A New Technique for Characterizing Comonomer Distribution in Polyolefins: High-Temperature Thermal Gradient Interaction Chromatography (HT-TGIC)

Use graphene coated silica core shell particles to provide rapid, precise, and equivalent chemical composition distribution analysis for polyolefin materials by high temperature thermal gradient interaction chromatography

High temperature thermal gradient interaction chromatography (HT-TGIC) has been widely used to measure chemical composition distribution due to its applicability to separate crystalline and non-crystalline amorphous polyolefin materials. The compatibility of HT-TGIC with various detectors (infrared (IR), light scattering (LS), and viscometer) has also allowed a comprehensive analysis of molecular architecture of polyolefin and recycled plastics. The introduction of an easy-to-fabricate graphene coated onto non-porous silica particles as HT-TGIC column in 2020 showed a superior chromatographic performance over the traditional graphite column. A reduction in peak broadness (∼47 %) under identical experimental conditions was demonstrated in that research. This paper similarly uses a graphene column but with the focus on optimization of experimental parameters (concentration, and thermal cooling and heating rates etc.). Equivalent chemical composition distribution (CCD) data to that obtained by the incumbent graphite column over a wide range of polyolefins products was achieved, in addition to a shortened analysis time from 120 min down to 88 min per sample. The materials studied included semicrystalline linear low-density polyethylene (LLDPE), elastomers, terpolymers, model blends to mimic recycled plastics. The results also suggest that the elimination of substrate pores enable a better HT-TGIC separation. Coupling the ease and reproducibility of the graphene column fabrication process enables long term chromatographic robustness. This not only results in equivalent CCD data compared to the traditional graphite column but also a 27 % reduction in analysis time. These results demonstrate a substantial advancement of technology in the high throughput industrial laboratory setting where fast testing turnaround time is critical. In addition, simple fabrication with commercially available silica particles and graphene nanopowder provides a cost-effective approach to make HT-TGIC columns reproducibly.

Influence of Microstructure on the Elution Behavior of Gradient Copolymers in Different Modes of Liquid Interaction Chromatography

We studied the influence of microstructure on the chromatographic behavior of gradient copolymers with different gradient strengths and block copolymer with completely segregated blocks by using gradient liquid adsorption chromatography (gLAC) and liquid chromatography at critical conditions (LCCC) for one of the copolymer constituents. The copolymers consist of repeating units of poly(propylene oxide) and poly(propylene phthalate) and have comparable average chemical composition and molar mass, and a narrow molar mass distribution to avoid as much as possible the influence of these parameters on the elution behavior of the copolymers. On both reversed stationary phases, the elution volume of gradient copolymers increases with the increasing strength of the gradient. The results indicate that for both modes of liquid interaction chromatography, it is important to consider the effect of microstructure on the elution behavior of the gradient copolymers in addition to the copolymer chemical composition and molar mass in the case of gLAC and the length of the chromatographically visible copolymer constituent in the case of LCCC.

Improving temperature gradient interaction chromatography of polyolefins by simultaneous use of different stationary phases

Temperature gradient interaction chromatography (TGIC) at high temperatures is a powerful method for the chemical composition separation of polyolefins. TGIC is a two-step process where the sample is crystallized on the stationary phase at low temperature followed by the elution of the sample components using a temperature gradient towards high temperatures. For TGIC typically a porous graphitic carbon (PGC) stationary phase is used. The separation mechanism is based on crystallization and adsorption/desorption phenomena and it has been shown that co-crystallization and co-adsorption may affect the separation. The present study reports on the simultaneous use of a non-adsorptive and an adsorptive stationary phase (column) in series to utilize both crystallization and adsorption for improved separation in TGIC. A silica column is used as the non-adsorptive support to allow for the crystallization of the polyolefin sample in the absence of an adsorptive force followed by the typical PGC column for adsorption/desorption. Accordingly, the loci of crystallization and adsorption/desorption are well separated from each other and can be adjusted independently. This novel column setup allows the sample to be introduced slowly onto the second (adsorptive) column eliminating possible co-adsorption and poor selectivity. Low molar mass polyethylene comprising of oligomers with approximately C₃₀C₁₃₀ was used to illustrate the importance of a non-adsorptive column for improved separation. Utilizing a non-adsorptive silica column allows for higher dynamic flow rates during crystallization, which improves separation. Shorter adsorptive columns are found to be more efficient in this experimental protocol as compared to standard TGIC experiments. Smaller PGC column sizes result in reduced longitudinal and Eddy diffusion and, hence, higher resolution of low and high molar mass polyolefins.

