A Model of Sister-Strand Crossing-Over

Sister chromatid exchanges in ring chromosomes following X‐irradiation of human lymphocytes

PURPOSE

To examine whether X-rays induce sister chromatid exchanges (SCE).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Peripheral lymphocytes irradiated in vitro or in vivo were cultured and treated with okadaic acid to generate premature chromosome condensation (PCC). When identical spreads were analysed using conventional Giemsa staining and pan-centromeric fluorescence in situ hybridization painting, ring chromosomes were observed.

RESULTS

In PCC preparations, cells in the late G(2) phase and late M phase were observed. In late M phase cells, 17-20% of ring chromosomes lacked one chromatid (single-chromatid ring), irrespective of dose. Both the distribution patterns of centromeres in rings and intercentromere distances in dicentric rings indicate that a considerable number of single-chromatid rings might be formed by SCE occurring in a chromosome-type ring, thereby joining strands of two rings, followed by a transformation into one ring. These single-chromatid rings were less stable in vivo than chromosome-type rings.

CONCLUSION

Single-chromatid rings visualized clearly using PCC techniques indicate SCE in the respective rings. Contrary to the conventional SCE-detecting technique, this approach does not require the use of bromodeoxyuridine, which itself leads to SCE. Some of the observed SCE might be secondary products resulting from the repair of radiation-induced DNA damage, while others may be spontaneous.

Dose-response function for Painter's SCE-model

The replication model for sister chromatid exchange (SCE), when introduced in 1980 by Painter, was claimed to be consistent with the one hit property of SCE. However, the argument offered in favour of the one hit property was based on a defective dose-response function, as shown in this paper, since dose as the independent parameter of any dose-response function was not included in the considerations. This missing part of the model's dose-response function is added and, by using Bessel functions, a formula for the complete dose-response function is presented. A re-examination of the newly derived function shows that, in the model, linearity holds only under certain restricted circumstances.