Asymmetric Electron Transfer in Reaction Centers of Purple Bacteria Strongly Depends on Different Electron Matrix Elements in the Active and Inactive Branches

Primary electron transfer in Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26 reaction centers under dehydration conditions

The photoinduced charge separation in Q_B-depleted reaction centers (RCs) from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26 in solid air-dried and vacuum-dried (~10^-2 Torr) films, obtained in the presence of detergent n-dodecyl-β-D-maltoside (DM), is characterized using ultrafast transient absorption spectroscopy. It is shown that drying of RC-DM complexes is accompanied by reversible blue shifts of the ground-state absorption bands of the pigment ensemble, which suggest that no dehydration-induced structural destruction of RCs occurs in both types of films. In air-dried films, electron transfer from the excited primary electron donor P^⁎ to the photoactive bacteriopheophytin H_A proceeds in 4.7 ps to form the P⁺H_A^- state with essentially 100% yield. P⁺H_A^- decays in 260 ps both by electron transfer to the primary quinone Q_A to give the state P⁺Q_A^- (87% yield) and by charge recombination to the ground state (13% yield). In vacuum-dried films, P^⁎ decay is characterized by two kinetic components with time constants of 4.1 and 46 ps in a proportion of ~55%/45%, and P⁺H_A^- decays about 2-fold slower (462 ps) than in air-dried films. Deactivation of both P^⁎ and P⁺H_A^- to the ground state effectively competes with the corresponding forward electron-transfer reactions in vacuum-dried RCs, reducing the yield of P⁺Q_A^- to 68%. The results are compared with the data obtained for fully hydrated RCs in solution and are discussed in terms of the presence in the RC complexes of different water molecules, the removal/displacement of which affects spectral properties of pigment cofactors and rates and yields of the electron-transfer reactions.

Why are photosynthetic reaction centres dimeric?

All photosynthetic organisms convert solar energy into chemical energy through charge separation in dimeric reaction centres. It is unknown why early reaction centres dimerised and completely displaced their monomeric ancestors. Here, we discuss several proposed explanations for reaction-centre dimerism and conclude-with only weak assumptions about the primordial dimerisation event-that the most probable explanation for the dimerism is that it arose because it enhanced light-harvesting efficiency by deepening the excitonic trap, i.e., by enhancing the rate of exciton transfer from an antenna complex and decreasing the rate of back transfer. This effect would have outweighed the negative effect dimerisation would have had on charge transfer within the reaction centre. Our argument implies that dimerisation likely occurred after the evolution of the first antennas, and it explains why the lower-energy state of the special pair is bright.

Hopping Maps for Photosynthetic Reaction Centers()

Photosynthetic reaction centers (PRCs) employ multiple-step tunneling (hopping) to separate electrons and holes that ultimately drive the chemistry required for metabolism. We recently developed hopping maps that can be used to interpret the rates and energetics of electron/hole hopping in three-site (donor-intermediate-acceptor) tunneling reactions, including those in PRCs. Here we analyze several key ET reactions in PRCs, including forward ET in the L-branch, and hopping that could involve thermodynamically uphill intermediates in the M-branch, which is ET-inactive in vivo. We also explore charge recombination reactions, which could involve hopping. Our hopping maps support the view that electron flow in PRCs involves strong electronic coupling between cofactors and reorganization energies that are among the lowest in biology (≤ 0.4 eV).

Pressure-induced spectral changes for the special-pair radical cation of the bacterial photosynthetic reaction center

