Effect of counterions on the shape, hydration, and degree of order at the interface of cationic micelles: the triflate case

FAIR and scalable management of small-angle X-ray scattering data

A modular and extensible research data management toolbox based on the programming language Python and the widely used computing platform Jupyter Notebook has been established for the acquisition, visualization, analysis and storage of small-angle X-ray scattering data.

A modular research data management toolbox based on the programming language Python, the widely used computing platform Jupyter Notebook, the standardized data exchange format for analytical data (AnIML) and the generic repository Dataverse has been established and applied to analyze small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) data according to the FAIR data principles (findable, accessible, interoperable and reusable). The SAS-tools library is a community-driven effort to develop tools for data acquisition, analysis, visualization and publishing of SAXS data. Metadata from the experiment and the results of data analysis are stored as an AnIML document using the novel Python-native pyAnIML API. The AnIML document, measured raw data and plots resulting from the analysis are combined into an archive in OMEX format and uploaded to Dataverse using the novel easyDataverse API, which makes each data set accessible via a unique DOI and searchable via a structured metadata block. SAS-tools is applied to study the effects of alkyl chain length and counterions on the phase diagrams of alkyltrimethyl­ammonium surfactants in order to demonstrate the feasibility and usefulness of a scalable data management workflow for experiments in physical chemistry.

Interaction of a bovine serum albumin (BSA) protein with mixed anionic-cationic surfactants and the resultant structure

The interaction of a bovine serum albumin (BSA) protein with the mixture of anionic sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and cationic dodecyltrimethylammonium bromide (DTAB) has been investigated by small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) and dynamic light scattering (DLS). Both SDS and DTAB as individuals interact electrostatically as well as hydrophobically with BSA and form connected protein-decorated micelle like complexes in the aqueous solution, in which the well-defined surfactant micelles are organized along the randomly distributed unfolded polypeptide chain of the protein. The protein-surfactant interaction has been tuned by adding different molar mixtures of SDS and DTAB in BSA aqueous solution. It is found that a lower molar fraction of either surfactant in the protein-mixed surfactant complexes results in the formation of a connected protein-decorated micelle structure similar to those of pure surfactants. As the molar fraction of one of the surfactants in the mixture approaches the equimolar fraction, the structure formed by the protein-mixed surfactant is very different from the connected protein-decorated micelle like structure. Different microstructures of BSA-mixed surfactant complexes are formed, mostly governed by the structure of mixed surfactants arising from the strong electrostatic interaction of oppositely charged components. In this case, unfolded proteins wrap the structures of mixed surfactants around their surface. Along with the connected protein-decorated micelle like structure, rod-like and bilayer vesicles of protein-surfactant complexes are formed at different molar fractions of mixed surfactants.

Dehydration Determines Hydrotropic Ion Affinity for Zwitterionic Micelles

Specific ion effects in zwitterionic micelles, especially for anions, are evident in reaction kinetics, zeta potential, and critical micelle concentration measurements. However, anion adsorption to zwitterionic micelles does not produce significant changes in shape, aggregation number, or interfacial hydration. Here we used molecular dynamics simulation of systems containing sulfobetaine zwitterionic micelles of N-dodecyl-N,N-dimethyl-3-ammonio-1-propanesulfonate (DPS) and nine different salts to explore ion adsorption in terms of group dehydration. Our results, in line with those obtained for cationic micelles, showed that the adsorption degree of anions containing both hydrophobic and hydrophilic portions, i.e., hydrotropes, were correlated with the ion dehydration and were governed mainly by the hydrophobic portion dehydration upon adsorption.

