Surface Charge Dependence of Polyelectrolyte-Induced Domain Size and Composition in Lipid Bilayer Membranes

Polymer-vesicle association

Mixed polymer-surfactant systems have been intensively investigated in the last two decades, with the main focus on surfactant micelles as the surfactant aggregate in interaction. The main types of phase behavior, driving forces and structural/rheological effects at stake are now fairly well understood. Polymer-vesicle systems, on the other hand, have received comparatively less attention from a physico-chemical perspective. In this review, our main goal has been to bridge this gap, taking a broad approach to cover a field that is in clear expansion, in view of its multiple implications for colloid and biological sciences and in applied areas. We start by a general background on amphiphile self-assembly and phase separation phenomena in mixed polymer-surfactant solutions. We then address vesicle formation, properties and stability not only in classic lipids, but also in various other surfactant systems, among which catanionic vesicles are highlighted. Traditionally, lipid and surfactant vesicles have been studied separately, with little cross-information and comparison, giving duplication of physico-chemical interpretations. This situation has changed in more recent times. We then proceed to cover more in-depth the work done on different aspects of the associative behavior between vesicles (of different composition and type of stability) and different types of polymers, including polysaccharides, proteins and DNA. Thus, phase behavior features, effects of vesicle structure and stability, and the forces/mechanisms of vesicle-macromolecule interaction are addressed. Such association may generate gels with interesting rheological properties and high potential for applications. Finally, special focus is also given to DNA, a high charge polymer, and its interactions with surfactants, and vesicles, in particular, in the context of gene transfection studies.

Mechanisms behind the Faceting of Catanionic Vesicles by Polycations: Chain Crystallization and Segregation

Vesicles composed of an anionic and a cationic surfactant, with a net negative charge, associate strongly with a hydrophobically modified polycation (LM200) and with an unmodified polycation with higher charge density (JR400), forming viscoelastic gel-like structures. Calorimetric results show that in these gels, LM200 induces a rise of the chain melting temperature (Tm) of the vesicles, whereas JR400 has the opposite effect. For both polymer-vesicle systems, the shear viscosity exhibits an inflection point at Tm, and for the LM200 system the measured relaxation times are significantly higher below Tm. The neat vesicles and the polycation-bound vesicles have a polygonal-like faceted shape when the surfactant chains in the bilayer are crystallized, as probed by cryo-transmission electron microscopy. Above Tm, the neat and the LM200-bound vesicles regain a spheroidal shape, whereas those in the JR400 system remain with a deformed faceted shape even above Tm. These shape changes are interpreted in terms of different mechanisms for the polymer-vesicle interaction, which seem to be highly dependent on polymer architecture, namely charge density and hydrophobic modification. A crystallization-segregation mechanism is proposed for the LM200-vesicle system, while, for the JR400-vesicle one, charge polarization-lateral segregation effects induced by the polycation in the catanionic bilayer are envisaged.

Network formation of catanionic vesicles and oppositely charged polyelectrolytes. Effect of polymer charge density and hydrophobic modification

In nonequimolar solutions of a cationic and an anionic surfactant, vesicles bearing a net charge can be spontaneously formed and apparently exist as thermodynamically stable aggregates. These vesicles can associate strongly with polymers in solution by means of hydrophobic and/or electrostatic interactions. In the current work, we have investigated the rheological and microstructural properties of mixtures of cationic polyelectrolytes and net anionic sodium dodecyl sulfate/didodecyldimethylammonium bromide vesicles. The polyelectrolytes consist of two cationic cellulose derivatives with different charge densities; the lowest charge density polymer contains also hydrophobic grafts, with the number of charges equal to the number of grafts. For both systems, polymer-vesicle association leads to a major increase in viscosity and to gel-like behavior, but the viscosity effects are more pronounced for the less charged, hydrophobically modified polymer. Evaluation of the frequency dependence of the storage and loss moduli for the two systems shows further differences in behavior: while the more long-lived cross-links occur for the more highly charged hydrophilic polymer, the number of cross-links is higher for the hydrophobically modified polymer. Microstructure studies by cryogenic transmission electron microscopy indicate that the two polymers affect the vesicle stability in different ways. With the hydrophobically modified polymer, the aggregates remain largely in the form of globular vesicles and faceted vesicles (polygon-shaped vesicles with largely planar regions). For the hydrophilic polycation, on the other hand, the surfactant aggregate structure is more extensively modified: first, the vesicles change from a globular to a faceted shape; second, there is opening of the bilayers leading to holey vesicles and ultimately to considerable vesicle disruption leading to planar bilayer, disklike aggregates. The faceted shape is tentatively attributed to a crystallization of the surfactant film in the vesicles. It is inferred that a hydrophobically modified polyion with relatively low charge density can better stabilize vesicles due to formation of molecularly mixed aggregates, while a hydrophilic polyion with relatively high charge density associates so strongly to the surfactant films, due to strong electrostatic interactions, that the vesicles are more perturbed and even disrupted.

