Triaspartate: A Model System for Conformationally Flexible DDD Motifs in Proteins

Conformational Manifold Sampled by Two Short Linear Motif Segments Probed by Circular Dichroism, Vibrational, and Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy

Disordered protein segments called short linear motifs (SLiM) serve as recognition sites for a variety of biological processes and act as targeting signals, modification, and ligand binding sites. While SLiMs do not adopt one of the known regular secondary structures, the conformational distribution might still reflect the structural propensities of their amino acid residues and possible interactions between them. In the past, conformational analyses of short peptides provided compelling evidence for the notion that individual residues are less conformationally flexible than locally expected for a random coil. Here, we combined various spectroscopies (NMR, IR, vibrational, and UV circular dichroism) to determine the Ramachandran plots of two SLiM motifs, i.e., GRRDSG and GRRTSG. They are two representatives of RxxS motifs that are capable of being phosphorylated by protein kinase A, an enzyme that plays a fundamental role in a variety of biological processes. Our results reveal that the nearest and non-nearest interactions between residues cause redistributions between polyproline II and β-strand basins while concomitantly stabilizing extended relative to turn-forming and helical structures. They also cause shifts in basin positions. With increasing temperature, β-strand populations become more populated at the expense of polyproline II. While molecular dynamics simulations with Amber ff14SB and CHARMM 36m force fields indicate residue-residue interactions, they do not account for the observed structural changes.

The relevance of short peptides for an understanding of unfolded and intrinsically disordered proteins

Over the last thirty years the unfolded state of proteins has attracted considerable interest owing to the discovery of intrinsically disordered proteins which perform a plethora of functions despite resembling unfolded proteins to a significant extent. Research on both, unfolded and disordered proteins has revealed that their conformational properties can deviate locally from random coil behavior. In this context results from work on short oligopeptides suggest that individual amino acid residues sample the sterically allowed fraction of the Ramachandran plot to a different extent. Alanine has been found to exhibit a peculiarity in that it has a very high propensity for adopting polyproline II like conformations. This Perspectives article reviews work on short peptides aimed at exploring the Ramachandran distributions of amino acid residues in different contexts with experimental and computational means. Based on the thus provided overview the article discussed to what extent short peptides can serve as tools for exploring unfolded and disordered proteins and as benchmarks for the development of a molecular dynamics force field.

Exploring Nearest Neighbor Interactions and Their Influence on the Gibbs Energy Landscape of Unfolded Proteins and Peptides

The Flory isolated pair hypothesis (IPH) is one of the corner stones of the random coil model, which is generally invoked to describe the conformational dynamics of unfolded and intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs). It stipulates, that individual residues sample the entire sterically allowed space of the Ramachandran plot without exhibiting any correlations with the conformational dynamics of its neighbors. However, multiple lines of computational, bioinformatic and experimental evidence suggest that nearest neighbors have a significant influence on the conformational sampling of amino acid residues. This implies that the conformational entropy of unfolded polypeptides and proteins is much less than one would expect based on the Ramachandran plots of individual residues. A further implication is that the Gibbs energies of residues in unfolded proteins or polypeptides are not additive. This review provides an overview of what is currently known and what has yet to be explored regarding nearest neighbor interactions in unfolded proteins.

Repeating Aspartic Acid Residues Prefer Turn-like Conformations in the Unfolded State: Implications for Early Protein Folding

Protein folding can be described as a motion of the polypeptide chain in a potential energy funnel, where the conformational manifold is narrowed as the chain traverses from a completely unfolded state until it reaches the folded (native) state. The initial folding stages set the tone for this process by substantially narrowing the manifold of accessible conformations. In an ideally unfolded state with no long-range stabilizing forces, local conformations (i.e., residual structures) are likely to drive the folding process. While most amino acid residues tend to predominantly adopt extended structures in unfolded proteins and peptides, aspartic acid exhibits a relatively high intrinsic preference for turn-forming conformations. Regions in an unfolded polypeptide or protein that are rich in aspartic acid residues may therefore be crucial sites for protein folding steps. By combining NMR and vibrational spectroscopies, we observed that the conformational sampling of multiple sequentially neighbored aspartic acid residues in the model peptides GDDG and GDDDG even show an on average higher propensity for turn-forming structures than the intrinsic reference system D in GDG, which suggests that nearest neighbor interactions between adjacent aspartic acid residues stabilize local turn-forming structures. In the presence of the unlike neighbor phenylalanine, nearest neighbor interactions are of a totally different nature in that it they decrease the turn-forming propensities and mutually increase the sampling of polyproline II (pPII) conformations. We hypothesize the structural role of aspartic residues in intrinsically disordered proteins in general, and particularly in small linear motifs, that are very much determined by their respective neighbors.

