Changing the binding specificity of a repressor by redesigning an alpha-helix

Extensive DNA-binding specificity divergence of a conserved transcription regulator

The DNA sequence recognized by a transcription regulator can be conserved across large evolutionary distances. For example, it is known that many homologous regulators in yeasts and mammals can recognize the same (or closely related) DNA sequences. In contrast to this paradigm, we describe a case in which the DNA-binding specificity of a transcription regulator has changed so extensively (and over a much smaller evolutionary distance) that its cis-regulatory sequence appears unrelated in different species. Bioinformatic, genetic, and biochemical approaches were used to document and analyze a major change in the DNA-binding specificity of Matα1, a regulator of cell-type specification in ascomycete fungi. Despite this change, Matα1 controls the same core set of genes in the hemiascomycetes because its DNA recognition site has evolved with it, preserving the protein-DNA interaction but significantly changing its molecular details. Matα1 and its recognition sequence diverged most dramatically in the common ancestor of the CTG-clade (Candida albicans, Candida lusitaniae, and related species), apparently without the aid of a gene duplication event. Our findings suggest that DNA-binding specificity divergence between orthologous transcription regulators may be more prevalent than previously thought and that seemingly unrelated cis-regulatory sequences can nonetheless be homologous. These findings have important implications for understanding transcriptional network evolution and for the bioinformatic analysis of regulatory circuits.

Inhibition of superinfection and the evolution of viral latency

Latent viruses generally defend their host cell against superinfection by nonlatent virulent mutants that could destroy the host cell. Superinfection inhibition thus seems to be a prerequisite for the maintenance of viral latency. Yet viral latency can break down when resistance to superinfection inhibition, known as ultravirulence, occurs. To understand the evolution of viral latency, we have developed a model that analyzes the epidemiology of latent infection in the face of ultravirulence. We show that latency can be maintained when superinfection inhibition and resistance against it coevolve in an arms race, which can result in large fluctuations in virulence. An example is the coevolution of the virulence and superinfection repressor protein of phage lambda (cI) and its binding target, the lambda oLoR operator. We show that this repressor/operator coevolution is the driving force for the evolution of superinfection immunity groups. Beyond latent phages, we predict analogous dynamics for any latent virus that uses a single repressor for the simultaneous control of virulence and superinfection.

Engineering transcription factors with novel DNA-binding specificity using comparative genomics

The transcriptional program for a gene consists of the promoter necessary for recruiting RNA polymerase along with neighboring operator sites that bind different activators and repressors. From a synthetic biology perspective, if the DNA-binding specificity of these proteins can be changed, then they can be used to reprogram gene expression in cells. While many experimental methods exist for generating such specificity-altering mutations, few computational approaches are available, particularly in the case of bacterial transcription factors. In a previously published computational study of nitrogen oxide metabolism in bacteria, a small number of amino-acid residues were found to determine the specificity within the CRP (cAMP receptor protein)/FNR (fumarate and nitrate reductase regulatory protein) family of transcription factors. By analyzing how these amino acids vary in different regulators, a simple relationship between the identity of these residues and their target DNA-binding sequence was constructed. In this article, we experimentally tested whether this relationship could be used to engineer novel DNA–protein interactions. Using Escherichia coli CRP as a template, we tested eight designs based on this relationship and found that four worked as predicted. Collectively, these results in this work demonstrate that comparative genomics can inform the design of bacterial transcription factors.

Specificity in two-component signal transduction pathways

Two-component signal transduction systems enable bacteria to sense, respond, and adapt to a wide range of environments, stressors, and growth conditions. In the prototypical two-component system, a sensor histidine kinase catalyzes its autophosphorylation and then subsequently transfers the phosphoryl group to a response regulator, which can then effect changes in cellular physiology, often by regulating gene expression. The utility of these signaling systems is underscored by their prevalence throughout the bacterial kingdom and by the fact that many bacteria contain dozens, or sometimes hundreds, of these signaling proteins. The presence of so many highly related signaling proteins in individual cells creates both an opportunity and a challenge. Do cells take advantage of the similarity between signaling proteins to integrate signals or diversify responses, and thereby enhance their ability to process information? Conversely, how do cells prevent unwanted cross-talk and maintain the insulation of distinct pathways? Here we address both questions by reviewing the cellular and molecular mechanisms that dictate the specificity of two-component signaling pathways.

Targeted chemical wedges reveal the role of allosteric DNA modulation in protein-DNA assembly

The cooperative assembly of multiprotein complexes results from allosteric modulations of DNA structure as well as direct intermolecular contacts between proteins. Such cooperative binding plays a critical role in imparting exquisite sequence specificity on the homeobox transcription factor (Hox) family of developmental transcription factors. A well-characterized example includes the interaction of Hox proteins with extradenticle (Exd), a highly conserved DNA binding transcription factor. Although direct interactions are important, the contribution of indirect interactions toward cooperative assembly of Hox and Exd remains unresolved. Here we use minor groove binding polyamides as structural wedges to induce perturbations at specific base steps within the Exd binding site. We find that allosteric modulation of DNA structure contributes nearly 1.5 kcal/mol to the binding of Exd to DNA, even in the absence of direct Hox contacts. In contrast to previous studies, the sequence-targeted chemical wedges reveal the role of DNA geometry in cooperative assembly of Hox-Exd complexes. Programmable polyamides may well serve as general probes to investigate the role of DNA modulation in the cooperative and highly specific assembly of other protein-DNA complexes.

