Master and Slave Relationship Between Two Types of Self-Propagating Insulin Amyloid Fibrils

"Nature or nurture" - How environmental factors influence the conformational memory of amyloid fibrils

Amyloid fibrils are complex protein structures with multilayered chiral architecture, that are known to self-propagate. The replication of the mother seed structure by daughter fibrils is known as conformational or templated memory. Using vibrational circular dichroism (VCD), electronic circular dichroism (ECD), transmission electron microscopy (TEM), and cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) we have shown that environmental factors (here agitation) can be a competing force against the templated growth of human lysozyme fibrils. In the cross-seeding experiment non-agitated daughters preserved the structure of agitated mothers, whereas agitated daughters did not always exhibit the same characteristics as their non-agitated mothers. This pattern was reflected on various levels of fibril architecture (secondary structure, protofilament handedness, morphology), demonstrating that the structural indeterminism originates from deeper levels of the fibril structure. This observation may contribute to a better understanding of the processes behind fibril formation.

Single-molecule Observation of Self-Propagating Amyloid Fibrils

The assembly of misfolded proteins into amyloid fibrils is associated with amyloidosis, including neurodegenerative diseases, such as Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, and prion diseases. The self-propagation of amyloid fibrils is widely observed in the aggregation pathways of numerous amyloidogenic proteins. This propensity with plasticity in primary nucleation allows amyloid fibril polymorphism, which is correlated with the pathology/phenotypes of patients. Because the interference with the nucleation and replication processes of amyloid fibrils can alter the amyloid structure and the outcome of the disease, these processes can be a target for developing clinical drugs. Single-molecule observation of amyloid fibril replication can be an experimental system to provide the kinetic parameters for simulation studies and confirm the effect of clinical drugs. Here, we review single-molecule observation of the amyloid fibril replication process using fluorescence microscopy and time-lapse atomic force microscopy, including high-speed atomic force microscopy. We discussed the amyloid fibril replication process and combined single-molecule observation results with molecular dynamics simulations.

Mini Abstract Structural dynamics in amyloid aggregation is related with various Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s disease symptoms. Single-molecule observation using high-speed atomic force microscopy can directly visualize the structural dynamics of individual amyloid aggregate assemblies. Here, we review historical and recent studies of single-molecule observation of amyloid aggregation with supportive molecular dynamics simulation.

A tale of two tails: Self-assembling properties of A- and B-chain parts of insulin's highly amyloidogenic H-fragment

Due to the spontaneous transition of native insulin into therapeutically inactive amyloid, prolonged storage decreases effectiveness of the hormone in treatment of diabetes. Various regions of the amino acid sequence have been implicated in insulin aggregation. Here, we focus on smaller fragments of the highly amyloidogenic H-peptide comprising disulfide-bonded N-terminal sections of insulin's A-chain (13 residues) and B-chain (11 residues). Aggregation patterns of N-terminal fragments of A-chain (ACC_1-13, ACC_1-11, ACC_6-13, ACC_6-11, all retaining Cys6A-Cys11A disulfide bond) and B-chain (B_1-11(7A)) are examined at acidic and neutral pH. ACC_1-11 is the smallest fragment found to be amyloidogenic at either pH; removal of the N-terminal GIVEQ section renders this fragment entirely non-amyloidogenic. The self-assembling properties of ACC_1-11 contrast with aggregation-resistant behavior of B_1-11(7A) and its disulfide-linked homodimer, (B_1-11)₂ aggregating only at neutral pH. Fibrillar ACC_1-11 is similar to insulin amyloid in terms of morphology and infrared features. Secondary nucleation is likely to account for the detected shortening of insulin aggregation lag phase at neutral pH upon cross-seeding with pre-formed fibrils of ACC_1-11 or (B_1-11)₂. An aggregation-enhancing effect of monomeric ACC_1-11 on co-dissolved native insulin is also observed. Our findings are discussed in the context of mechanisms of insulin aggregation.

