Fabrication of a planar zwitterionic lipid bilayer on titanium oxide

Advancements in Engineering Planar Model Cell Membranes: Current Techniques, Applications, and Future Perspectives

Cell membranes are crucial elements in living organisms, serving as protective barriers and providing structural support for cells. They regulate numerous exchange and communication processes between cells and their environment, including interactions with other cells, tissues, ions, xenobiotics, and drugs. However, the complexity and heterogeneity of cell membranes-comprising two asymmetric layers with varying compositions across different cell types and states (e.g., healthy vs. diseased)-along with the challenges of manipulating real cell membranes represent significant obstacles for in vivo studies. To address these challenges, researchers have developed various methodologies to create model cell membranes or membrane fragments, including mono- or bilayers organized in planar systems. These models facilitate fundamental studies on membrane component interactions as well as the interactions of membrane components with external agents, such as drugs, nanoparticles (NPs), or biomarkers. The applications of model cell membranes have extended beyond basic research, encompassing areas such as biosensing and nanoparticle camouflage to evade immune detection. In this review, we highlight advancements in the engineering of planar model cell membranes, focusing on the nanoarchitectonic tools used for their fabrication. We also discuss approaches for incorporating challenging materials, such as proteins and enzymes, into these models. Finally, we present our view on future perspectives in the field of planar model cell membranes.

Dissolved metal ions and mineral-liposome hybrid systems: Underlying interactions, synthesis, and characterization

Liposomes are versatile lipid-based vesicles with interesting physicochemical properties, making them excellent candidates for interdisciplinary applications in the medicinal, biological, and environmental sciences. The synthesis of mineral-liposome hybrid systems lends normally inert vesicles with the catalytic, magnetic, electrical, and optical properties of the integrated mineral species. Such applications require an understanding of the physicochemical interactions between organic molecules and inorganic crystal structures. This review provides an overview on these interactions and details on synthesis and characterization methods for these systems.

Inkjet-Printed Phospholipid Bilayers on Titanium Oxide Surfaces: Towards Functional Membrane Biointerfaces

Functional biointerfaces hold broad significance for designing cell-responsive medical implants and sensor devices. Solid-supported phospholipid bilayers are a promising class of biological materials to build bioinspired thin-film coatings, as they can facilitate interactions with cell membranes. However, it remains challenging to fabricate lipid bilayers on medically relevant materials such as titanium oxide surfaces. There are also limitations in existing bilayer printing capabilities since most approaches are restricted to either deposition alone or to fixed microarray patterning. By combining advances in lipid surface chemistry and on-demand inkjet printing, we demonstrate the direct deposition and patterning of covalently tethered lipid bilayer membranes on titanium oxide surfaces, in ambient conditions and without any surface pretreatment process. The deposition conditions were evaluated by quartz crystal microbalance-dissipation (QCM-D) measurements, with corresponding resonance frequency (Δf) and energy dissipation (ΔD) shifts of around −25 Hz and <1 × 10−6, respectively, that indicated successful bilayer printing. The resulting printed phospholipid bilayers are stable in air and do not collapse following dehydration; through rehydration, the bilayers regain their functional properties, such as lateral mobility (>1 µm2/s diffusion coefficient), according to fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) measurements. By taking advantage of the lipid bilayer patterned architectures and the unique features of titanium oxide’s photoactivity, we further show how patterned cell culture arrays can be fabricated. Looking forward, this work presents new capabilities to achieve stable lipid bilayer patterns that can potentially be translated into implantable biomedical devices.

Modelling the adsorption of phospholipid vesicles to a silicon dioxide surface using Langmuir kinetics

Supported Lipid Bilayers (SLBs) are model biological membranes that have been developed to study the interactions between biomolecules in a cell membrane. Though forming SLBs is relatively easy, their formation mechanism remains a topic of debate. When buffered solutions containing phosphatidylcholine vesicles are flowed over a silicon dioxide (SiO₂) surface they adsorb intact to the surface to form a Supported Vesicle Layer (SVL) if the pH of the buffer is above 9. We have run experiments with buffers with a pH at or above 9 to study the kinetics of the adsorption of 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC) vesicles to an SiO₂ surface, which is the first step in the formation of an SLB. We used a quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) to monitor the real-time changes in the mass of the SVL as it formed from solutions with different lipid concentrations. Increases in the maximum frequency change with increasing lipid concentration indicated that both adsorption and desorption of DOPC vesicles were occurring, and that an equilibrium was established between the DOPC vesicles in the SVL and in the bulk solution. From the data acquired we were able to determine that the equilibrium constant for the adsorption and desorption of DOPC vesicles was 18 ± 1. The data was fitted to a Langmuir adsorption model from which the rate constants for the adsorption and desorption of DOPC vesicles were determined to be k_a = (0.0107 ± 0.0004) mL mg^-1 s^-1 and k_d = (5.8 ± 0.3) × 10^-4 s^-1. The best fit to the experimental data was achieved if a parameter (α = (0.035 ± 0.003) s^-1) was used to account for the time taken for the lipid concentration to reach its steady state value in the flow cell used in the experiments.