The effect of pressure up to 6 kbars on the near to mid infrared absorption spectrum (7500-14,300 cm(-1) or 1333-700 nm) of the oxidized reaction center of Rhodobacter sphaeroides is measured and interpreted using density-functional B3LYP, INDO, and PM5 calculations. Two weak electronic transition origins at approximately 8010 and approximately 10,210 cm(-1) are unambiguously identified. The first transition is assigned to a Qy tripdoublet band that involves, in the localized description of the excitation, a triplet absorption on one of the bacteriochlorophyll molecules (PM) in the reaction center's special pair intensified by the presence of a radical cation on the other (PL). While most chlorophyll transition energies decrease significantly with increasing pressure, the tripdoublet band is found to be almost pressure insensitive. This difference is attributed to the additional increase in the tripdoublet-band energy accompanying compression of the pi-stacked special pair. The second band could either be the anticipated second Qy tripdoublet state, a Qx tripdoublet state, or a state involving excitation from a low-lying doubly occupied orbital to the half-occupied cationic orbital. A variety of absorption bands that are also resolved in the 8300-9600 cm(-1) region are assigned as vibrational structure associated with the first tripdoublet absorption. These sidebands are composites that are shown by the calculations to comprise many unresolved individual modes; while the calculated pressure sensitivity of each individual mode is small, the calculated pressure dependence of the combined sideband structure is qualitatively similar to the observed pressure dependence, preventing the positive identification of possible additional electronic transitions in this spectral region.

Probing the Contribution of Electronic Coupling to the Directionality of Electron Transfer in Photosynthetic Reaction Centers

Subpicosecond transient absorption studies are reported for a set of Rhodobacter (R.) capsulatus bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers (RCs) designed to probe the origins of the unidirectionality of charge separation via one of two electron transport chains in the native pigment-protein complex. All of the RCs have been engineered to contain a heterodimeric primary electron donor (D) consisting of a bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) and a bacteriopheophytin (BPh). The BPh component of the M heterodimer (Mhd) or L heterodimer (Lhd) is introduced by substituting a Leu for His M200 or His L173, respectively. Previous work on primary charge separation in heterodimer mutants has not included the Lhd RC from R. capsulatus, which we report for the first time. The Lhd and Mhd RCs are used as controls against which we assess RCs that combine the heterodimer mutations with a second mutation (His substituted for Leu at M212) that results in replacement of the native L-side BPh acceptor with a BChl (beta). The transient absorption spectra reveal clear evidence for charge separation to the normally inactive M-side BPh acceptor (H(M)) in Lhd-beta RCs to form D+H(M)- with a yield of approximately 6%. This state also forms in Mhd-beta RCs but with about one-quarter the yield. In both RCs, deactivation to the ground state is the predominant pathway of D decay, as it is in the Mhd and Lhd single mutants. Analysis of the results indicates an upper limit ofV2L/V2m < or = 4 for the contribution of the electronic coupling elements to the relative rates of electron transfer to the L versus M sides of the wild-type RC. In comparison to the L/M rate ratio (kL/kM) approximately 30 for wild-type RCs, our findings indicate that electronic factors contribute approximately 35% at most to directionality with the other 65% deriving from energetic considerations, which includes differences in free energies, reorganization energies, and contributions of one- and two-step mechanisms on the two sides of the RC.

Rewiring photosynthesis: engineering wrong-way electron transfer in the purple bacterial reaction centre

The purple bacterial reaction centre uses light energy to separate charge across the cytoplasmic membrane, reducing ubiquinone and oxidizing a c-type cytochrome. The protein possesses a macroscopic structural two-fold symmetry but displays a strong functional asymmetry, with only one of two available membrane-spanning branches of cofactors (the so-called A-branch) being used to catalyse photochemical charge separation. The factors underlying this functional asymmetry have been the subject of study for many years but are still not fully understood. Site-directed mutagenesis has been partially successful in rerouting electron transfer along the normally inactive B-branch, allowing comparison of the kinetics of equivalent electron transfer reactions on the two branches. Both the primary and secondary electron transfer steps on the B-branch appear to be considerably slower than their A-branch counterparts. The effectiveness of different mutations in rerouting electron transfer along the B-branch of cofactors is discussed.

The First Picoseconds in Bacterial Photosynthesis?Ultrafast Electron Transfer for the Efficient Conversion of Light Energy

In this Minireview, we describe the function of the bacterial reaction centre (RC) as the central photosynthetic energy-conversion unit by ultrafast spectroscopy combined with structural analysis, site-directed mutagenesis, pigment exchange and theoretical modelling. We show that primary energy conversion is a stepwise process in which an electron is transferred via neighbouring chromophores of the RC. A well-defined chromophore arrangement in a rigid protein matrix, combined with optimised energetics of the different electron carriers, allows a highly efficient charge-separation process. The individual molecular reactions at room temperature are well described by conventional electron-transfer theory.

