 9, 68-72).

Theoretical Insights into Sub-Terahertz Acoustic Vibrations of Proteins Measured in Single-Molecule Experiments

Proteins are an important class of nanobioparticles with acoustical modes in the sub-THz frequency range. There is considerable interest to measure and establish the role of these acoustical vibrations for biological function. So far, the technique providing the most detailed information about the acoustical modes of proteins is the very recent Extraordinary Acoustic Raman (EAR) spectroscopy. In this technique, proteins are trapped in nanoholes and excited by two optical lasers of slightly different wavelengths producing an electric field at low frequency (<100 GHz). We demonstrate that the acoustical modes of proteins studied by EAR spectroscopy are both infrared- and Raman-active modes, and we provided interpretation of the spectroscopic fingerprints measured at the single-molecule level. A combination of the present calculations with techniques based on the excitation of a single nanobioparticle by an electric field, such as EAR spectroscopy, should provide a wealth of information on the role of molecular dynamics for biological function.

Collective ion dynamics in liquid zinc: evidence for complex dynamics in a non-free-electron liquid metal

A detailed inelastic neutron scattering investigation of the THz dynamics of liquid zinc is presented. The observed Q dependence clearly reveals the existence of a complex dynamics made up of two distinct excitations. The highest energy mode is the prolongation of the longitudinal acoustic density fluctuations whereas the comparison with the phonon dynamics of crystalline hcp zinc suggests a transverse acousticlike nature for the second one. This mode seems related to peculiar anisotropic interactions, possibly connected to the behavior of the crystalline phase.

Terahertz Dynamics in Human Cells and Their Chromatin

The terahertz dynamics of human cells of the U937 line and their chromatin has been investigated by high-resolution inelastic X-ray scattering. To highlight its dynamical features in situ, nuclear DNA has been stained by uranyl-acetate salt. The general behavior of the collective dynamics of the whole cell is quite similar to that of bulk water, with a nearly wavevector-independent branch located at about 5 meV and a propagating mode with a linear trend corresponding to a speed of sound of 2900 ± 100 m/s. We provide the first experimental evidence for the existence of two branches also in the dispersion curves of chromatin. The high-energy mode displays an acoustic-like behavior with a sound velocity similar to unstained cells, but in this case the branch likely originates from the superposition of intramolecular DNA optic modes. A low-energy optic-like branch, distinctive of the chromatin moiety, is found at about 2.5 meV.

One role of hydration water in proteins: key to the "softening" of short time intraprotein collective vibrations of a specific length scale

High resolution inelastic X-ray scattering (IXS) experiments show that the "phonon energy softening" and "phonon population enhancement" observed in a hydrated native protein when increasing the temperature from 200 K to physiological temperature are not directly related to the protein structure. Such phenomena were also observed in a denatured sample without a defined tertiary structure and with a limited residual secondary structure. However, in a dry sample, such "softening" is strongly suppressed. These facts suggest that the above-mentioned protein "softening" phenomenon is water-induced. In addition, increasing the hydration level can also induce "phonon energy softening" at room temperature, but not at 200 K. This change may be due to a qualitative difference in the dynamics of hydration water at 200 K and at room temperature.

Coherent neutron scattering and collective dynamics in the protein, GFP

Collective dynamics are considered to be one of the major properties of soft materials, including biological macromolecules. We present coherent neutron scattering studies of the low-frequency vibrations, the so-called boson peak, in fully deuterated green fluorescent protein (GFP). Our analysis revealed unexpectedly low coherence of the atomic motions in GFP. This result implies a low amount of in-phase collective motion of the secondary structural units contributing to the boson peak vibrations and fast conformational fluctuations on the picosecond timescale. These observations are in contrast to earlier studies of polymers and glass-forming systems, and suggest that random or out-of-phase motions of the β-strands contribute greater than two-thirds of the intensity to the low-frequency vibrational spectra of GFP.

Secondary structure and rigidity in model proteins

There is tremendous interest in understanding the role that secondary structure plays in the rigidity and dynamics of proteins. In this work we analyze nanomechanical properties of proteins chosen to represent different secondary structures: α-helices (myoglobin and bovine serum albumin), β-barrels (green fluorescent protein), and α + β + loop structures (lysozyme). Our experimental results show that in these model proteins, the β motif is a stiffer structural unit than the α-helix in both dry and hydrated states. This difference appears not only in the rigidity of the protein, but also in the amplitude of fast picosecond fluctuations. Moreover, we show that for these examples the secondary structure correlates with the temperature- and hydration-induced changes in the protein dynamics and rigidity. Analysis also suggests a connection between the length of the secondary structure (α-helices) and the low-frequency vibrational mode, the so-called boson peak. The presented results suggest an intimate connection of dynamics and rigidity with the protein secondary structure.