Secondary Nucleation and the Conservation of Structural Characteristics of Amyloid Fibril Strains

Amyloid fibrils are ordered protein aggregates and a hallmark of many severe neurodegenerative diseases. Amyloid fibrils form through primary nucleation from monomeric protein, grow through monomer addition and proliferate through fragmentation or through the nucleation of new fibrils on the surface of existing fibrils (secondary nucleation). It is currently still unclear how amyloid fibrils initially form in the brain of affected individuals and how they are amplified. A given amyloid protein can sometimes form fibrils of different structure under different solution conditions in vitro, but often fibrils found in patients are highly homogeneous. These findings suggest that the processes that amplify amyloid fibrils in vivo can in some cases preserve the structural characteristics of the initial seed fibrils. It has been known for many years that fibril growth by monomer addition maintains the structure of the seed fibril, as the latter acts as a template that imposes its fold on the newly added monomer. However, for fibrils that are formed through secondary nucleation it was, until recently, not clear whether the structure of the seed fibril is preserved. Here we review the experimental evidence on this question that has emerged over the last years. The overall picture is that the fibril strain that forms through secondary nucleation is mostly defined by the solution conditions and intrinsic structural preferences, and not by the seed fibril strain.

Extremely Amyloidogenic Single-Chain Analogues of Insulin's H-Fragment: Structural Adaptability of an Amyloid Stretch

Relatively short amino acid sequences often play a pivotal role in triggering protein aggregation leading to the formation of amyloid fibrils. In the case of insulin, various regions of A- and B-chains have been implicated as the most relevant to the protein's amyloidogenicity. Here, we focus on the highly amyloidogenic H-fragment of insulin comprising the disulfide-bonded N-terminal parts of both chains. Analysis of the aggregation behavior of single-chain peptide derivatives of the H-fragment suggests that the A-chain's part initiates the aggregation process while the disulfide-tethered B-chain reluctantly adapts to amyloid structure. Merging of both A- and B-parts into single-chain continuous peptides (A-B and B-A) results in extreme amyloidogenicity exceeding that of the double-chain H-fragment as reflected by almost instantaneous de novo fibrillization. Amyloid fibrils of A-B and B-A present distinct morphological and infrared traits and do not cross-seed insulin. Our study suggests that the N-terminal part of insulin's A-chain containing the intact Cys6-Cys11 intrachain disulfide bond may constitute insulin's major amyloid stretch which, through its bent conformation, enforces a parallel in-register alignment of β-strands. Comparison of the self-association behavior of H, A-B, and B-A peptides suggests that A-chain's N-terminal amyloid stretch is very versatile and adaptive to various structural contexts.

Characterization of insulin cross-seeding: the underlying mechanism reveals seeding and denaturant-induced insulin fibrillation proceeds through structurally similar intermediates

Insulin rapidly fibrillates in the presence of amyloid seeds from different sources. To address its cross-reactivity we chose the seeds of seven model proteins and peptides along with the seeds of insulin itself. Model candidates were selected/designed according to their size, amino acid sequence, and hydrophobicity. We found while some seeds provided catalytic ends for inducing the formation of non-native insulin conformers and increase fibrillation, others attenuated insulin fibrillation kinetics. We also observed competition between the intermediate insulin conformers which formed with urea and amyloid seeds in entering the fibrillogenic pathway. Simultaneous incubation of insulin with urea and amyloid seeds resulted in the formation of nearly similar insulin intermediate conformers which synergistically enhance insulin fibrillation kinetics. Given these results, it is highly likely that, structurally, there is a specific intermediate in different pathways of insulin fibrillation that governs fibrillation kinetics and morphology of the final mature fibril. Overall, this study provides a novel mechanistic insight into insulin fibrillation and gives new information on how seeds of different proteins are capable of altering insulin fibrillation kinetics and morphology. This report, for the first time, tries to answer an important question that why fibrillation of insulin is either accelerated or attenuated in the presence of amyloid fibril seeds from different sources.

Native insulins in the presence of low urea concentrations or seeds with low hydrophobicity form ordered aggregates (amyloid fibrils), while high urea concentrations or the seeds with high level of hydrophobicity can induce the amorphous aggregation.

The Environment Is a Key Factor in Determining the Anti-Amyloid Efficacy of EGCG

Millions of people around the world suffer from amyloid-related disorders, including Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases. Despite significant and sustained efforts, there are still no disease-modifying drugs available for the majority of amyloid-related disorders, and the overall failure rate in clinical trials is very high, even for compounds that show promising anti-amyloid activity in vitro. In this study, we demonstrate that even small changes in the chemical environment can strongly modulate the inhibitory effects of anti-amyloid compounds. Using one of the best-established amyloid inhibitory compounds, epigallocatechin-3-gallate (EGCG), as an example, and two amyloid-forming proteins, insulin and Parkinson's disease-related α -synuclein, we shed light on the previously unexplored sensitivity to solution conditions of the action of this compound on amyloid fibril formation. In the case of insulin, we show that the classification of EGCG as an amyloid inhibitor depends on the experimental conditions select, on the method used for the evaluation of the efficacy, and on whether or not EGCG is allowed to oxidise before the experiment. For α -synuclein, we show that a small change in pH value, from 7 to 6, transforms EGCG from an efficient inhibitor to completely ineffective, and we were able to explain this behaviour by the increased stability of EGCG against oxidation at pH 6.

