In vitro human epidermal and polyethylene membrane penetration and retention of the sunscreen benzophenone-3 from a range of solvents

Establishing the importance of oil-membrane interactions on the transmembrane diffusion of physicochemically diverse compounds

The diffusion process through a non-porous barrier membrane depends on the properties of the drug, vehicle and membrane. The aim of the current study was to investigate whether a series of oily vehicles might have the potential to interact to varying degrees with synthetic membranes and to determine whether any such interaction might affect the permeation of co-formulated permeants: methylparaben (MP); butylparaben (BP) or caffeine (CF). The oils (isopropyl myristate (IPM), isohexadecane (IHD), hexadecane (HD), oleic acid (OA) and liquid paraffin (LP)) and membranes (silicone, high density polyethylene and polyurethane) employed in the study were selected such that they displayed a range of different structural, and physicochemical properties. Diffusion studies showed that many of the vehicles were not inert and did interact with the membranes resulting in a modification of the permeants' flux when corrected for membrane thickness (e.g. normalized flux of MP increased from 1.25±0.13μgcm(-1)h(-1) in LP to 17.94±0.25μgcm(-1)h(-1)in IPM). The oils were sorbed differently to membranes (range of weight gain: 2.2±0.2% for polyurethane with LP to 105.6±1.1% for silicone with IHD). Membrane interaction was apparently dependent upon the physicochemical properties including; size, shape, flexibility and the Hansen solubility parameter values of both the membranes and oils. Sorbed oils resulted in modified permeant diffusion through the membranes. No simple correlation was found to exist between the Hansen solubility parameters of the oils or swelling of the membrane and the normalized fluxes of the three compounds investigated. More sophisticated modelling would appear to be required to delineate and quantify the key molecular parameters of membrane, permeant and vehicle compatibility and their interactions of relevance to membrane permeation.

In-vitro permeation of the Insect repellent N,N-diethyl-m-toluamide (DEET) and the sunscreen oxybenzone

The permeation behaviours of the insect repellent N,N-diethyl-m-toluamide (DEET) and the sunscreen oxybenzone were assessed in a series of in-vitro diffusion studies, using piglet skin and poly (dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) membrane. The transmembrane permeability of DEET and oxybenzone across piglet skin and PDMS membrane was dependent on dissolving vehicles and test concentrations. An enhanced permeation increase across piglet skin was found for DEET and oxybenzone when both compounds were present in the same medium (DEET: 289% in propylene glycol, 243% in ethanol and 112% in poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG-400); oxybenzone: 139% in PEG-400, 120% in propylene glycol and 112% in ethanol). Permeation enhancement was also observed in PDMS membrane (DEET: 207% in ethanol, 124% in PEG-400 and 107% in propylene glycol; oxybenzone: 254%in PEG-400, 154% in ethanol and 105% in propylene glycol). PDMS membrane was found to be a suitable candidate for in-vitro diffusion evaluations. This study shows that the permeations of the insect repellent DEET and the sunscreen oxybenzone were synergistically enhanced when they were applied simultaneously.

Transdermal absorption of the herbicide 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid is enhanced by both ethanol consumption and sunscreen application

Xenobiotics absorption is a health concern and skin is a major exposure site for many of these chemicals. Both alcohol consumption and topical sunscreen application act as transdermal penetration enhancers for model xenobiotics. The effect of combining these two treatments on transdermal absorption of the herbicide 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) was therefore examined. Skin from rats ingesting low (1.5 g/kg) medium (4.3 g/kg) or high (6 g/kg) ethanol doses or saline control was treated with a commercially available sunscreen containing titanium dioxide and octyl methoxycinnimate and transdermal absorption of 2,4-D was monitored. Ethanol increased penetration by a factor of 1.9, 2.0 and 2.5 for animals treated with 1.5, 4.3 and 6 g/kg respectively, demonstrating an ethanol-induced dose response. Sunscreen application to skin from ethanol gavaged rats caused 2,4-D absorption above that induced by ethanol alone by an additional factor of 1.3, 2.1 and 2.9 for 1.5, 4.3 and 6 g/kg respectively. Comparing 2,4-D transdermal absorption after exposure to both ethanol and sunscreen with a theoretical value (sum of penetration after ethanol or sunscreen treatment) demonstrates that these two treatments enhance additively at the higher doses tested. Results of this study emphasize the importance of limiting excessive alcohol consumption in individuals with potential herbicide exposure rather than discouraging the use of sunscreens, since the consequences of UV-induced skin cancer are far more series than the risks that would be associated with observed increases in chemical exposure.

