T cells of lupus and molecular targets for immunotherapy

Histone-Specific CD4+ T Cell Plasticity in Active and Quiescent Systemic Lupus Erythematosus

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to assess whether circulating histone-specific T cells represent tools for precision medicine in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE).

METHODS

Seroprevalence of autoantibodies and HLA-DR beta (DRB) 1 profile were assessed among 185 patients with SLE and combined with bioinformatics and literature evidence to identify HLA-peptide autoepitope couples for ex vivo detection of antigen-specific T cells through flow cytometry. T cell differentiation and polarization was investigated in patients with SLE, patients with Takayasu arteritis, and healthy controls carrying HLA-DRB1*03:01 and/or HLA-DRB1*11:01. SLE Disease Activity Index 2000 and Lupus Low Disease Activity State were used to estimate disease activity and remission.

RESULTS

Histone-specific CD4+ T cells were selectively detected in patients with SLE. Among patients with a history of anti-DNA antibodies, 77% had detectable histone-specific T cells, whereas 50% had lymphocytes releasing cytokines or upregulating activation markers after in vitro challenge with histone peptide antigens. Histone-specific regulatory and effector T helper (Th) 1-, Th2-, and atypical Th1/Th17 (Th1*)-polarized cells were significantly more abundant in patients with SLE with quiescent disease. In contrast, total Th1-, Th2-, and Th1*-polarized and regulatory T cells were similarly represented between patients and controls or patients with SLE with active versus quiescent disease. Histone-specific effector memory T cells accumulated in the blood of patients with quiescent SLE, whereas total effector memory T cell counts did not change. Immunosuppressants were associated with expanded CD4+ histone-specific naive T (TN) and terminally differentiated T cells.

CONCLUSION

Histone-specific T cells are selectively detected in patients with SLE, and their concentration in the blood varies with disease activity, suggesting that they represent innovative tools for patient stratification and therapy.

B cell epitope spreading: mechanisms and contribution to autoimmune diseases

While a variety of factors act to trigger or initiate autoimmune diseases, the process of epitope spreading is an important contributor in their development. Epitope spreading is a diversification of the epitopes recognized by the immune system. This process happens to both T and B cells, with this review focusing on B cells. Such spreading can progress among multiple epitopes on a single antigen, or from one antigenic molecule to another. Systemic lupus erythematosus, multiple sclerosis, pemphigus, bullous pemphigoid and other autoimmune diseases, are all influenced by intermolecular and intramolecular B cell epitope spreading. Endocytic processing, antigen presentation, and somatic hypermutation act as molecular mechanisms that assist in driving epitope spreading and broadening the immune response in autoimmune diseases. The purpose of this review is to summarize our current understanding of B cell epitope spreading with regard to autoimmunity, how it contributes during the progression of various autoimmune diseases, and treatment options available.

Immunotherapy for autoimmune and inflammatory renal diseases

Immune-mediated renal disease (IMRD) accounts for 20 - 30% of the cases of end stage renal failure. It frequently occurs in the context of multi-system autoimmune disorders, including systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and primary systemic vasculitis. Current therapies are partially effective and comprise the combination of steroids with an immunosuppressive, such as cyclophosphamide. Their toxicity contributes to the morbidity and mortality of these disorders, and long-term treatment is necessary to prevent relapse. There is a clear need for better-targeted, more effective and less toxic therapy. Advances in our understanding of the immunopathogenesis of inflammatory autoimmune renal disease have identified potential targets for newer agents and have improved the monitoring of therapeutic responses. Recent experience with newer therapies in IMRD is reviewed. This has typically involved small, non-randomised, open-label trials and has addressed reversible features of disease activity. Larger, randomised comparisons to standard therapy are needed along with assessment of long-term efficacy and safety.

Therapy of systemic lupus erythematosus: a look into the future

The prognosis for patients with systemic lupus erythematosus has greatly improved over the past two decades. However, therapies that are more effective and that have fewer sequelae are needed to rescue patients from organ failure and further reduce mortality. Research under way, including that into induction of tolerance to self-antigens, prevention of the consequences of pathogenic autoantibody production, interference with the cytokine network and signal transduction, the identification and treatment of any infectious triggers, and stem cell therapy, offers hope of improved remedies or even of cure. Given the fact that a number of biological therapies for rheumatologic disease are already in use or are in the development stage, such progress may come soon.