The GCN4 bZIP targets noncognate gene regulatory sequences: quantitative investigation of binding at full and half sites

We previously reported that a basic region/leucine zipper (bZIP) protein, a hybrid of the GCN4 basic region and C/EBP leucine zipper, not only recognizes cognate target sites AP-1 (5'-TGACTCA-3') and cAMP-response element (CRE) (5'-TGACGTCA-3') but also binds selectively to noncognate DNA sites: C/EBP (CCAAT/enhancer binding protein, 5'-TTGCGCAA), XRE1 (xenobiotic response element, 5'-TTGCGTGA), HRE (HIF response element, 5'-GCACGTAG), and E-box (5'-CACGTG). In this work, we used electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA) and circular dichroism (CD) for more extensive characterization of the binding of wt bZIP dimer to noncognate sites as well as full- and half-site derivatives, and we examined changes in flanking sequences. Quantitative EMSA titrations were used to measure dissociation constants of this hybrid, wt bZIP, to DNA duplexes: Full-site binding affinities gradually decrease from cognate sites AP-1 and CRE with Kd values of 13 and 12 nM, respectively, to noncognate sites with Kd values of 120 nM to low microM. DNA-binding selectivity at half sites is maintained; however, half-site binding affinities sharply decrease from the cognate half site (Kd = 84 nM) to noncognate half sites (all Kd values > 2 microM). CD shows that comparable levels of alpha-helical structure are induced in wt bZIP upon binding to cognate AP-1 or noncognate sites. Thus, noncognate sites may contribute to preorganization of stable protein structure before binding target DNA sites. This work demonstrates that the bZIP scaffold may be a powerful tool in the design of small, alpha-helical proteins with desired DNA recognition properties.

Characterization of the lytic–lysogenic switch of the lactococcal bacteriophage Tuc2009

Tuc2009 is a temperate bacteriophage of Lactococcus lactis subsp. cremoris UC509 which encodes a CI- and Cro-type lysogenic-lytic switch region. A helix-swap of the alpha3 helices of the closely related CI-type proteins from the lactococcal phages r1t and Tuc2009 revealed the crucial elements involved in DNA recognition while also pointing to conserved functional properties of phage CI proteins infecting different hosts. CI-type proteins have been shown to bind to specific sequences located in the intergenic switch region, but to date, no detailed binding studies have been performed on lactococcal Cro analogues. Experiments shown here demonstrate alternative binding sites for these two proteins of Tuc2009. CI2009 binds to three inverted repeats, two within the intergenic region and one within the cro2009 gene. This DNA-binding pattern appears to be conserved among repressors of lactococcal and streptococcal phages. The Cro2009 protein appears to bind to three direct repeats within the intergenic region causing distortion of the bound DNA.

Altered specificity in DNA binding by the lac repressor: a mutant lac headpiece that mimics the gal repressor

Recognition of the lac operator by the lac repressor involves specific interactions between residues in the repressor's recognition helix and bases in the DNA major groove. Tyr17 and Gln18, at positions 1 and 2 in the lac repressor recognition helix, can be exchanged for other amino acids to generate mutant repressors that display altered specificity. We have solved the solution structure of a protein-DNA complex of an altered-specificity mutant lac headpiece in which Tyr17 and Gln18 were exchanged for valine and alanine, respectively, as found in the recognition helix of the gal repressor. As previously described by Lehming et al. (EMBO J. 1987, 6, 3145-3153), this altered-specificity mutant of the lac repressor recognizes a variant lac operator that is similar to the gal operator Oe. The mutant lac headpiece showed the predicted specificity and is also able to mimic the gal repressor by recognizing and bending the natural gal operator Oe. These structural data show that, while most of the anchoring points that help the lac headpiece to assemble on the lac operator were preserved, a different network of protein-DNA interactions connecting Ala17 and Val18 to bases in the DNA major groove drives the specificity towards the altered operator.

Switching DNA-binding specificity by unnatural amino acid substitution

The specificity of protein–nucleic acid recognition is believed to originate largely from hydrogen bonding between protein polar atoms, primarily side-chain and polar atoms of nucleic acid bases. One way to design new nucleic acid binding proteins of novel specificity is by structure-guided alterations of the hydrogen bonding patterns of a nucleic acid–protein complex. We have used cI repressor of bacteriophage λ as a model system. In the λ-repressor–DNA complex, the ɛ-NH₂ group (hydrogen bond donor) of lysine-4 of λ-repressor forms hydrogen bonds with the amide carbonyl atom of asparagine-55 (acceptor) and the O6 (acceptor) of CG6 of operator site O_L1. Substitution of lysine-4 (two donors) by iso-steric S-(2-hydroxyethyl)-cysteine (one donor and one acceptor), by site-directed mutagenesis and chemical modification, leads to switch of binding specificity of λ-repressor from C:G to T:A at position 6 of O_L1. This suggests that unnatural amino acid substitutions could be a simple way of generating nucleic acid binding proteins of altered specificity.

Sequence correlations between Cro recognition helices and cognate O(R) consensus half-sites suggest conserved rules of protein-DNA recognition

The O(R) regions from several lambdoid bacteriophages contain the three regulatory sites O(R)1, O(R)2 and O(R)3, to which the Cro and CI proteins can bind. These sites show imperfect dyad symmetry, have similar sequences, and generally lie on the same face of the DNA double helix. We have developed a computational method, which analyzes the O(R) regions of additional phages and predicts the location of these three sites. After tuning the method to predict known O(R) sites accurately, we used it to predict unknown sites, and ultimately compiled a database of 32 known and predicted O(R) binding site sets. We then identified sequences of the recognition helices (RH) for the cognate Cro proteins through manual inspection of multiple sequence alignments. Comparison of Cro RH and consensus O(R) half-site sequences revealed strong one-to-one correlations between two amino acids at each of three RH positions and two bases at each of three half-site positions (H1-->2, H3-->5 and H6-->6). In each of these three cases, one of the two amino acid/base-pairings corresponds to a contact observed in the crystal structure of a lambda Cro/consensus operator complex. The alternate amino acid/base combinations were rationalized using structural models. We suggest that the pairs of amino acid residues act as binary switches that efficiently modulate specificity for different consensus half-site variants during evolution. The observation of structurally reasonable amino acid-to-base correlations suggests that Cro proteins share some common rules of recognition despite their functional and structural diversity.

