Translocation of RecA-coated double-stranded DNA through solid-state nanopores

Improving the Performance of Selective Solid-State Nanopore Sensing Using a Polyhistidine-Tagged Monovalent Streptavidin

Solid-state (SS-) nanopore sensing has gained tremendous attention in recent years, but it has been constrained by its intrinsic lack of selectivity. To address this, we previously established a novel SS-nanopore assay that produces translocation signals only when a target biotinylated nucleic acid fragment binds to monovalent streptavidin (MS), a protein variant with a single high-affinity biotin-binding domain. While this approach has enabled selective quantification of diverse nucleic acid biomarkers, sensitivity enhancements are needed to improve the detection of low-abundance translational targets. Because the translocation dynamics that determine assay efficacy are largely governed by constituent charge characteristics, we here incorporate a polyhistidine-tagged MS (hMS) to alter the component detectability. We investigate the effects of buffer pH, salt concentration, and SS-nanopore diameter on the performance with the alternate reagent, achieve significant improvements in measurement sensitivity and selectivity, and expand the range of device dimensions viable for the assay. We used this improvement to detect as little as 1 nM miRNA spiked into human plasma. Overall, our findings improve the potential for broader applications of SS-nanopores in the quantitative analyses of molecular biomarkers.

Aggregation and Oligomerization Characterization of ß-Lactoglobulin Protein Using a Solid-State Nanopore Sensor

Protein aggregation is linked to many chronic and devastating neurodegenerative human diseases and is strongly associated with aging. This work demonstrates that protein aggregation and oligomerization can be evaluated by a solid-state nanopore method at the single molecule level. A silicon nitride nanopore sensor was used to characterize both the amyloidogenic and native-state oligomerization of a model protein ß-lactoglobulin variant A (βLGa). The findings from the nanopore measurements are validated against atomic force microscopy (AFM) and dynamic light scattering (DLS) data, comparing βLGa aggregation from the same samples at various stages. By calibrating with linear and circular dsDNA, this study estimates the amyloid fibrils' length and diameter, the quantity of the βLGa aggregates, and their distribution. The nanopore results align with the DLS and AFM data and offer additional insight at the level of individual protein molecular assemblies. As a further demonstration of the nanopore technique, βLGa self-association and aggregation at pH 4.6 as a function of temperature were measured at high (2 M KCl) and low (0.1 M KCl) ionic strength. This research highlights the advantages and limitations of using solid-state nanopore methods for analyzing protein aggregation.

High-Voltage Biomolecular Sensing Using a Bacteriophage Portal Protein Covalently Immobilized within a Solid-State Nanopore

The application of nanopores as label-free, single-molecule biosensors for electrical or optical probing of structural features in biomolecules has been widely explored. While biological nanopores (membrane proteins and bacteriophage portal proteins) and solid-state nanopores (thin films and two-dimensional materials) have been extensively employed, the third class of nanopores known as hybrid nanopores, where an artificial membrane substitutes the organic support membrane of proteins, has been only sparsely studied due to challenges in implementation. G20c portal protein contains a natural DNA pore that is used by viruses for filling their capsid with viral genomic DNA. We have previously developed a lipid-free hybrid nanopore by "corking" the G20c portal protein into a SiN_x nanopore. Herein, we demonstrate that through chemical functionalization of the synthetic nanopore, covalent linkage between the solid-state pore and the G20c portal protein considerably improves the hybrid pore stability, lifetime, and voltage resilience. Moreover, we demonstrate electric-field-driven and motor protein-mediated transport of DNA molecules through this hybrid nanopore. Our integrated protein/solid-state device can serve as a robust and durable framework for sensing and sequencing at high voltages, potentially providing higher resolution, higher signal-to-noise ratio, and higher throughput compared to the more conventional membrane-embedded protein platforms.

Application of nanopore sensors for biomolecular interactions and drug discovery

Biomolecular interactions, including protein-protein, protein-nucleic acid, and protein/nucleic acid-ligand interactions, play crucial roles in various cellular signaling and biological processes, and offer attractive therapeutic targets in numerous human diseases. Currently, drug discovery is limited by the low efficiency and high cost of conventional ensemble-averaging-based techniques for biomolecular interaction analysis and high-throughput drug screening. Nanopores are an emerging technology for single-molecule sensing of biomolecules. Owing to the robust advantages of single-molecule sensing, nanopore sensors have contributed tremendously to nucleic acid sequencing and disease diagnostics. In this minireview, we summarize the recent developments and outlooks in single-molecule sensing of various biomolecular interactions for drug discovery applications using biological and solid-state nanopore sensors.