Anticooperative Nearest-Neighbor Interactions between Residues in Unfolded Peptides and Proteins

Growing evidence suggests that the conformational distributions of amino acid residues in unfolded peptides and proteins depend on the nature of the nearest neighbors. To explore whether the underlying interactions would lead to a breakdown of the isolated pair hypothesis of the classical random coil model, we further analyzed the conformational propensities that were recently obtained for the two guest residues (x,y) of GxyG tetrapeptides. We constructed a statistical thermodynamics model that allows for cooperative as well as for anticooperative interactions between adjacent residues adopting either a polyproline II or a β-strand conformation. Our analysis reveals that the nearest-neighbor interactions between most of the central residues in the investigated GxyG peptides are anticooperative. Interaction Gibbs energies are rather large at high temperatures (350 K), at which point many proteins undergo thermal unfolding. At room temperature, these interaction energies are less pronounced. We used the obtained interaction parameter in a Zimm-Bragg/Ising-type approach to calculate the temperature dependence of the ultraviolet circular dichroism (CD) of the MAX3 peptide, which is predominantly built by KV repeats. The agreement between simulation and experimental data was found to be satisfactory. Finally, we analyzed the temperature dependence of the CD and ³J(H^NH^α) parameters of the amyloid β_1-9 fragment. The results of this analysis and a more qualitative consideration of the temperature dependence of denatured proteins probed by CD spectroscopy further corroborate the dominance of anticooperative nearest-neighbor interactions. Generally, our results show that unfolded peptides-and most likely also proteins-exhibit some similarity with antiferromagnetic systems.

Construction and comparison of the statistical coil states of unfolded and intrinsically disordered proteins from nearest-neighbor corrected conformational propensities of short peptides

Assessing the influence of nearest neighbors on the conformational ensemble of amino acid residues in unfolded and intrinsically disordered proteins and peptides is pivotal for a thorough understanding of the statistical coil state of unfolded proteins as well as of the energetics of the folding process. Research aimed at exploring nearest neighbor interactions has mostly focused on the analysis of restricted coil libraries that reflect conformational distributions in loops connecting more regular secondary structure segments. Recently, however, Toal et al. reported an experimentally based structural analysis of selected xy-pairs in GxyG tetrapeptides, which revealed quantitative information about conformational changes induced by nearest-neighbor interactions (Eur. J. Chem., 2015, 21, 5173-5192). Here, we perform analyses of Ramachandran plots of xy-pairs in GxyG and in coil libraries (Ting et al., PLOS CompBiol, 2010, 6, e1000763) using Hellinger distances as a quantitative measure of dissimilarities between Ramachandran distributions. Our analysis reveals that nearest-neighbor effects inferred from the above coil library are much less pronounced than corresponding structural changes observed for GxyG peptides. To determine whether nearest-neighbor induced conformational changes observed for GxyG can be utilized for the analysis of unfolded proteins, we analyzed sets of ³J(H^HH^α) coupling constants of three different unfolded proteins, namely the 130-residue fragment of the Staphylococcus aureus fibronectin-binding protein (FnBPc), denatured hen lysozyme, and the htau40 protein. For the first two proteins we found statistically meaningful correlations between predicted nearest-neighbor induced changes of ³J(H^HH^α) and experimentally observed deviations from corresponding coupling constants of GxG peptides in water, which we used as reference system with minimal nearest-neighbor interactions. This observation is in line with the NMR based understanding of these proteins being predominantly statistical coils. For htau40, however, which is known to exhibit residual structure and large deviations form statistical coil expectations, these correlations are weak or absent. Our results thus underscore the importance of nearest-neighbor interactions for a complete physical description of an ideal statistical coil state of a protein.