Purification and characterization of the repressor of the shiga toxin-encoding bacteriophage 933W: DNA binding, gene regulation, and autocleavage

The genes encoding Shiga toxin (stx), the major virulence factor of Shiga toxin-encoding Escherichia coli (STEC) strains, are carried on lambdoid prophages resident in all known STEC strains. The stx genes are expressed only during lytic growth of these temperate bacteriophages. We cloned the gene encoding the repressor of the Shiga toxin-encoding bacteriophage 933W and examined the DNA binding and transcriptional regulatory activities of the overexpressed, purified protein. Typical of nearly all lambdoid phage repressors, 933W repressor binds to three sites in 933W right operator (OR). Also typical, when bound at OR, 933W repressor functions as an activator at the PRM promoter and a repressor at the PR promoter. In contrast to other lambdoid bacteriophages, 933W left operator (OL) contains only two repressor binding sites, but the OL-bound repressor still efficiently represses PL transcription. Lambdoid prophage induction requires inactivation of the repressor's DNA binding activity. In all phages examined thus far, this inactivation requires a RecA-stimulated repressor autoproteolysis event, with cleavage occurring precisely in an Ala-Gly dipeptide sequence that is found within a "linker " region that joins the two domains of these proteins. However, 933W repressor protein contains neither an Ala-Gly nor an alternative Cys-Gly dipeptide cleavage site anywhere in its linker sequence. We show here that the autocleavage occurs at a Leu-Gly dipeptide. Thus, the specificity of the repressor autocleavage site is more variable than thought previously.

DNA-mediated assembly of weakly interacting DNA-binding protein subunits: in vitro recruitment of phage 434 repressor and yeast GCN4 DNA-binding domains

The specificity of DNA-mediated protein assembly was studied in two in vitro systems, based on (i) the DNA-binding domain of bacteriophage 434 repressor cI (amino acid residues 1-69), or (ii) the DNA-binding domain of the yeast transcription factor GCN4, (amino acids 1-34) and their respective oligonucleotide cognates. In vivo, both of these peptides are part of larger protein molecules that also contain dimerization domains, and the resulting dimers recognize cognate palindromic DNA sequences that contain two half-sites of 4 bp each. The dimerization domains were not included in the peptides tested, so in solution-in the presence or absence of non-cognate DNA oligonucleotides-these molecules did not show appreciable dimerization, as determined by pyrene excimer fluorescence spectroscopy and oxidative cross-linking monitored by mass spectrometry. Oligonucleotides with only one 4 bp cognate half-site were able to initiate measurable dimerization, and two half-sites were able to select specific dimers even from a heterogeneous pool of molecules of closely related specificity (such as DNA-binding domains of the 434 repressor and their engineered mutants that mimic the binding helix of the related P22 phage repressor). The fluorescent technique allowed us to separately monitor the unspecific, ionic interaction of the peptides with DNA which produced a roughly similar signal in the case of both cognate and non-cognate oligonucleotides. But in the former case, a concomitant excimer fluorescence signal showed the formation of correctly positioned dimers. The results suggest that DNA acts as a highly specific template for the recruitment of weakly interacting protein molecules that can thus build up highly specific complexes.

Engineering proteins that bind, move, make and break DNA

Recent protein engineering efforts have generated artificial transcription factors that bind new target DNA sequences and enzymes that modify DNA at new target sites. Zinc-finger-based transcription factors are favored targets for design; important technological advances in their construction and numerous biotechnological applications have been reported. Other notable advances include the generation of endonucleases and recombinases with altered specificities, made by innovative combinatorial and evolutionary protein engineering strategies. An unexpectedly high tolerance to mutation in the active sites of DNA polymerases is being exploited to engineer polymerases to incorporate artificial nucleotides or to display other, nonnatural activities.

Sequence-specific recognition of DNA by hydrophobic, alanine-rich mutants of the basic region/leucine zipper motif investigated by fluorescence anisotropy

We generated minimalist proteins capable of sequence-specific, high-affinity binding of DNA to probe how proteins are used and can be used to recognize DNA. In order to quantify binding affinities and specificities in our protein-DNA system, we used fluorescence anisotropy to measure in situ the thermodynamics of binding of alanine-rich mutants of the GCN4 basic region/leucine zipper (bZIP) domain to DNA duplexes containing target sites AP-1 (5'-TGACTCA-3') or ATF/CREB (5'-TGACGTCA-3'). We simplified the alpha-helical bZIP molecular recognition scaffold by alanine substitution: 4A, 11A, and 18A contain four, eleven, and eighteen alanine mutations in their DNA-binding basic regions, respectively. DNase I footprinting analysis demonstrates that all bZIP mutants retain the sequence-specific DNA-binding function of native GCN4 bZIP. Titration of fluorescein-labeled oligonucleotide duplexes with increasing amounts of protein yielded low nanomolar dissociation constants for all bZIP mutants in complex with the AP-1 and ATF/CREB sites: binding to the nonspecific control duplex was > 1000-fold weaker. Remarkably, the most heavily mutated protein 18A, containing 24 alanines in its 27-residue basic region, still binds AP-1 and ATF/CREB with dissociation constants of 15 and 7.8 nM, respectively. Similarly, wild-type bZIP binds these sites with K(d) values of 9.1 and 14 nM. 11A also displays low nanomolar dissociation constants for AP-1 and ATF/CREB, while 4A binds these sites with approximately 10-fold weaker K(d) values. Thus, both DNA-binding specificity and affinity are maintained in all our bZIP derivatives. This Ala-rich scaffold may be useful in design and synthesis of small alpha-helical proteins with desired DNA-recognition properties capable of serving as therapeutics targeting transcription.

DNA binding and bending to initiate packaging of phage lambda DNA

Physical and genetic studies verify that the DNA binding domain of protein gpNu1 (which initiates packaging of phage lambda DNA) is a winged helix-turn-helix (w HTH) and that gpNu1 dimers bind sites that are brought close through DNA bending.

Design and selection of novel Cys2His2 zinc finger proteins

Cys2His2 zinc finger proteins offer a stable and versatile framework for the design of proteins that recognize desired target sites on double-stranded DNA. Individual fingers from these proteins have a simple beta beta alpha structure that folds around a central zinc ion, and tandem sets of fingers can contact neighboring subsites of 3-4 base pairs along the major groove of the DNA. Although there is no simple, general code for zinc finger-DNA recognition, selection strategies have been developed that allow these proteins to be targeted to almost any desired site on double-stranded DNA. The affinity and specificity of these new proteins can also be improved by linking more fingers together or by designing proteins that bind as dimers and thus recognize an extended site. These new proteins can then be modified by adding other domains--for activation or repression of transcription, for DNA cleavage, or for other activities. Such designer transcription factors and other new proteins will have important applications in biomedical research and in gene therapy.