Formation of Supported Lipid Bilayers (SLBs) from Buffers Containing Low Concentrations of Group I Chloride Salts

Supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) are a useful tool for studying the interactions between lipids and other biomolecules that make up a cell membrane. SLBs are typically formed by the adsorption and rupture of vesicles from solution. Although it is known that many experimental factors can affect whether SLB formation is successful, there is no comprehensive understanding of the mechanism. In this work, we have used a quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) to investigate the role of the salt in the buffer on the formation of phosphatidylcholine SLBs on a silicon dioxide (SiO₂) surface. We varied the concentration of sodium chloride in the buffer, from 5 to 150 mM, to find the minimum concentration of NaCl that was required for the successful formation of an SLB. We then repeated the experiments with other group I chloride salts (LiCl, KCl, and CsCl) and found that at higher salt concentrations (150 mM) SLB formation was successful for all of the salts used, and the degree of deformation of the adsorbed vesicles at the critical vesicle coverage was cation-dependent. The results showed that at an intermediate salt concentration (50 mM) the critical vesicle coverage was cation-dependent and at low salt concentrations (12.5 mM) the cation used determined whether SLB formation was successful. We found that the successful formation of SLBs could occur at lower electrolyte concentrations for KCl and CsCl than it did for NaCl. To understand these results, we calculated the magnitude of the vesicle-surface interaction energy using the Derjaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek (DLVO) and extended-DLVO theory. We managed to explain the results obtained at higher salt concentrations by including cation-dependent surface potentials in the calculations and at lower salt concentrations by the addition of a cation-dependent hydration force. These results showed that the way that different cations in solution affect the 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC)-SiO₂ surface interaction energy depends on the ionic strength of the solution.

Atomistic Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Lipids Near TiO2 Nanosurfaces

Understanding of interactions between inorganic nanomaterials and biomolecules, and particularly lipid bilayers, is crucial in many biotechnological and biomedical applications, as well as for the evaluation of possible toxic effects caused by nanoparticles. Here, we present a molecular dynamics study of adsorption of two important constituents of the cell membranes, 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC) and 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (POPE), lipids to a number of titanium dioxide planar surfaces, and a spherical nanoparticle under physiological conditions. By constructing the number density profiles of the lipid headgroup atoms, we have identified several possible binding modes and calculated their relative prevalence in the simulated systems. Our estimates of the adsorption strength, based on the total fraction of adsorbed lipids, show that POPE binds to the selected titanium dioxide surfaces stronger than DMPC, due to the ethanolamine group forming hydrogen bonds with the surface. Moreover, while POPE shows a clear preference toward anatase surfaces over rutile, DMPC has a particularly high affinity to rutile(101) and a lower affinity to other surfaces. Finally, we study how lipid concentration, addition of cholesterol, as well as titanium dioxide surface curvature may affect overall adsorption.

Hybrid bilayer membranes on metallurgical polished aluminum

In this work we describe the functionalization of metallurgically polished aluminum surfaces yielding biomimetic electrodes suitable for probing protein/phospholipid interactions. The functionalization involves two simple steps: silanization of the aluminum and subsequent fusion of multilamellar vesicles which leads to the formation of a hybrid bilayer lipid membrane (hBLM). The vesicle fusion was followed in real-time by fast Fourier transform electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (FFT EIS). The impedance-derived complex capacitance of the hBLMs was approximately 0.61 µF cm⁻², a value typical for intact phospholipid bilayers. We found that the hBLMs can be readily disrupted if exposed to > 400 nM solutions of the pore-forming peptide melittin. However, the presence of cholesterol at 40% (mol) in hBLMs exhibited an inhibitory effect on the membrane-damaging capacity of the peptide. The melittin-membrane interaction was concentration dependent decreasing with concentration. The hBLMs on Al surface can be regenerated multiple times, retaining their dielectric and functional properties essentially intact.

Charge and Coordination Directed Liposome Fusion onto SiO2 and TiO2 Nanoparticles

TiO₂ and SiO₂ are very useful materials for building biointerfaces. A particularly interesting aspect is their interaction with lipid bilayers. Many past research efforts focused on phosphocholine (PC) lipids, which form supported lipid bilayers (SLB) on SiO₂ at physiological conditions but are adsorbed as intact liposomes on TiO₂. Low pH was required to form PC SLBs on TiO₂. This work intends to understand the surface forces and chemistry responsible for such differences. Two charge neutral lipids: 1,2-dioleoyl- sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC) and 2-((2,3-bis(oleoyloxy)propyl)dimethylammonio)ethyl ethyl phosphate (DOCPe) and two negatively charged lipids: 1,2-dioleoyl- sn-glycero-3-phospho-l-serine (DOPS) and 2-((2,3-bis(oleoyloxy)propyl)dimethylammonio)ethyl hydrogen phosphate (DOCP) were used. Using calcein leakage assays, adsorption measurement, cryo-TEM, and washing, we concluded that charge is the dominating factor on SiO₂. The two neutral lipids form SLB on SiO₂ at pH 3 and 7, but the two negatively charged ones cannot form. On TiO₂, both charge and coordination chemistry are important. The two anionic lipids formed SLB from pH 3 to 10. DOCP had stronger affinity than DOPS likely due to the tighter terminal phosphate binding of the former. The two neutral liposomes formed SLB only at pH 3, where phosphate interaction and van der Waals force are deemed important. The pH 3 prepared TiO₂ DOPC SLBs are destabilized at neutral pH, indicating the reversible nature of the interaction. This work has provided new insights into two important materials interacting with common liposomes, which are important for reproducible biosensing, device fabrication, and drug delivery applications.