A Critical Review on the Sensing, Control, and Manipulation of Single Molecules on Optofluidic Devices

Single-molecule techniques have shifted the paradigm of biological measurements from ensemble measurements to probing individual molecules and propelled a rapid revolution in related fields. Compared to ensemble measurements of biomolecules, single-molecule techniques provide a breadth of information with a high spatial and temporal resolution at the molecular level. Usually, optical and electrical methods are two commonly employed methods for probing single molecules, and some platforms even offer the integration of these two methods such as optofluidics. The recent spark in technological advancement and the tremendous leap in fabrication techniques, microfluidics, and integrated optofluidics are paving the way toward low cost, chip-scale, portable, and point-of-care diagnostic and single-molecule analysis tools. This review provides the fundamentals and overview of commonly employed single-molecule methods including optical methods, electrical methods, force-based methods, combinatorial integrated methods, etc. In most single-molecule experiments, the ability to manipulate and exercise precise control over individual molecules plays a vital role, which sometimes defines the capabilities and limits of the operation. This review discusses different manipulation techniques including sorting and trapping individual particles. An insight into the control of single molecules is provided that mainly discusses the recent development of electrical control over single molecules. Overall, this review is designed to provide the fundamentals and recent advancements in different single-molecule techniques and their applications, with a special focus on the detection, manipulation, and control of single molecules on chip-scale devices.

Tailoring Thermoplastic In-Plane Nanopore Size by Thermal Fusion Bonding for the Analysis of Single Molecules

We report a simple method for tailoring the size of in-plane nanopores fabricated in thermoplastics for single-molecule sensing. The in-plane pores were fabricated via nanoimprint lithography (NIL) from resin stamps, which were generated from Si masters. We could reduce the size of the in-plane nanopores from 30 to ∼10 nm during the thermal fusion bonding (TFB) step, which places a cover plate over the imprinted polymer substrate under a controlled pressure and temperature to form the relevant nanofluidic devices. Increased pressures during TFB caused the cross-sectional area of the in-plane pore to be reduced. The in-plane nanopores prepared with different TFB pressures were utilized to detect single-λ-DNA molecules via resistive pulse sensing, which showed a higher current amplitude in devices bonded at higher pressures. Using this method, we also show the ability to tune the pore size to detect single-stranded (ss) RNA molecules and single ribonucleotide adenosine monophosphate (rAMP). However, due to the small size of the pores required for detection of the ssRNA and rAMPs, the surface charge arising from carboxylate groups generated during O2 plasma oxidation of the surfaces of the nanopores to make them wettable had to be reduced to allow translocation of coions. This was accomplished using EDC/NHS coupling chemistry and ethanolamine. This simple modification chemistry increased the event frequency from ∼1 s-1 to >136 s-1 for an ssRNA concentration of 100 nM.

Recent advances in integrated solid-state nanopore sensors

The advent of single-molecule probing techniques has revolutionized the biomedical and life science fields and has spurred the development of a new class of labs-on-chip based on powerful biosensors. Nanopores represent one of the most recent and most promising single molecule sensing paradigms that is seeing increased chip-scale integration for improved convenience and performance. Due to their physical structure, nanopores are highly sensitive, require low sample volume, and offer label-free, amplification-free, high-throughput real-time detection and identification of biomolecules. Over the last 25 years, nanopores have been extensively employed to detect a variety of biomolecules with a growing range of applicatons ranging from nucleic acid sequencing to ultrasensitive diagnostics to single-molecule biophysics. Nanopores, in particular those in solid-state membranes, also have the potential for integration with other technologies such as optics, plasmonics, microfluidics, and optofluidics to perform more complex tasks for an ever-expanding demand. A number of breakthrough results using integrated nanopore platforms have already been reported, and more can be expected as nanopores remain the focus of innovative research and are finding their way into commercial instruments. This review provides an overview of different aspects and challenges of nanopore technology with a focus on chip-scale integration of solid-state nanopores for biosensing and bioanalytical applications.

Nanopore Technology for the Application of Protein Detection

Protein is an important component of all the cells and tissues of the human body and is the material basis of life. Its content, sequence, and spatial structure have a great impact on proteomics and human biology. It can reflect the important information of normal or pathophysiological processes and promote the development of new diagnoses and treatment methods. However, the current techniques of proteomics for protein analysis are limited by chemical modifications, large sample sizes, or cumbersome operations. Solving this problem requires overcoming huge challenges. Nanopore single molecule detection technology overcomes this shortcoming. As a new sensing technology, it has the advantages of no labeling, high sensitivity, fast detection speed, real-time monitoring, and simple operation. It is widely used in gene sequencing, detection of peptides and proteins, markers and microorganisms, and other biomolecules and metal ions. Therefore, based on the advantages of novel nanopore single-molecule detection technology, its application to protein sequence detection and structure recognition has also been proposed and developed. In this paper, the application of nanopore single-molecule detection technology in protein detection in recent years is reviewed, and its development prospect is investigated.

