Singlet Oxygen Generating Activity of an Electron Donor Connecting Porphyrin Photosensitizer Can Be Controlled by DNA

Singlet Oxygen Photophysics: From Liquid Solvents to Mammalian Cells

Molecular oxygen, O2, has long provided a cornerstone for studies in chemistry, physics, and biology. Although the triplet ground state, O2(X3Σg-), has garnered much attention, the lowest excited electronic state, O2(a1Δg), commonly called singlet oxygen, has attracted appreciable interest, principally because of its unique chemical reactivity in systems ranging from the Earth's atmosphere to biological cells. Because O2(a1Δg) can be produced and deactivated in processes that involve light, the photophysics of O2(a1Δg) are equally important. Moreover, pathways for O2(a1Δg) deactivation that regenerate O2(X3Σg-), which address fundamental principles unto themselves, kinetically compete with the chemical reactions of O2(a1Δg) and, thus, have practical significance. Due to technological advances (e.g., lasers, optical detectors, microscopes), data acquired in the past ∼20 years have increased our understanding of O2(a1Δg) photophysics appreciably and facilitated both spatial and temporal control over the behavior of O2(a1Δg). One goal of this Review is to summarize recent developments that have broad ramifications, focusing on systems in which oxygen forms a contact complex with an organic molecule M (e.g., a liquid solvent). An important concept is the role played by the M+•O2-• charge-transfer state in both the formation and deactivation of O2(a1Δg).

Protein Photodamaging Activity and Photocytotoxic Effect of an Axial-Connecting Phosphorus(V)porphyrin Trimer

An axial-connecting trimer of the porphyrin phosphorus(V) complex was synthesized to evaluate the relaxation process of the photoexcited state and the photosensitizer activity. The photoexcitation energy was localized on the central unit of the phosphorus(V)porphyrin trimer. The photoexcited state of the central unit was relaxed through a process similar to that of the monomer phosphorus(V)porphyrin. The excited state of this axially connected type of phosphorus(V)porphyrin trimer was not deactivated through intramolecular electron transfer. The singlet oxygen generation quantum yield of the trimer was almost the same as that of the monomer. The phosphorus(V)porphyrin, trimer, and monomer bound to human serum albumin and oxidized the tryptophan residue via singlet oxygen generation and electron transfer during visible light irradiation. The photocytotoxicity of these phosphorus(V)porphyrins on two cell lines was examined. The monomer induced photocytotoxicity; however, the trimer did not show cytotoxicity with or without photoirradiation. In summary, the photoexcited state of the trimer was almost the same as that of the monomer, and these phosphorus(V)porphyrins demonstrated a similar protein-photodamaging activity. The difference in association between the photosensitizer molecules and cells is the key factor of phototoxicity by these phosphorus(V)porphyrins.

Porphyrin as a versatile visible-light-activatable organic/metal hybrid photoremovable protecting group

Photoremovable protecting groups (PPGs) represent one of the main contemporary implementations of photochemistry in diverse fields of research and practical applications. For the past half century, organic and metal-complex PPGs were considered mutually exclusive classes, each of which provided unique sets of physical and chemical properties thanks to their distinctive structures. Here, we introduce the meso-methylporphyrin group as a prototype hybrid-class PPG that unites traditionally exclusive elements of organic and metal-complex PPGs within a single structure. We show that the porphyrin scaffold allows extensive modularity by functional separation of the metal-binding chromophore and up to four sites of leaving group release. The insertion of metal ions can be used to tune their spectroscopic, photochemical, and biological properties. We provide a detailed description of the photoreaction mechanism studied by steady-state and transient absorption spectroscopies and quantum-chemical calculations. Our approach applied herein could facilitate access to a hitherto untapped chemical space of potential PPG scaffolds.

Substituent Effect in Pyridinium Alkynylanthracenes on their Performance as Photosensitizers for Photodynamic Therapy

Progress in photodynamic therapy (PDT) relies on the design and synthesis of photosensitizers that can efficiently sensitize singlet oxygen using visible light irradiation while displaying limited dark toxicity. Here, we highlight the paper by Linker and coworkers published in this issue of Photochemistry and Photobiology, which evaluates the effect of the regiochemistry of pyridinium rings in three isomeric pyridinium alkynylanthracenes on their performance as photosensitizers for PDT in HeLa cells.

