Dependence of Reaction Rates for Bidirectional PCET on the Electron Donor–Electron Acceptor Distance in Phenol–Ru(2,2′-Bipyridine)32+ Dyads

Proton Domino Reactions at an Imidazole Relay Control the Oxidation of a TyrZ-His190 Artificial Mimic of Photosystem II

A close mimic of P680 and the TyrosineZ-Histidine190 pair in photosystem II (PS II) has been synthesized using a ruthenium chromophore and imidazole-phenol ligands. The intramolecular oxidation of the ligands by the photoproduced Ru(III) species is characterized by a small driving force, very similar to PS II where the complexity of kinetics was attributed to the reversibility of electron transfer steps. Laser flash photolysis revealed biphasic kinetics for ligand oxidation. The fast phase (τ<50 ns) corresponds to partial oxidation of the imidazole-phenol ligand, proton transfer within the hydrogen bond, and formation of a neutral phenoxyl radical. The slow phase (5-9 μs) corresponds to full oxidation of the ligand which is kinetically controlled by deprotonation of the distant 1-nitrogen of the imidazolium. These results show that imidazole with its two protonatable sites plays a special role as a proton relay in a 'proton domino' reaction.

Proton-controlled Action of an Imidazole as Electron Relay in a Photoredox Triad

Electron relays play a crucial role for efficient light-induced activation by a photo-redox moiety of catalysts for multi-electronic transformations. Their insertion between the two units reduces detrimental energy transfer quenching while establishing at the same time unidirectional electron flow. This rectifying function allows charge accumulation necessary for catalysis. Mapping these events in photophysical studies is an important step towards the development of efficient molecular photocatalysts. Three modular complexes comprised of a Ru-chromophore, an imidazole electron relay function, and a terpyridine unit as coordination site for a metal ion were synthesized and the light-induced electron transfer events studied by laser flash photolysis. In all cases, formation of an imidazole radical by internal electron transfer to the oxidized chromophore was observed. The effect of added base evidenced that the reaction sequence depends strongly on the possibility for deprotonation of the imidazole function in a proton-coupled electron transfer process. In the complex with Mn^II present as a proxy for a catalytic site, a strongly accelerated decay of the imidazole radical together with a decreased rate of back electron transfer from the external electron acceptor to the oxidized complex was observed. This transient formation of an imidazolyl radical is clear evidence for the function of the imidazole group as an electron relay. The implication of the imidazole proton and the external base for the kinetics and energetics of the electron trafficking is discussed.

Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer for Photoinduced Generation of Two-Electron Reduced Species of Quinone

Purpose-built molecules that follow the fundamental process of photosynthesis have significance in developing better insight into the natural photosynthesis process. Quinones have a significant role as electron acceptors in natural photosynthesis, and their reduction is assisted through H-bond donation or protonation. The major challenge in such studies is to couple the multielectron and proton-transfer process and to achieve a reasonably stable charge-separated state for the elucidation of the mechanistic pathway. We have tried to address this issue through the design of a donor-acceptor-donor molecular triad (2RuAQ) derived from two equivalent [Ru(bpy)₃]²⁺ derivatives and a bridging anthraquinone moiety (AQ). Photoinduced proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) for this molecular triad was systematically investigated in the absence and presence of hexafluoroisopropanol and p-toluenesulfonic acid (PTSA) using time-resolved absorption spectroscopy in the ultrafast time domain. Results reveal the generation of a relatively long-lived charge-separated state in this multi-electron transfer reaction, and we could confirm the generation of AQ^2- and Ru^III as the transient intermediates. We could rationalize the mechanistic pathway and the dynamics associated with photoinduced processes and the role of H-bonding in stabilizing charge-separated states. Transient absorption spectroscopic studies reveal that the rates of intramolecular electron transfer and the mechanistic pathways associated with the PCET process are significantly different in different solvent compositions having different polarities. In acetonitrile, a concerted PCET mechanism prevails, whereas the stepwise PCET reaction process is observed in the presence of PTSA. The results of the present study represent a unique model for the mechanistic diversity of PCET reactions.

Theoretical Study of Shallow Distance Dependence of Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer in Oligoproline Peptides

Long-range electron transfer is coupled to proton transfer in a wide range of chemically and biologically important processes. Recently the proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) rate constants for a series of biomimetic oligoproline peptides linking Ru(bpy)₃²⁺ to tyrosine were shown to exhibit a substantially shallower dependence on the number of proline spacers compared to the analogous electron transfer (ET) systems. The experiments implicated a concerted PCET mechanism involving intramolecular electron transfer from tyrosine to Ru(bpy)₃³⁺ and proton transfer from tyrosine to a hydrogen phosphate dianion. Herein these PCET systems, as well as the analogous ET systems, are studied with microsecond molecular dynamics, and the ET and PCET rate constants are calculated with the corresponding nonadiabatic theories. The molecular dynamics simulations illustrate that smaller ET donor-acceptor distances are sampled by the PCET systems than by the analogous ET systems. The shallower dependence of the PCET rate constant on the ET donor-acceptor distance is explained in terms of an additional positive, distance-dependent electrostatic term in the PCET driving force, which attenuates the rate constant at smaller distances. This electrostatic term depends on the change in the electrostatic interaction between the charges on each end of the bridge and can be modified by altering these charges. On the basis of these insights, this theory predicted a less shallow distance dependence of the PCET rate constant when imidazole rather than hydrogen phosphate serves as the proton acceptor, even though their pK_a values are similar. This theoretical prediction was subsequently validated experimentally, illustrating that long-range electron transfer processes can be tuned by modifying the nature of the proton acceptor in concerted PCET processes. This level of control has broad implications for the design of more effective charge-transfer systems.