Effects of mono- and di-valent metal cations on the morphology of lipid vesicles

Lipid vesicles are an attractive model membrane experimental platform that is widely used in a biological context. The stability of vesicles can affect their performance and depends on various experimental conditions. How bio-related ions affect vesicle morphology is poorly understood in some cases. Herein, we investigated changes in vesicle morphology influenced by cation in the static and flowing environments. The effects of different mono- and di-valent metal cations on the morphology of lipid vesicles were systematically studied using the various techniques. The results showed that divalent cations caused significant aggregation or fusion of lipid vesicles, but monovalent cations had little effect on the vesicle morphology. Cation binding increased the net surface potential of vesicles, leading to changes in the zeta potential. The same qualitative kinetics were observed for cations that had the same valence at the same ionic strength. However, different types of cations gave different quantitative effects. The order of the ability to destroy the vesicle morphology was Cu²⁺ > Mg²⁺ > Ca²⁺ > Na⁺ > K⁺. These results are of practical value in the use of lipid vesicles as a bionic model, and help to shed light on the role of ions at membrane surfaces and interfaces.

Nanoarchitectonic-Based Material Platforms for Environmental and Bioprocessing Applications

The challenges of pollution, environmental science, and energy consumption have become global issues of broad societal importance. In order to address these challenges, novel functional systems and advanced materials are needed to achieve high efficiency, low emission, and environmentally friendly performance. A promising approach involves nanostructure-level controls of functional material design through a novel concept, nanoarchitectonics. In this account article, we summarize nanoarchitectonic approaches to create nanoscale platform structures that are potentially useful for environmentally green and bioprocessing applications. The introduced platforms are roughly classified into (i) membrane platforms and (ii) nanostructured platforms. The examples are discussed together with the relevant chemical processes, environmental sensing, bio-related interaction analyses, materials for environmental remediation, non-precious metal catalysts, and facile separation for biomedical uses.

Effects of phosphatidylserine-containing supported lipid bilayers on the polarization of macrophages

Placement of dental implants initiates inflammatory foreign body response, in which macrophages play a central role and affect the subsequent tissue healing process such as bone formation. The purpose of this study was to fabricate phosphatidylserine (PS)-containing supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) on a titanium surface to regulate the polarization of macrophages, a critical factor that affects following tissue healing and regeneration. The fluorescent recovery after photobleaching images showed that the percentage of PS had a critical influence on the fluidity, and 20% PS had the highest fluidity. Furthermore, more expanded and elongated cells were observed in the SLB-coated groups. transforming growth factor-β1 and vascular endothelial growth factor, the key cytokine markers of M2 macrophage polarization, were increased in the SLB-coated groups, especially in the 20% PS group. Consistently, cells cultured on the SLB-coated titanium exhibited the distribution of CD206⁺ , which is a M2 macrophage specific maker. The results of this study demonstrated M2 polarization of macrophages on PS-SLB-coated titanium discs, which suggests the application of PS-SLB as an immune-regulating coating material to improve tissue reactions to dental implants. © 2018 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Biomed Mater Res Part A: 106A: 2625-2633, 2018.

Adsorption and binding dynamics of graphene-supported phospholipid membranes using the QCM-D technique

We report on the adsorption dynamics of phospholipid membranes on graphene-coated substrates using the quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D) technique. We compare the lipid vesicle interaction and membrane formation on gold and silicon dioxide QCM crystal surfaces with their graphene oxide (GO) and reduced (r)GO coated counterparts, and report on the different lipid structures obtained. We establish graphene derivative coatings as support surfaces with tuneable hydrophobicity for the formation of controllable lipid structures. One structure of interest formed is lipid monolayer membranes which were formed on rGO, which are otherwise challenging to produce. We also demonstrate and monitor biotin-avidin binding on such a membrane, which will then serve as a platform for a wide range of biosensing applications. The QCM-D technique could be extended to both fundamental studies and applications of other covalent and non-covalent interactions in 2-dimensional materials.

Interfacial Forces Dictate the Pathway of Phospholipid Vesicle Adsorption onto Silicon Dioxide Surfaces

The pathway of vesicle adsorption onto a solid support depends on the material composition of the underlying support, and there is significant interest in developing material-independent strategies to modulate the spectrum of vesicle-substrate interactions on a particular surface. Herein, using the quartz crystal microbalance-dissipation (QCM-D) technique, we systematically investigated how solution pH and membrane surface charge affect vesicle adsorption onto a silicon dioxide surface. While vesicle adsorption and spontaneous rupture to form complete supported lipid bilayer (SLBs) occurred in acidic conditions, it was discovered that a wide range of adsorption pathways occurred in alkaline conditions, including (i) vesicle adsorption and spontaneous rupture to form complete SLBs, (ii) vesicle adsorption and spontaneous rupture to form incomplete SLBs, (iii) irreversible adsorption of intact vesicles, (iv) reversible adsorption of intact vesicles, and (v) negligible adsorption. In general, SLB formation became more favorable with increasingly positive membrane surface charge although there were certain conditions at which attractive electrostatic forces were insufficient to promote vesicle rupture. To rationalize these findings, we discuss how solution pH and membrane surface charge affect interfacial forces involved in vesicle-substrate interactions. Taken together, our findings present a comprehensive picture of how interfacial forces dictate the pathway of phospholipid vesicle adsorption onto silicon dioxide surfaces and offer a broadly applicable framework to characterize the interactions between phospholipid vesicles and inorganic material surfaces.

