Benchmark study on methanol C-H and O-H bond activation by bare [Fe(IV)O](2+)

Organolanthanide Complexes Containing Ln-CH3 σ-bonds: Unexpectedly Similar Hydrolysis Rates for Trivalent and Tetravalent Organocerium

We report the gas-phase preparation, isolation, and reactivity of a series of organolanthanides featuring the Ln-CH3 bond. The complexes are formed by decarboxylating anionic lanthanide acetates to form trivalent [LnIII(CH3)(CH3CO2)3]- (Ln = La, Ce, Pr, Nd, Sm, Tb, Tm, Yb, Lu), divalent [EuII(CH3)(CH3CO2)2]-, and the first examples of tetravalent organocerium complexes featuring CeIV-Calkyl σ-bonds: [CeIV(O)(CH3)(CH3CO2)2]- and [CeIV(O)(CH3)(NO3)2]-. Attempts to isolate PrIV-CH3 and TbIV-CH3 were unsuccessful; however, fragmentation patterns reveal that the oxidation of LnIII to a LnIV-oxo-acetate complex is more favorable for Ln = Pr than for Ln = Tb. The rate of Ln-CH3 hydrolysis is a measure of bond stability, and it decreases from LaIII-CH3 to LuIII-CH3, with increasing steric crowding for smaller Ln stabilizing the harder Ln-CH3 bond against hydrolysis. [EuII(CH3)(CH3CO2)2]- engages in a much faster hydrolysis versus LnIII-CH3. The surprising observation of similar hydrolysis rates for CeIV-CH3 and CeIII-CH3 is discussed with respect to sterics, the oxo ligand, and bond covalency in σ-bonded organolanthanides.

Comparative oxidative ability of mononuclear and dinuclear high-valent iron-oxo species towards the activation of methane: does the axial/bridge atom modulate the reactivity?

Over the years, mononuclear Fe^IVO species have been extensively studied, but the presence of dinuclear Fe^IVO species in soluble methane monooxygenase (sMMO) has inspired the development of biomimic models that could activate inert substrates such as methane. There are some successful attempts; particularly the [(Por)(m-CBA) Fe^IV(μ-N)Fe^IV(O)(Por˙⁺)]^- species has been reported to activate methane and yield decent catalytic turnover numbers and therefore regarded as the closest to the sMMO enzyme functional model, as no mononuclear Fe^IVO analogues could achieve this feat. In this work, we have studied a series of mono and dinuclear models using DFT and ab initio DLPNO-CCSD(T) calculations to probe the importance of nuclearity in enhancing the reactivity. We have probed the catalytic activities of four complexes: [(HO)Fe^IV(O)(Por)]^- (1), [(HO)Fe^IV(O)(Por˙⁺)] (2), μ-oxo dinuclear iron species [(Por)(m-CBA)Fe^IV(μ-O)Fe^IV(O) (Por˙⁺)]^- (3) and N-bridged dinuclear iron species [(Por)(m-CBA)Fe^IV(μ-N)Fe^IV(O)(Por˙⁺)]^- (4) towards the activation of methane. Additionally, calculations were performed on the mononuclear models [(X)Fe^IV(O)(Por˙⁺)]ⁿ {X = N 4a (n = -2), NH 4b (n = -1) and NH₂4c (n = 0)} to understand the role of nuclearity in the reactivity. DFT calculations performed on species 1-4 suggest an interesting variation among them, with species 1-3 possessing an intermediate spin (S = 1) as a ground state and species 4 possessing a high-spin (S = 2) as a ground state. Furthermore, the two Fe^IV centres in species 3 and 4 are antiferromagnetically coupled, yielding a singlet state with a distinct difference in their electronic structure. On the other hand, species 2 exhibits a ferromagnetic coupling between the Fe^IV and the Por˙⁺ moiety. Our calculations suggest that the higher barriers for the C-H bond activation of methane and the rebound step for species 1 and 3 are very high in energy, rendering them unreactive towards methane, while species 2 and 4 have lower barriers, suggesting their reactivity towards methane. Studies on the system reveal that model 4a has multiple FeN bonds facilitating greater reactivity, whereas the other two models have longer Fe-N bonds and less radical character with steeper barriers. Strong electronic cooperativity is found to be facilitated by the bridging nitride atom, and this cooperativity is suppressed by substituents such as oxygen, rendering them inactive. Thus, our study unravels that apart from enhancing the nuclearity, bridging atoms that facilitate strong cooperation between the metals are required to activate very inert substrates such as methane, and our results are broadly in agreement with earlier experimental findings.

