Template-free RNA synthesis by Q beta replicase

A Concept of Complementarity Between Complexity and Redundancy can Account for Kant's Biological Teleology and Unify Mechanistic and Finalistic Biology

Over 160 years after Darwin and 70 years after the discovery of DNA, two fundamental questions of biology remain unanswered: What differentiates the living from the nonliving? How can mechanistic and finalistic or holistic biology be unified? Niels Bohr introduced a concept of complementarity in quantum physics and based on the paradox of light as a simultaneous wave and particle, conjectured that a similar concept might exist in biology that would solve the paradox of life originating from the nonliving. Bohr proposed that two mutually exclusive-independent observations may be necessary to explain a phenomenon and provided support to Immanuel Kant's idea that the "purposive" behaviour of organisms could only be explained in teleological terms and that mechanical and teleological approaches were necessary and complementary to explain biology. We present a concept of complementarity whereby biochemical pathways or cellular channels for the flow of information are simultaneously complex and redundant and complexity and redundancy complement each other. The postulates of biological complementarity are that (1) it was an essential condition in the origin of life; (2) it provided physiological flexibility that allowed organisms to mount self-protection response and complexity to evolve in the face of deleterious mutations before the evolution of bi-parental sex; (3) it laid the foundation for the evolution of a choice of response when confronted with threat; and (4) it applies to all levels of biological organizations and, thus, can serve as a basis for the unification of mechanistic and holistic biology. It is proposed that teleology is simultaneously constitutive and heuristic: constitutive because organisms' "purposive" behaviours are adaptive and are grounded in mechanism (complexity and redundancy), and heuristic because with our finite cognition and our goal-oriented (humans alone are aware of "tomorrow") and anthropomorphic pre-disposition, teleology will remain useful as a guide to our making sense of the world, even how to ask a meaningful question.

Applications of phage-derived RNA-based technologies in synthetic biology

As the most abundant biological entities with incredible diversity, bacteriophages (also known as phages) have been recognized as an important source of molecular machines for the development of genetic-engineering tools. At the same time, phages are crucial for establishing and improving basic theories of molecular biology. Studies on phages provide rich sources of essential elements for synthetic circuit design as well as powerful support for the improvement of directed evolution platforms. Therefore, phages play a vital role in the development of new technologies and central scientific concepts. After the RNA world hypothesis was proposed and developed, novel biological functions of RNA continue to be discovered. RNA and its related elements are widely used in many fields such as metabolic engineering and medical diagnosis, and their versatility led to a major role of RNA in synthetic biology. Further development of RNA-based technologies will advance synthetic biological tools as well as provide verification of the RNA world hypothesis. Most synthetic biology efforts are based on reconstructing existing biological systems, understanding fundamental biological processes, and developing new technologies. RNA-based technologies derived from phages will offer abundant sources for synthetic biological components. Moreover, phages as well as RNA have high impact on biological evolution, which is pivotal for understanding the origin of life, building artificial life-forms, and precisely reprogramming biological systems. This review discusses phage-derived RNA-based technologies terms of phage components, the phage lifecycle, and interactions between phages and bacteria. The significance of RNA-based technology derived from phages for synthetic biology and for understanding the earliest stages of biological evolution will be highlighted.

A Direct RNA-to-RNA Replication System for Enhanced Gene Expression in Bacteria

A long-standing objective of metabolic engineering has been to exogenously increase the expression of target genes. In this research, we proposed the permanent RNA replication system using DNA as a template to store genetic information in bacteria. We selected Qβ phage as the RNA replication prototype and made many improvements to achieve target gene expression enhancement directly by increasing mRNA abundance. First, we identified the endogenous gene Rnc, the knockout of which significantly improved the RNA replication efficiency. Second, we elucidated the essential elements for RNA replication and optimized the system to make it more easily applicable. Combined with optimization of the host cell and the system itself, we developed a stable RNA-to-RNA replication tool to directly increase the abundance of the target mRNA and subsequently the target protein. Furthermore, it was proven efficient in enhancing the expression of specific proteins and was demonstrated to be applicable in metabolic engineering. Our system has the potential to be combined with any of the existing methods for increasing gene expression.