Self-inhibition of insulin amyloid-like aggregation

NaCl induces formation of insulin tetramers leading to inhibition of amyloid formation.

De novo design of a biologically active amyloid

Most human proteins possess amyloidogenic segments, but only about 30 are associated with amyloid-associated pathologies, and it remains unclear what determines amyloid toxicity. We designed vascin, a synthetic amyloid peptide, based on an amyloidogenic fragment of vascular endothelial growth factor receptor 2 (VEGFR2), a protein that is not associated to amyloidosis. Vascin recapitulates key biophysical and biochemical characteristics of natural amyloids, penetrates cells, and seeds the aggregation of VEGFR2 through direct interaction. We found that amyloid toxicity is observed only in cells that both express VEGFR2 and are dependent on VEGFR2 activity for survival. Thus, amyloid toxicity here appears to be both protein-specific and conditional-determined by VEGFR2 loss of function in a biological context in which target protein function is essential.

The emergence of superstructural order in insulin amyloid fibrils upon multiple rounds of self-seeding

Typically, elongation of an amyloid fibril entails passing conformational details of the mother seed to daughter generations of fibrils with high fidelity. There are, however, several factors that can potentially prevent such transgenerational structural imprinting from perpetuating, for example heterogeneity of mother seeds or so-called conformational switching. Here, we examine phenotypic persistence of bovine insulin amyloid ([BI]) upon multiple rounds of self-seeding under quiescent conditions. According to infrared spectroscopy, with the following passages of homologous seeding, daughter fibrils gradually depart from the mother seed’s spectral characteristics. We note that this transgenerational structural drift in [BI] amyloid leads toward fibrils with infrared, chiroptical, and morphological traits similar to those of the superstructural variant of fibrils which normally forms upon strong agitation of insulin solutions. However, in contrast to agitation-induced insulin amyloid, the superstructural assemblies of daughter fibrils isolated through self-seeding are sonication-resistant. Our results suggest that formation of single amyloid fibrils is not a dead-end of the amyloidogenic self-assembly. Instead, the process appears to continue toward the self-assembly of higher-order structures although on longer time-scales. From this perspective, the fast agitation-induced aggregation of insulin appears to be a shortcut to amyloid superstructures whose formation under quiescent conditions is slow.

pH-Driven Polymorphism of Insulin Amyloid-Like Fibrils

Prions are infective proteins, which can self-assemble into different strain conformations, leading to different disease phenotypes. An increasing number of studies suggest that prion-like self-propagation may be a common feature of amyloid-like structures. Thus it is important to unravel every possible factor leading to the formation of different amyloid strains. Here we report on the formation of two types of insulin amyloid-like fibrils with distinct infrared spectroscopic features grown under slightly different pH conditions. Similar to prion strains, both insulin fibril types are able to self-propagate their conformational template under conditions, favoring spontaneous formation of different type fibrils. The low-pH-induced insulin amyloid strain is structurally very similar to previously reported strains formed either in the presence of 20% ethanol, or by modification of the amino acid sequence of insulin. A deeper analysis of literature data in the context of our current findings suggests a shift of the monomer-dimer equilibrium of insulin as a possible factor controlling the formation of different strains.

Polymorphism of amyloid-like fibrils can be defined by the concentration of seeds

Prions are infectious proteins where the same protein may express distinct strains. The strains are enciphered by different misfolded conformations. Strain-like phenomena have also been reported in a number of other amyloid-forming proteins. One of the features of amyloid strains is the ability to self-propagate, maintaining a constant set of physical properties despite being propagated under conditions different from those that allowed initial formation of the strain. Here we report a cross-seeding experiment using strains formed under different conditions. Using high concentrations of seeds results in rapid elongation and new fibrils preserve the properties of the seeding fibrils. At low seed concentrations, secondary nucleation plays the major role and new fibrils gain properties predicted by the environment rather than the structure of the seeds. Our findings could explain conformational switching between amyloid strains observed in a wide variety of in vivo and in vitro experiments.