Polyelectrolyte molecular weight and electrostatically-induced domains in lipid bilayer membranes

Polyelectrolyte-induced domain formation in charged lipid bilayer membranes was investigated as a function of polyelectrolyte molecular weight using 2H nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. Lipid bilayers consisting of mixtures of alpha- or beta-choline-deuterated 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC-alpha-d2 or POPC-beta-d2) plus the cationic amphiphile 1,2-dioleoyl-3-(dimethylamino)propane (DODAP) were exposed to the anionic polyelectrolyte poly(sodium 4-styrenesulfonate) (PSSS) of various molecular weights. Regardless of molecular weight, PSSS produced dual component 2H NMR spectra, indicating two distinct POPC populations, corresponding to PSSS-bound and PSSS-free lipid, in slow exchange with one another. Analysis of the 2H NMR subspectra quadrupolar splittings and intensities showed the PSSS-bound domain to be enriched in DODAP, with the PSSS-free domain correspondingly depleted. At polyelectrolyte loadings below global charge equivalence, PSSS bound DODAP stoichiometrically for all PSSS molecular weights, indicating that the polyelectrolyte chain lies flat upon the membrane surface. At higher PSSS loadings the domains dissipated, leading to single component 2H NMR spectra. At high NaCl concentrations PSSS dissociated from the bilayer surface. Domain size on a per PSSS chain basis increased while the degree of enrichment with DODAP decreased progressively as the PSSS chain length decreased. Such molecular weight-dependent domain characteristics have not been predicted theoretically and need to be taken into account in future refinements of domain models.

Polylysine-induced 2H NMR-observable domains in phosphatidylserine/phosphatidylcholine lipid bilayers

The interaction of three polylysines, Lys(5) (N = 5), Lys(30) (N = 30), and Lys(100) (N = 100), where N is the number of lysine residues per chain, with phosphatidylserine-containing lipid bilayer membranes was investigated using 2H NMR spectroscopy. Lys(30) and Lys(100) added to multilamellar vesicles composed of (70:30) (mol:mol) mixtures of choline-deuterated 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) + 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoserine (POPS) produced two resolvable 2H NMR spectral components under conditions of low ionic strength and for cases where the global anionic lipid charge was in excess over the global cationic polypeptide charge. The intensities and quadrupolar splittings of the two spectral components were consistent with the existence of polylysine-bound domains enriched in POPS, in coexistence with polylysine-free domains depleted in POPS. Lys(5), however, yielded no 2H NMR resolvable domains. Increasing ionic strength caused domains to become diffuse and eventually dissipate entirely. At physiological salt concentrations, only Lys(100) yielded 2H NMR-resolvable domains. Therefore, under physiological conditions of ionic strength, pH, and anionic lipid bilayer content, and in the absence of other, e.g., hydrophobic, contributions to the binding free energy, the minimum number of lysine residues sufficient to produce spectroscopically resolvable POPS-enriched domains on the 2H NMR millisecond timescale may be fewer than 100, but is certainly greater than 30.