Modular construction of extended DNA recognition surfaces: mutant DNA-binding domains of the 434 repressor as building blocks

Single-chain derivatives of the 434 repressor containing one wild-type and one mutant DNA-binding domain recognize the general operator ACAA-6 base pairs-NNNN, where the ACAA operator subsite is contacted by the wild-type and the NNNN tetramer by the mutant domain. The DNA-binding specificities of several single-chain mutants were studied in detail and the optimal subsites of the mutant domains were determined. The characterized mutant domains were used as building units to obtain homo- and heterodimeric single-chain derivatives. The DNA-binding properties of these domain-shuffled derivatives were tested with a series of designed operators of NNNN-6 base pairs-NNNN type. It was found that the binding specificities of the mutant domains were generally maintained in the new environments and the binding affinities for the optimal DNA ligands were high (with K(d) values in the range of 10(-11)-10(-10) M). Considering that only certain sequence motifs in place of the six base pair spacer can support optimal contacts between the mutant domains and their subsites, the single-chain 434 repressor mutants are highly specific for a limited subset of 14 base pair long DNA targets.

Target recognition by EcoKI: the recognition domain is robust and restriction-deficiency commonly results from the proteolytic control of enzyme activity

We report a genetic and biochemical analysis of a target recognition domain (TRD) of EcoKI, a type I restriction and modification enzyme. The TRDs of type I R-M systems are within the specificity subunit (HsdS) and HsdS confers sequence specificity to a complex endowed with both restriction and modification activities. Random mutagenesis has revealed that most substitutions within the amino TRD of EcoKI, a region comprising 157 amino acid residues, have no detectable effect on the phenotype of the bacterium, even when the substitutions are non- conservative. The structure of the TRD appears to be robust. All but one of the six substitutions that confer a restriction-deficient, modification-deficient (r(-)m(-)) phenotype were found to be in the interval between residues 80 and 110, a region predicted by sequence comparisons to form part of the protein-DNA interface. Additional site-directed mutations affecting this interval commonly impair both restriction and modification. However, we show that an r(-) phenotype cannot be taken as evidence that the EcoKI complex lacks endonuclease activity; in response to even a slightly impaired modification efficiency, the endonuclease activity of EcoKI is destroyed by a process dependent upon the ClpXP protease. Enzymes from mutants with an r(-)m(-) phenotype commonly retain some sequence-specific activity; methylase activity can be detected on hemimethylated DNA substrates and residual endonuclease activity is implied whenever the viability of the r(-)m(-) bacterium is dependent on ClpXP. Conversely, the viability of ClpX(-) r(-)m(-) bacteria can be used as evidence for little, or no, endonuclease activity. Of 14 mutants with an r(-)m(-) phenotype, only six are viable in the absence of ClpXP. The significance of four of the six residues (G91, G105, F107 and G141) is enhanced by the finding that even conservative substitutions for these residues impair modification, thereby conferring an r(-)m(-) phenotype.

BglII and MunI: what a difference a base makes

Restriction endonucleases are resilient to alterations in their DNA-binding specificities. Structures of the BglII and MunI endonucleases bound to their palindromic DNA sites, which differ by only their outer base pairs from the recognition sequences of BamHI and EcoRI, respectively, have recently been determined. A comparison of these complexes reveals surprising differences and similarities in structure, and provides a basis for understanding the immutability of restriction endonucleases.

Construction of protein binding sites in scaffold structures

We have developed a strategy for grafting a protein-protein interface based on the known crystal structure of a native ligand and receptor proteins in a complex. The key interaction residues at the ligand protein binding interface are transferred onto a scaffold protein so that the mutated scaffold protein will bind the receptor protein in the same manner as the ligand protein. First, our method identifies key residues and atoms in the ligand protein, which strongly interact with the receptor protein. Second, this method searches the scaffold protein for combinations of candidate residues, among which the distance between any two candidate residues is similar to that between relevant key interaction residues in the ligand protein. These candidate residues are mutated to key interaction residues in the ligand protein respectively. The scaffold protein is superposed onto the ligand protein based upon the coordinates of corresponding atoms, which are assumed to strongly interact with the receptor protein. Complementarity between scaffold and receptor proteins is evaluated. Scaffold proteins with a low superposing rms difference and high complementary score are accepted for further analysis. Then, the relative position of the scaffold protein is adjusted so that the interfaces between the scaffold and receptor proteins have a reasonable packing density. Other mutations are also considered to reduce the desolvation energy or bad steric contacts. Finally, the scaffold protein is cominimized with the receptor protein and evaluated. To test the method, the binding interface of barstar, the inhibitor of barnase, was grafted onto small proteins. Four scaffold proteins with high complementary scores are accepted.

A comparative study of the immunity region of lambdoid phages including Shiga-toxin-converting phages: molecular basis for cross immunity

Comparison of eight lambdoid phages, including three Shiga-toxin converting phages, has been carried out with respect to the immunity region, especially the recognition helices of their repressor and CRO proteins on the one hand, and operator sequences on the other. Some as yet unassigned components of the regulatory circuits have been inferred by computer search. The cross immunity phenomenon shown by phages VT2-Sa and lambda is explained on the basis of similarity in their sequences. In addition, the similarity of 933W and HK022 in the sequences of their recognition helices of repressor and CRO, on the one hand, and operators, on the other, has led us to predict that they will have identical or similar immunity specificity. This homology has enabled us also to locate the OL (and consequently PL) of phage 933W that has been thought to be non-existent.

DNA-induced conformational changes in bacteriophage 434 repressor

Although bacteriophage 434 repressor binds to its specific DNA sites only as a dimer, formation of the dimers in solution occurs at concentrations three orders of magnitude higher than those needed to bind the 434 operator DNA. Our results suggest that both specific and non-specific DNA induce conformational changes in repressor that lead to formation of repressor dimers. The repressor conformational changes induced by DNA occur at concentrations much lower than those needed for binding of repressor, suggesting that the alternative conformations of repressor persist even if the protein is not in direct contact with DNA. Hence, DNA acts in a "catalytic" fashion to induce a steady-state amount of an alternative repressor conformation that has an enhanced affinity for its specific binding site. These findings suggest that the repressor conformer induced by non-specific DNA is the form of the repressor that is optimized for searching for DNA binding sites along non-specific DNA. Upon finding a binding site, the repressor protein undergoes an additional conformational change that allows it to "lock-on" to its specific site.