Reaction of Ta3 - Clusters with Molecular Nitrogen: A Mechanism Investigation

Because of the inertness of molecular nitrogen, its practicable activation under mild conditions is a fundamental challenge. Ta3 - is an exceptionally small cluster that reacts with N2 at room temperature, leading finally to Ta3N2 -; Ta3N2 - also could react with N2 at room temperature, leading finally to Ta3N4 -, a product of interest in its own right because of its potential as a nitrogen fixation medium. The mechanisms of the Ta3 -- and Ta3N2 --mediated activation of the N≡N triple bond have been investigated. Our extensive computations elucidate mechanisms for the ready reactions, leading to stepwise cleavage of the N≡N bond. Initial isomeric N2/Ta3 - complexes, N≡N elongation, undergo a N≡N split over generally low barriers in a highly exothermic process. The nitrogen-atom or molecular exchange reactions found in the Ta3N2 -/N2 system may be of paramount importance in both applied and fundamental studies.

Lanthanide Complexes Containing a Terminal Ln═O Oxo Bond: Revealing Higher Stability of Tetravalent Praseodymium versus Terbium

We report on the reactivity of gas-phase lanthanide-oxide nitrate complexes, [Ln(O)(NO₃)₃]^- (denoted LnO²⁺), produced via elimination of NO₂^• from trivalent [Ln^III(NO₃)₄]^- (Ln = Ce, Pr, Nd, Sm, Tb, Dy). These complexes feature a Ln^III-O^• oxyl, a Ln^IV═O oxo, or an intermediate Ln^III/IV oxyl/oxo bond, depending on the accessibility of the tetravalent Ln^IV state. Hydrogen atom abstraction reactivity of the LnO²⁺ complexes to form unambiguously trivalent [Ln^III(OH)(NO₃)₃]^- reveals the nature of the oxide bond. The result of slower reactivity of PrO²⁺ versus TbO²⁺ is considered to indicate higher stability of the tetravalent praseodymium-oxo, Pr^IV═O, versus Tb^IV═O. This is the first report of Pr^IV as more stable than Tb^IV, which is discussed with respect to ionization potentials, standard electrode potentials, atomic promotion energies, and oxo bond covalency via 4f- and/or 5d-orbital participation.

Phenol Tautomerization Catalyzed by Acid-Base Pairs in Lewis Acidic Beta Zeolites: A Computational Study

We investigate the tautomerization of phenol catalyzed by acid-base active pair sites in Lewis acidic Beta zeolites by means of density functional calculations using the M06-L functional. An analysis of the catalytic mechanism shows that hafnium on the Beta zeolite causes the strongest absorption of phenol compared to zirconium, tin, and germanium. This can be rationalized by the highest delocalization of electron density between the Lewis site and the oxygen of phenol which can in turn be quantified by the perturbative E⁽²⁾ stabilization energy. The reaction is assumed to proceed in two steps, the phenol O-H bond dissociation and the protonation of the intermediate to form the cyclohexa-2,4-dien-1-one product. The rate determining step is the first one with a free activation energy of 26.3, 25.0, 22.1 and 22.7 kcal mol^-1 for Ge-Beta, Sn-Beta, Zr-Beta, and Hf-Beta zeolites, respectively. The turnover frequencies follow these reaction barriers. Hence, the intrinsic catalytic activity of the Lewis acidic Beta zeolites studied here is in the order of Hf-Beta≈Zr-Beta>Sn-Beta> Ge-Beta for the tautomerization of phenol.

Reassessment of the Mechanisms of Thermal C-H Bond Activation of Methane by Cationic Magnesium Oxides: A Critical Evaluation of the Suitability of Different Density Functionals

The mechanisms of the thermal reactions of the two iconic magnesium oxide cations MgO^.+ and Mg₂ O₂ ^.+ with methane have been re-evaluated at the CCSD(T)/CBS//CCSD/def2-TZVP level of theory. For the reaction of MgO^.+ with CH₄ , only the classical hydrogen-atom transfer (HAT) was found; in contrast, for the Mg₂ O₂ ^.+ /CH₄ couple, both HAT and proton-coupled electron-transfer (PCET) exist as mechanistic variants. In order to evaluate the suitability of density functional theory (DFT) methods, the reactions were computed by using 27 density functionals. The results obtained demonstrate that the various DFT methods often deliver rather different results for both geometric and energetic features. As to the prediction of the apparent barriers, pure functionals give the largest mean absolute errors. BMK, ωB97XD, and the double-hybrid functional mPW2PLYP were confirmed to come closest to the results provided by CCSD(T)/CBS. Thus, mechanistic conclusions based on a single DFT method should be viewed with great caution. In summary, this study may assist in the selection of a suitable quantum chemical method to unravel the mechanistic details of C-H bond activation by charged metal oxides.

