Effect of benzalkonium chloride/EDTA on the ocular bioavailability of ketorolac tromethamine following ocular instillation to normal and de-epithelialized corneas of rabbits

Small Molecule Topical Ophthalmic Formulation Development-Data Driven Trends & Perspectives from Commercially Available Products in the US

Topical ophthalmic drug product development is a niche research domain as the drug formulations need to be designed to perform in the unique ocular physiological conditions. The most common array of small molecule drug formulations intended for topical ophthalmic administration include solutions, suspensions, emulsions, gels, and ointments. The formulation components such as excipients and container closure are unique to serve the needs of topical ophthalmic delivery compared to other parenteral products. The selection of appropriate formulation platform, excipients, and container closure for delivery of drugs by topical ophthalmic route is influenced by a combination of factors like physicochemical properties of the drug molecule, intended dose, pharmacological indication as well as the market trends influenced by the patient population. In this review, data from literature and packaging inserts of 118 reference listed topical ophthalmic medications marketed in the US are collected and analyzed to identify trends that would serve as a guidance for topical ophthalmic formulation development for small molecule drugs. Specifically, the topics reviewed include current landscape of the available small molecule topical ophthalmic drug products in the US, physicochemical properties of the active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs), formulation platforms, excipients, and container closure systems.

Advanced nanodelivery platforms for topical ophthalmic drug delivery

Conventional eye drops have several limitations, including the need for multiple applications per dose, hourly based dosage regiments, and suboptimal ocular bioavailability (<5%). The efficacy of topical ophthalmic medications can be significantly improved by controlling their contact time with the adherent mucin layer and by inducing sustained release properties, thus allowing for a prolonged contact time of the drug with the ocular tissues, which eventually will lead to improved drug bioavailability and a significant decrease in the frequency of eyedrop instillation. In this review, we critically highlight recent and innovative nanodrug delivery platforms, with a primary focus on the integration of nanotechnology, biomaterials, and polymer chemistry to facilitate precise spatial and temporal control over sustained drug release to the cornea.

Effects of topical flurbiprofen sodium, diclofenac sodium, ketorolac tromethamine and benzalkonium chloride on corneal sensitivity in normal dogs

To evaluate corneal sensitivity by using the Cochet-Bonnet® esthesiometer in normal canine eyes at different time points following instillation of three different topical non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (flurbiprofen sodium 0.03%, diclofenac sodium 0.1% and ketorolac tromethamine 0.5%) and benzalkonium chloride 0.01%. Six healthy mixed breed dogs from the same litter were used in two different stages. First, one drop of flurbiprofen sodium 0.03% and diclofenac sodium 0.1% in each eye; second, one drop of ketorolac tromethamine 0.5% and benzalkonium chloride 0.01% in each eye. Baseline esthesiometry was obtained before eye drop application and every 15 minutes thereafter until a total of 105 minutes of evaluation time. A one-week interval was allowed between the two treatment phases. Statistical analysis was used to compare means according to time of evaluation and drug used. Diclofenac sodium 0.1% decreased corneal sensitivity at 75 and 90 minutes (P > 0.015) with possible interference on neuronal nociceptive activity and analgesic effect while ketorolac tromethamine 0.5% did not show any variation for esthesiometry means along the evaluation. Flurbiprofen sodium 0.03% resulted in increased esthesiometry values 30 minutes after instillation (P > 0.013), increasing corneal sensitivity and possibly producing a greater irritant corneal effect over its analgesic properties. Benzalkonium chloride 0.01% significantly increased corneal sensitivity at 15 minutes of evaluation (P > 0.001), most likely resulting from its irritating effect. Esthesiometry did not allow a definite conclusion over the analgesic effect of the NSAIDs tested; however it was effective in detecting fluctuations in corneal sensitivity.