Surface Charge and Overlayer pH Influence the Dynamics of Supported Phospholipid Films

Understanding the thermodynamics and kinetics of interactions between model lipid bilayers and planar supports is of critical importance in the furtherance of biosensing and the creation of biomimetic devices. Evaluating these properties can be accomplished through understanding the diffusional properties of the bilayer constituents. In this report, the dynamics of a model DMPC bilayer supported on a phosphorylated silica surface are studied in the presence and absence of interfacial Ca²⁺ as a function of pH of the aqueous overlayer. The data for this system reveal the importance of the balance of ionic interactions between the interfacial species, and the dependence of the diffusional, kinetic and thermodynamic properties of the system on pH. The thermodynamic data suggest that interactions between the bilayer and surface are mediated enthalpically rather than entropically.

Effects of Flow and Bulk Vesicle Concentration on Supported Lipid Bilayer Formation

Supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) have been used extensively in a variety of biotechnology applications and fundamental studies exploring lipid behavior. Despite their widespread use, various physicochemical parameters have yet to be thoroughly investigated for their impact on SLB formation. In this work, we have studied the importance of flow in inducing the rupture of surface adsorbed chicken egg-derived l-α-phosphatidylcholine (egg PC) vesicles on silica and gold surfaces via quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D). On silica at 25 °C, egg PC vesicles were found to adsorb in a flattened configuration (∼13 nm thick, compared to bulk vesicle diameters of ∼165 nm) but only undergo a transition to a stable SLB under flow conditions. In the absence of flow, an increase in system temperature to 37 °C was able to promote vesicle rupture and SLB formation on silica with a 10 times lower rupture time, compared to rupture under continuous flow (175 μL/min flow rate). Gold surfaces, with their increased hydrophobicity, led to less vesicle flattening once adsorbed (structures ∼60 nm thick), and did not support vesicle rupture or SLB formation, even at flow rates of up to 650 μL/min. We also showed that, under continuous flow conditions, vesicle adsorption rates on silica surfaces follow Langmuir kinetics, with an inverse dependence on bulk vesicle concentration, while an empirical power law dependence of vesicle rupture time on bulk vesicle concentration was observed. Ultimately, this work elicits fundamental insight into the importance of flow and bulk vesicle concentration in the adsorbed vesicle rupture process during SLB formation using QCM-D.

Plasmonic nanodisc arrays on calcinated titania for multimodal analysis of phosphorylated peptides

A hybrid material of gold nanodiscs on a calcinated titania nanofilm that allows for selective quantitative and qualitative characterization of surface-enriched phosphopeptides has been designed and reported. Fabrication was realized through a combination of layer-by-layer deposition and high temperature calcination for the titania, and hole-mask colloidal lithography for the plasmonic nanostructures. The morphology of the resulting titania material was rigorously characterized, exhibiting substantially decreased surface roughness, which allows for lithographic fabrication of plasmonic nanostructures. Moreover, high specificity in adsorption and enrichment of phosphopeptides was exhibited, which was verified by LSPR shifts and matching peaks under mass spectrometric analysis. The construction of these biochips should inform other combinatorial nanofabrication techniques, in addition to allowing future phosphoproteomic analyses to be performed in a time and resource-efficient manner.

Hybrid nanomaterials of WS2 or MoS2 nanosheets with liposomes: biointerfaces and multiplexed drug delivery

Lipid containing hybrid materials are of significant interest for biointerface research and drug delivery applications, and a large number of previous studies have focused on graphene oxide (GO). In this work, novel hybrid materials made of transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDCs) and phosphocholine (DOPC) liposomes were prepared and compared with GO. All these inorganic materials are 2D nanosheets. DOPC liposomes are adsorbed by tungsten disulfide (WS₂) as intact liposomes as indicated by cryo-TEM and liposome leakage assays. WS₂ likely uses van der Waals forces for liposome adsorption as determined from urea, salt, and surfactant washing experiments. In addition, WS₂ adsorbed doxorubicin (DOX) and DOPC liposomes synergistically. The adsorption capacity of DOPC on bare WS₂ was 22.5% of the weight of WS₂. After adsorbing DOX on WS₂, the liposome adsorption capacity increased to ∼110%. Hydrogen bonding also contributed to liposome adsorption on DOX-loaded WS₂. Confocal fluorescence microscopy confirmed the uptake of the DOPC/WS₂ hybrid material by HeLa cells, and the co-delivery of DOX and calcein was achieved by loading calcein inside the liposomes. This study provides fundamental insights into the interaction between PC liposomes and WS₂. Furthermore, preliminary biomedical applications of this hybrid material were explored.