Ta2 +-mediated ammonia synthesis from N2 and H2 at ambient temperature

In a full catalytic cycle, bare Ta₂ ⁺ in the highly diluted gas phase is able to mediate the formation of ammonia in a Haber-Bosch-like process starting from N₂ and H₂ at ambient temperature. This finding is the result of extensive quantum chemical calculations supported by experiments using Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance MS. The planar Ta₂N₂ ⁺, consisting of a four-membered ring of alternating Ta and N atoms, proved to be a key intermediate. It is formed in a highly exothermic process either by the reaction of Ta₂ ⁺ with N₂ from the educt side or with two molecules of NH₃ from the product side. In the thermal reaction of Ta₂ ⁺ with N₂, the N≡N triple bond of dinitrogen is entirely broken. A detailed analysis of the frontier orbitals involved in the rate-determining step shows that this unexpected reaction is accomplished by the interplay of vacant and doubly occupied d-orbitals, which serve as both electron acceptors and electron donors during the cleavage of the triple bond of N≡N by the ditantalum center. The ability of Ta₂ ⁺ to serve as a multipurpose tool is further shown by splitting the single bond of H₂ in a less exothermic reaction as well. The insight into the microscopic mechanisms obtained may provide guidance for the rational design of polymetallic catalysts to bring about ammonia formation by the activation of molecular nitrogen and hydrogen at ambient conditions.

Comparative Study of Methanol Activation by Different Small Mixed Silicon Clusters Si2M with M = H, Li, Na, Cu, and Ag

High-accuracy quantum chemical calculations were carried out to study the mechanisms and catalytic abilities of various mixed silicon species Si2M with M = H, Li, Na, Cu, and Ag toward the first step of methanol activation reaction. Standard heats of formation of these small triatomic Si clusters were determined. Potential-energy profiles were constructed using the coupled-cluster theory with extrapolation to complete basis set CCSD(T)/CBS, and CCSD(T)/aug-cc-pVTZ-PP for Si2Cu and Si2Ag. The most stable complexes generated by the interaction of methanol with the mixed clusters Si2M possess low-spin states and mainly stem from an M-O connection in preference to Si-O interaction, except for the Si2H case. In two competitive pathways including O-H and C-H bond breakings, the cleavage of the O-H bond in the presence of all clusters studied becomes predominant. Of the mixed clusters Si2M considered, the dissociation pathways of both O-H and C-H bonds with Si2Li turns out to have the lowest energy barriers. The most remarkable finding is the absence of the overall energy barrier for the O-H cleavage with the assistance of Si2Li. The breaking of O-H and C-H bonds with the assistance of Si2H, Si2Li, and Si2Na is kinetically preferred with respect to the Si2Cu and Si2Ag cases, apart from the case of Si2Na for O-H cleavage. In comparison with other transition-metal clusters with the same size, such as Cu3, Pt3, and PtAu2, the energy barriers for the O-H bond activation in the presence of small Si species, especially Si2H and Si2Li, are found to be lower. Consequently, these small mixed silicon clusters can be regarded as promising alternatives for the expensive metal-based catalysts currently used for methanol activation particularly and other dehydrogenation processes of organic compounds. The present study also suggests a further extensive search for other doped silicon clusters as efficient and more realistic gas-phase catalysts for important dehydrogenation processes in such a way that they can be experimentally prepared and implemented.

On the Mechanisms of Hydrogen-Atom Transfer from Water to the Heteronuclear Oxide Cluster [Ga2 Mg2 O5 ](.+) : Remarkable Electronic Structure Effects

Mechanistic insight into the homolytic cleavage of the O-H bond of water by the heteronuclear oxide cluster [Ga2 Mg2 O5 ](.+) has been derived from state-of-the-art gas-phase experiments in conjunction with quantum chemical calculations. Three pathways have been identified computationally. In addition to the conventional hydrogen-atom transfer (HAT) to the radical center of a bridging oxygen atom, two mechanistically distinct proton-coupled electron-transfer (PCET) processes have been identified. The energetically most favored path involves initial coordination of the incoming water ligand to a magnesium atom followed by an intramolecular proton transfer to the lone-pair of the bridging oxygen atom. This step, which is accomplished by an electronic reorganization, generates two structurally equivalent OH groups either of which can be liberated, in agreement with labeling experiments.