Investigation of B-branch electron transfer by femtosecond time resolved spectroscopy in a Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centre that lacks the QA ubiquinone

The dynamics of electron transfer in a membrane-bound Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centre containing a combination of four mutations were investigated by transient absorption spectroscopy. The reaction centre, named WAAH, has a mutation that causes the reaction centre to assemble without a Q(A) ubiquinone (Ala M260 to Trp), a mutation that causes the replacement of the H(A) bacteriopheophytin with a bacteriochlorophyll (Leu M214 to His) and two mutations that remove acidic groups close to the Q(B) ubiquinone (Glu L212 to Ala and Asp L213 to Ala). Previous work has shown that the Q(B) ubiquinone is reduced by electron transfer along the so-called inactive cofactor branch (B-branch) in the WAAH reaction centre (M.C. Wakeham, M.G. Goodwin, C. McKibbin, M.R. Jones, Photo-accumulation of the P(+)Q(B)(-) radical pair state in purple bacterial reaction centres that lack the Q(A) ubiquinone, FEBS Letters 540 (2003) 234-240). In the present study the dynamics of electron transfer in the membrane-bound WAAH reaction centre were studied by femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopy, and the data analysed using a compartmental model. The analysis indicates that the yield of Q(B) reduction via the B-branch is approximately 8% in the WAAH reaction centre, consistent with results from millisecond time-scale kinetic spectroscopy. Possible contributions to this yield of the constituent mutations in the WAAH reaction centre and the membrane environment of the complex are discussed.

Effects of Ionizable Residues on the Absorption Spectrum and Initial Electron-Transfer Kinetics in the Photosynthetic Reaction Center of Rhodobacter sphaeroides

Effects of ionizable amino acids on spectroscopic properties and electron-transfer kinetics in the photosynthetic reaction center (RC) of Rhodobacter sphaeroides are investigated by site-directed mutations designed to alter the electrostatic environment of the bacteriochlorophyll dimer that serves as the photochemical electron donor (P). Arginine residues at homologous positions in the L and M subunits (L135 and M164) are changed independently: Arg L135 is replaced by Lys, Leu, Glu, and Gln and Arg M164 by Leu and Glu. Asp L155 also is mutated to Asn, Tyr L164 to Phe, and Cys L247 to Lys and Asp. The mutations at L155, L164, and M164 have little effect on the absorption spectrum, whereas those at L135 and L247 shift the long-wavelength absorption band of P to higher energies. Fits to the ground-state absorption and hole-burned spectra indicate that the blue shift and increased width of the absorption band in the L135 mutants are due partly to changes in the distribution of energies for the zero-phonon absorption line and partly to stronger electron-phonon coupling. The initial electron-transfer kinetics are not changed significantly in most of the mutants, but the time constant increases from 3.0 +/- 0.2 in wild-type RCs to 4.7 +/- 0.2 in C(L247)D and 7.0 +/- 0.3 ps in C(L247)K. The effects of the mutations on the solvation free energies of the product of the initial electron-transfer reaction (P(+)) and the charge-transfer states that contribute to the absorption spectrum ( and ) were calculated by using a distance-dependent electrostatic screening factor. The results are qualitatively in accord with the view that electrostatic interactions of the bacteriochlorophylls with ionized residues of the protein are strongly screened and make only minor contributions to the energetics and dynamics of charge separation. However, the slowing of electron transfer in the Cys L247 mutants and the blue shift of the spectrum in some of the Arg L135 and Cys L247 mutants cannot be explained consistently by electrostatic interactions of the mutated residues with P and B(L); we ascribe these effects tentatively to structural changes caused by the mutations.