Insight into the Hydration of Cationic Surfactants: A Thermodynamic and Dielectric Study of Functionalized Quaternary Ammonium Chlorides

Hydrophobic interactions are one of the main thermodynamic driving forces in self-assembly, folding, and association processes. To understand the dehydration-driven solvent exposure of hydrophobic surfaces, the micellization of functionalized decyldimethylammonium chlorides, XC₁₀Me₂N⁺Cl^-, with a polar functional group, X = C₂OH, C₂OMe, C₂OC₂OMe, C₂OOEt, together with the "reference" compound decyltrimethylammonium chloride, C₁₀Me₃N⁺Cl^-, was investigated in aqueous solution by density measurements, isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC), and dielectric relaxation spectroscopy (DRS). From the density data, the apparent molar volumes of monomers and micelles were estimated, whereas the ITC data were analyzed with the help of a model equation, yielding the thermodynamic parameters and aggregation number. From the DRS spectra, effective hydration numbers of the free monomers and micelles were deduced. The comprehensive analysis of the obtained results shows that the thermodynamics of micellization are strongly affected by the nature of the functional group. Surprisingly, the hydration of micelles formed by surfactant cations with a single alkyl chain on quaternary ammonium is approximately the same, regardless of the alkyl chain length or functionalization of the headgroup. However, notable differences were found for the free monomers where increasing polarity lowers the effective hydration number.

Ultra-small and recyclable zero-valent iron nanoclusters for rapid and highly efficient catalytic reduction of p-nitrophenol in water

The synthesis of nanoscale zero-valent iron (NZVI) nanoclusters with dimensions ranging from 20 to 100 nm for the control of environmental pollutants has received substantial attention. However, due to the strong van der Waals and magnetic attraction forces of ZVI, synthesizing ZVI nanoclusters with a subnanometre size while retaining their surface activity and avoiding aggregation is challenging. Moreover, NZVI particles can be oxidized easily after the removal of contaminants even in anoxic environments, which makes the recovery and recycling of the particles very difficult. Here, for the first time, ultra-small zero-valent iron (ZVI) nanoclusters are successfully prepared in a micelle assisted method under mild conditions, and can be recycled simply. It is found that by encapsulating Fe3+ within the micelles, controlling the release of sulfur ions (S2-) from thiourea and forming the FeS nanoparticles as intermediates, the ZVI nanoclusters are produced with a precisely controlled size (<1 nm). A large number of zero-valent iron nanoclusters were assembled into quasi-spherical assemblages (with around 5 nm size), in which most of the nanoclusters exist discretely because of being coated by entangled hydrocarbon chains of the surfactant. The ZVI nanoclusters (with a diameter of <1 nm) exhibit excellent dispersibility and accessibility in solution, presenting significantly enhanced catalytic activity in the removal of p-nitrophenol from water. The as-prepared ZVI nanoclusters possess excellent stability and durability with the aid of NaBH4. Their catalytic activity/reusability can be comparable to those of the commonly used noble metal catalysts.

Specific Ion Effects on Zwitterionic Micelles Are Independent of Interfacial Hydration Changes

Zwitterionic micelles adsorb anions and several techniques were used to determine the specificity of this interaction. Although at a lower intensity, this adsorption can be compared to those observed in cationic micelles, which showed that interfacial dehydration is a fundamental property for the geometry and size of micelles. Because there is no information on the interfacial hydration of zwitterionic micelles, we used dielectric relaxation spectroscopy (DRS) together with molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to evaluate the importance of surface dehydration promoted by the binding of anions at the micellar interface (sodium bromide, sodium methanesulfonate, sodium trifluoroacetate, and sodium triflate) in N-dodecyl- N, N-dimethyl-3-ammonio-1-propanesulfonate (DPS) micelles. Our results, showing good agreement between DRS and MD simulations, strongly suggest that specific ion effects on zwitterionic micelles are unrelated to global changes in the interfacial hydration and depend on specific interactions of the headgroups with selected anions.

Ion dehydration controls adsorption at the micellar interface: hydrotropic ions

The properties of ionic micelles depend on the nature of the counterion, and these effects become more evident as the ion adsorption at the interface increases. Prediction of the relative extent of ion adsorption is required for rational design of ionic micellar aggregates. Unlike the well understood adsorption of monatomic ions, the adsorption of polyatomic ions is not easily predicted. We combined experimental and computational methods to evaluate the affinity of hydrotropic ions, i.e., ions with polar and apolar regions, to the surface of positively charged micelles. We analyzed cationic micelles of dodecyltrimethylammonium and six hydrotropic counterions: methanesulfonate, trifluoromethanesulfonate, benzenesulfonate, acetate, trifluoroacetate and benzoate. Our results demonstrated that the apolar region of hydrotropic ions had the largest influence on micellar properties. The dehydration of the apolar region of hydrotropic ions upon their adsorption at the micellar interface determined the ion adsorption extension, differently to what was expected based on Collins' law of matching affinities. These results may lead to more general models to describe the adsorption of ions, including polyatomic ions, at the micellar interface.