pH-dependent lipid vesicle interactions with plasma polymerized thin films

Model lipid vesicle and supported lipid bilayer (SLB) systems are used in a variety of applications including biosensing, cell membrane mimics, and drug delivery. Exposure of a surface to a vesicle solution provides a straightforward method for creating such systems via vesicle adsorption and collapse. However, this process is complex and the relationship between the surface physicochemical properties and vesicle collapse is poorly understood. Plasma polymers are thin conformal films that can be applied to a variety of materials to modify surface properties. This paper uses quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) to explore lipid vesicle interactions with plasma polymerized acrylic acid (ppAAc), allylamine (ppAAm), and ppAAc/ppAAm micropatterns. Vesicle interactions were dependent on plasma polymer chemistry and pH of the buffer solution. Vesicles readily and stably adsorbed to ppAAm over a wide pH range. ppAAc demonstrated limited interactions at pH 7 and vesicle adsorption at pH 4. Vesicle collapse and SLB formation could be induced using a pH change. FRAP was used to explore the fluidity of the lipid structures on both the patterned and unpatterned plasma polymer films. On ppAAm/ppAAc micropatterns, pH transitions combined with the presence of chemically distinct regions on the same substrate enabled immobile lipid islands on ppAAc to be surrounded by fluid lipid regions on ppAAm. This work demonstrates that plasma polymer films could enable spatially controlled vesicle adsorption and SLB formation on a wide variety of different substrates.

Analytical approaches to study domain formation in biomimetic membranes

Novel characterization methods open new horizons in the study of membrane mixtures.

Phosphatidyl-hydroxytyrosol and phosphatidyl-tyrosol bilayer properties

Hydroxytyrosol and tyrosol phospholipids were enzymatically synthesized and investigated for their bilayer properties. Dynamic light scattering demonstrated that hand extrusion at 100nm consistently resulted in liposomes of nearly 85nm diameter for both phosphatidyl-hydroxytyrosol (DOPHT) and phosphatidyl-tyrosol (DOPT). Transmission electron microscopy showed DOPT and DOPHT liposomes extruded at 100-nm to be spherical and non-distinctive from one another. Zeta potential measurements resulted in surface charges<-25mV, demonstrating both DOPT and DOPHT form highly stable liposomes. Quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring measurements demonstrated that liposomal adsorption was dependent on a combination of DOPT (or DOPHT) mole-percent and calcium ions concentration. Fluorescence anisotropy measurements indicated that melting temperatures of DOPT and DOPHT were below 4°C, suggesting that adsorption behavior and liposome formation was limited by electrostatic interactions and not gel-state formation.

Raman spectroscopy for detecting supported planar lipid bilayers composed of ganglioside-GM1/sphingomyelin/cholesterol in the presence of amyloid-β

The aggregation and fibril formation of amyloid β(Aβ) peptides onto a ganglioside-GM1-containing lipid membrane is a cause of neurodegenerative diseases. The mechanism of the initial binding and the conformational changes of Aβ on the membrane should be clarified. Fluorescence microscopy and Raman spectroscopy have been performed to investigate the supporting planar lipid bilayers (SPBs) composed of ganglioside-GM1, sphingomyelin and cholesterol. It is demonstrated that the SPBs are in a liquid-crystalline state when placed on mica, and increasing the amount of ganglioside-GM1 can decrease the lateral interaction between the acyl chains of the SPBs. It has been found that Aβ(1-40) initially interacts with the galactose ring of the ganglioside-GM1 head group, leading to its binding and gradual aggregation on the membrane surface. The obvious change observed in Raman spectroscopy in the ν(C-H) region confirms that the hydrophobic C-terminal of Aβ(1-40) inserts itself into the hydrophobic part of the SPBs. The Raman data indicate that α-helix and β-sheet structures of Aβ(1-40) increase and coexist over longer time frames. Based on these results, a model was proposed to describe the mechanism of the conformational changes and the aggregation of Aβ(1-40) that are mediated by ganglioside-GM1-containing SPBs.

Interfacing Zwitterionic Liposomes with Inorganic Nanomaterials: Surface Forces, Membrane Integrity, and Applications

Zwitterionic phosphocholine (PC) lipids are the main constituent of the mammalian cell membrane. PC bilayers are known for their antifouling properties, yet they are adsorbed by all tested inorganic nanoparticles. This feature article is focused on the developments in my laboratory in the past few years on this topic. The main experimental techniques include fluorescence-based liposome leakage assays, adsorption and desorption, and cryo-TEM. Different materials interact with PC liposomes differently. PC liposomes adsorb on SiO2, followed by membrane fusion with the surface forming supported lipid bilayers. TiO2 and other metal oxides adsorb only intact PC liposomes via lipid phosphate bonding; the steric effect from the choline group hinders subsequent liposome fusion onto the particles. Citrate-capped AuNPs are adsorbed very strongly via van der Waals forces, inducing local gelation. The result is transient liposome leakage upon AuNP adsorption or desorption and AuNP aggregation on the liposome surface. All carbon-based nanomaterials (graphene oxides, carbon nanotubes, and nanodiamond) are adsorbed mainly via hydrogen bonding. The oxidation level of graphene oxide strongly influences the outcome of the final hybrid material. In the context of inorganic nanoparticle adsorption, insights are given regarding the lack of protein adsorption by PC bilayers. These inorganic/lipid hybrid materials can be used for controlled release, drug delivery, and fundamental studies. A few examples of application are covered toward the end, and future perspectives are given.