Charge recombination and protein dynamics in bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers entrapped in a sol-gel matrix

Many proteins can be immobilized in silica hydrogel matrices without compromising their function, making this a suitable technique for biosensor applications. Immobilization will in general affect protein structure and dynamics. To study these effects, we have measured the P(+)Q(A)(-) charge recombination kinetics after laser excitation of Q(B)-depleted wild-type photosynthetic reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides in a tetramethoxysilane (TMOS) sol-gel matrix and, for comparison, also in cryosolvent. The nonexponential electron transfer kinetics observed between 10 and 300 K were analyzed quantitatively using the spin boson model for the intrinsic temperature dependence of the electron transfer and an adiabatic change of the energy gap and electronic coupling caused by protein motions in response to the altered charge distributions. The analysis reveals similarities and differences in the TMOS-matrix and bulk-solvent samples. In both preparations, electron transfer is coupled to the same spectrum of low frequency phonons. As in bulk solvent, charge-solvating protein motions are present in the TMOS matrix. Large-scale conformational changes are arrested in the hydrogel, as evident from the nonexponential kinetics even at room temperature. The altered dynamics is likely responsible for the observed changes in the electronic coupling matrix element.

B-side charge separation in bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers: nanosecond time scale electron transfer from HB- to QB

We report time-resolved optical measurements of the primary electron transfer reactions in Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction centers (RCs) having four mutations: Phe(L181) --> Tyr, Tyr(M208) --> Phe, Leu(M212) --> His, and Trp(M250) --> Val (denoted YFHV). Following direct excitation of the bacteriochlorophyll dimer (P) to its lowest excited singlet state P, electron transfer to the B-side bacteriopheophytin (H(B)) gives P(+)H(B)(-) in approximately 30% yield. When the secondary quinone (Q(B)) site is fully occupied, P(+)H(B)(-) decays with a time constant estimated to be in the range of 1.5-3 ns. In the presence of excess terbutryn, a competitive inhibitor of Q(B) binding, the observed lifetime of P(+)H(B)(-) is noticeably longer and is estimated to be in the range of 4-8 ns. On the basis of these values, the rate constant for P(+)H(B)(-) --> P(+)Q(B)(-) electron transfer is calculated to be between approximately (2 ns)(-)(1) and approximately (12 ns)(-)(1), making it at least an order of magnitude smaller than the rate constant of approximately (200 ps)(-)(1) for electron transfer between the corresponding A-side cofactors (P(+)H(A)(-) --> P(+)Q(A)(-)). Structural and energetic factors associated with electron transfer to Q(B) compared to Q(A) are discussed. Comparison of the P(+)H(B)(-) lifetimes in the presence and absence of terbutryn indicates that the ultimate (i.e., quantum) yield of P(+)Q(B)(-) formation relative to P is 10-25% in the YFHV RC.

Quinone reduction via secondary B-branch electron transfer in mutant bacterial reaction centers

Symmetry-related branches of electron-transfer cofactors-initiating with a primary electron donor (P) and terminating in quinone acceptors (Q)-are common features of photosynthetic reaction centers (RC). Experimental observations show activity of only one of them-the A branch-in wild-type bacterial RCs. In a mutant RC, we now demonstrate that electron transfer can occur along the entire, normally inactive B-branch pathway to reduce the terminal acceptor Q(B) on the time scale of nanoseconds. The transmembrane charge-separated state P(+)Q(B)(-) is created in this manner in a Rhodobacter capsulatus RC containing the F(L181)Y-Y(M208)F-L(M212)H-W(M250)V mutations (YFHV). The W(M250)V mutation quantitatively blocks binding of Q(A), thereby eliminating Q(B) reduction via the normal A-branch pathway. Full occupancy of the Q(B) site by the native UQ(10) is ensured (without the necessity of reconstitution by exogenous quinone) by purification of RCs with the mild detergent, Deriphat 160-C. The lifetime of P(+)Q(B)(-) in the YFHV mutant RC is >6 s (at pH 8.0, 298 K). This charge-separated state is not formed upon addition of competitive inhibitors of Q(B) binding (terbutryn or stigmatellin). Furthermore, this lifetime is much longer than the value of approximately 1-1.5 s found when P(+)Q(B)(-) is produced in the wild-type RC by A-side activity alone. Collectively, these results demonstrate that P(+)Q(B)(-) is formed solely by activity of the B-branch carriers in the YFHV RC. In comparison, P(+)Q(B)(-) can form by either the A or B branches in the YFH RC, as indicated by the biexponential lifetimes of approximately 1 and approximately 6-10 s. These findings suggest that P(+)Q(B)(-) states formed via the two branches are distinct and that P(+)Q(B)(-) formed by the B side does not decay via the normal (indirect) pathway that utilizes the A-side cofactors when present. These differences may report on structural and energetic factors that further distinguish the functional asymmetry of the two cofactor branches.