Counting ions and other nucleophiles at surfaces by chemical trapping

The interfaces of membranes and other aggregates are determined by the polarity, electrical charge, molecular volume, degrees of motional freedom and packing density of the head groups of the amphiphiles. These properties also determine the type of bound ion (ion selectivity) and its local density, i.e. concentration defined by choosing an appropriate volume element at the aggregate interface. Bulk and local ion concentrations can differ by orders of magnitude. The relationships between ion (or other compound) concentrations in the bulk solvent and in the interface are complex but, in some cases, well established. As the local ion concentration, rather than that in the bulk, controls a variety of properties of membranes, micelles, vesicles and other objects of theoretical and applied interests, measurement of local (interfacial, bound) ion concentrations is of relevance for understanding and characterizing such aggregates. Many experimental methods for estimating ion distributions between the bulk solution and the interface provide indirect estimates because they are based on concentration-dependent properties, rather than concentration measurements. Dediazoniation, i.e. the loss of N2, of a substituted diazophenyl derivative provides a tool for determining the number of nucleophiles (including neutral or negatively charged ions) surrounding the diazophenyl derivative prior to the dediazoniation event. This reaction, defined as chemical trapping, and the appropriate reference points obtained in bulk solution allow direct measurements of local concentrations of a variety of nucleophiles at the surface of membranes and other aggregates. Here we review our contributions of our research group to the use, and understanding, of this method and applications of chemical trapping to the description of local concentrations of ions and other nucleophiles in micelles, reverse micelles, vesicles and solvent mixtures. Among other results, we have shown that interfacial water determines micellar shape, zwitterionic vesicle-forming amphiphiles display ion selectivity and urea does not accumulate at micellar interfaces. We have also shown that reaction products can be predicted from the composition of the initial state, even in non-ideal solvent mixtures, supporting the usefulness of chemical trapping as a method to determine local concentrations. In addition, we have analysed the mechanism of dediazoniation, both on theoretical and experimental basis, and concluded that the formation of a free phenyl cation is not a necessary part of the reaction pathway.

Hydration and Counterion Binding of [C12MIM] Micelles

Surface-active ionic liquids based on imidazolium cations are promising targets for micellar catalysis in aqueous solution, yielding enhanced rate constants compared to surfactants based on n-alkyltrimethylammonium cations and exhibiting a pronounced counterion dependence ( Bica Chem. Commun. 2012 , 48 , 5013 - 5015 ; Cognigni Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2016 , 18 , 13375 - 13384 ). Probably most relevant to these effects is the interplay between headgroup hydration and counterion binding. To obtain more detailed information on these effects, aqueous solutions of 1-dodecyl-3-methylimidazolium ([C₁₂MIM]) bromide, iodide, and triflate (TfO^-) were investigated at 45 °C using broadband dielectric spectroscopy, viscosity measurements, and small-angle X-ray scattering experiments. Effective hydration numbers were determined, and information on the locations and mobilities of the condensed counterions, X^-, was derived. It was found that [C₁₂MIM] halide micelles were less hydrated than the corresponding n-dodecyltrimethylammonium ([C₁₂TA]X) aggregates. Together with their somewhat weaker counterion condensation, this difference probably explains their higher catalytic activity. Whereas [C₁₂MIM]Br micelles remained roughly spherical in the studied concentration range, rodlike aggregates were formed at high concentrations of the iodide and, in particular, the triflate surfactants. It appears that the much lower mobility of condensed TfO^- counterions is the reason for the very low catalytic activity of [C₁₂MIM]TfO micelles.