Parsimonious Scenario for the Emergence of Viroid-Like Replicons De Novo

Viroids are small, non-coding, circular RNA molecules that infect plants. Different hypotheses for their evolutionary origin have been put forward, such as an early emergence in a precellular RNA World or several de novo independent evolutionary origins in plants. Here, we discuss the plausibility of de novo emergence of viroid-like replicons by giving theoretical support to the likelihood of different steps along a parsimonious evolutionary pathway. While Avsunviroidae-like structures are relatively easy to obtain through evolution of a population of random RNA sequences of fixed length, rod-like structures typical of Pospiviroidae are difficult to fix. Using different quantitative approaches, we evaluated the likelihood that RNA sequences fold into a rod-like structure and bear specific sequence motifs facilitating interactions with other molecules, e.g., RNA polymerases, RNases, and ligases. By means of numerical simulations, we show that circular RNA replicons analogous to Pospiviroidae emerge if evolution is seeded with minimal circular RNAs that grow through the gradual addition of nucleotides. Further, these rod-like replicons often maintain their structure if independent functional modules are acquired that impose selective constraints. The evolutionary scenario we propose here is consistent with the structural and biochemical properties of viroids described to date.

From quasispecies to quasispaces: coding and cooperation in chemical and electronic systems

This contribution addresses the physical roles of spatial structures, either externally imposed or generated through self-assembly, either passive or active, on the physical chemistry of evolution. Starting with simple diffusion in closed capillaries, a one-dimensional space, it covers eight aspects of experimental and theoretical research into the interaction of evolution with spatial structures: in various dimensions, including hitherto unexplored ones, spanning from externally defined physical spaces to actively tailored spaces, assembled by the evolving components themselves. As such, it contains some original research by the author as well as tracing how other insights grew over three decades out of the mentorship of Manfred Eigen in the 1980s. Much of the early interest in spatial structures centres on its role in stabilizing higher order cooperative structures involving the coevolution of different molecules, as the genetic coding system exemplifies. Modern nanotechnology enables the design and construction of genetically encoded variants of smart components that can actively control both the proliferation of molecules and the structuring of space. A key role for this article is to show the continuity in this line of enquiry, beginning with quasispecies and projecting to autonomous microparticles with electronic genomes able to form programmable quasispaces.

Protein-RNA Interactions in the Single-Stranded RNA Bacteriophages

Bacteriophages of the Leviviridae family are small viruses with short single-stranded RNA (ssRNA) genomes. Protein-RNA interactions play a key role throughout the phage life cycle, and all of the conserved phage proteins - the maturation protein, the coat protein and the replicase - are able to recognize specific structures in the RNA genome. The phage-coded replicase subunit associates with several host proteins to form a catalytically active complex. Recognition of the genomic RNA by the replicase complex is achieved in a remarkably complex manner that exploits the RNA-binding properties of host proteins and the particular three-dimensional structure of the phage genome. The coat protein recognizes a hairpin structure at the beginning of the replicase gene. The binding interaction serves to regulate the expression of the replicase gene and can be remarkably different in various ssRNA phages. The maturation protein is a minor structural component of the virion that binds to the genome, mediates attachment to the host and guides the genome into the cell. The maturation protein has two distinct RNA-binding surfaces that are in contact with different regions of the genome. The maturation and coat proteins also work together to ensure the encapsidation of the phage genome in new virus particles. In this chapter, the different ssRNA phage protein-RNA interactions, as well as some of their practical applications, are discussed in detail.

Evolvability Tradeoffs in Emergent Digital Replicators

The role of historical contingency in the origin of life is one of the great unknowns in modern science. Only one example of life exists-one that proceeded from a single self-replicating organism (or a set of replicating hypercycles) to the vast complexity we see today in Earth's biosphere. We know that emergent life has the potential to evolve great increases in complexity, but it is unknown if evolvability is automatic given any self-replicating organism. At the same time, it is difficult to test such questions in biochemical systems. Laboratory studies with RNA replicators have had some success with exploring the capacities of simple self-replicators, but these experiments are still limited in both capabilities and scope. Here, we use the digital evolution system Avida to explore the interplay between emergent replicators (rare randomly assembled self-replicators) and evolvability. We find that we can classify fixed-length emergent replicators in Avida into two classes based on functional analysis. One class is more evolvable in the sense of optimizing the replicators' replication abilities. However, the other class is more evolvable in the sense of acquiring evolutionary innovations. We tie this tradeoff in evolvability to the structure of the respective classes' replication machinery, and speculate on the relevance of these results to biochemical replicators.

Importance of parasite RNA species repression for prolonged translation-coupled RNA self-replication

Increasingly complex reactions are being constructed by bottom-up approaches with the aim of developing an artificial cell. We have been engaged in the construction of a translation-coupled replication system of genetic information from RNA and a reconstituted translation system. Here a mathematical model was established to gain a quantitative understanding of the complex reaction network. The sensitivity analysis predicted that the limiting factor for the present replication reaction was the appearance of parasitic replicators. We then confirmed experimentally that repression of such parasitic replicators by compartmentalization of the reaction in water-in-oil emulsions improved the duration of self-replication. We also found that the main source of the parasite was genomic RNA, probably by nonhomologous recombination. This result provided experimental evidence for the importance of parasite repression for the development of long-lasting genome replication systems.