Analysis of accumulated T cell clonotypes in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus

OBJECTIVE

To compare the accumulated T cell clonotypes in peripheral blood (PB) samples obtained at various times, and the accumulated T cell clonotypes in a PB sample and in an affected kidney, from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE).

METHODS

Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) were obtained at 2-4 different times from each of 5 SLE patients, with or without flare-up of the disease; in addition, a biopsied kidney tissue sample was obtained from 1 of the patients. RNA was extracted from each sample and complementary DNA was prepared. Genes that encode the variable region of T cell receptor (TCR) B chains (BV) of 3 BV families, 5S1, 8, and 14, were amplified by reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (PCR), and the PCR products were cloned for sequencing.

RESULTS

A total of 877 cloned TCR genes was detected in the PBMC samples and the kidney sample. Oligoclonal T cell expansion was detected in 34 of the 36 PCR-amplified BV samples from PBMC (amplification of 3 BV families in 2-4 samples from 5 patients). The composition of clonally expanded T cell clonotypes was relatively stable in the patients with inactive SLE. In contrast, the composition of clonotypes in the PB changed drastically after the patient experienced the active phase of the disease. T cell clonotypes that had accumulated in the kidney appeared to be restricted and distinct from those that had accumulated in the PB of the same patient.

CONCLUSION

Different T cell clonotypes expand at different times and at different sites in patients with active SLE. The sensitizing antigens may change over the course of the disease and may be different at each site.

Progress in the treatment of proliferative lupus nephritis

Lupus nephritis is often well developed at the time of diagnosis. High-dose corticosteroids are universally accepted as the initial approach to the control of severe inflammation in the kidney. Long-term disease control and the minimization of iatrogenic risk usually require adjunctive therapies that target the more fundamental immunoregulatory disturbances of lymphoid cells. Of the available cytotoxic drugs, cyclophosphamide is currently among the most effective, although it cannot be considered ideal in terms of efficacy or toxicity. New prospects for the treatment of proliferative lupus nephritis include novel immunosuppressive agents (e.g. mycophenolate, cyclosporine, fludarabine), combination chemotherapy (e.g. cyclophosphamide plus fludarabine), and sequential chemotherapy (e.g. cyclophosphamide-azathioprine), immunological reconstitution using intensive cytoreductive chemotherapy (with or without stem cell rescue), co-stimulatory molecule inhibition (e.g. humanized anti-CD154 monoclonal antibody, CTLA4-Ig). Gene therapy remains an attractive prospect, but its feasibility clearly depends on the further definition of lupus-promoting genes and the availability of methods to establish stable expression of disease-corrective genes in the appropriate lymphoid cells.

Termination of human T cell tolerance to histones by presentation of histones and polyomavirus T antigen provided that T antigen is complexed with nucleosomes

OBJECTIVE

To investigate whether polyomavirus T antigen linked to histones through nucleosome-T antigen complexes has the potential to terminate histone-specific T cell anergy.

METHODS

Blood mononuclear cells from healthy individuals were used as the source to establish T cell lines initiated and maintained by T antigen, histones, nucleosome-T antigen complexes, or nucleosomes. Proliferative responses of these lines to T antigen, histones, and nucleosomes were determined.

RESULTS

Whereas T cell lines could be established using T antigen or T antigen-nucleosome complexes, histones or nucleosomes did not have this potential. However, T cell lines selected by T antigen-nucleosome complexes responded subsequently to histones and nucleosomes. Identical results were obtained with murine and human nucleosomes, provided that they were complexed with T antigen.

CONCLUSION

T antigen-specific T cells possess the potential to proliferate when interacting with an antigen-presenting cell that presents T antigen. In the presence of T antigens complexed with nucleosomes, T antigen-specific T cells offer bystander help that may terminate histone-specific T cell anergy. These T cells may progress into functional, autoimmune T cells if histones are properly presented.

T cell lines specific for polyomavirus T-antigen recognize T-antigen complexed with nucleosomes: a molecular basis for anti-DNA antibody production

We have previously demonstrated that in vivo expression of the polyomavirus DNA-binding T-antigen initiated production of IgG antibodies to T-antigen and to DNA, but not to a panel of autoantigens not related to nucleosomes, indicating an antigen-selective T cell-dependent B cell response. In this study, we demonstrate that CD4-positive T cells from both normal and systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) patients readily proliferate in response to pure T-antigen, and also to T-antigen in complex with nucleosomes. T-antigen-specific T cell lines from both normal individuals and SLE patients proliferate in response to nucleosome-T-antigen complexes, but not to nucleosomes or histones. B cells co-cultured with T-antigen-specific T cells and stimulated with nucleosome-T-antigen complexes produce anti-T-antigen and anti-DNA antibodies, indicating that such CD4-positive T cells have the potential to interact with B cells specific for individual components of nucleosome-T-antigen complexes. Thus, a non-self DNA-binding protein like polyomavirus T-antigen may initiate and maintain an antibody response to DNA when T-antigen is actively expressed.