Photosensitized Protein Damage by DiethyleneglycoxyP(V)tetrakis(p-n-butoxyphenyl)porphyrin Through Electron Transfer: Activity Control Through Self-aggregation and Dissociation

DiethyleneglycoxyP(V)tetrakis(p-n-butoxyphenyl)porphyrin (EGP(V)TBPP) forms a self-aggregation in an aqueous solution, and the photoexcited state of this molecule was effectively deactivated. Association with human serum albumin (HSA), a water-soluble protein, causes dissociation of the self-aggregation, resulting in recovery of the photosensitizer activity of EGP(V)TBPP. Under visible light irradiation, EGP(V)TBPP photosensitized HSA oxidation. The photosensitized singlet oxygen-generating activity of EGP(V)TBPP was confirmed by near-infrared emission measurement. A singlet oxygen quencher, sodium azide, partially inhibited the HSA photodamage; however, the quenching effect was estimated to be 57%. Another 43% of the HSA photodamage could be explained by the electron transfer mechanism. The redox potential of EGP(V)TBPP and the calculated Gibbs energy of electron transfer from tryptophan to photoexcited EGP(V)TBPP demonstrated the possibility of HSA oxidation through electron extraction. Fluorescence lifetime measurements of EGP(V)TBPP verified the electron transfer from HSA. The photosensitizer activity of EGP(V)TBPP can be controlled through an association with biomolecules, such as protein, and the electron transfer-mediated biomolecule photooxidation plays an important role in photodynamic therapy under hypoxia.

DNA-Triggered Enhancement of Singlet Oxygen Production by Pyridinium Alkynylanthracenes

There is an ongoing interest in ¹ O₂ sensitizers, whose activity is selectively controlled by their interaction with DNA. To this end, we synthesized three isomeric pyridinium alkynylanthracenes 2 o-p and a water-soluble trapping reagent for ¹ O₂ . In water and in the absence of DNA, these dyes show a poor efficiency to sensitize the photooxygenation of the trapping reagent as they decompose due to electron transfer processes. In contrast, in the presence of DNA ¹ O₂ is generated from the excited DNA-bound ligand. The interactions of 2 o-p with DNA were investigated by thermal DNA melting studies, UV/vis and fluorescence spectroscopy, and linear and circular dichroism spectroscopy. Our studies revealed an intercalative binding with an orientation of the long pyridyl-alkynyl axis parallel to the main axis of the DNA base pairs. In the presence of poly(dA : dT), all three isomers show an enhanced formation of singlet oxygen, as indicated by the reaction of the latter with the trapping reagent. With green light irradiation of isomer 2 o in poly(dA : dT), the conversion rate of the trapping reagent is enhanced by a factor >10. The formation of ¹ O₂ was confirmed by control experiments under anaerobic conditions, in deuterated solvents, or by addition of ¹ O₂ quenchers. When bound to poly(dG : dC), the opposite effect was observed only for isomers 2 o and 2 m, namely the trapping reagent reacted significantly slower. Overall, we showed that pyridinium alkynylanthracenes are very useful intercalators, that exhibit an enhanced photochemical ¹ O₂ generation in the DNA-bound state.

Probing the Interactions of Porphyrins with Macromolecules Using NMR Spectroscopy Techniques