Some physicochemical aspects of water-soluble mineral flotation

Some physicochemical aspects of water-soluble mineral flotation including hydration phenomena, associations and interactions between collectors, air bubbles, and water-soluble mineral particles are presented. Flotation carried out in saturated salt solutions, and a wide range of collector concentrations for effective flotation of different salts are two basic aspects of water-soluble mineral flotation. Hydration of salt ions, mineral particle surfaces, collector molecules or ions, and collector aggregates play an important role in water-soluble mineral flotation. The adsorption of collectors onto bubble surfaces is suggested to be the precondition for the association of mineral particles with bubbles. The association of collectors with water-soluble minerals is a complicated process, which may include the adsorption of collector molecules or ions onto such surfaces, and/or the attachment of collector precipitates or crystals onto the mineral surfaces. The interactions between the collectors and the minerals include electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions, hydrogen bonding, and specific interactions, with electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions being the common mechanisms. For the association of ionic collectors with minerals with an opposite charge, electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions could have a synergistic effect, with the hydrophobic interactions between the hydrophobic groups of the previously associated collectors and the hydrophobic groups of oncoming collectors being an important attractive force. Association between solid particles and air bubbles is the key to froth flotation, which is affected by hydrophobicity of the mineral particle surfaces, surface charges of mineral particles and bubbles, mineral particle size and shape, temperature, bubble size, etc. The use of a collector together with a frother and the use of mixed surfactants as collectors are suggested to improve flotation.

Sodium triflate decreases interaggregate repulsion and induces phase separation in cationic micelles

Dodecyltrimethylammonium triflate (DTATf) micelles possess lower degree of counterion dissociation (α), lower hydration, and higher packing of monomers than other micelles of similar structure. Addition of sodium triflate ([NaTf] > 0.05 M) to DTATf solutions promotes phase separation. This phenomenon is commonly observed in oppositely charged surfactant mixtures, but it is rare for ionic surfactants and relatively simple counterions. While the properties of DTATf have already been reported, the driving forces for the observed phase separation with added salt remain unclear. Thus, we propose an interpretation for the observed phase separation in cationic surfactant solutions. Addition of up to 0.03 M NaTf to micellar DTATf solutions led to a limited increase of the aggregation number, to interface dehydration, and to a progressive decrease in α. The viscosity of DTATf solutions of higher concentration ([DTATf] ≥ 0.06 M) reached a maximum with increasing [NaTf], though the aggregation number slightly increased, and no shape change occurred. We hypothesize that this maximum results from a decrease in interaggregate repulsion, as a consequence of increased ion binding. This reduction in micellar repulsion without simultaneous infinite micellar growth is, probably, the major driving force for phase separation at higher [NaTf].

Simultaneous synthesis and assembly of noble metal nanoclusters with variable micellar templates

Simultaneous synthesis and assembly of Au, Pt, and Pd nanoclusters (NCs; with sizes ≤3 nm) into mesoscale structures with defined boundaries are achieved using their metal halides, cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB), and thiourea (Tu). Geometric shape, hierarchical organization, and packing density of resultant assemblages vary depending on metal precursors and CTAB concentration. For example, rod- or tube-like assemblages are formed from Au NCs, giant vesicles and/or dandelion-like assemblages from Pt NCs, and rhombic/hexagonal platelet assemblages from PdS NCs and Pd NCs. These assemblages inherit pristine shapes from their respective variable micelles of CTA(+)-metal halide complexes. Owing to dynamical nature, the assembled NCs demonstrate various structural reforming behaviors. The metal halides, which serve as counterions of positively charged surfactant heads, screen the electrostatic repulsion among the surfactant molecules as well as the micelles, providing the driving force for the formation of soft templates. Meanwhile, the formation of NCs can be addressed from the perspective of nucleation and growth kinetics. The unique protecting role of surface sulfur, controlled release of S(2-) from Tu, and formation of NCs of metal sulfides as intermediates together lead to a relatively low rate-ratio of growth to nucleation and thus limit the size of product NCs. Our preliminary study also indicates that the assembled noble metal NCs have high catalytic activity and recyclability. In this regard, the present approach not only provides a facile means to construct NC-based metal catalysts but serves also as a simple way to visualize interaction and evolution of micelles of CTA(+)-metal halide complexes.