Inhibition of HIV-1 enhancer-controlled transcription by artificial enhancer-binding peptides derived from bacteriophage 434 repressor

An artificial HIV-1 enhancer-binding 42-residue peptide (R42) that had been derived from bacteriophage 434 repressor inhibited the cell-free in vitro transcription of HIV-1 enhancer-containing plasmids [Hehlgans, T., Stolz, M., Klauser, S., Cui, T., Salgam, P., Brenz Verca, S., Widmann, M., Leiser, A., Städler, K. & Gutte, B. (1993) FEBS Lett. 315, 51-55; Caderas, G. (1997) PhD Thesis, University of Zürich]. Here we show that, after N-terminal extension of R42 with a viral nuclear localization signal, the resulting nucR42 peptide was active in intact cells. NucR42 could be detected immunologically in nuclear extracts and produced a 60-70% reduction of the rate of transcription of an HIV-1 enhancer-carrying plasmid in COS-1 cells that had been cotransfected with the HIV enhancer plasmid, an expression plasmid for nucR42, and a control. NucR42 was also synthesized chemically and the synthetic product characterized by HPLC, mass spectrometry, and quantitative amino acid analysis. Band shift, footprint, and in vitro transcription assays in the presence of exogenous NF-kappaBp50 indicated that the binding sites of nucR42 and NF-kappaB on the HIV enhancers overlapped and that a relatively small excess of nucR42 sufficed to displace NF-kappaBp50. Band shift and in vitro transcription experiments showed also that exchange of the 434 repressor-derived nine-residue recognition helix of nucR42 for four glycines abolished the HIV enhancer binding specificity whereas leucine zipper- or retro-leucine zipper-mediated dimerization of R42 analogues increased it suggesting the potential application of such dimeric HIV enhancer-binding peptides as intracellular inhibitors of HIV replication.

Isolation of altered specificity mutants of the single-chain 434 repressor that recognize asymmetric DNA sequences containing the TTAA and TTAC subsites

A novel single-chain (sc) protein framework containing covalently dimerized DNA-binding domains (DBD) of the phage 434 repressor was used to construct combinatorial mutant libraries in order to isolate mutant DBDs with altered specificities. The library members contain one wild-type DBD and one mutant domain with randomized amino acids in the DNA-contacting region. Based on previous studies, the mutant sc derivatives are expected to recognize a general ACAA-6 bp-NNNN sequence, where ACAA is contacted by the wild-type and NNNN by the mutant domain. In principle, any sequence can stand for NNNN and serve as a selection target. Here an in vivo library screening method was used to isolate mutant sc repressors that interact with an asymmetric operator containing the TTAA target. Several mutants showed high affinity in vitro binding to operators containing the target and strong (up to 80-fold) preference for the TTAA target over the wild-type TTGT. Specificity studies revealed that certain mutants bound with substantially higher affinities (K(d) approximately 10(-11)M) to operators containing the TTAC sequence, a close homolog of the TTAA target. Thus, we have fortuitously isolated mutant sc repressors that show up to a several hundred-fold preference for TTAC over TTGT.

Localization of a protein-DNA interface by random mutagenesis

The type I restriction and modification enzymes do not possess obvious DNA-binding motifs within their target recognition domains (TRDs) of 150-180 amino acids. To identify residues involved in DNA recognition, changes were made in the amino-TRD of EcoKI by random mutagenesis. Most of the 101 substitutions affecting 79 residues had no effect on the phenotype. Changes at only seven positions caused the loss of restriction and modification activities. The seven residues identified by mutation are not randomly distributed throughout the primary sequence of the TRD: five are within the interval between residues 80 and 110. Sequence analyses have led to the suggestion that the TRDs of type I restriction enzymes include a tertiary structure similar to the TRD of the HhaI methyltransferase, and to a model for a DNA-protein interface in EcoKI. In this model, the residues within the interval identified by the five mutations are close to the protein-DNA interface. Three additional residues close to the DNA in the model were changed; each substitution impaired both activities. Proteins from twelve mutants were purified: six from mutants with partial or wild-type activity and six from mutants lacking activity. There is a strong correlation between phenotype and DNA-binding affinity, as determined by fluorescence anisotropy.

Carboxyl-terminal domain dimer interface mutant 434 repressors have altered dimerization and DNA binding specificities

Strong dimerization of the repressor, mediated by the carboxyl (C)-terminal domain, is a prerequisite for forming a specific complex with DNA and cooperative DNA binding to form tetramers. We have generated a computer model of the C-terminal domain of the 434 repressor based on the crystal structure of the homologous UmuD' protein. This model predicts that residues in the primary sequence between 93 and 168 contribute to the dimer interface. We changed several amino acid residues located in this region. Gel filtration and crosslinking assays were used to characterize the strength and specificity of dimerization of the purified repressor C-terminal domain dimer interface mutants. These results indicate that amino acid residues K121, H139, D161 and N163 contribute to the strength and/or specificity of dimerization. The relative affinity of the bacteriophage 434 repressor for 434 operators is determined, in part, by the repressor's ability to detect sequence-dependent structural alterations in the non-contacted region at the center of an operator site. We find that the relative ability of C-terminal domain dimer interface mutant repressors to dimerize does not necessarily predict their relative abilities to bind DNA, and that these proteins are deficient in detecting non-contacted base-dependent differences in operator strength. Our results show that the structure of the DNA in complex with these mutant proteins differs from that found in wild-type repressor-operator complexes, even though the sites of these mutations lie in a separate domain from that which contacts the DNA. These observations demonstrate that the structural integrity of the C-terminal domain dimer interface is required to appropriately orient the DNA binding information contained within the DNA-contacting N-terminal domain.

