Two genes for threonine accumulation in barley seeds

High-lysine maize: the key discoveries that have made it possible

Forty-five years ago, a paper published by Mertz et al. (Science 145:279-280, 1964) initiated a revolution in the history of plant protein quality and affected dramatically the study of cereal crop storage proteins. The observation of the high lysine content of the endosperm of the opaque-2 (o2) maize mutant was a key factor in bringing about a new concept in the production of cereal seeds with a high nutritional value. It has been a long and very interesting road with astonishing results over these 45 years. We are now probably about to see the release of commercially engineered high-lysine maize lines. We have decided to pinpoint some key contributions to the science behind high-lysine plants and concentrated on the research done on maize, which is possibly the most complete and simple example to illustrate the advances achieved. However, studies on other plant species such as barley and model species such as tobacco are totally relevant and will be briefly addressed.

Arabidopsis loss-of-function mutant in the lysine pathway points out complex regulation mechanisms

In plants, the amino acids lysine, threonine, methionine and isoleucine have L-aspartate-beta-semialdehyde (ASA) as a common precursor in their biosynthesis pathways. How this ASA precursor is dispersed among the different pathways remains vague knowledge. The proportional balances of free and/or protein-bound lysine, threonine, isoleucine and methionine are a function of protein synthesis, secondary metabolism and plant physiology. Some control points determining the flux through the distinct pathways are known, but an adequate explanation of how the competing pathways share ASA in a fine-tuned amino acid biosynthesis network is yet not available. In this article we discuss the influence of lysine biosynthesis on the adjacent pathways of threonine and methionine. We report the finding of an Arabidopsis thaliana dihydrodipicolinate synthase T-DNA insertion mutant displaying lower lysine synthesis, and, as a result of this, a strongly enhanced synthesis of threonine. Consequences of these cross-pathway regulations are discussed.

Engineering of the aspartate family biosynthetic pathway in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) by transformation with heterologous genes encoding feed-back-insensitive aspartate kinase and dihydrodipicolinate synthase

In prokaryotes and plants the synthesis of the essential amino acids lysine and threonine is predominantly regulated by feed-back inhibition of aspartate kinase (AK) and dihydrodipicolinate synthase (DHPS). In order to modify the flux through the aspartate family pathway in barley and enhance the accumulation of the corresponding amino acids, we have generated transgenic barley plants that constitutively express mutant Escherichia coli genes encoding lysine feed-back insensitive forms of AK and DHPS. As a result, leaves of primary transformants (T0) exhibited a 14-fold increase of free lysine and an 8-fold increase in free methionine. In mature seeds of the DHPS transgenics, there was a 2-fold increase in free lysine, arginine and asparagine and a 50% reduction in free proline, while no changes were observed in the seeds of the two AK transgenic lines analysed. When compared to that of control seeds, no differences were observed in the composition of total amino acids. The introduced genes were inherited in the T1 generation where enzymic activities revealed a 2.3-fold increase of AK activity and a 4.0-9.5-fold increase for DHPS. T1 seeds of DHPS transformants showed the same changes in free amino acids as observed in T0 seeds. It is concluded that the aspartate family pathway may be genetically engineered by the introduction of genes coding for feed-back-insensitive enzymes, preferentially giving elevated levels of lysine and methionine.

Genetic and amino-acid analysis of two maize threonine-overproducing, lysine-insensitive aspartate kinase mutants