Modeling of the effects of ion specificity on the onset and growth of ionic micelles in a solution of simple salts

A new version of the molecular thermodynamic model has been developed that takes into account the effect of ion specificity on the free energy of aggregation. The specificity of salt is reflected by differences in the bare ionic sizes and polarizabilities leading to the difference in the dispersion interaction of ions with the aggregate. The model also contains parameters that characterize the compactness of ionic pairs formed between a mobile ion and surfactant's headgroup. The values of these parameters show that more chaotropic heads form tighter pairs with chaotropic ions whereas more cosmotropic heads form more compact pairs with cosmotropic ions. The formation of compact pairs in the micelle corona diminishes the preferable curvature of the aggregates and promotes their growth. The model has been applied to aqueous solutions of cationic (alkyltrimethylammonium, alkyldimethylammonium, and alkylpyridinium) and anionic (alkylsulfate and alkylcarboxylate) surfactants in the presence of simple 1:1 salts. With a single set of parameter values, the model reproduces the critical micelle concentration-salinity curves and the sphere-to-rod transitions or the absence of thereof and describes the aggregate growth for different simple salts, in good agreement with experiment.

Molecular dynamics shows that ion pairing and counterion anchoring control the properties of triflate micelles: a comparison with triflate at the air/water interface

Micellar properties of dodecyltrimethylammonium triflate (DTA-triflate, DTATf) are very different from those of DTA-bromide (DTAB). DTATf aggregates show high aggregation numbers (Nagg), low degree of counterion dissociation (α), disk-like shape, high packing, ordering, and low hydration. These micellar properties and the low surface tension of NaTf aqueous solutions point to a high affinity of Tf(-) to the micellar and air/water interfaces. Although the micellar properties of DTATf are well defined, the source of the Tf(-) effect upon the DTA aggregates is unclear. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of Tf(-) (and Br(-)) at the air/water interface and as counterion of a DTA aggregate were performed to clarify the nature of Tf(-) preferences for these interfaces. The effect of NaTf or NaBr on surface tension calculated from MD simulations agreed with the reported experimental values. From the MD simulations a high affinity of Tf(-) toward the interface, which occurred in a specific orientation, was calculated. The micellar properties calculated from the MD simulations for DTATf and DTAB were consistent with experimental data: in MD simulations, the DTATf aggregate was more ordered, packed, and dehydrated than the DTAB aggregate. The Tf(-)/alkyltrimethylammonium interaction energies, calculated from the MD simulations, suggested ion pair formation at the micellar interface, stabilized by the preferential orientation of the adsorbed Tf(-) at the micellar interface.

Dielectric relaxation spectroscopy shows a sparingly hydrated interface and low counterion mobility in triflate micelles

The properties of ionic micelles are affected by the nature of the counterion. Specific ion effects can be dramatic, inducing even shape and phase changes in micellar solutions, transitions apparently related to micellar hydration and counterion binding at the micellar interface. Thus, determining the hydration and dynamics of ions in micellar systems capable of undergoing such transitions is a crucial step in understanding shape and phase changes. For cationic micelles, such transitions are common with large organic anions as counterions. Interestingly, however, phase separation also occurs for dodecyltrimethylammonium triflate (DTATf) micelles in the presence of sodium triflate (NaTf). Specific ion effects for micellar solutions of dodecyltrimethylammonium chloride (DTAC), bromide (DTAB), methanesulfonate (DTAMs), and triflate (DTATf) were studied with dielectric relaxation spectroscopy (DRS), a technique capable of monitoring hydration and counterion dynamics of micellar aggregates. In comparison to DTAB, DTAC, and DTAMs, DTATf micelles were found to be considerably less hydrated and showed reduced counterion mobility at the micellar interface. The obtained DTATf and DTAMs data support the reported central role of the anion's -CF3 moiety with respect to the properties of DTATf micelles. The reduced hydration observed for DTATf micelles was rationalized in terms of the higher packing of this surfactant compared to that of other DTA-based systems. The decreased mobility of Tf(-) anions condensed at the DTATf interface strongly suggests the insertion of Tf(-) in the micellar interface, which is apparently driven by the strong hydrophobicity of -CF3.