Identification of two forms of Q{beta} replicase with different thermal stabilities but identical RNA replication activity

The enzyme Qβ replicase is an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase, which plays a central role in infection by the simple single-stranded RNA virus bacteriophage Qβ. This enzyme has been used in a number of applications because of its unique activity in amplifying RNA from an RNA template. Determination of the thermal stability of Qβ replicase is important to gain an understanding of its function and potential applications, but data reported to date have been contradictory. Here, we provide evidence that these previous inconsistencies were due to the heterogeneous forms of the replicase with different stabilities. We purified two forms of replicase expressed in Escherichia coli, which differed in their thermal stability but showed identical RNA replication activity. Furthermore, we found that the replicase undergoes conversion between these forms due to oxidation, and the Cys-533 residue in the catalytic β subunit and Cys-82 residue in the EF-Tu subunit of the replicase are essential prerequisites for this conversion to occur. These results strongly suggest that the thermal stable replicase contains the intersubunit disulfide bond between these cysteines. The established strategies for isolating and purifying a thermally stable replicase should increase the usefulness of Qβ replicase in various applications, and the data regarding thermal stability obtained in this study may yield insight into the precise mechanism of infection by bacteriophage Qβ.

How RNA viruses maintain their genome integrity

RNA genomes are vulnerable to corruption by a range of activities, including inaccurate replication by the error-prone replicase, damage from environmental factors, and attack by nucleases and other RNA-modifying enzymes that comprise the cellular intrinsic or innate immune response. Damage to coding regions and loss of critical cis-acting signals inevitably impair genome fitness; as a consequence, RNA viruses have evolved a variety of mechanisms to protect their genome integrity. These include mechanisms to promote replicase fidelity, recombination activities that allow exchange of sequences between different RNA templates, and mechanisms to repair the genome termini. In this article, we review examples of these processes from a range of RNA viruses to showcase the diverse approaches that viruses have evolved to maintain their genome sequence integrity, focusing first on mechanisms that viruses use to protect their entire genome, and then concentrating on mechanisms that allow protection of the genome termini, which are especially vulnerable. In addition, we discuss examples in which it might be beneficial for a virus to 'lose' its genomic termini and reduce its replication efficiency.

Kinetic analysis of the entire RNA amplification process by Qbeta replicase

The kinetics of the RNA replication reaction by Qbeta replicase were investigated. Qbeta replicase is an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase responsible for replicating the RNA genome of coliphage Qbeta and plays a key role in the life cycle of the Qbeta phage. Although the RNA replication reaction using this enzyme has long been studied, a kinetic model that can describe the entire RNA amplification process has yet to be determined. In this study, we propose a kinetic model that is able to account for the entire RNA amplification process. The key to our proposed kinetic model is the consideration of nonproductive binding (i.e. binding of an enzyme to the RNA where the enzyme cannot initiate the reaction). By considering nonproductive binding and the notable enzyme inactivation we observed, the previous observations that remained unresolved could also be explained. Moreover, based on the kinetic model and the experimental results, we determined rate and equilibrium constants using template RNAs of various lengths. The proposed model and the obtained constants provide important information both for understanding the basis of Qbeta phage amplification and the applications using Qbeta replicase.

N.BspD6I DNA nickase strongly stimulates template-independent synthesis of non-palindromic repetitive DNA by Bst DNA polymerase

Highly efficient DNA synthesis without template and primer DNAs occurs when N.BspD6I DNA nickase is added to a reaction mixture containing deoxynucleoside triphosphates and the large fragment of Bst DNA polymerase. Over a period of 2 h, virtually all the deoxynucleoside triphosphates (dNTPs) become incorporated into DNA. Inactivation of N.BspD6I nickase by heating inhibits DNA synthesis. Optimal N.BspD6I activity is required to achieve high yields of synthesized DNA. Electron microscopy data revealed that the majority of DNA molecules have a branched structure. Cloning and sequencing of the fragments synthesized demonstrated that the DNA product mainly consists of multiple hexanucleotide non-palindromic tandem repeats containing nickase recognition sites. A possible mechanism is discussed that addresses template-independent DNA synthesis stimulated by N.BspD6I nickase.