Porphyrinic compounds are widespread in nature and play key roles in biological processes such as oxygen transport in blood, enzymatic redox reactions or photosynthesis. In addition, both naturally derived as well as synthetic porphyrinic compounds are extensively explored for biomedical and technical applications such as photodynamic therapy (PDT) or photovoltaic systems, respectively. Their unique electronic structures and photophysical properties make this class of compounds so interesting for the multiple functions encountered. It is therefore not surprising that optical methods are typically the prevalent analytical tool applied in characterization and processes involving porphyrinic compounds. However, a wealth of complementary information can be obtained from NMR spectroscopic techniques. Based on the advantage of providing structural and dynamic information with atomic resolution simultaneously, NMR spectroscopy is a powerful method for studying molecular interactions between porphyrinic compounds and macromolecules. Such interactions are of special interest in medical applications of porphyrinic photosensitizers that are mostly combined with macromolecular carrier systems. The macromolecular surrounding typically stabilizes the encapsulated drug and may also modify its physical properties. Moreover, the interaction with macromolecular physiological components needs to be explored to understand and control mechanisms of action and therapeutic efficacy. This review focuses on such non-covalent interactions of porphyrinic drugs with synthetic polymers as well as with biomolecules such as phospholipids or proteins. A brief introduction into various NMR spectroscopic techniques is given including chemical shift perturbation methods, NOE enhancement spectroscopy, relaxation time measurements and diffusion-ordered spectroscopy. How these NMR tools are used to address porphyrin-macromolecule interactions with respect to their function in biomedical applications is the central point of the current review.

Photooxidation Activity Control of Dimethylaminophenyl-tris-(N-methyl-4-pridinio)porphyrin by pH

To control the activity of photodynamic agents by pH, an electron donor-connecting cationic porphyrin, meso-(N',N'-dimethyl-4-aminophenyl)-tris(N-methyl-p-pyridinio)porphyrin (DMATMPyP), was designed and synthesized. The photoexcited state (singlet excited state) of DMATMPyP was deactivated through intramolecular electron transfer under a neutral condition. The pK a of the protonated DMATMPyP was 4.5, and the fluorescence intensity and singlet oxygen-generating activity increased under an acidic condition. Furthermore, the protonation of DMATMPyP enhanced the biomolecule photooxidative activity through electron extraction. Photodamage of human serum albumin (HSA) was observed under a neutral condition because a hydrophobic HSA environment can reverse the deactivation of photoexcited DMATMPyP. However, an HSA-damaging mechanism of DMATMPyP under a neutral condition was explained by singlet oxygen production. Therefore, it is indicated that the protein photodamaging activity of DMATMPyP goes into an OFF state under a neutral hypoxic condition. Under an acidic condition, the HSA photodamaging quantum yield by DMATMPyP through electron extraction could be preserved in the presence of a singlet oxygen quencher. Photooxidation of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide by DMATMPyP was also enhanced under an acidic condition. This study demonstrated the concept of using pH to control photosensitizer activity via inhibition of the intramolecular electron transfer deactivation and enhancement of the oxidative activity through the electron extraction mechanism. Specifically, biomolecule oxidation through electron extraction may play an important role in photodynamic therapy to treat tumors under a hypoxic condition.

Biomimetic Carriers Based on Giant Membrane Vesicles for Targeted Drug Delivery and Photodynamic/Photothermal Synergistic Therapy

Membrane vesicles derived from live cells show great potential in biological applications due to their preserved cell membrane properties. Here, we demonstrate that cell-derived giant membrane vesicles can be used as vectors to deliver multiple therapeutic drugs and carry out combinational phototherapy for targeted cancer treatment. We show that therapeutic drugs can be efficiently encapsulated into giant membrane vesicles and delivered to target cells by membrane fusion, resulting in synergistic photodynamic/photothermal therapy under light irradiation. This study highlights biomimetic giant membrane vesicles for drug delivery with potential biomedical application in cancer therapeutics.

Controlled Photodynamic Action of Axial Fluorinated DiethoxyP(V)tetrakis(p-methoxyphenyl)porphyrin through Self-Aggregation

DiethoxyP(V)tetrakis(p-methoxyphenyl)porphyrin (EtP(V)TMPP) and its fluorinated derivative (FEtP(V)TMPP) were synthesized to examine their photodynamic action. These P(V)porphyrins were aggregated in an aqueous solution, resulting in the suppression of their photodynamic activity. In the presence of human serum albumin (HSA), a water-soluble protein, the aggregation states were resolved and formed a binding complex between P(V)porphyrin and HSA. These P(V)porphyrins photosensitized the oxidation of the tryptophan residue of HSA under the irradiation of long-wavelength visible light (>630 nm). This protein photodamage was explained by the electron transfer from tryptophan to the photoexcited state of P(V)porphyrins and singlet oxygen generation. The axial fluorination reduced the redox potential of the one-electron reduction of P(V)porphyrin and increased the electron transfer rate constant. However, this axial fluorination decreased the binding constant with HSA, and the quantum yield of photosensitized HSA damage through electron transfer was decreased. The photocytotoxicity of these P(V)porphyrins to HaCaT cells was also confirmed, and FEtP(V)TMPP demonstrated stronger phototoxicity than EtP(V)TMPP. In summary, a self-aggregation of porphyrin photosensitizers and resolving by targeting biomacromolecules may be used to target selective photodynamic action. The redox potential and an association with a targeting biomolecule are the important factors of the electron transfer-mediated mechanism, which is advantageous under hypoxic tumor conditions.