Terminal Deoxynucleotidyl Transferase Deficiency Reduces the Incidence of Autoimmune Nephritis in (New Zealand Black × New Zealand White)F1 Mice

Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase (TdT) enzyme activity in lymphocytes generates diversity in the Ag receptor repertoires by adding template-independent N nucleotides and disrupting homology-directed rearrangements. The importance of this diversity in vivo and the significance of the suppression of TdT during fetal life remain uncertain. Previous studies have shown that in TdT knockout mice (TdT°) 1) the T cell repertoire is less peptide oriented; and 2) natural autoantibody, particularly anti-DNA autoantibodies, are less polyreactive, and their mean affinities are reduced. Consequently, the suppression of TdT during early T/B cell ontogeny may participate in controlling autoimmunity. To study the impact of TdT suppression in autoimmune-prone mice, we introduced the TdT null mutation into the (NZB × NZW)F1 (B/W) mouse strain. We show that TdT deficiency significantly reduces the incidence of autoimmune nephritis and prolongs survival compared with those in control mice. Surprisingly, the long-term survivor TdT° mice produced amounts of anti-ADN and anti-histone autoantibodies similar to those of their TdT+ littermates. However, these TdT° mice showed no evidence of renal inflammation, and the immune deposits were restricted to the mesangium, whereas basal membrane deposits were clearly correlated with overt renal disease. The present study supports the idea that the absence of TdT enzyme activity in lymphocytes protects mice against autoimmunity and could offer a therapeutic approach to autoimmune diseases. Moreover, our results may help to unravel the mechanisms of lupus nephritis.

Immunotherapy for autoimmune and inflammatory renal diseases

New treatments for autoimmune renal disease are required, and a developing knowledge of its underlying immunopathogenesis has identified sites where immunotherapy is likely to be effective. Experience with intravenous immunoglobulin and lymphocyte depletion by monoclonal antibodies in systemic vasculitis and systemic lupus erythematosus is awaiting confirmation by randomized trials. Treatments at or near clinical testing include monoclonal antibody blockade of leucocyte-endothelial interactions and CD40 mediated B-cell activation, and immunoablation with autologous stem-cell transplantation for more severe multisystem autoimmune disease.

Anti-CD40 Ligand Antibody Treatment of SNF1 Mice with Established Nephritis: Preservation of Kidney Function

Prior studies have demonstrated that treatment of young, prenephritic lupus-prone mice with Ab directed against CD40 ligand (CD40L) prolongs survival and decreases the incidence of severe nephritis. In this report, we show that for (SWR × NZB)F1 (SNF1) animals with established lupus nephritis, long-term treatment with anti-CD40L beginning at either 5.5 or 7 mo of age prolonged survival and decreased the incidence of severe nephritis. “Older” mice were chosen for these studies to more closely resemble the clinical presentation of patients with established renal disease. We show that age at the start of treatment, which typically correlates with severity of disease, is an important factor when determining an efficacious therapeutic protocol since animals that began treatment at 7 mo of age required a more aggressive treatment protocol than animals at 5.5 mo of age. Remarkably, several anti-CD40L-treated animals beginning treatment at age 5.5 mo demonstrated a decline in proteinuria, as opposed to increasing proteinuria levels seen in hamster IgG (HIg)-treated controls, and histologic examination of kidneys from anti-CD40L-treated mice revealed dramatically diminished inflammation, sclerosis/fibrosis, and vasculitis, in marked contrast to the massive inflammation and kidney destruction observed in control animals that received hamster IgG. Spleens from anti-CD40L-treated mice also exhibited markedly reduced inflammation and fibrosis compared with controls. Together, these results show that treatment of older, nephritic SNF1 animals with long-term anti-CD40L immunotherapy significantly prolongs survival, reduces the severity of nephritis, and diminishes associated inflammation, vasculitis, and fibrosis.