Replicable and recombinogenic RNAs

This paper summarizes results of the 40-year studies on replication and recombination of RNA molecules in the cell-free amplification system of bacteriophage Q. Special attention is paid to the molecular colony technique that has provided for the discovery of the nature of "spontaneous" RNA synthesis by Q replicase and of the ability of RNA molecules to spontaneously rearrange their sequences under physiological conditions. Also discussed is the impact of these data on the concept of RNA World and on the development of new in vitro cloning and diagnostic tools.

Isolation of Qbeta polymerase complexes containing mutant species of elongation factor Tu

The RNA genome of coliphage Qbeta is replicated by a complex of four proteins, one of them being the translation elongation factor Tu. The role of EF-Tu in this RNA polymerase complex is still unclear, but the obligate presence of translationally functional EF-Tu in the cell hampers the use of conventional mutational analysis. Therefore, we designed a system based on affinity chromatography and could separate two types of complexes by placing an affinity tag on mutated EF-Tu species. Thus, we were able to show a direct link between the vital tRNA binding property of EF-Tu and polymerase activity.

History of modern genetics in Germany

The history of modern genetics in Germany during the 20th century is a story of missed chances. In the USA the genetic revolution opened a fascinating new field for ambitious scientists and created a rapidly growing new industry. Meanwhile Germany stood aside, combating with political and social restrictions. Promising young scientists who wanted to work in the field left Germany for the US, and big companies moved their facilities out of the country. Up until the middle of the 1990s molecular biology in Germany remained a "sleeping beauty" even though many brilliant scientists did their jobs very well. Then a somewhat funny idea changed everything: the German minister for education and science proclaimed the BioRegio contest in order to award the most powerful biotechnology region in Germany concerning academia and especially industry. Since then Germany's biotechnology industry has grown constantly and rapidly due to the foundation of a number of small biotech companies; big companies have returned their interests and their investments to Germany, paralleled by an improvement in academic research because of more funding and better support especially for younger scientists. In respect to biotechnology and molecular biology, Germany is still a developing country, but it has started to move and to take its chances in an exciting global competition.

Polymerization of nontemplate bases before transcription initiation at the 3' ends of templates by an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase: an activity involved in 3' end repair of viral RNAs

The 3' ends of RNAs associated with turnip crinkle virus (TCV), including subviral satellite (sat)C, terminate with the motif CCUGCCC-3'. Transcripts of satC with a deletion of the motif are repaired to wild type (wt) in vivo by RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp)-mediated extension of abortively synthesized oligoribonucleotide primers complementary to the 3' end of the TCV genomic RNA. Repair of shorter deletions, however, are repaired by other mechanisms. SatC transcripts with the 3' terminal CCC replaced by eight nonviral bases were repaired in plants by homologous recombination between the similar 3' ends of satC and TCV. Transcripts with deletions of four or five 3' terminal bases, in the presence or absence of nonviral bases, generated progeny with a mixture of wt and non-wt 3' ends in vivo. In vitro, RdRp-containing extracts were able to polymerize nucleotides in a template-independent fashion before using these primers to initiate transcription at or near the 3' end of truncated satC templates. The nontemplate additions at the 5' ends of the nascent complementary strands were not random, with a preference for consecutive identical nucleotides. The RdRp was also able to initiate transcription opposite cytidylate, uridylate, guanylate, and possibly adenylate residues without exhibiting an obvious preference, flexibility previously unreported for viral RdRp. The unexpected existence of three different repair mechanisms for TCV suggests that 3' end reconstruction is critical to virus survival.

Isomorphism of quasispecies and percolation models

Population dynamics of tRNA-like macromolecules and viruses have been interpreted by Eigen (1971, Naturwissenschaften58, 465-526) on the basis of the "quasispecies" model. The present paper contains a qualitative analysis of the similarities between Eigen's quasispecies model and percolation models. In fact, different phenomena characterized by an analogous inner structure can conceivably be described by quite similar mathematical formalisms. The occurrence of a threshold in specific processes predicted by the models is considered first. Secondly, Ising's model of ferromagnetism is taken into account in the last section. An interpretation of the above-mentioned biological theory in terms of percolation, implying a zeroth-order approximation to the real situation, might be a point of departure to a deeper insight obtainable with more refined approaches. A better comprehension of biological phenomena might in any case arise from a percolative approach, even if the description of the systems is simplified. An overview of some quasispecies results and some plausible applications are presented.