Nanodiagnostics: A review of the medical capabilities of nanopores

Modern diagnostics strive to be accurate, fast, and inexpensive in addition to properly identifying the presence of a disease, infection, or illness. Early diagnosis is key; catching a disease in its early stages can be the difference between fatality and treatment. The challenge with many diseases is that detectability of the disease scales with disease progression. Since single molecule sensors, e.g., nanopores, can sense biomolecules at low concentrations, they have the potential to become clinically relevant in many of today's medical settings. With nanopore-based sensing, lower volumes and concentrations are required for detection, enabling it to be clinically beneficial. Other advantages to using nanopores include that they are tunable to an enormous variety of molecules and boast low costs, and fabrication is scalable for manufacturing. We discuss previous reports and the potential for incorporating nanopores into the medical field for early diagnostics, therapeutic monitoring, and identifying relapse/recurrence.

Slowing down DNA translocation through solid-state nanopores by edge-field leakage

Solid-state nanopores allow high-throughput single-molecule detection but identifying and even registering all translocating small molecules remain key challenges due to their high translocation speeds. We show here the same electric field that drives the molecules into the pore can be redirected to selectively pin and delay their transport. A thin high-permittivity dielectric coating on bullet-shaped polymer nanopores permits electric field leakage at the pore tip to produce a voltage-dependent surface field on the entry side that can reversibly edge-pin molecules. This mechanism renders molecular entry an activated process with sensitive exponential dependence on the bias voltage and molecular rigidity. This sensitivity allows us to selectively prolong the translocation time of short single-stranded DNA molecules by up to 5 orders of magnitude, to as long as minutes, allowing discrimination against their double-stranded duplexes with 97% confidence.

Sequence-Specific Recognition of HIV-1 DNA with Solid-State CRISPR-Cas12a-Assisted Nanopores (SCAN)

Nucleic acid detection methods are crucial for many fields such as pathogen detection and genotyping. Solid-state nanopore sensors represent a promising platform for nucleic acid detection due to its unique single molecule sensitivity and label-free electronic sensing. Here, we demonstrated the use of the glass nanopore for highly sensitive quantification of single-stranded circular DNAs (reporters), which could be degraded under the trans-cleavage activity of the target-specific CRISPR-Cas12a. We developed and optimized the Cas12a assay for HIV-1 analysis. We validated the concept of the solid-state CRISPR-Cas12a-assisted nanopores (SCAN) to specifically detect the HIV-1 DNAs. We showed that the glass nanopore sensor is effective in monitoring the cleavage activity of the target DNA-activated Cas12a. We developed a model to predict the total experimental time needed for making a statistically confident positive/negative call in a qualitative test. The SCAN concept combines the much-needed specificity and sensitivity into a single platform, and we anticipate that the SCAN would provide a compact, rapid, and low-cost method for nucleic acid detection at the point of care.

Durable, Stable, and Functional Nanopores Decorated by Self-Assembled Dipeptides

Nanopores have become an important tool for the detection and analysis of molecules at the single-molecule level. Surface modification of solid-state nanopores can improve their durability and efficiency. Peptides are ideal for surface modifications as they allow tailoring of multiple properties by a rational design of their sequence. Here, silicon nitride nanopores were coated by a dipeptide layer where a l-3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine (DOPA) residue is the anchoring element and the other amino acid moiety is the functional element. DOPA binds tightly to many types of surfaces and allows a one-step functionalization of surfaces by simple immersion. As a result, the lifetime of coated nanopores increased from hours to months and the current-stability has significantly improved with respect to uncoated pores. This improvement is achieved by controlling the surface wettability and charge. Peptide-coated nanopores can be utilized as sensitive sensors that can be adjusted based on the choice of the functional moiety of the coated peptide. In addition, the coating slows down dsDNA translocation because of the DNA interaction with the pore coating.

Quantitative Analysis of Factors Affecting the Event Rate in Glass Nanopore Sensors

While the solid-state nanopore sensors have shown exceptional promise with their single-molecule sensitivity and label-free operations, one of the most significant challenges in the nanopore sensor is the limited analyte translocation event rate that leads to prolonged sensor response time. This issue is more pronounced when the analyte concentration is below the nanomolar (nM) range, owing to the diffusion-limited mass transport. In this work, we systematically studied the experimental factors beyond the intrinsic analyte concentration and electrophoretic mobility that affect the event rate in glass nanopore sensors. We developed a quantitative model to capture the impact of nanopore surface charge density, ionic strength, nanopore geometry, and translocation direction on the event rate. The synergistic effects of these factors on the event rates were investigated with the aim to find the optimized experimental conditions for operating the glass nanopore sensor from the response time standpoint. The findings in the study would provide useful and practical insight to enhance the device response time and achieve a lower detection limit for various glass nanopore-sensing experiments.

Multiplexed DNA Identification Using Site Specific dCas9 Barcodes and Nanopore Sensing

Decorating double-stranded DNA with dCas9 barcodes to identify characteristic short sequences provides an alternative to fully sequencing DNA samples for rapid and highly specific analysis of a DNA sample. Solid state nanopore sensors are especially promising for this type of single-molecule sensing because of the ability to analyze patterns in the ionic current signatures of DNA molecules. Here, we systematically demonstrate the use of highly specific dCas9 probes to create unique barcodes on the DNA that can be read out using nanopore sensors. Single dCas9 probes are targeted to various positions on DNA strands up to 48 kbp long and are effectively measured in high salt conditions typical of nanopore sensing. Multiple probes bound to the same DNA strand at characteristic target sequences create distinct barcodes of double and triple peaks. Finally, double and triple barcodes are used to simultaneously identify two different DNA targets in a background mixture of bacterial DNA. Our method forms the basis of a fast and versatile assay for multiplexed DNA sensing applications in complex samples.