Recognition of nonconserved bases in the P22 operator by P22 repressor requires specific interactions between repressor and conserved bases

The ability of P22 repressor protein to distinguish between the six naturally occurring operator binding sites is critically important in determining whether the bacteriophage chooses to grow lytically or lysogenically. We have shown that changes in the highly conserved bases at P22 operator positions 3, 5, 6, and 7 prevent specific binding of P22 repressor. Moreover, studies of mutant proteins identified the three repressor amino acids that directly contact these conserved bases. The pattern of operator sequence conservation permits these direct amino acid-base pair interactions to occur in all except one of the 12 operator half-sites in the phage chromosome. Therefore, repressor differential affinity for these sites cannot be due to these highly conserved base pair-amino acid interactions. Our binding studies show that the nonconserved bases at positions 2 and 4 also play an important role in determining the relative affinity of the naturally occurring P22 operators for P22 repressor. Our data indicate that the direct contacts between the three solvent-exposed amino acids and the conserved bases in the binding site lock these amino acids in place, forming a scaffold allowing the rest of the amino acids side chains to form weaker interactions with the nonconserved bases in the binding site.

Engineering novel proteins by transfer of active sites to natural scaffolds

Novel functional proteins have been generated by the transfer of active sites to structurally homologous proteins and to new structural contexts. The most successful examples of these approaches succeeded in providing effective new tools in biochemistry and protein chemistry and in suggesting new models in drug design.

Recognition of DNA by single-chain derivatives of the phage 434 repressor: high affinity binding depends on both the contacted and non-contacted base pairs

Single-chain derivatives of the phage 434 repressor, termed single-chain repressors, contain covalently dimerized DNA-binding domains (DBD) which are connected with a peptide linker in a head-to-tail arrangement. The prototype RR69 contains two wild-type DBDs, while RR*69 contains a wild-type and an engineered DBD. In this latter domain, the DNA- contacting amino acids of thealpha3 helix of the 434 repressor are replaced by the corresponding residues of the related P22 repressor. We have used binding site selection, targeted mutagenesis and binding affinity studies to define the optimum DNA recognition sequence for these single-chain proteins. It is shown that RR69 recognizes DNA sequences containing the consensus boxes of the 434 operators in a palindromic arrangement, and that RR*69 optimally binds to non-palindromic sequences containing a 434 operator box and a TTAA box of which the latter is present in most P22 operators. The spacing of these boxes, as in the 434 operators, is 6 bp. The DNA-binding of both single-chain repressors, similar to that of the 434 repressor, is influenced indirectly by the sequence of the non-contacted, spacer region. Thus, high affinity binding is dependent on both direct and indirect recognition. Nonetheless, the single-chain framework can accommodate certain substitutions to obtain altered DNA-binding specificity and RR*69 represents an example for the combination of altered direct and unchanged indirect readout mechanisms.

Single-chain repressors containing engineered DNA-binding domains of the phage 434 repressor recognize symmetric or asymmetric DNA operators

Single-chain (sc) DNA-binding proteins containing covalently dimerized N-terminal domains of the bacteriophage 434 repressor cI have been constructed. The DNA-binding domains (amino acid residues 1 to 69) were connected in a head-to-tail arrangement with a part of the natural linker sequence that connects the N and C-terminal domains of the intact repressor. Compared to the isolated N-terminal DNA-binding domain, the sc molecule showed at least 100-fold higher binding affinity in vitro and a slightly stronger repression in vivo. The recognition of the symmetric O(R)1 operator sequence by this sc homodimer was indistinguishable from that of the naturally dimerized repressor in terms of binding affinity, DNase I protection pattern and in vivo repressor function. Using the new, sc framework, mutant proteins with altered DNA-binding specificity have also been constructed. Substitution of the DNA-contacting amino acid residues of the recognition helix in one of the domains with the corresponding residues of the Salmonella phage P22 repressor c2 resulted in a sc heterodimer of altered specificity. This new heterodimeric molecule recognized an asymmetric, artificial 434-P22 chimeric operator with high affinity. Similar substitutions in both 434 domains have led to a new sc homodimer which showed high affinity binding to a natural, symmetric P22 operator. These findings, supported by both in vitro and in vivo experiments, show that the sc architecture allows for the introduction of independent changes in the binding domains and suggest that this new protein framework could be used to generate new specificities in protein-DNA interaction.

In vivo selection of basic region-leucine zipper proteins with altered DNA-binding specificities

A transcription interference assay was used to generate mutant basic region-leucine zipper proteins with altered DNA-binding specificities. A library of mutants of a CCAAT/enhancer binding protein was constructed by randomizing five DNA-contacting amino acids in the basic region Asn-18, Ala-15, Val-14, Ser-11, and Arg-10. These mutants were then selected for their ability to bind mutant recognition sequences containing substitutions at the 2 and 3 positions of the wild-type sequence 5'-A5T4T3G2C1G1'C2'A3A4'T5'-3'. Mutants containing the sequence Leu-18Tyr-15Xaa-14Tyr-11Arg-10, in which four of the five contact residues are altered, were identified that recognize the palindromic sequence 5'-ATCYCGY'GAT-3' (Xaa = asparagine when Y = G; Xaa = methionine when Y = A). Moreover, in a selection against the sequence 5'-ATTACGTAAT-3', mutants were obtained containing substitutions not only in the basic region but also in the hinge region between the basic and leucine zipper regions. The mutant proteins showed high specificity in a functional transcription interference assay. A model for the interaction of these mutants with the target DNA sequences is discussed.

Dramatic changes in DNA-binding specificity caused by single residue substitutions in an Arc/Mnt hybrid repressor

Arc and Mnt are homologous repressors which recognize operator sequences that differ at 8-10 important positions. Nevertheless, single residue changes in an Arc/Mnt hybrid protein can switch DNA-binding specificity between the two operators and even allow one particular hybrid to bind strongly to both operators. The ability of single residue changes to radically alter binding specificity involves: 'master' residues that mediate some base contacts directly and some base contacts indirectly through residue-residue hydrogen bonds; identical residues which can make alternative sets of DNA contacts in the two operators; and amplification of the effect of each mutation because the proteins bind operator DNA as tetramers.

