Altering the 3 UTR endonucleolytic cleavage site of a Chlamydomonas chloroplast mRNA affects 3-end maturation in vitro but not in vivo

Knockout of the plastid RNase E leads to defective RNA processing and chloroplast ribosome deficiency

Ribonuclease E (RNase E) represents a key enzyme in bacterial RNA metabolism. It plays multifarious roles in RNA processing and also initiates degradation of mRNA by endonucleolytic cleavage. Plastids (chloroplasts) are derived from formerly free-living bacteria and have largely retained eubacterial gene expression mechanisms. Here we report the functional characterization of a chloroplast RNase E that is encoded by a single-copy nuclear gene in the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana. Analysis of knockout plants revealed that, unlike in bacteria, RNase E is not essential for survival. Absence of RNase E results in multiple defects in chloroplast RNA metabolism. Most importantly, polycistronic precursor transcripts overaccumulate in the knockout plants, while several mature monocistronic mRNAs are strongly reduced, suggesting an important function of RNase E in intercistronic processing of primary transcripts from chloroplast operons. We further show that disturbed maturation of a transcript encoding essential ribosomal proteins results in plastid ribosome deficiency and, therefore, provides a molecular explanation for the observed mutant phenotype.

Site-specific binding of a PPR protein defines and stabilizes 5' and 3' mRNA termini in chloroplasts

Chloroplast mRNA populations are characterized by overlapping transcripts derived by processing from polycistronic precursors. The mechanisms and functional significance of these processing events are poorly understood. We describe a pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR) protein, PPR10, whose binding defines mRNA segments derived from two transcription units in maize chloroplasts. PPR10 interacts in vivo and in vitro with two intergenic RNA regions of similar sequence. The processed 5' and 3' RNA termini in these regions overlap by approximately 25 nucleotides. The PPR10-binding sites map precisely to these overlapping sequences, and PPR10 is required specifically for the accumulation of RNAs with these termini. These findings show that PPR10 serves as a barrier to RNA decay from either the 5' or 3' direction and that a bound protein provides an alternative to an RNA hairpin as a barrier to 3' exonucleases. The results imply that protein 'caps' at both 5' and 3' ends can define the termini of chloroplast mRNA segments. These results, together with recent insights into bacterial RNA decay, suggest a unifying model for the biogenesis of chloroplast transcript populations and for the determinants of chloroplast mRNA stability.

The nucleus-encoded factor MCD4 participates in degradation of nonfunctional 3' UTR sequences generated by cleavage of pre-mRNA in Chlamydomonas chloroplasts

The 3' maturation of chloroplast pre-mRNAs in Chlamydomonas proceeds via endonucleolytic cleavage, exonucleolytic trimming of the upstream cleavage product, and rapid degradation of the downstream moiety. However, the cis elements and trans factors remain to be characterized in detail. In the case of atpB, a 300 nucleotide processing determinant (PD), consisting of an inverted repeat (IR) and endonuclease cleavage site (ECS), directs 3' maturation. To further characterize the PD, 15 variants were examined in vivo in ectopic contexts. This revealed that the IR, and nucleotides 15-37 downstream of the ECS stimulate processing. A candidate trans factor for 3' maturation was subsequently functionally analyzed. This factor is encoded by the nuclear locus MCD4, and the mcd4 mutant was known to accumulate abnormally 3'-processed chloroplast mRNAs. When the mcd4 mutation was crossed into strains containing reporter genes with insertions of several PD versions, processing was reduced in some cases. This caused accumulation of RNA sequences downstream of the PD, which are normally degraded. From these data, it can be suggested that MCD4 facilitates the endonucleolytic cleavage step in 3' end maturation of atpB and perhaps other mRNAs, by interacting with the IR, RNA downstream of the IR, or with proteins bound there.

An in vivo internal deletion in the N-terminus region of Arabidopsis cystathionine gamma-synthase results in CGS expression that is insensitive to methionine

Cystathionine gamma-synthase (CGS), the first enzyme of methionine biosynthesis in higher plants, plays an important role in the biosynthesis pathway and in regulating methionine metabolism in plant cells. In response to methionine, the expression of this enzyme is regulated via amino acid sequences located in its N-terminal. Here, using reverse transcription PCR and ribonuclease protection analysis, we demonstrate that, in addition to the full-length CGS transcript, a deleted form exists in Arabidopsis. The deleted transcript of CGS that lacks 90 or 87 nt located internally in the regulatory N-terminal region of CGS maintains the reading frame of the protein. Its association with polyribosomes indicates that this deleted form of CGS is translated. In order to study the function of this deleted form of CGS, we overexpressed it in transgenic tobacco plants. We found that the transgenic plants engineered to express only the deleted form of CGS accumulated methionine to a much higher level than those that expressed the full-length CGS. Furthermore, in vitro feeding experiments revealed that the deleted form of CGS is not subject to feedback regulation by methionine, as reported for the full-length transcript. Therefore, although most likely produced from the full-length CGS, the transcript of the deleted form is insensitive to methionine application and its expression may be important for maintaining methionine metabolism even in the presence of a high level of methionine.

