Theoretical Study of Internal Vibrational Relaxation and Energy Transport in Polyatomic Molecules

Tracking Energy Transfer across a Platinum Center

Rigid, conjugated alkyne bridges serve as important components in various transition-metal complexes used for energy conversion, charge separation, sensing, and molecular electronics. Alkyne stretching modes have potential for modulating charge separation in donor–bridge–acceptor compounds. Understanding the rules of energy relaxation and energy transfer across the metal center in such compounds can help optimize their electron transfer switching properties. We used relaxation-assisted two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy to track energy transfer across metal centers in platinum complexes featuring a triazole-terminated alkyne ligand of two or six carbons, a perfluorophenyl ligand, and two tri(p-tolyl)phosphine ligands. Comprehensive analyses of waiting-time dynamics for numerous cross and diagonal peaks were performed, focusing on coherent oscillation, energy transfer, and cooling parameters. These observables augmented with density functional theory computations of vibrational frequencies and anharmonic force constants enabled identification of different functional groups of the compounds. Computations of vibrational relaxation pathways and mode couplings were performed, and two regimes of intramolecular energy redistribution are described. One involves energy transfer between ligands via high-frequency modes; the transfer is efficient only if the modes involved are delocalized over both ligands. The energy transport pathways between the ligands are identified. Another regime involves redistribution via low-frequency delocalized modes, which does not lead to interligand energy transport.

Competition of Several Energy-Transport Initiation Mechanisms Defines the Ballistic Transport Speed

The ballistic regime of vibrational energy transport in oligomeric molecular chains occurs with a constant, often high, transport speed and high efficiency. Such a transport regime can be initiated by exciting a chain end group with a mid-infrared (IR) photon. To better understand the wavepacket formation process, two chemically identical end groups, azido groups with normal, ¹⁴N₃-, and isotopically substituted, ¹⁵N₃-, nitrogen atoms, were tested for wavepacket initiation in compounds with alkyl chains of n = 5, 10, and 15 methylene units terminated with a carboxylic acid (-a) group, denoted as ¹⁴N₃Cn-a and ¹⁵N₃Cn-a. The transport was initiated by exciting the azido moiety stretching mode, the ν_N≡N tag, at 2100 cm^–1 (¹⁴N₃Cn-a) or 2031 cm^–1 (¹⁵N₃Cn-a). Opposite to the expectation, the ballistic transport speed was found to decrease upon ¹⁴N₃ → ¹⁵N₃ isotope editing. Three mechanisms of the transport initiation of a vibrational wavepacket are described and analyzed. The first mechanism involves the direct formation of a wavepacket via excitation with IR photons of several strong Fermi resonances of the tag mode with the ν_N=N + ν_N–C combination state while each of the combination state components is mixed with delocalized chain states. The second mechanism relies on the vibrational relaxation of an end-group-localized tag into a mostly localized end-group state that is strongly coupled to multiple delocalized states of a chain band. Harmonic mixing of ν_N=N of the azido group with CH₂ wagging states of the chain permits a wavepacket formation within a portion of the wagging band, suggesting a fast transport speed. The third mechanism involves the vibrational relaxation of an end-group-localized mode into chain states. Two such pathways were found for the ν_N≡N initiation: The ν_N=N mode relaxes efficiently into the twisting band states and low-frequency acoustic modes, and the ν_N–C mode relaxes into the rocking band states and low-frequency acoustic modes. The contributions of the three initiation mechanisms in the ballistic energy transport initiated by ν_N≡N tag are quantitatively evaluated and related to the experiment. We conclude that the third mechanism dominates the transport in alkane chains of 5–15 methylene units initiated with the ν_N≡N tag and the wavepacket generated predominantly at the CH₂ twisting band. The isotope effect of the transport speed is attributed to a larger contribution of the faster wavepackets for ¹⁴N₃Cn-a or to the different breadth of the wavepacket within the twisting band. The study offers a systematic description of different transport initiation mechanisms and discusses the requirements and features of each mechanism. Such analysis will be useful for designing novel materials for energy management.

Unidirectional coherent energy transport via conjugated oligo(p-phenylene) chains

We discovered a way to funnel high-frequency vibrational quanta rapidly and unidirectionally over large distances using oligo(p-phenylene) chains. After mid-IR photon photoexcitation of a -COOH end group, the excess energy is injected efficiently into the chain, forming vibrational wavepackets that propagate freely along the chain. The transport delivers high-energy vibrational quanta with a range of transport speeds reaching 8.6 km/s, which exceeds the speed of sound in common metals (∼5 km/s) and polymers (∼2 km/s). Efficiencies of energy injection into the chain and transport along the chain are found to be very high and dependent on the extent of conjugation across the structure. By tuning the degree of conjugation via electronic doping of the chain, the transport speed and efficiency can be controlled. The study opens avenues for developing materials with controllable energy transport properties for heat management, schemes with efficient energy delivery to hard-to-reach regions, including transport against thermal gradients, and ways for initiating chemical reactions remotely.