DNA-modulated photosensitization: current status and future aspects in biosensing and environmental monitoring

Recently, photosensitized oxidation has been explored in many fields of research and applications, such as photodynamic therapy (PDT) and photodynamic antimicrobial chemotherapy (PACT). Although the photosensitized generation of ROS features emerging applications, controllable management of the photosensitization process is still sometimes problematic. DNA has long been considered the carrier for genetic information. With the in-depth study of the chemical properties of DNA, the molecular function of DNA is gradually witnessed by the scientific community. Undoubtedly, the selective recognition nature of DNA endows them excellent candidate modulators for photosensitized oxidation. According to current research, reports on DNA regulation of photosensitized oxidation can be roughly divided into two categories in principle: P-Q quenching pair-switched photosensitization and host-guest interaction-switched photosensitization. In this review, the development status of these two analytical methods will be summarized, and the future development direction of DNA-modulated photosensitization in biosensing and environmental monitoring will also be prospected.

Kinetics of Spontaneous Bimetallization between Silver and Noble Metal Nanoparticles

A physical mixture of polymer-protected Ag nanoparticles and Rh, Pd, or Pt nanoparticles spontaneously forms Ag-core bimetallic nanoparticles. The formed nanoparticles were smaller than the parent Ag nanoparticles. In the initial process of this reaction, the surface plasmon absorption of Ag nanoparticles diminished and then almost ceased within one hour. Within several minutes, the decrease in Ag surface plasmon absorption could be analyzed by second-order reaction. This reaction was accelerated with an increase of temperature and the energy gap in the Fermi level between Ag and the other metals. The activation energy (Ea ) of this reaction could be determined. An electron transfer reaction from Ag to other metal nanoparticles was proposed as the initial interaction between these metal nanoparticles because the Fermi level of Ag is relatively high, and the electron transfer is possible in terms of energy. The Marcus plot between the rate constant and the driving force, roughly estimated from the work function of metals, and the observed Ea values reasonably explained the proposed electron transfer mechanism.

Controllable Photodynamic Therapy Implemented by Regulating Singlet Oxygen Efficiency

With singlet oxygen (1O2) as the active agent, photodynamic therapy (PDT) is a promising technique for the treatment of various tumors and cancers. But it is hampered by the poor selectivity of most traditional photosensitizers (PS). In this review, we present a summary of controllable PDT implemented by regulating singlet oxygen efficiency. Herein, various controllable PDT strategies based on different initiating conditions (such as pH, light, H2O2 and so on) have been summarized and introduced. More importantly, the action mechanisms of controllable PDT strategies, such as photoinduced electron transfer (PET), fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET), intramolecular charge transfer (ICT) and some physical/chemical means (e.g. captivity and release), are described as a key point in the article. This review provide a general overview of designing novel PS or strategies for effective and controllable PDT.

Singlet oxygen generation properties of an inclusion complex of cyclic free-base porphyrin dimer and fullerene C60

We demonstrate that a cyclic free-base porphyrin dimer and its inclusion complex with fullerene C₆₀ possess the ability to generate singlet oxygen (¹O₂) under visible light irradiation.