The aspartate-derived amino-acid pathway leads to the production of the essential amino-acids lysine, methionine, threonine and isoleucine. Aspartate kinase (AK) is the first enzyme in this pathway and exists in isoforms that are feedback inhibited by lysine and threonine. Two maize (Zea mays L.) threonine-overproducing, lysine-insensitive AK mutants (Ask1-LT19 and Ask2-LT20) were previously isolated. The present study was conducted to determine the map location of Ask2 and to examine the amino-acid profiles of the Ask mutants. The threonine-overproducing trait conferred by Ask2-LT20 was mapped to the long arm of chromosome 2. Both mutants exhibited increased free threonine concentrations (nmol/mg dry weight) over wild-type. The percent free threonine increased from approximately 2% in wild-type kernels to 37-54% of the total free amino-acid pool in homozygous mutant kernels. Free methionine concentrations also increased significantly in homozygous mutants. Free lysine concentrations were increased but to a much lesser extent than threonine or methionine. In contrast to previous studies, free aspartate concentrations were observed to decrease, indicating a possible limiting factor in threonine synthesis. Total (free plus protein-bound) amino-acid analyses demonstrated a consistent, significant increase in threonine, methionine and lysine concentrations in the homozygous mutants. Significant increases in protein-bound (total minus free) threonine, methionine and lysine were observed in the Ask mutants, indicating adequate protein sinks to incorporate the increased free amino-acid concentrations. Total amino-acid contents (nmol/kernel) were approximately the same for mutant and wild-type kernels. In five inbred lines both Ask mutations conferred the threonine-overproducing phenotype, indicating high expressivity in different genetic backgrounds. These analyses are discussed in the context of the regulation of the aspartate-derived amino-acid pathway.

Molecular analysis of the aspartate kinase-homoserine dehydrogenase gene from Arabidopsis thaliana

The gene encoding Arabidopsis thaliana aspartate kinase (ATP:L-aspartate 4-phosphotransferase, EC 2.7.2.4) was isolated from genomic DNA libraries using the carrot ak-hsdh gene as the hybridizing probe. Two genomic libraries from different A. thaliana races were screened independently with the ak probe and the hsdh probe. Nucleotide sequences of the A. thaliana overlapping clones were determined and encompassed 2 kb upstream of the coding region and 300 bp downstream. The corresponding cDNA was isolated from a cDNA library made from poly(A)(+)-mRNA extracted from cell suspension cultures. Sequence comparison between the Arabidopsis gene product and an AK-HSDH bifunctional enzyme from carrot and from the Escherichia coli thrA and metL genes shows 80%, 37.5% and 31.4% amino acid sequence identity, respectively. The A. thaliana ak-hsdh gene is proposed to be the plant thrA homologue coding for the AK isozyme feedback inhibited by threonine. The gene is present in A. thaliana in single copy and functional as evidenced by hybridization analyses. The apoprotein-coding region is interrupted by 15 introns ranging from 78 to 134 bp. An upstream chloroplast-targeting sequence with low sequence similarity with the carrot transit peptide was identified. A signal sequence is proposed starting from a functional ATG initiation codon to the first exon of the apoprotein. Two additional introns were identified: one in the 5' non-coding leader sequence and the other in the putative chloroplast targeting sequence. 5' sequence analysis revealed the presence of several possible promoter elements as well as conserved regulatory motifs. Among these, an Opaque2 and a yeast GCN4-like recognition element might be relevant for such a gene coding for an enzyme limiting the carbon-flux entry to the biosynthesis of several essential amino acids. 3' sequence analysis showed the occurrence of two polyadenylation signals upstream of the polyadenylation site. This work is the first report of the molecular cloning of a plant ak-hsdh genomic sequence. It describes a promoter element that may bring new insights to the regulation of the biosynthesis of the aspartate family of amino acids.

Concerted regulation of lysine and threonine synthesis in tobacco plants expressing bacterial feedback-insensitive aspartate kinase and dihydrodipicolinate synthase

The essential amino acids lysine and threonine are synthesized in higher plants by two separate branches of a common pathway. This pathway is primarily regulated by three key enzymes, namely aspartate kinase (AK), dihydrodipicolinate synthase (DHPS) and homoserine dehydrogenase (HSD), but how these enzymes operate in concert is as yet unknown. Addressing this issue, we have expressed in transgenic tobacco plants high levels of bacterial AK and DHPS, which are much less sensitive to feedback inhibition by lysine and threonine than their plant counterparts. Such expression of the bacterial DHPS by itself resulted in a substantial overproduction of lysine, whereas plants expressing only the bacterial AK overproduced threonine. When both bacterial enzymes were expressed in the same plant, the level of free lysine exceeded by far the level obtained by the bacterial DHPS alone. This increase, however, was accompanied by a significant reduction in threonine accumulation compared to plants expressing the bacterial AK alone. Our results suggested that in tobacco plants the synthesis of both lysine and threonine is under a concerted regulation exerted by AK, DHPS, and possibly also by HSD. We propose that the balance between lysine and threonine synthesis is determined by competition between DHPS and HSD on limiting amounts of their common substrate 3-aspartic semialdehyde, whose level, in turn, is determined primarily by the activity of AK. The potential of this molecular approach to increase the nutritional quality of plants is discussed.