Single-Molecule Analysis with Solid-State Nanopores

Solid-state nanopores and nanopipettes are an exciting class of single-molecule sensors that has grown enormously over the last two decades. They offer a platform for testing fundamental concepts of stochasticity and transport at the nanoscale, for studying single-molecule biophysics and, increasingly, also for new analytical applications and in biomedical sensing. This review covers some fundamental aspects underpinning sensor operation and transport and, at the same time, it aims to put these into context as an analytical technique. It highlights new and recent developments and discusses some of the challenges lying ahead.

Differentiation of selectively labeled peptides using solid-state nanopores

Determination of the amino acid sequence of a protein is critical for understanding various biological processes. Mass spectrometry has mainly been used for protein identification; however, there are limitations to its sensitivity when detecting low abundance proteins. In this study, we attempted to distinguish between three similar peptide sequences (∼40 amino acids, ∼5 kDa) that differed only by the location or number of cysteine residues with solid-state nanopores. The cysteine residues are located at one end, one at the center, and at both ends for each of the three peptides. We found that differentiation of the three types of peptides by nanopore signals was difficult. However, when the cysteine residue was labeled with a negatively charged molecule, Flamma® 496, the labeled peptides showed distinct signals for each peptide. Comparing the relative current blockades of labeled peptides with applied voltages, we found that the label was able to change peptide conformations and the resulting ionic current signals from the three labeled peptides were distinguished based on the relative current blockade, full width at half-maximum of the current blockade distribution, and single-molecule level peak shape analysis. Our results suggest that solid-state nanopores combined with a targeted labeling strategy could be used to obtain characteristic peptide signatures that could ultimately be used for protein identification.

Estimating RNA Polymerase Protein Binding Sites on λ DNA Using Solid-State Nanopores

In this work, using a silicon nitride nanopore based device, we measure the binding locations of RNA Polymerase (RNAP) on 48.5 kbp (16.5 μm) long λ DNA. To prevent the separation of bound RNAPs from a λ DNA molecule in the high electric field inside a nanopore, we cross-linked RNAP proteins to λ DNA by formaldehyde. We compare the current blockage event data measured with a mixture of λ DNA and RNAP under cross-link conditions with our control samples: RNAP, λ DNA, RNAP, and λ DNA incubated in formaldehyde separately and in a mixture. By analyzing the time durations and amplitudes of current blockage signals of events and their subevents, as well as subevent starting times, we can estimate the binding efficiency and locations of RNAPs on a λ DNA. Our data analysis shows that under the conditions of our experiment with the ratio of 6 to 1 for RNAP to λ DNA molecules, the probability of an RNAP molecule to bind a λ DNA is ∼42%, and that RNAP binding has a main peak at 3.51 μm ± 0.53 μm, most likely corresponding to the two strong promoter regions at 3.48 and 4.43 μm of λ DNA. However, individual RNAP binding sites were not distinguished with this nanopore setup. This work brings out new perspectives and complications to study transcription factor RNAP binding at various positions on very long DNA molecules.

Recent Progress in Solid-State Nanopores

The solid-state nanopore has attracted much attention as a next-generation DNA sequencing tool or a single-molecule biosensor platform with its high sensitivity of biomolecule detection. The platform has advantages of processability, robustness of the device, and flexibility in the nanopore dimensions as compared with the protein nanopore, but with the limitation of insufficient spatial and temporal resolution to be utilized in DNA sequencing. Here, the fundamental principles of the solid-state nanopore are summarized to illustrate the novelty of the device, and improvements in the performance of the platform in terms of device fabrication are explained. The efforts to reduce the electrical noise of solid-state nanopore devices, and thus to enhance the sensitivity of detection, are presented along with detailed descriptions of the noise properties of the solid-state nanopore. Applications of 2D materials including graphene, h-BN, and MoS₂ as a nanopore membrane to enhance the spatial resolution of nanopore detection, and organic coatings on the nanopore membranes for the addition of chemical functionality to the nanopore are summarized. Finally, the recently reported applications of the solid-state nanopore are categorized and described according to the target biomolecules: DNA-bound proteins, modified DNA structures, proteins, and protein oligomers.

The Utility of Nanopore Technology for Protein and Peptide Sensing

Resistive pulse nanopore sensing enables label-free single-molecule analysis of a wide range of analytes. An increasing number of studies have demonstrated the feasibility and usefulness of nanopore sensing for protein and peptide characterization. Nanopores offer the potential to study a variety of protein-related phenomena that includes unfolding kinetics, differences in unfolding pathways, protein structure stability, and free-energy profiles of DNA-protein and RNA-protein binding. In addition to providing a tool for fundamental protein characterization, nanopores have also been used as highly selective protein detectors in various solution mixtures and conditions. This review highlights these and other developments in the area of nanopore-based protein and peptide detection.

