Dynamics of stimulation-induced muscle adaptation: insights from varying the duty cycle

Adaptive change in electrically stimulated muscle: a framework for the design of clinical protocols

Adult mammalian skeletal muscles have a remarkable capacity for adapting to increased use. Although this behavior is familiar from the changes brought about by endurance exercise, it is seen to a much greater extent in the response to long-term neuromuscular stimulation. The associated phenomena include a markedly increased resistance to fatigue, and this is the key to several clinical applications. However, a more rational basis is needed for designing regimes of stimulation that are conducive to an optimal outcome. In this review I examine relevant factors, such as the amount, frequency, and duty cycle of stimulation, the influence of force generation, and the animal model. From these considerations a framework emerges for the design of protocols that yield an overall functional profile appropriate to the application. Three contrasting examples illustrate the issues that need to be addressed clinically.

The effect of eating on lower esophageal sphincter electrical activity

Electrical activity of the lower esophageal sphincter (LES) has been recorded mainly in vitro and in anesthetized animals. Swallowing produces relaxation of the LES, followed by its contraction. These changes should be associated with changes in LES electrical activity. To determine whether changes in LES electrical activity can be used to recognize the beginning of a meal, four dogs were implanted with two electrodes in the longitudinal axis of the LES. The electrodes were connected to an implantable device for recording of electrical activity. After recovery, dogs underwent two experiments: 1) combined recordings of LES electrical activity and esophageal manometry to test the effect of dry swallows, water, and solid food swallows on LES electrical activity and 2) telemetric recording of LES electrical activity during a standard meal. All amplitudes were in mV, means+/-SD, ANOVA, P<0.05. In experiment 1, an increase in the amplitude of LES electrical activity was associated with the substance being swallowed, i.e., at rest: 0.31+/-0.06; dry swallows: 0.6+/-.0.1; water: 0.67+/-0.12; solid food: 1.06+/-0.17, P<0.001. In experiment 2, there was a pronounced and characteristic increase in amplitude of LES electrical activity during feeding, 0.26+/-0.1; during fasting, 0.99+/-0.23; while eating, 0.31+/-0.1 postprandial, P<0.001. In conclusion, the beginning and duration of a meal are identified by distinct, easily recognizable changes in the amplitude of LES electrical activity. These changes depend on the type of the substance being swallowed and are most prominent with solid food. Changes in LES electrical activity can potentially be used for automatic eating detection.

Adaptive conditioning of skeletal muscle in a large animal model (Sus domesticus)

Recognition of the adaptive capacity of mammalian skeletal muscle has opened the way to a number of clinical applications. For most of these, the fast, fatigue-susceptible fibres need to be transformed stably to fast, fatigue-resistant fibres that express the 2A myosin heavy chain isoform. The thresholds for activity-induced change are size-dependent, so although the requisite patterns of electrical stimulation are known for the rabbit, in humans these same patterns would produce type 1 fibre characteristics, with an undesirable loss of contractile speed and power. We have used histochemistry, immunohistochemistry and electrophoretic separations to evaluate a possible conditioning regime in a large animal model. Stimulation of the porcine latissimus dorsi muscle with a phasic 30-Hz pattern for up to 41 days converted all type 2X and 2A/2X fibres to 2A with only a small increase in the type 1 population, from 17% to 22%. Stimulation for longer periods increased the proportion of type 1 fibres to 52%. Based on this model, stimulation regimes designed to achieve a stable 2A phenotype in humans should deliver fewer stimulating impulses, possibly by a factor of 2, than the pattern assessed here. Any such pattern needs to be tested for at least 8 weeks.

Short-term electrical stimulation alters tongue muscle fibre type composition

OBJECTIVE

To examine whether short-term exogenous activation of a tongue muscle induced a phenotypic shift from a fast to a slow fibre-type, and thus assess a potential therapeutic avenue to protect against obstructive sleep apnoea (OSA).

METHODS

New Zealand White rabbit genioglossus (GG) muscle, characteristically a fast muscle, was continuously stimulated at a frequency attributed to slow muscle (10Hz, 3V DC pulses) using an implanted micro-circuit for 7 days. Changes in muscle fibre types and aerobic capacity were assessed between stimulated and un-stimulated (control) groups using immunohistochemistry and electrophoresis for myosin heavy chain (MHC) and assayed for citrate synthase.