Regulation of lysine synthesis in transgenic potato plants expressing a bacterial dihydrodipicolinate synthase in their chloroplasts

The essential amino acid lysine is synthesized in higher plants by a complex pathway that is predominantly regulated by feedback inhibition of two enzymes, namely aspartate kinase (AK) and dihydrodipicolinate synthase (DHPS). Although DHPS is thought to play a major role in this regulation, the relative importance of AK is not known. In order to study this regulation, we have expressed in the chloroplasts of transgenic potato plants a DHPS derived from Escherichia coli at a level 50-fold above the endogenous DHPS. The bacterial enzyme is much less sensitive to lysine inhibition than its potato counterpart. DHPS activity in leaves, roots and tubers of the transgenic plants was considerably higher and more resistant to lysine inhibition than in control untransformed plants. Furthermore, this activity was accompanied by a significant increase in level of free lysine in all three tissues. Yet, the extent of lysine overproduction in potato leaves was significantly lower than that previously reported in leaves of transgenic plants expressing the same bacterial enzyme, suggesting that in potato, AK may also play a major regulatory role in lysine biosynthesis. Indeed, the elevated level of free lysine in the transgenic potato plants was shown to inhibit the lysine-sensitive AK activity in vivo. Our results support previous reports showing that DHPS is the major rate-limiting enzyme for lysine synthesis in higher plants, but they suggest that additional plant-specific regulatory factors are also involved.

High threonine producer mutant ofNicotiana sylvestris (Spegg. and Comes)

Mutagenesis and the subsequent selection of mesophyll diploid protoplasts ofNicotiana sylvestris on growth inhibitory concentrations of lysine plus threonine has led to the isolation of an LT-resistant mutant. Regeneration of this line (RLT 70) and analysis of its descendants demonstrated the dominant monogenic nuclear character of the resistance gene, further namedak-LT1. When the inhibition properties of aspartate kinase were examined in the homozygous mutant, lysine-sensitive activity could no longer be detected. In comparison, 70%-80% of the wild-type enzyme activity was usually inhibited by lysine, and the rest by threonine. Evidence for the existence of at least two AK isoenzymes was obtained by ion-exchange chromatography, where two peaks of activity could be detected: the first one to be eluted is lysine sensitive, and the second one threonine sensitive. One consequence of the altered regulation of AK in the mutant was the enhanced production of soluble threonine. Threonine accumulation was observed to occur throughout the life cycle of the mutant plant as well as in its different organs. In particular, leaves exhibited a 45-fold increment of soluble threonine, which corresponds to a 13-fold increase in total threonine: almost one-third of the total amino acids was free and proteinbound threonine. In RLT 70 seeds, 20% of the free amino acid pool was in the form of threonine (70-fold accumulation compared to the wild type), and total threonine content was increased five fold. As a general rule, the other amino acids were also more abundant in RLT 70 seeds, such that the total of amino acids present was between two to four times higher, but in contrast with the situation encountered in leaves, this was also due to a higher protein-bound amino acid content.