Temperature Gradient Interaction Chromatography: A Perspective

The application of temperature gradient interaction chromatography (TGIC) as an advanced technique for the characterisation of polymers is discussed, in comparison to other liquid chromatography techniques and in particular the ubiquitous size exclusion chromatography. Specifically, the use of reversed-phase TGIC for the interrogation of complex branched polymers and normal-phase TGIC for characterisation of high-molar mass end-functionalised polymers is highlighted.

Polyolefin Analyses with a 10 mm Multinuclear NMR Cryoprobe

Polyolefins are important and broadly used materials. Their molecular microstructures have direct impact on macroscopic properties and dictate end-use applications. ¹³C NMR is a powerful analytical technique used to characterize polyolefin microstructures, such as long-chain branching (LCB), but it suffers from low sensitivity. Although the ¹³C sensitivity of polyolefin samples can be increased by about 5.5 times with a cryoprobe, when compared with a conventional broadband observe (BBO) probe, further sensitivity enhancement is in high demand for studying increasingly complex polyolefin microstructures. Toward this goal, distortionless enhancement by polarization transfer (DEPT) and refocused insensitive nuclei enhanced by polarization transfer (RINEPT) are explored. The use of hard, regular, and new short adiabatic 180° ¹³C pulses in DEPT and RINEPT is investigated. It is found that RINEPTs perform better than DEPTs and a sensitivity enhancement of 3.1 can be achieved with RINEPTs. The results of RINEPTs are further analyzed with statistics software JMP and recommendations for optimal usage of RINEPTs are suggested. An example of analyzing saturated chain ends in an ethylene-octene copolymer sample with a hard 180° ¹³C RINEPT pulse is demonstrated. It is shown that the experimental time can be further reduced in half because of faster proton relaxation, where the total experimental time is about 580 times shorter when compared to using a conventional method and a 10 mm BBO probe. A naturally abundant nitrogen-containing polyolefin is analyzed using ¹H-¹⁵N HMBC and, to our knowledge, is the first ¹H-¹⁵N HMBC presented in the field of polyolefin characterization. The relative amount of similar nitrogen-containing structures is quantified by two-dimensional integration of ¹H-¹⁵N HMBC. Two pragmatic technical challenges related to using high-sensitivity NMR cryoprobes are also addressed: (1) A new ¹H decoupling sequence Bi_Waltz_65_256pl is proposed to address decoupling artifacts in ¹³C{¹H} NMR spectra which contain a strong ¹³C signal with a high signal-to-noise ratio (S/N). (2) A simple pulse sequence that affords zero-slope spectral baselines and quantitative results is presented to address acoustic ringing that is often associated with high-sensitivity cryoprobe use.

Analyses of Short Chain Branches in Polyolefins with Improved 1H NMR Spectroscopy

Polyolefin microstructures, for example, short chain branching (SCB) and short chain branch distribution (SCBD), have a direct impact on properties and thus ultimately influence end-use applications. The ¹H NMR approach to analyze SCB and SCBD is particularly useful when only a limited amount of sample is available, for example, polyolefin film layers or the fractions from polyolefin separation techniques, such as gel permeation chromatography (GPC), crystallization elution fractionation (CEF), high temperature liquid chromatography (HTLC), and thermal gradient interaction chromatography (TGIC). In this paper, we discuss the best approach to find a good decoupling frequency and propose an improved ¹H pulse sequence with homonuclear decoupling for better measuring SCB. With this new pulse it is possible to reach a S/N of 10 (level of quantification) for the methyl signal from SCB in an ethylene-hexene copolymer (EH, 3.6 mol % H) in 3.5 min with 0.5 μg of sample. We also show an easy method to calculate SCB/1000C and demonstrate the proper use of heteronuclear single quantum coherence (HSQC) to measure SCB in a complicated system. A very quick approach to examine the presence of a small amount of LDPE in a polyolefin sample is also suggested, which can reduce NMR acquisition time from a couple of days to a few minutes.

Improving chromatographic separation of polyolefins on porous graphitic carbon stationary phases: effects of adsorption promoting solvent and column length

The chromatographic separation of complex polyolefins on porous graphitic carbon stationary phases is strongly influenced by the composition of the mobile phase. Of particular interest is the effect of the chemical structure of the adsorption promoting solvent as this component of the mobile phase determines the adsorption–desorption behavior of the polyolefin molecules. In a systematic study, alkyl alcohols and linear alkanes are used as adsorption promoting solvents and the effect of the molecules' carbon chain length on chromatographic resolution is investigated. As representative examples, solvent gradient interaction chromatography experiments on polypropylene stereoisomers and ethylene-co-1-octene copolymers are presented. In a further study, the effect of increasing chromatographic column length on the solvent gradient separation of ethylene-co-1-octene copolymers is investigated. In summary, it is shown that the polypropylene stereoisomers are retained in 1-octanol as well as in n-decane and n-dodecane, allowing for identification of the individual stereoisomers in complex blends. For ethylene-co-1-octene copolymers it is shown that separation improves with increasing carbon chain length of the adsorption promoting solvent. Maximum resolution is obtained when a column length of 300 mm is used with 1-dodecanol as the adsorption promoting solvent.