Kinetics, energetics, and electronic coupling of the primary electron transfer reactions in mutated reaction centers of Blastochloris viridis

Femtosecond spectroscopy in combination with site-directed mutagenesis has been used to study the dynamics of primary electron transfer in native and 12 mutated reaction centers of Blastochloris (B) (formerly called Rhodopseudomonas) viridis. The decay times of the first excited state P* vary at room temperature between of 0.6 and 50 ps, and at low temperatures between 0.25 and 90 ps. These changes in time constants are discussed within the scope of nonadiabatic electron transfer theory using different models: 1) If the mutation is assumed to predominantly influence the energetics of the primary electron transfer intermediates, the analysis of the room temperature data for the first electron transfer step to the intermediate P(+)B(A)(-) yields a reorganization energy lambda = 600 +/- 200 cm(-1) and a free energy gap Delta G ranging from -600 cm(-1) to 800 cm(-1). However, this analysis fails to describe the temperature dependence of the reaction rates. 2) A more realistic description of the temperature dependence of the primary electron transfer requires different values for the energetics and specific variations of the electronic coupling upon mutation. Apparently the mutations also lead to pronounced changes in the electronic coupling, which may even dominate the change in the reaction rate. One main message of the paper is that a simple relationship between mutation and a change in one reaction parameter cannot be given and that at the very least the electronic coupling is changed upon mutation.

Selective perturbation of the second electron transfer step in mutant bacterial reaction centers

In order to specifically perturb the primary electron acceptor B(A) -- a monomeric bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) a -- involved in bacterial photosynthetic charge separation (CS), the protein environment of B(A) in the reaction center (RC) of Rhodobacter sphaeroides was modified by site-directed mutagenesis. Isolated RCs were characterized by redox titrations, low temperature optical spectroscopy, ENDOR/TRIPLE resonance spectroscopy and femtosecond time-resolved spectroscopy. Two mutations were studied: In the GS(M203) mutant a serine is introduced near the ring E keto group of B(A), while in FY(L146) a phenylalanine near the ring A acetyl group of B(A) is replaced by tyrosine. In all mutations the oxidation potential of the primary electron donor P as well as the electronic structure of both the P(*+) radical cation and the radical anion of the secondary electron acceptor, H(A)(*-), are not significantly altered compared to the wild type (WT), while changes of the optical absorption spectra at 77 K in the BChl Q(X) and Q(Y) regions are observed. The GS(M203) mutation only leads to a minor retardation of the CS reactions at room temperature, whereas for FY(L146) significant deviations from the native electron transfer (ET) rates could be detected: In addition to a faster first (2.9 ps) and a slower second (1 ps) ET step, a new 8-ps time constant was found in the FY(L146) mutant, which can be ascribed to a fraction of RCs with slowed down secondary ET. The results allow us to address the functional role of the acetyl group of B(A) and question the role of the free energy changes as the main determining factor of ET rates in RCs. It is concluded that structural rearrangements alter the electronic coupling between the pigments and thereby influence the rate of fast CS.

High yield of B-branch electron transfer in a quadruple reaction center mutant of the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides

A new reaction center (RC) quadruple mutant, called LDHW, of Rhodobacter sphaeroides is described. This mutant was constructed to obtain a high yield of B-branch electron transfer and to study P(+)Q(B)(-) formation via the B-branch. The A-branch of the mutant RC contains two monomer bacteriochlorophylls, B(A) and beta, as a result of the H mutation L(M214)H. The latter bacteriochlorophyll replaces bacteriopheophytin H(A) of wild-type RCs. As a result of the W mutation A(M260)W, the A-branch does not contain the ubiquinone Q(A); this facilitates the study of P(+)Q(B)(-) formation. Furthermore, the D mutation G(M203)D introduces an aspartic acid residue near B(A). Together these mutations impede electron transfer through the A-branch. The B-branch contains two bacteriopheophytins, Phi(B) and H(B), and a ubiquinone, Q(B.) Phi(B) replaces the monomer bacteriochlorophyll B(B) as a result of the L mutation H(M182)L. In the LDHW mutant we find 35-45% B-branch electron transfer, the highest yield reported so far. Transient absorption spectroscopy at 10 K, where the absorption bands due to the Q(X) transitions of Phi(B) and H(B) are well resolved, shows simultaneous bleachings of both absorption bands. Although photoreduction of the bacteriopheophytins occurs with a high yield, no significant (approximately 1%) P(+)Q(B)(-) formation was found.