Determining the Physical Properties of Molecules with Nanometer-Scale Pores

Nanometer-scale pores have been developed for the detection, characterization, and quantification of a wide range of analytes (e.g., ions, polymers, proteins, anthrax toxins, neurotransmitters, and synthetic nanoparticles) and for DNA sequencing. We describe the key requirements that made this method possible and how the technique evolved. Finally, we show that, despite sound theoretical work, which advanced both the conceptual framework and quantitative capability of the method, there are still unresolved questions that need to be addressed to further improve the technique.

Single molecule multiplexed nanopore protein screening in human serum using aptamer modified DNA carriers

The capability to screen a range of proteins at the single-molecule level with enhanced selectivity in biological fluids has been in part a driving force in developing future diagnostic and therapeutic strategies. The combination of nanopore sensing and nucleic acid aptamer recognition comes close to this ideal due to the ease of multiplexing, without the need for expensive labelling methods or extensive sample pre-treatment. Here, we demonstrate a fully flexible, scalable and low-cost detection platform to sense multiple protein targets simultaneously by grafting specific sequences along the backbone of a double-stranded DNA carrier. Protein bound to the aptamer produces unique ionic current signatures which facilitates accurate target recognition. This powerful approach allows us to differentiate individual protein sizes via characteristic changes in the sub-peak current. Furthermore, we show that by using DNA carriers it is possible to perform single-molecule screening in human serum at ultra-low protein concentrations.

It is still a challenge for current nanopore sensing methods to differentiate multiple analytes from complex biological material. Here, the authors graft nucleic acid aptamer sequences along the backbone of a double stranded DNA carrier for the detection of multiple protein targets in human serum.

Solid-State Nanopore Analysis of Diverse DNA Base Modifications Using a Modular Enzymatic Labeling Process

Many regulated epigenetic elements and base lesions found in genomic DNA can both directly impact gene expression and play a role in disease processes. However, due to their noncanonical nature, they are challenging to assess with conventional technologies. Here, we present a new approach for the targeted detection of diverse modified bases in DNA. We first use enzymatic components of the DNA base excision repair pathway to install an individual affinity label at each location of a selected modified base with high yield. We then probe the resulting material with a solid-state nanopore assay capable of discriminating labeled DNA from unlabeled DNA. The technique features exceptional modularity via selection of targeting enzymes, which we establish through the detection of four DNA base elements: uracil, 8-oxoguanine, T:G mismatch, and the methyladenine analog 1,N⁶-ethenoadenine. Our results demonstrate the potential for a quantitative nanopore assessment of a broad range of base modifications.

Nanopore-Based Measurements of Protein Size, Fluctuations, and Conformational Changes

Proteins are structurally dynamic macromolecules, and it is challenging to quantify the conformational properties of their native state in solution. Nanopores can be efficient tools to study proteins in a solution environment. In this method, an electric field induces electrophoretic and/or electro-osmotic transport of protein molecules through a nanopore slightly larger than the protein molecule. High-bandwidth ion current measurement is used to detect the transit of each protein molecule. First, our measurements reveal a correlation between the mean current blockade amplitude and the radius of gyration for each protein. Next, we find a correlation between the shape of the current signal amplitude distributions and the protein fluctuation as obtained from molecular dynamics simulations. Further, the magnitude of the structural fluctuations, as probed by experiments and simulations, correlates with the ratio of α-helix to β-sheet content. We highlight the resolution of our measurements by resolving two states of calmodulin, a canonical protein that undergoes a conformational change in response to calcium binding.

Label-Free, Multiplexed, Single-Molecule Analysis of Protein-DNA Complexes with Nanopores

Protein interactions with specific DNA sequences are crucial in the control of gene expression and the regulation of replication. Single-molecule methods offer excellent capabilities to unravel the mechanism and kinetics of these interactions. Here, we develop a nanopore approach where a target DNA sequence is contained in a hairpin followed by a ssDNA. This system allows DNA-protein complexes to be distinguished from bare DNA molecules as they are pulled through a single nanopore detector, providing both equilibrium and kinetic information. We show that this approach can be used to test the inhibitory effect of small molecules on complex formation and their mechanisms of action. In a proof of concept, we use DNAs with different sequence patterns to probe the ability of the nanopore to distinguish the effects of an inhibitor in a complex mixture of target DNAs and proteins. We anticipate that the use of this technology with arrays of thousands of nanopores will contribute to the development of transcription factor binding inhibitors.