Structure of the NF-kappa B transcription factor: a holistic interaction with DNA

An unexpected mode of binding to DNA is revealed in two crystal structures of a transcription factor that is essential for many signalling pathways in eukaryotic cells.

How 434 repressor discriminates between OR1 and OR3. The influence of contacted and noncontacted base pairs

The sequence of the bacteriophage 434 OR1 (ACAAAACTTTCTTGT) differs from its OR3 (ACAGTTTTCTTGT) at positions 4-6. X-ray analysis shows that the side chain of Gln33 of the 434 repressor makes van der Waals' and H-bond contacts with the T at position 4' in complex with OR1, but no specific contact is observed at this position in 434 repressor-OR3 complexes. No contacts are made by repressor to the bases at positions 5 or 6 in either binding site. The significance of the sequence differences between OR1 and OR3 in determining the operator affinity for repressor were examined by constructing synthetic variants of these operators. Measurements of the affinity of these operators for repressor as a function of ionic strength revealed that although base pairs 5 and 6 are not contacted by 434 repressor, they can nonetheless influence operator affinity for repressor by modulating the degree to which ionic interactions contribute to the overall binding energy. Both the magnitude and direction of their effect depends on the status of repressor's contacts to the bases at position 4. The role of contact made by Gln33 to position 4 was examined by mutating this amino acid to Ala and by examining the affinity of wild type repressor for an operator bearing a 5-methylcytosine at position 4' in an OR1-4G mutant. These experiments showed that repressor's preferences at operator positions 5 and 6 are linked to its position 4 preference via a van der Waals' contact between amino acid 33 and a methyl group on the base at operator position 4'. Together, the results of the experiments shown here reveal that bases that do not contact the protein alter its preferences for bases at the contacted operator position 4.

Structure-based design of transcription factors

Computer modeling suggested that transcription factors with novel sequence specificities could be designed by combining known DNA binding domains. This structure-based strategy was tested by construction of a fusion protein, ZFHD1, that contained zinc fingers 1 and 2 from Zif268, a short polypeptide linker, and the homeodomain from Oct-1. The fusion protein bound optimally to a sequence containing adjacent homeodomain (TAATTA) and zinc finger (NGGGNG) subsites. When fused to an activation domain, ZFHD1 regulated promoter activity in vivo in a sequence-specific manner. Analysis of known protein-DNA complexes suggests that many other DNA binding proteins could be designed in a similar fashion.

Expression, purification, and functional characterization of the carboxyl-terminal domain fragment of bacteriophage 434 repressor

The repressor protein of bacteriophage 434 binds to DNA as a dimer of identical subunits. Its strong dimerization is mediated by the carboxyl-terminal domain. Cooperative interactions between the C-terminal domains of two repressor dimers bound at adjacent sites can stabilize protein-DNA complexes formed with low-affinity binding sites. We have constructed a plasmid, pCT1, which directs the overproduction of the carboxyl-terminal domain of 434 repressor. The protein encoded by this plasmid is called CT-1. Cells transformed with pCT1 are unable to be lysogenized by wild-type 434 phage, whereas control cells are lysogenized at an efficiency of 1 to 5%. The CT-1-mediated interference with lysogen formation presumably results from formation of heteromeric complexes between the phage-encoded repressor and the plasmid-encoded carboxyl-terminal domain fragment. These heteromers are unable to bind DNA and thereby inhibit the repressor's activity in promoting lysogen formation. Two lines of evidence support this conclusion. First, DNase I footprinting experiments show that at a 2:1 ratio of CT-1 to intact 434 repressor, purified CT-1 protein prevents the formation of complexes between 434 repressor and its OR1 binding site. Second, cross-linking experiments reveal that only a specific heterodimeric complex forms between CT-1 and intact 434 repressor. This latter observation indicates that CT-1 interferes with 434 repressor-operator complex formation by preventing dimerization and not by altering the conformation of the DNA-bound repressor dimer. Our other evidence is also consistent with this suggestion. We have used deletion analysis in an attempt to define the region which mediates the 434 repressor-CT-1 interaction. CT-1 proteins which have more than the last 14 amino acids removed are unable to interfere with 434 repressor action in vivo.

Specificity determinants for the interaction of lambda repressor and P22 repressor dimers

The related phage lambda and phage P22 repressors each bind cooperatively to adjacent and separated operator sites, an interaction that involves a pair of repressor dimers. The specificities of these interactions differ: Each dimer interacts with its own type but not with dimers of the heterologous repressor. The two repressors exhibit significant amino acid sequence homology in their carboxy-terminal domains, which are responsible for both dimer formation and the dimer-dimer interaction. Here, we identify a collection of amino acid substitutions that disrupt the protein-protein interaction of DNA-bound lambda repressor dimers and show that several of these substitutions have the same effect when introduced at the corresponding positions of P22 repressor. We use this information to construct a variant of the lambda repressor bearing only six non-wild-type amino acids that has a switched specificity; that is, it binds cooperatively with P22 repressor, but not with wild-type lambda repressor. These results identify a series of residues that determine the specificities of the two interactions.

A permutational approach toward protein-DNA recognition

The cI repressor of bacteriophage 434, known as 434 repressor, binds to 14-bp operator sequences by means of a helix-turn-helix motif. To probe the requirements for selective DNA recognition by this class of DNA binding proteins, as well as to generate new proteins with altered specificities, a library of approximately 3 x 10(6) mutants was generated that contains all permutations of five residues in the recognition helix (helix 3) of the repressor. These mutants were then selected in vivo for their ability to bind both wild-type (WT) and mutant operator sequences. The results of the selection demonstrate that four of these residues--Gln28, Gln29, Ser30, and Gln33--play a critical role in recognition of the WT operator. A number of repressors with mutations at Thr27 showed altered DNA binding affinities and specificities. The approach described here may also prove useful in studies of DNA recognition by other classes of DNA binding proteins.