Low-Temperature Vibrational Energy Transport via PEG Chains

We used relaxation-assisted two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy to study the temperature dependence (10-295 K) of end-to-end energy transport across end-decorated PEG oligomers of various chain lengths. The excess energy was introduced by exciting the azido end-group stretching mode at 2100 cm^-1 (tag); the transport was recorded by observing the asymmetric C═O stretching mode of the succinimide ester end group at 1740 cm^-1. The overall transport involves diffusive steps at the end groups and a ballistic step through the PEG chain. We found that at lower temperatures the through-chain energy transport became faster, while the end-group diffusive transport time and the tag lifetime increase. The modeling of the transport using a quantum Liouville equation linked the observations to the reduction of decoherence rate and an increase of the mean-free-path for the vibrational wavepacket. The energy transport at the end groups slowed down at low temperatures due to the decreased number and efficiency of the anharmonic energy redistribution pathways.

Intramolecular vibrational energy redistribution and the quantum ergodicity transition: a phase space perspective

The onset of facile intramolecular vibrational energy flow can be related to features in the connected network of anharmonic resonances in the classical phase space.

Tuning Molecular Vibrational Energy Flow within an Aromatic Scaffold via Anharmonic Coupling

From guiding chemical reactivity in synthesis or protein folding to the design of energy diodes, intramolecular vibrational energy redistribution harnesses the power to influence the underlying fundamental principles of chemistry. To evaluate the ability to steer these processes, the mechanism and time scales of intramolecular vibrational energy redistribution through aromatic molecular scaffolds have been assessed by utilizing two-dimensional infrared (2D IR) spectroscopy. 2D IR cross peaks reveal energy relaxation through an aromatic scaffold from the azido- to the cyano-vibrational reporters in para-azidobenzonitrile (PAB) and para-(azidomethyl)benzonitrile (PAMB) prior to energy relaxation into the solvent. The rates of energy transfer are modulated by Fermi resonances, which are apparent by the coupling cross peaks identified within the 2D IR spectrum. Theoretical vibrational mode analysis allowed the determination of the origins of the energy flow, the transfer pathway, and a direct comparison of the associated transfer rates, which were in good agreement with the experimental results. Large variations in energy-transfer rates, approximately 1.9 ps for PAB and 23 ps for PAMB, illustrate the importance of strong anharmonic coupling, i.e., Fermi resonance, on the transfer pathways. In particular, vibrational energy rectification is altered by Fermi resonances of the cyano- and azido-modes allowing control of the propensity for energy flow.

Ballistic and diffusive vibrational energy transport in molecules

Energy transport in molecules is essential for many areas of science and technology. Strong covalent bonds of a molecular backbone can facilitate the involvement of the molecule's high-frequency modes in energy transport, which, under certain conditions, makes the transport fast and efficient. We discuss such conditions and describe various transport regimes in molecules, including ballistic, diffusive, directed diffusion, and intermediate regime cases, in light of recently developed experimental and theoretical approaches.

2D-IR spectroscopy of hydrogen-bond-mediated vibrational excitation transfer

Inter-molecular vibrational energy transfer in the hydrogen-bonded complexes of methyl acetate and 4-cyanophenol is studied by dual-frequency 2D-IR spectroscopy.