Selection and characterization of a rice mutant resistant to 5-methyltryptophan

A rice plant resistant to 5-methyltryptophan (5MT) was selected from mutagenized M3 seeds (Oryza sativa L. var. Sasanishiki) originating from panicles treated with ethylene imine (0.2%) 2 h after flowering. When germinated on 5MT-containing medium, the seeds (M4) from selfed plants segregated with a 3 resistant:1 sensitive ratio, indicating that the plant was heterozygous for a resistance gene and that the resistance was dominant. The resistance was also expressed in callus derived from seeds. Analysis of the free amino acids in seeds, seedlings, and calli showed that homozygous resistant plants (TR1) contained higher levels of total free amino acids than sensitive plants. In particular the levels of tryptophan, phenylalanine, and histidine were, respectively, 8.5, 5.4, and 4.9 times higher than those in the sensitive plants.

Lysine-insensitive aspartate kinase in two threonine-overproducing mutants of maize

Aspartate kinase (AK; EC 2.7.2.A) catalyzes the first reaction in the biosynthesis pathway for aspartate-derived amino acids in plants. Aspartate kinase was purified from wildtype and two maize (Zea mays L.) genotypes carrying unlinked dominant mutations,Ask LT19 andAsk2 -LT20, that conferred overproduction of threonine, lysine, methionine and isoleucine. The objective of this investigation was to characterize the AKs from mutant and wildtype plants to determine their role in regulating the synthesis of aspartate-derived amino acids in maize. Kernels of the homozygousAsk2 mutant exhibited 174-, 10-, 13- and 2-fold increases in, in this sequence, free threonine, lysine, methionine and isoleucine, compared to wildtype. In wildtype maize, AK was allosterically feedback-inhibited by lysine with 10 μML-lysine required for 50% inhibition. In contrast, AK purified from the isogenic heterozygousAsk and homozygousAsk2 mutants required 25 and 760 μM lysine for 50% inhibition, respectively, indicating thatAsk andAsk2 were separate structural loci for lysine-regulated AK subunits in maize. Further characterization of purified AK from the homozygous mutantAsk2 line indicated altered substrate and lysine inhibition kinetics. The apparent Hill coefficient was 0.7 for the mutantAsk2 AK compared with 1.6 for the wildtype enzyme, indicating that the mutant allele conferred the loss of a lysinebinding site to the mutant AK. Lysine appeared to be a linear noncompetitive inhibitor ofAsk2 AK with respect to MgATP and an uncompetitive inhibitor with respect to aspartate compared to S-parabolic, I parabolic noncompetitive inhibition of wildtype AK. Reduced lysine sensitivity of theAsk2 gene product appeared to reduce the lysine inhibition of all of the AK activity detected in homozygousAsk2 plants, indicating that maize AK is a heteromeric enzyme consisting of the two lysine-sensitive polypeptides derived from theAsk andAsk2 structural genes.

Tissue culture isolation of a second mutant locus for increased threonine accumulation in maize

Regenerable maize (Zea mays L.) tissue cultures were selected for ability to grow in the presence of inhibitory (1.0-1.5 mM) concentrations of L-lysine plus L-threonine. Testcross kernels from one regenerated plant (LT20) segregated for wild-type and high free threonine concentration in a 1∶1 ratio consistent with a single dominant gene for high free threonine. Free threonine concentrations (nmol/mg dry weight) increased an average of 29-fold in bulked F2 kernel samples from heterozygous mutant plants, and the total (free plus protein-bound) threonine concentration increased 68%. Increases in protein-bound methionine, lysine and glycine concentrations were also noted, suggesting a possible effect of the mutation on protein concentration and composition. Allelism tests with a previously selected mutant line, Ltr (*)19, showed that two unlinked, codominant genes conditioned the high free threonine phenotype. Based on a separate study of aspartate kinase feedback inhibition characteristics in the two mutant lines, we propose that the mutant alleles [gene and allele designations are according to guidelines for maize genetic nomenclature (Burnham et al. 1975)] be designated Ask-LT19 and Ask2-LT20 for the Ltr (*)19 and LT20 mutants, respectively.