A transmembrane peptide from the human EGF receptor: behaviour of the cytoplasmic juxtamembrane domain in lipid bilayers

Solid state (2)H NMR spectroscopy was employed to study peptides related to the transmembrane domain of the human epidermal growth factor receptor, for insight into the interaction of its cytoplasmic juxtamembrane domain with the membrane surface. Since such receptors have clusters of (+)charged amino acids in this region, the effect of (-)charged phosphatidylserine at the concentration found naturally in the cytoplasmic leaflet (15 mol%) was considered. Each peptide contained 34 amino acids, which included the hydrophobic 23 amino acid stretch thought to span the membrane and a ten amino acid segment beyond the 'cytoplasmic' surface. Non-perturbing deuterium probe nuclei were located within alanine side chains in intramembranous and extramembranous portions. (2)H NMR spectra were recorded at 35 degrees C and 65 degrees C in fluid lipid bilayers consisting of (zwitterionic) 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoylphosphatidylcholine, with and without 15 mol% (anionic) phosphatidylserine. The cationic extramembranous portion of the receptor backbone was found to be highly rotationally mobile on a time scale of 10(-4)-10(-5) s in both types of membrane - as was the alpha-helical intramembranous portion. Deuterium nuclei in alanine side chains (-CD(3)) detected modest changes in peptide backbone orientation and/or dynamics related to the presence of 1-stearoyl-2-oleoylphosphatidylserine: in the case of the extramembranous portion of the peptide these seemed related to lipid charge. Temperature effects on the peptide backbone external to the membrane were qualitatively different from effects on the helical transmembrane domain - likely reflecting the different physical constraints on these peptide regions and the greater flexibility of the extramembranous domain. Effects related to lipid charge could be detected in the spectrum of CD(3) groups on the internally mobile side chain of Val(650), six residues beyond the membrane surface.

2H NMR and polyelectrolyte-induced domains in lipid bilayers

2H NMR studies of polyelectrolyte-induced domain formation in lipid bilayer membranes are reviewed. The 2H NMR spectrum of choline-deuterated phosphatidylcholine (PC) reports on any and all sources of lipid bilayer surface charge, since these produce a conformation change in the choline head group of PC, manifest as a change in the 2H NMR quadrupolar splitting. In addition, homogeneous and inhomogeneous surface charge distributions are differentiated. Adding polyelectrolytes to lipid bilayers consisting of mixtures of oppositely charged and zwitterionic lipids produces 2H NMR spectra which are superpositions of two Pake sub-spectra: one corresponding to a polyelectrolyte-bound lipid population and the other to a polyelectrolyte-free lipid population. Quantitative analysis of the quadrupolar splittings and spectral intensities of the two sub-spectra indicate that the polyelectrolyte-bound populations is enriched with oppositely charged lipid, while the polyelectrolyte-free lipid population is correspondingly depleted. The same domain-segregation effect is produced whether cationic polyelectrolytes are added to anionic lipid bilayers or anionic polyelectrolytes are added to cationic lipid bilayers. The 2H NMR spectra permit a complete characterization of domain composition and size. The anion:cation ratio within the domains is always stoichiometric, as expected for a process driven by Coulombic interactions. The zwitterionic lipid content of the domains is always statistical, reflecting the systems tendency to minimize the entropic cost of demixing charged lipids into domains. Domain formation is observed even with rather short polyelectrolytes, suggesting that individual polyelectrolyte chains aggregate at the surface to form "superdomains". Overall, the polyelectrolyte bound at the lipid bilayer surface appears to lie flat along the surface and to be essentially immobilized through its multiple electrostatic contacts.

Nucleotide chain length and the morphology of complexes with cationic amphiphiles: (31)P-NMR observations

31P-NMR and UV spectroscopies were used to study the interactions between cationic amphiphile-containing lipid bilayers and either a phosphorothioate oligonucleotide (OligoS) (n=21) or polyadenylic acid (PolyA) (n approximately 18,000). Multilamellar vesicles (MLVs) were composed of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) or 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (DOPE) in binary mixture with either of the cationic lipids, N-[1-(2, 3-dioleoyloxy)propyl]-N',N',N'-trimethylammonium chloride (DOTAP) or cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB). A UV-difference assay showed that OligoS binding ceased above a 1:1 anion/cation ratio, while PolyA binding continued until a 2:1 ratio was reached, indicating a 'flat' conformation for bound OligoS, but not necessarily for PolyA. Cross-polarization (31)P-NMR of the nucleotide chains bound to 100% DOTAP MLVs produced spectra virtually identical to those of dry powders of OligoS or PolyA, indicating effective immobilization of the surface-bound nucleotide chains. Hahn echo (31)P-NMR showed that MLVs composed of binary mixtures of POPC with DOTAP or CTAB retained a lamellar bilayer architecture upon adding nucleotide chains. At less than stoichiometric anion/cation ratios little or no signal attributable to free nucleotide chains was visible. A narrow signal at the chemical shift expected for phosphorothiodiesters or phosphodiesters became visible at greater levels of added OligoS or PolyA, respectively, indicating the presence of mobile nucleotide chains. Salt addition caused complete desorption of the nucleotide chains. When POPC was replaced with DOPE, binding of OligoS or PolyA produced non-bilayer lipid phases in the presence of DOTAP, but not in the presence of CTAB.