Effect of pH and penetration enhancers on cysteamine stability and trans-corneal transport

Ocular cystinosis is a rare metabolic disorder characterized by the presence of insoluble cystine crystals inside the corneal stroma, with consequent photophobia, keratopathies and frequent corneal erosions. The current therapy consists in the lifetime ophthalmic administration of cysteamine, drug characterized by extremely high hydrophilicity, low molecular weight (77g/mol), and easy oxidization to disulfide. Ocular delivery of cysteamine is very challenging, for its poor permeability and stability in solution. The purpose of the present paper was to study the impact of formulation pH and composition on (1) the trans-corneal delivery and (2) the stability in solution of cysteamine, with particular focus on the use of alpha-cyclodextrin (α-CD), benzalkonium chloride (BAC) and disodium edetate (EDTA). Permeation experiments were performed ex vivo through freshly excised porcine cornea; stability was evaluated for six months at -20°, +4° and +25°C; irritation potential was evaluated using HET-CAM assay. The results showed that cysteamine trans-corneal diffusion is strictly dependent on both pH (7.4 preferred to 4.2) and buffering capacity, that negatively impact on the permeation; EDTA did not enhance the trans-corneal diffusion of cysteamine neither at pH 7.4 nor at pH 4.2, while benzalkonium chloride (BAC), antimicrobial agent present within commercial eye-drops, significantly enhanced it. Notably, α-CD was able to promote the trans-corneal diffusion of cysteamine and, at a 5.5%, a 4-fold higher penetration compared to the BAC-containing formulation was obtained. EDTA and acidic pH demonstrated to be essential for cysteamine stability. The formulation obtained by combining α-CD and EDTA was characterized by significant permeation, good stability profile, and no irritation potential, even if the tolerability should be further confirmed by in vivo test.

Effect of in vitro transcorneal approach of aceclofenac eye drops through excised goat, sheep, and buffalo corneas

The current study involves the evaluation of factors that influence the transcorneal permeation of aqueous drops of aceclofenac ophthalmic formulation through freshly excised goat, sheep, and buffalo corneas. Aceclofenac formulation with different concentrations 0.1-0.5% (w/v) and with different pH and different preservatives, was taken into account. The amount of drug permeated from different formulations was estimated using an Franz diffusion cell. A linear increase in drug permeation was observed with increase in pH (5.5 to 7.4). The apparent permeability coefficient was found to be maximum 15.01 ± 0.45 on goat cornea and maximum transport of aceclofenac was observed at physiological pH of tears (i.e., 7). The results advocate that aceclofenac 0.5% (w/v) ophthalmic solution (pH 7.0) containing BAK (0.01%) provides maximum in vitro ocular permeability through goat, sheep, and buffalo corneas.

Ocular pharmacokinetics of 0.45% ketorolac tromethamine

Purpose

A new carboxymethylcellulose (CMC)-containing ophthalmic formulation of 0.45% ketorolac, pH 6.8 (Acuvail^®) was recently developed for treatment of inflammation and pain after cataract surgery. This study compared pharmacokinetics of the new formulation with that of a prior formulation, 0.4% ketorolac, pH 7.4 (Acular LS^®).

Methods

Ketorolac formulations were administered bilaterally (35 μL) to female New Zealand White rabbits. Samples from aqueous humor and iris-ciliary body were collected at multiple time points, and ketorolac was quantified using liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry.

Results

In aqueous humor, the peak concentration (C_max) and area under the concentration-time curve (AUC_0–τ) of ketorolac were, respectively, 389 ng/mL and 939 ng·h/mL following administration of the CMC-containing 0.45% ketorolac, pH 6.8, and 211 ng/mL and 465 ng·hr/mL following administration of the 0.4% ketorolac, pH 7.4. In iris-ciliary body, C_max and AUC_0–τ of ketorolac were, respectively 450 ng/g and 2040 ng·h/g after administration of the CMC-containing 0.45% ketorolac, pH 6.8, and 216 ng/g and 699 ng·h/g after administration of the 0.4% ketorolac, pH 7.4. PK simulations predicted an AUC_0–τ of 2910 ng·h/g for twice daily, CMC-containing 0.45% ketorolac, pH 6.8, compared to 725 ng·h/g for 4 times daily, 0.4% ketorolac, pH 7.4.

Conclusions

The CMC-containing formulation of 0.45% ketorolac, pH 6.8, increased ketorolac bioavailability by 2-fold in aqueous humor and by 3-fold in iris-ciliary body in comparison to the 0.4% ketorolac, pH 7.4, allowing a reduced dosing schedule from 4 times daily to twice daily.

NC-1059: a channel-forming peptide that modulates drug delivery across in vitro corneal epithelium

PURPOSE

The goal of this study was to determine whether a synthetic peptide, NC-1059, can modulate the corneal epithelium to increase the permeation of therapeutic agents across this barrier.