Single-Molecule Characterization of DNA-Protein Interactions Using Nanopore Biosensors

Detection and characterization of nucleic acid-protein interactions, particularly those involving DNA and proteins such as transcription factors, enzymes, and DNA packaging proteins, remain significant barriers to our understanding of genetic regulation. Nanopores are an extremely sensitive and versatile sensing platform for label-free detection of single biomolecules. Analyte molecules are drawn to and through a nanoscale aperture by an electrophoretic force, which acts upon their native charge while in the sensing region of the pore. When the nanopore's diameter is only slightly larger than the biopolymer's cross section (typically a few nm); the latter must translocate through the pore in a linear fashion due to the constricted geometry in this region. These features allow nanopores to interrogate protein-nucleic acids in multiple sensing modes: first, by scanning and mapping the locations of binding sites along an analyte molecule, and second, by probing the strength of the bond between a protein and nucleic acid, using the native charge of the nucleic acid to apply an electrophoretic force to the complex while the protein is geometrically prevented from passing through the nanopore. In this chapter, we describe progress toward nanopore sensing of protein-nucleic acid complexes in the context of both mapping binding sites and performing force spectroscopy to determine the strength of interactions. We conclude by reviewing the strengths and challenges of the nanopore technique in the context of studying DNA-protein interactions.

Quantifying Nanomolar Protein Concentrations Using Designed DNA Carriers and Solid-State Nanopores

Designed "DNA carriers" have been proposed as a new method for nanopore based specific protein detection. In this system, target protein molecules bind to a long DNA strand at a defined position creating a second level transient current drop against the background DNA translocation. Here, we demonstrate the ability of this system to quantify protein concentrations in the nanomolar range. After incubation with target protein at different concentrations, the fraction of DNA translocations showing a secondary current spike allows for the quantification of the corresponding protein concentration. For our proof-of-principle experiments we use two standard binding systems, biotin-streptavidin and digoxigenin-antidigoxigenin, that allow for measurements of the concentration down to the low nanomolar range. The results demonstrate the potential for a novel quantitative and specific protein detection scheme using the DNA carrier method.

New technologies for DNA analysis--a review of the READNA Project

The REvolutionary Approaches and Devices for Nucleic Acid analysis (READNA) project received funding from the European Commission for 41/2 years. The objectives of the project revolved around technological developments in nucleic acid analysis. The project partners have discovered, created and developed a huge body of insights into nucleic acid analysis, ranging from improvements and implementation of current technologies to the most promising sequencing technologies that constitute a 3(rd) and 4(th) generation of sequencing methods with nanopores and in situ sequencing, respectively.

Relevance of the Drag Force during Controlled Translocation of a DNA-Protein Complex through a Glass Nanocapillary

Combination of glass nanocapillaries with optical tweezers allowed us to detect DNA-protein complexes in physiological conditions. In this system, a protein bound to DNA is characterized by a simultaneous change of the force and ionic current signals from the level observed for the bare DNA. Controlled displacement of the protein away from the nanocapillary opening revealed decay in the values of the force and ionic current. Negatively charged proteins EcoRI, RecA, and RNA polymerase formed complexes with DNA that experienced electrophoretic force lower than the bare DNA inside nanocapillaries. Force profiles obtained for DNA-RecA in our system were different than those in the system with nanopores in membranes and optical tweezers. We suggest that such behavior is due to the dominant impact of the drag force comparing to the electrostatic force acting on a DNA-protein complex inside nanocapillaries. We explained our results using a stochastic model taking into account the conical shape of glass nanocapillaries.

Observing Changes in the Structure and Oligomerization State of a Helical Protein Dimer Using Solid-State Nanopores

Protein analysis using solid-state nanopores is challenging due to limitations in bandwidth and signal-to-noise ratio. Recent improvements of those two aspects have made feasible the study of small peptides using solid-state nanopores, which have an advantage over biological counterparts in tunability of the pore diameter. Here, we report on the detection and characterization of peptides as small as 33 amino acids. Silicon nitride nanopores with thicknesses less than 10 nm are used to provide signal-to-noise (S/N) levels up to S/N ∼ 10 at 100 kHz. We demonstrate differentiation of monomer and dimer forms of the GCN4-p1 leucine zipper, a coiled-coil structure well studied in molecular biology, and compare with the unstructured 33-residue monomer. GCN4-p1 is sequence segment associated with homodimerization of the transcription factor General Control Nonderepressible 4 (GCN4), which is involved in the control of amino acid synthesis in yeast. The differentiation between two oligomeric forms demonstrates the capabilities of improved solid-state nanopore platforms to extract structural information involving short peptide structures.