Fabrication of charged membranes by the solvent-assisted lipid bilayer (SALB) formation method on SiO2 and Al2O3

In this study, we employed the solvent-assisted lipid bilayer (SALB) formation method to fabricate charged membranes on solid supports. The SALB formation method exploits a ternary mixture of lipid-alcohol-aqueous buffer to deposit lamellar phase structures on solid supports upon gradual increase of the buffer fraction. Using the quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation (QCM-D) technique, we investigated the formation of negatively and positively charged membranes via the SALB formation method and directly compared with the vesicle fusion method on two different oxide films. Bilayers containing an increasing fraction of negatively charged DOPS lipid molecules were successfully formed on both SiO2 and Al2O3 substrates using the SALB formation method at physiological pH (7.5). In contrast, the vesicle fusion method did not support bilayer formation on Al2O3 and those containing more than 10% DOPS ruptured on SiO2 only under acidic conditions (pH 5). Characterization of the fraction of negatively charge DOPS by in situ annexin 5A binding assay revealed that the fraction of DOPS lipid molecules in the bilayers formed on Al2O3 is significantly higher than that formed on SiO2. This suggests that the SALB self-assembly of charged membranes is predominantly governed by the electrostatic interaction. Furthermore, our findings indicate that when multicomponent lipid mixtures are used, the relative fraction of lipids in the bilayer may differ from the fraction of lipids in the precursor mixture.

A phenomenological model of the solvent-assisted lipid bilayer formation method

The mechanism of solvent-assisted lipid bilayer assembly at the solid–liquid interface is elucidated by matching an adsorption model to quartz crystal microbalance data.

Driving Adsorbed Gold Nanoparticle Assembly by Merging Lipid Gel/Fluid Interfaces

Surface forces between inorganic nanoparticles and lipid bilayer is of great relevance to biophysics, medicine, and nanobiotechnology. Adsorbed nanoparticles may influence the fluidity of the underlying lipids, which may in turn influence nanoparticle assembly. Herein three types of lipids (DOPC, Tc = -20 °C; DMPC, Tc = 23 °C; and DPPC, Tc = 41 °C) are used, all with the same phosphocholine (PC) headgroup. Gold nanoparticle (AuNP) color change is monitored as a function of lipid phase transition temperature (Tc), surface ligands on AuNPs, and temperature. Liposomes with higher fluidity induce much faster aggregation of AuNPs. Aside from the kinetic aspect of faster diffusion on fluid bilayers, this faster color change is attributed to the local lipid gelation and merging of gelled regions to eliminate the interface between different lipid phases.

A Stable Lipid/TiO2 Interface with Headgroup-Inversed Phosphocholine and a Comparison with SiO2

Zwitterionic phosphocholine (PC) lipids are highly biocompatible, representing a major component of the cell membrane. A simple mixing of PC liposomes and silica (SiO2) surface results in liposome fusion with the surface and formation of supported lipid bilayers. However, the stability of this bilayer is relatively low because adsorption is based mainly on weak van der Waals force. PC lipids strongly adsorb by TiO2 via chemical bonding with the lipid phosphate. The lack of fusion on TiO2 is attributable to the steric effect from the choline group in PC. In this study, inverse phosphocholine lipids (CP) are used, directly exposing the phosphate. Using a calcein leakage assay and cryo-TEM, fusion of CP liposome with TiO2 is demonstrated. The stability of this supported bilayer is significantly higher than that of the PC/SiO2 system, as indicated by washing the membrane under harsh conditions. Adsorption of CP liposomes by TiO2 is inhibited at high pH. Interestingly, the CP liposome cannot fuse with silica surface because of a strong charge repulsion. This study demonstrates an interesting interplay between a soft matter surface and metal oxides. By tuning the lipid structure, it is possible to rationally control the interaction force. This study provides an alternative system for forming stable supported bilayers on TiO2, and represents the first example of interfacing inverse lipids with inorganic surfaces.

New poly(amino acid methacrylate) brush supports the formation of well-defined lipid membranes

A novel poly(amino acid methacrylate) brush comprising zwitterionic cysteine groups (PCysMA) was utilized as a support for lipid bilayers. The polymer brush provides a 12-nm-thick cushion between the underlying hard support and the aqueous phase. At neutral pH, the zeta potential of the PCysMA brush was ∼-10 mV. Cationic vesicles containing >25% DOTAP were found to form a homogeneous lipid bilayer, as determined by a combination of surface analytical techniques. The lipid mobility as measured by FRAP (fluorescence recovery after photobleaching) gave diffusion coefficients of ∼1.5 μm(2) s(-1), which are comparable to those observed for lipid bilayers on glass substrates.