Shallow Distance Dependence for Proton-Coupled Tyrosine Oxidation in Oligoproline Peptides

We have explored the kinetic effect of increasing electron transfer (ET) distance in a biomimetic, proton-coupled electron-transfer (PCET) system. Biological ET often occurs simultaneously with proton transfer (PT) in order to avoid the high-energy, charged intermediates resulting from the stepwise transfer of protons and electrons. These concerted proton-electron-transfer (CPET) reactions are implicated in numerous biological ET pathways. In many cases, PT is coupled to long-range ET. While many studies have shown that the rate of ET is sensitive to the distance between the electron donor and acceptor, extensions to biological CPET reactions are sparse. The possibility of a unique ET distance dependence for CPET reactions deserves further exploration, as this could have implications for how we understand biological ET. We therefore explored the ET distance dependence for the CPET oxidation of tyrosine in a model system. We prepared a series of metallopeptides with a tyrosine separated from a Ru(bpy)32+ complex by an oligoproline bridge of increasing length. Rate constants for intramolecular tyrosine oxidation were measured using the flash-quench transient absorption technique in aqueous solutions. The rate constants for tyrosine oxidation decreased by 125-fold with three added proline residues between tyrosine and the oxidant. By comparison, related intramolecular ET rate constants in very similar constructs were reported to decrease by 4-5 orders of magnitude over the same number of prolines. The observed shallow distance dependence for tyrosine oxidation is proposed to originate in part from the requirement for stronger oxidants, leading to a smaller hole-transfer effective tunneling barrier height. The shallow distance dependence observed here and extensions to distance-dependent CPET reactions have potential implications for long-range charge transfers.

Excited State Interaction of Ruthenium (II) Imidazole Phenanthroline Complex [Ru(bpy)2 ipH]2+ with 1,4-Benzoquinone: Simple Electron Transfer or Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer?

The unidirectional proton coupled electron transfer (PCET) from the excited state of Ru(II) imidazole phenanthroline complex [Ru(bpy)₂ ipH]²⁺ to 1,4-benzoquinone, was studied by steady-state (SS) and time-resolved (TR) fluorescence and transient absorption (TA) measurements. The pK_a (9.7) and pK_a * (8.6) values of the complex suggest that it behaves as a photoacid on excitation. The difference in the quenching rates obtained from SS and TR fluorescence studies indicate participation of both dynamic quenching and static quenching involving the hydrogen bonded ipH ligand of [Ru(bpy)₂ ipH]²⁺ with the 1,4-benzoquinone quencher, formed in the ground state. Within the hydrogen bonded complex, the ruthenium centre acts as the electron donor, while the ipH ligand acts as the proton donor to the hydrogen bonded 1,4-benzoquinone that acts simultaneously both as the electron and proton acceptor. It is proposed that the static quenching in the hydrogen bonded [Ru(bpy)₂ ipH]²⁺ -1,4-benzoquinone pairs occurs involving the PCET mechanism, while the dynamic quenching occurs through the simple ET mechanism, on diffusional encounter of the isolated 1,4-benzoquinone with the excited [Ru(bpy)₂ ipH]²⁺ complex. The occurrence of broad TA bands around 420-430 nm suggests formation of both 1,4-benzoquinone radical anion as well as the 1,4-benzosemiquinone radical by the interaction of excited [Ru(bpy)₂ ipH]²⁺ with 1,4-benzoquinone, thus supporting the ET process in the studied system.

Activationless Multiple-Site Concerted Proton-Electron Tunneling

The transfer of protons and electrons is key to energy conversion and storage, from photosynthesis to fuel cells. Increased understanding and control of these processes are needed. A new anthracene-phenol-pyridine molecular triad was designed to undergo fast photoinduced multiple-site concerted proton-electron transfer (MS-CPET), with the phenol moiety transferring an electron to the photoexcited anthracene and a proton to the pyridine. Fluorescence quenching and transient absorption experiments in solutions and glasses show rapid MS-CPET (3.2 × 1010 s-1 at 298 K). From 5.5 to 90 K, the reaction rate and kinetic isotope effect (KIE) are independent of temperature, with zero Arrhenius activation energy. From 145 to 350 K, there are only slight changes with temperature. This MS-CPET reaction thus occurs by tunneling of both the proton and electron, in different directions. Since the reaction proceeds without significant thermal activation energy, the rate constant indicates the magnitude of the electron/proton double tunneling probability.

Long-lived charge separation in dye–semiconductor assemblies: a pathway to multi-electron transfer reactions

Key approaches to achieve long-lived charge separation and promote conduction band mediated electron transfer in dye-sensitized semiconductor assemblies.