Manipulating the direction of electron transfer in the bacterial reaction center by swapping Phe for Tyr near BChl(M) (L181) and Tyr for Phe near BChl(L) (M208)

We have investigated the primary charge separation processes in Rb. capsulatus reaction centers (RCs) bearing the mutations Phe(L181) --> Tyr, Tyr(M208) --> Phe, and Leu(M212) --> His. In the YFH mutant, decay of the excited primary electron donor P occurs with an 11 +/- 2 ps time constant and is trifurcated to give (1) internal conversion to the ground state ( approximately 10% yield), (2) charge separation to the L side of the RC ( approximately 60% yield), and (3) electron transfer to the M-side bacteriopheophytin BPh(M) ( approximately 30% yield). These results relate previous work in which the ionizable residues Lys (at L178) and Asp (at M201) have been used to facilitate charge separation to the M side of the RC, and the widely studied L181 and M208 mutants. One conclusion that comes from this work is that the Tyr (M208) --> Phe and Gly(M201) --> Asp mutations near the L-side bacteriochlorophyll (BChl(L)) raise the free energy of P(+)BChl(L)(-) by comparable amounts. The results also suggest that the free energy of P(+)BChl(M)(-) is lowered more substantially by a Tyr at L181 than a Lys at L178. The results on the YFH mutant further demonstrate that the free energy differences between the L- and M-side charge-separated states play a significant role in the directionality of charge separation in the wild-type RC, and place limits on the contributing role of differential electronic matrix elements on the two sides of the RC.

Thermooptic effect in chloroplast thylakoid membranes. Thermal and light stability of pigment arrays with different levels of structural complexity

In chloroplast thylakoid membranes, chiral macrodomains, i.e., large arrays of pigment molecules with long-range chiral order, have earlier been shown to undergo light-induced reversible and irreversible structural changes; such reorganizations did not affect the short-range, excitonic pigment-pigment interactions. These structural changes and similar changes in lamellar aggregates of the main chlorophyll a/b light-harvesting complexes exhibited a linear dependence on the intensity of light that was not utilized in photosynthesis. It has been hypothesized that the light-induced rearrangements are driven by a thermooptic effect, i.e., thermal fluctuations due to the dissipation of excess excitation energies [Barzda, V., et al. (1996) Biochemistry 35, 8981-8985]. To test this hypothesis, we have utilized circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy to investigate the structural stability of the chiral macrodomains and the constituent bulk pigment-protein complexes of granal thylakoid membranes against heat and prolonged, intense illumination. (i) In intact thylakoid membranes, the chiral macrodomains displayed high stability below 40 degrees C, but they were gradually disassembled between 50 and 60 degrees C; the thermal stability of the chiral macrodomains could be decreased substantially by suspending the membranes in reaction media that were hypotonic or had low ionic strength. (ii) The chiral macrodomains were also susceptible to high light: prolonged illumination with intense white light (25 min, 2500 microE m(-)(2) s(-)(1), 25 degrees C) induced similar, irreversible disassembly to that observed at high temperatures; in different preparations, lower thermal stability was coupled to lower light stability. (iii) The light stability depended significantly on the temperature: between about 5 and 15 degrees C, the macrodomains in the intact thylakoids were virtually not susceptible to high light; in contrast, the same preillumination at 35-40 degrees C almost completely destroyed the chiral macrodomains. (iv) As testified by the excitonic CD bands, the molecular organization of the pigment-protein complexes in all samples exhibited very high thermal stability between about 15 and 65 degrees C, and virtually total immunity against intense illumination. These data are fully consistent with the hypothesis of a thermooptic effect, and are interpreted within the frame of a simple model.