Tetrakis(N-methyl-p-pyridinio)porphyrin and its zinc complex can photosensitize damage of human serum albumin through electron transfer and singlet oxygen generation

The photosensitized protein-damaging activity of water-soluble freebase tetrakis([Formula: see text]-methyl-[Formula: see text]-pyridinio)porphyrin (H2TMPyP), and its zinc complex (ZnTMPyP) was investigated using human serum albumin (HSA) as a target protein. These porphyrins bound to HSA and caused photosensitized oxidation of the tryptophan residue. The protein damage was enhanced in deuterium oxide and inhibited by sodium azide, a physical quencher of singlet oxygen, suggesting the contribution of singlet oxygen. However, an excess amount of sodium azide could not completely inhibit protein damage. These findings suggest the partial contribution of another mechanism to the protein damage, possibly the electron transfer mechanism. The Gibbs free energy of the electron transfer mechanism showed that electron transfer-mediated tryptophan oxidation by photoexcited H2TMPyP is more advantageous than that by ZnTMPyP. Actually, the quantum yield of protein damage through electron transfer by H2TMPyP was larger than that by ZnTMPyP. In addition, this study demonstrated that the association between porphyrin and protein plays an important role in photosensitized protein damage.

Determination of Singlet Oxygen and Electron Transfer Mediated Mechanisms of Photosensitized Protein Damage by Phosphorus(V)porphyrins

The mechanism of photosensitized protein damage byphosphorus(V) tetraphenylporphyrin derivatives (P(V)TPPs) wasquantitatively clarified. P(V)TPPs bound to human serum albumin(HSA), a water-soluble protein, and damaged its tryptophan residueduring photoirradiation. P(V)TPPs photosensitized singlet oxygen ((1)O(2))generation, and the contribution of (1)O(2) to HSA damage was confirmedby the inhibitory effect of sodium azide, a (1)O(2) quencher. However,sodium azide could not completely inhibit HSA damage, suggesting thecontribution of an electron transfer mechanism to HSA damage. Thedecrement in the fluorescence lifetime of P(V)TPPs by HSA supportedthe electron transfer mechanism. The contribution of these processes could be determined by the kinetic analysis of the effect ofsodium azide on the photosensitized protein damage by P(V)TPPs.

Bacteriochlorin Dyads as Solvent Polarity Dependent Near-Infrared Fluorophores and Reactive Oxygen Species Photosensitizers

Symmetrical, near-infrared absorbing bacteriochlorin dyads exhibit gradual reduction of their fluorescence (intensity and lifetime) and reactive oxygen species photosensitization efficiency (ROS) with increasing solvent dielectric constant ε. For the directly linked dyad, significant reduction is observed even in solvents of moderate ε, while for the dyad containing a 1,4-phenylene linker, reduction is more parallel to an increase in solvent ε. Bacteriochlorin dyads are promising candidates for development of environmentally responsive fluorophores and ROS sensitizers.

Synthesis and photodynamic activities of a new metronidazole-appended porphyrin and its Zn(II) complex

One novel porphyrin 5,10,15-tris(phenyl)-20-[4-(2-(2-methyl-5-nitro-imidazolyl)ethoxyl)phenyl] porphyrin and its zinc(II) metalloporphyrin were synthesized and characterized by IR, UV-vis, 1H NMR, MS and elemental analysis. The single crystal structure of zinc(II) porphyrin shows that the Zn(II) ion is coordinated with four nitrogen atoms of porphyrin ring and one oxygen atom of ethanol from axial, forming a five-coordinated square pyramidal geometry. Their cytotoxicity and photodynamic activity against breast cancer cells were studied. The results indicate that both of the porphyrins display high phototoxicity to the breast cancer cells with the negligible dark toxicity. In addition, the photodynamic activity of zinc(II) porphyrin was obviously higher than that of the free porphyrin.

Development of a D–π–A pyrazinium photosensitizer possessing singlet oxygen generation

(D–π–)₂A pyrazinium dyes (OEJ-1 and OEJ-2) bearing a counter anion (X⁻ = Br⁻ or I⁻) have been newly developed as a photosensitizer possessing singlet oxygen (¹O₂) generation.