Creation of genetic information by DNA polymerase of the thermophilic bacterium Thermus thermophilus

Genetic information encoded in a template of a genome is replicated in a complementary way by DNA polymerase or RNA polymerase with high fidelity; no creation of information occurs in this reaction unless an error occurs. We report here that DNA polymerase of the thermophilic bacterium Thermus thermophilus can synthesize up to 200 kb linear double-stranded DNA in vitro in the complete absence of added primer and template DNAs, indicating that genetic information is actively created by protein. This ab initio DNA synthesis occurs at 74 degrees C and requires magnesium ion. There is a lag time of approximately 1 h and then the reaction proceeds linearly. The synthesized DNAs have a variety of sequences; they are mostly tandem repetitive sequences, e.g. (CATGTATA) n , (TGTATGTATACATACATA) n and (TATACGTA) n . Some degenerate sequences of these basic repeat units are also found. The similar repetitive sequences are found in many natural genes. These results, together with similar results found using DNA polymerase of archaeon Thermococcus litoralis , suggest that creative, non-replicative synthesis of DNA by protein was a driving force for diversification of genetic information at a certain stage of the evolution of life on the early earth.

The forces driving molecular evolution

Competitive replication among RNA or DNA molecules at linear and non-linear rates of propagation has been reviewed from the perspective of a recent physicochemical model of molecular evolution and the findings are applied to pre-replication, prebiotic and biological evolution. A system of competitively replicating molecules was seen to follow a path of least action on both its thermodynamic and kinetic branch, in evolving toward steady state kinetics and equilibrium for the nucleotide condensation reaction. Stable and unstable states of coexistence, between competing molecular species, arise at nonlinear rates of propagation, and they derive from an equilibrium between kinetic forces. The de novo formation of self-replicating RNA molecules involves damping of these scalar forces, error tolerance and RNA driven strand separation. Increases in sequence complexity in the transition to self-replication does not exceed the free energy dissipated in RNA synthesis. Retrodiction of metabolic pathways and phylogenetic evidence point to the occurrence of three pre-replication metabolic systems, driven by autocatalytic C-fixation cycles. Thermodynamic and kinetic factors led to the replication take over. Biological evolution was found to involve resource capture, in addition to competition for a shared resource.

Template-independent repair of the 3' end of cucumber mosaic virus satellite RNA controlled by RNAs 1 and 2 of helper virus

RNA viruses which do not have a poly(A) tail or a tRNA-like structure for the protection of their vulnerable 3' termini may have developed a different strategy to maintain their genome integrity. We provide evidence that deletions of up to 7 nucleotides from the 3' terminus of cucumber mosaic cucumovirus (CMV) satellite RNA (satRNA) were repaired in planta in the presence of the helper virus (HV) CMV. Sequence comparison of 3'-end-repaired satRNA progenies, and of satRNA and HV RNA, suggested that the repair was not dependent on a viral template. The 3' end of CMV satRNA lacking the last three cytosines was not repaired in planta in the presence of tomato aspermy cucumovirus (TAV), although TAV is an efficient helper for the replication of CMV satRNA. With use of pseudorecombinants constructed by the interchange of RNAs 1 and 2 of TAV and CMV, evidence was provided that the 3'-end repair was controlled by RNAs 1 and 2 of CMV, which encode subunits of the viral RNA replicase. These results, and the observation of short repeated sequences close to the 3' terminus of repaired molecules, suggest that the HV replicase maintains the integrity of the satRNA genome, playing a role analogous to that of cellular telomerases.

The natural 6 S RNA found in Q beta-infected cells is derived from host and phage RNA

The RNA of Escherichia coli infected with RNA bacteriophage Q beta was isolated and screened for replicable short-chained RNA. In contrast to earlier assumptions we show that (i) short-chained replicable RNA is a very minor part of the RNA synthesized in the infection cycle, and (ii) that the replicable RNA isolated from infected cells is derived from cellular RNA, in particular 23 S rRNA and 10 Sa RNA, and from Q beta RNA itself. None of the many RNA species known from in vitro experiments was found. The RNA species isolated were all inefficient templates. No replicable RNA could be isolated from non-infected cells. Even in cells expressing high amounts of Q beta replicase very few RNA species could be isolated. RNA generated in vitro in template-free synthesis is therefore not derived from RNA species found in vivo, and replicable RNA found in vitro is generated by a mechanism fundamentally different from the one operating in vivo.