RESULTS

Compared to the un-stimulated control group, stimulated GG muscles had more (approximately 13%) type I MHC (slow-twitch) content; a proportional decrease in type II MHC (fast-twitch) isoform also occurred in the stimulated GG muscle (P<0.05). Electrophoresis analysis on whole muscle and single fibre MHC showed an increased type I expression in the stimulated GG muscle (P<0.01). A commensurate rise in citrate synthase activity, indicating a change in aerobic capacity, was also observed in the stimulated GG muscles.

CONCLUSION

Together, these results demonstrate a successful alteration in tongue muscle characteristics using exogenous electrical stimulation and perhaps a potential therapeutic application for OSA.

Chronic electrostimulation after nerve repair by self-anastomosis: effects on the size, the mechanical, histochemical and biochemical muscle properties

This study tests the effects of chronic electrostimulation on denervated/reinnervated skeletal muscle in producing an optimal restoration of size and mechanical and histochemical properties. We compared tibialis anterior muscles in four groups of rats: in unoperated control (C) and 10 weeks following nerve lesion with suture (LS) in the absence of electrostimulation and in the presence of muscle stimulation with either a monophasic rectangular current (LSEm) or a biphasic modulated current (LSEb). The main results were (1) muscle atrophy was reduced in LSEm (-26%) while it was absent in LSEb groups (-8%); (2) the peak twitch amplitude decreased in LS and LSEm but not in LSEb groups, whereas the contraction time was shorter; (3) muscle reinnervation was associated with the emergence of type IIC fibers and proportions of types I, IIA and IIB fibers recovered in the superficial portion of LSEb muscles; (4) the ratio of oxidative to glycolytic activities decreased in the three groups with nerve injury and repair; however, this decrease was more accentuated in LSEm groups. We conclude that muscle electrostimulation following denervation and reinnervation tends to restore size and functional and histochemical properties during reinnervation better than is seen in unstimulated muscle.

Mechanical properties of the latissimus dorsi muscle after cyclic training

Cardiomyoplasty is a procedure developed to improve heart performance in patients suffering from congestive heart failure. The latissimus dorsi (LD) muscle is surgically wrapped around the failing ventricles and stimulated to contract in synchrony with the heart. The LD muscle is easily fatigued and as a result is unsuitable for cardiomyoplasty. For useful operation as a cardiac-assist device, the fatigue resistance of the LD muscle must be improved while retaining a high power output. The LD muscle of rabbits was subjected to a training regime in which cyclic work was performed. Training transformed the fiber-type composition from approximately equal proportions of fast oxidative glycolytic (FOG) and fast glycolytic (FG) fibers to one composed of almost entirely of FOG with no FG, which increased fatigue resistance while retaining rapid contraction kinetics. Muscle mass and cross-sectional area increased but power output decreased, relative to control muscles. This training regime represents a significant improvement in terms of preserving muscle mass and power compared with other training regimes, while enhancing fatigue resistance, although some fiber damage occurred. The power output of the trained LD muscle was calculated to be sufficient to deliver a significant level of assistance to a failing heart during cardiomyoplasty.

ASIC or PIC? Implantable stimulators based on semi-custom CMOS technology or low-power microcontroller architecture

To gain a better understanding of the effects of chronic stimulation on mammalian muscles we needed to generate patterns of greater variety and complexity than simple constant-frequency or burst patterns. We describe here two approaches to the design of implantable neuromuscular stimulators that can satisfy these requirements. Devices of both types were developed and used in long-term experiments. The first device was based on a semi-custom Application Specific Integrated Circuit (ASIC). This approach has the advantage that the circuit can be completely tested at every stage of development and production, assuring a high degree of reliability. It has the drawback of inflexibility: the patterns are produced by state machines implemented in silicon, so each new set of patterns requires a fresh production run, which is costly and time-consuming. The second device was based on a commercial microcontroller (Microchip PIC16C84). The functionality of this type of circuit is specified in software rather than in silicon hardware, allowing a single device to be programmed for different functions. With the use of features designed to improve fault-tolerance we found this approach to be as reliable as that based on ASICs. The encapsulated devices can easily be accommodated subcutaneously on the flank of a rabbit and a recent version is small enough to implant into the peritoneal cavity of rats. The current devices are programmed with a predetermined set of 12 patterns before assembly; the desired pattern is selected after implantation with an electronic flash gun. The operating current drain is less than 40 microA.