Cross-competition in transgenic chloroplasts expressing single editing sites reveals shared cis elements

RNA editing in organelles of angiosperm plants results in alteration of Cs to Us in transcripts. In most editing sites analyzed in vitro or in vivo, sequences within approximately 30 nucleotides (nt) 5' and 10 nt 3' of the edited C have been found to be required for selection of the correct C editing target and for editing efficiency, but no consensus sequences have been identified. The effect of high-level expression of two different minigenes carrying either the rpoB-2 or the ndhF-2 editing site on editing was determined for all 31 known edited Cs in two transgenic tobacco lines. The editing efficiencies of both the corresponding rpoB and ndhF editing sites in the endogenous genes' transcripts and in several other genes' transcripts were reduced in the chloroplast transgenic plants. Conserved nucleotides could be identified in the sequences immediately 5' of each overexpressed editing site and in the sites in the additional genes that experienced a competition effect, though the conserved nucleotides differ 5' of rpoB-2 and 5' of ndhF-2. Inspection of sequences surrounding chloroplast and mitochondrial editing sites reveals that they can be grouped into clusters which carry conserved nucleotides within 30 nt 5' of the C target of editing. The data are consistent with a model in which the same trans factor recognizes several chloroplast or mitochondrial editing sites, depending on the particular sequence 5' of the edited C.

An mRNA 3' processing site targets downstream sequences for rapid degradation in Chlamydomonas chloroplasts

In Chlamydomonas chloroplasts, atpB pre-mRNA matures through a two-step process. Initially, endonuclease cleavage occurs 8-10 nt downstream of the mature 3' end, which itself lies at the end of a stem-loop-forming inverted repeat (IR) sequence. This intermediate product is then trimmed by a 3' -->5' exonuclease activity. Although the initial endonucleolytic cleavage by definition generates two products, the downstream product of atpB pre-mRNA endonucleolytic processing cannot be detected, even transiently. This product thus appears to be highly unstable, and it can be hypothesized that specific mechanisms exist to prevent its accumulation. In experiments described here, the atpB 3' maturation site was placed upstream of reporter genes in vivo. Constructs containing both the IR and endonuclease cleavage site (ECS) did not accumulate the reporter gene mRNA, whereas constructs containing only the IR did accumulate the reporter mRNA. The ECS alone gave an intermediate result, suggesting that the IR and ECS act synergistically. Additional secondary structures were used to test whether 5' -->3' and/or 3' -->5' exonuclease activities mediated degradation. Because these structures did not prevent degradation, rapid endonucleolytic cleavages most likely trigger RNA destruction after ECS cleavage. On the other hand, fragments resulting from cleavage within the endogenous atpB mRNA could occasionally be detected as antisense transcripts of the adjacent reporter genes. Because endonuclease cleavages are also involved in the 5' maturation of chloroplast mRNAs, where only the downstream cleavage product accumulates, it appears that chloroplast endoribonuclease activities have evolved mechanisms to selectively stabilize different ECS products.

Novel approach in plastid transformation

Engineering the nuclear genome of plants is perceived to be associated with problems regarding biosafety and the stability of expression of the transgene. Alternative transformation strategies using the genomic outfit of the plastid promise to be more successful in this respect. Over the past few years progress has been made in screening procedures, and plastid transformation technology has allowed function to be assigned to open reading frames, massive expression of insecticidal agents and proteins involved in herbicide resistance, and the accumulation of biopolymers. Recently, the design of a novel femtoinjection technique that allows injection into chloroplasts has provided the opportunity to further manipulate and understand chloroplastic gene expression.

Processing and degradation of chloroplast mRNA

The conversion of genetic information stored in DNA into a protein product proceeds through the obligatory intermediate of messenger RNA. The steady-state level of an mRNA is determined by its relative synthesis and degradation rates, i.e., an interplay between transcriptional regulation and control of RNA stability. When the biological status of an organism requires that a gene product's abundance varies as a function of developmental stage, environmental factors or intracellular signals, increased or decreased RNA stability can be the determining factor. RNA stability and processing have long been known as important regulatory points in chloroplast gene expression. Here we summarize current knowledge and prospects relevant to these processes, emphasizing biochemical data. The extensive literature on nuclear mutations affecting chloroplast RNA metabolism is reviewed in another article in this volume (Barkan and Goldschmidt-Clermont, this issue).