Altered 3'-terminal RNA structure in phage Qbeta adapted to host factor-less Escherichia coli

The RNA phage Qbeta requires for the replication of its genome an RNA binding protein called Qbeta host factor or Hfq protein. Our previous results suggested that this protein mediates the access of replicase to the 3'-end of the Qbeta plus strand RNA. Here we report the results of an evolutionary experiment in which phage Qbeta was adapted to an Escherichia coli Q13 host strain with an inactivated host factor (hfq) gene. This strain initially produced phage at a titer approximately 10,000-fold lower than the wild-type strain and with minute plaque morphology, but after 12 growth cycles, phage titer and plaque size had evolved to levels near those of the wild-type host. RNAs isolated from adapted Qbeta mutants were efficient templates for replicase without host factor in vitro. Electron microscopy showed that mutant RNAs, in contrast to wild-type RNA, efficiently interacted with replicase at the 3'-end in the absence of host factor. The same set of four mutations in the 3'-terminal third of the genome was found in several independently evolved phage clones. One mutation disrupts the base pairing of the 3'-terminal CCCOH sequence, suggesting that the host factor stimulates activity of the wild-type RNA template by melting out its 3'-end.

Molecular evolution of RNA in vitro

Experimental studies of RNA evolution in vitro are reviewed in the context of Eigen's 1971 theory and its subsequent extensions. Current research activity and future prospects for using automated molecular biology techniques for in vitro evolution experiments are surveyed.

Prion function and dysfunction: a structure-based scenario

Prion diseases are transmissible, neurodegenerative disorders associated with as yet incompletely defined isoforms of a cellular protein termed prion protein (PrP). We have now identified in PrP structural information compatible with nucleotide- and nucleic acid-binding. As such, PrP contains a putative nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH)-binding site. Moreover, the PrP octarepeats reveal homology to the nucleic acid-binding and strand-annealing octarepeats of mammalian heterogeneous ribonucleoprotein (RNP) A1. Therefore, PrP may have NADH-dependent oxidoreductase activity as well as A1-like functions such as nucleic acid annealing and splicing. Moreover, we propose that infectious prions are propagated through a dynamic molecular symbiosis between a ribozyme-like nucleic acid and a conformational isomer of the RNP-like prion protein. Thus, our model has important implications for the understanding and treatment of prion diseases.

A theory of evolution that includes prebiotic self-organization and episodic species formation

A theory has been proposed that encompasses pre-replication changes in RNA synthesis and non-gradual variant formation, in addition to competitive replication. Using a fundamental theorem of natural selection and maximum principle scaled to nucleotide condensation, evolution in vitro was demonstrated to maximally damp both kinetic and thermodynamic forces driving this reaction, from its pre-replication stage. This led to the finding that evolution follows a path of least action. These principles form the framework for a general theory of evolution, whose scope extends beyond evolution modeled by synthesis of non-interacting RNA molecules. It applies, in particular, to standard processes, such as competitive crystallization. In calculations simulating de novo formation of self-replicating RNA molecules in the Qbeta replicase system, spontaneous changes in strand secondary structure promoted the transition from random copolymerization to template-directed polymerization. This finding indicates selection preceded genome self-propagation. Non-gradual species formation was attributed to the presence of heterogeneous thermodynamic forces. Growth unconstrained by competition follows mutation to a variant able to utilize a free energy source alien to its progenitors. Evolution in a heterogeneous system can, therefore, exhibit discontinuous rates of species formation and spawn new species populations. Natural selection among competing self-propagators thus gives way to a principle of wider scope stating that evolution optimally damps the physicochemical forces causing change within an evolving system.

Sequence analysis of RNA species synthesized by Q beta replicase without template

Q beta replicase amplifies certain short-chained RNA templates autocatalytically with high efficiency. In the absence of extraneously added template, synthesis of new RNA species by Q beta replicase is observed under conditions of high enzyme and substrate concentrations and after long lag times. Even under identical conditions, different RNA species are produced in different experiments. The sequences of several independent template-free products have been determined by cloning their cDNAs into plasmids by a novel cloning procedure. Their nucleotide chain lengths are small, ranging from 25 to about 50 nucleotides. While their primary sequences are unrelated except for the invariant 5'-terminal G and 3'-terminal C clusters, their tentative secondary structures show a common principle: both their plus and minus strands have a stem at the 5' terminus, while the 3' terminus is unpaired. Direct accumulation of sufficient quantities of early template-free synthesis products by Q beta replicase is prevented by the inherent irreproducibility of the synthesis process and by the rapid change of the products during amplification by evolution processes, but large amounts of such RNA can be synthesized in vitro by transcription from the cDNA clones. RNA species produced in template-free reactions replicate much more slowly than the optimized RNA species characterized previously. These experimental results illustrate how biological information can be gained in small bits by trial and error.