Randomizing the unfolded state of peptides (and proteins) by nearest neighbor interactions between unlike residues

To explore the influence of nearest neighbors on conformational biases in unfolded peptides, we combined vibrational and 2D NMR spectroscopy to obtain the conformational distributions of selected "GxyG" host-guest peptides in aqueous solution: GDyG, GSyG, GxLG, GxVG, where x/y=A, K, L, V. Large changes of conformational propensities were observed due to nearest-neighbor interactions, at variance with the isolated pair hypothesis. We found that protonated aspartic acid and serine lose their above-the-average preference for turn-like structures in favor of polyproline II (pPII) populations in the presence of neighbors with bulky side chains. Such residues also decrease the above-the-average pPII preference of alanine. These observations suggest that the underlying mechanism involves a disruption of the hydration shell. Thermodynamic analysis of (3) J(H(N) ,H(α) ) (T) data for each x,y residue reveals that modest changes in the conformational ensemble masks larger changes of enthalpy and entropy governing the pPII↔β equilibrium indicating a significant residue dependent temperature dependence of the peptides' conformational ensembles. These results suggest that nearest-neighbor interactions between unlike residues act as conformational randomizers close to the enthalpy-entropy compensation temperature, eliminating intrinsic biases in favor of largely balanced pPII/β dominated ensembles at physiological temperatures.

Local order in the unfolded state: conformational biases and nearest neighbor interactions

The discovery of Intrinsically Disordered Proteins, which contain significant levels of disorder yet perform complex biologically functions, as well as unwanted aggregation, has motivated numerous experimental and theoretical studies aimed at describing residue-level conformational ensembles. Multiple lines of evidence gathered over the last 15 years strongly suggest that amino acids residues display unique and restricted conformational preferences in the unfolded state of peptides and proteins, contrary to one of the basic assumptions of the canonical random coil model. To fully understand residue level order/disorder, however, one has to gain a quantitative, experimentally based picture of conformational distributions and to determine the physical basis underlying residue-level conformational biases. Here, we review the experimental, computational and bioinformatic evidence for conformational preferences of amino acid residues in (mostly short) peptides that can be utilized as suitable model systems for unfolded states of peptides and proteins. In this context particular attention is paid to the alleged high polyproline II preference of alanine. We discuss how these conformational propensities may be modulated by peptide solvent interactions and so called nearest-neighbor interactions. The relevance of conformational propensities for the protein folding problem and the understanding of IDPs is briefly discussed.

pH-Independence of trialanine and the effects of termini blocking in short peptides: a combined vibrational, NMR, UVCD, and molecular dynamics study

Several lines of evidence now well establish that unfolded peptides in general, and alanine in specific, have an intrinsic preference for the polyproline II (pPII) conformation. Investigation of local order in the unfolded state is, however, complicated by experimental limitations and the inherent dynamics of the system, which has in some cases yielded inconsistent results from different types of experiments. One method of studying these systems is the use of short model peptides, and specifically short alanine peptides, known for predominantly sampling pPII structure in aqueous solution. Recently, He et al. ( J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2012 , 134 , 1571 - 1576 ) proposed that unblocked tripeptides may not be suitable models for studying conformational propensities in unfolded peptides due to the presence of end effect, that is, electrostatic interactions between investigated amino acid residues and terminal charges. To determine whether changing the protonation states of the N- and C-termini influence the conformational manifold of the central amino acid residue in tripeptides, we have examined the pH-dependence of unblocked trialanine and the conformational preferences of alanine in the alanine dipeptide. To this end, we measured and globally analyzed amide I' band profiles and NMR J-coupling constants. We described conformational distributions as the superposition of two-dimensional Gaussian distributions assignable to specific subspaces of the Ramachandran plot. Results show that the conformational ensemble of trialanine as a whole, and the pPII content (χpPII = 0.84) in particular, remains practically unaffected by changing the protonation state. We found that compared to trialanine, the alanine dipeptide has slightly lower pPII content (χpPII = 0.74) and an ensemble more reminiscent of the unblocked Gly-Ala-Gly model peptide. In addition, a two-state thermodynamic analysis of the conformational sensitive Δε(T) and (3)J(H(N)H(α))(T) data obtained from electronic circular dichroism and H NMR spectra indicate that the free energy landscape of trialanine is similar in all protonation states. MD simulations for the investigated peptides corroborate this notion and show further that the hydration shell around unblocked trialanine is unaffected by the protonation/deprotonation of the C-terminal group. In contrast, the alanine dipeptide shows a reduced water density around the central residue as well as a less ordered hydration shell, which decreases the pPII propensity and reduces the lifetime of sampled conformations.

