Using flow to switch the valency of bacterial capture on engineered surfaces containing immobilized nanoparticles

Interplay of physico-chemical and mechanical bacteria-surface interactions with transport processes controls early biofilm growth: A review

Biofilms initiate when bacteria encounter and are retained on surfaces. The surface orchestrates biofilm growth through direct physico-chemical and mechanical interactions with different structures on bacterial cells and, in turn, through its influence on cell-cell interactions. Individual cells respond directly to a surface through mechanical or chemical means, initiating "surface sensing" pathways that regulate gene expression, for instance producing extra cellular matrix or altering phenotypes. The surface can also physically direct the evolving colony morphology as cells divide and grow. In either case, the physico-chemistry of the surface influences cells and cell communities through mechanisms that involve additional factors. For instance the numbers of cells arriving on a surface from solution relative to the generation of new cells by division depends on adhesion and transport kinetics, affecting early colony density and composition. Separately, the forces experienced by adhering cells depend on hydrodynamics, gravity, and the relative stiffnesses and viscoelasticity of the cells and substrate materials, affecting mechanosensing pathways. Physical chemistry and surface functionality, along with interfacial mechanics also influence cell-surface friction and control colony morphology, in particular 2D and 3D shape. This review focuses on the current understanding of the mechanisms in which physico-chemical interactions, deriving from surface functionality, impact individual cells and cell community behavior through their coupling with other interfacial processes.

Mechanical Properties and Concentrations of Poly(ethylene glycol) in Hydrogels and Brushes Direct the Surface Transport of Staphylococcus aureus

Surface-associated transport of flowing bacteria, including cell rolling, is a mechanism for otherwise immobile bacteria to migrate on surfaces and could be associated with biofilm formation or the spread of infection. This work demonstrates how the moduli and/or local polymer concentration play critical roles in sustaining contact, dynamic adhesion, and transport of bacterial cells along a hydrogel or hydrated brush surface. In particular, stiffer more concentrated hydrogels and brushes maintained the greatest dynamic contact, still allowing cells to travel along the surface in flow. This study addressed how the mechanical properties, molecular architectures, and thicknesses of minimally adhesive poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG)-based coatings influence the flow-driven surface motion of Staphylococcus aureus MS2 cells. Three protein-repellant PEG-dimethylacrylate hydrogel films (∼100 μm thick) and two protein-repellant PEG brushes (8-16 nm thick) were sufficiently fouling-resistant to prevent the accumulation of flowing bacteria. However, the rolling or hopping-like motions of gently flowing S. aureus cells along the surfaces were specific to the particular hydrogel or brush, distinguishing these coatings in terms of their mechanical properties (with moduli from 2 to 1300 kPa) or local PEG concentrations (in the range 10-50% PEG). On the stiffer hydrogel coatings having higher PEG concentrations, S. aureus exhibited long runs of surface rolling, 20-50 μm in length, an increased tendency of cells to repeatedly return to some surfaces after rolling and escaping, and relatively long integrated contact times. By contrast, on the softer more dilute hydrogels, bacteria tended to encounter the surface for brief periods before escaping without return. The dynamic adhesion and motion signatures of the cells on the two brushes were bracketed by those on the soft and stiff hydrogels, demonstrating that PEG coating thickness was not important in these studies where the vertically oriented surfaces minimized the impact of gravitational forces. Control studies with similarly sized poly(ethylene oxide)-coated rigid spherical microparticles, that also did not arrest on the PEG coatings, established that the bacterial skipping and rolling signatures were specific to the S. aureus cells and not simply diffusive. Dynamic adhesion of the S. aureus cells on the PEG hydrogel surfaces correlated well with quiescent 24 h adhesion studies in the literature, despite the orientation of the flow studies that eliminated the influence of gravity on bacteria-coating normal forces.

Easy come easy go: surfaces containing immobilized nanoparticles or isolated polycation chains facilitate removal of captured Staphylococcus aureus by retarding bacterial bond maturation

Adhesion of bacteria is a key step in the functioning of antimicrobial surfaces or certain types of on-line sensors. The subsequent removal of these bacteria, within a ∼ 10-30 min time frame, is equally important but complicated by the tendency of bacterial adhesion to strengthen within minutes of initial capture. This study uses Staphylococcus aureus as a model bacterium to demonstrate the general strategy of clustering adhesive surface functionality (at length scales smaller than the bacteria themselves) on otherwise nonadhesive surfaces to capture and retain bacteria (easy come) while limiting the progressive strengthening of adhesion. The loose attachment facilitates bacteria removal by moderate shearing flow (easy go). This strategy is demonstrated using surfaces containing sparsely and randomly arranged immobilized amine-functionalized nanoparticles or poly-l-lysine chains, about 10 nm in size. The rest of the surface is backfilled with a nonadhesive polyethylene glycol (PEG) brush that, by itself, repels S. aureus. The nanoparticles or polymer chains cluster cationic functionality, providing small regions that attract negatively charged S. aureus cells. Compared with surfaces of nearly uniform cationic character where S. aureus adhesion quickly becomes strong (on a time scale less than 5 min), placement of cationic charge in small clusters retards or prevents processes that increase bacteria adhesion on a time scale of ∼ 30 min, providing "easy go" surfaces.

How Bacteria Adhere to Brushy PEG Surfaces: Clinging to Flaws and Compressing the Brush

This study examined the compression of solvated polymer brushes on bioengineered surfaces during the initial stages of Staphylococcus Aureus (S. aureus) adhesion from gentle flow. A series of PEG [poly(ethylene glycol)] brushes, 7 to 17 nm in height and completely non-adhesive to proteins and bacteria, were modified by the incorporation of sparse isolated ~10 nm cationic polymer "patches" at their bases. These nanoscale regions, which lacked PEG tethers, were electrostatically attractive towards negative bacteria or proteins. S. aureus drawn to the interface by multiple adhesive patches compressed the PEG brush in the remaining contact region. The observed onset of bacterial or fibrinogen capture with increases in patch content was compared with calculations. Balancing the attraction energy (proportional to the number of patches engaging a bacterium during capture) against steric forces (calculated using the Alexander-DeGennes treatment) provided perspective on the brush compression. The results were consistent with a bacteria-surface gap on the order of the Debye length in these studies. In this limit of strong brush compression, structural features (height, persistence length) of the brush were unimportant so that osmotic pressure dominated the steric repulsion. Thus, the dominant factor for bacterial repulsion was the mass of PEG in the brush. This result explains empirical reports in the literature that identify the total PEG content of a brush as a criteria for prevention of bioadhesion, independent of tether length and spacing, within a reasonable range for those parameters. Bacterial capture was also compared to that of protein capture. It was found, surprisingly, that the patchy brushes were more protein-than bacteria-resistant. S. aureus adhesion driven by patches within otherwise protein-resistant PEG brushes was explained by the bacteria's greater tendency to compress large areas of brush to interact with many patches. By contrast, proteins are thought to penetrate the brush at a few sites of PEO-free patches. The finding provides a mechanism for the literature reports that in-vitro protein resistance is a poor predictor of in-vitro implant failure related to cell-surface adhesion.