Images of evolution: origin of spontaneous RNA replication waves

Self-replicating molecules set up traveling concentration waves that propagate in an aqueous enzyme solution. The velocity of each wave provides an accurate (+/- 0.1%) noninvasive measure of fitness for the RNA species currently growing in its front. Evolution may be followed from changes in the front velocity, and these differ from wave to wave. Thousands of controlled evolution reactions in traveling waves have been monitored in parallel to obtain quantitative images of the stochastic process of natural selection. An RNA polymerase (RNA-dependent RNA nucleotidyltransferase, EC 2.7.7.6), extracted from bacteria infected by the Q beta RNA virus, catalyzes the replication. The traveling waves that arise spontaneously without added RNA provide a model system for major evolutionary change.

Origins of genes: "big bang" or continuous creation?

Many protein families are common to all cellular organisms, indicating that many genes have ancient origins. Genetic variation is mostly attributed to processes such as mutation, duplication, and rearrangement of ancient modules. Thus it is widely assumed that much of present-day genetic diversity can be traced by common ancestry to a molecular "big bang." A rarely considered alternative is that proteins may arise continuously de novo. One mechanism of generating different coding sequences is by "overprinting," in which an existing nucleotide sequence is translated de novo in a different reading frame or from noncoding open reading frames. The clearest evidence for overprinting is provided when the original gene function is retained, as in overlapping genes. Analysis of their phylogenies indicates which are the original genes and which are their informationally novel partners. We report here the phylogenetic relationships of overlapping coding sequences from steroid-related receptor genes and from tymovirus, luteovirus, and lentivirus genomes. For each pair of overlapping coding sequences, one is confined to a single lineage, whereas the other is more widespread. This suggests that the phylogenetically restricted coding sequence arose only in the progenitor of that lineage by translating an out-of-frame sequence to yield the new polypeptide. The production of novel exons by alternative splicing in thyroid receptor and lentivirus genes suggests that introns can be a valuable evolutionary source for overprinting. New genes and their products may drive major evolutionary changes.

Quantitative analysis of mutation and selection in self-replicating RNA

Mutation and selection as principles of Darwinian evolution have contributed a wealth to qualitative insight and understanding of complex biological organizations. However, for quantitative measurements of Darwinian evolution, only model systems are sufficiently simple to allow calculation of values for the relevant evolution parameters. The model system used for our study comprises short-chained RNA species whose self-replication is catalyzed by Q beta replicase. In this system, phenotypic expression of a genotype is reduced to its efficiency in directing its own synthesis. The mechanism of single-stranded RNA reproduction is well understood: RNA synthesis profiles can be described by compact equations. The selection behaviour of competing RNA species can be precisely predicted, using these equations, from kinetic parameters of the species: at low concentrations, RNA species are selected for overall growth rate (fecundity), at higher concentrations, for rapid binding of replicase (selection for competition), and at still higher concentrations, for minimizing losses caused by formation of inactive double strands. Finally, an ecosystem may be established where the different species coexist, their relative concentrations being functions of their kinetic parameters. The analysis of competition and selection can be extended to mutants of a species. Experimental conditions can be found where quantitative measurement of mutation rates and selective values of mutants is possible. The interplay of mutation and selection results in establishing a quasispecies distribution where mutants are represented according to their rates of mutational formation and their selective values. Replicating RNA clones, when amplified, rapidly build up quasispecies distributions containing pronounced "hot spots", produced predominantly by error propagation of nearly neutral mutants. The primitive model system shows the same complex Darwinian behaviour as observed in evolution of biological systems. In the absence of extraneously added template, Q beta replicase synthesizes after long lag times self-replicating RNA de novo. In a first step, nucleoside triphosphates are condensed randomly; self-replicating templates produced by chance are amplified and optimized.

On the nature of spontaneous RNA synthesis by Q beta replicase

Numerous RNA species of different length and nucleotide sequence grow spontaneously in vitro in Q beta replicase reactions where no RNA templates are added deliberately. Here, we show that this spontaneous RNA synthesis by Q beta replicase is template directed. The immediate source of template RNA can be the laboratory air, but there are ways to eliminate, or at least substantially reduce, the harmful effects of spontaneous synthesis. Solitary RNA molecules were detected in a thin layer of agarose gel containing Q beta replicase, where they grew to form colonies that became visible upon staining with ethidium bromide. This result provides a powerful tool for RNA cloning and selection in vitro. We also show that replicating RNAs similar to those growing spontaneously are incorporated into Q beta phage particles and can propagate in vivo for a number of phage generations. These RNAs are the smallest known molecular parasites, and in many aspects they resemble both the defective interfering genomes of animal and plant viruses and plant virus satellite RNAs.