Differential metabolism of sodium azide in maize callus and germinating embryos

Sodium azide is a potent mutagen of maize (Zea mays L.) kernels that may have potential as a point mutagen for inducing biochemical mutations in maize tissue cultures. Azide mutagenicity was evaluated in friable, embryogenic maize callus and a nonregenerable maize suspension culture by determining the number of resistant variant cell lines able to grow on media containing inhibitory concentrations of lysine plus threonine (LT). The number of LT-resistant variants selected from either culture type did not increase in response to azide treatment. In addition, there was no increase in somatic mutations in more than 100 plants regenerated from azide treated LT-resistant lines. The levels of mutagenic metabolite of azide (presumably azidoalanine), were determined by bioassay in the two azide-treated maize callus types and compared to levels of mutagenic metabolite in embryos isolated from azide-treated kernels. The two types of maize tissue cultures and isolated embryos contained similar levels of mutagenic metabolite 4 h after azide treatment indicating similar uptake and conversion of azide to mutagenic metabolite in the three tissues. Mutagenic metabolite in azide-treated embryos did not significantly decrease after 40 h. However, mutagenic metabolite levels in both azide-treated tissue cultures decreased to near background levels within 20 h providing evidence for rapid metabolism of the azide mutagenic metabolite. The lack of evidence for azide mutagenicity in maize callus and its known potent mutagenicity in kernels appears to be associated with specific differences in azide metabolism between callus tissues and kernel embryos.

Free proline contents in two different groups of rice mutants resistant to hydroxy-L-proline

In four rice (Oryza sativa L.) mutants resistant to hydroxy-L-proline (Hyp), HYP101, HYP203, HYP205 and HYP210, and in their original variety, Nipponbare, free proline and Hyp contents in the seeds and in the 14-day-old seedlings have been determined. The four mutants can be divided into two groups: HYP101 and HYP203 are classified as to recessive gene and the levels of free proline are similar to that of the original variety; the second group includes mutants HYP205 and HYP210 where the Hyp resistance is transmitted heterozygously and, both in the seeds and in the seedlings, a remarkable increase in free proline content is observed. In particular, free proline contents in the seeds of HYP205 and HYP210 are, respectively, 24 and 12 times that of the original variety. Hyp is detected only in the seedlings cultured with Hyp solution. In the Hyp resistant seedlings of HYP205 and HYP210, Hyp contents are twice that of the original variety and less than half in the seedlings of HYP101 and HYP203. Hyp resistance and differential proline levels are also evident in the callus initiated from the mutants. This suggests that the Hyp resistant mutants are good genetic markers both in planta and in vitro. The Hyp mutants are also discussed with regard to stress resistance.

Feedback-insensitive aspartate kinase isoenzymes in barley mutants resistant to lysine plus threonine

The regulatory properties of aspartate kinase (EC 2.7.2.4) and homoserine dehydrogenase (EC 1.1.1.3) in two barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) mutants resistant to growth inhibition by lysine plus threonine, Rothamsted (R) 3004 and R3202, were compared with those in the normal, sensitive parent line cv. Bomi. Three forms of aspartate kinase (AKI, AKII, AKIII) were chromatographically separated and were considered to represent at least three independently regulated isoenzymes. Aspartate kinase I was inhibited by threonine; AKII and AKIII by lysine or lysine plus S-adenosylmethionine. The characteristics of AKI were unchanged in the mutants. Aspartate kinase II and AKIII from Bomi were both inhibited by lysine and by lysine plus S-adenosylmethionine. Aspartate kinase II from mutant R3202 was altered in its properties such that it was insensitive to lysine or lysine plus S-adenosylmethionine; AKII from mutant R3004 did not differ in its properties from AKII of Bomi. The concentration of lysine required to give half maximal inhibition of AKIII from R3004 was ten times that required for AKIII of Bomi; AKIII from R3202 did not differ from that of Bomi in this regard. There was no change in the properties of homoserine dehydrogenase of the mutants as compared with that of Bomi. We conclude that the lt1 and lt2 loci code for structural genes for lysine- and lysine plus S-adenosylmethionine-sensitive aspartate kinase isoenzymes. The mutant genes Lt1b and Lt2 in R3202 and R3004 respectively code for feedback-desensitized isoenzymes. The presence of one of these is sufficient to allow the synthesis of methionine to overcome the growth inhibition by lysine plus threonine.