Fluorescence quenching of the N-methylquinolinium cation by pairs of water or alcohol molecules

The proposed mechanism involves an electron transfer from H₂O/ROH to the excited quinolinium, concerted with proton transfer to the second hydroxy molecule.

Influence of Proton Acceptors on the Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer Reaction Kinetics of a Ruthenium-Tyrosine Complex

A polypyridyl ruthenium complex with fluorinated bipyridine ligands and a covalently bound tyrosine moiety was synthesized, and its photo-induced proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) reactivity in acetonitrile was investigated with transient absorption spectroscopy. Using flash-quench methodology with methyl viologen as an oxidative quencher, a Ru³⁺ species is generated that is capable of initiating the intramolecular PCET oxidation of the tyrosine moiety. Using a series of substituted pyridine bases, the reaction kinetics were found to vary as a function of proton acceptor concentration and identity, with no significant H/D kinetic isotope effect. Through analysis of the kinetics traces and comparison to a control complex without the tyrosine moiety, PCET reactivity was found to proceed through an equilibrium electron transfer followed by proton transfer (ET-PT) pathway in which irreversible deprotonation of the tyrosine radical cation shifts the ET equilibrium, conferring a base dependence on the reaction. Comprehensive kinetics modeling allowed for deconvolution of complex kinetics and determination of rate constants for each elementary step. Across the five pyridine bases explored, spanning a range of 4.2 pK_a units, a linear free-energy relationship was found for the proton transfer rate constant with a slope of 0.32. These findings highlight the influence that proton transfer driving force exerts on PCET reaction kinetics.

Unusual distance dependences of electron transfer rates

There are regimes in which electron transfer rates increase with increasing donor–acceptor distance, leading to rate maxima at large donor–acceptor separations.

Conformational Change with Steric Interactions Affects the Inner Sphere Component of Concerted Proton-Electron Transfer in a Pyridyl-Appended Radical Cation System

Proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) model systems combine one-electron oxidants and bases to generate net hydrogen atom acceptors. We have generated two persistent pyridyl-appended radical cations: 10-(pyrid-2-yl)-10H-phenothiazinium (PPT•+) and 3-(pyrid-2-yl)-10-methyl-10H-phenothiazinium (MPTP•+). EPR spectra and corresponding calculations indicate phenothiazinium radical cations with minimal spin on the pyridine nitrogen. Addition of hindered phenols causes the radical cations to decay, and protonated products and the corresponding phenoxyl radicals to form. The ΔG° values for the formation of intermediates (determined through cyclic voltammetry and pKa measurements) rule out a stepwise mechanism, and kinetic isotope effects support concerted proton–electron transfer (CPET) as the mechanism. Calculations indicate that the reaction of PPT•+ + tBu3PhOH undergoes a significant conformational change with steric interactions on the diabatic surface while maintaining the hydrogen bond; in contrast, MPTP•+ + tBu3PhOH maintains its conformation throughout the reaction. This difference is reflected in both experiment and calculations with ΔG(⧧)MPTP•+ < ΔG(⧧)PPT•+ despite ΔG°MPTP•+ > ΔG°PPT•+. Experimental results with 2,6-di-tert-butyl-4-methoxyphenol are similar. Hence, despite the structural similarity between the compounds, differences in the inner sphere component for CPET affect the kinetics.

Moving protons and electrons in biomimetic systems

An enormous variety of biological redox reactions are accompanied by changes in proton content at enzyme active sites, in their associated cofactors, in substrates and/or products, and between protein interfaces. Understanding this breadth of reactivity is an ongoing chemical challenge. A great many workers have developed and investigated biomimetic model complexes to build new ways of thinking about the mechanistic underpinnings of such complex biological proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) reactions. Of particular importance are those model reactions that involve transfer of one proton (H(+)) and one electron (e(-)), which is equivalent to transfer of a hydrogen atom (H(•)). In this Current Topic, we review key concepts in PCET reactivity and describe important advances in biomimetic PCET chemistry, with a special emphasis on research that has enhanced efforts to understand biological PCET reactions.

Photoinduced PCET in ruthenium-phenol systems: thermodynamic equivalence of uni- and bidirectional reactions

Six termolecular reaction systems comprised of Ru(4,4′-bis(trifluoromethyl)-2,2′-bipyridine)32+, phenols with different para substituents, and pyridine in acetonitrile undergo proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) upon photoexcitation of the metal complex. Five of these six phenols are found to release in concerted fashion an electron to the ruthenium photooxidant and a proton to the pyridine base. The kinetics for this concerted bidirectional PCET process and its relationship to the reaction free energy were compared to the driving-force dependence of reaction kinetics for unidirectional concerted proton–electron transfer (CPET) between the same phenols and Ru(2,2′-bipyrazine)32+, a combined electron/proton acceptor. The results strongly support the concept of thermodynamic equivalence between separated electron/proton acceptors and single-reagent hydrogen-atom acceptors. A key feature of the explored systems is the similarity between molecules employed for bi- and unidirectional CPET.