New poly(amino acid methacrylate) brush supports the formation of well-defined lipid membranes

A novel poly(amino acid methacrylate) brush comprising zwitterionic cysteine groups (PCysMA) was utilized as a support for lipid bilayers. The polymer brush provides a 12-nm-thick cushion between the underlying hard support and the aqueous phase. At neutral pH, the zeta potential of the PCysMA brush was ∼-10 mV. Cationic vesicles containing >25% DOTAP were found to form a homogeneous lipid bilayer, as determined by a combination of surface analytical techniques. The lipid mobility as measured by FRAP (fluorescence recovery after photobleaching) gave diffusion coefficients of ∼1.5 μm(2) s(-1), which are comparable to those observed for lipid bilayers on glass substrates.

Self-assembly formation of lipid bilayer coatings on bare aluminum oxide: overcoming the force of interfacial water

Widely used in catalysis and biosensing applications, aluminum oxide has become popular for surface functionalization with biological macromolecules, including lipid bilayer coatings. However, it is difficult to form supported lipid bilayers on aluminum oxide, and current methods require covalent surface modification, which masks the interfacial properties of aluminum oxide, and/or complex fabrication techniques with specific conditions. Herein, we addressed this issue by identifying simple and robust strategies to form fluidic lipid bilayers on aluminum oxide. The fabrication of a single lipid bilayer coating was achieved by two methods, vesicle fusion under acidic conditions and solvent-assisted lipid bilayer (SALB) formation under near-physiological pH conditions. Importantly, quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation (QCM-D) monitoring measurements determined that the hydration layer of a supported lipid bilayer on aluminum oxide is appreciably thicker than that of a bilayer on silicon oxide. Fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) analysis indicated that the diffusion coefficient of lateral lipid mobility was up to 3-fold greater on silicon oxide than on aluminum oxide. In spite of this hydrodynamic coupling, the diffusion coefficient on aluminum oxide, but not silicon oxide, was sensitive to the ionic strength condition. Extended-DLVO model calculations estimated the thermodynamics of lipid-substrate interactions on aluminum oxide and silicon oxide, and predict that the range of the repulsive hydration force is greater on aluminum oxide, which in turn leads to an increased equilibrium separation distance. Hence, while a strong hydration force likely contributes to the difficulty of bilayer fabrication on aluminum oxide, it also confers advantages by stabilizing lipid bilayers with thicker hydration layers due to confined interfacial water. Such knowledge provides the basis for improved surface functionalization strategies on aluminum oxide, underscoring the practical importance of surface hydration.

Liposome supported metal oxide nanoparticles: interaction mechanism, light controlled content release, and intracellular delivery

Zwitterionic phosphotydylcholine lipo-somes stably adsorb a number of metal oxide nanoparticles via its phosphate group. This is different from physisorption and fusion with SiO2. The hybrid materials can be internalized by cancer cells and TiO2 allows light controlled liposome content release.

Contribution of the hydration force to vesicle adhesion on titanium oxide

Titanium oxide is a biocompatible material that supports vesicle adhesion. Depending on experimental parameters, adsorbed vesicles remain intact or rupture spontaneously. Vesicle rupture has been attributed to electrostatic attraction between vesicles and titanium oxide, although the relative contribution of various interfacial forces remains to be clarified. Herein, we investigated the influence of vesicle surface charge on vesicle adsorption onto titanium oxide and observed that electrostatic attraction is insufficient for vesicle rupture. Following this line of evidence, a continuum model based on the DLVO forces and a non-DLVO hydration force was applied to investigate the role of different interfacial forces in modulating the lipid-substrate interaction. Within an experimentally significant range of conditions, the model shows that the magnitude of the repulsive hydration force strongly influences the behavior of adsorbed vesicles, thereby supporting that the hydration force makes a strong contribution to the fate of adsorbed vesicles on titanium oxide. The findings are consistent with literature reports concerning phospholipid assemblies on solid supports and nanoparticles and underscore the importance of the hydration force in influencing the behavior of phospholipid films on hydrophilic surfaces.

Label-free study of the function of ion channel protein on a microfluidic optical sensor integrated with artificial cell membrane

A label-free optical sensor was constructed by integrating pH sensing material and supported phospholipid bilayers (SPBs) in a microfluidic chip. The pH sensing material was composed of a double layer structure consisting of chitosan hydrogel and electrochemically etched porous silicon. The pH change in the microchip could induce a reversible swelling of the chitosan hydrogel layer and consequently caused a shift in effective optical thickness (EOT) of the double layer, which could be observed by Fourier transformed reflectometric interference spectroscopy (FT-RIS). After phospholipid bilayers (PLBs) were self-assembled on the sensing layer, the EOT almost remained constant during the cycling of pH from 7.4 to 6.2, indicating the blockage of H(+) translocation by the PLBs. For studying the behavior of ion channel protein, gramicidin A, a typical ion channel protein, was inserted in the SPBs for mimicking the ion transportation function of cell membrane. Due to the H(+) transportation capability of gramicidin A, the optical response to pH change could partially recover. In the presence of Ca(2+), the pore of the ion channel protein was blocked, causing a significant decrease in the EOT response upon pH change. The bio-functionalized microfluidic sensor fabricated in this work will provide a reliable platform for studying the function of ion channel protein, which is an important class of drug targets.