Nanopore sensing of individual transcription factors bound to DNA

Transcription factor (TF)-DNA interactions are the primary control point in regulation of gene expression. Characterization of these interactions is essential for understanding genetic regulation of biological systems and developing novel therapies to treat cellular malfunctions. Solid-state nanopores are a highly versatile class of single-molecule sensors that can provide rich information about local properties of long charged biopolymers using the current blockage patterns generated during analyte translocation, and provide a novel platform for characterization of TF-DNA interactions. The DNA-binding domain of the TF Early Growth Response Protein 1 (EGR1), a prototypical zinc finger protein known as zif268, is used as a model system for this study. zif268 adopts two distinct bound conformations corresponding to specific and nonspecific binding, according to the local DNA sequence. Here we implement a solid-state nanopore platform for direct, label- and tether-free single-molecule detection of zif268 bound to DNA. We demonstrate detection of single zif268 TFs bound to DNA according to current blockage sublevels and duration of translocation through the nanopore. We further show that the nanopore can detect and discriminate both specific and nonspecific binding conformations of zif268 on DNA via the distinct current blockage patterns corresponding to each of these two known binding modes.

Detection of Individual Proteins Bound along DNA Using Solid-State Nanopores

DNA in cells is heavily covered with all types of proteins that regulate its genetic activity. Detection of DNA-bound proteins is a challenge that is well suited to solid-state nanopores as they provide a linear readout of the DNA and DNA-protein volume in the pore constriction along the entire length of a molecule. Here, we demonstrate that we can realize the detection of even individual DNA-bound proteins at the single-DNA-molecule level using solid-state nanopores. We introduce and use a new model system of anti-DNA antibodies bound to lambda phage DNA. This system provides several advantages since the antibodies bind individually, tolerate high salt concentrations, and will, because of their positive charge, not translocate through the pore unless bound to the DNA. Translocation of DNA-antibody samples reveals the presence of short 12 μs current spikes within the DNA traces, with amplitudes that are about 4.5 times larger than that of dsDNA, which are associated with individual antibodies. We conclude that transient interactions between the pore and the antibodies are the primary mechanism by which bound antibodies are observed. This work provides a proof-of-concept for how nanopores could be used for future sensing applications.

Nanopore Analysis of Single-Stranded Binding Protein Interactions with DNA

We study the binding of E. coli single-stranded binding protein (SSB) to single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) using a solid-state nanopore assay. We find that saturated nucleoprotein complexes can be distinguished easily from free SSB, ssDNA, or double-stranded DNA individually and demonstrate that the high affinity of SSB for ssDNA can be exploited to achieve high-fidelity differentiation from duplex molecules in a mixture. We then study nucleoprotein filament formation by systematically varying the amount of SSB relative to ssDNA. We observe a concomitant shift in the mean amplitude of electrical events that is consistent with weakly cooperative binding. Finally, we compare circular and linearized ssDNA saturated with SSB and use the results to infer structural details of the nucleoprotein complex.

Challenges in DNA motion control and sequence readout using nanopore devices

Nanopores are being hailed as a potential next-generation DNA sequencer that could provide cheap, high-throughput DNA analysis. In this review we present a detailed summary of the various sensing techniques being investigated for use in DNA sequencing and mapping applications. A crucial impasse to the success of nanopores as a reliable DNA analysis tool is the fast and stochastic nature of DNA translocation. We discuss the incorporation of biological motors to step DNA through a pore base-by-base, as well as the many experimental modifications attempted for the purpose of slowing and controlling DNA transport.

Specific protein detection using designed DNA carriers and nanopores

Nanopores are a versatile technique for the detection and characterization of single molecules in solution. An ongoing challenge in the field is to find methods to selectively detect specific biomolecules. In this work we describe a new technique for sensing specific proteins using unmodified solid-state nanopores. We engineered a double strand of DNA by hybridizing nearly two hundred oligonucleotides to a linearized version of the m13mp18 virus genome. This engineered double strand, which we call a DNA carrier, allows positioning of protein binding sites at nanometer accurate intervals along its contour via DNA conjugation chemistry. We measure the ionic current signal of translocating DNA carriers as a function of the number of binding sites and show detection down to the single protein level. Furthermore, we use DNA carriers to develop an assay for identifying a single protein species within a protein mixture.

Nanopore-based assay for detection of methylation in double-stranded DNA fragments

DNA methylation is an epigenetic modification of DNA in which methyl groups are added at the 5-carbon position of cytosine. Aberrant DNA methylation, which has been associated with carcinogenesis, can be assessed in various biological fluids and potentially can be used as markers for detection of cancer. Analytically sensitive and specific assays for methylation targeting low-abundance and fragmented DNA are needed for optimal clinical diagnosis and prognosis. We present a nanopore-based direct methylation detection assay that circumvents bisulfite conversion and polymerase chain reaction amplification. Building on our prior work, we used methyl-binding proteins (MBPs), which selectively label the methylated DNA. The nanopore-based assay selectively detects methylated DNA/MBP complexes through a 19 nm nanopore with significantly deeper and prolonged nanopore ionic current blocking, while unmethylated DNA molecules were not detectable due to their smaller diameter. Discrimination of hypermethylated and unmethylated DNA on 90, 60, and 30 bp DNA fragments was demonstrated using sub-10 nm nanopores. Hypermethylated DNA fragments fully bound with MBPs are differentiated from unmethylated DNA at 2.1- to 6.5-fold current blockades and 4.5- to 23.3-fold transport durations. Furthermore, these nanopore assays can detect the CpG dyad in DNA fragments and could someday profile the position of methylated CpG sites on DNA fragments.