Disorder and order in unfolded and disordered peptides and proteins: a view derived from tripeptide conformational analysis. II. Tripeptides with short side chains populating asx and β-type like turn conformations

In the preceding paper, we found that ensembles of tripeptides with long or bulky chains can include up to 20% of various turns. Here, we determine the structural and thermodynamic characteristics of GxG peptides with short polar and/or ionizable central residues (D, N, C), whose conformational distributions exhibit higher than average percentage (>20%) of turn conformations. To probe the side-chain conformations of these peptides, we determined the (3)J(H(α),H(β)) coupling constants and derived the population of three rotamers with χ1 -angles of -60°, 180° and 60°, which were correlated with residue propensities by DFT-calculations. For protonated GDG, the rotamer distribution provides additional evidence for asx-turns. A comparison of vibrational spectra and NMR coupling constants of protonated GDG, ionized GDG, and the protonated aspartic acid dipeptide revealed that side chain protonation increases the pPII content at the expense of turn populations. The charged terminal groups, however, have negligible influence on the conformational properties of the central residue. Like protonated GDG, cationic GCG samples asx-turns to a significant extent. The temperature dependence of the UVCD spectra and (3)J(H(N)H(α)) constants suggest that the turn populations of GDG and GNG are practically temperature-independent, indicating enthalpic and entropic stabilization. The temperature-independent J-coupling and UVCD spectra of GNG require a three-state model. Our results indicate that short side chains with hydrogen bonding capability in GxG segments of proteins may serve as hinge regions for establishing compact structures of unfolded proteins and peptides.

Disorder and order in unfolded and disordered peptides and proteins: a view derived from tripeptide conformational analysis. I. Tripeptides with long and predominantly hydrophobic side chains

We performed a conformational analysis of the central residues of three tripeptides glycyl-L-isoleucyl-glycine (GIG), glycyl-L-tyrosyl-glycine (GYG) and glycyl-L-arginyl-glycine (GRG) in aqueous solution, based on a global analysis of amide I' band profiles and NMR J-coupling constants. The results are compared with recently reported distributions of GVG, GFG and GEG. For GIG and GYG, we found that even though the polyproline II (pPII) fraction is below 0.5, it is still the most populated conformation, whereas GVG and GFG show both a larger β-strand fraction. For GRG, we observed a clear dominance of pPII over β-strand, reminiscent of observations for GEG and GKG. This finding indicates that terminal charges on otherwise hydrophobic residue side chains stabilize pPII over β-strand conformations. For all peptides investigated we found that a variety of compact and turn-like conformations constitute nearly 20 percent of their conformational distributions. Attempts to analyze our data with a simple two-state pPII-->/<--β model therefore do not yield any satisfactory reproduction of experimental results. A comparison of the obtained GxG ensembles with conformational distributions of GxG segments in truncated coil libraries (helices and sheets omitted) revealed a much larger fraction of type II β(i+2) and type III β like conformations for the latter. Thus, a comparison of conformational distributions of unfolded peptide segments in solution and in coil libraries reveal interesting information on how the interplay between intrinsic propensities of amino acid residues and non-local interactions in polypeptide chains determine the conformations of loop segments in proteins.