METHODS

An in vitro system employing transformed human corneal epithelial (THCE) cells was optimized for this study. Culture conditions were identified to promote formation of a confluent monolayer that rapidly develops a substantial transepithelial electrical resistance. Electrical parameters were measured with a modified Ussing flux chamber, and solute flux was quantified with fluorescently labeled compounds.

RESULTS

NC-1059 causes a concentration-dependent increase in short-circuit current and an increase in transepithelial electrical conductance when assessed in modified Ussing chambers. The effect of NC-1059 on transepithelial electrical resistance was reversible. To test for paracellular permeability and size exclusion, FITC-labeled dextran ranging in size from 10 to 70 kDa was used. Dextran permeated the corneal cell monolayer in the presence, but not the absence, of NC-1059. Fluorescein sodium and carboxyfluorescein were then used as low molecular weight markers with similar NC-1059-modulated kinetics being observed. Maximum permeation for the fluorescein derivatives occurred 30 to 90 minutes after a 5-minute NC-1059 exposure. A prototypical drug, methotrexate, also exhibited increased permeation in the presence of NC-1059.

CONCLUSIONS

NC-1059 enhances drug permeation across cultured corneal epithelial cell monolayers by transiently affecting the paracellular pathway. Thus, NC-1059 is a lead compound for development of cotherapeutic agents to enhance access and effectiveness of ophthalmic compounds.

Effect of formulation factors on in vitro permeation of moxifloxacin from aqueous drops through excised goat, sheep, and buffalo corneas

The purpose of this investigation was to evaluate the effect of formulation factors on in vitro permeation of moxifloxacin from aqueous drop through freshly excised goat, sheep, and buffalo corneas. Aqueous isotonic ophthalmic solutions of moxifloxacin hydrochloride of different concentrations (pH 7.2) or 0.5% (wt/vol) solutions of different pH or 0.5% solutions (pH 7.2) containing different preservatives were made. Permeation characteristics of drug were evaluated by putting 1 mL formulation on freshly excised cornea (0.50 cm(2)) fixed between donor and receptor compartments of an all-glass modified Franz diffusion cell and measuring the drug permeated in the receptor (containing 10 mL bicarbonate ringer at 37 degrees C under stirring) by spectrophotometry at 291 nm, after 120 minutes. Statistical analysis was done by one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by Dunnett's test. Increase in drug concentration in the formulation resulted in an increase in the quantity permeated but a decrease in percentage permeation. Increase in pH of the solution from 5.5 to 7.2 increased drug permeation, indicating pH-dependent transport. Compared with control formulation, moxifloxacin 0.5% (wt/vol) solution (pH 7.2) containing disodium edetate (EDTA) (0.01% wt/vol) produced significantly (P < .05) higher permeation with all the corneas. Formulation with benzyl alcohol significantly (P < .05) increased permeation with buffalo cornea compared with its control. Presence of benzalkonium chloride (BAK) (0.01% wt/vol) and EDTA (0.01% wt/vol) in the formulation increased permeation to the maximum with all the corneas. The results suggest that moxifloxacin 0.5% ophthalmic solution (pH 7.2) containing BAK (0.01%) and EDTA (0.01%) provides increased in vitro ocular availability through goat, sheep, and buffalo corneas.

Synergistic effect of EDTA and boric acid on corneal penetration of CS-088

In order to investigate the effects of EDTA and boric acid (EDTA/boric acid) on the corneal penetration of CS-088, an ophthalmic agent, the apparent permeability coefficient of CS-088 in the presence of EDTA/boric acid across the isolated corneal membranes of rabbits was measured using an in vitro penetration chamber system. FITC-dextran (M.W. 4400) and an electrical method based on membrane resistance were used to provide a quantitative assessment of the enhancing effect of EDTA/boric acid. The corneal penetration of CS-088 was significantly enhanced in the presence of EDTA/boric acid by approximately 1.6-fold. The permeability-enhancing effect of EDTA/boric acid was apparently synergistic and concentration-dependent on both EDTA and boric acid. The penetration of FITC-dextran, a paracellular marker, and electrical resistance of corneal membranes were not affected in the presence of EDTA/boric acid. Furthermore, no enhancing effect of EDTA/boric acid was observed in de-epithelialized corneas, although de-epithelialized corneas exhibited a markedly higher permeability of CS-088 that was 24-fold greater than that for intact corneas. In conclusion, EDTA/boric acid synergistically enhances the transcellular permeability of CS-088 in the outer layer but not in the inner layers of the corneal membrane.