Surface charge response of the phosphatidylcholine head group in bilayered micelles from phosphorus and deuterium nuclear magnetic resonance

Solid-state phosphorus (31P) and deuterium (2H) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy over the temperature range of 25-50 degreesC were used to investigate bilayered micelles (bicelles) composed of 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC) and 1, 2-dihexanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DHPC) in the presence of either the anionic lipid 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-3-phosphoglycerol (DMPG) or the cationic lipid 1,2-dimyristoyl-3-trimethylammonium-propane (DMTAP). The 31P-NMR spectra demonstrate that bicellar structures form with DMPG/DMPC ratios ranging from 0 to 50/50 and with DMTAP/DMPC ratios from 0 to 40/60, while the overall concentration of DHPC remains constant. The formation of bicelles containing charged amphiphiles is contingent upon the presence of NaCl, with 50 mM NaCl being sufficient for bicelle formation at all concentrations of charged amphiphile investigated, while 150 mM NaCl affords better resolution of the various 31P-NMR resonance signals. The 2H-NMR spectra demonstrate that the quadrupolar splittings (Deltanu) of head group-deuterated DMPC change inversely as a function of the amount of negative versus positive charge present, and that the changes for deuterons on the alpha-carbon are opposite in sense to those for deuterons on the beta-carbon. This indicates that head group-deuterated phosphatidylcholine functions as a molecular voltmeter in bicelles in much the same fashion as it does in spherical vesicles.

Destabilization of cationic lipid vesicles by an anionic hydrophobically modified poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) copolymer: a solid-state 31P NMR and 2H NMR study

The effect of binding PNIPAM-Py-Gly, a copolymer of N-isopropylacrylamide, N-[4-(1-pyrenyl)butyl]-N-n-octadecylacrylamide and N-glycydyl-acrylamide, on membrane stability in cationic multilamellar vesicles (MLVs) was examined using solid-state phosphorus (31P) and deuterium (2H) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. For MLVs of composition n-octadecyldiethylene oxide (ODEO)+cholesterol (CHOL)+1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC)+dimethyldioctadecylammonium bromide (DODAB) (molar ratios 75:10.5:10.5:4), PNIPAM-Py-Gly induced a complete conversion from a bilayer-type 31P NMR spectrum to one characteristic of lipids undergoing isotropic motional averaging, indicating the existence of regions of high local membrane curvature. This response was sustained even at elevated temperatures. For MLVs of composition POPC+1,2-dioleoyloxy-3-(trimethylammonio)-propane (DOTAP), only at high levels of DOTAP and ionic strength did PNIPAM-Py-Gly induce even a partial conversion to an isotropic-type 31P NMR spectrum. At lower pH this effect was diminished. Raising the temperature eliminated the isotropic 31P NMR spectral component, and this effect was not reversible upon returning to room temperature. 2H NMR spectroscopy of headgroup-deuterated DOTAP and POPC confirmed the 31P NMR results, but did not provide specific surface electrostatic information. We conclude that the binding of PNIPAM-Py-Gly to phospholipid-based vesicles is dominated by electrostatic attraction between cationic lipids and the polymer's glycine residues. At high binding levels, the polymer assumes a collapsed conformation at the surface, resulting in regions of high local curvature of the lipid assembly. For ODEO-based liposomes, these effects are magnified by the additional contribution of hydrogen bonding to the strength of polymer binding.