Nanoscale departures: excess lipid leaving the surface during supported lipid bilayer formation

The behavior of small liposomes on surfaces of inorganic oxides remains enigmatic. Under appropriate conditions it results in the formation of supported lipid bilayers (SLBs). During this process, some lipids leave the surface (desorb). We were able to visualize this by a combination of time-resolved fluorescence microscopy and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching studies. Our observations also allowed us to analyze the kinetics of bilayer patch growth during the late stages of SLB formation. We found that it entails a balance between desorption of excess lipids and further adsorption of liposomes from solution. These studies were performed with liposomes containing zwitterionic phospholipids (dioleoylphosphatidylcholine alone or a mixture of dioleoylphosphatidylcholine, dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine, and cholesterol) on TiO2 in the presence of Ca(2+) but in the absence of other salts.

Influence of osmotic pressure on adhesion of lipid vesicles to solid supports

The adhesion of lipid vesicles to solid supports represents an important step in the molecular self-assembly of model membrane platforms. A wide range of experimental parameters are involved in controlling this process, including substrate material and topology, lipid composition, vesicle size, solution pH, ionic strength, and osmotic pressure. At present, it is not well understood how the magnitude and direction of the osmotic pressure exerted on a vesicle influence the corresponding adsorption kinetics. In this work, using quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation (QCM-D) monitoring, we have experimentally studied the role of osmotic pressure in the adsorption of zwitterionic vesicles onto silicon oxide. The osmotic pressure was induced by changing the ionic strength of the solvent across an appreciably wider range (from 25 to 1000 mM NaCl outside of the vesicle, and 125 mM NaCl inside of the vesicle, unless otherwise noted) compared to that used in earlier works. Our key finding is demonstration that, by changing osmotic pressure, all three generic types of the kinetics of vesicle adsorption and rupture can be observed in one system, including (i) adsorption of intact vesicles, (ii) adsorption and rupture after reaching a critical vesicle coverage, and (iii) rupture just after adsorption. Furthermore, theoretical analysis of pressure-induced deformation of adsorbed vesicles and a DLVO-type analysis of the vesicle-substrate interaction qualitatively support our observations. Taken together, the findings in this work demonstrate that osmotic pressure can either promote or impede the rupture of adsorbed vesicles on silicon oxide, and offer experimental evidence to support adhesion energy-based models that describe the adsorption and spontaneous rupture of vesicles on solid supports.

Assembly of lipid bilayers on silica and modified silica colloids by reconstitution of dried lipid films

A method is presented for the assembly of lipid bilayers on silica colloids via reconstitution of dried lipid films solvent-cast from chloroform within packed beds of colloids ranging from 100 nm to 10 μm in diameter. Rapid solvent evaporation from the packed bed void volume results in uniform distribution of dried lipid throughout the colloidal bed. Fluorescence measurements indicate that significant, if not quantitative, retention of DOPC or DPPC films cast between sub-bilayer and multilayer quantities occurs when the colloids are redispersed in aqueous solution. Phospholipid bilayers assembled in this manner are shown to effectively passivate the surface of 250 nm colloids to nonspecific adsorption of bovine serum albumin. The method is shown to be capable of preparing supported bilayers on colloid surfaces that do not generally support vesicle fusion such as poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) modified silica colloids. Bilayers of lipids that have not been reported to self-assemble by vesicle fusion, including gel-phase lipids and single-chain diacetylene amphiphiles, can also be formed by this method. The utility of the solid-core support is demonstrated by the facile assembly of supported lipid bilayers within fused silica capillaries to generate materials that are potentially suitable for the analysis of membrane interactions in a microchannel format.

pH-driven assembly of various supported lipid platforms: a comparative study on silicon oxide and titanium oxide

Supported lipid platforms are versatile cell membrane mimics whose structural properties can be tailored to suit the application of interest. By identifying parameters that control the self-assembly of these platforms, there is potential to develop advanced biomimetic systems that overcome the surface specificity of lipid vesicle interactions under physiological conditions. In this work, we investigated the adsorption kinetics of vesicles onto silicon and titanium oxides as a function of pH. On each substrate, a planar bilayer and a layer of intact vesicles could be self-assembled in a pH-dependent manner, demonstrating the role of surface charge density in the self-assembly process. Under acidic pH conditions where both zwitterionic lipid vesicles and the oxide films possess near-neutral electric surface charges, vesicle rupture could occur, demonstrating that the process is driven by nonelectrostatic interactions. However, we observed that the initial rupturing process is insufficient for propagating bilayer formation. The role of electrostatic interactions for propagating bilayer formation differs for the two substrates; electrostatic attraction between vesicles and the substrate is necessary for complete bilayer formation on titanium oxide but is not necessary on silicon oxide. Conversely, in the high pH regime, repulsive electrostatic interactions can result in the irreversible adsorption of intact vesicles on silicon oxide and even a reversibly adsorbed vesicle layer on titanium oxide. Together, the results show that pH is an effective tool to modulate vesicle-substrate interactions in order to create various self-assembled lipid platforms on hydrophilic substrates.