Formation of multimers of linear satellite RNAs

A 22-base region of turnip crinkle virus satellite-RNA C (sat-RNA C) is involved in the accumulation of monomeric and dimeric forms. Deletions within the region inhibited the accumulation of sat-RNA C monomers. However, normal ratios of dimers to monomers occurred if the 22 bases were replaced by 22 unrelated bases or if the location of this region was altered. Therefore, these specific 22 bases are not involved in the accumulation of sat-RNA C monomers. Examination of the sequences at the junctions of multimers of all three turnip crinkle virus sat-RNAs revealed the deletion of bases corresponding to the 3' and 5' ends of monomeric units as well as the addition of nucleotides not present in monomers. Based on these results, we present a model to explain the formation of multimers of linear subviral RNAs associated with turnip crinkle virus. Our model suggests that multimers are formed by the reinitiation of replication by the replicase before release of the nascent strand. We have previously proposed the same mechanism for the formation of defective interfering RNAs, chimeric sat-RNAs, and sat-RNA recombinants in the turnip crinkle virus system (Cascone, Carpenter, Li, and Simon. (1990). EMBO J. 9, 1709-1715).

An in vivo recombinant RNA capable of autocatalytic synthesis by Q beta replicase

A variety of small RNAs ranging from tens to hundreds of nucleotides in length grow autocatalytically in a Q beta replicase (Q beta phage RNA-dependent RNA polymerase) reaction in the absence of added template, and similar RNAs are found in Q beta phage-infected Escherichia coli cells. Three such RNAs have been sequenced. One of them that is 221 nucleotides (nt) long ('MDV-1' RNA) has been found to be partially homologous to Q beta phage RNA 8, which might be considered as an indication of its origination from by-products of the Q beta RNA replication. To gain further insight into the origin and function of these RNAs, we have sequenced a new RNA, 120 nt long, isolated from the products of spontaneous synthesis by the nominally RNA-free Q beta replicase preparation. The minus strand of this RNA appeared to be a recombinant RNA, composed of the internal fragment of Q beta RNA (approximately 80 nt long) and the 33-nt-long 3'-terminal fragment of E. coli tRNA(1Asp). This seems to be the first strong indication of RNA recombination in bacterial cells. The various implications of this finding are discussed.

Cybernetic origins of replication

An evolutionary progression leading toward replication is resolved into several phases; (a) the replication of RNA segments by self-priming and -templating, (b) the replication of single stranded molecules by elongation and controlled scission, (c) replication of complementary duplexes and (d) replication of DNA. The initial phase is suggested by evidence for the existence of tandem repeats in an early population of molecules presumed to be ancestral to today's structural RNAs. Relics of these repeats are seen in the positioning of sequence matches between transfer and ribosomal RNAs. Conservation of the positions of the matches is indicated by persistence of a periodicity in their spacings along the molecules. Selection is viewed as a vector, with a source and a focus. The evolutionary progression entails shifts in the source of selection, from external catalysts to the replicating molecule itself, and in its focus, from substrate to replicator, to the products of the replicator's activity. When the source and focus of selection are the same selection becomes internalized, and replication and Darwinian evolution follow. Catalytic specificity is regarded as an antecedent to natural selection. Shifting of the source and focus of selection and switches in evolution's 'vehicle', the most fundamental thing that evolves, result in profound changes in the modes of evolution. Control provides a conceptual framework within which entry into a Darwinian mode of evolution, and ultimately liberation from Darwinian evolution might be explained.

Hypotheses on the appearance of life on Earth (review)

It is generally accepted within the natural sciences that life emerged on Earth by a kind of proto-Darwinian evolution from molecular assemblies that were predominantly formed from the various constituents of the primitive atmosphere and hydrosphere. Evolutionary stages under discussion are: the self-organization of spontaneously formed biomolecules into early precursors of life (protobionts), their stepwise evolution via (postulated) protocells to (postulated) progenotes and the Darwinian evolution from progenotes to the three kingdoms of contemporary organisms (archaebacteria, eubacteria and eukaryotes). Considerable discrepancies between scientists have arisen because all evolutionary stages from prebiotic molecules to progenotes are entirely hypothetical and so are the postulated environmental conditions. We can only theorize that all those environmental conditions that allow the existence of the various forms of contemporary life might have allowed also the development of their precursors. Because of all these difficulties the hypothesis that life came to our planet from a remote place of our universe (panspermia) has been revived. But experimental evidence only supports the view that spores can--under favorable circumstances--survive a relatively short journey within our solar system (interplanetary transfer of life). It is extremely unlikely that spores can survive a journey of hundreds or thousands of years through interstellar space.