Nanopores suggest a negligible influence of CpG methylation on nucleosome packaging and stability

Nucleosomes are the fundamental repeating units of chromatin, and dynamic regulation of their positioning along DNA governs gene accessibility in eukaryotes. Although epigenetic factors have been shown to influence nucleosome structure and dynamics, the impact of DNA methylation on nucleosome packaging remains controversial. Further, all measurements to date have been carried out under zero-force conditions. In this paper, we present the first automated force measurements that probe the impact of CpG DNA methylation on nucleosome stability. In solid-state nanopore force spectroscopy, a nucleosomal DNA tail is captured into a pore and pulled on with a time-varying electrophoretic force until unraveling is detected. This is automatically repeated for hundreds of nucleosomes, yielding statistics of nucleosome lifetime vs electrophoretic force. The force geometry, which is similar to displacement forces exerted by DNA polymerases and helicases, reveals that nucleosome stability is sensitive to DNA sequence yet insensitive to CpG methylation. Our label-free method provides high-throughput data that favorably compares with other force spectroscopy experiments and is suitable for studying a variety of DNA-protein complexes.

Detection of two isomeric binding configurations in a protein-aptamer complex with a biological nanopore

Protein-DNA interactions play critical roles in biological systems, and they often involve complex mechanisms and dynamics that are not easily measured by ensemble experiments. Recently, we showed that folded proteins can be internalized inside ClyA nanopores and studied by ionic current recordings at the single-molecule level. Here, we use ClyA nanopores to sample the interaction between the G-quadruplex fold of the thrombin binding aptamer (TBA) and human thrombin (HT). Surprisingly, the internalization of the HT:TBA complex inside the nanopore induced two types of current blockades with distinguished residual current and lifetime. Using single nucleobase substitutions to TBA we showed that these two types of blockades originate from TBA binding to thrombin with two isomeric orientations. Voltage dependencies and the use of ClyA nanopores with two different diameters allowed assessing the effect of the applied potential and confinement and revealed that the two binding configurations of TBA to HT display different lifetimes. These results show that the ClyA nanopores can be used to probe conformational heterogeneity in protein:DNA interactions.

Smooth DNA transport through a narrowed pore geometry

Voltage-driven transport of double-stranded DNA through nanoscale pores holds much potential for applications in quantitative molecular biology and biotechnology, yet the microscopic details of translocation have proven to be challenging to decipher. Earlier experiments showed strong dependence of transport kinetics on pore size: fast regular transport in large pores (> 5 nm diameter), and slower yet heterogeneous transport time distributions in sub-5 nm pores, which imply a large positional uncertainty of the DNA in the pore as a function of the translocation time. In this work, we show that this anomalous transport is a result of DNA self-interaction, a phenomenon that is strictly pore-diameter dependent. We identify a regime in which DNA transport is regular, producing narrow and well-behaved dwell-time distributions that fit a simple drift-diffusion theory. Furthermore, a systematic study of the dependence of dwell time on DNA length reveals a single power-law scaling of 1.37 in the range of 35-20,000 bp. We highlight the resolution of our nanopore device by discriminating via single pulses 100 and 500 bp fragments in a mixture with >98% accuracy. When coupled to an appropriate sequence labeling method, our observation of smooth DNA translocation can pave the way for high-resolution DNA mapping and sizing applications in genomics.

SSB binding to single-stranded DNA probed using solid-state nanopore sensors

Single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) binding protein plays an important role in the DNA replication process in a wide range of organisms. It binds to ssDNA to prevent premature reannealing and to protect it from degradation. Current understanding of SSB/ssDNA interaction points to a complex mechanism, including SSB motion along the DNA strand. We report on the first characterization of this interaction at the single-molecule level using solid-state nanopore sensors, namely without any labeling or surface immobilization. Our results show that the presence of SSB on the ssDNA can control the speed of nanopore translocation, presumably due to strong interactions between SSB and the nanopore surface. This enables nanopore-based detection of ssDNA fragments as short as 37 nt, which is normally very difficult with solid-state nanopore sensors, due to constraints in noise and bandwidth. Notably, this fragment is considerably shorter than the 65 nt binding motif, typically required for SSB binding at high salt concentrations. The nonspecificity of SSB binding to ssDNA further suggests that this approach could be used for fragment sizing of short ssDNA.

Detecting DNA depurination with solid-state nanopores

Among the different types of DNA damage that occur endogenously in the cell, depurination is especially prevalent. These lesions can initiate mutagenesis and have been implicated in a variety of diseases, including cancer. Here, we demonstrate a new approach for the detection of depurination at the single-molecule scale using solid-state nanopores. We induce depurination in short duplex DNA using acidic conditions and observe that the presence of apurinic sites results in significantly slower dynamics during electrokinetic translocation. This procedure may be valuable as a diagnostic for in situ quantification of DNA depurination.