In vitro permeation of repellent DEET and sunscreen oxybenzone across three artificial membranes

DEET and oxybenzone are two essential active ingredients in repellent and sunscreen products. We performed a series of in vitro diffusion studies to evaluate the transmembrane permeation of DEET and oxybenzone across three artificial membranes, low-density polyethylene (LDPE), low fouling composite (LFC) and mixed cellulose esters (MCE), from concurrent use of commercial repellent and sunscreen preparations. Permeation of DEET and oxybenzone across the test membranes was synergistically increased when both the repellent and the sunscreen formulations were applied simultaneously. Different application sequences and formulation types also resulted in variable permeation profiles of DEET and oxybenzone. Compared to biological piglet epidermis under the identical experimental conditions, transmembrane permeation of DEET was suppressed in LDPE and LFC membranes, but enhanced in MCE membrane; transmembrane permeation of oxybenzone was reduced in LFC membrane, but increased in LDPE and MCE membranes. Permeability coefficients of DEET and oxybenzone in all three artificial membranes were significantly different from those in piglet skin. It was concluded that the permeation profiles of the compounds were dependent upon physicochemical characteristics of the membranes and the formulations.

Characterisation of the water–isopropyl myristate system

Partition coefficients for compounds (solutes) from water to isopropyl myristate, IPM, have been obtained from the literature, either as directly determined partition coefficients or from solubilities in water and in IPM. The general solvation equation of Abraham has been applied to 141 such partition coefficients, as logPipm, and it is shown that the main solute factors that influence partition are dipolarity/polarisability, hydrogen bond acidity and hydrogen bond basicity that reduce partition, and volume that increases partition. These factors are quantitatively very similar to those that influence partition in the water to olive oil system, and indicate that IPM has the expected behaviour of a long chain, hydrophobic ester. It is shown that the water to IPM system is a poor model for partition between water and human stratum corneum and for permeation from water through human skin.

Ion-pairs of ibuprofen: increased membrane diffusion

The purpose of the present study was to determine the influence of pH and ion-pairing on the permeation of ibuprofen across polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) membrane. The solubility of ibuprofen sodium was determined at a range of pH values. Saturated solutions were then used to determine the influence of pH on diffusion across PDMS as a model membrane. The apparent partition coefficient of ibuprofen sodium between n-octanol and phosphate buffer at various pH values was also investigated. Organic salts of ibuprofen using ethylamine, diethylamine, triethylamine and ethylene diamine as counter-ions were synthesized and the influence of these counter-ions on the permeation of ibuprofen was studied. The presence of ion-pairing was confirmed using 1H NMR and 13C NMR. Diffusion studies at different pH values (4.0, 5.0, 6.0, 7.0 and 8.0) indicated that ibuprofen sodium flux increased significantly with increasing pH from 4.0 to 7.0. Above pH 7.0 a decrease in diffusion was observed. The permeability coefficient increased with an increase in the amount of unionized acid. The apparent partition coefficient was directly related to the steady-state flux. The steady-state flux of ibuprofen increased up to 16-fold using different counter-ions. The highest flux was measured from ibuprofen triethylamine. The flux of ibuprofen salts across a lipophilic membrane can be increased by formation of ion-pairs. The extent of enhancement is associated with the lipophilicity, extent of ion-pairing and reduction in charge over the drug molecule.

Can increasing the viscosity of formulations be used to reduce the human skin penetration of the sunscreen oxybenzone?

The effect of adding thickening agents on the penetration of a sunscreen benzophenone-3 through epidermal and a high-density polyethylene membrane was studied using both very thick (infinite dose) and thin (in use) applications. Contradictory results were obtained. Thickening agents retard skin penetration, in a manner consistent with a diffusional resistance in the formulation, when applied as an infinite dose. In contrast, when applied as in thin (in use) doses, thickening agents promote penetration, most likely through greater stratum corneum diffusivity arising from an enhanced hydration by the thicker formulations. The two key implications from this work are (i) a recognition of the danger in the potential extrapolation of infinite dosing to in use situations, and (ii) to recognize that thicker formulations may sometimes enhance the penetration of other topical agents when applied "in use".

Probing the effect of vehicles on topical delivery: understanding the basic relationship between solvent and solute penetration using silicone membranes

PURPOSE

In the present study we examined the relationship between solvent uptake into a model membrane (silicone) with the physical properties of the solvents (e.g., solubility parameter, melting point, molecular weight) and its potential predictability. We then assessed the subsequent topical penetration and retention kinetics of hydrocortisone from various solvents to define whether modifications to either solute diffusivity or partitioning were dominant in increasing permeability through solvent-modified membranes.

METHODS

Membrane sorption of solvents was determined from weight differences following immersion in individual solvents, corrected for differences in density. Permeability and retention kinetics of 3H-hydrocortisone, applied as saturated solutions in the various solvents, were determined over 48 h in horizontal Franz-type glass diffusion cells.