The complex between phage 434 repressor DNA-binding domain and operator site OR3: structural differences between consensus and non-consensus half-sites

BACKGROUND

The repressor of phage 434 binds to a set of operator sites as a homodimer. Its relative affinities for these sites determine the switch from lysogenic to lytic growth. The six 434 operator sites (OR1, OR2, OR3, OL1, OL2 and OL3) have a particularly simple organization; all are 14 base pairs long, with a conserved 5'-ACAA sequence symmetrically placed at either end, and a variable central six base pairs. OR3 is unique among naturally-occurring 434 operator sites in that it contains a non-consensus base pair, G.C, at the fourth position of the otherwise invariant 5'-ACAA sequence. Comparisons among structures of the 434 repressor DNA-binding domain, R1-69, bound to various operator sites, allow us to analyze differential specificity in regulatory complexes of this kind.

RESULTS

We have determined the structure at 2.5 A resolution of a complex of R1-69 with DNA containing the OR3 site and compared it with previously studied complexes of R1-69 bound to OR1 and OR2. There are surprisingly extensive structural differences between the consensus and non-consensus half-sites of OR3 with respect to their interactions with R1-69, including a shift in the DNA backbone and a small rotation of the entire R1-69 monomer.

CONCLUSIONS

Recognition of the base pair difference that is critical for the 434 regulatory switch involves a number of amino acid residues, not just the one or two side chains in direct contact with the G-C base pair. Moreover, the repressor imposes a somewhat altered DNA conformation on the non-consensus half-site.

Construction of chimeric proteins from the sigma N-associated transcriptional activators VnfA and AnfA of Azotobacter vinelandii shows that the determinants of promoter specificity lie outside the 'recognition' helix of the HTH motif in the C-terminal domain

Functional chimeras have been generated from the transcriptional activators VnfA and AnfA, which control expression of the alternative nitrogenases in Azotobacter vinelandii. The activation profiles of the native and chimeric proteins have been determined using lacZ fusions to A. vinelandii anf and vnf promoters in Klebsiella pneumoniae. Replacing the C-terminal domain of AnfA with that of VnfA gives a protein with the promoter specificity of VnfA, confirming that the C-terminal domain contains the determinants of promoter specificity. However, substituting the VnfA sequence from the turn in the helix-turn-helix motif to the C-terminus does not alter the promoter specificity of AnfA. These changes in promoter specificity were reflected in changes in affinity for a VnfA-binding site, as measured by an in vivo repression assay using a lacZ fusion to a synthetic promoter. This supports the assumption that promoter recognition is determined by activator binding to enhancer--like sequences, and shows that the principal determinants of specific DNA-binding lie outside the 'recognition' helix. This may be a general feature of transcriptional activators dependent on sigma N (sigma 54). The chimera with the promoter specificity of VnfA retained the dependence on nitrogenase Fe protein characteristic of AnfA, indicating that this property is not related to particular promoter sequences, but is a function of the central or N-terminal domains of AnfA.

Dimerization of leucine zippers analyzed by random selection

The leucine zipper is a coiled coil that mediates specific dimerization of bZIP DNA-binding domains. A hydrophobic spine involving the conserved leucines runs down the coiled-coil and is thought to stabilize the dimer. We used the method of random selection to further define the primary sequence requirements for homodimer formation and heterodimer formation with Fos. When positions on either side of the hydrophobic spine of GCN4 are diversified to include the corresponding residues of Jun, a large percentage of the resulting sequences form homodimers, and a large percentage form heterodimers with Fos. Basic residues were preferred, but not essential, at position e of zippers which heterodimerize with Fos. When random sequences containing 5 heptad repeat of leucines are subject to a selection for homodimer formation, a diverse set of sequences is isolated. Certain residues are preferred at each position in the heptad repeat, although no essential primary sequence determinants could be identified. No pair of residues not involving the conserved leucines could be identified which strongly promotes homodimerization. These results suggest that factors determining leucine zipper dimerization are complex, with numerous interactions contributing to the association.

Identification and genetic mapping of a homeobox gene to the 4p16.1 region of human chromosome 4

A human craniofacial cDNA library was screened with a degenerate oligonucleotide probe based on the conserved third helix of homeobox genes. From this screening, we identified a homeobox gene, H6, which shared only 57-65% amino acid identity to previously reported homeodomains. H6 was physically mapped to the 4p16.1 region by using somatic cell hybrids containing specific deletions of human chromosome 4. Linkage data from a single-stranded conformational polymorphism derived from the 3' untranslated region of the H6 cDNA placed this homeobox gene more than 20 centimorgans proximal of the previously mapped HOX7 gene on chromosome 4. Identity comparisons of the H6 homeodomain with previously reported homeodomains reveal the highest identities to be with the Nk class of homeobox genes in Drosophila melanogaster.

Definition of receptor binding domains in interferon-alpha

Earlier studies from this laboratory had identified three regions in interferon-alpha (IFN-alpha) that influence the active conformation of the molecule. These domains are associated with the amino acid residues 10-35, 78-107, and 123-166. In this report, we define these domains more accurately by identifying their critical clusters of amino acids. Using a panel of IFN-alpha 2a variants in antiviral, growth inhibitory, and receptor binding studies, we are able to show that these three domains, defined by residues 29-35, 78-95, and 123-140, are likely located on the surface of the molecule, with domains 29-35 and 123-140 in close spatial proximity. We conclude that the 29-35 and 123-140 domains are responsible for IFN-alpha receptor binding interactions and constitute receptor recognition sites in IFN-alpha. Extrapolating from our biological activity data, in the context of a number of predictive algorithms that provide insights into the hydrophobicity/hydrophilicity, surface probability, and flexibility of amino acid clusters, we infer that the residues 29-35 influence the active configuration of IFN-alpha most significantly. This region likely represents a loop structure that is relatively rigid in configuration. The carboxy-terminally located strategic domain, 123-140, is comprised of two clusters of amino acid residues, one that forms part of a rigid alpha-helix, the other a more flexible loop structure. Similarly, the 78-95 domain comprises a portion of an alpha-helical structure that is followed by a loop structure. Close examination of the amino acid sequences in all three regions among the different species of IFN-alpha s and human IFN-beta indicate that the 29-35 and 123-140 domains are most highly conserved, yet some variance is apparent in the 78-95 domain. We propose that the 78-95 region influences species specificity among the murine and human IFN-alpha s and determines the differential specificity of action between human IFN-alpha and human IFN-beta.