Ballistic Energy Transport in Oligomers

The development of nanocomposite materials with desired heat management properties, including nanowires, layered semiconductor structures, and self-assembled monolayer (SAM) junctions, attracts broad interest. Such materials often involve polymeric/oligomeric components and can feature high or low thermal conductivity, depending on their design. For example, in SAM junctions made of alkane chains sandwiched between metal layers, the thermal conductivity can be very low, whereas the fibers of ordered polyethylene chains feature high thermal conductivity, exceeding that of many pure metals. The thermal conductivity of nanostructured materials is determined by the energy transport between and within each component of the material, which all need to be understood for optimizing the properties. For example, in the SAM junctions, the energy transport across the metal-chain interface as well as the transport through the chains both determine the overall heat conductivity, however, to separate these contributions is difficult. Recently developed relaxation-assisted two-dimensional infrared (RA 2DIR) spectroscopy is capable of studying energy transport in individual molecules in the time domain. The transport in a molecule is initiated by exciting an IR-active group (a tag); the method records the influence of the excess energy on another mode in the molecule (a reporter). The energy transport time can be measured for different reporters, and the transport speed through the molecule is evaluated. Various molecules were interrogated by RA 2DIR: in molecules without repeating units (disordered), the transport mechanism was expected and found to be diffusive. The transport via an oligomer backbone can potentially be ballistic, as the chain offers delocalized vibrational states. Indeed, the transport regime via three tested types of oligomers, alkanes, polyethyleneglycols, and perfluoroalkanes was found to be ballistic, whereas the transport within the end groups was diffusive. Interestingly, the transport speeds via these chains were different. Moreover, the transport speed was found to be dependent on the vibrational mode initiating the transport. For the difference in the transport speeds to be explained, the chain bands involved in the wavepacket formation were analyzed, and specific optical bands of the chain were identified as the energy transporters. For example, the transport initiated in alkanes by the stretching mode of the azido end group (2100 cm(-1)) occurs predominantly via the CH2 twisting and wagging chain bands, but the transport initiated by the C=O stretching modes of the carboxylic acid or succinimide ester end groups occurs via C-C stretching and CH2 rocking bands of the alkane chain. Direct formation of the wavepacket within the CH2 twisting and wagging chain bands occurs when the transport is initiated by the N═N stretching mode (1270 cm-1) of the azido end-group. The transport via optical chain bands in oligomers involves rather large vibrational quanta (700-1400 cm(-1)), resulting in efficient energy delivery to substantial distances. Achieved quantitative description of various energy transport steps in oligomers, including the specific contributions of different chain bands, can result in a better understanding of the transport steps in nanocomposite materials, including SAM junctions, and lead towards designing systems for molecular electronics with a controllable energy transport speed.

Room-temperature ballistic energy transport in molecules with repeating units

In materials, energy can propagate by means of two limiting regimes: diffusive and ballistic. Ballistic energy transport can be fast and efficient and often occurs with a constant speed. Using two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy methods, we discovered ballistic energy transport via individual polyethylene chains with a remarkably high speed of 1440 m/s and the mean free path length of 14.6 Å in solution at room temperature. Whereas the transport via the chains occurs ballistically, the mechanism switches to diffusive with the effective transport speed of 130 m/s at the end-groups attached to the chains. A unifying model of the transport in molecules is presented with clear time separation and additivity among the transport along oligomeric fragments, which occurs ballistically, and the transport within the disordered fragments, occurring diffusively. The results open new avenues for making novel elements for molecular electronics, including ultrafast energy transporters, controlled chemical reactors, and sub-wavelength quantum nanoseparators.

Vibrational energy transport in molecules studied by relaxation-assisted two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy

This review presents an overview of the relaxation-assisted two-dimensional infrared (RA 2DIR) spectroscopy method for measuring structures and energy transport dynamics in molecules. The method strongly enhances the range of accessible distances compared to traditional 2DIR and offers new structural reporters, such as the energy transport time, cross-peak amplification factors, and connectivity patterns. The use of the method for assigning vibrational modes with various levels of delocalization is illustrated. RA 2DIR relies on vibrational energy transport in molecules; as such, the transport mechanism can be conveniently studied by the method. Applications to identify diffusive and ballistic energy transport are demonstrated.

Communication: fast transport and relaxation of vibrational energy in polymer chains

We investigate ballistic vibrational energy transport through optical phonon band in oligomeric chains in the presence of decoherence. An exact solution is obtained for the excitation density in the space-time representation in the continuous limit and this solution is used to characterize the energy transport time and intensity. Three transport mechanisms are identified such as ballistic, diffusive, and directed diffusive regimes, occurring at different distances and time scales. The crossover between the two diffusive regimes is continuous, while the switch between the ballistic and diffusive mechanisms occurs in a discontinuous manner in accord with the recent experimental results on energy transport in perfluoroalkanes.

Temperature dependence of the ballistic energy transport in perfluoroalkanes

Temperature dependence of intramolecular energy transport in perfluoroalkane oligomers with a chain length of 3-11 carbon atoms terminated by a carboxylic acid moiety on one end and a -CF2H group on another end was studied in solution experimentally and theoretically. Experiments were performed using a dual-frequency relaxation-assisted two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy method. The energy transport was initiated by exciting the C═O stretching mode of the acid and recorded by measuring a cross-peak amplitude between the C═O stretching and the C-H bending modes as a function of the waiting time between the excitation and probing. An efficient transport regime with a mean free path of 16.4 ± 2 Å is observed at 35 °C. The energy transport speed decreases at elevated temperatures, indicating a switch from the ballistic transport regime to diffusive. The modeling of the energy transport involving both ballistic and diffusive mechanisms is performed. It explains the temperature dependence of the energy transport speed and confirms a switch of the transport regime from ballistic at lower temperatures to diffusive at higher temperatures.