Relaxation Process of Photoexcited meso-Naphthylporphyrins while Interacting with DNA and Singlet Oxygen Generation

Electron donor-connecting cationic porphyrins meso-(1-naphthyl)-tris(N-methyl-p-pyridinio)porphyrin (1-NapTMPyP) and meso-(2-naphthyl)-tris(N-methyl-p-pyridinio)porphyrin (2-NapTMPyP) were designed and synthesized. DFT calculations speculate that the photoexcited states of 1- and 2-NapTMPyPs can be deactivated via intramolecular electron transfer from the naphthyl moiety to the porphyrin moiety. However, the quenching effect through the intramolecular electron transfer is insufficient, possibly due to the orthogonal position of the electron donor and the porphyrin ring and the relatively small driving force: Gibbs energies are 0.11 and 0.07 eV for 1- and 2-NapTMPyPs, respectively. It was speculated that more than 0.3 eV of the driving force is required to realize effective electron transfer in similar electron-donor connecting porphyrin systems. These porphyrins aggregated around the DNA strand, accelerating the deactivation of their excited singlet state and decreasing their photosensitized singlet oxygen-generating activities. In the presence of a sufficiently large concentration of DNA, these porphyrins can bind to a DNA strand stably, leading to an increased fluorescence quantum yield and lifetime. Singlet oxygen generation was also suppressed by the aggregation of porphyrins around DNA. Although the quantum yield of singlet oxygen generation was recovered in the presence of sufficient DNA, the singlet oxygen generated by DNA-binding porphyrins was significantly smaller than that without DNA. These results suggest that DNA-binding drugs limit the generation of photosensitized singlet oxygen by quenching the DNA strand.

Singlet oxygen in DNA nanotechnology

CONSPECTUS: Singlet oxygen ((1)O2), the first excited electronic state of molecular oxygen, is a significant molecule, despite its minute size. For more than half a century, the molecule has been widely used and studied in organic synthesis, due to its characteristic oxygenation reactions. Furthermore, (1)O2 plays a key role in mechanisms of cell death, which has led to its use in therapies for several types of cancer and other diseases. The high abundance of oxygen in air provides a wonderful source of molecules that can be excited to the reactive singlet state, for example, by UV/vis irradiation of a photosensitizer molecule. Although convenient, this oxygen abundance also presents some challenges for purposes that require (1)O2 to be generated in a controlled manner. In the past decade, we and others have employed DNA nanostructures to selectively control and investigate the generation, lifetime, and reactions of (1)O2. DNA-based structures are one of the most powerful tools for controlling distances between molecules on the nanometer length scale, in particular for systems that closely resemble biological settings, due to their inherent ability to specifically form duplex structures with well-defined and predictable geometries. Here, we present some examples of how simple DNA structures can be employed to regulate (1)O2 production by controlling the behavior of (1)O2-producing photosensitizers through their interactions with independent quencher molecules. We have developed different DNA-based systems in which (1)O2 production can be switched ON or OFF in the presence of specific DNA sequences or by changing the pH of the solution. To further illustrate the interplay between DNA structures and (1)O2, we present three pieces of research, in which (1)O2 is used to activate or deactivate DNA-based systems based on the reaction between (1)O2 and cleavable linkers. In one example, it is demonstrated how a blocked oligonucleotide can be released upon irradiation with light of a specific wavelength. In more complex systems, DNA origami structures composed of more than 200 individual oligonucleotides were employed to study (1)O2 reactions in spatially resolved experiments on the nanoscale.

Nile blue can photosensitize DNA damage through electron transfer

The mechanism of DNA damage photosensitized by Nile blue (NB) was studied using (32)P-5'-end-labeled DNA fragments. NB bound to the DNA strand was possibly intercalated through an electrostatic interaction. Photoirradiated NB caused DNA cleavage at guanine residues when the DNA fragments were treated with piperidine. Consecutive guanines, the underlined G in 5'-GG and 5'-GGG, were selectively damaged through photoinduced electron transfer. The fluorescence lifetime of NB was decreased by guanine-containing DNA sequence, supporting this mechanism. Single guanines were also slightly damaged by photoexcited NB, and DNA photodamage by NB was slightly enhanced in D2O. These results suggest that the singlet oxygen mechanism also partly contributes to DNA photodamage by NB. DNA damage photosensitized by NB via electron transfer may be an important mechanism in medicinal applications of photosensitizers, such as photodynamic therapy in low oxygen.