RESULTS

Solvent sorption into the membrane could be related to differences in solubility parameters, MW and hydrogen bonding (r2=0.76). The actual and predicted volume of solvent sorbed into the membrane was also found to be linearly related to Log hydrocortisone flux, with changes in both diffusivity and partitioning of hydrocortisone observed for the different solvent vehicles.

CONCLUSIONS

A simple structure-based predictive model can be applied to the sorption of solvents into silicone membranes. Changes in solute diffusivity and partitioning appeared to contribute to the increased hydrocortisone flux observed with the various solvent vehicles. The application of this predictive model to the more complex skin membrane remains to be determined.

LC analysis of benzophenone-3: II application to determination of 'in vitro' and 'in vivo' skin penetration from solvents, coarse and submicron emulsions

The aim of this study was to determine the skin penetration of benzophenone-3 in vitro and in vivo in order to investigate a possible influence of formulation. Six different vehicles, three solvents and three different emulsion types were evaluated in vitro and in vivo. Each vehicle was applied to the skin model at 2 mg cm(-2). First, histological studies on ear pigskin and human skin were evaluated. In vitro measurements were performed with static diffusion cells using pigskin at 1, 2, 4, and 8-h. In vivo, benzophenone-3 concentration in stratum corneum was evaluated by the stripping method after 30-min application on forearm of volunteers. It was shown that ear pigskin and human skin appear similar and in both experiments significant differences between vehicles were noticed. The six vehicles could be ranked in the same order of benzophenone-3 skin concentration. At 8-h, the highest concentration of benzophenone-3 in skin was obtained with propylene glycol, and O/W submicron emulsion. On the contrary. the two oily solvents. W/O emulsion and O/W coarse emulsion restrain the concentration of this UV-filter in the skin. At each time, permeability in vitro and in vivo were well correlated. Low concentrations were measured in the receptor fluid suggesting that percutaneous absorption of this UV-filter across the skin would be minimal. The in vitro and in vivo skin penetration capacity of benzophenone-3 from six vehicles was confirmed and quantified. A satisfactory relationship between binary in vitro and in vivo was established.

Assessment and clinical implications of absorption of sunscreens across skin

Topical sunscreen products are widely used for protection of the skin against the harmful effects of exposure to ultraviolet radiation. Sunscreen agents are incorporated into many everyday-use cosmetics as well as so called 'beach' products. An ideal sunscreen product will provide effective protection against UV radiation with minimal skin absorption of the active ingredients. There is now clear evidence that a common sunscreen chemical, benzophenone-3, is absorbed systemically following topical application to the skin. Other more lipophilic sunscreens are absorbed into the skin, but penetration to deeper tissues and the cutaneous circulation appears to be limited. However, the extent to which sunscreens that are absorbed into the stratum corneum are absorbed to deeper tissues and the systemic circulation over time is currently unknown. The formulation vehicle in which the sunscreen is presented to the skin has a significant effect on absorption into and through the skin. Alcohol-based formulations appear to increase sunscreen absorption. In addition, some sunscreen chemicals may enhance the skin absorption of other sunscreens when applied in combination. Clearly, further research into the influence of sunscreen and formulation properties on skin absorption could lead to optimal design of sunscreen products with respect to efficacy and minimizing absorption. Despite the extensive use of sunscreen products, there have been few reports of adverse effects, and these tend to be limited to acute dermatitis and allergies. Some recent reports have raised concerns that sunscreen chemicals may damage tissues, particularly in the presence of UV radiation. Further research into the toxicity of sunscreens is urgently required. Given the information currently available and the importance of protecting the skin against sun damage, there is no clear justification for restricting the use of sunscreen products at this time.

Diffusion modeling of percutaneous absorption kinetics. 1. Effects of flow rate, receptor sampling rate, and viable epidermal resistance for a constant donor concentration

A diffusion model for the percutaneous absorption of a solute through the skin is developed for the specific case of a constant donor concentration with a finite removal rate from the receptor due to either perfusion rate or sampling. The model has been developed to include a viable epidermal resistance and a donor-stratum corneum interfacial resistance. Numerical inversion of the Laplace domain solutions were used for simulations of solute flux and cumulative amount absorbed and to model specific examples of percutaneous absorption. Limits of the Laplace domain solutions were used to define the steady-state flux, lag time, and receptor concentration. Steady-state approximations obtained from the solutions were used to relate the steady-state flux and the effective permeability coefficient to the viable epidermis resistance, a donor-stratum corneum interfacial resistance, receptor removal rate, and partitioning between the receptor and donor phases. The lag time was shown to be dependent on these parameters and on the volume of the receptor phase. It is concluded that curvilinear cumulative amount and flux-time profiles are dependent on the processes affecting percutaneous absorption, the shapes of the profiles reflecting the processes most determining transport.