The chromatographic separation of complex polyolefins on porous graphitic carbon stationary phases is strongly influenced by the composition of the mobile phase.

Method development in interaction polymer chromatography

Interaction polymer chromatography (IPC) is an umbrella term covering a large variety of primarily enthalpically-dominated macromolecular separation methods. These include temperature-gradient interaction chromatography, interactive gradient polymer elution chromatography (GPEC), barrier methods, etc. Also included are methods such as liquid chromatography at the critical conditions and GPEC in traditional precipitation-redissolution mode. IPC techniques are employed to determine the chemical composition distribution of copolymers, to separate multicomponent polymeric samples according to their chemical constituents, to determine the tacticity and end-group distribution of polymers, and to determine the chemical composition and molar mass distributions of select blocks in block copolymers. These are all properties which greatly affect the processing and end-use behavior of macromolecules. While extremely powerful, IPC methods are rarely employed outside academic and select industrial laboratories. This is generally because most published methods are "bespoke" ones, applicable only to the particular polymer being examined; as such, potential practitioners are faced with a lack of inductive information regarding how to develop IPC separations in non-empirical fashion. The aim of the present review is to distill from the literature and the author's experience the necessary fundamental macromolecular and chromatographic information so that those interested in doing so may develop IPC methods for their particular analytes of interest, regardless of what these analytes may be, with as little trial-and-error as possible. While much remains to be determined in this area, especially, for most techniques, as regards the role of temperature and how to fine-tune this critical parameter, and while a need for IPC columns designed specifically for large-molecule separations remains apparent, it is hoped that the present review will help place IPC methods in the hands of a more general, yet simultaneously more applied audience.

Comprehensive Analysis of Oxidized Waxes by Solvent and Thermal Gradient Interaction Chromatography and Two-Dimensional Liquid Chromatography

This report addresses the comprehensive analysis of oxidized/functionalized polyethylene waxes according to chemical composition and molar mass by selective chromatographic methods. For the first time, tailored high-temperature interaction chromatography in solvent gradient (HT-SGIC) and thermal gradient (HT-TGIC) modes are used for the chemical composition separation of these materials. Separation protocols are developed using three model wax samples with different degrees of oxidation. For the chromatographic separations polar silica gel is used as the stationary phase. Solvent gradients of decane and cyclohexanone are used in HT-SGIC at 110 °C to separate the bulk waxes into several heterogeneous fractions according to polarity and the type of functionality. Column temperature and gradient manipulation are shown to influence chromatographic resolution and retention. The HT-SGIC investigations are complemented by HT-TGIC separations where a solvent mixture of decane and cyclohexanone is used as the mobile phase in isocratic mode. It is shown that HT-SGIC and HT-TGIC provide different types of separation, however, both are predominantly based on differences in functionality. To provide comprehensive information on chemical composition (functionality) and molar mass, HT-SGIC and HT-TGIC are coupled to HT-SEC, using ortho-dichlorobenzene as the second dimension mobile phase. Clear differences between oxidized and nonoxidized waxes are detected in HT-2D-LC providing comprehensive information on the molecular heterogeneity of these materials.

Separation of Branched Poly(bisphenol A carbonate) Structures by Solvent Gradient at Near-Critical Conditions and Two-Dimensional Liquid Chromatography

Branching is a molecular metric that strongly influences the application properties of polymers. Consequently, detailed information on the microstructure is required to gain a deeper understanding of structure-property relationships. In the present case, we employ high-performance liquid chromatography to characterize the branching in a poly(bisphenol A carbonate) (PC). To this end, a method was developed based on a mobile phase gradient in a very narrow range (±1.4 vol %) around the point of adsorption (98.9/1.1 vol % chloroform/methyl tert-butyl ether), which we refer to as solvent gradient at near-critical conditions. Application of such gentle gradient enabled separation of PC according to end-groups. The separation mechanism was confirmed by collecting fractions of a separated sample and subsequently analyzing these by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry. Hyphenating the developed gradient method with size-exclusion chromatography as the second dimension (2D-LC) enabled separation of linear and branched PC chains and determination of the molar mass distribution of the fractions. A reversed elution order was observed for branched species in 2D-LC, meaning that low molar mass chains exhibited higher elution volumes in the first dimension than higher molar masses. This finding was explained by influences of end-groups as well as the architecture of the branched polymer chains.